Tensile, Thermal, Flammability and Morphological Properties of Sepiolite Filled Ethylene Propylene Diene Monomer (EDPM) Rubber Composites
Tensile, Thermal, Flammability and Morphological Properties of Sepiolite Filled Ethylene Propylene Diene Monomer (EDPM) Rubber Composites
https://doi.org/10.1007/s13726-018-0609-6
ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Received: 22 August 2017 / Accepted: 20 January 2018 / Published online: 20 March 2018
© Iran Polymer and Petrochemical Institute 2018
Abstract
The effect of sepiolite loading content on the curing characteristics, tensile mechanical, thermal, swelling, flammability and
morphological properties of sepiolite-filled ethylene propylene diene monomer (EPDM) composites was investigated. The
composites were prepared with sepiolite loadings of 0–70 part per hundred (phr) of rubber using a two-roll mill. The results
highlighted the improvement in the tensile properties and cross-link density values peaked at 60 phr of sepiolite loading.
The scorch time, curing time, swelling percentage, and linear burning rate of the composites decreased with an increase in
sepiolite loading. Thermogravimetric analysis showed an increasing trend with increase in sepiolite loading. The tempera-
tures corresponding to 5, 25 and 50% weight loss (T5wt%, T25wt% and T50wt%) and the percentage of char residue gradually
increased with increase in sepiolite loading. The homogenous dispersion of the sepiolite particles in the EPDM matrix and
the formation of zigzag structures, especially at 60 phr, were the main reasons of the improvement of mechanical properties
which were confirmed by the morphological studies. The formation of a protective layer, which acted as a barrier against
heat transfer into the deeper layers, enhanced the flammability resistance of the composites. Notably, the EPDM filled with
60 phr sepiolite exhibited excellent performance in the aspects of mechanical, thermal stability and flammability properties
and resistance towards swelling.
Keywords Sepiolite · Cure characteristics · Tensile properties · Swelling behaviour · Thermal stability · Flammability
13
Vol.:(0123456789)
288 Iranian Polymer Journal (2018) 27:287–296
nanosized tunnel structures [14, 15]. The fibrous-like struc- Table 1 Elemental Analyte Amount (wt %)
ture of sepiolite is dispersed into the polymer matrix easier compositions of sepiolite
obtained by XRF CaO 47.49
than platelet-like minerals such as MMT [16]. Moreover,
sepiolite can prevent flocculation when it is distributed SiO2 41.53
within the network of a polymer, which would reduce MgO 10.09
filler agglomeration [11] and result in higher mechanical K 2O 0.25
reinforcement. Interestingly, sepiolite has the potential to Fe2O3 0.19
strengthen the fire retardant properties, since it can form a Al2O3 0.18
char layer at the silicate surface. It can act as a barrier that Na2O 0.11
lessens the oxygen transmission rate, impedes flame spread SrO 0.09
and keeps the structural integrity of the burnt samples [17, NiO 0.03
18]. With promising characteristics, sepiolite becomes a ZrO2 0.02
potential filler to improve the properties of polymer com- CuO 0.02
posites such as mechanical, thermal and flame retardancy
properties. Sepiolite clay has an interesting mechanical rein-
forcing capability in various polymeric matrices [19–21]. Table 2 Compounding formulations for EPDM/sepiolite composites
However, little research has paid attention to the applicabil- (phr)
ity of sepiolite as a reinforcing filler in EPDM. Materials Content (phr)
EPDM is a synthetic elastomer which can be used as
EPDM 100
electrical insulating materials, building profiles, electrical
Zinc oxide 5
sheathings, roofing materials, cover stripes and cables [22].
Stearic acid 1.5
Wang et al. [23] conducted a preliminary study on surface
TMTDa 1.5
free energy and tensile properties of EPDM filled with a
MBTb 0.8
fixed amount of sepiolite treated with various coupling
Sulphur 1.5
agents. They observed a good dispersion of the sepiolite
Sepiolite 0, 4, 10, 20, 30, 60, 70
with the presence of coupling agent that improved the ten-
sile properties of the composites. However, the researchers a
Tetramethyl thiuram disulphide
focused on a limited number of properties (i.e. tensile prop- b
Mercaptobenzothiazole
erties and surface energy) of the EPDM/sepiolite compos-
ites. In response to this issue, additional studies are needed
to generate positive outcomes from the various properties of sepiolite clay was obtained from Hebei DFL Minmet Refrac-
the sepiolite-filled EPDM composites. tories Corp., China.
In this study, the potential of sepiolite as a filler in EPDM Table 1 shows the elemental compositions of sepiolite
was studied based on the cure characteristics, mechanical, clay obtained using an X-ray fluorescence (XRF) spectrom-
swelling, thermal and flammability properties of EPDM/ eter (RIX 3000, Rigaku Industrial Corp., Osaka, Japan).
sepiolite composites at various sepiolite loadings that to the The sepiolite was pre-dried in an oven at 80 °C for 24 h
best of our knowledge [24] has not been reported before. before density measurement which was developed using a
The morphology of the tensile fracture surface and the char gas pycnometer (AccuPyc II 1330, Micromeritics Instru-
residue of the composites was examined to associate with ment Corp., USA). The density of sepiolite was found to be
their tensile and flammability properties. 2.9461 g/cm3. This material had an average particle size of
4.08 µm, obtained using a particle size analyser (Sympatec
GmbH, Clausthal-Zellerfeld, Germany). Other compound-
Experimental ing ingredients, such as zinc oxide, stearic acid, tetramethyl
thiuram disulphide (TMTD), mercaptobenzothiazole (MBT)
Materials and sulphur, were purchased from Bayer (M) Ltd.
EPDM in the form of Vistalon 2504N was used in this Sample preparation
research and purchased from Exxon Mobil Chemical. It con-
tained 54% ethylene with 3.6% of ethylidene norbornene Just prior to preparation of compounds, any existing mois-
(ENB) and Mooney viscosity [ML (1 + 4) at 125 °C]of 26.8 ture was removed by placing the sepiolite in an oven for
(Mooney Unit). The density of the EPDM was 0.818 g/ 24 h at 80 °C. Table 2 illustrates the compounding for-
cm3 measured using an analytical weighing balance (XB mulations for EPDM/sepiolite composites prepared on a
220A, Precisa Gravimetrics Ag, Dietikon, Switzerland). The two-roll mill (XK-160, Shanghai Rubber Machine Works,
13
Iranian Polymer Journal (2018) 27:287–296 289
Shanghai, China). All composites were mixed for 21 min calculated based on Eq. (3) where δs, δr, R and T are the
according to ASTM D3568. Utilizing a moving die rheom- solubility parameters of the solvent and rubber network, the
eter (MDR2000, Alpha Technologies, Ohio, USA) at universal gas constant (8.314 J/mol K) and absolute tem-
160 °C, the optimum cure time (t90) and scorch time (ts2) perature, respectively. The χ value of 0.49 was obtained
were obtained according to ASTM D2240. Based on their using Eq. (3):
respective t90 values, the compounds were moulded into
(3)
( )
𝜒 = 𝛿s − 𝛿r V0 ∕RT.
2 or 3 mm rectangular sheets with a dimension of either
150 mm × 122 mm × 2 mm or 145 mm × 110 mm × 3 mm The degree of cross-link density (V) is given by Eq. (4):
using an electrically heated hydraulic press (GT-7014-A30C, 1
GoTech Testing Machine Inc., Taichung City, Taiwan) at V=
2Mc
. (4)
160 °C with a pressure of 10 MPa.
Thermal analysis
Tensile properties
Thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) using an analyser
To prepare the dumbbell shaped specimens, 2 mm compres- (Pyris™ 6 TGA, Perkin Elmer, USA) was performed on
sion moulded sheets were punched after storing in a desicca- 10 mg samples that were heated from 30 to 600 °C at 20 °C/
tor for 24 h. According to ASTM D412, a universal testing min under nitrogen flow (50 mL/min). TGA measured the
machine (Instron 3366, Instron, Singapore) was adopted to weight loss as a function of temperature.
measure the tensile strength, elongation at break and tensile
stress at 100% elongation. The measurements were con- Flammability test
ducted at a crosshead speed of 500 m/min with 10 kN load.
According to ASTM D635, the horizontal burning test was
Swelling behaviour performed to test the flammability. The samples were cut
into a dimension of 125 mm × 13 mm × 3 mm. The flame
Swelling tests for the EPDM/sepiolite composites were was ignited at one end of the sample using natural gas. The
performed in toluene according to ASTM D471-12a. An burnt length and time for the flame front to reach the 25 mm
electrical balance was used to weigh the vulcanized samples reference mark and travel to the 100 mm reference mark
after they were cut into 30 mm × 5 mm × 2 mm strips. The were noted. Equation (5) was used to calculate the linear
compounds took 72 h to achieve swelling equilibrium. The burning rates of the burnt samples, where V denotes the lin-
three samples for each compound were immersed in toluene. ear burning rate, L is the burnt length and t denotes the time
Once the samples reached the swelling equilibrium, they in minutes [26]:
were wiped, weighed and recorded after removing from the V = 60L∕t. (5)
liquid. The formula to determine the swelling ratio is accord-
ing to Eq. (1): Morphological study
13
290 Iranian Polymer Journal (2018) 27:287–296
Fig. 2 Variation of MH of EPDM/sepioite composites as a function Fig. 3 Effects of sepiolite loading on scorch time and cure time of
of sepiolite loading EPDM/sepiolite composites
13
Iranian Polymer Journal (2018) 27:287–296 291
strength slightly declines at 70 phr of sepiolite, even though solvent penetration into the composites, which was related
it is higher than that of unfilled EPDM composite. When to a lower cross-link density. Figure 6 demonstrates that the
the loading of filler is more than 60 phr, the filler–filler swelling percentage of sepiolite-filled EPDM composites
interactions become stronger than the rubber–filler inter- decreases with an increase of filler content up to 60 phr.
action. Therefore, a slight reduction in tensile strength is The penetration of toluene into the sepiolite/EPDM network
observed. This observation can confirm by Payne effect (log is restricted by the cross-links through reducing the solvent
G′ − strain %) [32, 33]. diffusion path that, in turn, precludes further swelling of the
Figure 4 also displays the elongation at break of EPDM/ sepiolite/EPDM composites. Nevertheless, the swelling level
sepiolite composites, which follows a trend similar to that for increases when the sepiolite loading reaches 70 phr due to a
tensile strength. With sepiolite up to 60 phr, the good adhe- poor dispersion of sepiolite at high filler loading that causes
sion among well-dispersed sepiolite particles enables the inadequate wetting of sepiolite by EPDM. Subsequently, it
EPDM matrix distributes the force evenly to the filler and increases the solvent diffusion path that enables direct diffu-
reduces the potential for propagation of crack. This enhances sion of solvent. Hence, both higher swelling percentage and
the elastic properties of the composite to gain a higher strain lower swelling resistance take place concurrently.
tolerance. In elastomer composites, the agglomeration of The Flory–Rehner equation is applicable to determine the
filler particles decreases the elongation at break to limit the number of cross-link points per unit volume [25]. Figure 6
movement of the rubber chain in the presence of stress. Con- also demonstrates that the cross-link density is inversely pro-
sequently, it caused a slight reduction of elongation at break portional to the swelling percentage. At 60 phr filler load-
at 70 phr. A similar finding was also reported by Ismail et al. ing, the efficient distribution and good interaction between
[34], stating that the incorporation of clay into the EPDM sepiolite and EPDM matrix could produce more cross-links.
matrix increased the elongation at break of the composites
up to an optimum loading.
Figure 5 presents the tensile modulus of EPDM/sepiolite
composites. The results show that the modulus of the com-
posites increases when the sepiolite loading increases up to
the optimum loading of 60 phr. This means that the filler can
influence the stiffness of the composites [35] at higher load-
ing levels. However, the modulus decreases gradually when
the sepiolite loading reaches 70 phr. This may be due to
excess sepiolite which tends to form agglomerates, which are
able to slip and therefore cause lubrication effect upon shear.
Swelling behaviour
13
292 Iranian Polymer Journal (2018) 27:287–296
Table 3 TGA results of unfilled Sepiolite Temp at 5% wt Temp at 25% wt Temp at 50% wt Max wt loss (%) Char residue
EPDM and sepiolite-filled content (phr) loss, T5 (°C) loss, T25 (°C) loss, T50 (°C) at 600 °C (%)
EPDM composites
0 432 477 489 56.4 5.7
4 434 478 491 54.8 8.2
10 438 478 491 52.3 13.2
20 440 479 492 44.1 20.2
30 446 481 494 42.3 25.4
60 449 483 498 38.6 37.9
70 458 485 500 34.5 41.9
13
Iranian Polymer Journal (2018) 27:287–296 293
Fig. 8 Tensile fracture surfaces of the EPDM/sepiolite composites with sepiolite loadings of a 0 phr, b 10 phr, c 20 phr, d 60 phr, and e 70 phr at
2000× magnification
13
294 Iranian Polymer Journal (2018) 27:287–296
Fig. 10 Charred surfaces of EPDM/sepiolite composites with sepiolite loadings of a 30 phr, b 60 phr, and c 70 phr at 1000× magnification
13
Iranian Polymer Journal (2018) 27:287–296 295
loading. The flammability resistance of the composites 13. Tartaglione G, Tabuani D, Camino G, Moisio M (2008) PP and
improved due to the formation of protective barrier layers PBT composites filled with sepiolite: morphology and thermal
behaviour. Compos Sci Technol 68:451–460
demonstrated by lower linear burning rate of composite 14. Kotal M, Bhowmick AK (2015) Polymer nanocomposites from
samples. The EPDM composites containing 60 phr sepio- modified clays: recent advances and challenges. Prog Polym Sci
lite demonstrated the best performance of tensile proper- 51:127–187
ties (i.e. strength, elongation-at-break, modulus), swell- 15. Chen H, Lu H, Zhou Y, Zheng M, Ke C, Zeng D (2012) Study
on thermal properties of polyurethane nanocomposites based on
ing, thermal stability and flame resistance, which are key organo-sepiolite. Polym Degrad Stab 97:242–247
characteristics for use of EPDM as insulating materials in 16. Bilotti E, Zhang R, Deng H, Quero F, Fischer HR, Peijs T (2009)
the construction and transport sectors. Sepiolite needle-like clay for PA6 nanocomposites: an alternative
to layered silicates? Compos Sci Technol 69:2587–2595
Acknowledgements The authors would like to thank all levels of 17. Darder M, Matos CRS, Aranda P, Gouveia RF, Ruiz-Hitzky
staff in the Department of Materials and Mineral Resources Engineer- E (2016) Bionanocomposite foams based on the assembly of
ing, Universiti Sains Malaysia (USM). They provided a wide variety starch and alginate with sepiolite fibrous clay. Carbohydr Polym
of unconditional facilities to make this research success. One of the 157:1933–1939
authors is also deeply indebted to the Ministry of Higher Education 18. Hapuarachchi TD, Peijs T (2010) Multiwalled carbon nanotubes
of Malaysia (KPT(BS)821115065540) and Universiti Teknologi Mara and sepiolite nanoclays as flame retardants for polylactide and its
(UiTM) (600-BPD (PKH.1/2/9946) for providing funding to conduct natural fibre reinforced composites. Compos A 41:954–963
this research. 19. Lowe DJ, Chapman AV, Cook S, Busfield JJC (2011) Natural
rubber nanocomposites by in situ modification of clay. Macromol
Mater Eng 296:693–702
20. Bidsorkhi HC, Soheilmoghaddam M, Heidar Pour R, Adelnia H,
Mohamad Z (2014) Mechanical, thermal and flammability prop-
References erties of ethylene-vinyl acetate (EVA)/sepiolite nanocomposites.
Polym Test 37:117–122
1. Rattanasom N, Saowapark T, Deeprasertkul C (2007) Reinforce- 21. Takei T, Oda R, Miura A, Kumada N, Kinomura N, Ohki R,
ment of natural rubber with silica/carbon black hybrid filler. Koshiyama H (2013) Effect of dispersion of sepiolite in sepi-
Polym Test 26:369–377 olite-NBR composite on the tensile strength. Compos Part B
2. Razzaghi-Kashani M, Hasankhani H, Kokabi M (2007) Improve- 44:260–265
ment in physical and mechanical properties of butyl rubber with 22. Shokrzadeh A, Naderi G, Esmizadeh E (2014) Mechanical and
montmorillonite organo-clay. Iran Polym J 16:671–679 rheological properties of calcium carbonate-filled ethylene pro-
3. Datta J, Kosiorek P, Wloch M (2016) Effect of high loading of pylene diene elastomer reinforced by metallic acrylate salt. Fibers
titanium dioxide particles on the morphology, mechanical and Polym 15:1694–1700
thermo-mechanical properties of the natural rubber-based com- 23. Wang F, Tang QG, Chen C, Chen YL, Liu HM, Liu HF (2013)
posites. Iran Polym J 25:1021–1035 Effect of sepiolite nanofibers on properties of EPDM nanocom-
4. Rooj S, Das A, Heinrich G (2011) Tube-like natural halloysite/ posites. Appl Mech Mater 320:595–598
fluoroelastomer nanocomposites with simultaneous enhanced 24. Mohd Zaini NA, Ismail H, Rusli A (2017) Short review on sepi-
mechanical, dynamic mechanical and thermal properties. Eur olite-filled polymer nanocomposites. Polym Plast Technol Eng
Polym J 47:1746–1755 56:1665–1679
5. Praveen S, Chattopadhyay PK, Albert P, Dalvi VG, Chakraborty 25. Flory PJ, Rehner J (1943) Statistical mechanics of cross-linked
BC, Chattopadhyay S (2009) Synergistic effect of carbon black polymer networks II. swelling. J Chem Phys 11:521
and nanoclay fillers in styrene butadiene rubber matrix: develop- 26. America Society for Testing and Materials: ASTM D635-14.
ment of dual structure. Compos A 40:309–316 Standard test method for rate of burning and/or extent and time
6. Pavlidou S, Papaspyrides CD (2008) A review on polymer-layered of burning of plastics in horizontal position
silicate nanocomposites. Prog Polym Sci 33:1119–1198 27. Chikh A, Benhamida A, Kaci M, Pillin I, Bruzaud S (2016) Syn-
7. Nguyen QT, Baird DG (2006) Preparation of polymer–clay nano- ergistic effect of compatibilizer and sepiolite on the morphology
composites and their properties. Adv Polym Technol 25:270–285 of poly(3-hydroxybutyrate-co-3-hydroxyvalerate)/poly(butylene
8. Pojanavaraphan T, Schiraldi DA, Magaraphan R (2010) Mechani- succinate) blends. Polym Test 53:19–28
cal, rheological, and swelling behavior of natural rubber/mont- 28. Suárez M, García-Romero E (2012) Variability of the surface
morillonite aerogels prepared by freeze-drying. Appl Clay Sci properties of sepiolite. Appl Clay Sci 67–68:72–82
50:271–279 29. Malas A, Das CK (2011) Carbon black–clay hybrid nanocompos-
9. Razavi-Nouri M, Karami M, Naderi G (2017) Rheological ites based upon EPDM elastomer. J Mater Sci 47:2016–2024
behavior and morphology of acrylonitrile-butadiene rubber/ 30. Teh PL, Ishak ZAM, Hashim AS, Karger-Kocsis J, Ishiaku US
poly(ethylene-co-vinyl acetate) blends filled by various organo- (2004) Effects of epoxidized natural rubber as a compatibilizer
clay contents. Appl Clay Sci 145:1–10 in melt compounded natural rubber-organoclay nanocomposites.
10. Chivrac F, Pollet E, Schmutz M, Avérous L (2010) Starch nano- Eur Polym J 40:2513–2521
biocomposites based on needle-like sepiolite clays. Carbohydr 31. Khimi SR, Pickering KL (2014) A new method to predict opti-
Polym 80:145–153 mum cure time of rubber compound using dynamic mechanical
11. Olivato JB, Marini J, Yamashita F, Pollet E, Grossmann MVE, analysis. J Appl Polym Sci 131:1–6
Avérous L (2017) Sepiolite as a promising nanoclay for nano- 32. Fröhlich J, Niedermeier W, Luginsland HD (2005) The effect of
biocomposites based on starch and biodegradable polyester. Mater filler-filler and filler-elastomer interaction on rubber reinforce-
Sci Eng C 70:296–302 ment. Compos A 36:449–460
12. Zotti A, Borriello A, Ricciardi M, Antonucci V, Giordano M, 33. Kamal MM, Clarke J, Ahmad A (2009) Comparison of properties
Zarrelli M (2015) Effects of sepiolite clay on degradation and fire of natural rubber compounds with various fillers. J Rubber Res
behaviour of a bisphenol A-based epoxy. Compos B 73:139–148 12:27–44
13
296 Iranian Polymer Journal (2018) 27:287–296
34. Nabil H, Ismail H, Azura AR (2013) Compounding, mechanical 38. Chen H, Zheng M, Sun H, Jia Q (2007) Characterization and
and morphological properties of carbon-black-filled natural rub- properties of sepiolite/polyurethane nanocomposites. Mater Sci
ber/recycled ethylene-propylene-diene-monomer (NR/R-EPDM) Eng A 445–446:725–730
blends. Polym Test 32:385–393 39. Khobragade PS, Hansora DP, Naik JB, Chatterjee A (2016) Flame
35. Sombatsompop N, Kumnuantip C (2003) Rheology, cure char- retarding performance of elastomeric nanocomposites: a review.
acteristics, physical and mechanical properties of tire tread Polym Degrad Stab 130:194–244
reclaimed rubber/natural rubber compounds. J Appl Polym Sci 40. Gong J, Tian N, Wen X, Chen X, Liu J, Jiang Z, Mijowska E,
87:1723–1731 Tang T (2014) Synergistic effect of fumed silica with N
i2O3 on
36. Bidsorkhi HC, Adelnia H, Naderi N, Moazeni N, Mohamad Z improving flame retardancy of poly(lactic acid). Polym Degrad
(2017) Ethylene vinyl acetate copolymer nanocomposites based Stab 104:18–27
on (un)modified sepiolite: flame retardancy, thermal, and mechan- 41. Dittrich B, Wartig KA, Hofmann D, Mülhaupt R, Schartel B
ical properties. Polym Compos 38:1302–1310 (2013) Flame retardancy through carbon nanomaterials: car-
37. Roy N, Bhowmick AK (2010) Novel in situ polydimethylsiloxane- bon black, multiwall nanotubes, expanded graphite, multi-layer
sepiolite nanocomposites: structure-property relationship. Poly- graphene and graphene in polypropylene. Polym Degrad Stab
mer 51:5172–5185 98:1495–1505
13