Review Jurnal Lipid Nanoparticle A Novel Carrier For C
Review Jurnal Lipid Nanoparticle A Novel Carrier For C
Inventi Rapid: Cosmeceuticals Vol. 2015, Issue 3 1 2015 pcc 16287 © Inventi Journals (P) Ltd
[ISSN 0976-3864] Published on Web 06/06/2015, www.inventi.in
REVIEW ARTICLE
Figure 1: Triggered drug release and super saturation effect. Drug loaded NLC are incorporated into an o/w cream [11]
Figure 2: Mechanism of drug expulsion during storage of SLN dispersions, transition to highly ordered lipid crystal [14, 15]
system. Although a partially disturbed barrier in many skin reported to be embedded into the solid lipid matrix or to be
diseases (e.g. atopic eczema and psoriasis) can favour API localised at the surface of solid platelets and the surfactant
permeation through the horny layer, adequate skin layer.
penetration is still an important challenge in the The penetration of active compounds into human skin
development of topical dermatics. Conventional drug was studied using the Tesa stripping test investigated
carrier systems, such as creams and ointments, result in compounds included coenzyme Q10 and retinol. The
API uptake of only a few percent, which moreover as a rule coenzyme Q10 was dissolved in isopropanol, in liquid
is linked to a rather high inter individual variation of paraffin or applied as an aqueous SLN dispersion. This
uptake rates. Consequently, API levels within the diseased shows the cumulative amount of the compound in the
skin may be sub-therapeutic in some patients while strips as a function of the strip number. SLN proved to be
inducing unwanted local or systemic side effects in others. most efficient in promoting penetration into the stratum
Moreover, highly lipophilic compounds can penetrate via corneum. For cosmetic products, it is important that the
the hair follicle. Follicular uptake may be most relevant active compounds stay in the skin, penetrate sufficiently
with rigid API crystalline particles and particulate carriers deep but not too deep leading to systemic availability.
with a size of 3–10 μm. Other than with the horny layer, Penetration should be sufficient to lead to a cosmetic effect
micrometer size does not exclude penetration into but not a pharmaceutics effect. Penetration studies with
follicular orifices. Besides acting as a permeation barrier, drugs in pharmaceutical dermal formulations revealed that
the horny layer is also a reservoir for topically applied the degree of penetration obviously depends on the
substances. For example, four days after the application of chemical composition of the formulation. In-vitro skin
glucocorticoids under occlusion, vasoconstriction could be penetration studies were also per-formed in NLC using
re-induced by renewed occlusion of the treatment area. retinol as the compound of interest for cosmetics and
More recently, a saturable uptake of UV filters was pharmaceuticals. The studies revealed a different
described. Investigations with primaquine demonstrated penetration profile compared to the nanoemulsion used as
that both binding to corneocyte keratin as well as the reference. Initially, the concentrations were lower (due to
miscibility of the drug with the lipid domains contribute to prolonged release from particle), after a 24-h period,
the horny layer reservoir. [9, 10] higher retinol levels were found in the residual skin. The
studies were performed using the Franz cell model and
COSMETIC AND TOPICAL BENEFITS OF LIPID porcine skin. Preparation of the particles with this
NANOPARTICLE relatively high amount of oil led to the formation of oil
Improved Skin Penetration nanocompartments, which means the solid lipid
Solid lipid nanoparticles (SLN, Nanopearls®) are made of nanoparticle investigated was in fact an NLC type 3. The
lipids solid at room temperature, the surface being covered flux of retinol from lipid particle dispersion was compared
by a surfactant (tensid, emulsifier) shell which stabilizes to the flux of retinol from an o/w nanoemulsion which
the dispersion. Nanostructured lipid carriers (NLC) are served as control (identical composition, solid lipid
mixtures of solid and fluid lipids, the fluid lipid phase is replaced by Miglyol 812). The flux of retinol from the
Inventi Rapid: Cosmeceuticals Vol. 2015, Issue 3 2 2015 pcc 16287 © Inventi Journals (P) Ltd
[ISSN 0976-3864] Published on Web 06/06/2015, www.inventi.in
REVIEW ARTICLE
nanoemulsion system remained unchanged during the stability in these systems. The SLN and NLC remain as
investigated period. Due to increased order and increased definite particles during the storage time. [19, 20]
expulsion of drug the flux increased from the nanoparticle It was found that the higher concentrated particle
dispersion. [11, 12] dispersions showed sufficient physical stability during
storage whereas low concentrated ones aggregated. Lipid
Loading Capacity Nanoparticle dispersions with increasing lipid content
A major drawback of SLN is the frequently low loading were produced. The higher concentrated were practically
capacity which is limited to about 10% of the amount of unchanged in size during storage avoiding the problems of
lipid (leading to about 1% of the final dispersion) to ensure lower concentrated dispersions The explanation is that in
stability of the system . This is due to the specific nature of the low concentrated particle dispersions, the particles are
the solid lipid matrix and holds true especially with APIs of freely diffusible can collide and aggregate. In the highly
only moderate lipophilicity. Therefore both the physico- concentrated dispersions, the particles are fixed in the
chemical parameters of active agent and lipid have to be pearl-like network diffusion and subsequent aggregation is
considered. The review by Mehnert [13, 9] high lights these reduced. [11]
aspects; Pay-load for a number of drugs too low and Drug
expulsion during storage (Figure 2). Film Formation and Occlusive Property
NLC have been developed to overcome the drawbacks The stratum corneum contains 10-20% water. If the water
associated with SLN. They are considered to be the second content falls below this value (i.e., if water evaporation
generation of lipid nanoparticles. Compared to SLN, NLC from the skin to the atmosphere is increased) the
show a higher loading capacity for active compounds by protective layer of the skin is no longer intact and starts to
creating a less ordered solid lipid matrix, i.e. by blending a get chapped. In this case, occlusive topicals have to be
liquid lipid with the solid lipid, a higher particle drug applied in order to regenerate the water content of the
loading can be achieved. Therefore, the NLC have an stratum corneum and thus repair the surface of the skin.
increased drug loading capacity in comparison to SLN and Due to occlusion water Evaporation from the skin to the
the possibility of drug expulsion during storage is less. [14, atmosphere is decreased and water is thus retained within
16] the skin. The stratum corneum swells, which leads to a
drug permeation enhancing effect. However, many of the
Improved Chemical Stability topical with good occlusive properties (e.g., petrolatum,
The solid matrix of SLN can protect labile APIs from fats, fatty acids) have an unacceptable Cosmetic or
hydrolysis and oxidation. This is of relevance for topical aesthetic appearance. Therefore different w/o and o/w
agents used for antiaging and mild acne. SLN improve the emulsions have been developed. They represent a
chemical stability of tocopherol, retinol and coenzyme Q10 compromise between occlusive performance and
as compared to an aqueous dispersion tocopherol by 57%. appearance on the skin. The occlusive character of SLN is
[9, 17] A much more sensitive cosmetic molecule is retinol. due to film formation after application to the skin, leading
Under the influence of light and oxygen, it decomposes to a to decreased water evaporation. [21, 22] Souto et al., [23] found
variety of structures, e.g. different epoxy retinoids. The a higher occlusive factor for SLN in comparison to NLC of
stabilization effect of SLN on retinol was investigated using the same lipid content. Comparing NLC with different oil
different lipids as matrix material and different surfactants content showed that an increase in oil content leads to a
and surfactant mixtures. Firstly, the study revealed that the decrease of the occlusive factor.
stabilization effect differed between the lipids used, this
indicates that for very sensitive molecules, the lipid has to Skin Hydration and Elasticity
be selected carefully. Unfavorable lipids (e. g. too acidic The reduction of trans epidermal water loss (TEWL)
lipids) can lead to a less pronounced stabilization. caused by occlusion leads to an increase in skin hydration
Secondly, different extents of stabilization were observed after dermal application of SLN, NLC or formulations
as a function of surfactant. [11, 18] containing them. An in-vivo study showed that the SLN
containing o/w cream increased the skin hydration
Improved Physical Stability significantly more than the conventional o/w cream. In this
The liposomes represent the most innovative cosmetic study the skin hydration effect after repetitive application
carrier system of the 1980s, introduced to the market by of an o/w cream containing SLN and a conventional o/w
the company Dior in 1986 (product “Capture”). Despite the cream was investigated for 28 days. A significant higher
many positive features, a major problem up today is the increase in skin hydration was found by Müller et al., [19] for
limited physical stability of liposomes in the presence of oil an NLC-containing cream compared to conventional cream.
emulsion droplets and surfactants. The liposomes tend to
fuse with each other and with the surfactant layer of oil Enhanced Skin Bioavailability of Actives and Skin
droplets. The number of liposomes in o/w formulations is Targeting
steadily decreasing with increasing shelf-life. Approaches Cosmetic actives should localize in the skin but not cause
of increasing the rigidity of the liposomal bilayer could only any systemic effects to avoid crossing the border between a
delay but not avoid this effect. A major advantage of lipid cosmetic and a pharmaceutical formulation. Therefore, a
nanoparticles with solid matrix is their high physical certain penetration into the skin is desired, especially the
Inventi Rapid: Cosmeceuticals Vol. 2015, Issue 3 3 2015 pcc 16287 © Inventi Journals (P) Ltd
[ISSN 0976-3864] Published on Web 06/06/2015, www.inventi.in
REVIEW ARTICLE
active should be localized in the skin. The same is valid for and etomidate are released spontaneously from the solid
many pharmaceutical actives, e.g. corticoids. Localization in lipid matrix an initial burst release is followed by a
the upper skin minimizes side effects such as skin thinning. prolonged release for several days or even six weeks, as
For the corticoid prednicarbate it could be nicely shown demonstrated with prednisolone and clobetasole
that the drug localizes more in the upper skin compared to propionate, respectively. [9, 26, 27]
an emulsion based formulation occlusion (e.g. plastic foil
onto cream applied to skin) promotes the penetration of Novel Technique Applicable for Production
actives into the skin. Increased penetration of coenzyme Q Lipid nanoparticles are prepared from lipid, emulsifier and
10 was described after application of a Q 10-loaded SLN water/solvent by using different methods and are
suspension in comparison to solutions of isopropanol and discussed below: [28]
liquid paraffin. Penetration into the skin was determined 1. High pressure homogenization
by a tape stripping test (Scotch® tape). The cumulative a. Hot homogenization
amount of the first 5 strips was 53% for the SLN b. Cold homogenization
suspension, 30% for isopropanol and just 2% for liquid 2. Ultrasonication/high speed homogenization
paraffin, calculated in % of applied dose. [19, 24] 3. Solvent Emulsification Evaporation Technique
4. Solvent emulsification-diffusion method
Controlled Release of Cosmetic Compound 5. Supercritical fluid method
The perfume Allure was incorporated in SLN and the 6. Microemulsion based method
release studied compared to a nanoemulsion of identical 7. Spray drying method
lipid content and surfactant composition. The initial release 8. Double emulsion method
was similar, most likely due to perfume present in the 9. Precipitation technique
outer shell of the SLN. During the follow-up period to 8 h, 10. Solvent injection technique
release from the SLN was delayed. This opens the prospect 11. Membrane contractor technique
of developing longer lasting perfume formulations based 12. Film-ultrasound dispersion.
on the prolonged release of the perfume from the solid lipid
matrix. [11, 25] Lipid Nanoparticle as Novel UV Sunscreen System
Drug release from SLN has been evaluated using The two basic UV protection systems are molecular UV
steroids as well as other agents as model drugs. Tetracain blockers (sunscreens) and particulate compounds such as
Inventi Rapid: Cosmeceuticals Vol. 2015, Issue 3 4 2015 pcc 16287 © Inventi Journals (P) Ltd
[ISSN 0976-3864] Published on Web 06/06/2015, www.inventi.in
REVIEW ARTICLE
Inventi Rapid: Cosmeceuticals Vol. 2015, Issue 3 5 2015 pcc 16287 © Inventi Journals (P) Ltd
[ISSN 0976-3864] Published on Web 06/06/2015, www.inventi.in
REVIEW ARTICLE
21. Wissing S A, Lippacher A, Muller R H. Investigationos n the 27. Hu F Q, Yuan H, Zhang H H, Fang M. Preparation of solid lipid
occlusive properties of solid lipid nanoparticles (SLN). J nanoparticles with clobetasol propionate by a novel solvent
Cosmetic sci, 52: 313-324, 2001. diffusion method in aqueous system and physicochemical
22. Barry B W, Southwell D, Woodford R. Optimization of characterization. Int J Pharm, 239:121–128, 2002.
bioavailability of topical steroids: Penetratione nhancerus 28. Kesharwani R, Nair S K, Patel D. Solid Lipid Nanoparticle
nder occlusion. J Invent Dermatol, 8 (2):49-52, 1984. (SLN): A Modern Approach for Drug Delivery. Journal of
23. Souto E B, Wissing S A, Barbosa C M, Muller R H. Pharma Research, 2(11):13-21, 2013.
Development of a controlled release formulation based on 29. Song C, Liu S, A new healthy sunscreen system for human:
SLN and NLC for topical clotrimazole delivery. Int J Pharm, solid lipid nanoparticles as carrier for 3,4,5-
278: 71–77, 2004. trimethoxybenzoylchitin and the improvement by adding
24. Sivaramakrishnan R. Glucocorticoid entrapment into lipid Vitamin E. Int J Biol Macromol, 36:116-119, 2005.
carriers characterisation by parelectric spectroscopy and 30. Bangale M S, Mitkare S S, Gittani S G, Sakarkar D M. Recent
influence on dermal uptake. J Control Release, 97(3):493–502, Nanotechnological aspects in cosmetics and dermatological
2004. preparation. International Journal of Pharmacy &
25. Wissing S A, Mader K, Muller R H. Solid lipid nanoparticles Pharmaceutical Sciences, 4(3):88-97, 2012.
(SLN) as a novel carrier system offering prolonged release of
the perfume Allure (Chanel). Int Symp Control Release Bioact Cite this article as: Dilip Patel, Vikash Kumar, Roohi
Mater, 27:311–312, 2000. Kesharwani et al. Lipid Nanoparticle a Novel Carrier for
26. Zur A M, Mehnert W. Drug release and release mechanism of Cosmetics and Topical Preparation: A Review. Inventi
prednisolone loaded solid lipid nanoparticles. Pharmazie, Rapid: Cosmeceuticals, 2015(3):1-6, 2015.
53:552–555, 1998.
Inventi Rapid: Cosmeceuticals Vol. 2015, Issue 3 6 2015 pcc 16287 © Inventi Journals (P) Ltd
[ISSN 0976-3864] Published on Web 06/06/2015, www.inventi.in