A Study On The Impact of Education in The Tribal Sector of West Bengal and Its Contribution To Social Development
A Study On The Impact of Education in The Tribal Sector of West Bengal and Its Contribution To Social Development
3499-3511
http://ilkogretim-online.org
doi: 10.17051/ilkonline.2021.02.365
Dr. Kajol Kanti Ghosh Research Guide Department Of Education, University Teaching
Department, Seacom Skills University Birbhum, West Bengal, India.
Abstract
One of the most important components of any civilization, education is essential for the
growth of the individual. It serves as a tool for raising standards of living and achieving a
long, healthy life. Only 58.96% of Indian tribal people are literate, which is much less than
the country's total literacy rate. The focus of the current study was on West Bengal's need
for tribal development. West Bengal's overall literacy situation is unsatisfactory. Finding
out the changes in literacy and educational level of tribal pupils in various West Bengal
districts is the main goal of the research project. The harsh truth is that indigenous
students continue to lag behind in many areas and must overcome numerous obstacles,
despite numerous constitutional provisions and programmes for the trials. The ability to
learn is a key factor in changing the cultural norms and lifestyles of tribal pupils, as well
as their attitude and ability to become economically independent. It has been
acknowledged that education is a crucial component in tribal students' growth. This
essay's goal is to explore how education affects tribal communities and how it contributes
to the social development of tribal sector of West Bengal. The material used in the current
work was obtained exclusively from secondary sources, including the West Bengal and
India Censuses of 2001 and 2011, as well as other related academic studies. According to
the study's findings, education benefits tribal students.
1. Introduction
The Scheduled Tribes are given special status under the Indian Constitution (STs). The
STs make up around 8% of the Indian population and are once known as adivasis,
vanbasis, tribes, or tribals. There are around 573 Scheduled Tribes spread across the
nation, each of which speaks a unique language distinct from the one that is most often
used in the State in which they reside. In India, there are more than 270 of these languages
(Adhikari, 2021). There are approximately 67.8 million tribal people in India, according
3497 | Suvendu Sar A Study On The Impact Of Education In The Tribal Sector
Of West Bengal And Its Contribution To Social Development
to the 2001 census. Compared to other nation states in the world, India has the most tribal
inhabitants. Even though they are regarded as the country's original inhabitants, tribal
people lack access to basic necessities for daily existence. In addition to being socially,
economically, and educationally backward, they also experience widespread
discrimination. They have been taken advantage of in a number of ways, including forced
eviction from their homes and land alienation in the name of development. Tribal people
have always had a deep relationship with the forest or environment, and this relationship
is reflected in their culture, customs, and traditions as well as their way of life.
One of the fundamental prerequisites for creating men and establishing nations is
education. For the development of human resources, it is essential. Education transmits
information, abilities, and character. To meet the requirements of the Directive Principles
of State Policy, the governments of India began to rely more heavily on literacy initiatives
that emphasised the 3Rs (Reading, Writing, and Arithmetic) (al., 2021). The report makes
an effort to critically evaluate the statistics and state of education among Tribes
throughout India against the backdrop of the New Education Policy, which is likely to be
introduced soon. One of the main forces driving change in the direction of progress is
education. Literacy and educational attainment are strong indicators of social and
economic development among the backward groups, and education is in fact an input not
only for the economic development of Scheduled Tribes (ST), but also for the inner
strength of the tribal communities that helps them in meeting the new challenges of life.
Education is the cultural process that turns each newborn human infant into a
contributing adult in a particular human culture. Backwardness in education has a clear
gender component. High levels of structural inequality, based on the institutions of caste
and ethnicity, are a defining feature of Indian society. Despite making up a sizeable
portion of the country's population, India's tribal community is numerically a small
portion of the entire population. Tribal and indigenous people make up roughly 8.6% of
the nation's population in India and 5.50% of the population of West Bengal, respectively.
The Scheduled Tribes, often known as "Adivasis," refers to the indigenous occupants.
They were perpetually socially and geographically isolated for much of history (Calder,
2021). They were dispersed over numerous biological zones and belonged to multiple
races with varying cultural traits, varied languages, and varied religions. They have been
culturally impacted by the Sanskritization process, and other displacing factors have
made them a minority in society.
It is not advisable to study development in isolation. Development does not equate to the
rise of a small number of wealthy people. Development cannot occur, according to
Amartya Sen (1999), unless human capabilities are fully addressed and marginalised
people' plights are remedied. He actually emphasised the capabilities and human
freedoms, which can only be realised when the general public is assured of their right to
political freedom, access to economic possibilities, social opportunities, transparency,
3498 | Suvendu Sar A Study On The Impact Of Education In The Tribal Sector
Of West Bengal And Its Contribution To Social Development
and security. These circumstances are related even if they are distinct from one another
(Chandra Guru, 2020). Even though tribes are developing in India, the pace of growth has
been rather sluggish. It is still a truth that many indigenous women may have missed out
on educational chances at various points, and in order to empower them, various skill
training programmes must be created and implemented.
West Bengal, which is situated on the country's eastern side, has a border with
Bangladesh. The state extends latitudinally and longitudinally from 21°38′N to 27°10′N
and 58°50′E to 89°50′E. According to the 2011 census, West Bengal had 21463270 people
overall, making it the seventh most populous state in India. It also had the second-highest
population density with 1029 people per square kilometre. The state's Human
development index (HDI) is 0.492. (2008).
3499 | Suvendu Sar A Study On The Impact Of Education In The Tribal Sector
Of West Bengal And Its Contribution To Social Development
2. Literature Review
There is a lot of literature on tribal development and the rise of tribal education. Virginius
Xaxa (2015) asserts that other from providing the tribal people with safety nets, the
colonial state did little little to enhance their socioeconomic circumstances. He claims that
the same programme was maintained in post-independence India with only minor
changes, such as the allocation of a specific number of seats in state-sponsored
educational institutions and public agencies. These rules designated 7.5% of the positions
in the federal and state governments for tribe members (S.K., 2020). This has given them
access to a wide range of government services. Despite the fact that reservations offer
employment chances, many times the reserved seats go unfilled since the applicants
3500 | Suvendu Sar A Study On The Impact Of Education In The Tribal Sector
Of West Bengal And Its Contribution To Social Development
lacked the appropriate education and abilities. The situation is considerably worse when
there is a quota for higher grade services because there aren't any people that meet the
requirements.
According to Pradhan and Sanjay Kumar (2011), tribal people continue to lag behind non-
tribal people despite special programmes like Ashram schools, the introduction of
vernacular at the elementary level, and instruction in regional dialects. Government
officials and decision-makers ought to make every effort to raise their educational status
in such situations. The 2007 article by Arun Kumar Ghosh offers in-depth research on the
tribal education in West Bengal and Jharkhand. Few tribal people, according to him,
urgently require special attention for basic education and literacy. He talks about the
reasons why the tribal populations of "Ho" and "Mahali" in Jharkhand and "Lodha" in
West Bengal have low literacy rates. He notices that compared to their male counterparts,
these tribal enrollment rates for women are significantly lower. Following primary
education, a further steep fall in enrollment was seen, and this pattern persisted for both
males and females. Because youngsters must help their family members with planting,
weeding, plantation, and harvesting tasks, the dropout rate is higher during the
cultivation period (Prasasti, 2021). Another important reason why indigenous children
drop out of school is economic hardship. The author makes a number of
recommendations to achieve gender equity in education, including encouraging parents
to send their daughters to school, customising the curriculum to meet the requirements
of tribal children, and providing separate restrooms for girls.
2.1. Education
Education is concerned with how people live their lives. Its purpose is to raise people's
quality of life. Every hour of a person's life is spent learning something new. Every event,
no matter how minor, leaves its stamp on the individual. Learning is a continuous process
that involves being exposed to new information, concepts, and experiences both formally
and informally. Additionally, it involves the systematic formal transmission of
knowledge, skills, ideas, values, norms, and attitudes (Google, 2020).
The primary role of education has been to preserve and disseminate some of society's
cultural treasures. Education, according to Short (1971), is the guardian of a society's
identity. Only by making education accessible to every member of society has education
been able to fulfil its conservative role as the keeper of society's identity.
Education will improve one's chances of finding a better job and becoming a leader in
society's politics, all of which together will raise one's social standing and reputation. In
everyday situations, education takes on a powerful role by preparing people to handle
complex life tasks (Kalam, 2020). The distribution of the younger generation into diverse
roles is facilitated by the educational process and the numerous specialisations and
certification levels that go along with it. Greater social and occupational mobility as well
as a fundamental break with the status quo are the outcomes.
3501 | Suvendu Sar A Study On The Impact Of Education In The Tribal Sector
Of West Bengal And Its Contribution To Social Development
People think of education as a strong tool for establishing modern society. In other words,
the most significant tool for socioeconomic mobility in the modern world is education. It
is believed that education is a necessity for economic growth. According to the Norwegian
Ministry of Foreign Affairs (2003), education is a prerequisite for progress. Sen (1999)
described education as freedom. The ability of an individual to carry out a specific social
function is crucial for growth (Kennedy, 2020).
2.2. Tribe
Generally speaking, the word "tribe" conjures up images of primitivism, barbarism, and
wildness. However, this idea very recently came into existence. It has been utilised
politically since the emergence of colonialism. Knowing the fundamental characteristics
of the colonised population was one of colonialism's requirements so that local cultural
elements and sentiments could be either appropriately harmonised or eliminated as
needed during different periods of colonialism. Consequently, the phrase was found to be
beneficial not just among the recently discovered people in distant regions of America,
Africa, and Australia but also in the more developed regions of India, China, and the Arab
world (ing, 2021).
According to Verrier Elwin, the word "tribe" has a Latin basis, and the middle English
word "Tribuz," which referred to the three divisions that the early Romans were divided
into, eventually developed into the present English word "tribe." Similar to this, different
authors have used different nomenclature to define the tribes. They were renamed from
"Backward Hindus" by Ghurye to "Submerged Humanity" by Das and Das, while others
called them "Aboriginals," "Primitive Tribe," "Adivasi," "Vanyajati," "Vanabasi,"
"Adimjati," and "Pahari" (Tirpude College of Social Work, n.d.).
Tribe has undergone additional change in the years following independence. There is no
definition or criteria for the Scheduled Tribes in the Indian Constitution (for
Constitutional provisions for Scheduled Tribes see Appendix. 2). The Scheduled Tribes
are defined as "those tribes or tribal communities, or portions of or groups within such
tribes or tribal communities, as are deemed under Article 342(i) to be the Scheduled
Tribes for the purposes of this Constitution" in Article 366(25) of the Constitution (Lal,
2021). According to Article 342(i) of the Constitution, "The President may, after
consultation with the Governor of a State or that of a Union Territory, by public
notification, specify the Tribes or Tribal Communities or Parts of the Tribal Communities
or Parts which shall, for the purposes of this Constitution, be deemed as Scheduled Tribes
in relation to that State or Union Territory, as the case may be." While the Scheduled
Tribes are determined by the President pursuant to Article 342(i) of the Constitution
through a public notification, the Parliament may, by law, include or exclude any tribal
community in any state or union territory, or any portion thereof, from the list of
Scheduled Tribes.
3502 | Suvendu Sar A Study On The Impact Of Education In The Tribal Sector
Of West Bengal And Its Contribution To Social Development
From the literature that has been reviewed thus far, it can be inferred that although not
many, a sizable number of research have attempted to analyse the relationship between
social development and education. However, no study has yet attempted to evaluate the
role that education plays in the social development of West Bengal's tribal people. The
majority of works on tribal development have generalised the idea of scheduled tribes as
one single homogenous group, adding further complexity to the research area, it is crucial
to highlight after carefully examining the works of the famous scholars on the subject.
Despite the fact that tribal communities are diverse and do not belong to a single
homogenous group, the majority of published works tend to concentrate on tribal
communities as a whole (Radhakrishnan, 2020). Due to the lack of relevant study on
tribal people, this research endeavour attempts to take a thorough look at the problem
and come up with workable solutions to the current gaps. There is a large research
vacuum that needs to be addressed with the aid of our proposed research because there
is a severe lack of concrete literature on the tribal sector of West Bengal.
When it comes to their accomplishments in the areas of economy and education, the
scheduled tribe population as a whole is still far behind the non-scheduled population.
Throughout the entire plan period, many measures have been adopted to close gaps and
speed up development, particularly among the Scheduled Tribes. However, there hasn't
been much progress toward improving "quality of life." An integrated strategy is
necessary for a thorough comprehension of the issues pertaining to tribal development
(Sachidananda, 2020). The current study primarily examines the effects of education in
West Bengal's tribal community as well as the habitat and socioeconomic advancement
of the state's Scheduled Tribe population during the course of the Plan.
Essentially, this is a descriptive or analytical essay. The data was gathered from a variety
of books, scholarly articles, newspapers, journals, and trustworthy websites. The
theoretical study has been supported by a few maps, illustrations, and graphs. The
secondary data sources on which this essay is based. Past field studies, pertinent books,
journals, census data, and reports make up the secondary sources. A random sampling
approach is used to acquire data from the respondents. The sample size is 200 in this
study.
3503 | Suvendu Sar A Study On The Impact Of Education In The Tribal Sector
Of West Bengal And Its Contribution To Social Development
3.1. Hypothesis
In a research process, the choice and preparation of instruments and technologies for
data collecting is crucial. The effectiveness and applicability of a research tool may have
a significant impact on the study's conclusion. The researcher employed a variety of
instruments to get information from the respondents in order to achieve each objective,
including questionnaires, schedules for statements of opinion, and organised interview
schedules (Shukla, 2020). By consulting the specialists, the content validity of the tools
that had been produced was guaranteed. The English version is appended to the Bengali-
prepared tools. The qualitative method was used for the current investigation. The data
have been analysed using SPSS 25.0.
The researcher used a variety of approaches and procedures to investigate the study's
stated aims and collect relevant data from the chosen sample. Any research study's
methodology heavily relies on the appropriateness and viability of the data collection
techniques. The researcher cannot properly and honestly conduct his investigation
without choosing and using the right and effective procedures and approaches. The
following methods of gathering data were used: questionnaires, a list of opinion
statements, structured and unstructured interviews, participant observation, and
document analysis.
The random sampling method has been applied. The randomization of test results is
taken into consideration by the random sampling technique, which means that each
example has a similar possibility of being chosen to represent the entire population. It is
seen as one of the most notable and direct data grouping procedures in research fields
3504 | Suvendu Sar A Study On The Impact Of Education In The Tribal Sector
Of West Bengal And Its Contribution To Social Development
(probability and experiences, math, etc.). It thinks about reasonable data combination,
which permits studies to reach honest outcome.
4. Data Analysis
This research is qualitative in nature. As a result, the study combined qualitative research
techniques with simple statistical techniques like percentage analysis to explain and
analyse the data and to substantiate the claims. The required data is used to offer
descriptive information. To evaluate and analyse the data, descriptive statistics are also
used.
Describing or summarizing features from a group of data with a descriptive stat is called
descriptive statistics. The process of using and analyzing these stats is called descriptive
statistics.
Table 1 demonstrates that for our investigation, the variations in education and social
development are statistically significant. Education has a greater mean value than social
development.
3505 | Suvendu Sar A Study On The Impact Of Education In The Tribal Sector
Of West Bengal And Its Contribution To Social Development
Education
N
Mean
Std. Deviation
Social Development
N
Mean
Std. Deviation
Correlations
Education Social
Development
3506 | Suvendu Sar A Study On The Impact Of Education In The Tribal Sector
Of West Bengal And Its Contribution To Social Development
N 200 200
Social Correlation .142* 1.000
Development Coefficient
Sig. (2-tailed) 0.01 0.02
N 200 200
*Correlation is significant at the 0.05 level (2-tailed).
According to above Table 2, it is clear that there is only a weak correlation between
education and social development (r=.142).
70
60
PERSONS (%)
50
40
30 India
20 West Bengal
10
0
1961 1971 1981 1991 2001 2011 2021
YEAR
According to secondary data shown in Table 3, the literacy rate among tribal people is
rising.
The percentage of literate people was 7.59 in 1961. In 2021, it rises to 64.78 percent. It
increased to 62.48 percent in West Bengal from 05.69 percent. In contrast to non-tribal
people, the tribal population has a lower literacy rate, but there are many reasons for this,
the three most significant of which are: I the lack of a school in the area; (ii) the poor
economic situation, which can make some tribal members apathetic toward pursuing an
3507 | Suvendu Sar A Study On The Impact Of Education In The Tribal Sector
Of West Bengal And Its Contribution To Social Development
education; and (iii) the importance of the curriculum and the mode of instruction in
discouraging tribal members from pursuing an education.
The primary barrier to the advancement of the tribal peoples is a lack of awareness
brought on by educational illiteracy. According to our analysis, there is a statistically
significant relationship between education and social development. Thus, the hypothesis
H1 is accepted and the H2 is rejected. The literacy rate among tribal people is also rising
steadily, but it is relatively lower than India among the Scheduled Tribes of West Bengal
(Som, 2020).
6. Conclusion
3508 | Suvendu Sar A Study On The Impact Of Education In The Tribal Sector
Of West Bengal And Its Contribution To Social Development
According to the current study, education is the first requirement for any kind of
progress. The study examined the relationship between education and the development
of tribal people. It was named "a study on the influence of education in the tribal sector
of West Bengal and its contribution to social development." It was an endeavour to
research the educational situation and development barriers facing tribal people in
general. In the study, distinctive problems that prevented the proliferation of education
among them were analysed along with the relationship between education and the social
development of tribal communities. The report provided a critical analysis of government
involvement in tribal development, notably in the area of education (Vimala, 2020).
Among other things, education policy reform is crucial for the socioeconomic
advancement and self-determination of tribal people. The study supports the notion that
education is a crucial precondition for growth and unquestionably indicated that
education has a key role in the development of tribal peoples, especially marginalised
groups in society. The study also identified a number of variables that are the
fundamental roadblocks to the growth of indigenous communities' educational uplift.
There have been several studies from all over the world on tribal development, social
structure, children's educational levels, and other topics, but none have particularly
looked at the impact of education on the life skills of tribal students in West Bengal. Even
in 2021, West Bengal's literacy situation is unsatisfactory. The largest obstacle to the
sustainable development of tribal communities is their under awareness of the policies
and programmes that have been created for them. Raising tribal literacy rates is the only
way to strengthen these programmes (Werfhorst, 2021). We have hope for the future
since the progress made over the past ten years has been positive, and most importantly,
the literacy gaps between males and females and rural and urban areas are expected to
close. By encouraging them and offering incentives for setting up an educational system,
we can improve the quality of life for tribal people.
7. References
3510 | Suvendu Sar A Study On The Impact Of Education In The Tribal Sector
Of West Bengal And Its Contribution To Social Development
21. Som, Kalyan Sundar and Mishra, R.P. (2020), “Literacy and Their Differential in
West Bengal” International Journal of Science and Research, Volume 3, Issue 6, pp.
1537-1545.
22. Vimala, R., Mehrotra, R. & Jandhyala, K. (2020). Incentives in elementary
education. Do they make a difference? Journal of Education Planning and
Administration, 11(2), 141-153.
23. Werfhorst, Herman G Van De., & Luijkx, Ruud. (2021). Educational field of study
and social mobility: Disaggregating social origin and education. Sociology, 44, 695-
715.
24. Xaxa, Virginius. 2020. ‘Labour market and Adivasis: An Overview’, S.R.Sankaran
Chair, Conference series, NIRD, Hyderabad: 6-22.
25. Yadav. M. S. (2020). The education commission’s perspectives on society,
education and development. In Ved Prakash, & K. Biswal (Eds.), Perspectives on
education and development – Revisiting education commission and after. New
Delhi: Shipra Publications.
*******
3511 | Suvendu Sar A Study On The Impact Of Education In The Tribal Sector
Of West Bengal And Its Contribution To Social Development