The Wall Street Journal - February 28, 2025 - 250228 - 114355
The Wall Street Journal - February 28, 2025 - 250228 - 114355
00
DJIA 43239.50 g 193.62 0.45% NASDAQ 18544.42 g 2.8% STOXX 600 557.11 g 0.5% 10-YR. TREAS. g 10/32 , yield 4.284% OIL $70.35 À $1.73 GOLD $2,883.20 g $34.60 EURO $1.0399 YEN 149.82
Trump administration of- were aiding Ukraine. that surrender was tanta- offered the most detailed pic- Please turn to page A7
ficials moved to drop a CFPB
lawsuit that accused Capital
One of misleading customers
over the interest rates on
their savings accounts. A4
Nvidia Hackman’s Death Probed
The ‘Spy Sheikh’
Andrew Tate, under investi-
gation for human trafficking in
Adapted Taking the AI
Romania, arrived in the U.S. af-
ter a Trump official discussed
the case with Bucharest. A5
Its Chips World by Storm
To Keep
20TH CENTURY FOX/EVERETT COLLECTION
U.S. NEWS
U.S.WATCH PENNSYLVANIA
Hiker Finds Puppy
PENTAGON
Trans Troops
NEW ENGLAND
Ocean Temperature
30-year fixed rate mortgage,
weekly
Thursday
Missing for Week Face Removal Lower Last Year 8%
6.76%
A Pennsylvania hiker had The military services have The waters off New Eng-
followed his dog off a moun- 30 days to figure out how land had another warm year 7
tain trail this week when he they will seek out and iden- but didn’t heat up as fast as
glanced toward a deep coal tify transgender service earlier this decade, bucking a 6
pit below and saw a tail members to remove them trend of higher warming
move near a pile of rocks. from the force—a daunting worldwide, said scientists %
Collin Leiby, an avid hiker task that may end up relying who study the Atlantic Ocean
and wedding photographer, on troops self-reporting or near Maine.
4
locked eyes with the animal tattling on their colleagues. The Gulf of Maine, which
and knew it was Freddy, a 6- A memo sent to Defense touches three New England
month-old golden retriever Department leaders on Thurs- states and Canada, emerged 3
whose disappearance had day—after the Pentagon filed it as a test case for climate
sparked a weeklong search in as part of a response to a law- change about a decade ago 2
Pottsville, a community in suit—orders the services to set because it is warming much 2018 ’20 ’2%
eastern Pennsylvania’s his- up procedures to identify faster than most of the
toric coal country. Leiby had troops diagnosed with or being world’s oceans. The gulf is Source: Freddie Mac
been on alert for the missing treated for gender dysphoria home to some of the coun-
dog and finally found him
Monday, about 10 feet down
the coal pit, too weary to
by March 26. They will then
have 30 days to begin remov-
ing those troops from service.
try’s most valuable seafood
species.
The gulf’s annual sea sur-
Pending
U.S. Home
make his way out. The order expands on the face temperature last year
Pam and Joe Palko had executive order signed by was 51.5 degrees Fahrenheit,
pulled out all the stops since President Trump during his according to the Gulf of
Freddy went missing on Feb. early days in office setting out Maine Research Institute in
17. They took to social media. steps toward banning trans- Portland. That was more than
Sales Hit
COLLIN LEIBY/ASSOCIATED PRESS
They chased tips. They orga- gender individuals from serv- 0.88 F above the long-term
nized volunteers to distribute ing in the military. The direc- average from 1991 to 2020,
fliers in schools, churches and
across town in Pottsville. They
even hired a company that
tive has been challenged in
court. An initial but incomplete
count of transgender troops
the institute said in a report
released this month. Although
last year was the gulf’s 12th
New Low
Collin Leiby found Freddy in a coal pit in Pottsville, Pa. The
puppy’s disappearance sparked a massive community search.
uses search dogs to track
missing pets, and another that
flew thermal drones overhead.
—Associated Press
easily identifiable through
medical records is in the hun-
dreds, U.S. officials said.
—Associated Press
warmest year on record, it
was down from the fifth
warmest a year earlier, it said.
—Associated Press
In January
BY ED FRANKL
FAA Will
President Trump plans to use higher tariffs on goods from China, Mexico and Canada to try to force those countries to curb drug smuggling into the U.S.
Hire More
Trade Fight hint that the Canada and Mex-
ico tariffs could be delayed
we can reach an agreement.”
Mexican authorities extra-
While the National Security
Council is in contact with ma-
chemicals used to make fenta-
nyl, according to people close
Air-Traffic
Expands on
again, saying that they were
scheduled for April 2. The ad-
ministration backed off those
dited to the U.S. drug boss Ra-
fael Caro Quintero, who is
wanted for the 1985 killing of
jor foreign partners such as
China, intensive negotiations
haven’t been conducted on
to Beijing’s decision-making.
The people said the lack of an
offer from China on fentanyl
Controllers
comments at the time, and on a Drug Enforcement Adminis- how to avoid the tariffs, an was a reason that no direct
OKLAHOMA CITY—U.S.
impose the tariffs, though Trudeau of Canada said on fewer fentanyl overdose Liu Pengyu, the spokesman Transportation Secretary Sean
Continued from Page One talks are ongoing. Thursday that less than 1% of deaths in the U.S. at the Chinese Embassy in Duffy said the federal govern-
The administration had post- Trump’s initial tariff the fentanyl smuggled into the “It’s 10 plus 10,” Trump Washington, defended ment would take steps to hire
poned the Canada and Mexico threats set off a flurry of ne- U.S. comes from Canada. said in the Oval Office, refer- China’s record in fighting more air-traffic controllers
tariffs for 30 days at the be- gotiations on how to avoid “Canada is not the source ring to his China tariffs. drug-trafficking. and spend billions of dollars
ginning of February to allow the duties, with Mexico com- of problems for the United Mexican cartels making Unlike Canadian and Mexi- to upgrade the nation’s avia-
for negotiations. mitting troops to the U.S. bor- States,” he said. “If on Tues- bootleg fentanyl, often with can leaders, Xi has shown lit- tion system.
“The drugs continue to der to curb migration and day there are unjustified tar- China-sourced precursor chem- tle interest in focusing solely As part of plans to increase
pour into our country, killing Canada setting up a fentanyl iffs brought in on Canada, we icals, are the major source of on a deal about fentanyl, the staffing, Duffy said the Fed-
hundreds of thousands of peo- task force. will have an immediate and the opioid that has caused a people said. Rather, he aims to eral Aviation Administration
ple,” said Trump, a Republi- President Claudia Shein- strong response.” U.S. public-health crisis. negotiate a broader agreement would boost pay for students
can, after being asked about baum of Mexico said Thurs- China responded to the Evidence suggests that the with Trump that could define at its air-traffic control acad-
whether he had seen progress. day, referring to Trump’s first round of U.S. tariffs deadly drug also is increas- the tone of bilateral relations. emy in Oklahoma City by 30%
“The families are destroyed comments: “As you know, he with retaliatory duties of its ingly manufactured and ex- In a bid to prepare for trade to $22.84 an hour in the com-
after that happens.” has his way of communicat- own and is likely to do so ported from Canada, though talks with the Trump adminis- ing days.
The announcement came a ing, but as usual, we have a again when new U.S. duties numbers remain small com- tration, the Journal reported Duffy said Thursday the FAA
day after Trump appeared to cool head and optimism that are imposed. pared with Mexico. early this month, Beijing has would streamline hiring and
The most recent federal been trying to put together an shave more than four months
data show fatal overdoses kill- initial proposal that involves from the process of training
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
(USPS 664-880) (Eastern Edition ISSN 0099-9660)
CORRECTIONS ing about 240 people every
day. At the same time, the
reinstating a trade agreement
signed with the first Trump
new controllers. “We have to
pay young people more to stay
(Central Edition ISSN 1092-0935) (Western Edition ISSN 0193-2241)
Editorial and publication headquarters: 1211 Avenue of the Americas, New York, N.Y. 10036
AMPLIFICATIONS numbers are declining quickly.
Preliminary data show
administration in early 2020, a
renewed pledge not to devalue
in the academy,” Duffy said.
The secretary touted what
Published daily except Sundays and general legal holidays. graduates can earn: an average
Periodicals postage paid at New York, N.Y., and other mailing offices.
about 86,900 fatal overdoses the yuan to help its exporters,
A photo caption with a in the 12 months ended last and an offer to make more in- of $160,000. Pay varies by loca-
Postmaster: Send address changes to The Wall Street Journal,
200 Burnett Rd., Chicopee, MA 01020. Page One article on Wednes- September, down 24% from vestments in the U.S. tion, and the FAA said the fig-
All Advertising published in The Wall Street Journal is subject to the applicable rate card, day about a Ukrainian-U.S. the prior 12-month period. But Xi has yet to make that ure didn’t include overtime.
copies of which are available from the Advertising Services Department, Dow Jones & Co. minerals deal incorrectly iden- The driver of the decline is a offer, the people said. For now, Airline executives and con-
Inc., 1211 Avenue of the Americas, New York, N.Y. 10036. The Journal reserves the right tified an excavator as a roughly 31% decline in deaths Beijing thinks it can handle troller-union officials praised
not to accept an advertiser’s order. Only publication of an advertisement shall constitute
final acceptance of the advertiser’s order. bucket-wheel excavator. linked to synthetic opioids, the 10% additional tariffs. The Duffy’s plan. “This is a critical
Letters to the Editor: Fax: 212-416-2891; email: [email protected] the drug class that largely in- levies have raised the average initial step to making our avia-
Need assistance with your subscription?
In some editions Thursday, cludes fentanyl. duty rate on Chinese imports tion system even safer,” Ameri-
By web: customercenter.wsj.com; By email: [email protected] a U.S. News article about pos- U.S. overdose deaths have to 24.5% from about 14.5% as can Airlines Chief Executive
By phone: 1-800-JOURNAL (1-800-568-7625) sible tariffs on goods from the largely gone in one direction— of 2023, according to Gavekal Robert Isom said.
Reprints & licensing: European Union incorrectly up—for decades, and a decline Dragonomics, an economic- Duffy said he would ask
By email: [email protected]
By phone: 1-800-843-0008
identified Sen. Bill Hagerty of this size is unprecedented. consulting firm. Congress to fund upgrades to
(R., Tenn.) as from Louisiana. Beijing so far hasn’t made Chinese companies already the technology underpinning
WSJ back issues and framed pages: wsjshop.com
an offer to the Trump admin- have proven adept at avoid- the nation’s air-traffic control
Our newspapers are 100% sourced from sustainably certified mills. Readers can alert The Wall Street istration that shows a ing U.S. tariffs by rerouting system, pointing to its reliance
Journal to any errors in news articles
GOT A TIP FOR US? SUBMIT IT AT WSJ.COM/TIPS by emailing [email protected] or stepped-up commitment to re- their products through other on decades-old copper wire,
by calling 888-410-2667. ducing China’s exports of countries. floppy disks and phone jacks.
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * * * * Friday, February 28, 2025 | A3
U.S. NEWS
Actor Hackman
And His Wife
Are Found Dead
BY ELLEN GAMERMAN working.’ ” Hackman went on
AND ALYSSA LUKPAT to win a best actor Oscar.
He sometimes spoke about
Gene Hackman, a two-time his father’s abandoning his
Oscar winner whose storied family when Hackman was 13
acting career included “The years old. Driving away, he
U.S. NEWS
USAID CFPB Aims
Staffers Bid To Drop
Farewell
WASHINGTON—U.S.
Capital One
Agency for International De-
velopment workers, some in
tears, carted away belongings
Lawsuit
from a final visit to their
now-closed headquarters on BY DYLAN TOKAR
Thursday as the Trump ad-
ministration’s rapid-fire dis- Trump administration offi-
mantling of the congressio- cials are moving to drop a gov-
nally authorized agency ernment watchdog’s lawsuit
moved into its final stages. that accused Capital One Fi-
Notices are going out to nancial of misleading custom-
terminate over 90% of USAID’s ers over the interest rates on
contracts for humanitarian their savings accounts.
and development work around A notice of voluntary dis-
the world, and the Supreme missal was filed in federal
Court has temporarily blocked court in Virginia, where the
a judge’s order requiring the Consumer Financial Protection
administration to release bil- Bureau brought its case in Jan-
lions of dollars in foreign aid. uary. Mark Paoletta, chief legal
“We’re just here to say officer for the CFPB, also
thank you for your service. moved to dismiss other en-
We appreciate everything forcement actions, including
you’ve done and all the sacri- the agency’s lawsuits against
fices you’ve made in service real-estate company Rocket
to your country,” said Randy Homes and a student-loan ser-
NATHAN HOWARD/REUTERS
U.S. NEWS
House Votes
Become Tricky
For Democrats
Injuries, age weigh Several Republicans were on
the fence, but the party was
on party attendance anticipating some breathing
as tiny GOP majority room, because of Democrats’
spotty recent attendance re-
puts bills in doubt cord. On previous contentious
votes, including the Laken
BY XAVIER MARTINEZ Riley immigration bill and a
WORLD NEWS
Leader Urges Kurds to Disarm Ukraine Rattled as
Path is uncertain
to ending the deadly
U.S. Eyes 2022 Plan
conflict that has BY YAROSLAV TROFIMOV need to reinvent the wheel, the
AND MICHAEL R. GORDO person said. The U.S. approach
destabilized Mideast should be to take the frame-
A suggestion by the Trump work from that 2022 negotiat-
BY JARED MALSIN administration’s top negotiator ing effort and adapt it to the
AND ELVAN KIVILCIM that a Ukraine peace deal current circumstances, the
would be based on talks con- person said.
ISTANBUL—An imprisoned ducted in Istanbul nearly three Witkoff also didn’t intend
Kurdish militant leader urged years ago has buoyed Russian his comments to be an en-
his followers on Thursday to officials and spooked Ukraine dorsement of capping the
give up their weapons, open- and its backers. Ukrainian military at a low
ing an opportunity to defuse a To Kyiv, recent remarks by level of troops, the person said.
YASIN AKGUL/AGENCE FRANCE-PRESSE/GETTY IMAGES
conflict that has killed tens of Steve Witkoff appeared to em- The U.S. believes Ukraine
thousands of people in recent brace the Kremlin’s key, and in- needs security safeguards, the
decades, and destabilized Tur- correct, talking point over the person said, adding that the
key and the wider Middle East. past three years: That Ukraine Trump administration and its
Abdullah Öcalan, who is in and Russia were about to interlocutors would have con-
his mid-70s, is the leader and strike a peace deal in Istanbul versations about what that
founder of the outlawed Kurd- and that Kyiv walked away un- means and which nations
istan Workers’ Party, known der pressure the West. could provide them.
as the PKK. He also called for Russian President Vladimir The White House’s National
the group to disband and for Putin has demanded that any Security Council didn’t reply to
its allied factions to disarm af- future peace talks be based on questions about what Witkoff
ter some 40 years of violence. a return to the meant by a re-
“All groups must lay down People hold a photograph of jailed PKK leader Abdullah Öcalan in Diyarbakir, Turkey. Istanbul param- turn to the Is-
their arms and the PKK must eters, which in tanbul frame-
dissolve itself,” Öcalan wrote in curity threat and help settle In Syria, Öcalan’s call, if im- thing, Turkey has offered in Moscow’s inter- Negotiator’s work.
a statement composed in the is- one of the nation’s most im- plemented, could help the coun- return for the PKK laying pretation fore- comment seen The Witkoff
land prison off the coast of Is- portant political questions af- try’s fragile transition away down their arms. The Turkish see a sharp cut comments came
tanbul where he has been held ter decades in which millions from autocratic rule. Kurdish- government could free Öcalan in Ukraine’s as an embrace ahead of an ex-
since 1999, when he was cap- of Kurds have demanded rec- led Syrian militias allied with or other Kurdish leaders from military, a ban pected meeting
tured in Kenya by Turkish intel- ognition. Öcalan’s statement is the PKK are among the main prison as a part of a possible on foreign
of Kremlin between Presi-
ligence officers. He called on his likely to strengthen President obstacles to the new govern- future deal, some analysts say. weapons and talking points. dent Trump and
movement to use democratic Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, who ment in Damascus consolidat- The president’s office troops, and a Zelensky over a
means to achieve their aims. could claim the call to disarm ing power after rebels ousted didn’t respond to a request for Russian veto on deal to give the
The statement follows as a domestic victory that Bashar al-Assad, ending some comment. Western secu- U.S. rights to
months of negotiations and boosts Turkey’s security. 14 years of rebellion and war in The conflict also has been a rity assistance in case of re- Kyiv’s mineral resources.
was read on his behalf at a Öcalan’s move comes after December. The militias control source of friction between An- newed conflict. Ukraine refuses The Istanbul talks were con-
news conference in Istanbul, more than a year of conflict that a swath of northeastern Syria kara and Washington for a de- to return to that draft, which vened as Russian tanks were
after pro-Kurdish officials altered the balance of power in where some of them are backed cade, since the Obama admin- was never completed or ap- on the Kyiv ring road, a culmi-
brought it from the prison. The the wider Middle East, includ- by U.S. troops and air power. istration partnered with some proved by President Volodymyr nation of negotiations that be-
message could have far-reach- ing Israel’s war with Hamas The path to resolving the Syrian Kurdish militants in Zelensky. gan shortly after the Feb. 24,
ing consequences for Turkey, militants in Gaza and Iranian- conflict remains uncertain, the war against Islamic State. “I think we will be using 2022, Russian invasion. They
Syria and the broader region. allied militias across the region. with no clear plan for a peace Washington in recent years that framework as a guidepost reflected the battlefield situa-
The PKK, designated as a The weakening of Iran contrib- process and thousands of PKK- has said it makes a distinction to get a peace deal done,” Wit- tion when Ukraine’s statehood
terrorist group by Turkey and uted to the fall of the Assad re- affiliated fighters spread between the PKK and members koff said on CNN about the Is- was on the verge of collapse,
the U.S., has fought a slow- gime in Syria in 2024, further across the region. Much will of its Syrian branch that have tanbul talks, which were held and Russia was dictating terms
burning war with the Turkish realigning the region and re- depend on how Erdogan and worked with the U.S. military. in March 2022. for a surrender.
state, including gun and bomb moving a key Turkish opponent. the Turkish government choose The leader of the U.S.-backed Witkoff’s comments weren’t Russian troops, however,
attacks and years of guerrilla A resolution to the conflict to respond to Öcalan’s message Syrian Democratic Forces, Gen. intended to be an endorsement were defeated around Kyiv and
warfare, since the 1980s. The with PKK could help remove an and whether Kurdish militants Mazloum Abdi, on Thursday of the Russian view that the rest of northern Ukraine as
group initially fought for an in- irritant from Turkey’s relation- comply with the call to disarm. said Öcalan’s call for disarma- Ukraine should be largely de- negotiators gathered in Istan-
dependent Kurdish state and ship with the U.S., which has Thousands of battle-hard- ment didn’t apply to his organi- militarized or that Russia bul. Ukraine has since re-
later demanded more rights been strained by an American ened Kurdish fighters would zation, though he said he wel- should have a veto over foreign claimed additional areas of the
for Kurds, a broad ethnic group military partnership with some have to be demobilized. Key comed the initiative for a peace military support for Kyiv or se- Kharkiv and Kherson regions.
of tens of millions of people Kurdish fighters in the battle leaders of PKK affiliates, in- process with Turkey. curity assurances for Ukraine, Even after hostilities end,
spread across Turkey, Syria, against Islamic State extremists. cluding a political party linked Some Kurdish citizens said said a person familiar with his Ukraine will maintain armed
Iraq and Iran. The PKK has af- “We believe it will help bring to the group in Syria, recently they felt deflated because the thinking. His view is that the forces at the maximal size that
filiates in all four countries. peace to this troubled region,” have said they would comply statement lacked specifics two parties were close to a is required to deter another
In Turkey, an end to the said Brian Hughes, National Se- with Öcalan’s message. It is about how the conflict would deal in Istanbul and that the Russian invasion, Zelensky
conflict could resolve a top se- curity Council spokesman. also not clear what, if any- be resolved. Trump administration didn’t said.
lamp design with a revolutionary where it’s extends 6”. of light is actually down and
light source. The combination needed.
out, perfect for task light.
delivers exponentially
more light for " 6”
reading or any The
Floor Lamps
other task. KIS Lamp
TM
available in
11”
and LampLight Satin Brass U.K. Prime Minister Keir Starmer and President Trump met Thursday at the White House.
(SHOWN),
Underlighting light source
Trump Eases
Gun Metal
is overrated Bronze and
Earlier on Thursday, U.S. pected agreement’s specifics
Brushed Silver officials said it was premature or how it would recoup the
In your lamps, the new to decide on the U.S. role in billions of dollars in military
“retrofit” CFL and LED bulbs
do not produce the same
amount of task light as ordinary
"
Height of
floor lamp
15”
Criticism any peacekeeping force until
an agreement halting the
fighting between Ukraine and
and economic aid given to
Ukraine over the last three
years of war.
bulbs. Just as we’ve gotten
older and our eyesight
adjusts from
43” to 59”
Of Kyiv Russia is reached.
After attempts by President
Andrezj Duda of Poland and
Zelensky, angling to keep
the U.S. interested in protect-
ing his country, agreed to
has declined, OUR LIGHT Seeing is Believing President Emmanuel Macron sign a deal giving U.S. compa-
US PATENTS Continued from Page One of France, Starmer sought U.S. nies access to Ukraine’s rare
HAS FAILED US. The patented KIS lamp and
10,378,698 mission for Ukraine, he did air support and other military earth materials.
10,422,488
Lamplight projects a massive succeed in improving the dour assistance for 30,000 Euro- A senior U.S. official said
amount of illumination on mood between Washington pean troops who could deploy Thursday that the deal with
YOU NEED: your reading material. Reader and European capitals over to Ukraine as peacekeepers. Ukraine does not include any
• A quantity and bulbs and all components are differing views on ending the Trump, speaking at a Cabi- specific promises to fund fu-
quality of light unconditionally guaranteed war in Ukraine. net meeting Wednesday, said ture fighting nor did it com-
geared to for 3 years. “You’re trying to find a di- his goal was to stop the fight- mit to putting any U.S. per-
better contrast vide between us that doesn’t ing in Ukraine before seriously sonnel in the region.
Take advantage of our 30 day exist,” he said at a postmeet- considering any U.S. backing British officials said Starmer,
and clarity for Also includes handheld
risk free trial* and see what ing news conference, in re- for Europeans who will serve who met with Trump in Sep-
older eyes. LED dimmer and you’ve been missing. sponse to questions about as a deterrent against Russian tember before the U.S. election
switch for brightness
• Less glare in your control – perfect *If unsatisfied, simply return with Trump’s stances on the war attacks against the European and has had phone conversa-
for adjusting prepaid shipping labels provided for and general foreign policy. peacekeeping force. tions with him since, believes
field of vision ambient light.
full credit. “We’re the closest of nations, “Peacekeeping is very easy. winning him over is critical.
and we had very good discus- It’s making the deal that’s A U.K. official acknowl-
sions today.” very tough,” Trump, a Repub- edged that the defense of Eu-
Only 32 WATTS FREE SHIPPING Trump also suggested the lican, said. “Let me make rope and Ukraine would de-
Compare to any lamp U.S. and U.K. are on the verge peace first.” pend in part on the U.S. and
at any price. $50 OFF of a trade deal. “I think we’ll Trump said Thursday he its willingness to backstop the
have two deals,” Trump said. considered U.S. involvement in deterrents they put in place.
Use coupon code TF29
“I think we’ll have a deal on extracting rare earth minerals Two weeks ago, during a
" ending the war, and I think from Ukraine, part of a pro- meeting with allies in Brus-
SPECIAL OFFER
Table lamp height Floor Lamps $425 Now Only $375 we’re going to end up with a posed mineral rights deal, as a sels, U.S. Defense Secretary
includes KIS adjusts from great trade deal with you, and possible “backstop,” falling Pete Hegseth vowed that
lamp, (5) bulbs, 27” to 32” Table Lamps $375 Now Only $325 it’s an honor to be with you.” short of European requests for “there will not be U.S. troops
lampshade and Asked whether Starmer tried U.S. security assistance to the deployed to Ukraine.”
"
LED Dimmer. Table lamps available Visit us online at to convince him to spare the proposed peacekeepers. The next day, Vice Presi-
Easy assembly. in Satin Brass or U.K. from tariffs, Trump re- “It’s like a huge economic dent JD Vance contradicted
Lamp column
simply screws
Brushed Silver
morelamplight.com plied: “He tried, he was work-
ing hard.”
development project, so it’ll
be good for both countries,”
that promise in an interview
with The Wall Street Journal,
into the base.
or call 1- 888-211-6305 As a sign of the partnership’s
strength, Starmer presented
Trump said during the news
conference. “We’ll be dig-
leaving the possibility of U.S.
forces operating in Ukraine
© 16776 West Park Circle Dr. | Chagrin Falls, Ohio 44023
Trump with a letter from King ging—dig, dig, digging.” on the table. The only thing
Charles III inviting him for a Trump, however, didn’t ad- he ruled out was Ukraine
state visit. Trump accepted. dress questions about the ex- joining NATO.
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Friday, February 28, 2025 | A7
WORLD NEWS
ATTENTION PARENTS & HIGH SCHOOL JOURNALISTS IN THE NEW YORK AREA
IN PARTNERSHIP WITH
The New York Post is committed to the future of journalism and we are excited to bring back our
Scholars Contest, in partnership with Command Education, the nation's leader in college consulting.
RE
WORLD NEWS
sault were everywhere. But thinking its priority was eco- Democratic Union said it would
even preparations by Hamas as nomic concessions to seek a coalition with its smaller
blatant as militants activating strengthen its rule over Gaza, center-left rival, after an elec-
Israeli sim cards and moving the Israeli military officials tion in which the far right dou-
forces to designated gathering said. bled its share of the vote.
points on Oct. 6, 2023, weren’t Hamas sat out fighting be- The two events could mark
treated with urgency by Israel tween Israel and another the start of resistance to U.S.
officials, the report concluded. smaller militant group in Gaza pressure on European main-
Those officials believed An Israeli soldier stands by the bodies of Israelis killed during the Oct. 7, 2023, Hamas attack. following its 2021 battle with stream parties to share power
Hamas was either doing a mil- Israel. That led Israeli officials with far-right groups whose
itary exercise, preparing to pied by a potential attack in the area and three days to any major confrontation. That to assume Hamas had been agendas more closely match
defend from an attack by Is- its north by Hezbollah mili- fully repel the attackers. was true, the Israeli officials deterred. the Trump administration’s.
rael, or readying small pin- tants from Lebanon, making Israel had regular soldiers said, until Sinwar took control Crucially, Israel misjudged Politicians and analysts in
point cross-border raids. The Gaza a blind spot that became in intelligence and observers and reoriented the group toward how much Hamas thought Germany have billed the Ger-
indicators were reminiscent of an easy target for Hamas. in the field who warned a direct attack on Israel. But Is- Iran, Lebanese militant group man coalition negotiations as
events over the previous year, Hamas took advantage on Hamas was planning an at- raeli intelligence missed the Hezbollah, Palestinians in the the last chance for the politi-
strengthening the misconcep- Oct. 7, storming the border on tack. But that information strategic shift, the probe said. West Bank and Israel’s own cal center to reverse a popu-
tion among military officials the Jewish holiday of Simchat wasn’t enough to dissuade se- Hamas launched the Octo- Palestinian citizens would join list trend that has turned the
that nothing was unusual. Torah when fewer troops nior intelligence officials from ber 2023 attack, its own offi- the battle. Hamas ultimately Alternative for Germany from
The findings, the result of posted along the border. the overall assessment that cials have said, after seeing never received the full backing a fringe group with connec-
the highest-level probe into Hamas didn’t want a war. the internal upheaval in Israel from any of these groups, tions with neo-Nazis into the
the worst attack on Israel in caused by a controversial plan though Hezbollah launched country’s second-largest polit-
the country’s history, shed Overwhelming attack to overhaul the judiciary. rockets across Israel’s border, ical force. The group, created
new light on the scale of Is- In gaming out an assault Missed signals As the assault neared its creating a two-front war that in 2013, now holds a quarter
raeli intelligence failures and from Gaza, Israel’s military Even after discovering in crescendo, Mohammad Deif, divided Israel’s forces. of seats in Parliament and will
scope of Hamas’s planning. planners assumed a worst- 2022 a Hamas plan to attack the group’s military chief, Israeli intelligence lacked lead the opposition to the gov-
The details likely will case scenario in which Hamas southern Israel, the country’s called on all Gazans to grab any real internal criticism of ernment.
prompt further reckoning in tried to breach four to eight officials determined the docu- any weapon and storm Israel. its thinking, an official said. In On Thursday, almost five
Israel, where no politician and points along the border, the ment, called Operation Jericho Thousands of civilians rushed recent decades, military intel- months after Austria’s election,
only a handful of military fig- report found. In fact, the mili- Wall, was more an aspiration across the border, looting and ligence strayed from the key the center-right People’s Party,
ures have resigned over the tants attacked nearly 60. than an actual assault manual. engaging in violence. mission of providing an early or ÖVP, center-left Social Dem-
failings, though the report Hamas’s first target was the The theoretical plan for an By noon on Oct. 7, 2023, warning and became deeply ocratic Party and pro-business
doesn’t apportion blame. Israeli base responsible for the attack on southern Israel was there were 5,600 militants and involved in providing tactical Neos party said they had
area around the Gaza Strip, approved by Hamas in 2019, civilians from Gaza inside Is- intelligence for Israel’s wider agreed to form a government.
where it killed the top com- and got operational approval rael. Israel only had hundreds military operations. “Behind us are what were
Focus was on north manders and wiped out Israel’s in August 2021. By April 2022, of soldiers defending the bor- “The specific intelligence perhaps the most difficult gov-
Hours before the attack, se- area intelligence capabilities. Hamas was considering dates der that morning. details that popped up during ernment negotiations in the
nior military officials were up The strike left Israel blind for for the attack, which was only that night [of Oct. 6, 2023] history of our country,” said
late into the night discussing three hours as the broader op- known to a select few, but for weren’t strong enough to Christian Stocker, ÖVP head
suspicious behavior by Hamas. eration unfolded and allowed which thousands of operatives Fighting blind break a yearslong conception,” and designated chancellor.
Israeli military chief of staff waves of militants to cross the had trained for years. Starting at 6:29 a.m., as the official said. Their program includes
Herzi Halevi told his deputies fence into Israel unopposed. The origins of the Oct. 7 at- Hamas fired rockets, 1,500 measures right-wing populists
to gather more information for Militants had free rein to tack stretch back to 2016, with fighters invaded. have called for, such as cutting
a briefing the next day. No one attack military bases, kill civil- the rise of the group’s now- “We are at war,” Israeli bri- Upshot for Israel welfare payments to asylum
thought time was a critical ians at a desert rave and in deceased leader Yahya Sinwar gade commander Asaf Hamami The report recommends Is- seekers, abolishing family re-
factor, Israeli officials said. agricultural communities. In through the leadership ranks, said over the radio at 6:45 a.m. rael establish an intelligence unification for refugees and
However, Israel’s top gen- total, 1,200 security personnel the investigation said. The first hours of the attack unit whose sole purpose is to barring Islamic headscarves for
eral in its north was sum- and civilians were killed that Israel had believed Hamas were the most damaging and evaluate warning signals, sig- girls under 14. The parties also
moned late that night to army day and 251 people were taken was focused on building a state deadly for Israel because it nificantly increase the size of said they would freeze rents
headquarters in Tel Aviv. Is- hostage. It would take 5½ in Gaza and trying to take con- had no eyes on the ground af- the military and beef up bor- for a year and combat exces-
rael’s military was preoccu- hours to get reinforcements to trol of the West Bank, before ter its chain of command was der defenses. sive government spending.
CLOCKWISE FROM TOP: UAE PRESIDENTIAL COURT/REUTERS; YUKI IWAMURA/BLOOMBERG NEWS; RON SACHS/CNP/ZUMA PRESS
While many are plunging tens The U.A.E. has long seen it-
of billions of dollars into con- self as something of a Swit-
centrated areas—SoftBank is zerland—a trusted point of
making a huge bet on OpenAI trade for East and West—and
and the tech giants are heav- choosing sides on AI would
ing money at data centers— risk damaging relations with
Tahnoon is planning to spread China. But the allure of the
more money broadly around U.S. lead on AI was too much
the fledgling sector than al- to ignore.
most anyone else. Tahnoon picked the U.S.
Huawei routers were ripped
out of G42’s offices and West-
Risky time ern equipment put in its place,
It is a risky time to be while Tahnoon and his aides
splashing so much cash on AI. continued negotiating with
The low-cost AI model from the administration on details.
China’s DeepSeek has abruptly To enable a deal, the ad-
shaken assumptions on the ministration paired Tahnoon’s
need for heavy investment. company with Microsoft. G42
Valuations across tech have agreed to use Microsoft’s
skyrocketed, and even opti- cloud for AI work and also to
mistic venture capitalists of- comply with U.S. export re-
ten acknowledge the market is strictions as a part of the deal,
in a searing frenzy. Leading AI and Microsoft invested $1.5
companies expect to lose bil- billion in G42, joining its
lions of dollars for years to board of directors.
come, while pledges of future The country has ambitions
profitability rest on hazy as- to host massive data centers
sumptions of a tidal wave of that run Western large lan-
demand. Sheikh Tahnoon bin Zayed Al Nahyan meets in Dubai with Bill Gates, top. Jeffrey Ding, bottom left, caught Tahnoon’s guage models. Semiconductor
Many see parallels to the attention with a book on AI. Right, news of AI breakthroughs by China’s DeepSeek sent stocks plummeting in January. manufacturing could follow, as
late-stage dot-com bubble, government officials have had
when the cash-splashers of from the U.A.E. embassy was so intrigued by computer- At the time, Abu Dhabi’s ing him as the main custodian discussions with TSMC and
the era plunged tens of bil- knocked on his door and said, aided chess that he hired a wealth and economic strategy of Abu Dhabi’s wealth. Samsung about building chip
lions of dollars into building “I cannot find your book in sizable team of engineers to were largely under the control Taken with his own busi- fabrication plants in Abu
out fiber-optic cable networks any bookstore. Can I get two make him a program named of Tahnoon’s brother, Mo- ness empire—a sprawling col- Dhabi, people familiar with
based on projections that in- copies?” Smith recalled. Hydra that could compete hamed. As de facto leader of lection of real estate, mari- the discussions said.
ternet growth would be even Tahnoon grew up in the with the world’s best players. the country, he pushed to si- time, banking and food assets, “We definitely would like
more rapid than it was. A glut shadow of his brother Sheikh Erdogan Günes, a computer phon off part of the emirate’s many with government ties— the U.S. government to give us
of fiber and enormous losses Mohamed bin Zayed Al chess specialist for opening oil wealth and put it into in- that gave Tahnoon control more green lights,” Xiao said,
followed. Nahyan, the longtime crown moves, said he often talked by vestments and economic de- over more than $1.5 trillion as adding U.S. companies are
Tahnoon isn’t deterred. prince who was named presi- phone for two or more hours a velopment, building the of last year, according to data ready to do deals with G42.
His strategy is to use his dent of the U.A.E. in 2022. day with the sheikh as they wealth fund bounty Tahnoon firm Global SWF.
cash and influence not only to While his brother rubbed monitored Hydra’s games. would later inherit. Western business leaders
enable the U.A.E. and Abu shoulders with foreign leaders In late 2017, Tahnoon’s in- Mohamed had long viewed were enamored. Practical obstacles
Dhabi to profit from the rise and crafted plans to remake terest increased after he the tech sector as a big piece Microsoft’s Smith first met Many practical obstacles
of AI, but to make the U.A.E. a Abu Dhabi’s economy, Tah- learned that Google’s AI pro- of that puzzle, and in 2017 Tahnoon in March 2023 on a beckon. There’s no obvious
global hub for the technology. noon honed extracurricular gram AlphaZero had beaten made a push into AI, launch- business trip to Abu Dhabi, link between building data
Seeing enormous global de- activities. the world’s best computer ing a national strategy for the where they struck up a con- centers—scant generators of
mand for years to come, his He became so hooked on chess program after needing technology to make the U.A.E. versation about AI and energy. employment, often located in
vision is that chip plants, data competing with his brothers just four hours to learn the “the world leader in AI” by Tahnoon has also developed a remote locations—and spark-
centers and local AI compa- in “Age of Empires,” a video- rules. It was far more power- 2031. (It was later changed to rapport with OpenAI’s Sam ing a rush of AI software jobs
nies will build a post-oil eco- game where players develop ful than Hydra ever was— “a” world leader). Altman. Early last year, the nearby.
nomic future for the tiny-but- hunter gatherers into power- opening his eyes to the power After Mohamed became the two men discussed a since- Abu Dhabi also faces geo-
powerful emirate a 90 minute ful civilizations, that he hired of AI, he told associates. UAE’s president, there was abandoned plan to finance a political challenges similar to
drive from Dubai—and for the an employee from the com- The following year, he speculation that Tahnoon global network of chip facto- the Microsoft deal. The U.A.E.
country overall. pany that makes the game to tapped Peng Xiao, the former would be named crown prince. ries to be built by TSMC. would need U.S. clearance to
coach him on tactics, former chief technology officer at Instead, Mohamed gave the BlackRock CEO Larry Fink buy far more chips—as well as
employees said. software-turned-Bitcoin firm role to his own son and says he frequently visits the for chip building equipment if
Ornate palace He turned a palace within MicroStrategy, to start G42, a awarded Tahnoon an apparent U.A.E. and talks to Tahnoon it wants to host semiconduc-
From his ornate palace in his royal compound into a company devoted to applica- consolation prize: oversight of about technology, health, lon- tor fabrication plants.
Abu Dhabi, Tahnoon person- gym. He funds one of the tions of AI. two sovereign funds, enthron- gevity—another obsession of The Trump administration
ally tracks the progress of world’s top cycling teams— the sheikh’s—and AI. hasn’t yet weighed in on the
global large language models UAE Team Emirates—and he topic, but Ahmed Yahia,
on a dashboard his research- rides on an island near the MGX’s CEO, said the company
ers built for him on his phone presidential palace he ringed ‘Unique advantage’ plans to spend 70% to 80% of
and computer. He urges subor- with cycling paths. He liked Abu Dhabi “has a position its money in the U.S.
dinates at the giant network super-light Colnago bikes so of influence way beyond the Meanwhile, Tahnoon is
of companies he owns to rap- much that he instructed one size of the population,” said sowing seeds with those in
idly incorporate AI. of his companies to buy the Fink, whose firm is partnering the president’s orbit. MGX
Tahnoon has “the capital to Italian firm that makes them. with a Tahnoon-led entity to took part in a $6 billion fund-
invest in what is a very capi- Tahnoon has poured money invest in AI infrastructure. raise by xAI late last year.
tal-intensive endeavor,” said into building up Brazilian jiu “He believes they have a Tahnoon’s asset manager
Brad Smith, the president of jitsu and other forms of grap- unique advantage in AI.” Lunate recently participated
Microsoft, who has worked ex- pling around the globe. A After the AI frenzy took off in a $1.5 billion additional in-
tensively with the sheikh. black belt, he started a well- in 2023, Tahnoon’s ambitions vestment in Affinity, the in-
During one meeting with funded championship tourna- ran into thorny geopolitics. vestment fund run by Presi-
Tahnoon, he and Microsoft ment that has “become the As national security ad- dent Trump’s son-in-law,
CEO Satya Nadella mentioned Olympics of our sport,” said viser, he has long attracted Jared Kushner, whom Tah-
a book by George Washington Bobby Razak, a filmmaker who criticism for overseeing the noon met in the first Trump
KEVIN DIETSCH/GETTY IMAGES
University professor Jeffrey is making a documentary on UAE’s vast spying operation. administration.
Ding that suggests AI could be Tahnoon and the event. Due to an eye condition, he is Speaking to a podcast in
the base of coming global eco- “He’s definitely one of the almost always photographed December, Kushner recalled a
nomic growth. Founding Fathers of mixed indoors in sunglasses, adding 2018 meeting when he was
The sheikh scribbled it martial arts,” he said, a sport to his aura of intrigue. visiting the region. Tahnoon
down on his notepad, and that “would not be where it Security analysts have told him, “Jared, I’m not
soon after, Ding was eating was today” without Tahnoon. warned G42 subsidiaries have meeting with you unless you
lunch in his Washington, D.C., The interest in AI has roots U.S. President Joe Biden and U.A.E. President Sheikh been involved in surveillance spend two hours after with
office when a representative in the early 2000s, when he Mohamed bin Zayed Al Nahyan met last year in Washington. of Emirati residents and dis- me to talk about AI.”
ARTS IN REVIEW
D
eparting his lovely FILM REVIEW | KYLE SMITH Finn Cole, Woody Harrelson and
home in Scotland for a Simu Liu in ‘Last Breath,’ which is
Claustrophobic Cinema
deep-sea diving expe- based on a true story.
dition, a young man
tells his fiancée not to
worry: It’s just like go- even condescending toward his
ing into outer space, except in the new partner, Chris, that he is beg-
opposite direction. Not unreason- Divers race against time to rescue their trapped coworkers ging for an arc of redemption, but
ably, she asks: Is that supposed to it never comes. Mr. Harrelson,
reassure me? who brings so much zingy energy
Unlike the audience, young dersea line. Sealing themselves in cated technological marvels, but countdown clock appears: His re- and intelligence to virtually every
Chris (Finn Cole) and his be- a submarine-like tube that sub- as Mr. Parkinson illustrates with serve system grants him only 10 role he takes, does somewhat bet-
trothed, Morag (Bobby Rains- jects them to 10 atmospheres of supreme suspense, all of it is ulti- minutes of breathing time as ter, even though he gets only a
bury), do not know they are char- pressure, they prepare for a walk mately at the mercy of the fickle storms force the ship some 600 few lines to build his back story.
acters in a movie, and so cannot on the sea floor, some 300 feet and feral sea. Moreover, there is a feet away. Mr. Parkinson does a To have such a talented actor in
hear the doomy sounds of onrush- below the waves. This being a no- particular cinematic challenge lay- superb job of showing us just how the cast and give him so little to
ing disaster in the subaquatic toriously grumpy body of water, ered atop the natural one: So sty- dark it is underneath, so inky that do feels like dereliction of duty.
thriller “Last Breath.” There 20-foot swells bedevil the ship as gian is the darkness underwater, even with a light you might not As for Chris, an everyman
wouldn’t be a movie if everything it tries to maintain its position and such is the nature of the div- be able to see something a few rather than a hero whose misad-
were about to go perfectly for over the target, and when some ing helmet, that it’s difficult to yards in front of you. As the situ- ventures are the heart of the
Chris, and when we hear that it’s systems go offline the divers’ capture either what is happening ation becomes ever more agoniz- story, Mr. Cole simply seems too
the last mission for a retiring col- problems are just beginning. or the expressions of the actors. ing, seemingly going well past the small and recessive for the part,
league, Duncan (Woody Harrel- Based on the 2019 documen- Most of the acting burden there- point of survivability, every tech- which demands someone with the
son), the potential for a serious tary of the same name, “Last fore falls on Mr. Harrelson, exhort- nical challenge becomes the cen- world-class charisma Tom Hanks
mishap hits approximately 100%. Breath” intently, gravely evokes ing his divers (without a helmet) ter of its own suspenseful mini- displayed in “Apollo 13.” That film
True to its lovers’ discussion, the the details of one of the most dan- from the relative safety of the bell, drama. took its time establishing the cul-
film is much like an outer-space gerous trades on earth. Every and to Mark Bonnar and Cliff Cur- Yet “Last Breath,” which runs ture from which the endangered
adventure, one in particular: valve, dial, tube and air hose looks tis as the dive supervisor and a compact 91 minutes, doesn’t feel astronauts came and gave us am-
“Apollo 13.” like it carries the potential for cat- ship’s captain who try to manage like a finished film: The dialogue ple reason to love them; “Last
Chris, his fellow diver Dave astrophic failure in the eyes of the a chaotic situation from the bridge is strictly functional, and there is Breath” feels, by contrast, rushed.
(Simu Liu), and Duncan, who is to director, Alex Parkinson, who also against a ticking clock. so little time for establishing Mr. Parkinson should have put as
FOCUS FEATURES
supervise their operations from a co-wrote the script, having writ- When one man gets his “umbil- character that none of the three much care into personalities as he
diving bell, head out on a ship ten and co-directed the earlier ical”—his oxygen line—stuck, and principals really makes an impres- did into their harrowing environ-
from Aberdeen into the North Sea nonfiction film. Ships and diving consequently gets separated from sion. This is especially true of Mr. ment. In short, these characters
to perform maintenance on an un- bells are extraordinarily sophisti- the other diver, an onscreen Liu, whose Dave is so cold and don’t get enough room to breathe.
Gene Hackman’s
lovable, too; equaled
perhaps only by Bur-
gess Meredith’s
Mickey in “Rocky,” he
Unsentimental Grit
created one of the
most revered of all
the sports-movie
coaches in 1986’s
“Hoosiers.” With his
BY KYLE SMITH he personified unsentimental grit. caustic voice—he
For boomers whose taste for bleak could tear into the air
T
he term “character actor” is a and rough-edged cinema started to like a police siren—he
puzzler. Don’t all actors play take over the Hollywood studios was seemingly an ur-
characters? For decades, the starting around 1967, his rise was ban figure, but he
label was applied to performers perfectly timed. After building a made a delightful,
who weren’t beautiful enough to reputation on the New York stage, and unexpected,
play leads. In “Bonnie and Clyde,” he received an Oscar nomination for move into westerns,
Warren Beatty was a leading man; “Bonnie and Clyde,” and earned an- winning an Oscar for
the fellow who played his brother, other three years later as a sensi- playing a typically
Buck Barrow, was a character actor: tive son dealing with his father’s cantankerous sheriff
Gene Hackman. impending death in “I Never Sang in Clint Eastwood’s
Mr. Hackman, who was found for My Father.” Mr. Hackman was “Unforgiven.”
dead Wednesday in his home in now cemented as an unlikely star. Citing heart prob-
Santa Fe, N.M., at age 95, gave such He proved a successor to James lems, Mr. Hackman
a crackling, vivid per- Cagney and Hum- retired unexpectedly
formance that he and phrey Bogart, with in 2004, leaving
others who would the critical difference 2001’s Wes Anderson
previously have been The star pushed that, in accordance dramedy “The Royal
dismissed as charac- boundaries with the new prefer- played Popeye Doyle. Largely ignored The actor in ‘The French Tenenbaums” as one of his final
ter actors—his one- ence for all things by audiences, and overshadowed by Connection’; he was found dead in roles. It was an especially poignant
time classmate and created new dark and menacing, Mr. Coppola’s “The Godfather Part II” his home on Wednesday. one, built around the decline and de-
Dustin Hoffman, Jack
Nicholson, Al Pacino—
kinds of his characters often
faced failure. “The
the same year (not to mention an-
other 1974 hit, “Young Frankenstein,” blockbuster “The Poseidon Adven-
mise of his character, a woefully bad
father whose blunders leave his chil-
joined the front rank characters. French Connection,” a in which an uncharacteristically ture,” he portrayed a rugged minister dren warped and depressed. Yet
of a new generation manhunt set against wacky Mr. Hackman was hilarious as forced into an impossible situation such was Mr. Hackman’s charm that,
of leading men in vis- a brutally realistic de- a blind hermit), “The Conversation” at the climax, hanging by a valve by the time his character was laid to
ceral, punchy movies piction of a collapsing would later join the pantheon of mo- wheel that he used his last reserves rest under a fictitious gravestone
like 1971’s “The French Connection,” New York, ended with Popeye’s tar- mentous 1970s cinema. Mr. Hack- of strength to painfully turn. Doom- (“died tragically rescuing his family
in which Mr. Hackman’s blistering get—“Frog One”—still at large. And in man would essentially reprise his ing himself in the act, he cleared a from the wreckage of a destroyed
performance as the cynical but ob- a follow-up that was at least as character for a flashier thriller, the passage for others but was left with sinking battleship”), he had turned
sessively dedicated NYPD detective powerful, 1975’s “The French Con- 1998 Will Smith man-on-the-run no option but to plunge to his death, an aggressively eccentric figure in a
Popeye Doyle won him an Oscar. nection II,” Doyle was not only cap- tale “Enemy of the State,” which using his final words to scream at severely whimsical movie into a
Mr. Hackman—balding, gruff, pug- tured but shot up with drugs and was prescient about the potential God: “We’ve come all this way, no proxy for every failed dad whose
nacious, not infrequently angry, oc- forced to undergo heroin withdrawal. for technology to keep tabs on us all. thanks to you. . . . We didn’t ask you children nevertheless can’t conceive
casionally snakishly charming, with In 1974’s “The Conversation,” a Mr. Hackman’s work, such as the to fight for us, but dammit, don’t of existence without him. Mr. Hack-
MOVIESTORE/SHUTTERSTOCK
a surprisingly effective if rarely de- groundbreaking Francis Ford Coppola 1975 noir “Night Moves” and the fight against us.” man’s importance to his profession
ployed smile—was among the hand- drama about wiretapping, corruption 1973 road movie with Mr. Pacino, In another huge hit of the period, was similar: Looking back, it’s hard
ful of actors upon whom 1970s cin- and the elusiveness of truth, Mr. “Scarecrow,” found him stubbornly his impish Lex Luthor was like a to imagine the movies without him.
ema was built. As befitting a man Hackman hogtied his energies to fighting a deeply troubled culture spoof of a sleazy politician that
who in real life had lied about his play a meek, withdrawn, painfully while doing his best to maintain a played perfectly off the utter sincer- Mr. Smith is the Journal’s film
age to join the Marine Corps at 16, shy man as convincingly as he shred of dignity. Even in the 1972 ity of Christopher Reeve’s Super- critic.
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Friday, February 28, 2025 | A11
ARTS IN REVIEW
S
New York THEATER REVIEW | CHARLES ISHERWOOD
▶ Email your answer—in the subject line—to [email protected] by 11$59 p.m. Eastern Time Sunday,
The characters are brought March 2. A solver selected at random will win a WSJ mug. Last week’s winner: Blair Seelinger, Wake Forest,
together after their mother NC. Complete contest rules at WSJ.com/Puzzles. (No purchase necessary. Void where prohibited. U.S.
has a stroke. residents 18 and over only.)
A12 | Friday, February 28, 2025 THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
SPORTS
JASON GAY
He has endless memories of a mother Maureen’s room, fish sports. “Toughness,” he said. tournament bid to the conference
hockey childhood, skating the around a T-shirt drawer, and grab “What makes our players spe- McKelvie, the coach in waiting, winner.
frigid Smith Rink until his Dad’s Dad’s 1960 gold medal to show cial is what they’re willing to do described it as “rugged.” There will be a Riley on staff
team practiced. Back then, facili- off. for their country,” Riley said. “We want a team that is able to next season, too. As has been the
ties were spartan, but there was a “Every time I did that, I’d “They want to be part of some- wear teams down through physi- case for the past couple of years,
sizable home ice advantage— [think], ‘Why does Dad stay at thing bigger than themselves.” cality and competitiveness,” he one of the Black Knights assistants
Smith Rink was enormous, West Point?’” Brian recalled. “He Rob Riley, who served as head said. will be Brian’s son, a former col-
stretching an exhausting 233 feet, could be coaching in the NHL. He coach from 1986 until 2004, No one, I’m told, was more lege hockey star and developing
Brian said. (NHL rinks are 200 could be coaching any big time echoed his brother’s admiration of competitive than Jack Riley, who coach himself.
feet long.) hockey school—but he’s staying at the cadets. remained that way long into re- His name is Jack Riley.
Visiting teams got tired just West Point.” “It’s such a challenging grind— tirement, Brian said. You can’t keep a good hockey
looking at it. “As a kid, you don’t under- the academic piece, and you throw “He’d come up to me at a game family away from the ice.
playing for them again. “This is about their experience while, took over in last place, with malfunctioning toilets, showers the mirror” and “be a better
In the third annual survey con- at work, and it’s not what happens players describing the facility as that didn’t work, and a rat infesta- owner.” That rings especially true
ducted by the NFL Players Associa- on the field,” said former offensive outmoded while also giving poor tion. But this year, Washington’s after the team stood out last year
tion, Washington ranked 11th out lineman JC Tretter, the NFLPA’s marks to the food they’re served. improvement was part of a broader for reasons that had nothing to do
of 32 teams after finishing dead chief strategy officer. “There is no The team noted in a statement that theme of positive change that with their on-field flameout.
last in the first two editions. Play- connection to those things.” it has plans for a state-of the art union officials saw as welcome re- Union officials said most team
ers pointed to the hiring of Dan For the second consecutive sea- facility that it hopes to complete in sponse to their feedback. Overall, owners used last year’s feedback as
Quinn, who rated No. 1 among all son, the Dolphins and Minnesota 2027. there was a 41% increase in grades an impetus to make changes in the
head coaches, as one of the keys Vikings topped the survey, with “Our goal is to provide the best of A- or above, with the Los Ange- right direction—and the Jets were
behind the turnaround. Other im- Miami the only team to receive an possible environment, facilities and les Chargers (30th to 5th) and At- the lone exception.
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Friday, February 28, 2025 | A13
OPINION
Why Dems Are in the Wilderness BOOKSHELF | By Brandy Schillace
D o n a l d
Trump’s shock
lapse was years in the mak-
ing. The left’s takeover of the
uity” and the “human rights”
of government-provided
direction? Engage muscle
memory and do the easy:
First Words and
Final Moments
troops are bro Democratic Party began with health, housing, education fight, fight, fight. Thus the bi-
fist-bumping, the rise of Barack Obama and and daycare. To agree with zarre sight of Democrats ral-
having used it steadily eradicated dissent- Bernie Sanders only 95% of lying fervently in favor of
their online ing voices. Nancy Pelosi’s the time is, in today’s Demo- government waste, fraud and
POTOMAC influence to “majority makers”—the Blue cratic Party, iconoclastic. inefficiency. Expect this to
browbeat GOP Dogs and moderates who won A few Democrats are feel- continue.
WATCH
senators into her the speakership in 2006— ing their way toward a new This could be the MAGA
Bye Bye I Love You: The Story
By Kimberley
A. Strassel
confirming were made to support unpop- model of economic populism, future. The GOP is a party of Of Our First and Last Words
most of the ular legislation and paid for it many factions, and their
By Michael Erard
p r e s i d e n t ’s in lost elections. Progressives policy disagreements fre-
MIT, 344 pages, $32.95
nominees. They might be care- targeted and polarized other Republicans shouldn’t quently produce stalemates
ful of the political conformity holdouts, picked them off in and governing heartache. In-
get smug. They’re
O
they wish for. primaries, or drove them to fluential Trump supporters lga Janá!ková did not have long to live as she lay
Democrats are wandering resignation. It was Saul Alin- repeating the other are honing their own meth- still upon the sofa, her hair in waves surrounding
somewhere between the des- sky’s “Rules for Radicals.” ods for stamping out even a “wide, gentle face.” The 21-year-old had con-
ert and the wilderness. Their The Squad’s wild proposals party’s mistakes. mild disagreement with the tracted typhoid and come home to die, watched over by
Trump thumping left them for the Green New Deal, open president’s approach: rally her father, the Czech composer Leoš Janá!ek. For hours
without power, a leader or a borders, Medicare for all—a online supporters to pile on, that February in 1903 Janá!ek waited at his daughter’s
message, and their current, program of socialism that tra- deep-sixing the wokeism, label the target a member of side, making notes of her “speech melodies”—her words
near total irrelevance is one ditional Democrats initially carving out sensible posi- the “uniparty” or the “estab- but also her sighs, her intonation, the music of her final
result. Mr. Trump blazes his rejected—is now mainstream tions here and there on the lishment,” threaten a pri- moments (“I am dying, I am dying”). He also captured
way through Washington thinking, the policy litmus border or Israel while dou- mary. This exact playbook her feverish deliriums: “that was some walk we took!”
while Democrats—a day late, test for party entry. Who even bling down on redistributive was exercised numerous and “there are just angels there.” These were among the
and two topics short—stage remembers the politics of goodies for the working times over the past few last words Janá!ková spoke, but they weren’t the final
stand-ins outside the Trea- Sens. Mark Pryor, Evan Bayh class. The most prominent weeks of nomination votes. sounds she uttered.
sury building, Chuck and Mary Landrieu, much less example is Pennsylvania’s “Rules for Radicals.” With an ear for every
Schumer shout-gasping “We those of John Breaux, Sam Sen. John Fetterman. This It’s a recipe for intellectual exhalation, her father
will win!” Nunn and Fritz Hollings? Joe isn’t being met with open stagnation. It’s a departure marked down single
Win what? The Democratic Manchin and Kyrsten Sinema arms. At a recent anti-Trump from the modern conservative syllables, such as “kuk,”
Party can’t effectively oppose tried imposing a smidgen of protest, Pennsylvanians movement, which has been “tak” and “jeje,” along
Mr. Trump’s worldview if it fiscal sanity and energy real- lumped Mr. Fetterman into defined by its innovative with the sound of her
doesn’t formulate a coherent ity on Joe Biden’s agenda. their tirade, while Fetterman ideas, from school choice to sighs, “a-ja.” Nonsense,
one of its own. Many Demo- Their reward was to be staffers keep resigning in civil-service reform. It sits maybe. Or perhaps a dif-
crats rolled out of the election hounded in their homes, protest. One recent ex-em- unnaturally in a movement ferent kind of sense,
acknowledging the urgent chased into bathrooms by ac- ployee derided him as “a use- that has long prized individu- akin to that made by
need for a change in direc- tivists, and discouraged from ful idiot for Republicans.” alism and entrepreneurship preverbal children trying
tion—for moderation, an end seeking re-election. If Democrats didn’t already and condemned the left’s col- to communicate using a
to cultural radicalism, a re- The problem isn’t so much know the progressive agenda lectivism. It mistakes the goal meaning all their own.
connect with working-class that Democrats won’t em- was a political loser (and Ka- of party unity (the act of Care for the dying
Americans. They immediately brace moderation as they no mala Harris’s campaign sub- members compromising on resembles nothing so
crashed into the left-wing longer know how. Today’s terfuge proves they did), they strongly held positions for a much as care for the
base, threatening political Democratic “moderate” is a do now. What to do with an legislative victory) with the newly born. This deep,
death to heretics. Even if the lawmaker who ventures the ash heap of a political plat- tyranny of party conformity immeasurable connection
party had the spine to push occasional criticism of Hamas form, one nonetheless rigidly (think like we do, or get the is precisely what Michael
back, who exactly on the Dem- or of men in women’s sports enforced by liberal shock boot). Erard, a linguist and historian, most wants to explore.
ocratic bench even remembers while hurrying to flag his troops, and no charismatic And look how it worked “With our earliest utterances,” he writes, “we announce
how to be a moderate? support for gun control, cli- figure with the spine or out for Democrats. ourselves” and are recognized “as persons ready to par-
What looks like a rapid col- mate absolutism, racial “eq- know-how to lead a change of Write to [email protected]. ticipate in social life.” With our last sounds, we carve
out a space for leaving it. “Bye Bye I Love You” follows
both of these journeys, searching for what these words—
Fyodor Dostoevsky’s Struggle With Faith and our desperate need to hear them—reveal about their
meaning, our mortality and the ephemerality of being
human.
HOUSES OF As Fyodor student of natural science, I believe, help Thou my unbe- there is no happiness in inac- In the West, we hang our own myths upon our babies’
WORSHIP Dostoevsky Ivan accepts that amoral natu- lief.” That Dostoevsky writes tivity, that the mind which first words, imbuing them with meaning that is sup-
By Gary Saul was taken to ral laws govern everything “even if” someone were to does not labor will wither, posed to tell us something about the child’s burgeoning
Morson Siberia as a and that good and evil are so- prove that the truth excludes that it is not possible to love personality. In American English, the most common first
political cial conventions. But he can’t Christ already indicates that one’s neighbor without sacri- words are “mommy,” “daddy,” “ball,” “bye,” “Hi” and
prisoner in relinquish a belief in transcen- he, like Ivan, will never be con- ficing to him of one’s own la- “No.” But there are similarities between languages, too.
1850, Natalya Fonvizina gave dent, absolute morality. His tent with the complacent nihil- bor.” In short, Dostoevsky When a child says “mommy,” it feels like a deep connec-
him a copy of the New Testa- whole being tells him that not ism of other intellectuals. concluded: “Happiness lies tion. Yet these are words likely spoken around the baby
ment, the only book prisoners all standards are mere conven- This peculiar kind of faith, not in happiness but only in with high regularity. “Interactions with parents and
were allowed to have. It sus- tion; some things, such as which consists partly of doubt, the attempt to achieve it.” So caregivers are important to babies,” Mr. Erard explains.
tained him in adversity and child abuse, are plainly wrong. has become Dostoevsky’s does faith. They will use the words for things that most intimately
led him to faith. Five years Ivan is torn by this contradic- trademark and explains why Variations on this theme relate to themselves, things that are a part of their new
later, when Fonvizina was tion. Dostoevsky’s spokesman, he has brought so many peo- appear in several of his novels. world.
deeply depressed, Dostoevsky Father Zosima, assures Ivan ple to God. It is hard to imag- In “The Idiot,” Ippolit declares First words are also a matter of interpretation. Babies
consoled her in what is doubt- that even if he never finds ine educated Westerners con- that “Columbus was not happy speak protophones first—sounds that aren’t quite words
less the best-known letter in faith, he will never give up verted by Dante or Milton, for when he had discovered Amer- but that we might read as the “runway of his creative
Russian literature. searching for it. “That is the ica, but when he was discover- experimentation.” Mr. Erard provides one such example
Recalling his own days of peculiarity of your heart,” Zo- ing it. . . . It’s life that matters, using his own child’s first words, “round round,” uttered
despair, Dostoevsky explained sima instructs, “but thank the The Russian novelist nothing but life—the process while peering at a ceiling fan. As a father, the author
that “at such moments one Creator who has given you a of discovering, the everlasting found himself trying to plot a future personality based
thirsts for faith like ‘parched lofty heart capable of such accepted the idea that and perpetual process, not the on these words: Perhaps the child would like a ball; per-
grass,’ and one finds it at last suffering . . . [and] of seeking belief includes doubt discovery itself.” But that is haps he will enjoy sports. The words had meaning for
because the truth becomes evi- for higher things, for our absurd, the unnamed hero of the speaker as much as the listener, an identifiable sub-
dent in unhappiness.” The faith dwelling is in the heavens.” and embraces wonder. “Notes From Underground” text: “I am he who notices fast-moving round things.” I
Dostoevsky found resembled To be sure, Dostoevsky comments. After all, once one speak, therefore I am.
not an unshakable conviction writes to Fonvizina, God knows he doesn’t really want The first half of “Bye Bye I Love You” provides this
but a struggle with doubt. “I sometimes sends blissful mo- whom God’s existence was a the goal, how can he strive for linguistic geography, but the heart of the book is in the
will tell you that I am a child of ments when “I love and feel simple fact. Dostoevsky’s idea it? For the underground man, country beyond, where there are no maps. Death comes.
this century, a child of disbelief loved by others.” Then he af- that the essence of faith lies in “there seems to be a kind of When it arrives, via age and illness, when the mind and
and doubt,” he wrote. “I am firms his own “credo”: Noth- the process of searching for it pun in it all.” body give way to encroaching entropy, last words carry
that today and (I know) will re- ing is “more beautiful, pro- speaks to those who are also Tolstoy once criticized Dos- deep and abiding meanings. And yet, most dying people
main so until the grave.” found, sympathetic . . . and children of “disbelief and toevsky as “all struggle,” but it
Since the rise of modern more perfect than Christ.” doubt.” is that characteristic that ex-
science, educated people have Whether or not Christ existed, Dostoevsky’s focus on pro- plains why his ideas resonate As we enter and leave the world, the task of
often found it difficult to be- his image is an unsurpassable cess rather than goal shaped with so many. Those who can’t communication looms large. Simple sounds
lieve with calm certainty the ideal, a picture of the best his view of human life. The view life with fashionable
ideal of their medieval prede- possible moral being. utopian socialists of his day complacency, who understand and gestures can take on great importance.
cessors. Like Dostoevsky, they Dostoevsky continues: “If presumed that if you gave that uncertainty can be a
experience a painful internal someone proved to me that people everything so that blessing and that no scientific
conflict. “How much terrible Christ is outside the truth, and they had nothing to strive discovery will ever reveal life’s are, in their last moments, silent. Reliable databases of
torture this thirst for faith has that in reality the truth were for, they would be happy. meaning, find inspiration in last words do not exist. Collections of famous last words
cost me even now, which is all outside Christ, I should still Dostoevsky believed the op- Dostoevsky’s supremely para- are rarely bedside recordings; more likely they are
the stronger in my soul the prefer to remain with Christ posite. People would instead doxical idea that true faith in- highly curated and probably mythologized. In the “ordi-
more arguments I find against rather than with the truth.” soon see that “they had no cludes doubt and embraces nary language of ordinary dying,” deep philosophical
it,” Dostoevsky wrote. How can one believe in what more life left, no freedom of wonder. utterance is rare. “It seems cruel to dangle such a pros-
Readers of “The Brothers one knows to be untrue? In the spirit . . . no personality. . . . pect in front of people,” Mr. Erard writes. “After all,
Karamazov” will recognize Gospel of Mark, the father who They would see that their hu- Mr. Morson is a professor of rainbows don’t happen every time it rains.”
this same tortured struggle in implores Jesus to cure his af- man image had disappeared.” Slavic languages and literatures Dying is not only the stopping of heartbeats and the
its intellectual hero, Ivan. As a flicted child exclaims: “Oh Lord They would recognize “that at Northwestern University. cessation of breath; it happens incrementally all over.
The brain and its gifts are not exempt. As hypoxia sets
in, there isn’t enough oxygen to feed the brain. Thoughts
Rubio Can Unhijack ‘Human Rights’ cloud, grow confused, collide. Words fail. There are sto-
ries unnumbered where loved ones are left in silence,
watching their beloved struggle and fail to communicate.
By Robert P. George of human rights. The rights to human life in all stages and concerns about violations of We pine for those precious last things to be said. We
life, religious freedom, freedom imposing conditions to fun- human rights—especially free- want assurances that we are heard and understood, too.
S
ecretary of State Marco of expression, and due process neling foreign aid on behalf of dom of speech and religion— We want those last moments to be ones of linguistic
Rubio has taken swift of law are all rooted, as Martin gay rights and transgender not only in Russia and China, connection, a memento mori we can keep. But should
action against woke Bi- Luther King Jr. observed, in ideology. but even in democracies like we? Have we, in our focus on words as the mark of
den-era policies. Passports natural law and enshrined in This reconception of human Germany, Sweden and the U.K. being and becoming, missed something more important?
now list a holder’s sex, not our nation’s founding docu- rights spurred Secretary Mike In bluntly condemning the po- In Papua New Guinea, aging people are described as
“gender,” and there’s no “X” ments. An understanding of Pompeo to establish the Com- licing of speech in Germany becoming children again. They lose mobility, they make
option; and U.S. embassies are mission on Unalienable Rights and thought in the U.K., where less sense, they end as nonverbal zik mandion—“unripe”
forbidden to display “pride” in 2019, under the chairman- people have been arrested for or a “not yet ready child.” And here, the first part of Mr.
flags or any other banners The Founders’ ship of Harvard legal scholar praying silently, Mr. Vance Erard’s study returns with great poignancy. In the unripe
than the Stars and Stripes. definition of the term Mary Ann Glendon. In its re- sent a message that protec- utterance of babies, we can still find connection. The
These efforts are important port, the commission outlined tion and promotion of human body language, the look, the touch, the flutter of lashes.
and commendable. But Mr. is ripe for revival. the historical Western concep- rights is in the U.S. national “The final utterance, in whatever mode it appears”—
Rubio can do more. He can re- tion of rights and recom- interest. whether the squeeze of the fingers, or perhaps a letting
institute the State Depart- mended that the U.S. be “cau- Mr. Rubio ought to revive go of them—can smooth the path to dying. What matters
ment’s efforts during the first rights as deriving from the in- tious” about “expanding” it. the report of the Commission is that we are open to that moment, ready to receive
Trump administration to re- herent and equal dignity of ev- The effort to stifle “legiti- on Unalienable Rights and use what the dying can give, even in silence. There doesn’t
store the original understand- ery person echoes the Ameri- mate debate by recasting con- it as a guidance document to need to be a word for everything.
ing of human rights. Over the can Founders’ prophetic testable policy preferences as reform human-rights policy.
past 30 years, the definition proclamation “that all men are fixed and unquestionable hu- Americans deserve a State De- Ms. Schillace, the editor in chief of the journal Medi-
of human rights has been re- created equal” and “endowed man rights imperatives,” the partment that defends rights cal Humanities, is the host of the online “Peculiar Book
worked by progressives to by their Creator” with “un- commission’s report noted, that accord with the constitu- Club” podcast and the author of “Death’s Summer Coat.”
promote socially liberal alienable rights.” “promotes intolerance, im- tional order that our Founders
causes and woke dogma. During the Obama and Bi- pedes reconciliation, devalues established.
Human rights have long den administrations, the State core rights, and denies rights Coming in BOOKS this weekend
been a driving moral force in Department reconceived hu- in the name of rights.” Mr. George is a professor of Meghan Cox Gurdon on the best 20 children’s books of
America’s foreign policy. Ron- man rights to advance left- In his recent speech at the jurisprudence and director of the last 20 years • Silicon Valley and the future of the
ald Reagan made the case wing causes, from castigating Munich Security Conference, the James Madison Program West • Catholic confession in America • Merle Oberon’s
against Soviet expansionism countries like Poland for laws Vice President JD Vance ex- in American Ideals and Insti- life on screen • How to manage our emotions • & more
and oppression in the language that uphold the sanctity of pressed the U.S. government’s tutions at Princeton.
A14 | Friday, February 28, 2025 THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
OPINION
REVIEW & OUTLOOK LETTERS TO THE EDITOR
A Mineral Deal Ukraine Can’t Refuse Two Views on the ‘Myth of the Trade Deficit’
In their Feb. 21 op-ed “Trump’s Messrs. Gramm and Boudreaux do
V
olodymyr Zelensky visits the White Ukraine’s budget. That’s important because
House on Friday to nail down a mineral Ukraine uses domestic revenue to fund its mili- Myth of the Trade Deficit,” Phil an excellent job of explaining the ne-
Gramm and Donald Boudreaux cor- cessity of trade deficits when the U.S.
rights deal between the U.S. and tary, including soldier pay and weapons. Russia
rectly note that when American de- has a net inflow of foreign investment,
Ukraine, and it’s an offer the wants a peace deal that limits mand for investment exceeds domes- a capital account surplus. Too often,
Ukrainian President couldn’t The agreement gives Ukraine’s military. tic savings, trade deficits create people view this accounting identity
refuse. But regardless of Presi- the U.S. a stake in the no The mineral deal includes American jobs by funding otherwise as bookkeeping mumbo jumbo. The
dent Trump’s bullying de- U.S. security guarantees unfunded domestic investment with case of the Volkswagen plant in Chat-
mands, the deal gives the U.S. country’s peaceful future. but says the U.S. “supports offshore savings. But that hasn’t tanooga, Tenn., can help illustrate the
a stake in Ukraine’s future. Ukraine’s efforts to obtain se- been the case for decades. Risk- tangible reality of this link.
Ukraine is in many ways an curity guarantees needed to averse offshore savings proffered at In 2008 Volkswagen announced its
underdeveloped country, and that includes its establish lasting peace.” It’s hard to know what near-zero interest rates didn’t fund plan to spend about a billion dollars
natural resources. The country has Europe’s that unspecific promise means, but in Mr. increased business investment. They to build a factory in Chattanooga. The
largest supply of uranium, second-largest sup- Trump’s mind it probably means Europeans funded a one-time increase in sub- plant was built by American workers
prime consumption before the finan- using American materials on Ameri-
ply of natural gas, and substantial reserves of help first.
cial crisis and an enormous deficit-fi- can soil. German ownership of the fa-
lithium and other rare-earth minerals. These re- Mr. Trump continues to peddle falsehoods nanced increase in handouts after cility only makes sense if Americans
sources are valued at about $1 trillion, and about how much aid the U.S. and Europe have the financial crisis. received goods and services of equal
about a third are in Russian-occupied territory provided Ukraine. He claims the U.S. is “in for We borrowed and gave away value in exchange. That is, to get the
in eastern Ukraine. $350 billion” in Ukraine. But through December goods made by offshore workers who money, Volkswagen had to sell a bil-
Mr. Trump wants a share of those resources the real U.S. total was nearly $120 billion in mil- would have been unemployed when lion dollars of goods directly to Amer-
as repayment for the aid the U.S. has provided itary, financial and humanitarian support. their savings exceeded investment. icans, or indirectly by selling to others
Kyiv during the war. This is the transactional He says Europe has given much less than the Even if we had insisted that Ameri- who sell to Americans, which deducts
way Mr. Trump views the world and it smacks U.S., but it has spent or promised $137 billion, cans work to pay back their bor- a billion dollars from the trade ac-
of reparations, but Mr. Zelensky had little according to Europe’s authoritative Kiel Insti- rowed income, it wouldn’t have in- count. Were this not the case, we
creased employment. It would have would have given away a billion-dollar
choice other than to oblige if he wants to secure tute. The U.S. has provided more arms because
re-employed workers who lost their factory.
a credible “peace” with Russia. Mr. Zelensky it has more, but Europe has provided more aid jobs when we bought goods made by Ironically, had the factory been
was at least able to negotiate better terms than overall. offshore workers who lent us their built on barges in the Tennessee River
Mr. Trump first demanded. By the way, Mr. Trump on Thursday walked savings rather than buying our and shipped overseas, along with the
Under the final deal, Ukraine will pay half of back his claim last week that Mr. Zelensky is a goods—an identity that’s hard to rec- jobs it created in Chattanooga, it
all revenue from developing these resources to “dictator.” Press question: “Do you still think ognize when lower wages equilibrate would have counted as an export and
an investment fund jointly owned with the U.S. Zelensky is a dictator?” employment. been cheered by those who view trade
The agreement says contributions will be in- Mr. Trump: “Did I say that? I can’t believe ED CONARD surpluses as economic gains.
vested “to promote the safety, security and pros- I said that. Next question.” American Enterprise Institute DAVID W. KREUTZER
perity of Ukraine.” The details will be worked out That welcome, if head-spinning, reversal is New York Falls Church, Va.
between the economic ministries, and Ukraine’s more proof that what matters isn’t what Mr.
Parliament will have to ratify it. Trump says but what he does. That is especially
The war has caused enormous destruction true as the war negotiations begin in earnest
in Ukraine, which will need hundreds of billions between the U.S. and Russia. French and British Remember Putin’s Long and Bloody Résumé
of dollars to rebuild. Foreign taxpayers can’t be leaders traveled to Washington this week to Your editorial Feb. 20 “Trump Tilts Politkovskaya, who was assassinated
expected to cover this cost, and Ukraine will lobby Mr. Trump to provide a U.S. backstop for Toward a Ukraine Sellout” notes that in her apartment building for expos-
need private investment. Other investors might any European troops that deploy to Ukraine af- President Trump has been feuding ing rights abuses in Chechnya; Alex-
be more inclined to help Ukraine rebuild if the ter a deal is struck. with President Zelensky over the war ander Litvinenko, who was poisoned
U.S. is involved. If the mineral deal makes Mr. Trump more between Russia and Ukraine. Mr. in London after accusing the Russian
The deal won’t apply to resources that have inclined to provide that guarantee, so much the Trump has evidently become buddies Federal Security Bureau of trying to
already been developed and contribute to better for Ukraine, Europe and the U.S. with Vladimir Putin and claims, for murder the oligarch Boris Berezovsky;
instance, that Mr. Zelensky is a dicta- Natalya Estemirova, noted human-
tor because there hasn’t been an elec- rights activist who was abducted near
‘Crush Zionism’ on Your Own Time tion since the war began. Never mind
that under Ukrainian law elections
her home and found with bullet holes
in her head and chest after she began
are suspended during wartime. investigating kidnappings and murder
R
emember when Sen. Chuck Schumer was The students recited droning slogans and In making such statements this in Chechnya; Sergei Magnitsky, the
revealed to have told the president of handed out leaflets reading “Crush Zionism,” way, the president forgets or ignores whistle-blowing lawyer who had im-
Columbia University not to worry about with a boot stomping on a star of David. Prof. a long list of horrors that have flowed plicated Russian officials in a tax
Congressional oversight because “universities’ Avi Shilon, a top scholar visiting from Israel, from the only true authoritarian in fraud and later died in jail; and Boris
political problems are really only among Repub- tried to reason with the four wannabe Hamas- the conflict. Here are a few: Nemtsov, shot dead on a bridge near
licans”? Well, Republicans are now in power in niks in Arabic but they didn’t speak any. The assassinations of Russian dissi- the Kremlin for protesting against
Washington. Will colleges adapt? The two Barnard students were expelled and dent Alexei Navalny; Yevgeny Prigo- Russia’s aggression against Ukraine.
Columbia’s anti-Israel student coalition an- zhin, head of the Wagner mercenary Mr. Trump says that his Russian
a third from Columbia is suspended pending an
group, who died in a suspicious heli- counterpart wants peace. The free
nounced Sunday that two student activists investigation. The fourth hasn’t been identified; copter crash; Sergei Yushenkov, world, and the families of those he
have been expelled by Barnard College, which masks can provide impunity. leader of the anti-Kremlin party Lib- has slain, await the evidence.
is closely affiliated with Columbia across the Barnard’s first statement after the expulsion eral Russia who was shot in front of HARVEY A. SILVERGLATE
street. The two seniors disrupted a class to explained, “When rules are broken, when there his Moscow home; the journalist Anna Cambridge, Mass.
shout Hamas propaganda, so Barnard kicked is no remorse, no reflection, and no willingness
them out and told them don’t come back. to change, we must act.” We hope Barnard redis-
Imagine that.
But on Wednesday masked anti-Israel activ-
covers its backbone and punishes the rioters.
Colleges allowed hard-left and Islamic bul-
Reciprocal Tariffs Only Cause Reciprocal Pain
ists stormed a Barnard building to demand the lies to break the rules last year. Typically they Douglas A. Irwin writes powerfully changing their trade policies, Mr.
expulsions be reversed. Barnard says a staff got off scot-free or were put on probation. about the problems of outsourcing Trump should take a page out of
our trade policy to other countries “The Art of the Deal” and find win-
member was physically assaulted and sent to the Some received suspensions that, with faculty
(“‘Reciprocal’ Tariffs Make No Sense,” win propositions that reduce barriers
hospital by the rioters, but it allowed them to help, were reduced to a requirement to take a op-ed, Feb. 14). By promising to re- to trade, not erect new ones. Doing
camp out for hours, vandalize walls and shout joke course on lawful protest. ciprocate others’ tariffs, we are prom- so would enrich the lives of all Amer-
support for Hamas “resistance.” Instead of re- The likes of Sen. Schumer were never going ising to reciprocate their foolishness. icans, boost domestic manufacturing
moving them, Barnard canceled classes. to hold schools accountable. Now, colleges that It’s time to end the failed experi- and lower prices for domestic pro-
At one point Columbia Students for Justice let activists get away with intimidating Jews— ment with tariffs, especially against ducers and consumers—exactly the
in Palestine boasted, “Dean Leslie Grinage of even if they hide behind the word “Zionist”—risk larger economies, like China. Mr. goals Mr. Trump promised on the
@BarnardCollege just asked for our permission federal investigation for failing to uphold Jewish Trump’s own Council of Economic campaign trail.
to use the bathroom. Guess who has the upper students’ civil rights. As the lawyer Alyza Lewin Advisers confirmed the policy’s fail- DAVID HEBERT
hand now?” They refused to take off masks and asks, “Would university administrators permit ure in 2019. Writing of the adminis- American Inst. for Economic Research
dispersed only after being assured they wouldn’t student clubs to demand that Catholics disavow tration’s attempts, the group stated: Grand Rapids, Mich.
“Rather than changing its practices,
face disciplinary consequences. the Vatican or that Muslims shed their connec-
China announced retaliatory tariffs
Here’s what they were rallying to defend: On tion to Mecca in order to be accepted?” on U.S. goods,” as did Canada, the Eu- Rauch Responds to Criticism
Jan. 21, four masked students banging on drums Another route is to investigate discrimina- ropean Union, Mexico, Russia and
entered a History of Modern Israel class. They tion against Israeli students on the basis of While, like any author, I welcome
Turkey. President Biden’s trade repre-
held up a picture of Hamas terrorists pointing their national origin. That, too, violates Title VI attention from the estimable Wall
sentative in 2024 reported that China
Street Journal, neither the headline
guns with the caption “The Enemy Will Not See of the Civil Rights Act. There are plenty of op- “persisted and even [became] more
nor the text of Barton Swaim’s review
Tomorrow,” along with the inverted red trian- tions when the party in power doesn’t consider aggressive” in response to U.S. levies.
accurately represents my work (“It’s
gle Hamas uses to mark targets in its videos. antisemitism to be somebody else’s issue. The president has adopted tariffs
All the Evangelicals’ Fault . . . Again,”
as a hammer but not all of our prob-
Houses of Worship, Feb. 21). My book
lems are nails. Such blunt instru-
A Total Subsidy That Needs DOGE ments ultimately fail to accomplish
their aims. Rather than seek to pun-
is framed as an apology to Christians
for my own misguided celebration of
secularization, and it ends with a
ish or threaten other countries into
H
ard to believe, but the U.S. Export-Import businesses that don’t need or receive govern- plea to fellow secular liberals to rec-
Bank may underwrite a foreign-backed ment support? The Mozambique project would ognize and support, rather than ne-
glect or dismiss, Christianity’s impor-
liquefied natural gas export project in Af- be capable of exporting 13 million tons a year How DOGE Could Wield AI tant role in our country’s political
rica that would compete with (MTPA). The U.S. currently can
American fuel shipments. Talk Why should U.S. export 140 MTPA with another Against Waste in Healthcare and cultural health.
Mr. Swaim correctly notes that I
about an agency in need of the taxpayers underwrite a 86 under construction, plus 89 Your Feb. 11 editorial “The Federal
join with many Christians in criticiz-
DOGE treatment. under regulatory review. Spending Boom Rolls On” states that
ing white evangelicals’ choice to put
The ExIm Bank’s putative foreign LNG project? Earlier this month TotalEn- the Department of Government Effi-
power ahead of principle. For one
purpose is to finance purchases ergies said it planned to boost ciency is only nibbling at the edges of
such criticism, see Matthew 4:10. But
Washington’s spending problem so
of U.S. exports and make Amer- investments in U.S. LNG. Great. readers will find my book to be more
long as it takes Medicare and Medic-
ican products more globally competitive. In prac- Europe and Japan could use all the U.S. LNG ex- aid off the reform list. There’s a way
balanced than his portrayal.
tice, the agency finances investments by big busi- ports they can get as they try to wean them- JONATHAN RAUCH
to solve this problem. Elon Musk’s em-
nesses that primarily benefit foreign companies selves off Russian gas without damaging their Washington
ployees doubtless have the know-how
and governments, much like the U.S. Agency for economies with high energy prices. France in- to develop the DOGE Smart Payment
International Development. creased imports of Russian LNG by 81% last year, System, powered by artificial intelli-
France’s TotalEnergies’ Mozambique LNG ex- despite the war in Ukraine. gence, to screen claims for Medicare
port project is an example. Mozambique boasts Unlike other Western energy giants, TotalEner- and Medicaid and weed out question- Pepper ...
large natural gas reserves off its coasts, but the gies didn’t withdraw from Russia after the Ukraine able ones before they are paid.
The goal would be to reduce
And Salt
East African country suffers from conflict and in- invasion. It still owns large stakes in three major
stability, which has spooked private investors. To- Russian LNG export projects. TotalEnergies last fraud, waste and abuse, which is es- THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
timated to be a significant percent-
tal wants the U.S. and other governments to finance year also signed “a strategic cooperation agree-
age of the $1.5 trillion CMS budget.
its $20 billion LNG project to reduce its risk. ment to deepen their collaboration” with state- The DOGE system could be trained
The ExIm Bank approved a $4.7 billion loan owned China Petroleum and Chemical Cooperation. using the gigantic database of claims
for the project in 2020 on the rationale that TotalEnergies seems to be leveraging its part- that have been paid and denied.
China and Russia might otherwise finance the nerships with Russia and China to argue that the Think about it: A 5% reduction would
deal. But this justification strays from the U.S. should finance its Mozambique project to generate billions in savings each
agency’s stated mission. counter those U.S. adversaries in Africa. The Bi- year. Repeat offenders would be held
Attacks by Islamic militants in the region den ExIm leaders invoked a similar rationale to accountable, limiting future abuse in
prompted TotalEnergies to pause the project in approve a $1.6 billion loan guarantee for a solar a virtuous cycle.
2021. Biden officials never finalized funding, but and battery storage project in Angola, among HANK WERRONEN
Washington
TotalEnergies CEO Patrick Pouyanne recently other wasteful projects.
said he expects the Trump team to do so soon. If Republicans in Congress let ExIm’s authori-
Letters intended for publication should
“Security has improved, but it will never be per- zation lapse next year, they could claim victory be emailed to [email protected]. Please
fect,” he noted. Not perfect? Islamic State mili- for shutting down at least one agency. Mean- include your city, state and telephone
tants are rampaging across the region. time, the Trump Administration can order the number. All letters are subject to
Why should U.S. taxpayers underwrite a risky agency to freeze new deals to avoid throwing editing, and unpublished letters cannot “This isn’t what I intended
be acknowledged.
foreign project that competes with American good taxpayer money after bad. when I started Casual Fridays.”
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Friday, February 28, 2025 | A15
OPINION
A
Moves Left t Yosemite National Park,
one person is responsible
Native American tribes and environ-
mentalists could make it to court,
Joe Biden was inaugurated and re-
for rescuing visitors from stored the Obama boundaries,
By Ira Stoll locked bathrooms: a feder- prompting lawsuits from Utah offi-
ally employed locksmith. cials. With Mr. Trump back in office,
A
t the end of a recently pub- When he was fired recently in Presi- affected communities are likely in
lished Associated Press investi- dent Trump’s bureaucratic purge, for more political whiplash. But Mr.
gation into American tech com- park rangers could do little but pro- Trump’s actions didn’t relinquish the
panies “that have supported Israel’s test by scaling El Capitan with an area to an unregulated Wild West.
wars” came a disclosure: “The Asso- upside-down American flag. The ab- Then and now, the Bureau of Land
ciated Press receives financial assis- surdity of having access to basic fa- Management has overseen the area,
tance from the Omidyar Network.” cilities hinge on one man reflects a along with the 65% of Utah’s area
The language indicates a shift at deeper dysfunction that goes beyond that is designated federal public
the media outlet, whose special Mr. Trump’s scattershot effort. land. It isn’t hard to see why Utahns
White House access President Trump After the outcry, the Trump ad- are angry.
BRITTANY COLT,
recently withdrew. The news-gather- ministration reversed some firings, Political observers too often oper-
ing cooperative was once funded and the National Park Service said it ate on the false premise that with-
largely by dues from member news- would hire several thousand sea- drawing the feds necessarily means
papers. Now it increasingly relies on sonal workers—presumably a lock- An upside-down American flag hangs on El Capitan in Yosemite. that no constituencies, institutions
handouts from left-leaning charities. smith or two among them. The Na- or incentives will arise to deliver
Yet it insists its journalism is “inde- tional Park Service’s operations are was established, California has data on land conditions, while data what is good for the people. That
pendent” and “nonpartisan.” a vivid microcosm of a broader dis- passed laws that protect Yosemite analytics help optimize tourism doesn’t mean federal power has no
Bloomberg estimates eBay cussion about the federal govern- from environmental and commercial through timed entries, online reser- role—but that it should serve as a
founder Pierre Omidyar’s fortune at ment’s purview in the modern age. harm. The California Environmental vations and crowd monitoring. facilitator of localism, supporting
$12.5 billion. Federal election re- The National Park Service was es- Quality Act mandates environmental Meanwhile, state park systems, pri- pluralism rather than undermining it
cords show he gave $1 million in tablished in 1916 to manage and pro- reviews for developments near the vate conservation initiatives and in the name of some nebulous
March 2024 to the ACLU Voter Edu- tect national parks, ensuring the park, while the California Endan- nonprofit organizations already “unity.”
cation Fund and $450,000 in 2016 to preservation of natural and cultural gered Species Act protects vulnera- manage vast landscapes, proving If Yosemite became a California
political-action committees oppos- resources amid growing tourism, in- ble species like the California condor. that effective land stewardship state park tomorrow, would it sud-
ing the Trump-Pence ticket. dustrial expansion and threats from doesn’t depend on federal oversight. denly become a strip mall? Of course
unregulated development. The na- Yet the bureaucracy remains. not. Federal control persists not be-
tional parks themselves came before If Yosemite became a Why? Because it follows the Lindy cause it’s necessary, but because it’s
The nonprofit media that, beginning with Yellowstone in
California state park effect: The longer it’s been estab- the status quo—an assumption
1872. At the time, there were few le- lished, the longer it endures and—in rarely challenged despite changing
outlet takes handouts from gal safeguards for conservation, tomorrow, would it the case of federal power—expands realities. As environmental protec-
the Omidyar Network and leading to concerns about deforesta-
turn into a strip mall? beyond its original purpose long af- tions, technology and governance
tion, excessive grazing of livestock, ter its necessity has faded. Returning structures progress, so should the
other ideological charities. commercial development and unreg- federal public lands to state and local approach to public lands. If Congress
ulated tourism spoiling these scenic control isn’t only about parks. It’s had the backbone, it could strike a
treasures. Over the next four de- Air-quality standards through the about preventing many policy mat- deal that ensures joint local control
Previous media spending by Mr. cades, environmental activists suc- California Air Resources Board help ters from being needlessly subjected between state officials and indige-
Omidyar, his wife and their network ceeded in getting national parks keep Yosemite’s air clean. The Forest to the micromanagement and twisted nous groups.
has supported stridently far-left and federalized. Practice Act regulates logging to pre- incentives of federal politicking. For many Washington technocrats
anti-Israel outlets, including the In- That was more than 100 years vent habitat destruction, and Propo- In 2017, Mr. Trump reduced the accustomed to an antiquated govern-
tercept, which recently launched as ago—long before Washington had sition 65 protects water quality by size of the Bears Ears National Mon- ing philosophy of reflexive federal-
an independent nonprofit, and In anywhere near as much on its plate limiting toxic chemical releases. All ument in Utah. The year before, ization from the steam engine era,
These Times. The Intercept has ques- as it does today. Yet many elected of- these laws, alongside existing federal President Obama, under the Antiqui- that’s an uncomfortable conversa-
tioned the reporting of the New York ficials speak of protecting public protections, help preserve Yosemite. ties Act, had designated those 1.3 tion. When it comes to the long-term
Times on Hamas’s systematic sexual lands as though the only thing stand- Technology has revolutionized en- million acres—larger than some na- risks of power consolidation, they
assault of Israelis. It also suggested ing in the way of Yosemite turning vironmental management, allowing tional parks—a national monument. will continue to miss the forest for
that the Times is biased in favor of into an exploited quarry is its desig- local agencies to oversee natural re- Both Mr. Obama’s and Mr. Trump’s the trees.
Israel because the current Times ex- nation as federal public land. The re- sources without heavy federal in- decrees divided locals and stoked
ecutive editor’s late father was active ality is quite the opposite. volvement. Satellite monitoring and fears that sacred sites would be ex- Mr. Showah writes That Patch-
in a pro-Israel press-watchdog group. Since the National Park Service remote sensing provide real-time ploited for mining. work, a Substack newsletter.
In These Times devotes an entire
section to “Palestine” alongside “pol-
itics” and “opinion.” It cheers boy-
cotts of Israel and smears the Jewish
state’s war of self-defense as a “geno-
How MAGA Bungled the German Election
cidal onslaught.” Germany’s election Vance come in—or rather, don’t. In Messrs. Musk and Vance simply must be equally false. But this effort
The Omidyar Network’s grant to on Sunday pro- the last two months, these tri- didn’t know what they were talking to graft U.S. political and culture
the AP is ostensibly to expand cover- duced a lot of los- bunes of Donald Trump and Make about. wars onto Germany—with its own
age of artificial intelligence, but ers, and two of the America Great Again national con- For instance, there are good rea- history and present concerns—
somehow the funds paid for report- bigger ones aren’t servatism threw their weight be- sons for that firewall Mr. Vance de- proved baffling or off-putting rather
ers to scrutinize Microsoft’s and even German: Elon hind the AfD. cried. Among the AfD’s most promi- than compelling to many Germans.
Google’s use by the Israeli govern-
POLITICAL Musk and JD Mr. Musk opined that only this nent politicians is Björn Höcke, the The trouble is that more is at
ment. The AP had a hard-earned rep-
ECONOMICS Vance. They can’t party could “save” Germany, and in- party’s leader in the state of Thurin- stake than embarrassment for a cou-
utation for nonpartisanship. It’s sad say they weren’t troduced party leader Alice Weidel to gia, who’s been convicted twice of ple foolish American politicos. This
By Joseph C.
to see that reputation rented to warned. the Anglosphere via a one-hour inter- ill-fated foray into German politics
Sternberg
Omidyar and ruined for what appears To recap: Ger- view in English on his X platform. Mr. could have negative consequences
to be a quarter-million-dollar grant. man voters have Vance met Ms. Weidel during a trip to A center-right chancellor for American interests.
That sum is a small share of the swung toward the right in frustra- Munich a little more than a week be- The most serious is the possibility
AP’s total foundation action. The AP’s tion over out-of-control immigration fore the election—a much-publicized should be good news for Messrs. Musk and Vance alienated
2023 annual report boasts of “81 and economic malaise. The biggest conference—and then in a speech the GOP. Musk and Vance Mr. Merz. Europe’s largest economy
grants totaling $60.9 million.” Other winner was Friedrich Merz, leader of warned Germany against erecting po- has just elected one of the more pro-
money comes from groups with agen- the center-right Christian Democrats litical “firewalls.” shouldn’t have meddled. U.S. politicians within the country’s
das. The KR Foundation, a Denmark- Union, whose 28.6% vote share—in- Mr. Vance’s comment was a direct most pro-U.S. party. But widespread
based organization that backs “a cluding that of the CDU’s Bavarian jab at mainstream German politi- irritation at MAGA’s pro-AfD turn,
rapid phase-out of fossil fuels,” is an sister party, the Christian Social cians’ refusal to contemplate coali- using a Nazi slogan—“Alles für plus Mr. Trump’s recent erratic ap-
AP funder. So is the Hewlett Founda- Union—will make him the next chan- tions with the AfD, a stricture born Deutschland,” the motto of Hitler’s proach to the Ukraine war, seems to
tion, which was a force behind Joe cellor. The biggest losers were par- of the AfD’s refusal to purge appar- Brownshirts—in campaign rallies. have pushed a politician who once
Biden’s inflationary spending poli- ties of the center-left, the Social ent Nazi sympathizers from its lead- (Mr. Höcke, a former history teacher, led Atlantic Bridge—a political net-
cies. Hewlett has spent more than $2 Democrats (a humiliating 16.4%) and ership ranks. has appealed the convictions and working organization that’s exactly
million backing AP coverage. the Greens (11.6%). Embarrassingly for the two Amer- said he hadn’t known the phrase’s what the name implies—to now
A spokeswoman for AP told me Then there’s the far-right Alterna- icans, these interventions appear to historical associations.) Ms. Weidel speak of the need for German “inde-
that “each foundation goes through a tive for Germany, or AfD. In many have had zero effect on German vot- said during the campaign she regret- pendence” from Washington.
thorough standards review to ensure ways, this party had a very good ers. The AfD’s slight rise in opinion ted trying to expel him from the MAGA promises a realism-based
its commitment to editorial indepen- election. Its 20.8% vote share dou- polls after Mr. Musk started stomp- party in 2017, and now he may be approach to foreign policy. What
dence” and that “AP retains complete bles the tally from the 2021 election, ing around the china shop in January trying to seed his loyalists among Messrs. Musk and Vance delivered in
editorial control over its journalism.” despite (not, as some worry, because looks like a mere continuation of a the AfD’s parliamentary caucus, the Germany is almost exactly the oppo-
She said omitting Omidyar from a of) some of its leaders’ persistent gradual polling improvement that Frankfurter Allgemeine newspaper site: a headlong rush into the politics
public list of AP’s funders was an flirtations with Nazi rhetoric. had been already under way for reported this week. of a country they apparently don’t
“oversight” and will be corrected. Still, some caveats attach. The some time. And it may have been an The MAGA case for the AfD understand, in an effort to project
The Omidyar Network didn’t reply to party’s final vote count was notice- illusion, given that the party fell seemed to be that America’s main- America’s particular set of cultural
my questions. ably short of the 22% to 23% support short on election day. stream media launched a deceptive and political neuroses onto the rest
One journalistic project unlikely to it enjoyed in many opinion polls at One explanation for MAGA’s lack resistance against Mr. Trump and of the world, and with ill effects for
be funded by big foundations: ener- times in 2023 and 2024. In parlia- of influence on the election outcome therefore negative reporting else- America. Next time perhaps they’ll
getic investigative coverage of the mentary coalition building, a few may be Germans’ suspicion that where about parties of the right want to stick to “America first.”
charities themselves—their out-of- points is a big deal. The party is a
touch politicized groupthink, extrava- significant force, but it hasn’t yet
gantly compensated executives and
counterproductive spending.
Meanwhile, if Mr. Trump’s roll-
shaken off the question of whether
there’s a ceiling to its support.
The AfD’s underperformance is all
Congress Can Easily Green-Light DOGE
back of AP’s special access makes the more noticeable because fate By Jed Rubenfeld of constitutional rights.) Such claims provision would satisfy these restric-
readers more skeptical, that may be seemed to arrange current events in would be made moot if Congress gave tions because it’s directed at reduc-
T
healthy. For-profits can make the the party’s favor. Its signature issue he firestorm over President the president express power to take ing expenditures, but Senate Demo-
idealistic, evidence-based case that is hostility to migration. The last Trump’s alleged executive these actions. crats would surely object.
good journalism is good business. month of the campaign was domi- overreach—and most of the The reason Mr. Trump’s Republi- Here’s where things get interest-
Perhaps in nonprofit journalism, nated by news of two terrible crimes court cases challenging it—could be can allies in Congress haven’t already ing. In the event of an objection, the
both parties to the transaction will allegedly committed by migrants largely extinguished if a single sen- done so is the Senate filibuster. De- nonpartisan Senate parliamentarian
realize that when a news organiza- who ought to have been deported tence were added to the soon-to-be- spite taking control of the White determines whether a provision in a
tion starts selling its reputation, its months, or years, earlier. And still passed reconciliation bill: “Notwith- House, the Senate and the House, Re- reconciliation bill is “in order.” But
value diminishes. In any case, read- the AfD managed not to achieve even standing any other provision of law, publicans are still powerless to enact the parliamentarian’s determination
ers will figure it out. the 22% support many polls pre- for fiscal years 2025-26 the presi- is only advisory. The real power lies
dicted right before the election. dent is hereby authorized and di- with the Senate’s presiding officer,
Mr. Stoll writes at TheEditors.com. This is where Messrs. Musk and rected to identify and eliminate at A simple sentence in the who can ignore the parliamentarian.
least $500 billion of waste, fraud and reconciliation bill would The Senate’s presiding officer hap-
abuse in federal spending by auditing pens to be the vice president.
expenditures, discharging employees resolve legal concerns. In other words, JD Vance would
PUBLISHED SINCE 1889 BY DOW JONES & COMPANY or officers, canceling grants and re- have the ultimate authority to decide
Lachlan Murdoch ducing or eliminating agencies and if the provision on waste, fraud and
Executive Chairman, News Corp departments.” most of their legislative agenda be- abuse could stay in the reconciliation
Rupert Murdoch Robert Thomson
Chairman Emeritus, News Corp Chief Executive Officer, News Corp Most of the challenges to Mr. cause they don’t have the 60 Senate bill. The Senate can overrule the vice
Emma Tucker Almar Latour Trump’s executive orders and the ac- votes needed to overcome a filibus- president, but it would require a
Editor in Chief Chief Executive Officer and Publisher tions of the Department of Govern- ter. But the Senate can’t filibuster a three-fifths vote.
Liz Harris, Managing Editor DOW JONES MANAGEMENT: ment Efficiency don’t involve consti- reconciliation bill. Reconciliation is Majority Leader John Thune
Charles Forelle, Deputy Editor in Chief Mae M. Cheng, EVP, General Manager, tutional rights. Instead, the plaintiffs virtually the only opportunity for warned Republicans in January to re-
Elena Cherney, Senior Editor; David Crow, Leadership; David Cho, Barron’s Editor in Chief; claim that Mr. Trump is violating congressional Republicans to enact a spect the parliamentarian’s determi-
Jason P. Conti, General Counsel, Chief
Executive Editor; Chip Cummins, Newswires; statutes or exercising authority Con- law with a simple majority in the nations. The last vice president to ig-
Taneth Evans, Digital; Alex Martin, Print & Compliance Officer; Dianne DeSevo, Chief People
Officer; Jared DiPalma, Chief Financial Officer; gress hasn’t granted him. That’s the House and Senate. nore the parliamentarian was Nelson
Writing; Michael W. Miller, Features & Weekend;
Bruce Orwall, Enterprise; Philana Patterson, Artem Fishman, Chief Technology Officer; core claim behind the court cases at- The catch is that a federal statute Rockefeller in 1975. But this adminis-
Audio; Amanda Wills, Video David Martin, Chief Revenue Officer, Business tacking Mr. Trump’s firings, grant and Senate traditions limit what can tration doesn’t seem likely to feel
Intelligence; Dan Shar, EVP, General Manager,
Wealth & Investing; Ashok Sinha, Chief
freezes, dismantling of the U.S. go into a reconciliation bill. In gen- constrained by unwritten senatorial
Paul A. Gigot
Editor of the Editorial Page Communications Officer; Josh Stinchcomb, EVP & Agency for International Develop- eral, reconciliation can be used only norms that stand in the way of Con-
Gerard Baker, Editor at Large Chief Revenue Officer, WSJ | Barron’s Group; ment, decision to give Elon Musk ac- for measures directed at federal reve- gress’s majority will.
EDITORIAL AND CORPORATE HEADQUARTERS:
Sherry Weiss, Chief Marketing Officer cess to agency data and so on. (His nue and expenditures—but not those
1211 Avenue of the Americas, New York, N.Y., 10036 executive order on birthright citizen- that affect Social Security. There’s a Mr. Rubenfeld is a Yale law
Telephone 1-800-DOWJONES ship does involve an alleged violation good argument that my proposed professor.
S&P 5861.57 g 1.59%
BUSINESS & FINANCE
© 2025 Dow Jones & Company. All Rights Reserved.
S&P IT g 3.79%
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
DJ TRANS g 0.62% WSJ $ IDX À 0.67% 2–YR. TREAS. yield 4.079% NIKKEI (Midday) 37182.09 g 2.81% See more at WSJ.com/Markets
Friday, February 28, 2025 | B1
Alphabet
been working on building
practical quantum computers
for decades, the technology is
Nasdaq
the development of useful, re- quantum system,” said Oskar still at least a decade away
20
liable quantum computers. AW Painter, head of quantum from commercial use, accord- BY HEATHER GILLERS
The chip, dubbed S/R
EU hardware for AWS. “It’s ing to Painter. Other compa- AND ANGUS BERWICK
TE
Ocelot, can lower RS designed to test our 10 nies and industry experts say
the costs of reduc- ability to perform it is just a few years away. Fresh tariff threats and a
ing quantum com- quantum error cor- Amazon, Microsoft and tech selloff dragged stocks
puting errors by as rection, and once we 0 Google are all trying to solve lower, with the S&P 500 sur-
much as 90%, the Seattle- have that building block, the challenge of quantum er- rendering the last of its gains
based tech giant said. Amazon’s then we can scale it up Microsoft ror correction, though for the year.
The race to build a Ocelot chip to a much larger size.” –10 Google’s work in developing A reported uptick in jobless
practical quantum com- One of quantum com- Sept% 2024 Oct% Nov% Dec% Jan% ’25 Feb%
superconducting quantum cir- claims Thursday followed dis-
puter has been heating up puting’s biggest challenges is cuits is most similar to Ama- appointing home-sales data.
among startups and the that qubits, the basic units of Source: FactSet zon’s, according to Painter. Re- Investors, meanwhile, tried to
world’s biggest tech compa- quantum computation, gener- sults of Amazon’s work were digest the Trump administra-
nies. Amazon Web Services’ ate errors as they tackle prob- the environment like heat and Quantum computers can published in Nature, a leading tion’s plans on tariffs and fed-
announcement comes just a lems, with the errors increas- vibrations, which force them crunch numbers in a funda- scientific journal, on Wednes- eral spending cuts.
week after Microsoft claimed ing as quantum systems get out of their quantum state. mentally different way from day. The technology-heavy Nas-
a quantum-computing break- bigger. Qubits are fragile and Quantum error correction is traditional computers and can Amazon formally kicked off daq Composite fell 2.8%, or
through by creating a new susceptible to “noise,” essen- used to help fix the problems do certain computations or- its efforts to build a quantum 530.84 points, to close at
state of matter. Alphabet’s tially small disturbances in created from that noise. ders of magnitude faster. They Please turn to page B2 18544.42, while the Dow Jones
Industrial Average fell 0.5%, or
193.62 points, to 43239.5. The
Microsoft Higher Coffee Prices Are Coming, Smucker Says S&P 500 dropped 1.6%, or
94.49 points, to 5861.57, push-
ing its total return for the year
Be Eased
BY AMRITH RAMKUMAR
Meta
AND TOM DOTAN
BY PATRICK COFFEE data and privacy have become “We are committed to pro-
a common feature of the on- viding a seamless user experi-
A combination of websites line economy, where informa- ence for our fans, as well as
and apps for all 32 teams in tion that can help advertisers safeguarding their informa-
STEPHANIE SCARBROUGH/AP
the National Football League better target consumers is tion,” the NFL said in a state-
collected detailed data from prized. A patchwork of state ment that was included in the
consumers without directly laws has attempted to rein in report. The statement also
AUTOS informing them that their the use of these data, but thanked the DAAP for ac-
The holding company data could be used for tar- businesses’ self-regulation knowledging that the NFL is
geted advertising or providing programs are often the closest now compliant.
behind Italy’s Agnelli them with clear ways to opt thing to a na- The league’s NFL team websites and apps attract significant traffic.
family plans to cut its out, according to a report tional code. collection of ge-
stake in Ferrari. B3 from the Digital Advertising The report’s olocation data data, consumers have to be olocation data might then be
Accountability Program, an in- author, also The advertising made the omis- able to opt in with that clear, shared with advertisers. The
dustry watchdog. known as the alliance sion of clear meaningful and prominent app has now been updated to
Information collected by DAAP, is part disclosures and disclosure,” said Sridhar. include such language, accord-
third-party ad-tech vendors of BBB National acknowledges o p t - o u t “They have to know when ing to the report.
PATRICK T. FALLON/AFP/GETTY IMAGES
included online behavioral Programs, a prompts partic- they’re consenting, what Other teams’ apps told us-
data and geolocation data, business asso-
that the NFL is ularly signifi- they’re consenting about and ers that their data may be col-
which may be used by adver- ciation that en- now compliant. cant, because exactly what that means with lected by advertisers but
tisers or other parties to de- courages ad- location is very regard to how their data is be- didn’t explicitly seek consent.
termine the exact locations herence to self- closely tied to a ing used for interest-based ad- The apps now include such
and movements of an individ- regulatory single individ- vertising.” prompts.
ual’s phone or other mobile principles such as those of the ual, said Divya Sridhar, vice In early 2023, for example, NFL team websites and
device. DAA. president of global privacy di- the Cleveland Browns’ app apps attract a significant
The lack of clear disclo- The NFL worked with the vision and privacy initiatives called on consumers to enable amount of traffic. Approxi-
HEARD ON sures and opt-outs didn’t meet DAAP for more than a year be- operations at BBB National location services to “get ac- mately 1.2 million people vis-
THE STREET standards set by the Digital fore the report’s release to up- Programs. cess to FirstEnergy Stadium ited the San Francisco 49ers
Advertising Alliance, a data date its global privacy policy Companies should make features, receive in-stadium website across desktop and
Nvidia is far from privacy-focused nonprofit con- and ensure that all affiliated withdrawing from data collec- notifications and unlock con- mobile in January, the last
running out of sisting of various ad-industry properties comply with the tion as easy as consenting, she tent and promotions based on month that the team played a
road. B10 trade groups, the report said. program’s data-privacy princi- said. your location.” But it didn’t game, according to digital
Skirmishes over consumer ples, the report said. “Since this is sensitive warn customers that their ge- Please turn to page B4
B2 | Friday, February 28, 2025 NY * **** THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
A HKEX.................................................B9 Nelnet...............................................A3
Amazon
Advanced Micro Devices..A1
Affirm Holdings....................B10
Alphabet...............................B1,B10
HP........................................................B4
J
Nvidia..............................A1,B2,B10
P
PayPal............................................B10
Unveils
New Chip
JetBlue Airways...................B10
Amazon.com.....................B1,B10
J.M. Smucker..............................B1 Pinterest......................................B10
Apple..............................................B10
Autodesk........................................B2 JPMorgan Chase..................B10 R
C K Rolls-Royce Holdings..........B3
BUSINESS NEWS
break, as previously guided, de- –1 “We are well-placed to be- said the company’s unexpected
claring a payout of 6 pence for come a market leader in SMRs, announcement of a share buy-
2024—its first since January where we see a significant back has lighted a fire under
2020 when the Covid-19 pan- –2 value creation opportunity,” the the shares.
demic forced it to implement 2018 ’20 ’24 company said. “The burning platform has
measures to preserve cash. Note: £1=$1.27 Rolls-Royce expects to de- long been extinguished, propel-
Since taking charge two Sources: the company Rolls-Royce resumed paying dividends after a five-year break.. liver 2025 underlying operating ling Rolls-Royce to a group
years ago, Chief Executive Tu- profit—a key metric for the which is now firing on all cylin-
fan Erginbilgic has worked to commercial flights since the significantly improved perfor- ings that significantly beat ex- group that strips out excep- ders.”
tighten focus, prioritize core end of the pandemic. mance, despite a supply chain pectations. tional items—of between £2.7 The company said underly-
activities and drive efficiencies. “Strong 2024 results build environment that remains chal- The civil aerospace business billion and £2.9 billion. That ing operating profit in 2024
After initially calling the com- on our progress last year, as we lenging.” was the key driver: Engine de- would see the company beat its was £2.46 billion, up from £1.59
pany “a burning platform,” he transform Rolls-Royce into a Rolls-Royce—which sells and liveries increased 16% while previous midterm target two billion and ahead of the com-
has overseen an increase of high-performing, competitive, maintains civil aircraft engines, revenue from its engine servic- years earlier than planned. pany’s guided range of between
more than sevenfold in the resilient, and growing busi- produces engines for military ing business increased 28% due In new midterm targets, the £2.1 billion and £2.3 billion.
share price. ness,” Erginbilgic said in a aircraft and vessels and powers to continued growth in air company now expects £3.6 bil- Revenue on an underlying basis
The engine maker also has statement. the U.K.’s nuclear submarine travel and as tight aircraft ca- lion to £3.9 billion of underlying rose to £17.85 billion from £15.41
benefited from a rebound in “All core divisions delivered fleet—reported full-year earn- pacity means engines are flying operating profit with an oper- billion.
WASH WEEKLYTODAY L I V E O N T H E N B C FA M I LY O F N E T W O R K S
IS A GREAT DAY FOR A CAR WASH ! SEBRING INTERNATIONAL SPEEDWAY | MARCH 12-15
®
!"#$%"& '
LEVEL UP YOUR
PROTECTION GAME
Graphene-Infused
Carbonite
Surface Hardener
™
BUYING A NEW OR
PRE-OWNED VEHICLE?
PROTECT IT WITH...
FLOORLINER™ HP
Lifetime Paint Protection! Unlock next-generation defense with tailor-made FloorLiner HP.
This hefty mat is built to stay in place, preventing grit
and stains from damaging your interior.
DEMAND
(
Auto. Home. Pet. Find Your Fit. 1-800-441-6287
MICHAEL FISHER
HOLLY JOHNSON
of the news media world. with Google have long been The site is now publishing
Sites including CNN Under- fraught with challenges. They pieces from one full-time
scored and Forbes Vetted offer scramble when Google tweaks writer and considering hiring
tips on everything from mat- its algorithms, updating web- Freelance writers such as Holly Johnson and Christian de Looper are struggling to adapt. more full-time staff, this per-
tresses and knife sets to sav- site designs or crafting head- son said.
ings accounts, making money lines to notch higher in search By its definition, separate enti- on Google’s search engine. why who wrote it, in terms of CNN Underscored, which
when users click on links and rankings. The latest changes ties can include freelancers They determined that Google their employment status, has worked with Marketplace for a
buy products. are among the most dramatic, and content from services and had flagged the site for run- anything to do with it,” he portion of its content, found
They depend on Google to say executives. people not employed directly ning afoul of its guidelines, but added. De Looper, who is 31 many of its articles were also
drive much of their traffic, and “Google is gatekeeping the by the host site. weren’t sure which specific years old, said he lost upward delisted from Google late last
therefore revenue. But over revenue models publishers use Google says that affiliate rules they violated, according of 25% of his income as work year. The company ended the
the past year, Google created to stay in business,” Jeff Li, a content and freelancers aren’t, to people close to Forbes. with affiliate sites disap- relationship with Marketplace,
stricter rules that dinged cer- general manager for digital at on their own, violations of its The Forbes leaders had a peared. removed freelancer-written
tain sites that farm out arti- Time who recently left the policy, and that it is targeting hunch the foul was related to Since eliminating freelancer posts from Google search and
cles to freelancers, among company, said in a November content explicitly designed to its use of freelancers. In De- contributions, Forbes Vetted stopped its work with many
other things. LinkedIn post. get clicks by piggybacking on cember, Forbes Vetted told content began appearing back freelancers.
The goal, Google has said, Google launched its “site publishers’ brands. freelancers it was cutting ties. in Google’s search engine. “Most of the publications
was to give users higher-qual- reputation abuse” policy early A Google spokesman said Christian de Looper, who “Forbes continues to part- just said this business model is
ity search results. The out- last year and updated its lan- that sort of abuse “leads to a has been writing about con- ner closely with Google to en- not viable now,” said Holly
come was a crisis for some guage in November to specify bad search experience for peo- sumer technology for more sure we’re better serving our Johnson, who has been writing
sites. Traffic for Forbes Advi- that its spam policy prohibits ple and an uneven playing than a decade, was one such audiences,” a Forbes spokes- about personal finance for 15
sor, a personal-finance recom- certain content “created by a field for content creators.” freelancer. He said he under- woman said. years, including for CNN Un-
mendation site, fell 83% in separate entity” from appear- About a week before Black stands that Google is trying to The Google spokesman said derscored. “If you don’t show
January from the same month ing in its search pages, even Friday, leaders at Forbes Vet- ensure users see high-quality the company has a careful re- up in Google search, you might
the year before, according to with a publisher’s oversight. ted couldn’t find their content content. “But I don’t really see view and appeals process for as well not exist.”
MARIO ANZUONI/REUTERS
9,000
2025, which and other
ends in Octo- charges are ex-
ber. It expects pected to be
to incur about around $1.2 bil-
Jeff Bezos is taking more sian cosmonaut’s solo space- $150 million in Total number of lion.
celebrities—as well as his flight in the early 1960s. additional re- The details
partner—to the great beyond. Blue Origin has been flying structuring and
layoffs as a result of of the layoffs
Bezos’ Blue Origin said its people on short trips to other charges restructuring at HP came shortly
next space-tourism trip will space since 2021, when Bezos in connection Inc. after HP re-
include pop star Katy Perry, and three others flew on its with the cuts, ported higher
above right, and Gayle King, New Shepard vehicle. The primarily due revenue for its
the broadcast journalist, trips to space with New to cash labor fiscal first
right. Also joining the crew: Shepard send passengers on costs. quarter, boosted by what Chief
Lauren Sánchez, Bezos’ part- board more than 62 miles The layoffs will vary by Executive Enrique Lores said
ner, above. Sánchez put the above Earth in a capsule, country, based on local legal was strong demand for its
group together for the mis- where they experience a few requirements and consulta- new technologies, which is
sion, according to Blue Origin. minutes of floating and take tions with employee works sparking an upgrade cycle for
Former NASA scientist Aisha in views of the planet. councils and other employee personal computers.
Bowe, Kerianne Flynn, who The company has taken representatives, HP said. The The Palo Alto, Calif., com-
JAMIE MCCARTHY/GETTY IMAGES
worked in fashion, and re- other high-profile people on company employed approxi- pany posted a profit of $565
search scientist Amanda the trips, including Star Trek mately 58,000 workers across million, or 59 cents a share,
Nguyen will be on the flight. actor William Shatner. 59 countries, according to its for its three-months ended
Bezos’ company described Blue Origin on Tuesday said most recent annual filing with Jan. 31, compared with $622
the all-female crew as the it completed its 10th human the Securities and Exchange million, or 62 cents a share, a
first in decades, saying there mission with New Shepard. Commission. year earlier. Revenue in-
hadn’t been one since a Rus- —Micah Maidenberg Dubbed “Future Now” and creased 2.4% to $13.5 billion.
NFL Took cording to Heidi Saas, an at- weaker than the 0.2% decline
“Secured Party” for all purposes hereunder.
The sale of the Collateral will be subject to all applicable third-party consents and regulatory and other governmental
approvals, if any, as well as the terms of sale prepared by Secured Party. Without limitation to the foregoing, please torney specializing in data that consensus estimates com-
take notice that there are specific requirements for any prospective bidder in connection with bidding on the Collateral.
privacy and related technolo- piled by Vuma pointed to. –3
The Collateral is being offered as a single lot, “as-is, where-is”, with no express or implied warranties, representations,
User Data gies who reviewed the report. Like-for-like revenue less pass-
statements or conditions of any kind made by Secured Party or any person acting for or on behalf of Secured Party, 2015 ’20 ’24
without any recourse whatsoever to Secured Party, Secured Party’s affiliates, direct and indirect holders of equity in
Secured Party, directors, officers, agents, or employees of Secured Party or its affiliates or equity holders, or any other It is also unclear whether through costs, a closely Note: £1 = $1.27 Source: S&P Capital IQ
person acting for or on behalf of Secured Party of Secured Party or its affiliates or equity holders. Each bidder must
make its own inquiry regarding the Collateral. The winning bidder shall be responsible for the payment of all transfer ad-tech vendors will delete watched measure of top-line
Improperly
taxes, stamp duties, and similar taxes incurred in connection with the purchase of the Collateral.
Secured Party reserves the right to (i) credit bid, (ii) reject any bid if Secured Party determines, in its sole and absolute any data they have already performance, strips out ex- cline. Analysts had forecast a
discretion, that such bid was made by a participant that is not a Qualified Bidder (as defined in the Terms of Sale), (iii)
accept a lower bid if the bid is on terms that Secured Party determines is more favorable to Secured Party or is from
collected from consumers who penses billed to clients, cur- 1.8% rise, according to the
a bidder that, in Secured Party’s determination, offers a more certain likelihood of execution, (iv) adjourn the sale to now decide to opt out, Saas rency movements and the ef- same consensus.
another date and time, and (v) impose any other commercially reasonable conditions upon the sale of the Collateral
as Secured Party may deem proper. said. fects of acquisitions and Analysts attribute WPP’s
Each prospective bidder (other than Secured Party or its affiliates) will further be required to represent in writing to
Secured Party, among other things, that such bidder (a) is acquiring the Collateral for investment purposes, solely Continued from page B1 The NFL, speaking for itself business sales. underperformance relative to
for the purchaser’s own account and not with a view to distribution or resale of the Collateral; (b) is an accredited
investor within the meaning of the applicable securities laws; (c) has sufficient knowledge and experience in financial
market intelligence firm Simi- as well as its individual teams, Weakness in project-based some peers to its greater reli-
and business matters so as to be capable of evaluating the merits and risks of investment and has sufficient financial larweb. declined to comment beyond work made last year and last ance on tech and China. WPP
means to afford the risk of investment in the Collateral; (d) will not resell or otherwise hypothecate the Collateral
without a valid registration under applicable federal or state laws, including, without limitation, the Securities The team’s iOS and Android its statement in the report. quarter tougher, but the com- said revenue from tech compa-
Act of 1933, as amended (the “Securities Act”), or an available exemption therefrom; provided that Secured Party
reserves the right to verify that each certificate for the limited liability company interests to be sold bears a legend apps also had 3,200 daily ac- Despite more state-level pany’s performance should nies stabilized in the second
substantially to the effect that such interests have not been registered under the Securities Act and to impose such
other limitations or conditions in connection with the sale of the Collateral as Secured Party deems necessary or
tive users last month, Similar- lawsuits and fines stemming pick up over the course of this half, with growth in North
advisable in order to comply with the Securities Act or any other applicable law; (e) is not an Embargoed Person (as web said. from data-privacy violations, year, WPP Chief Executive America in the final quarter
defined in the Terms of Sale); (f) is not capitalized with a Crowd Funding Structure; and (g) will purchase the Collateral
in compliance with all applicable federal and state laws. Meeting any requirements of the foregoing shall be at the The report leaves several the primary risk for large and Mark Read said. after a period in which clients
sole responsibility, risk, cost, and expense of a prospective bidder.
All bids (other than credit bids of Secured Party) must be for cash with no financing or other conditions, and the
questions unanswered, such influential organizations such Its shares fell 16% in London, sought to rein in spending.
successful bidder must be prepared to deliver immediately available good funds as required by the Terms of Sale and as for how long the NFL teams as the NFL still concerns dam- to levels last seen in late 2020. “Having had a challenging
otherwise comply with the bidding requirements and the Terms of Sale. The selected bidder must (i) deposit with a
title company or other agent designated by Secured Party 10% of the selected bidder’s final bid within twenty-four collected the consumer data, age to brand perception and For 2025, the owner of 18 months, I think that is posi-
(24) hours of completion of the auction, (ii) pay the full amount of its bid as the purchase price for the Collateral, after
deduction of the selected bidder’s deposits, by wire transfer of immediately available federal funds, no later than 2:00 how much data the teams ac- reputation, according to agencies including GroupM, tive,” Read said.
p.m. prevailing Eastern Time on April 14, 2025, as set forth in, and subject to the terms of, the Terms of Sale, and (iii)
otherwise comply with the bidding requirements and the Terms of Sale.
cumulated in total and how Brandi M. Bennett, a data pri- VML and Ogilvy expects like- But China continued to
Further information concerning the Collateral, the requirements for obtaining information and bidding on the interests widely it was shared across vacy and security attorney for-like revenue less pass- weigh on results, with quar-
and the Terms of Sale can be obtained by contacting Sarah Lagosh, Managing Director, Eastdil Secured, L.L.C., by
telephone at (617) 784-3978 or by email at [email protected]. the NFL’s network of teams whose past clients have in- through costs to range from a terly like-for-like revenue less
and third-party vendors, ac- cluded NFL franchises. flat performance to a 2% de- pass-through costs down 21%.
B6 | Friday, February 28, 2025 * ** THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
MARKETS DIGEST
EQUITIES
Dow Jones Industrial Average S&P 500 Index Nasdaq Composite Index
Last Year ago Last Year ago Last Year ago
43239.50 t 193.62, or 0.45% Trailing P/E ratio 25.91 27.13 5861.57 t 94.49, or 1.59% Trailing P/E ratio * 25.82 22.85 18544.42 t 530.84, or 2.78% Trailing P/E ratio *† 34.12 34.12
High, low, open and close for each P/E estimate * 20.42 18.62 High, low, open and close for each P/E estimate * 22.57 21.25 High, low, open and close for each P/E estimate *† 28.05 30.65
trading day of the past three months. Dividend yield 1.87 1.83 trading day of the past three months. Dividend yield * 1.25 1.49 trading day of the past three months. Dividend yield *† 0.71 0.81
All-time high 45014.04, 12/04/24 All-time high 6144.15, 02/19/25 All-time high: 20173.89, 12/16/24
COMMODITIES wsj.com/market-data/commodities
Metal & Petroleum Futures Soybean Meal (CBT)-100 tons; $ per ton. Treasury Bonds (CBT)-$100,000; pts 32nds of 100% Mexican Peso (CME)-MXN 500,000; $ per MXN
March 293.20 295.60 290.70 290.90 –2.50 12,497 March 118-070 118-100 117-140 117-230 –18.0 330,672 March .04884 .04902 .04855 .04873 –.00008 148,299
Contract Open June 117-300 117-300 117-060 117-160 –18.0 1,694,389
May 302.50 305.00 299.60 300.20 –2.30 249,970 June .04821 .04841 .04797 .04813 –.00008 1,292
Open High hi lo Low Settle Chg interest Treasury Notes (CBT)-$100,000; pts 32nds of 100%
Soybean Oil (CBT)-60,000 lbs.; cents per lb. Euro (CME)-€125,000; $ per €
Copper-High (CMX)-25,000 lbs.; $ per lb. March 44.95 45.65 44.58 44.75 –.22 8,343 March 110-245 110-275 110-135 110-195 –7.5 200,869
March 1.0495 1.0505 1.0405 1.0413 –.0089 616,551
March 4.5375 4.6230 4.5040 4.5800 0.0400 9,099 May 45.59 46.23 45.20 45.35 –.24 241,045 June 110-255 110-265 110-140 110-205 –8.0 4,750,947
5 Yr. Treasury Notes (CBT)-$100,000; pts 32nds of 100% June 1.0552 1.0552 1.0458 1.0466 –.0088 34,615
May 4.5835 4.6685 4.5490 4.6185 0.0320 122,084 Rough Rice (CBT)-2,000 cwt.; $ per cwt.
Gold (CMX)-100 troy oz.; $ per troy oz. March 13.31 13.31 t 13.19 13.28 .06 1,408
March 107-155 107-170 107-087 107-135 –3.2 382,518
March 2918.50 2922.80 2870.40 2883.20 –34.60 12,069 June 107-210 107-230 107-137 107-192 –3.2 5,942,119 Index Futures
May 13.61 13.65 13.53 13.62 .04 10,174
April 2931.40 2935.80 2879.00 2895.90 –34.70 370,604 2 Yr. Treasury Notes (CBT)-$200,000; pts 32nds of 100%
Wheat (CBT)-5,000 bu.; cents per bu. March 103-029 103-037 103-002 103-020 –1.0 184,392 Mini DJ Industrial Average (CBT)-$5 x index
May 2937.30 2942.40 s 2893.90 2909.70 –35.20 185 March 566.00 566.50 544.00 546.75 –19.25 6,999
June 2959.70 2963.20 2907.00 2923.90 –35.00 83,985 June 103-107 103-122 103-079 103-102 –.8 3,792,749 March 43484 43949 43277 43297 –209 76,084
May 579.25 580.25 560.00 562.50 –17.25 217,657 30 Day Federal Funds (CBT)-$5,000,000; 100 - daily avg.
July 2959.00 2959.00 s 2921.00 2936.60 –35.10 22 June 43828 44317 43649 43667 –209 1,858
Wheat (KC)-5,000 bu.; cents per bu. Feb 95.6700 95.6725 t 95.6700 95.6700 505,965
Aug 2986.10 2987.40 2932.70 2949.60 –35.10 24,837
March 582.50 590.50 566.25 571.25 –13.75 4,402
Mini S&P 500 (CME)-$50 x index
May 95.7300 95.7350 95.7200 95.7300 364,508
Palladium (NYM) - 50 troy oz.; $ per troy oz. March 5980.00 6014.50 5873.00 5876.25 –94.50 2,079,208
March 923.50 925.00 t 899.00 901.30 –21.60 467
May 598.00 599.50 579.50 585.25 –13.25 118,942 Three-Month SOFR (CME)-$1,000,000; 100 - daily avg.
Cattle-Feeder (CME)-50,000 lbs.; cents per lb. Dec 95.6350 95.6375 t 95.6350 95.6350 –.0025 1,032,162
June 6040.75 6071.00 5929.00 5932.00 –95.25 36,433
June 927.50 931.00 t 910.00 915.30 –13.60 18,320
March 274.650 277.250 274.350 276.450 2.075 16,131 March'25 95.7000 95.7025 95.6925 95.6975 –.0050 1,278,706 Mini S&P Midcap 400 (CME)-$100 x index
Platinum (NYM)-50 troy oz.; $ per troy oz. April 273.575 276.200 273.500 275.550 2.025 25,843 March 3114.20 t 3066.10 3068.40
3132.00 –39.40 41,824
March 962.70 962.70 953.60 951.90 –18.60 388
Cattle-Live (CME)-40,000 lbs.; cents per lb. Currency Futures June 3128.00 t 3097.30 3093.00
3149.70 –37.90 1
April 975.60 982.70 951.80 957.70 –18.90 71,491
Feb 198.825 199.725 198.825 199.400 .575 753 Mini Nasdaq 100 (CME)-$20 x index
Silver (CMX)-5,000 troy oz.; $ per troy oz. April 194.750 196.400 194.450 196.125 1.500 149,142
Japanese Yen (CME)-¥12,500,000; $ per 100¥ March 21249.00 21386.50 t 20583.25 20605.75 –581.25 279,875
March 32.235 32.290 31.470 31.801 –0.471 21,874 March .6726 .6735 .6671 .6685 –.0049 291,178
Hogs-Lean (CME)-40,000 lbs.; cents per lb. June 21506.25 21618.25 t 20810.25 20833.50 –584.25 4,931
May 32.535 32.595 31.765 32.110 –0.465 113,624 June .6800 .6804 .6741 .6754 –.0050 34,967
Crude Oil, Light Sweet (NYM)-1,000 bbls.; $ per bbl.
April 87.200 87.275
t 84.300 84.375 –3.925 107,481
Canadian Dollar (CME)-CAD 100,000; $ per CAD Mini Russell 2000 (CME)-$50 x index
June 100.000 100.175
t 97.425 97.600 –3.275 60,352 March 2183.10 2200.60 t 2143.30 2144.50 –33.70 421,762
April 68.82 70.54 68.61 70.35 1.73 305,639 March .6978 .6988 .6926 .6930 –.0053 306,310
May 68.49 70.13 68.32 69.95 1.65 182,420
Lumber (CME)-27,500 bd. ft., $ per 1,000 bd. ft. June .7010 .7016 .6956 .6960 –.0052 9,409 June 2205.10 2218.80 t 2162.30 2163.60 –33.90 3,915
March 627.50 634.50 616.00 630.50 5.00 2,104 British Pound (CME)-£62,500; $ per £ Sept 2202.00 2223.70 t 2202.00 2182.70 –34.70 12
June 68.13 69.69 67.99 69.50 1.55 190,184
May 656.50 667.00 651.50 662.00 5.50 3,386 March 1.2608 –.0076 193,146
Sept 66.92 68.20 66.72 67.99 1.29 103,440 1.2675 1.2689 1.2597 Mini Russell 1000 (CME)-$50 x index
Dec 65.83 66.96 65.70 66.71 1.10 185,913
Milk (CME)-200,000 lbs., cents per lb. June 1.2651 1.2686 1.2597 1.2606 –.0077 8,234 March 3227.00 3284.50 3214.90 3215.40 –50.60 6,127
June'26 64.74 65.62 64.57 65.33 0.87 97,515
Feb 20.22 20.22 20.20 20.21 .01 3,668 Swiss Franc (CME)-CHF 125,000; $ per CHF U.S. Dollar Index (ICE-US)-$1,000 x index
March 19.00 19.12 18.82 19.00 .18 5,098 March 1.1202 1.1207 1.1124 1.1136 –.0077 96,028
NY Harbor ULSD (NYM)-42,000 gal.; $ per gal. March 106.51 107.24 106.35 107.18 .85 36,590
March 2.3480 2.3981 2.3392 2.3959 .0516 12,318
Cocoa (ICE-US)-10 metric tons; $ per ton. June 1.1323 1.1331 1.1245 1.1255 –.0077 410
March 8,863 8,863 8,836 9,130 30 444 Australian Dollar (CME)-AUD 100,000; $ per AUD June 106.10 106.85 106.10 106.79 .84 1,419
April 2.2962 2.3496 2.2875 2.3481 .0561 101,429
May 9,216 9,338 8,907 9,255 25 48,866 March .6309 .6315 .6233 .6244 –.0065 181,330
Gasoline-NY RBOB (NYM)-42,000 gal.; $ per gal.
March 1.9464 2.0020 1.9394 1.9966 .0477 12,948
Coffee (ICE-US)-37,500 lbs.; cents per lb. June .6313 .6319 .6238 .6249 –.0065 2,746 Source: FactSet
April 2.1949 2.2448 2.1896 2.2418 .0496 120,000 March 378.00 378.00 377.80 378.75 –.70 323
Natural Gas (NYM)-10,000 MMBtu.; $ per MMBtu. May 371.60 382.65 369.05 373.60 –1.60 81,284
April
May
3.966
4.030
4.065
4.118
3.878
3.944
3.934 –.025
3.984 –.035
220,352
218,392
Sugar-World (ICE-US)-112,000 lbs.; cents per lb.
March 20.75 20.85 19.61 19.69 –.95 48,483
Bonds | wsj.com/market-data/bonds/benchmarks
July 4.333 4.410 4.259 4.293 –.035 101,329 May 19.60 19.71 18.78 18.89 –.70 369,696
Sugar-Domestic (ICE-US)-112,000 lbs.; cents per lb.
Sept
Oct
4.359
4.393
4.429
4.465
4.286
4.323
4.313 –.039
4.349 –.038
102,585
128,030 May 36.99 36.99 36.99 36.99 –1.01 1,063 Tracking Bond Benchmarks
Jan'26 5.132 5.201 5.078 5.096 –.035 124,038 Sept 37.39 37.39 37.39 37.39 –.66 1,829
Cotton (ICE-US)-50,000 lbs.; cents per lb. Return on investment and spreads over Treasurys and/or yields paid to investors compared with 52-week
March 65.20 65.20 65.20 65.20 –.17 193 highs and lows for different types of bonds
Agriculture Futures May 66.90 67.35 66.55 66.60 –.27 148,375 Total Total
Corn (CBT)-5,000 bu.; cents per bu. Orange Juice (ICE-US)-15,000 lbs.; cents per lb. return YTD total Yield (%) return YTD total Yield (%)
March 478.25 481.25 463.75 464.75 –13.50 46,457 March 299.55 299.55 t 284.95 293.30 –3.55 267 close return (%) Index Latest Low High close return (%) Index Latest Low High
May 493.50 496.25 480.00 481.00 –12.50 823,658 May 301.25 302.35 t 286.90 294.80 –4.85 7,896 Mortgage-Backed Bloomberg Fixed Income Indices
Oats (CBT)-5,000 bu.; cents per bu. Broad Market Bloomberg Fixed Income Indices
March 362.00 363.75 354.50 360.25 –2.00 64 Interest Rate Futures 2140.16 2.3 U.S. Aggregate 4.640 4.100 5.310 2120.09 2.6 Mortgage-Backed 4.920 4.340 5.570
May 370.50 374.50 364.25 372.75 .25 3,152
Soybeans (CBT)-5,000 bu.; cents per bu. Ultra Treasury Bonds (CBT) - $100,000; pts 32nds of 100% U.S. Corporate Indexes Bloomberg Fixed Income Indices 2088.18 2.6 Ginnie Mae (GNMA) 4.920 4.460 5.580
March 1024.00 1034.00 1021.00 1022.75 –1.75 25,092 March 124-120 124-150 123-090 123-170 –31.0 54,987 1250.27 2.6 Fannie mae (FNMA) 4.920 4.310 5.580
3264.97 2.3 U.S. Corporate 5.120 4.640 5.750
May 1041.25 1051.25 1035.00 1037.25 –4.00 373,502 June 124-090 124-100 123-050 123-130 –31.0 1,735,746
3181.33 1.8 Intermediate 4.880 4.400 5.670 1927.91 2.7 Freddie Mac (FHLMC) 4.790 4.150 5.510
4274.88 3.3 Long term 5.610 5.070 6.010 601.59 1.2 Muni Master 3.309 3.074 3.760
Cash Prices | wsj.com/market-data/commodities Thursday, February 27, 2025 618.82 2.3 Double-A-rated 4.810 4.260 5.330 425.20 1.6 7-12 year 3.063 2.837 3.557
These prices reflect buying and selling of a variety of actual or “physical” commodities in the marketplace—separate 890.29 2.3 Triple-B-rated 5.300 4.850 5.950 487.12 1.3 12-22 year 3.721 3.469 4.032
from the futures price on an exchange, which reflects what the commodity might be worth in future months. High Yield Bonds ICE BofA 462.35 0.8 22-plus year 4.284 3.959 4.533
Thursday Thursday Thursday
580.44 2.0 High Yield Constrained 7.087 6.975 8.322 Global Government J.P. Morgan†
Copper,Comex spot 4.5800 Wheat,No.2 soft red,St.Louis-u 5.5263
Energy Iron Ore, 62% Fe CFR China-s *106.9 Wheat - Hard - KC (USDA) $ per bu-u 5.9125 601.16 1.9 Triple-C-rated 11.122 11.050 13.872 550.51 1.1 Global Government 3.480 3.010 3.740
Coal,C.Aplc.,12500Btu,1.2SO2-r,w 76.000 Steel, HRC USA, FOB Midwest Mill-s *870.0 Wheat,No.1soft white,Portld,OR-u 6.0750
3871.59 2.2 High Yield 100 6.404 6.208 7.871 843.42 1.8 Canada 2.960 2.910 3.870
Coal,PwdrRvrBsn,8800Btu,0.8SO2-r,w 14.200 Battery/EV metals Food
Metals BMI Lithium Carbonate, EXW China, =99.5%-v,w 10525 506.95 2.0 Global High Yield Constrained 6.824 6.808 8.112 364.24 0.4 EMU§ 3.004 2.726 3.365
BMI Lithium Hydroxide, EXW China, =56.5% -v,w 9625 Beef,carcass equiv. index
Gold, per troy oz BMI Cobalt sulphate, EXW China, >20.5% -v,w 3588 choice 1-3,600-900 lbs.-u 299.26 381.94 1.6 Europe High Yield Constrained 5.219 5.219 6.710 660.77 0.8 France 3.150 2.870 3.460
Engelhard industrial 2873.00 BMI Nickel Sulphate, EXW China, >22%-v,k 3538 select 1-3,600-900 lbs.-u 287.23 U.S Agency Bloomberg Fixed Income Indices 470.16 -0.002 Germany 2.440 2.080 2.770
Handy & Harman base 2880.80 BMIFlakeGraphite,FOBChina,-100Mesh,94-95%-v,m 435 Broilers, National comp wtd. avg.-u,w 1.2555
Handy & Harman fabricated 3197.69 Butter,AA Chicago-d 2.3450 1870.73 1.6 U.S Agency 4.400 3.960 5.190 266.05 -1.5 Japan 1.730 1.100 1.750
LBMA Gold Price AM *2913.55
Fibers and Textiles Cheddar cheese,bbl,Chicago-d 180.50
187.00
1656.80 1.4 10-20 years 4.350 3.920 5.190 513.51 0.01 Netherlands 2.640 2.290 2.980
LBMA Gold Price PM *2901.00 Burlap,10-oz,40-inch NY yd-n,w 0.8700 Cheddar cheese,blk,Chicago-d
Krugerrand,wholesale-e 2994.65 Cotton,1 1/16 std lw-mdMphs-u 0.6460 Milk,Nonfat dry,Chicago lb.-d 120.00 3552.61 3.9 20-plus years 4.840 4.240 5.300 791.49 1.2 U.K. 4.730 4.030 5.070
Maple Leaf-e 3023.44 Cotlook 'A' Index-t *78.00 Coffee,Brazilian,Comp-y 3.8056
American Eagle-e 3023.44 Hides,hvy native steers piece fob-u n.a. Coffee,Colombian, NY-y 3.9205 2861.18 2.2 Yankee 4.900 4.380 5.580 921.85 2.7 Emerging Markets ** 7.324 7.084 8.073
Mexican peso-e 3479.78 Wool,64s,staple,Terr del-u,w n.a. Eggs,large white,Chicago-u,w 8.2950 *Constrained indexes limit individual issuer concentrations to 2%; the High Yield 100 are the 100 largest bonds † In local currency § Euro-zone bonds
Austria crown-e 2825.46 Flour,hard winter KC-p 15.95
Austria phil-e 3023.44 Grains and Feeds Hams,17-20 lbs,Mid-US fob-u n.a.
** EMBI Global Index Sources: ICE Data Services; Bloomberg Fixed Income Indices; J.P.Morgan
Silver, troy oz. Bran,wheat middlings, KC-u,w 100 Hogs,Iowa-So. Minnesota-u 87.10
Engelhard industrial
Handy & Harman base
31.5000
31.4350
Corn,No. 2 yellow,Cent IL-bp,u
Corn gluten feed,Midwest-u,w
4.3700
126.2
Pork bellies,12-14 lb MidUS-u
Pork loins,13-19 lb MidUS-u
1.6881
1.0138 Global Government Bonds: Mapping Yields
Handy & Harman fabricated 39.2940 Corn gluten meal,Midwest-u,w 439.1 Steers,Tex.-Okla. Choice-u 197.00
LBMA spot price *£25.0700 Steers,feeder,Okla. City-u,w 333.13
Yields and spreads over or under U.S. Treasurys on benchmark two-year and 10-year government bonds in
Cottonseed meal-u,w n.a.
(U.S.$ equivalent) *31.7150 Hominy feed,Cent IL-u,w 116 Fats and Oils selected other countries; arrows indicate whether the yield rose(s) or fell (t) in the latest session
Coins,wholesale $1,000 face-a 24004 Meat-bonemeal,50% pro Mnpls-u,w 275
Country/ Yield (%) Spread Under/Over U.S. Treasurys, in basis points
Other metals Oats,No.2 milling,Mnpls-u 4.1025 Degummed corn oil, crude wtd. avg.-u,w n.a. Coupon (%) Maturity, in years Latest(l) 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 Previous Month ago Year ago Latest Prev Year ago
LBMA Platinum Price PM *971.0 Rice, Long Grain Milled, No. 2 AR-u,w 35.25 Grease,choice white,Chicago-h 0.5100
LBMA Palladium Price PM *929.0 Sorghum,(Milo) No.2 Gulf-u n.a. Lard,Chicago-u n.a. 4.125 U.S. 2 4.079 s l 4.071 4.193 4.712
Platinum,Engelhard industrial 962.0 SoybeanMeal,Cent IL,rail,ton48%-u,w 301.80 Soybean oil,crude;Centl IL-u,w 0.4556 4.625 10 4.284 s l 4.248 4.529 4.314
Palladium,Engelhard industrial 930.0 Soybeans,No.1 yllw IL-bp,u 9.8800 Tallow,bleach;Chicago-h 0.5400 4.750 Australia 2 3.790 t 3.801 3.920 3.828 -28.1 -85.9
l -29.6
Aluminum, LME, $ per metric ton *2670.5 Wheat,Spring14%-pro Mnpls-u 7.8475 Tallow,edible,Chicago-u n.a.
3.500 10 4.349 t l 4.373 4.489 4.143 6.2 11.0 -15.8
KEY TO CODES: A=ask; B=bid; BP=country elevator bids to producers; C=corrected; D=CME; E=Manfra,Tordella & Brookes; H=American Commodities Brokerage Co; 2.500 France 2 2.161 t l 2.183 2.414 2.936 -192.5 -189.9 -175.1
K=bi-weekly; M=monthly; N=nominal; n.a.=not quoted or not available; P=Sosland Publishing; R=SNL Energy; S=Platts-TSI; T=Cotlook Limited; U=USDA; V=Benchmark
Mineral Intelligence; W=weekly; Y=International Coffee Organization; Z=not quoted. *Data as of 2/26 3.000 10 3.107 t l 3.120 3.277 2.940 -118.0 -114.3 -136.1
Source: Dow Jones Market Data 2.200 Germany 2 2.045 t 2.074 2.245 2.954 -200.8 -173.3
l -204.1
2.500 10 2.420 t l 2.436 2.535 2.467 -186.7 -182.7 -183.4
Exchange-Traded Portfolios | wsj.com/market-data/mutualfunds-etfs 2.950 Italy 2 2.319 t l 2.356 2.577 3.436 -176.7 -172.6 -125.1
3.650 10 3.546 t l 3.548 3.631 3.906 -74.1 -71.5 -39.5
Closing Chg YTD
Largest 100 exchange-traded funds. Preliminary close data as of 4:30 p.m. ET ETF Symbol Price (%) (%) 0.700 Japan 2 0.818 s l 0.791 0.697 0.169 -326.8 -329.1 -451.9
Thursday, February 27, 2025 Closing Chg YTD SchwabUS LC Grw SCHG 26.81 –2.51 –3.8 1.200 10 1.396 s l 1.367 1.220 0.695 -289.1 -289.6 -360.6
ETF Symbol Price (%) (%) SPDR S&PMdCpTr MDY 559.66 –1.27 –1.7
Closing Chg YTD 2.500 Spain 2 2.241 t l 2.268 2.502 3.103 -184.5 -181.4 -158.4
ETF Symbol Price (%) (%) SPDR S&P Div SDY 136.47 –0.21 3.3
iShNatlMuniBd MUB 107.41 –0.18 0.8
CommSvsSPDR XLC 100.53 –0.97 3.8 iSh1-5YIGCpBd IGSB 52.24 ... 1.0
TechSelectSector XLK 222.59 –3.64 –4.3 3.450 10 3.055 s l 3.052 3.168 3.343 -123.2 -121.1 -95.9
VanEckSemicon SMH 228.79 –6.16 –5.5
XLY iSh1-3YTreaBd SHY 82.47 0.04 0.6 4.125 U.K. 2 4.174 t 4.184 4.291 4.647 10.2 -4.0
CnsmrDiscSel 212.43 –1.44 –5.3
VangdSC Val VBR 195.87 –1.05 –1.2 l 8.8
DimenUSCoreEq2 DFAC 34.51 –1.37 –0.2 iShRussMC IWR 88.42 –1.11 0.0
VangdExtMkt VXF 185.38 –1.50 –2.4 4.250 10 4.514 s l 4.506 4.591 4.132 22.7 24.3 -16.9
EnSelSectorSPDR XLE 89.61 0.54 4.6 iShRuss1000 IWB 321.39 –1.53 –0.2
VangdSC Grwth VBK 270.48 –1.96 –3.4
FidWiseBTC FBTC 72.75 –1.18 –10.8 iShRuss1000Grw IWF 387.60 –2.65 –3.5
VangdDivApp VIG 200.35 –0.61 2.3 Source: Tullett Prebon, Tradeweb FTSE U.S. Treasury Close
FinSelSectorSPDR XLF 51.13 0.55 5.8 iShRuss1000Val IWD 191.79 –0.32 3.6
VangdFTSEAWxUS VEU 60.76 –1.33 5.8
iShRuss2000 IWM 212.39 –1.53 –3.9
GrayscaleBitcoin
HealthCrSelSect
GBTC
XLV
65.95
147.22
–1.14 –10.9
–0.41 7.0 iShS&P500Grw IVW 99.34 –2.62 –2.2
VangdFTSEDevMk
VangdFTSE EM
VEA
VWO
51.03
45.30
–1.18
–1.76
6.7
2.9
Corporate Debt
IndSelSectorSPDR XLI 134.53 –0.35 2.1 iShS&P500Value IVE 194.58 –0.47 1.9
iShSelectDiv DVY 136.43 –0.34 3.9
VangdGrowth VUG 398.60 –2.51 –2.9 Prices of firms' bonds reflect factors including investors' economic, sectoral and company-specific
InvscNasd100 QQQM 206.05 –2.75 –2.1
InvscQQQI QQQ 500.27 –2.78 –2.1 iSh7-10YTreaBd IEF 94.80 –0.12 2.5 VangdHiDiv VYM 132.18 –0.55 3.6 expectations
VangdInfoTech VGT 588.97 –3.52 –5.3
InvscS&P500EW
iShBitcoin
RSP
IBIT
178.20
47.35
–0.87 1.7
–1.27 –10.7
iSh20+YTreaBd
iShUSTech
TLT
IYW
91.31
152.18
–0.71
–3.64
4.6
–4.6 VangdIntermBd BIV 76.26 –0.10 2.0 Investment-grade spreads that tightened the most…
iShUSTreasuryBd GOVT 22.89 –0.11 –0.4 VangdIntrCorpBd VCIT 81.75 –0.20 1.8 Spread*, in basis points
iShCoreDivGrowth DGRO 63.34 –0.41 3.3
VangdIntermTrea VGIT 59.03 –0.02 1.8 Issuer Symbol Coupon (%) Yield (%) Maturity Current One-day change Last week
iShCoreMSCIEAFE IEFA 75.44 –1.09 7.3 iSh0-3MTreaBd SGOV 100.63 0.03 0.3
JEPQ –2.51 VangdLC VV 269.05 –1.65 –0.2
iShCoreMSCIEM IEMG 54.15 –1.97 3.7 JPMNasdEqPrem 55.13 –2.2
Medtronic MDT 5.550 5.30 March 15, ’40 101 –8 n.a.
iShCoreMSCITotInt IXUS 69.81 –1.40 5.5 JPM EqPrem JEPI 58.69 –0.68 2.0 VangdMegaGrwth MGK 332.44 –2.66 –3.2
iShCoreS&P500 IVV 587.78 –1.59 –0.2 JPM UltShIncm JPST 50.60 ... 0.5 VangdMC VO 266.79 –0.99 1.0 Mitsubishi UFJ Financial … 2.048 4.82 July 17, ’30 70 –7 70
PacerUSCashCows COWZ –0.94 VangdRealEst VNQ 93.11 0.40 4.5
iShCoreS&P MC IJH 61.25 –1.23 –1.7 56.96 0.8
Toyota Motor Credit … 2.150 4.56 Feb. 13, ’30 44 –7 45
iShCoreS&P SC IJR 110.84 –1.41 –3.8 ProShUltPrQQQ TQQQ 71.64 –8.29 –9.5 VangdRuss1000Grw VONG 99.83 –2.61 –3.4
iShCoreS&PTotUS ITOT 128.03 –1.56 –0.5 SPDRBbg1-3MTB BIL 91.70 0.01 0.3 VangdS&P500ETF VOO 537.97 –1.61 –0.2 Discovery Communications … 6.350 6.76 June 1, ’40 247 –6 246
iShCoreS&PUSGrw IUSG 136.43 –2.37 –2.1 SPDR DJIA Tr DIA 432.35 –0.46 1.6 VangdST Bond BSV 77.95 ... 0.9
SPDR Gold GLD 264.93 –1.52 9.4 VangdSTCpBd VCSH 78.77 –0.01 1.0 America Movil … 6.125 5.56 March 30, ’40 128 –4 128
iShCoreS&PUSVal IUSV 94.38 –0.45 1.9
iShCoreTotUSDBd IUSB 46.04 –0.15 1.9 SPDRPtfDevxUS SPDW 36.42 –1.17 6.7 VangdShortTrea VGSH 58.53 0.02 0.6 Mutual of Omaha Cos. Global Funding … 5.350 4.76 April 9, ’27 66 –4 n.a.
iShCoreUSAggBd AGG 98.81 –0.15 2.0 SPDRS&P500Value SPYV 52.16 –0.46 2.0 VangdSC VB 235.23 –1.42 –2.1
iShEdgeMSCIMinUSA USMV 93.31 –0.07 5.1 SPDRPtfS&P500 SPLG 68.83 –1.56 –0.2 VangdTaxExemptBd VTEB 50.52 –0.18 0.8 Shell Finance US … 4.125 4.95 May 11, ’35 66 –4 60
iShEdgeMSCIUSAQual QUAL 178.94 –1.43 0.5 SPDRS&P500Growth SPYG 86.03 –2.58 –2.1 VangdTotalBd BND 73.35 –0.12 2.0 Banco Santander … 5.439 5.01 July 15, ’31 90 –4 84
iShGoldTr IAU 54.20 –1.53 9.5 SPDR S&P 500 SPY 585.05 –1.60 –0.2 VangdTotIntlBd BNDX 49.33 –0.10 0.6
iShiBoxx$IGCpBd
iShMBS
LQD
MBB
109.13
93.67
–0.42
–0.14
2.1
2.2
SchwabIntEquity
SchwabUS BrdMkt
SCHF
SCHB
19.78
22.58
–1.20
–1.66
6.9
–0.5
VangdTotIntlStk
VangdTotalStk
VXUS
VTI
62.22
288.51
–1.33
–1.55
5.6
–0.4
…And spreads that widened the most
iShMSCI EAFE EFA 81.41 –1.13 7.7 SchwabUS Div SCHD 28.17 0.07 3.1 VangdTotWrldStk VT 119.52 –1.51 1.7 Mutual of Omaha Cos. Global Funding* … 4.750 4.86 Oct. 15, ’29 74 12 72
iShMSCIEAFEValue EFV 57.37 –0.81 9.3 SchwabUS LC SCHX 23.13 –1.62 –0.2 VangdValue VTV 175.68 –0.34 3.8
Citigroup C 4.750 5.77 May 18, ’46 118 6 108
Goldman Sachs GS 6.750 5.71 Oct. 1, ’37 141 6 131
Borrowing Benchmarks | wsj.com/market-data/bonds/benchmarks Toyota Motor Credit … 5.350 5.09 Jan. 9, ’35 81 6 68
Burlington Northern Santa Fe … 6.150 5.09 May 1, ’37 81 5 n.a.
Money Rates February 27, 2025 John Deere Capital … 4.400 4.70 Sept. 8, ’31 61 5 52
HP HPQ 6.000 5.76 Sept. 15, ’41 117 5 n.a.
Key annual interest rates paid to borrow or lend money in U.S. and international markets. Rates below are a 5
International Business Machines IBM 4.150 5.40 May 15, ’39 111 n.a.
guide to general levels but don’t always represent actual transactions.
Week —52-WEEK— Week —52-WEEK—
High-yield issues with the biggest price increases…
Inflation Latest ago High Low Latest ago High Low Bond Price as % of face value
Jan. Index Chg From (%) Issuer Symbol Coupon (%) Yield (%) Maturity Current One-day change Last week
Treasury 4.386 55.200 5.471 4.286
level Dec. '24 Jan. '24 Federal funds
Walgreen … 4.400 7.22 Sept. 15, ’42 72.219 2.71 n.a.
Effective rate 4.3400 4.3300 5.3400 4.3300 MBS 4.409 63.988 5.526 4.294
U.S. consumer price index High 4.4700 4.5500 5.6500 4.4700 Lumen Technologies LUMN 7.650 9.45 March 15, ’42 84.875 1.88 83.030
All items 317.671 0.65 3.0 Low 4.3200 4.3200 5.3300 4.3000 Weekly survey 1.11
Core 323.842 0.57 3.3
Nissan Motor Acceptance … 5.300 5.35 Sept. 13, ’27 99.875 n.a.
Bid 4.3200 4.3200 5.3300 4.3200
Offer 4.3500 4.3300 5.3600 4.3300 Latest Week ago Year ago Hughes Satellite Systems … 5.250 10.47 Aug. 1, ’26 93.250 0.88 92.000
International rates
Treasury bill auction Efesto Bidco … 7.500 7.65 Feb. 15, ’32 99.250 0.50 98.827
Week 52-Week Freddie Mac
Latest High Low
4 weeks 4.235 4.245 5.285 4.230 Teva Pharmaceutical Finance … 6.150 5.96 Feb. 1, ’36 101.527 0.50 100.750
ago 13 weeks 4.195 4.225 5.255 4.195 30-year fixed 6.76 6.85 6.94
Bausch Health … 11.000 10.78 Sept. 30, ’28 100.625 0.38 98.000
26 weeks 4.180 4.220 5.170 4.110 5.94 6.04 6.26
Prime rates 15-year fixed
0.13
ZF North America Capital … 4.750 4.68 April 29, ’25 100.000 99.875
U.S. 7.50 7.50 8.50 7.50 Other short-term rates Notes on data:
Canada 5.20 5.20 7.20 5.20
Japan 1.625 1.625 1.625 1.475 Week 52-Week U.S. prime rate is the base rate on corporate
…And with the biggest price decreases
Latest ago high low loans posted by at least 70% of the 10 largest
Lumen Technologies LUMN 7.600 9.81 Sept. 15, ’39 83.030 –1.47 n.a.
Policy Rates U.S. banks, and is effective December 19, 2024.
Euro zone 2.90 2.90 4.50 2.90 Call money Other prime rates aren’t directly comparable; Transocean RIG 7.500 10.15 April 15, ’31 88.099 –1.44 92.000
lending practices vary widely by location;
Switzerland 1.00 1.00 2.25 1.00 6.25 6.25 7.25 6.25 Discount rate is effective December 19, 2024. Bath & Body Works BBWI 6.875 6.38 Nov. 1, ’35 103.809 –0.81 104.000
Britain 4.50 4.50 5.25 4.50 Secured Overnight Financing Rate is as of
Commercial paper (AA financial) DISH DBS … 5.125 15.91 June 1, ’29 67.500 –0.50 64.625
Australia 4.10 4.10 4.35 4.10 February 26, 2025. DTCC GCF Repo Index is
90 days 4.32 4.31 5.37 4.26 Depository Trust & Clearing Corp.'s weighted
–0.39
Overnight repurchase average for overnight trades in applicable Paramount Global PARA 6.875 6.29 April 30, ’36 104.649 n.a.
U.S. 4.38 4.37 5.45 4.00 Secured Overnight Financing Rate CUSIPs. Value traded is in billions of U.S. dollars. Navient NAVI 5.625 7.38 Aug. 1, ’33 89.131 –0.37 88.750
Federal-funds rates are Tullett Prebon rates as
4.33 4.35 5.40 4.27 –0.35
U.S. government rates
of 5:30 p.m. ET. Topaz Solar Farms … 5.750 6.12 Sept. 30, ’39 96.500 97.496
Value 52-Week Sources: Federal Reserve; Bureau of Labor
Discount Latest Traded High Low *Estimated spread over 2-year, 3-year, 5-year, 10-year or 30-year hot-run Treasury; 100 basis points=one percentage pt.; change in spread shown is for Z-spread.
Statistics; DTCC; FactSet;
Note: Data are for the most active issue of bonds with maturities of two years or more
4.50 4.50 5.50 4.50 DTCC GCF Repo Index Tullett Prebon Information, Ltd. Source: MarketAxess
B8 | Friday, February 28, 2025 * ** THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
ADP ADP 311.30 -0.08 Caterpillar CAT 340.00 -2.58 Dover DOV 196.51 -1.17 GlobalFoundries GFS 38.35 -2.26 L3HarrisTech LHX 204.90 2.57 Verisk Analytics VRSK 0.6 .45 /.39 Q Mar31 /Mar14 Smith & Nephew ADR SNN 2.5 .447 SA May28 /Mar28
AutoZone AZO 3444.69 51.72 Celestica CLS 107.87 -3.81 Dow DOW 38.43 -0.42 GlobeLife GL 124.18 2.25 Labcorp LH 247.79 -3.56 Xcel Energy XEL 3.1 .57 /.5475 Q Apr20 /Mar14 Vinci Partners VINP 7.1 .15 Q Mar27 /Mar13
Avalonbay AVB 223.02 1.44 Cemex CX 6.29 -0.17 Doximity DOCS 69.45 -3.45 GlobusMedical GMED 78.67 -1.34 LamResearch LRCX 76.17 -5.13
COR 249.01 -1.64 t DrReddy'sLab RDY 12.95 -0.09 GoDaddy GDDY 174.94 LamarAdv LAMR 122.16 -0.43 Note: Dividend yields as of 3:30 p.m. ET
t Avantor AVTR 16.49 -0.73 Cencora -2.02 Reduced Sources: FactSet; Dow Jones Market Data
AveryDennison AVY 185.49 -0.26 t CenovusEnergy CVE 13.75 -0.17 DraftKings DKNG 42.74 -0.62 GoldFields GFI 18.40 -0.72 LasVegasSands LVS 43.74 0.01
WPP
0.%
S&P Fall levy on China would begin the
same day.
The peso fell 0.3% against
tends to drift down.”
Elsewhere:
The U.K. advertising group
posted a steeper-than-
expected drop in revenue and
0
–0.%
Sharply the U.S. dollar while the Cana-
dian dollar fell 0.7%.
Nvidia reported on
European stocks fell, with
auto shares among notable
projected little improvement
this year. Shares plummeted
16% in London.
Wednesday a 78% rise in sales losers.
S&P 500
Continued from page B1 for the past quarter, to $39.3 Salesforce
–1.0
where we get daily surprises.” billion, and it forecast about The 10-year Treasury yield The software company’s
Trump said late Wednesday $43 billion for its current closed at 4.284%. On Wednes- profit rose last quarter, but
–1.% he was considering 25% tariffs quarter, beating analyst ex- day, yields settled below its revenue outlook missed
on imports pectations. Shares initially 4.25%, logging a six-session expectations. Shares
–2.0 THURSDAY’S from the Euro- ticked up Thursday but then downward streak. dropped 4%.
MARKETS pean Union, fell 8.5%, the company’s worst
–2.% targeting cars post-earnings percentage de- The 2-year Treasury yield Stellantis
and other goods. He said cline since 2018. closed at 4.079%, up from President Trump’s European
Nasdaq Composite
Five-minute intervals much-heralded measures Analysts blamed narrower 4.071% Wednesday. Union tariff threats knocked
–3.0
against Mexico and Canada profit margins and worries down shares in auto
10 a.m. 11 noon 1 p.m. 2 3 4 were coming. Then, in a so- about Nvidia’s sales in China. Bitcoin traded around manufacturers in the region.
Source: FactSet cial-media post Thursday, he Jay Hatfield, chief executive at $83,000. U.S.-listed shares of
Jeep maker Stellantis
declined 5.5%.
Its DEI
£117.75 company launched a share and other one-off items—in- fees for third-party content, and a strong pipeline for
+6%
120 buyback of £500 million, or creased 9.8% to £4.15 billion, such as exchange data, that is 2025.”
$633.8 million, supported by with the corresponding mar- distributed directly to custom- For 2025, LSEG expects or-
Targets 11%
110
sustained growth across all its
key segments.
Shares climbed 6% in
gin rising to 48.8% from
47.2%. A company-compiled
consensus had adjusted Ebitda
ers.
The board declared a total
dividend of 130 pence a share,
ganic constant currency
growth in total income ex-
cluding recoveries of 6.5% to
Thursday’s trading. at £4.11 billion. up from 115 pence a share a 7.5%. It also forecasts its con-
BY CANDICE CHOI 10% The stock-exchange and fi- The group’s total income year earlier. stant currency Ebitda margin
nancial-information company excluding recoveries rose to “We have been a driving to rise by half a percentage
Goldman Sachs Group is 100 said pretax profit rose to £1.26 £8.49 billion from £8.01 bil- force behind reforms that se- point to a full percentage
no longer spelling out its di- billion last year from £1.195 lion, ahead of a company-com- cure London’s position as a point and free cash flow of at
versity hiring targets. 9% billion in 2023. This missed piled consensus of £8.47 bil- leading global venue for capi- least £2.4 billion.
The bank’s annual report Sept. 2024 ’2% forecasts of £2.18 billion, lion. Within this, data and tal raising,” Chief Executive It said the buyback should
no longer lays out the prog- Note: £1 = $1.27
based on estimates from two analytics income grew 4.5% Officer David Schwimmer be completed by July of this
ress it has made on hiring Source: FactSet analysts taken from FactSet. and capital-markets income said. “We also reached an im- year.
women, Black, Hispanic, Asian
and LGBTQ+ professionals.
31%
mon said the bank made ad- tor said on Thursday that net ing optimizing listing proce- vival in Hong climbed about for the next fiscal year, Finan-
justments to reflect legal de- profit reached a fourth-quar- dures, lowering transaction Kong’s and 24% in 2025, cial Secretary Chan said HKEX
velopments in the U.S., but ter high of 3.78 billion Hong costs to bolster its securities China’s stock closing at will step up its promotion in
stood by its commitment to a Kong dollars, equivalent to market and adopting new markets this HK$365 on Southeast Asia and the Middle
diverse workforce. US$486.2 million, climbing measures aimed at greater year, fueled by Increase in the Thursday. East and seek areas of cooper-
“We strongly believe that around 46% from a year ear- capital-market cooperation a surge in sen- DBS Group ation, including the listing of
merit and diversity are not lier. Revenue and other in- with mainland Chinese com- timent toward
company’s revenue Research said exchange-traded funds to
mutually exclusive. Our people come increased 31% to panies to boost dual listings. Chinese tech and other income for in a note that “promote two-way capital
are a powerful example of that HK$6.38 billion—a new quar- “Looking to 2025, ongoing shares after the quarter improving risk flows.”
and that’s why we will con- terly record—as trading and geopolitical and macroeco- homegrown appetite will In the middle-to-long term,
tinue to focus on the impor- clearing fees rose across the nomic developments will likely startup Deep- likely continue the new listing overhauls
tance of attracting and retain- cash, derivatives and com- continue impacting global Seek renewed in the near mentioned in the budget, such
ing diverse, exceptional modities markets, the com- markets,” HKEX Chief Execu- confidence in China’s AI tech- term, “supported by recent re- as improvements to the vet-
talent,” the statement said. pany said. tive Bonnie Y Chan said. nology. rating of tech stocks and a ting process and optimizing
Goldman earlier this month Both measures were “However, there are also “Since the beginning of this more supportive policy tone listing thresholds, could help
said it was ending its require- slightly ahead of consensus encouraging signs of economic year, trading has been even from the Chinese government attract more initial public of-
ment that companies in the estimates in a Visible Alpha revitalization, with stimulative more active, with average toward the private economy.” ferings to Hong Kong, analysts
U.S. and Western Europe have poll, with analysts expecting policies in mainland China and daily turnover exceeding Citi Research raised the at DBS said. If the IPO appli-
diverse boards for it to take net profit of HK$3.71 billion interest-rate cuts in other ma- HK$200 billion recently, up by target price on HKEX’s stock cations translate into success-
them public. The company and revenue of HK$6.32 bil- jor markets providing renewed more than 50% over last year’s to HK$410 from HK$370 after ful listings, “they could inject
cited legal developments re- lion. vibrancy to Hong Kong’s fund- average. Total market capital- the results as it lifted its aver- more liquidity and trading
lated to board-diversity re- HKEX witnessed stronger raising and secondary mar- ization reached HK$40 tril- age daily turnover forecasts momentum into the market,”
quirements for the decision. trading volumes during the kets,” she said. lion,” he said. for 2025 and 2026 on the sen- they said.
B10 | Friday, February 28, 2025 THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
Make new friends, but keep the an indicator of its market share
old. PayPal is striking a lot of new gains.
partnerships in the payments and The company said its aim is to
commerce business these days. But accelerate branded checkout total
its original cohort is still the most payment volume growth to be-
important: consumers. tween 8% and 10% annually by
The digital-payments business 2027. That would be a big jump
has gotten a lot harder in recent from 2024’s 6% currency-neutral
years. What might have been a growth rate.
steady, yearslong shift to e-com- For PayPal to win with mer-
merce for traditional businesses chants behind the scenes, its best
like restaurants or grocery stores argument would be to show them
happened in a flash during the that it can continue to deliver its
pandemic. So did a change in con- loyal users to be their customers,
sumers’ payment habits, like tap- better than rivals such as Apple,
ping to pay with digital wallets via Klarna, Affirm and others.
their phones. “We are the only ones with a
All that pulled forward a surge two-sided ecosystem, with access
in growth—but the letdown has to merchants at scale, with access
been harsh, especially as digital- to 80 million-plus shopper profiles,
payment technologies have gotten and access to hundreds of millions
increasingly commoditized and of consumers on an open, agnostic
fiercely competitive with the rise platform, to be able to deliver that
of players such as Apple. next version of commerce,” Chief
The journey of PayPal’s stock Executive Alex Chriss told analysts
since the pandemic has been ex- on Tuesday.
treme. Its shares started 2020 at One thing PayPal aims to do is
ABBIE PARR/AP
$70.73
$310 in July 2021. On “Pay with Venmo”
The chip maker’s revenue projection of $43 billion for the April quarter exceeded Wall Street’s forecast. Thursday, they service, setting a rev-
closed at $70.73. enue aim of over $2
ries about tariffs. Revenue beat rising suspicion among some that the company’s GTC conference
Wall Street’s consensus by about AI is a bubble about to pop in next month, which is expected to
$1.2 billion, which is actually the spectacular dot-com fashion. highlight new products coming
smallest margin since Nvidia’s AI Nvidia and other prominent AI after this year’s Blackwell family.
business started booming in early names saw their stocks melt The bar is high; Nvidia is now
2023. down last month after claims a $3 trillion company that de-
The company also confirmed from a Chinese AI startup called pends on the spending of other
that its Blackwell line will cause a DeepSeek raised questions about big companies wanting an edge in
small hit to the company’s gross the computing costs really needed AI. But with those companies un-
margin for much of this year. to train advanced AI models. willing to tap the brakes, Nvidia’s
Investors shouldn’t fret over More recently, reports that race still has some legs left.
the latter. Even gross margins in companies like Microsoft might —Dan Gallagher PayPal regained some momentum in profitability and user growth last year.
HOMES | MARKETS | PEOPLE | REDOS | SALES THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Friday, February 28, 2025 | M1
$1.9
MILLION
Assessed value of a Sheep
Pond Road house when it sold
for $200,000 last year. In
January, days after this
photo was taken, it was
condemned and
demolished.
BY E.B. SOLOMONT workers excavated below the house—precari- The progression of erosion can be unpredict-
O
ously perched on a bluff besieged by crashing able. The island has weathered a series of bad
n a frigid December morning, waves—and slid steel beams underneath the storms over the past few years that have
emergency work crews arrived 1,300-square-foot, three-bedroom structure. taken out bigger chunks of the beach, lending
at Sheep Pond Road on Nan- Later, they jacked it up and rolled it back urgency to the issue of what can be done—and
tucket at daybreak with an ur- about 200 feet from the water’s edge. who should pay for it.
gent mission: Stop a wood- Over the past few years, homeowners on “What’s happening on Sheep Pond is no dif-
shingle beach house from Sheep Pond Road have faced a series of in- ferent than what’s been happening forever—
tumbling into the ocean. creasingly critical decisions over how to pro- it’s just that the houses are running out of
The land around the meandering road on the tect their idyllic beach enclave from erosion. room now,” said Gary Winn of Maury People
Massachusetts island’s south shore has ceded Since 2020, three houses on Sheep Pond have Sotheby’s International Realty, who has been
about 10 feet a year to the water for decades, been condemned and demolished as the water selling real estate on Nantucket for more than
claiming roughly half a dozen homes since the has crept closer. Others have been moved back 40 years.
early 2000s. Now, erosion threatened to take out of harm’s way or sold at fire-sale prices. Nantucket, in recent years, has tried to take
another. The experience on Sheep Pond Road is a a more proactive approach. Nearly 2,400
Contractor Rob Andersen said his crew microcosm of Nantucket and other coastal buildings on the island are at risk of flood and
worked quickly, trying to beat a storm that communities where homeowners and local erosion-related damage by 2070, which could
was forecast to roll in that evening, bringing governments are wrestling with the emotional amount to $3.4 billion in damages, according
35 to 60 mile-an-hour wind gusts. By nightfall, and financial implications of climate change. Please turn to page M5
FROM TOP: TUCKER FINERTY FOR WSJ; MATTHEW J. LEE/THE BOSTON GLOBE/GETTY IMAGES; KIT NOBLE (2); ZACK DEZON FOR WSJ (GRIFFIN)
$3.4
BILLION
Nantucket estimated
erosion and flood
damages by
2070
At least seven houses have been demolished since 2014, including the longtime summer home of George and Marie Frazza, which was condemned and torn down in October 2023.
M2 | Friday, February 28, 2025 NY THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
LUXURY
PRIVATE PROPERTIES
REAL ESTATE
DESERVES A
LUXURY AUCTION ®
Ken Griffin Buys Julia Koch’s
SELLING WITHOUT RESERVE!
Unit at Posh New York Co-op
WATERFRONT
15 H
Billionaire
hedge funder
ACRES! UPDATE Ken Griffin has
long been
known as one of residential
real estate’s biggest whales,
presiding over a personal
property empire es-
timated to be worth
billions. Now, he’s SOLD
auction
ONLINE $60 million or more. It was
formally listed for $48 mil- seen as the city’s top co-op for buying the most expen- compound in Miami’s Coco-
lion in 2023. building. Developed around sive properties in the nut Grove neighborhood
The Citadel founder al- 1930 by James T. Lee, the world’s priciest buildings and a huge swath of land in
ready owns a Manhattan grandfather of Jacqueline and neighborhoods, often Palm Beach, Fla., where he
apartment a few blocks Kennedy Onassis, it has breaking price records in has spent more than $450
Bre"#w$$d - G$ver"$rs Cl%b away at 220 Central Park drawn bold-faced names the process. million.
South, which is widely con- including the Kochs, Ron- He owns a $122 million The listing agents of the
NASHVILLE, TENNESSEE sidered the city’s best ald Lauder and former London mansion near Buck- 740 Park unit were Leighton
condo building. He paid Treasury secretary Steven ingham Palace, a Hamptons Candler, Bradley Comisar
$238 million for an apart- Mnuchin. compound he bought from and Jennifer Reardon of
ment there in 2019. By Over the years, Griffin Calvin Klein for $84.45 mil- Corcoran.
comparison, 740 Park is has developed a reputation lion, a roughly $107 million —Katherine Clarke
• 5 Bedroom, 6 Full & 2 Half Bath Estate on the 3rd Green • 1.81± Acres stown, about 20 land and ren- He also reoriented
400 acres,
• Finishes: Marble, Travertine, Mahogany, Venetian Plaster, Etc. • Elevator miles northwest of ovations. the house with a
6-bedroom
• Chef’s Kitchen • 11-Seat Theater • Bowling Alley • Sauna & Steam Room Baltimore, where Plank, who front porch.
house
• Billiards Room with TV Surround & Bar • Basketball & Pickleball Court the athletic-apparel lives about 10 Plank reno-
• Outdoor Kitchen • Firepit • Infinity Pool & Spa • Whole-House Generator company is based. miles away, used he closed the farm’s horse vated two barns and added
• Home Gym • Mosquito Spray System • Well Irrigation • 5-Car Garage Known as Sagamore Farm, it the farm as a guesthouse, a racing operations in 2021 a third barn, with a com-
has a six-bedroom, roughly horse-training facility and a because of the time com- bined capacity of over 200
((866) 924!5294
4 16,000-square-foot main retreat center for employ- mitment required. horses, said Dulin.
INTERLUXE.COM/WJBRENT house as well as horse train- ees, he said. He had hoped Plank, who has been CEO Plank sold a Georgetown
ing and breeding facilities, to use the property to raise of Under Armour off and on mansion for $17.25 million
This property is listed for sale by Allison Gallagher - TN Lic. # - 362136 - Synergy - (615) 720-6273. Not a solicitation
for listings or offer to sell real property. Interluxe provides advertising and online bidding services only through TN according to listing agent horses to compete in Triple since he founded the com- in 2020.
Denie Dulin of Compass. Crown races, he said, but pany in 1996, started qui- —Sarah Paynter
Auctioneer Tim Mast, Lic.# 5252, TN Real Estate Broker Tim Mast, Lic.# 299329 Tranzon Asset Advisors - 731-610-
5436. The final original deadline for bids is Friday, March 21, 2025 at 5:00pm CST. Bidding may close earlier due to
bid activity as indicated by the timer in the auction. For full terms please visit www.interluxe.com.
#1 Agent in Ridgewood, NJ
402 S Beach Road | Jupiter Island 7 Beds | 11 Baths| $35,000,000 in Total Sales Volume in 2023 & 2024*
Experience coastal luxury in this all-new construction masterpiece that’s like owning your own 5-star resort. Nestled on
2+/- acres with +/- 150 feet of direct ocean frontage, complete with a private beach equipped with power and water. Be Frances Hanson Ekblom
the first to own this legacy property, designed for lasting durability and timeless elegance. The property offers 7 ensuites, Licensed Associate Broker
11 bathrooms, breathtaking ocean views, sweeping balconies, and a west-side garden. Built with limestone, cypress, oak, Founding Agent
and copper, blending modern technology with enduring quality. Guesthouse includes a fitness room and kitchenette. M 201.602.4683 | O 551.284.0175
A spectacular palm alleé creates a pool pavilion paradise that includes a fireplace, lush landscaping, and a motor court with [email protected]
a 4-car garage. A rare opportunity for unparalleled luxury on Jupiter Island.
C 772-253-1852
*Source: NJMLS MLS 01.01.2023-12.31.2023 & 01.01.2024–12.16.2024.
E [email protected] Frances Hanson Ekblom is a team of real estate agents affiliated with Compass, a licensed
real estate broker and abides by Equal Housing Opportunity laws. All material presented herein is
W JupiterIslandForSale.com
intended for informational purposes only. Information is compiled from sources deemed reliable
but is subject to errors, omissions, changes in price, condition, sale, or withdrawal without notice.
Photos may be virtually staged or digitally enhanced and may not reflect actual property conditions.
1 Franklin Avenue, Suites 2-3 Ridgewood NJ 07450
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Friday, February 28, 2025 | M3
PRIVATE PROPERTIES
“They value their privacy,” he said.
The house has a sculptural
staircase and round skylight in-
spired by the Guggenheim, Gonza-
lez said. Other elements of the
property have a tropical aesthetic,
such as ipe wood and a coral key-
stone roof deck. The living room
is 100 feet long. There is also a
separate five-car garage with staff
quarters.
The Kollmanns have made up-
dates to the property over the
years, replac-
FOR SALE ing the floors,
$88 installing a
new roof and
MILLION upgrading landscaping,
the
2 docks, pool,
Gonzalez said.
private beach
They briefly
listed the
house for $38 million in 2020,
thinking they would not be able to
use it because of the pandemic.
“They quickly changed their mind
when they saw Florida was open
for business,” he said.
The Kollmanns, who have
homes in Germany, the South of
France and elsewhere in Europe,
have decided to sell the Miami
Beach home because they are not
using it as much as they used to,
Gonzalez said. They also feel it is
a good time to sell, given the
strong dollar and massive price
appreciation of Miami real estate
since Covid, he said.
—E.B. Solomont
7:00A M 6:00PM
8:00A M
ORAL REPRESENTATIONS CANNOT BE RELIED UPON AS CORRECTLY STATING THE REPRESENTATIONS OF THE DEVELOPER. FOR CORRECT REPRESENTATIONS, MAKE REFERENCE TO THIS BROCHURE AND TO THE DOCUMENTS REQUIRED BY SECTION 718.503, FLORIDA
STATUTES,TOBEFURNISHEDBYADEVELOPERTOABUYERORLESSEE.Thisisnotintendedtobeanoffertosell,orsolicitationtobuy,condominiumunitstoresidentsofanyjurisdictionwhereprohibitedbylaw,andyoureligibilityforpurchasewilldependuponyourstateofresidency.
Allimagesanddesignsdepictedhereinareartists’conceptualrenderings,whicharebaseduponpreliminarydevelopmentplans,andaresubjecttochangewithoutnoticeinthemannerprovidedintheofferingdocuments.Allsuchmaterialsarenottoscaleandareshownsolelyforillustrative
purposes. This project is being developed by N Flagler Drive Developer, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company, which was formed solely for such purpose. Olara is sponsored by a Savanna affiliate. Savanna is a proven owner, operator, developer, and institutional fund manager with a
30-yeartrackrecord. Ithasinvestedinanddevelopedover17millionsquarefeetofrealestate.OtheraffiliatedpartiesincludetheMactaggartFamilyPartnership,whichhasinvestedinanddevelopedpremierrealestateprojectsintheUnitedStatesandEnglandforover100years,aswellas
HaymesInvestmentCompanyandBrandonRinker.HaymesandRinkerassistedintheacquisitionofsixoftheeightparcelswithin theassemblagethatbecametheOlaradevelopmentsiteandservedasdevelopmentconsultantsasthesitewasassembledandthedevelopmentvisionwas
finalized.TheprincipalsofHaymesInvestmentCompanyhaveowned,operated,anddevelopedmillionsofsquarefeetofcommercial,residential,and retailrealestateinNewYork,Florida,andaroundtheUnitedStates.BrandonRinkerhasassembledsomeofthepremiersitesinthePalm
Beaches. The Condominium has been registered with the Massachusetts Board of Registration of Real Estate Brokers and Salespersons F-1277-01-01. THE COMPLETE OFFERING TERMS ARE IN A FLORIDA PROSPECTUS AVAILABLE FROM THE DEVELOPER. A CPS-12 APPLICATION HAS BEEN ACCEPTED
IN NEW YORK AS FILE NO. CP22-0089. WARNING: THE CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF REAL ESTATE HAS NOT INSPECTED, EXAMINED, OR QUALIFIED THIS OFFERING. This advertisement is a solicitation for the sale of units in Olara Condominium; N.J. Registration #: 22-04-0012. Equal Housing Opportunity.
M4 | Friday, February 28, 2025 NY THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
PRIVATE PROPERTIES
and his Oscar for the 1944 film racing entrepreneur Charles How- his siblings are spread across the
“Going My Way,” which sits on ard, who owned the legendary country. “It’s difficult to turn the
the mantel, his son said. horse Seabiscuit. Bing, a horse- page emotionally, but all good
Now, following Kathryn’s death racing enthusiast, knew the How- things come to an end,” he said.
in 2024, the 11-bedroom residence ard family and became familiar While the affluent Hillsborough
is going on the market for the with the property through them, area is known for its multimillion-
first time in roughly six decades. his son said. In the early 1960s, he dollar estates, no sale has come
The asking price is $40 million, a purchased the estate as a gift for close to the $40 million asking
potentially record-setting number Kathryn. The Crosbys moved into price of the Crosby estate. The
for Hillsborough, said listing the house with Harry and his sib- current $30 million record for the
agent Jennifer Gilson of Golden lings Nathaniel and Mary Frances. area was set in 2021 by the sale of
Gate Sotheby’s International Re- The Crosbys made significant a house then owned by billionaire
alty. changes to the property, said Wood paneling came from the Elon Musk, Gilson said.
With frescoes, ornate fireplaces Harry, who works in finance in collection of William Randolph Hearst. —Katherine Clarke
I am more
than who I
Riven Oaks, c. 1900
Designed by James Brown Lord
for Miss Mary LeRoy King
am on paper.
Inside the Gated Community of Tuxedo Park
Less than one hour to NYC
Spectacular 13,000sq ft home
in need of renovation and restoration
It’s time to let your skills shine.
let’s get in touch
Find resources for breaking through barriers like
FRANCINE LIZA Jeff, STAR
degree screens and stereotypes. It’s time to tear the
Licensed Real Estate Salesperson paper ceiling limiting STARs: workers Skilled Through
845-915-4567 (office) Alternative Routes rather than a bachelor’s degree.
201-970-1737 (cell)
www.tuxedohudsonrealty.com TEAR THE PAPER CEILING.ORG
#HireSTARs
TUXEDO
HUDSON
REALTY
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. NY Friday, February 28, 2025 | M5
MANSION
THE
RESIDENCESNAPLES.COM
AT LAKE KEOWEE
ORAL REPRESENTATIONS CANNOT BE RELIED UPON AS CORRECTLY STATING
REPRESENTATIONS OF THE DEVELOPER. FOR CORRECT REPRESENTATIONS,
MAKE REFERENCE TO THE DOCUMENTS REQUIRED BY SECTION 718.503, FLORIDA Private Residential Community with
STATUTES, TO BE FURNISHED BY A DEVELOPER TO A BUYER OR LESSEE.
Luxury Lake and Golf Lifestyle
This project has been filed in the state of Florida and no other state. This is not an offer to sell or solicitation of offers to buy Sunset SC, Two Hours from Atlanta
thecondominiumunitsinstateswheresuchofferorsolicitationcannotbemade.EqualHousingOpportunity.Rosewood
Residences Lido Key is owned and being developed, offered and sold by WSR—Lido Beach, LLC (“Developer”). The
project is not owned, developed or sold by Rosewood Hotels and Resorts, L.L.C. or any of its affiliates (“Rosewood”).
Reserveatlakekeowee.com
Developer uses the Rosewood marks pursuant to a license agreement with Rosewood, which may be terminated under
certain conditions. Rosewood does not assume any responsibility or liability in connection with the condominium.
© Copyright 2025. All rights reserved. The Ronto Group®. Rosewood Hotels and Resorts®.
M6 | Friday, February 28, 2025 NY THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
MANSION
Continued from page M5 tucket’s Conservation Com- be demolished.
has insurance on the prop- mission has been conserva- A Boston real-estate de-
erty, but it doesn’t cover tive about what projects it veloper who purchased a
erosion. Instead of stress- permits, in part to ensure pair of houses on Sheep
ing, the couple decided to properties aren’t protected Pond for $3.9 million in
enjoy what they have. at the expense of others. 2022 is grappling with fall-
“You’re sitting there That’s left Sheep Pond resi- out from the investment.
looking at the open ocean,” dents in a bind, said Glenn After developer Brett Fodi-
said Maloney, whose kids Wood, who represented the man defaulted on a $2.925
surf in front of their house. residents in the 2003 law- million mortgage, the
“I go sit on the beach, and if suit. “Without any really homes were set to be auc-
I see someone on the beach good option, the only op- tioned in December. Then,
in a day, it’s a surprise.” tion is retreat,” he said. one of the houses was con-
Located about 30 miles Even if Sheep Pond resi- demned. Rob Andersen and
south of Cape Cod, Nan- dents manage to install his crew were called to
tucket has grappled with erosion control, it is un- move it. The company Fodi-
erosion for decades. likely they could prevent man used to buy the prop-
In the 1990s, residents of the inevitable, said Gas- erty has since filed for
Siasconset, on the eastern barro. Plus, the town is Chapter 11 bankruptcy.
end of Nantucket, formed a also dealing with erosion James Maloney listed his
nonprofit, funded by locals, near the island’s ferry ter- home for $3.5 million in
that installed sand-filled James Caulfield paid $2.125 million for two houses. The one above rents for up to $40,000 a minal, an airport runway 2023, a couple of months
geotubes to absorb the week. Residents in Siasconset installed geotubes in 2014 to help prevent erosion. and a wastewater treat- after his neighbors, the
force of waves along ment plant. “Our society Frazzas, had to tear down
Sankaty Bluff and Baxter allocates $1 million a year can’t function without a their home. He said erosion
Road. But the project, to such planning, said Nan- wastewater treatment had nothing to do with the
which cost more than $15 tucket’s town manager, C. plant,” he said. decision. He and his wife
million, sparked contro- Elizabeth Gibson.
versy over the private She and other local offi-
group’s use of the public cials, however, say there is ‘We went into this investment knowing
beach, and whether the also a level of responsibility
barriers caused damage to among homeowners. “This it may not be there forever.’
nearby unprotected areas. is private property and, un- —James Caulfield, Sheep Pond homeowner since 2020
In recent years, the town fortunately, there’s nature
moved away from just re- at work here,” she said.
acting to coastal risk and In 2003, five home- Over the past decade, at purchased a home in Mar-
adopted a proactive ap- owners on Sheep Pond least seven houses on blehead, another coastal
proach with its Coastal Re- Road sued the town and Sheep Pond Road have been town, and decided to give
silience Plan. It currently county for negligence after demolished. After a series up Nantucket. They have
of storms, a summer home since dropped the asking
officials failed to maintain a owned by New Yorkers price to $2.395 million.
Nantucket’s Receding Shoreline Boston 100-foot stretch of the pub- George and Marie Frazza Entertainment executive
Demolished lic road before it collapsed, was condemned and demol- Michael Burns listed a two-
Moved M A SS . blocking access to their ished in October 2023. bedroom cottage in the
Fire sale homes. Five years later, a Then in February 2024, a summer of 2024 for
jury sided with home- house on Sheep Pond that $850,000. Burns, vice chair-
Sh
Toppled into
ee
R I. owners and told the town was once listed for $2.2 man of film studio Lions-
p
the ocean
Po
2024 to rebuild the road. million sold for $600,000. gate, also owns a larger
nd
M ar t ha’s A few years ago, portions Four months later, long- home on the adjacent lot.
Ro
V i neyar
y d
ad
of the new road began to time owners Jane Carlin The smaller property was
2017 crumble. This time, the and Benjamin Gifford were in contract twice before he
2010
2024
2025 town plans to relocate it. trying to donate their took it off the market in
2023 500 feet Massachusetts law pro- house, assessed at $1.9 mil- January.
ORAL REPRESENTATIONS CANNOT BE RELIED UPON AS CORRECTLY STATING REPRESENTATIONS OF THE DEVELOPER. FOR CORRECT REPRESENTATIONS, MAKE REFERENCE
TO THIS BROCHURE AND TO THE DOCUMENTS REQUIRED BY SECTION 718.503, FLORIDA STATUTES, TO BE FURNISHED BY A DEVELOPER TO A BUYER OR LESSEE.
1809 Brickell Property Owner, LLC is the developer and the offeror of The St. Regis Residences, Miami. This offering is not intended for any resident of a jurisdiction where such an offering is prohibited. The St. Regis
Residences, Miami is not owned, developed, or sold by Marriott International, Inc. or its affiliates, which has not confirmed the accuracy of any of the statements or representations made about the project. Images are artists’
renderings and not exact reflections of the finished product nor the precise view from each Unit. Consult the Developer’s Prospectus to understand this offering, the amenities, the proposed budgets, terms, conditions, fees,
specifications, Unit dimensions and method for Unit calculation, site plans, and to learn what is included with purchase and by payment of regular assessments. All prices are subject to change and do not include optional
features, design packages, or premiums for upgrades. This Condominium has been registered with the Massachusetts Board of Registration of Real Estate Brokers and Salespersons F-1287-01-01. The complete offering
terms for New York residents are in a CPS-12 application available from the offeror at File No. CP23-0071. WARNING TO CALIFORNIA RESIDENTS: The California Department of Real Estate has not inspected, examined, or
qualified this offering. This advertisement is a solicitation for the sale of units in 1809 Brickell Condominium N.J. Registration No 23-04-0009. 1809 Brickell Property Owner, LLC 2025.
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. NY Friday, February 28, 2025 | M7
MANSION
BY KATHERINE CLARKE THE MARKET
I Meet the
n 1987, Forbes pub-
lished its first billion-
aires list, featuring 140
individuals whose com-
Superbillionaires
bined wealth totaled $295
billion. At the time, the
richest person in the world
was Japan’s Yoshiaki Tsut-
sumi, a real-estate tycoon
worth $20 billion.
Today, the world’s richest
person, Elon Musk, is worth The world’s ultrarich are growing in number, and
$419.4 billion, roughly 21 changing real-estate and wealth as we know it
times as much as Tsutsumi
at his peak and more than
two million times as much
as the median net worth of
an American household, ac- Since 2023, Bezos has spent $234 million assembling three
cording to exclusive data properties on Miami’s Indian Creek Island. Below, in Lake
from global wealth intelli- Tahoe, Zuckerberg spent $59 million in 2018 cobbling
gence firm Altrata. together two private estates.
As the ranks of global
billionaires have swelled in
recent years, a new cate-
gory of ultrarich has
emerged—the superbillion-
aire. Musk is one of just 24
people worldwide who
qualify for that distinction,
defined as individuals
worth $50 billion or more.
As of early February,
those superbillionaires’ for-
tunes accounted for more
than 16% of all billionaire
wealth, a dramatic increase
from 4% in 2014, according
to Altrata. Their combined obviously controlled signifi- Each of the superbillion-
net worth totaled $3.3 tril- cant amounts of wealth, but aires on Altrata’s list has
lion, equivalent to the nom- now you’re talking about direct personal residential
inal GDP of France. Of the differences in the billionaire real-estate holdings of at
FROM TOP: DEBORAH ACOSTA/WSJ; JASON HENRY FOR WSJ; KAGAN MCLEOD (ILLUSTRATION)
24 people, 16 qualified as population themselves,” least $100 million, and of-
centi-billionaires, meaning said Maya Imberg, head of ten far more, according to
they have a net worth of at thought leadership and ana- the company. Imberg said
least $100 billion. lytics at Altrata, who has that number is likely to be
The rise of the superbill- been researching the super- a significant underestimate
ionaire has coincided with a billionaire set. “It’s quite in some cases because real
significant leap in luxury staggering just how much estate can often be held in
markets across the world, the net worths of some of a partner’s name or owned
including real estate, as these people have grown.” by one of these billionaires’
these individuals cobble to- In major luxury real-es- companies or holding com-
gether massive portfolios of tate markets like New York, panies.
luxury homes. Miami, Palm Beach, Fla., The superbillionaire pop-
Experts say the data Los Angeles and Aspen, ulation is made up in large
shows how the ranks of the Colo., new supertall towers part by entrepreneurs who
ultrarich have begun to pull and spec mansions have made their money in the
away from the merely popped up geared specifi- tech sector, or whose indus-
wealthy, and how a subset cally to the billionaire set, try was catapulted to new
has been propelled to new The 24 superbillionaires are comprised in large part of entrepreneurs who made their money and there has been an ex- levels by technological ad-
heights. in tech and include, clockwise from top left, Michael Bloomberg, Mark Zuckerberg, Larry plosion of nine-figure home vances. Of the top 10 rich-
“Billionaires have always Ellison, Elon Musk, Jeff Bezos and Bill Gates. sales across the country. Please turn to page M8
M8 | Friday, February 28, 2025 NY THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
MANSION
The Retailers came the world’s first con- years, and that has The Industrialists Inarguably, the con-
firmed billionaire in allowed some of centration of wealth
1916. During that period, a these businesses to among a small num-
company’s value accounted scale, and created a ber of tech entrepre-
for physical assets like huge amount of neurs gives these indi-
property and machinery, shareholder value,” viduals unprecedented
more so than the types of said Steven Kaplan, a influence over policy,
intellectual property and professor at the Uni- media and society.
promise of future scale and versity of Chicago Musk controls SpaceX,
earnings that push up val- Booth School of Busi- Tesla, and X, influenc-
ues today. ness who studies fi- ing everything from
Today’s tech billionaires nance and inequality. space exploration to
make up a significant por- “Walmart is an exam- online discourse, as
tion of the superbillionaire ple, Amazon is an- well as more recently
pool. Their wealth is linked other. These are busi- having the ear of
almost entirely to the stock nesses that couldn’t President Trump. Be-
prices and therefore future have scaled to this zos owns the Wash-
cash flows of the companies level without tech- ington Post. Zucker-
they started. Amazon nology.” Clockwise from top left: Gautam Adani, berg heads Instagram,
founder Jeff Bezos, Meta The current Mukesh Ambani, Prajogo Pangestu, Julia Facebook and
founder Mark Zuckerberg makeup of the super- Koch and Bill Koch Threads, platforms
and Nvidia’s Jensen Huang billionaire population used by billions.
have all recently seen their also shows a shift from the wealth, according to federal These superbillionaires oper-
fortunes fluctuate by tens of world’s richest people in- data. In the late 1980s, the ate in a largely deregulated
Clockwise from top left: Alice Walton, James Walton, Samuel billions in a single year, de- heriting their wealth to a top 1% held 23%. digital landscape where
Robson Walton, Bernard Arnault, Francoise Bettencourt pending on investor senti- rise in self-made billion- The rise of the superbill- oversight is limited.
Meyers and Amancio Ortega ment. The scale of their aires. “The great American ionaire raises fundamental Kaplan, a self-described
wealth is unparalleled—but fortunes of today are new questions about the future optimist, said he sees the
Continued from page M7 monopoly, Andrew Carnegie so is its volatility. money, not old,” said a 2024 of wealth distribution and same advances in tech and
est individuals on the list, dominated the steel in- Unlike past genera- report by the Heritage economic power in the U.S. globalization that fueled the
six fall into that category. dustry, and Corne- tions, where for- Foundation, a conservative and globally. Economists rise of the superbillionaire
Of the total 24 superbillion- lius Vanderbilt tunes were built think tank, which noted the and politicians remain split as being a net positive for
aires, only three were fe-
male. Only seven were
based outside the U.S.
amassed a for-
tune through
railroads.
$100 over decades,
today’s tech-
driven econ-
absence of names like Astor,
Carnegie, Mellon, Rockefel-
ler and Vanderbilt on lists
over the importance of al-
lowing billionaire wealth to
remain uncapped as a
society, though in the U.S.
they have hurt the manufac-
turing sectors that used to
The rise of the superbill- Their wealth,
MILLION omy has also like the Forbes 400. means to encourage innova- be an economic driver for
Minimum worth of
ionaire marks a transforma- while vast, enabled “Of the approximately 97 tion, or whether society the middle class.
personal real estate
tion in the composition of was spread founders to still-living billionaires on can function equitably Luigi Zingales, an eco-
each superbillionaire
the world’s ultrawealthy, ex- across indus- amass enor- the 2005 Forbes 400 list when so much capital is nomics professor and host
holds
perts said. In the 19th and tries that de- mous sums in a who inherited fortunes, less concentrated in the hands of the podcast “Capital-
early 20th centuries, the fined an era of matter of just a few than half are still on the list of so few. isn’t,” said he sees the rise
richest men were industrial- physical infrastructure years. today…. The minority of the superbillionaire
ists: John D. Rockefeller and manufacturing. Through “We have had huge tech- of heirs and heiresses class as a symptom of
built Standard Oil into a Standard Oil, Rockefeller be- nological change the last 40 who remain on the The World’s Superbillionaires the failure of capital-
list today were three A ranking of those whose net worth is ism in the U.S.
times more likely to above $50 billion “A good capitalist
have fallen in the ESTIMATED system is a system
Forbes rankings than WORTH that doesn’t reward
NAME IN BILLIONS KEY BUSINESS
to have risen,” the re- exactly anybody too
port said. 1. Elon Musk $419.4 Tesla much, because it re-
Those shifts can be 2. Jeff Bezos $263.8 Amazon mains competitive,
traced to the 1980s and every new inno-
3. Bernard
and 90s. That’s due Arnault $238.9 LVMH vation is quickly cop-
to vast advancements ied,” he said.
in technology during 4. Larry Ellison $237 Oracle Zingales blamed the
that period and, with 5. Mark
$220.8 Meta U.S. legal system for
that, a rise in the Zuckerberg allowing tech compa-
globalized nature of 6. Sergey Brin $160.5 Alphabet nies to protect their
business. trade secrets and in-
7. Steven Ballmer $157.4 Microsoft
Nobel Prize-win- novations to the point
Above, Buffett paid $31,500 in 1958 to buy the Omaha, Neb., ning economist Jo- 8. Warren Buffett $154.2 Berkshire where competition is
Hathaway
house where he still lives. Right, Bloomberg has a Beaux-Arts seph Stiglitz, a pro- impossible. “I’m the
townhouse on New York’s Upper East Side. fessor at Columbia
9. James Walton $117.5 Walmart first one to say we
University, said he at- 10. Samuel
$114.4 Walmart need incentives for
tributes some of the Robson Walton people to innovate.
rise of the super 11. Amancio However, that some-
Ortega $113 Inditex
wealthy to the inabil- body is reaping such
ity of antitrust laws 12. Alice Walton $110.2 Walmart large rewards suggests
to contend with mo- that the incentives are
13. Jensen Huang $108.4 Nvidia
nopoly power in the too much that we
tech sector. 14. Bill Gates $106 Microsoft could have gotten the
“We have antitrust 15. Michael same outcome with
laws that were well Bloomberg $103.4 Bloomberg much less,” he said.
adapted to Standard 16. Larry Page $100.9 Alphabet Stiglitz also cau-
Oil but that don’t tioned that wealth in-
work well in the tech 17. Mukesh
$90.6 Reliance equality can eventu-
Ambani Industries
sphere,” he said. ally translate to
“Monopoly power has 18. Charles Koch $67.4 Koch political inequality,
given rise to the po- 19. Julia Koch $65.1 Koch which in turn com-
tential of enormous pounds wealth in-
20. Francoise
amounts of wealth.” Bettencourt $61.9 L’Oreal equality. “These guys
He also pointed to Meyers live in a totally dif-
how today’s superbill- Adani ferent world from or-
ionaires have become
21. Gautam Adani $60.6 Group dinary Americans. So
masters at tax avoid- 22. Michael Dell $59.8 Dell Tech. they don’t have to
ance and adept at deal with public
23. Zhong Nongfu
taking advantage of Shanshan $57.7 Spring schools, public hospi-
weaknesses in corpo- tals and they don’t
INTRODUCING AMARA. rate governance laws 24. Prajogo
$55.4 Barito rely on health insur-
Pangestu Pacific
to extract “obscene ance in the way that
amounts of money” in Source: Altrata , as of Feb. 4, 2025 ordinary Americans
salary and bonuses. do,” he said. “That
“These guys have, kind of deep divide is
both at the corporate polarizing and I think
level and at the indi- it undermines the
vidual level, been kind of solidarity
even better at avoid- that is important for
ing taxes than in the functioning of a
making good prod- society.”
ucts,” Stiglitz said. Where to next? It’s
“The level of taxes plausible that we
they pay as a share of could see the world’s
their profits should first trillionaire in the
be an embarrassment next few decades.
to them.” The 24 su- “One would probably
perbillionares de- have said no in the
clined to comment or past, but anything’s
FROM LEFT: MARIA JULIE BORER FOR WSJ; DANIELLA ZALCMAN FOR WSJ; KAGAN MCLEOD (ILLUSTRATIONS, 4)
didn’t respond to re- Clockwise from left: Zhong Shanshan, possible these days,”
quests for comment. Warren Buffett and Michael Bloomberg Imberg said.
Estimations of bil-
lionaire net worth are by
NOW A ND NEVE R AGAIN. nature an inexact science.
While it’s simple to calcu-
The Tech Execs
Step inside to bayfront residences unequaled in Sarasota, late the value of publicly
traded corporate stock, it’s
perhaps because they open to a panorama of the city’s entire much trickier to reach an
skyline. Here is a stage for expansive living — a breathtaking estimate of value for a pri-
esplanade, pool terrace, and even, a berth for your boat. vately held company. Im-
berg said Altrata’s findings
This is that once-and-forever moment. Reserve yours today. can vary from rankings in
Forbes and the Bloomberg
Billionaires’ Index because
of factors like methodology
and the daily fluctuations of
stock prices.
The explosion of billion-
CONDOMINIUM RESIDENCES FROM THE $4Ms
aire net worth comes at a
9 4 1 . 8 6 7. 7 1 6 0 | A M A R A S A R A S O TA . C O M time of growing economic
disparity in the U.S. In
Equal housing ORAL REPRESENTATIONS CANNOT BE RELIED UPON AS CORRECTLY STATING REPRESENTATIONS 2024, the top 1% of Ameri-
opportunity OF THE DEVELOPER. FOR CORRECT REPRESENTATIONS, MAKE REFERENCE TO THE DOCUMENTS
REQUIRED BY SECTION 718.503, FLORIDA STATUTES, TO BE FURNISHED BY A DEVELOPER TO A BUYER OR LESSEE. can households held $49.2 Clockwise from top left: Jensen Huang, Michael Dell, Mark
trillion in wealth, or about Zuckerberg, Sergey Brin, Larry Ellison, Elon Musk, Steve
30% of the country’s total Ballmer, Jeff Bezos, Larry Page and Bill Gates
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. NY Friday, February 28, 2025 | M9
MANSION
BY FRED A. BERNSTEIN INSIDE STORY
FROM TOP: LAURA PETRILLA FOR WSJ (2); CHRISTOPHER LITTLE/WESTERN PENNSYLVANIA CONSERVANCY
That’s about 40 times the cost of
building the house in the 1930s. $7 his disposal,” Gun-
ther says. “So I
Clearly, keeping Fallingwater MILLION wouldn’t say any-
dry—a process that could be thing was a mistake.
called stallingwater—is a chal- Instead, the house’s
lenge. During my visit, the house design presented in-
was enveloped in scaffolding, on Fallingwater. After delibera- Conservancy, which owns the herently challenging
which was going to allow workers tion, Gunther decided to cancel house, witnessed that fascination features to water-
to complete the waterproofing job the tours scheduled for March during another spate of repairs 25 proof, such as flag-
by April. Then, in early February, that were to include access to the years ago, which, not coinciden- stone terraces that
the scaffolding contractor, Brand- platforms—putting visitors in tally, was the last time I visited serve as roofs for
Safway Industries of Pittsburgh, hard hats farther out over the wa- the house, in a rural area about interior spaces be-
became concerned about the force terfall than any other members of 50 miles southeast of Pittsburgh. low.”
of the water hitting the base of the public, ever. According to Gunther, tickets to But Fallingwa-
the scaffolding, which is right in In December, before Fallingwa- the tours that included scaffold ter’s preservation
the path of the waterfall. ter closed for an annual 10-week access were selling quickly (at architect, Pamela
Work on that part of the scaf- winter break, some visitors were $89 per person) before he had to ing by the American Institute of Jerome, of New York’s Architec-
folding was halted while the com- disappointed to see the scaffold- change the agenda. Visitors will Architects in 1991, Fallingwater tural Preservation Studio, says
pany strengthened the structure. ing, which made the house almost still be able to see repair work in attracted more than 143,000 visi- that Wright could have called for
That, Gunther says, caused unex- unrecognizable. But others were progress throughout the house. tors in 2024, Gunther says. copper flashing where roofs or
pected delays. A spokesman for fascinated by the work in prog- Completed in 1937 and voted the It also attracts a lot of water. terraces intersect walls. The
BrandSafway declined to comment ress. The Western Pennsylvania country’s most significant build- Rain and melting snow have been Please turn to page M10
RESIDENCESLIDOKEY.COM
MANSION
Left, wooden platforms along the house’s south side will let workers repair
the cantilevered ‘shelf’ above. Enclosures, above, are heated to keep workers
comfortable and building materials at a constant temperature, at center.
ADVERTISEMENT
Property Portfolio
To Advertise: Visit WSJ.com/ classified, Email: [email protected] or Call: 800-845-9719
55+ LIVING IN 5 GREAT FLORIDA LOCATIONS LONGBOAT KEY, FLORIDA PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA
The Florida lifestyle of your dreams can be yours at Valencia, where Beautifully renovated Bay Isles Harbor - 5BR/6.5BA/6.556sf home Step into a world of resort-style living at Apex at Avenir by GL Homes,
gorgeous new homes, world-class amenities, and an exciting lifestyle await! on lush .6 acre waterfront estate lot. New dock and lift for 30ft boat and where everything you need is right outside your door and an impressive
Enjoy a magnificent clubhouse, resort-style pool, pickleball, and so much Bay Isles Beach Club membership included - Longboat Key Club golf/ Clubhouse is within walking distance. Live in a new home with peaceful
more. Luxury Club Villas and single-family homes include luxury standard tennis membership available. Contact Walter Group Real Estate for more surroundings away from the hustle and bustle, yet close enough to indulge
features. 5 amazing locations – Boynton Beach, Naples, Fort Myers, Port St. information. in world-class dining, shopping, and entertainment of Palm Beach Gardens
Lucie and Tampa. Experience the best today! Call or visit for more. and West Palm Beach just a short drive away.
Mid $300s - $2 million $7,995,000 WalterGroupRealEstate.com $900s - $1.7 million ApexAvenir.com
Walter Group Michael Saunders & Company, Broker
GL Homes Janet Walter GL HOMES
phone: 800.495.6406 phone: 941.232.2000 [email protected] phone: 800.526.5430
PRIVATE PROPERTIES
Waterfront Home
On Lake Tahoe
Aims for a Record
A waterfront Lake Tahoe home on it, she said. He renovated the
with its own small golf course roughly 900-square-foot house
could set a Nevada record. and converted it into a guest-
The roughly 5.5-acre Glenbrook house, then built the current four-
property is asking $65 million, bedroom main house, completing
making it the most expensive both projects in 1989. The roughly
home for sale on the lake. If it 8,200-square-foot, single-story
fetches its asking price, it would main house is designed so that
top the current state record, nearly every room has a lake
which was set by a $62 view, Rachelle said. The
million Lake Tahoe sale FOR SALE fireplaces are made of un-
in Incline Village last
year, according to Zillow. $65 cut stone and the main
living room has a 20-foot-
ADVERTISEMENT
Distinctive Properties
To advertise: email [email protected] or WSJ.com/classifieds
CALIFORNIA FLORIDA
BERKELEY • CA
DISTINCTIVE
816 ARLINGTON AVENUE
$14,995,000 C A L L F O R D E TA I L S $8,900,000
JUST SOLD
NOTABLE
COmmErCiALprOpErTiEs
every Wednesday
(800) 366-3975 | [email protected]
For more information visit: wsj.com/classifieds
© 2025 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.
All Rights Reserved.
© 2025 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
M12 | Friday, February 28, 2025 NY THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
MANSION
Overcoming Shyness
And Meeting the Queen
It wasn’t until her 30s that the ‘1923’ actress got over
her fear of performing in front of others
G
rowing up, I didn’t like to Russian nobility but relocated to
perform or be looked at. London with his family after the HELEN’S BAG
Attention brought on em- Russian Revolution of 1917. He
barrassment, and acting in school was a London cabbie and then a “1923”? In the “Yellow-
plays was about disappearing driving examiner. He was smart, stone” prequel, I play Cara
rather than standing out. I didn’t gentle and funny, and I don’t ever Dutton, the family matriarch
get over this completely until my recall him raising his voice. and an Irish immigrant.
30s. My mother, Kitty, was the
Into my teens, performing al- 13th of 14 kids in a working- Running lines? I
lowed me to be behind a fortress. class family. She was carry scripts every-
In character, I was able to trans- smart, though without where in my bag.
form into someone who was more much education, and she The supermarket
glamorous, more fascinating, was a brilliant seamstress. is a nice distrac-
more dramatic and especially She never neglected us, but tion while I learn
more articulate, since actors have I sensed she didn’t love be- them. I mumble away
the words of fine writers. ing a mother. like a mad person.
Now, of course, I realize that as I was the middle child. Kate is
an actor, you are actually being two years older, and Peter is three Queen Elizabeth? The only
yourself, with the freedom to years younger. Kate and I were time she mentioned “The
shape how you’re perceived as a brought up to be financially self- Queen” was when she invited
character. sufficient, without any pressure to me to tea in 2018 at the
marry. Royal Ascot racecourse. I was
When I was 6, I seated between a Sheikh and Helen Mirren at the Golden Globes in 2024. Far left, Mirren on the right
played the Virgin Mary Prince Philip. at age 6 with her father, Basil, and brother, Peter, in England in 1952.
in elementary school.
There were no lines, And? I was already a Dame I joined the Royal Shakespeare director Taylor Hackford, in Lake
FROM LEFT: HELEN MIRREN (FAMILY PHOTO); PARAMOUNT+; DAN DOPERALSKI/GETTY IMAGES
and it’s one of my fa- by then. She said to the Company, a huge deal. Tahoe, Nev. We moved into our
vorite roles to this day. Sheikh, “This is Dame Helen. That year, I was cast to co-star lovely Japanese contemporary
At 13, I auditioned She played me in the film.” He with James Mason in my first ma- home about five years ago. We
for the Royal Ballet looked utterly confused. jor British film, “Age of Consent.” also have homes in Italy’s Puglia
School, performing in There was a very tasteful nude region and in east London.
front of men for the scene. Mason’s character is an I still have my mother’s Singer
first time. The rejection artist who falls in love with me treadle sewing machine in Lon-
was mortifying. sionate about Shakespeare. and paints me on a sparsely popu- don. For me, it represents a gen-
At St Bernard’s Con- I was set on acting school, but lated island on Australia’s Great eration of British women who
My parents didn’t have much vent Grammar School, the princi- our local council didn’t offer arts Barrier Reef. Nude scenes are pro- were courageous and stoic. It’s a
money, but they weren’t in debt. pal, Mother Mary Mildred, gave me grants. I attended the New College foundly uncomfortable, especially symbol of survival.
Our first house was in Westcliff- profound advice: “Beware of fear.” I of Speech and Drama, a teachers at age 22. Mason was a gentle- —As told to Marc Myers
on-Sea, along England’s south- took it as “Be fearless,” but now I school, and continued with the man, and director Michael Powell
eastern coast. We didn’t have a think she meant fight off fear that National Youth Theatre. I put the made the scene feel natural. My Helen Mirren, 79, is an award-
fridge or central heating. When I causes you to make bad decisions teaching diploma in my closet and shyness was slipping away. winning English actress known for
was 9, we moved into a terraced or to take paths that paralyze you. never looked at it again. Probably my most visible her roles in the film “The Queen,”
Edwardian house in Leigh-on-Sea. My high school English teacher In 1965, I was cast as Cleopatra screen projects were TV’s “Prime Broadway’s “The Audience” and
It was a bit of a squish for five, urged me to apply to the National in Shakespeare’s “Antony and Suspect,” from 1991 to 2006, and TV’s “Prime Suspect” and “Eliza-
but it was a very happy home. Youth Theatre in London, and I Cleopatra.” It was a perfect role “The Queen” in 2006. beth I.” She stars in season 2 of
My father, Basil, was born into was accepted. By then, I was pas- to overcome my shyness. In 1968, Today, I live with my husband, “1923” on Paramount+.