Copy of TAP - Terminalia Catappa (Talisay) and Pandan Leaves As Dishwashing Liquid 2
Copy of TAP - Terminalia Catappa (Talisay) and Pandan Leaves As Dishwashing Liquid 2
___________________________________________________________________________
Submitted to
Bocaue, Bulacan
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
Submitted by:
Barrios, Aldrin G.
___________________________________________________________________________
1
This capstone research project entitled “ TAP: Terminalia Catappa (Talisay) and Pandan
Leaves as Dishwashing Liquid” using Talisay Leaves and Pandan Leaves is presented and
submitted by Mr. Aldrin Barrios, Mr. Yiel Dela Cruz, Ms. Edzy Morales, Mr. Kyle Pingol and
Ms. Marsha Ramos, in partial fulfillment for the requirements for the Academic Track: Science,
___________________________________
RESEARCH ADVISER
___________________________________
DATE SIGNED
___________________________________
CLASS ADVISER
___________________________________
DATE SIGNED
2
Accepted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the Academic Strand Science, Technology,
___________________________________
SCHOOL PRINCIPAL
___________________________________
DATE SIGNED
___________________________________
ASSISTANT PRINCIPAL
___________________________________
DATE SIGNED
3
Permission is given to the following people to have access to this research paper.
_________________________________
_________________________________
_________________________________
_________________________________
_________________________________
4
Abstract
This study aimed to develop an eco-friendly dishwashing liquid using Talisay leaf
extract and pandan leaves, offering a plant-based alternative to conventional dishwashing liquids.
The formula was tested for grease removal, foaming, odor elimination, rinsing ease, and user
effectiveness, our goal was to provide a more affordable, environmentally friendly option.
Although Talisay leaves are known for their antibacterial properties, this study did not test for
antibacterial activity, nor did it include commercial skin compatibility tests. A comparison with
Brand X showed similar cleaning efficiency, but with a lower environmental impact. These
findings suggest that Talisay leaf extract could be a viable ingredient for biodegradable
5
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
The researcher would like to express sincere gratitude to everyone who has believed in
First and foremost, we thank Lord God Almighty for His guidance, wisdom, and strength
throughout this capstone project. Without His grace, this achievement would not have been
possible.
To Mrs. May Diaz, our research adviser, whose expertise, guidance, and encouragement
were invaluable from the beginning to the end of this project. Her mentorship played a key role
To Mrs. Monina Velayo, thank you for giving the researcher the opportunity to conduct
this study and for providing continuous guidance and support throughout the process.
To Ms. Maria Gwen Lazaro, the Principal, for placing her trust in the researchers and
believing in our ability to successfully complete the study. Her confidence was a motivating
We also want to express our sincere appreciation to Mrs. Ana Marie Magpayo for her
help, assistance, and suggestions, which greatly contributed to improving and refining our
capstone project.
To our parents, we extend our deepest gratitude for their help and advice in assisting us in
obtaining the materials we needed for our study. Their unwavering support has made our work
easier, allowing us to save valuable time, money, and effort. Their encouragement and guidance
have been instrumental in the success of our project, and we truly appreciate everything they
Furthermore, we sincerely thank Sto. Niño Academy, as well as its staff and students, for
generously lending us the necessary materials to create our product. Your support and kindness
have been invaluable to our project’s success. We truly appreciate your assistance and
6
Lastly, we acknowledge ourselves for the dedication, hard work, and teamwork we have put
into this project. Despite the challenges we faced, our perseverance and commitment allowed us
to successfully develop our product. This experience has not only enhanced our skills but also
7
DEDICATION
First and foremost, we dedicate this research to our beloved parents, who have
continuously believed in us throughout our journey. Their unwavering trust, unconditional love,
and constant support have been our greatest motivation to persevere and strive for excellence.
Their sacrifices, from providing for our education to encouraging us during our most challenging
times, have played a crucial role in the successful completion of this study. Even in the smallest
Secondly, we extend this dedication to our school, Sto. Niño Academy, which has served
as our second home and the foundation of our academic journey. We are grateful for the
institution’s commitment to shaping young minds and nurturing our potential. To our Capstone
Research Project adviser, Mrs. May B. Diaz, we sincerely appreciate your guidance, patience,
and tireless efforts in mentoring us throughout this research. Your wisdom, constructive
feedback, and encouragement have been instrumental in refining our work and helping us
We also extend our gratitude to our assistant principal, Mrs. Monina Velayo, and our
principal, Mrs. Maria Gwen Y. Lazaro, for their unwavering support and trust in our capabilities.
Your leadership, dedication, and belief in us have given us the confidence to push forward and
Furthermore, we dedicate this project to our teachers, classmates, and friends who
have stood by us throughout this research. To our mentors and subject teachers, thank you for
imparting your knowledge, instilling in us the value of critical thinking, and always encouraging
us to do our best. To our peers, your companionship, collaboration, and moral support have made
8
Additionally, we dedicate this research to ourselves, the researchers, for our
perseverance, determination, and commitment to completing this study. Despite the challenges,
setbacks, and moments of doubt, we never wavered in our pursuit of knowledge and excellence.
This project is a testament to our hard work, patience, and resilience. The long nights of research,
the endless revisions, and the sacrifices we made along the way were all worth it. We take pride
in our growth, both academically and personally, as this journey has shaped us into more
Finally, above all, we dedicate this work to God Almighty, who has been our source of
strength, wisdom, and perseverance throughout this journey. His divine guidance has led us
through moments of doubt and exhaustion, and through His grace, we were able to complete this
research successfully. We are deeply grateful for His blessings, protection, and the opportunities
9
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Abstract...................................................................................................................................... 5
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT......................................................................................................... 6
DEDICATION........................................................................................................................... 8
TABLE OF CONTENTS............................................................................................. 10
CHAPTER 1................................................................................................................................. 11
I. Introduction...........................................................................................................................11
VII. Hypothesis........................................................................................................................ 16
CHAPTER 2................................................................................................................................. 20
REFERENCES........................................................................................................................ 26
CHAPTER 3................................................................................................................................. 30
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY............................................................................................... 30
INGREDIENTS :..................................................................................................................... 30
PROCEDURES....................................................................................................................... 33
● Degreaser test................................................................................................................. 35
CHAPTER 4................................................................................................................................. 40
10
PRESENTATION, ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION OF DATA..................................40
CHAPTER 5................................................................................................................................. 46
Summary of Findings...............................................................................................................46
Conclusions........................................................................................................................47
Recommendations....................................................................................................................49
CHAPTER 6................................................................................................................................. 51
11
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
I. Introduction
TAP is a dishwashing liquid made from the extract of Talisay leaves (Terminalia catappa)
with the intention of neutralizing the odor and the grease that would be found on kitchen utensils.
This product is more eco-friendly and less harsh than typical dishwashing liquids, which often
contain synthetic chemicals. By infusing Talisay leaf extract into this dishwashing liquid, the
product promises to be biodegradable and eco-friendly yet has strong cleaning powers.
Most dishwashing liquids sold in the market today contain chemical surfactants,
preservatives, and artificial fragrances that can cause environmental pollution and skin irritation.
The need for more environmentally friendly and gentle skin has been growing, and innovation
has been pushed to use plant-based ingredients. TAP fits into this trend by using Talisay leaves as
Talisay leaves are often ignored and thrown away, especially in tropical countries, like the
Philippines, where it grows abundantly. However, these leaves were known for centuries for their
medicinal and antibacterial properties. The leaves from the Talisay tree are employed in
aquaculture to adjust the water quality and treat various fish diseases through its natural tannins
and organic compounds. Their antimicrobial and antioxidant property indicates that it may also
(Berto, 2020) states that the leaves are ovate with shiny surfaces; their length could range
from 10 to 25 cm in length, usually having a conical base with a rounded top. Studies indicate
that Talisay leaves contain numerous tannins and flavonoids, hence, other organic compounds
that were proven to support the antibacterial properties of such extracts. Other natural
compounds that exist in it also inhibit bacterial growth, giving promise to adding the extract as
12
More importantly, (Del Campo, 2022) mentioned the antioxidant and antibacterial
potential of Talisay leaf extract, focusing on its potential to combat harmful microorganisms. The
aquaculture, such as personal care products and household cleaners. By capitalizing on these
natural properties, TAP is focusing on offering a dishwashing liquid that is effective, non-toxic,
TAP greatly helps in waste reduction and the reuse of natural resources. All
liquid dish soap. This research has found the effectiveness of Talisay leaves in household
cleaning products and tested their key ingredient potential in eco-friendly formulations for
dishwashing liquids.
13
II. Background of the Study
Every day, families and commercial kitchens throughout the world use dishwashing
liquids to clean dishes, cookware, and utensils. Grease, oil, and food residues can be effectively
removed by using conventional dishwashing liquids, which are frequently made of artificial
chemicals and surfactants. However, harsh additives like phosphate, artificial perfumes, and
surfactants based on petrochemicals may be present in these goods, endangering both human
health and the environment. Many sectors and customers are looking for safer, greener options as
Dishwashing liquids are essential household cleaning agents designed to remove grease,
food residues, and odors from kitchenware. Commercial dishwashing products typically contain
synthetic surfactants and chemicals, which, although effective, may cause environmental
pollution and skin irritation due to prolonged exposure. In recent years, there has been increasing
awareness and demand for eco-friendly and biodegradable alternatives made from natural
plant-based ingredients that are safer for both humans and the environment.
Terminalia catappa, commonly known as Talisay, is a tropical tree found in many parts of
the Philippines and other tropical regions. Its fallen leaves are often abundant and considered
waste, yet studies have shown that these leaves are rich in antibacterial and cleansing
compounds, such as tannins, flavonoids, and saponins. These bioactive components have been
proven to exhibit cleansing and antimicrobial properties, making Talisay leaves a promising raw
Using Talisay leaves in dishwashing liquid presents an opportunity to reuse natural waste
Additionally, combining Talisay leaves with other natural ingredients like Pandan (Pandanus
amaryllifolius) can improve the scent and appeal of the product, aligning with consumer
14
III. Research Aim
This study aims to develop an eco-friendly dishwashing liquid using Talisay leaves
extract and Pandan Leaves. The research seeks to assess its effectiveness in terms of degreasing
capability, scent, and ease of rinsing compared to commercially available dishwashing liquids.
In this capstone research, the researchers will focus on TAP: Terminalia Catappa
(Talisay) as a Dishwashing Liquid. This study aims to create a dishwashing liquid made from
talisay leaves extract that will help the environment reduce waste and create an eco-friendly
dishwashing liquid. Additionally, These are the specific questions that researcher seek to answer
in this study:
1. How effective is TAP Dishwashing liquid with manipulated amounts of talisay extract
1.2 Foaming
2. How effective is TAP dishwashing liquid with manipulated amount of talisay extract
compared to Brand x
2.2 Foaming
3. How does Pandan extract impact the quality of TAP in terms of:
15
4. User preferences for TAP overall quality with different mixtures in terms of:
4.2 Stain
1. To develop an eco-friendly dishwashing liquid that effectively cleans kitchenware while
2. To use Talisay leaves extract and Pandan leaves for cleaning, utilizing its natural
4. To promote the use of biodegradable and less toxic ingredients, reducing the reliance on
harsh chemicals that can harm both human health and the environment.
This study aims to create a dishwashing liquid made from talisay leaves extract and
Pandan leaves that will help the environment reduce waste and create an eco-friendly
For Environments
This study will benefit the environment by reducing the amount of chemicals that are
This study will benefit households that always use dishwashing liquids on a daily basis.
By using this alternative they could also help the environment reduce water pollution.
16
For Restaurants and Food Industry
Dishwashing liquid plays a crucial role in maintaining cleanliness and ensuring food
safety in the commercial kitchens of restaurants, hotels, cafeterias, and other food service
establishments.
For Manufacturers
Talisay leaves are an inexpensive, renewable resource that manufacturers can use to
make sustainable products, giving them a competitive edge in the expanding market for
This product can be used as a reference by future researchers so they can improve this
VII. Hypothesis
● Null Hypothesis (H₀): Talisay leaves extract and Pandan leaves extract does not
● Alternative Hypothesis (H₁): Talisay leaves extract and Pandan leaves extract enhances
17
VIII. Scope and Delimitation
Scope
This study focuses on formulating TAP as dishwashing liquid with Talisay leaves, Pandan
leaves, Decyl Glucoside, Sodium Laureth Sulfate, Glycerine and salt as dishwashing liquid. This
study will examine the effectiveness in terms of Grease removal, Foaming effect, Gentleness on
hands, Odor removal, and scent. This study will also focus on creating effective dishwashing
liquid that is effective and contains less chemicals compared to commercial brands. Additionally,
we will also test staining and ease of rinsing of our product and we the researchers will only use
the utensils provided by our respondents that are used to store foods ensuring real world
Delimitations
This study will not include TAP dishwashing liquid long term shelf life, long term health
effects as the experiment can only be evaluated for a short period of time. We also would not
include the consistent amount or drops of TAP dishwashing used by testers as they have different
methods of cleaning and the study will not include other types of leaves and artificial colorings,
Researchers will also not include antibacterial testing of talisay extract in this study.
18
Definition of Terms
meters recorded. It is widely cultivated in the tropics, as a shade tree, for ornament and for
2. Pandan Leaves (Pandanus amaryllifolius) – Pandan is a herbaceous tropical plant that
3. Dishwashing Liquid – Dishwashing liquids, as the name implies, serve us primarily to
4. Degreasing Capability – Degreasing is a crucial process that removes dirt, grit, scale,
corrosion, grease, oil, and other foreign matter from system hardware parts before
5. Foaming Property – To provide contact time on a soiled surface to allow the wetting
agents, detergents and degreasers enough time to do their jobs (Cleaner Solutions, 2024) .
6. Gentleness on Hands – This specially formulated dishwashing liquid is free from harsh
chemicals and fragrances that can cause skin reactions (Jason Godwin, 2023).
7. Odor Removal – Odors are powerful chemicals ready to react with anything, up to and
including the sensitive nerves in your nose. Removing them often requires equally
8. Biodegradable – An item can be broken down into increasingly smaller pieces by
9. Eco-friendly – products or sometimes services that are not harmful to the environment
10.Phytochemicals – they protect your cells from damage caused by environmental toxins
(Microban, 2024).
19
REFERENCE
Cleaner Solutions. “What You Need to Know About Foam.” 16 January 2024,
https://cleanersolutions.net/what-you-need-to-know-about-foam/.
2023,
https://donatethisrecyclethat.com/understanding-green-vs-eco-friendly/.
Godwin, Jason. “Best Dishwashing Liquid for Sensitive Hands – Say Goodbye to
https://cleanhomeexpert.co.uk/best-dishwashing-liquid-for-sensitive-hands-sa
y-goodbye-to-irritation/.
Graham, Vanessa. “The most natural tools to remove smells in the home.” 16 May
2023,
https://molekule.com/blogs/all/the-most-natural-tools-to-remove-smells-in-th
e-home.
https://www.microban.com/antimicrobial-solutions/overview/antibacterial-vs
-antimicrobial.
PCC. “Hand dishwashing liquids: what you need to know.” 6 March 2022,
https://www.products.pcc.eu/en/blog/hand-dishwashing-liquids-what-you-nee
d-to-know/.
Precision Companies. “What Is Degreasing And What Role Does it Play?” 1 May
2023,
https://www.precgroup.com/what-is-degreasing-and-what-role-does-it-play/.
https://www.bbcgoodfood.com/howto/guide/what-biodegradable-really-means.
https://www.thespruceeats.com/cooking-with-pandan-3217067.
10 May 2023,
https://www.uclahealth.org/news/article/what-are-phytochemicals-and-why-s
hould-you-eat-more-them.
20
CHAPTER 2
Dishwashing Liquid
According to Borković et al. (2022), the consumption of dishwashing liquids for manual
and machine washing continues to rise globally. Despite the growing popularity of dishwashers,
hand dishwashing remains predominant in many regions. A good dishwashing liquid is expected
to remove grease, food residues, and other contaminants from various dish materials while
ensuring that the dishes remain smooth, shiny, and free of harmful chemical residues. In recent
years, consumers have been increasingly concerned with the environmental impact of the
chemicals in traditional dishwashing liquids, prompting the search for natural alternatives
Hand dishwashing liquids (HDL) are one of the most important groups of household
chemicals. In physicochemical terms, they are aqueous solutions of surface-active agents and
colorants, opacifiers as well as substances giving formulations a pearly appearance. In line with
the most recent trends, hand dishwashing liquids should not only have good functionality
(appropriate detergent, foaming, or rheological properties) but also demonstrate a high level of
In 2022, the vast majority of consumers across the globe saw their purchasing behavior
become at least a little more environmentally friendly compared to five years earlier (Davies,
2025). The current shift is mainly driven by consumer awareness of rising environmental issues
and the detrimental effects of synthetic chemicals on health and the environment generally. As a
result, the industry is adopting alternative ingredients derived from natural sources to meet the
demand for biodegradable and non-toxic products. Eco-friendly dishwashing liquids stand out
from their conventional counterparts due to their commitment to using plant-based and
Dishwashing saw exceptional growth in the Philippines in 2023, with growth for both
hand dishwashing and automatic dishwashing. However, while automatic dishwashers are slowly
gaining ground in urban and high-income households in the Philippines, hand dishwashing
21
remains the preferred method for washing dishes for most consumers, owing to its
International, 2024).
Terminalia catappa, or Talisay, also known as Indian Almond, is a tropical plant studied
for its bioactive compounds. Various studies have reported that the ethanol extract of Talisay
leaves contains 51.2 percent faxed oil (called catalpa oil) with 54 percent olefins, palmitin, and
tannin, Phytochemical screening of aqueous and organic solvent leaf extracts yielded tannins,
The antimicrobial activities of Talisay leaf extracts were confirmed by several studies.
The ethanolic extract of the plant was shown to be effective in checking the growth of
Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria, including Terminalia catappa L. This plant has been
traditionally used by the community to treat skin infections caused by bacteria or fungi
(Mardhiyani, 2021). Antimicrobial activity was shown to be due to flavonoids and tannins that
Talisay showed positive antibacterial activity with a value of 13.3±1.1547. The findings clearly
indicated that the plant extract used has potential antioxidant and antibacterial agents.
provides the scientific basis and may help to discover new chemical classes of antioxidant and
antibacterial substances that could serve as selective agents against degenerative diseases. This
investigation has opened up the possibility of the use of Talisay leaves extract in producing
antioxidant and antibacterial agents that function as an alternative to highly available antioxidant
A 2023 study investigated the antibacterial effects of ethanolic extracts from red and
brown T. catappa leaves against Staphylococcus aureus. The findings revealed that a 20% (w/v)
concentration of the red leaf extract exhibited the highest inhibition zone of 13.67 ± 0.76 mm.
The phytochemical test of the extracts showed that both extracts contained alkaloids, saponins,
22
flavonoids, tannins, and steroids, but terpenoid compounds were only found in the red ketapang
also harvested for the perfume industry, and many prominent perfume brands now produce
ethnic Asian fragrances, including pandan perfume (Wang et al., 2024). It is a very popular
ingredient in food, cosmetics, and household products. Pandan leaves possess the characteristic
smell that is attributed primarily to 2-acetyl-1-pyrroline, a volatile compound responsible for the
sweet and nutty aroma associated with the pandan leaves. The compound has also been detected
in other varieties of aromatic rice, including jasmine and basmati rice. As such, pandan would be
Talisay leaves, derived from the Terminalia catappa tree, are rich in bioactive
saponins, and coumarins, but terpenoids were absent (Mwangi, Wangui Clement et al., 2024).
secondary metabolites with a variety of important functions in plant physiology, offer promising
health benefits for humans. These benefits include acting as antioxidant compounds,
Making them effective in eliminating various bacterial strains. A study demonstrated that a
polyphenolic solution could eliminate at least 99.9% of tested microorganisms, highlighting its
potential as a disinfectant.
fermented Terminalia catappa leaves revealed a wide range of concentrations, with saponin
being the most abundant compound at 1009.24 mg/g, The analysis of polyphenolic contents in
unfermented Terminalia catappa leaf revealed that saponin exhibited the highest concentration
(1666.03 mg/g).
23
According to Brodie Cook (2025). Saponins are natural surfactants found in many
plants. A surfactant is a substance that helps water spread and lift away dirt. It works by bonding
with both water and oils, breaking down grease so it can be rinsed or wiped away easily.
Additionally, According to Rai Summi, et al., (2021) Saponins are the plant based
natural surfactants characterized by their foam forming properties in aqueous solution. Their
natural origin makes them eco-friendly, bio-degradable and non-toxic. Further, they possess
better physicochemical properties than the syn-thetic ones. They are also reported to exhibit a lot
biological activities and wide distribution in nature, saponin rich plants deserve deeper insight as
a sustainable source of natural surfactants as they possess the potential to replace toxic synthetic
surfactants abundant today. The surfactant properties of saponins in aqueous solutions can be
aglycone and hydro-philic polar glycone moieties. This structural feature of a saponin molecule
According to Jianzi Huang et al., (2024) Tannins, another class of polyphenols found in
Talisay leaves, are known for their astringent and antimicrobial properties. Tannins can bind to
proteins and lipids, disrupting microbial cell membranes and enhancing the sanitizing potential
of dishwashing liquids. Tannins have been reported as antibacterial, antifungal, and antiviral
compounds by preventing enzymatic activities and inhibiting the synthesis of nucleic acids.
According to Hassanpour, Seyyed Hossein, and Alireza Doroudi (2023) Flavonoids are
a diverse group of polyphenolic compounds found in many plants, known for their antioxidant,
antimicrobial, and anti-inflammatory properties. The more the flavonoid structure makes the
hydrogen transfer faster and easier, the more the flavonoid’s antioxidant power will be enhanced.
This property is advantageous in cleaning products, as it helps maintain the stability and efficacy
of the formulations. These bioactive compounds have gained attention for their potential
application in eco-friendly cleaning products due to their ability to enhance hygiene and surface
protection.
24
Dishwashing Liquid Foaminess
The foam works to loosen and lift dirt and debris from the surface, making it easier to
remove. This type of cleaning is often used in factories and other industrial settings where there
is a lot of dirt and greasy build-up. Foam cleaners can be used for internal and external cleaning
of tanks, as well as floors, cladding, walls, production equipment and many other hard surfaces
SLES
According to Rashid, (2023) Sodium Lauryl Ether Sulfate (SLES) is a widely used
surfactant in various industries, including personal care, household cleaning, and industrial
applications. It is a versatile and effective surfactant that offers many benefits. It plays a crucial
role in the dishwashing liquid's ability to remove dirt, oils, and grease from dishes, making it an
less irritating to the skin and eyes. This makes SLES a preferred choice in formulations
designed for sensitive skin or for products intended for frequent use, such as shampoos and body
25
REFERENCES
Borković, A., Dugić, P., Botić, T., Tatić, S., Markuljević, D., Drljača, D., & Dragić, D. (2022).
Organization for
Nuclear Research).
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.6371252
Cook, Brodie. “The Cleaning Power of Saponins: A Natural Way to Tackle Grease & Grime.” 3
Dataintelo, More, A. B., & Dataintelo. (2025, January 7). Sodium Lauryl Ether Sulfate (SLES)
https://dataintelo.com/report/sodium-lauryl-ether-sulfate-sles-market
r.search.yahoo.com/_ylt=Awrx.OexxMdnJQIAHPqzRwx.;_ylu=Y29sbwNzZzMEcG9zA
zIEdnRpZAMEc2VjA3Ny/RV=2/RE=1742354865/RO=10/RU=https%3a%2f%2f2.zoppoz.workers.dev%3a443%2fhttps%2fwww.a
cademia.edu%2f90869376%2fPhytochemical_Screening_Antioxidant_and_Antibacterial
_Property_of_Talisay_Terminalia_catappa_Leaves_Ethanolic_Extract_Against_Staphylo
coccus_aureus_Used_as_Formulated_Ointment/RK=2/RS=zSzZ9w06l82AxY7O6v_iZP
AHmEk-.
Dewi, Asiska Permata, and Dini Mardhiyani. “Formulation and Antibacterial Activity of Liquid
Soap Containing Ketapang (Terminalia catappa L.) Leaves Extract.” vol. Vol 4, no. Issue
https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/df47/6b9e246ebfd6ee5f67cbf8b7c23c1f20aee8.pdf.
26
Hassanpour, Seyyed Hossein, and Alireza Doroudi. “Review of the antioxidant potential of
doi:10.22038/AJP.2023.21774
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10474916/
Jianzi Huang, Madiha Zaynab, Yasir Sharif, Jallat Khan, Rashid Al-Yahyai, Monther Sadder,
Munawar Ali, Saber R. Alarab, Shuangfei Li, Tannins as antimicrobial agents: Understanding
toxic effects on pathogens, Toxicon, Volume 247, 2024, 107812, ISSN 0041-0101,
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.toxicon.2024.107812.
Mandal, Manas Kumar, and Abraham J Domb. “Antimicrobial Activities of Natural Bioactive
doi:10.3390/pharmaceutics16060718
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11206801/
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10986026/
Rai, S., Acharya-Siwakoti, E., Kafle, A., Devkota, H. P., & Bhattarai, A. (2021a). Plant-Derived
Saponins: A Review of Their Surfactant Properties and Applications. Sci, 3(4), 44.
https://doi.org/10.3390/sci3040044
https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/sles-king-all-surfactants-mudasar-rashid-#:~:text=1.,at%
20a%20relatively%20low%20cost.
24 August 2023,
https://homecourt.co/blogs/dish-soap/the-environmental-impact-of-choosing-eco-friendly
-dishwashing-liquid.
27
Sodium Laureth Sulfate (SLES): cosmetic ingredient INCI. (n.d.).
https://cosmetics.specialchem.com/inci-ingredients/sodium-laureth-sulfate
Studocu. (n.d.). Research RRL - 2 Foreign Literature Liquid detergent has an increasing demand
https://www.studocu.com/ph/document/ramon-magsaysay-high-school-manila/corporate-
law-physical/research-rrl/89895299
VAGESTINI, Luh Made Ary Somia; KAWURI, Retno; DEFIANI, Made Ria. Antibacterial
Activity of Red and Brown Ethanolic Extract of Ketapang (Terminalia catappa.) Leaves Against
Doi:
https://doi.org/10.24843/metamorfosa.2023.v10.i01.p17.
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0367326X24003277#:~:text=Pand
anus%20amaryllifolius%20Roxb.-,P.,In%20addition%2C%20P.
Wasilewski, T., Seweryn, A. & Krajewski, M. Improvement in the Safety of Use of Hand
Dishwashing Liquids Through the Addition of Hydrophobic Plant Extracts. J Surfact Deterg 19,
1315–1326 (2016).
https://doi.org/10.1007/s11743-016-1868-x
28
Xie, Jun. “SLES in Dishwashing Liquid: The Ultimate Ingredient for High-Performance
https://yeserchem.com/sles-in-dishwashing-liquid-the-ultimate-ingredient-for-high-performance
formulations/#:~:text=SLES%20is%20a%20powerful%20surfactant,penetrate%20and%20lift%
%20soils.
Zainudin. “Phytochemical and Antimicrobial Analyses of Terminalia Catappa Linn. Ethanol Leaf
https://scimatic.org/storage/journals/11/pdfs/615.pdf.
https://zogics.com/product-guide-library/what-is-sodium-laureth-sulfate/?srsltid=AfmBO
orTPDaquZVqy_T23utXop6ydZrwe-DjMvbzv-UlIrxtuIh3NJQx
29
CHAPTER 3
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
RESEARCH METHOD
This chapter details the materials, tools, and equipment used in the study, as well as
the systematic methods and procedures followed to achieve the objectives of the research. It
provides a clear and structured approach to how the study was conducted. This chapter is
INGREDIENTS :
a. Glycerine - acts as a moisturizer to prevent skin dryness, improves the liquid's texture,
helps maintain product stability, and makes the dishwashing liquid gentle on the skin.
b. Iodized Salt - Used as thickening agent for sodium laureth sulfate
c. Moisturizer ( Decyl Glucoside) - prevents skin dryness by keeping hand soft after using
d. Pandan Leaves - they serve as our fragrance for dishwashing liquid
e. SLES (Sodium Laureth Sulfate) - A surfactant that creates foam and helps remove
f. Talisay Leaves - contain natural antibacterial and antimicrobial properties, which help in
g. Water - serves as the main solvent that dissolves SLES and extracts nutrients from
30
TOOLS AND EQUIPMENT :
a. Bottles
- These serve as the final packaging for the dishwashing liquid, making it easy to
b. Bowls
- These bowls hold Talisay and Pandan leaves during extraction and can also store
pre-mixed ingredients and after heating, a bowl can hold the cooled extract before
c. Butane
- provides the necessary heat for boiling or simmering the ingredients during the
d. Funnel
- helps pour the liquid detergent into bottles without spilling, ensuring a clean and
efficient transfer of the final product. It also prevents wastage and maintains
e. Knife
- It is used for chopping Talisay and Pandan leaves into smaller pieces to aid in the
extraction process.
f. Ladle
- It is used for pouring hot extracts or mixing solutions without causing spills or
burns.
- these cups ensure that the correct amount of water, extracts, and other liquid
31
i. Pot
- It is used to boil Talisay leaves and pandan leaves for extracting their active
- It ensures safety when handling hot pots or pans during the heating and extraction
process.
- This tub serves as a container for preparing, mixing, and temporarily storing the
l. Sponge
- It is used for stirring and mixing the ingredients, ensuring an even blend of the
n. Stove
- It is essential for heating the extract to enhance the release of antibacterial and
o. Strainer
- It is used to separate solid leaf residues from the extracted Talisay and Pandan
p. Tongs
- are useful for picking up and handling hot leaves, bottles, or other materials
32
PROCEDURES
1. The researchers gathered all the materials that will be used in making the Talisay
dishwashing liquid.
2. The researchers measured each ingredient that would be used to make different
TABLE 1.0
2. Use a weighing scale to determine the exact measurement of talisay leaves.
3. Wash the leaves thoroughly to remove dirt and other impurities.
5. Put 100 grams of Talisay leaves with 200 grams of pandan leaves in the pot, then boil it
6. After 30 minutes remove all the talisay leaves from the pot.
8. After 2 hours, boil the Talisay extract with the pandan leaves for 30 minutes.
9. Strain the mixture to separate the liquid extract from the leaf residues, except the pandan
leaves.
33
Making of the SLES
1. Get 5 liters of water and then put it in a small plastic tub.
2. After adding 5 liters of water, add the SLES and stir it with a spatula until it dissolves.
3. Then, leave it or let it stay for 24 hours until it fully dissolves.
Mixture A
2. Add 500 mL of SLES with the talisay and pandan extract.
3. Get 57.5 grams of iodized salt, put it in the bowl, and stir it in one direction.
4. While stirring add the glycerine (5 ml) and Decyl Glucoside (5 ml).
5. Once the mixture becomes thick, it is ready and can be transferred into bottles.
Mixture B
3. Get 57.5 grams of iodized salt, put it in the bowl, and stir it in one direction.
4. While stirring add the glycerine (5 ml) and Decyl Glucoside (5 ml).
5. Once the mixture becomes thick, it is ready and can be transferred into bottles.
Mixture C
3. Get 57.5 grams of iodized salt put in the bowl, and stir it in one direction.
4. While stirring add the glycerine (5 ml) and Decyl Glucoside (5 ml).
5. Once the mixture becomes thick, it is ready and can be transferred into bottles.
34
B. Testing of TAP dishwashing liquid
● Degreaser test
1. The researcher will provide participants in the canteen with each mixture
(A,B,C) to test in their own dishes.
2. The participants will observe the cleaning effect of each mixtures
● Foaming effect
1. The researcher will provide participants in the canteen with each mixture
(A,B,C) to test in their own dishes.
2. The participants will observe the foaming effect of each mixtures
● Gentleness on hands
1. After cleaning with different mixtures (A,B,C) the participants will
observe their hands to check if allergies or irritations occur.
● Odor Removal
1. After cleaning each participants will smell each utensils to check and if the
utensil still have
● Scent Test
1. The participants will smell each mixture (A,B,C) and observe if they can
smell the pandan scent
.
● Staining and Rinsing
1. The participants will also check if mixture (A,B,C) will leave stains in
utensils and they will also observe if TAP dishwashing liquid is easy to
rinse.
35
2. Comparison with brand X
Researchers will compare TAP dishwashing liquid to brand x to test if TAP dishwashing
liquid can be an alternative even if it contains less chemical.
● Degreaser test
● Foaming effect
● Gentleness on hands
● Odor Removal
● Color
● Scent
Table 2.0
Possible Risk and Safety in the Talisay Extract and Pandan Process
36
ingested accidentally. "Avoid contact with eyes" to
prevent misuse.
Table 3.0
Skin and Eye SLES can cause dryness, irritation, ● Wear gloves and protective
Irritation or eye discomfort. eyewear when handling.
Decyl Glucoside may irritate ● Maintain proper dilution of
sensitive skin. surfactants and extracts.
Talisay and Pandan extracts can ● Conduct a patch test before
trigger allergies. large-scale use.
Microbial Talisay and Pandan extracts can ● Use preservatives like sodium
Contamination encourage bacterial or fungal benzoate or citric acid.
growth. ● Filter extracts to remove debris.
Glycerine attracts moisture, ● Store in clean, airtight
increasing the risk of contamination. containers.
Stability and Iodized salt can cause cloudiness or ● Add salt slowly while stirring
Separation separation in the formulation. to avoid excessive thickening.
Talisay and Pandan extracts may ● Use emulsifiers or stabilizers
settle or form precipitates. like xanthan gum if needed.
● Conduct stability testing before
mass production.
Unexpected SLES and Decyl Glucoside may ● Perform small batch testing
Chemical react with iodized salt, affecting before large-scale production.
Reactions foaming. ● Adjust pH to 6–7 for a
Talisay’s tannins may alter surfactant balanced formulation.
efficiency.
37
COST AND EXPENSES
Table 4.0
Total Cost and Expenses in Making and Testing Talisay Dishwashing Liquid
38
Table 5.0
39
CHAPTER 4
Performance Made by the Dishwashing Liquid Based on the Testing that the Researcher
Conducted
Table 1.0
Mixture A
Grease II I I
removal
Foaming II I I
effect
Gentleness II I I
on hands
Odor III I
removal
Scent of II II
mixture
Table 1.0 shows the effectiveness of Mixture A in removing grease, its foaming effect,
gentleness on hands, odor removal, and scent. The mixture had very effective grease removal and
foaming, which implied that it is a strong cleaning agent. The mixture was gentle on hands;
hence, it can be used frequently. In most cases, odor removal was considered very effective,
which implied that the mixture removes unwanted odors. However, the odor of the mixture
received good to neutral ratings, which means that although acceptable, it is not a feature to be
highlighted. Overall, the data suggests that Mixture A is effective in cleaning and odor removal,
with the potential for improvement in scent formulation to enhance user satisfaction.
40
Table 2.0
Mixture B
Grease II II
removal
Foaming I I II
effect
Gentleness I I II
on hands
Odor III I
removal
Scent of I III
mixture
Table 2.0 presents the effectiveness of Mixture B in terms of grease removal, foaming
effect, gentleness on hands, odor removal, and scent. The mixture was rated very effective to
neutral in grease removal, indicating that while it performs well, some users found it only
moderately effective. The foaming effect received very effective, effective, and neutral ratings,
suggesting that its foaming ability is adequate but could be improved. Gentleness on hands was
also rated across as very effective to neutral, implying that it is generally safe for use but it may
need slight enhancement for some users. Odor removal was mostly rated as very effective,
confirming its strong ability to eliminate unwanted smells. However, the scent of the mixture
received effective to neutral ratings, indicating that while acceptable, it may not be a strong
feature. Overall, the data suggests that Mixture B is effective in cleaning and odor removal, but
its foaming ability and scent could be improved for better user satisfaction.
41
Table 3.0
Mixture C
Grease III I
removal
Foaming III I
effect
Gentleness II II
on hands
Odor III I
removal
Scent of II I I
mixture
Table 3.0 The ability of Mixture C is shown in Table 3.0 by giving grease removal
ability, foaming effect, gentleness on hand, removal of odor, and scent. Grease removal was rated
as very effective, and the foaming effect was also rated as very effective, which elicits both
strong cleaning and lathering characteristics. Odor removal received a very effective rating,
which means that the mixture altogether removes unwanted odors. However, the gentleness on
hands was rated from very effective to neutral, meaning that while it is mostly skin-friendly,
some users may find it slightly stronger. The scent of the mixture received mixed ratings, ranging
from very effective to neutral, implying that while some found it pleasant, others were neutral
about its appeal. Overall, Mixture C does well in grease removal, foaming, and odor elimination,
but there is room for improvement in gentleness and scent to enhance user satisfaction.
42
Table 4.0
Brand X
Grease IIII
removal
Foaming IIII
effect
Gentleness IIII
on hands
Odor IIII
removal
Scent of IIII
mixture
grease removal, foaming action, hand gentleness, odor elimination, and fragrance of the blend.
The product's efficacy was rated on a five-point basis: Very Effective, Effective, Neutral, Not
Effective, and Not Very Effective. The findings present Brand X being marked as "Very
Effective" in all areas, with all criteria having four marks (IIII). This presents that the product is
performing outstandingly in grease removal, generating foam, being soft on hands, getting rid of
odor, and having a good odor. No markings were noted under other effectiveness areas, further
43
Table 5.0
Brand X
The table 5.0 The table compares the rinsing and staining capabilities of dishwashing
liquids made from Mixtures A, B and C with Brand X. The first measure looks at the rinsing
properties of the dishwashing liquid, and Mixtures A, B and Brand X received four tally marks
(IIII) under "Yes" indicating "rinses off easily", while Mixture C received three tally marks (III)
for "Yes" and one tally mark (I) for "No", indicating that it rinses off slightly less easily. The
second measure looks at the No staining properties of the dishwashing liquids, and all of the
mixtures and Brand X received four tally marks (IIII) under the measure of "No" indicating that
none of the dishwashing liquids stained the utensil/plate. Overall, the findings indicate that all
four formulations do well to not stain, while Mixture C has a slight reduction in its rinsing ability
44
Table 6.0
Overall IIII
preference
Table 6.0 This presents user preferences based on the color and overall performance of
different dishwashing mixtures, including Mixtures A, B, C, and Brand X. The results indicate
that Brand X received four tally marks (IIII) for both preferred color and overall preference,
while Mixtures A, B, and C did not receive any marks in these categories. This suggests that
users favored Brand X over the other mixtures in terms of both appearance and overall
performance.
45
CHAPTER 5
This chapter will provide a summary of the findings, draw conclusions from the testing and
Summary of Findings
assessed based on several factors, including grease removal, foaming effect, gentleness on hands,
odor elimination, scent, rinsing ability, staining properties, and user preference. The results are as
follows:
Grease Removal
All mixtures showed good grease removal capability. Mixtures A and C were mostly
rated as "Very Effective," while Mixture B had a combination of "Very Effective" and "Neutral"
ratings. Brand X received consistent "Very Effective" which outperformed all mixtures.
Foaming Action
The foaming ability of the dishwashing liquids varied. Mixtures A and C received "Very
Effective" ratings, indicating good foaming properties. Mixture B had a mix of "Very Effective,"
"Effective," and "Neutral" ratings, suggesting that its foaming ability is present but could be
further improved. Brand X had the highest ratings, being marked as "Very Effective" in all
responses.
No Skin Irritation
Mixture A was generally rated as "Very Effective," indicating it does not irritate the skin.
Mixtures B and C had ratings that ranged from "Very Effective" to "Neutral," meaning that while
they are generally skin-friendly, some users had varying preferences. Brand X received
consistently "Very Effective" ratings, highlighting that no skin reaction happened on the users
hands.
46
Odor Elimination
All formulations performed well in odor removal. Mixtures A, B, and C were mostly
rated as "Very Effective," showing that they effectively remove unwanted odors. Brand X
Aroma of Mixture
The scent of the dishwashing liquids was rated differently by users. Mixtures A and B
received "Effective" to "Neutral" ratings, suggesting that while their scents were acceptable, they
might not be a standout feature. Mixture C had a mix of "Very Effective" and "Neutral" ratings,
indicating varying preferences. Brand X was rated "Very Effective" across all responses,
All dishwashing liquids were assessed for their rinsing ability and whether they left stains
on utensils. Mixtures A, B, and Brand X were marked as "easily rinsed off," while Mixture C had
a slightly lower rating in this category. None of the formulations caused staining, as all received
Brand X performed consistently well in all categories, receiving "Very Effective" ratings
across all aspects. The tested mixtures also demonstrated effectiveness but had some variations
User Preference
Brand X was the most preferred dishwashing liquid in terms of color and overall
performance, receiving the highest ratings. Mixtures A, B, and C did not receive preference
marks in these categories, indicating that Brand X was the most favored among users.
47
Conclusions
This research successfully developed a dishwashing liquid using Talisay leaf extract,
liquids that is effective, affordable, and eco-friendly. Through thorough testing of Mixtures A, B,
and C, the formulated dishwashing liquids demonstrated effectiveness in grease removal, odor
elimination, and foaming action, while also being generally skin-friendly. Among the three,
Mixture A and Mixture C showed the best results, particularly in cleaning efficiency and
foaming properties. These formulations have the potential for further refinement and commercial
use.
The inclusion of Talisay leaf extract enhances the product with natural antibacterial properties,
boosting its cleaning ability while offering a plant-based alternative. Additionally, the
while identifying areas for improvement, such as fragrance retention and no skin irritation on
hands. This suggests that while the formulation is effective, further enhancements could improve
Future studies could explore packaging solutions that align with the product’s sustainability goals
and the potential use of natural essential oils to enhance its scent. Beyond product development,
This study contributes to the growing body of research on plant-based cleaning products,
supporting the shift toward biodegradable, non-toxic alternatives that benefit both human health
48
Recommendations
recommendations for future scientists, producers, and industry professionals are as follows:
Future studies may determine particular natural ingredients that will help the dishwashing
liquid additionally become gentle yet effective. Future studies may conduct additional trials to
help eliminate the use of chemical surfactants and conduct laboratory testing of antibacterial
properties alongside with different ingredients. They could also explore more ways to improve
and introduce more color variations of this product and further improve precise testing and
For Manufacturers:
Intensifying the fragrance and providing a more pleasing scent could further enhance
consumer satisfaction. Incorporating skin-friendly additives could also make the product more
acceptable for daily use. Manufacturers can also work on creating environment-friendly
packaging to keep up with sustainability trends and appeal to consumers who are
green-conscious.
Consumer preference surveys will identify the most important areas of product
improvement. Compliance with industry standards and regulations is also essential in ensuring
product safety and efficacy. Clear labeling of product benefits, ingredients, and usage will assist
reduction and safer disposal of wastewater can lead to conservation of the environment.
Promoting the usage of natural surfactants over chemical ones can further increase the
49
For Marketing and Product Development:
Attractive and informative packaging that communicates the benefits of the product, for
example, effectiveness in grease removal, nice odor, and eco-friendliness, should be emphasized
by the companies. Consumer education regarding appropriate use and storage should also take
precedence. Promotion campaigns that bring out the theme of using natural ingredients, being
stores will raise consumer awareness and convenience. Building alliances with supermarkets and
internet sites can secure broad distribution. Special discounts and promotional offers for
50
CHAPTER 6
INGREDIENTS USED:
51
52
TOOLS AND EQUIPMENTS:
53
54
55
PROCEDURES
56
(Strain out the talisay leaves) (Let it cool for 2 hours)
(Boil again with pandan leaves for another 30 (Let it cool again for 2 hours.)
minutes)
57
Making the dishwashing liquid
Add (250ml of Talisay and pandan extract) Put 45ml iodized salt in the mix
and (Sles 500ml)
58
Product
TESTING
1st Canteen
Mixture A
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1SbALkhPyT9LS491enTFiXL_8eGIpXREn/view?usp=drive_lin
Mixture B
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1STPhBYzU8FL0mZQsbc2MME5SZOj5MoI1/view?usp=drive_
link
Mixture C
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1UMosrfm3UlZ6cAnpMzdfsyRquOBeeVVf/view?usp=drive_lin
59
2nd Canteen
Mixture A
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Pxh_8ia_cjXsaX9WIou40bUla1jalan1/view?usp=drive_link
Mixture B
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1QgGP9CxYE1HMfm_zno3_L-GI3kH6ESHb/view?usp=drive_li
nk
Mixture C
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1SIMbVKygSm1e8c_Lr4MJ55DZWXuEJn4f/view?usp=drive_li
nk
3rd Canteen
Mixture A
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1P4p22a-xpCKVt8l4gLbtwcslc3DMbL24/view?usp=drive_link
Mixture B
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1SIu9_3uIOrFyno_Ahxt2Oy8kNblptVqX/view?usp=drive_link
Mixture C
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Q_vSfE8IHvwrFEQD1tHQOBoSO0EitVZ0/view?usp=drive_li
nk
4th Canteen
Mixture A
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Py9MVWk3vfs080qjF9F2Badt7U92CWh4/view?usp=drive_lin
Mixture B
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1RKxNU_I8Y34jY1inH5kCM7_KCeICr6e5/view?usp=drive_lin
Mixture C
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1SskoVb8tpse6dGBxwoUyF1Xc9zQ5ayzS/view?usp=drive_link
Brand X
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Gtd7FjEneiSNsPe2fSLBV-ZYOu4GwEiF/view?usp=drive_link
60
Before:
After:
61
MIXTURE A
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1YfjHweu4qbuyRq_BgjPJp9kQYmrJ1hjV/view?usp=drive_link
Before:
After:
62
MIXTURE B
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1jXg0rNLovaGd6pJ1JhLalbVI_sAFwjhJ/view?usp=drive_link
Before:
After:
63
MIXTURE C
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1EaghfzF9a05IHZdhnwmd4b6KX_BXtZM-/view?usp=drive_lin
k\
Before:
After:
64
COST AND EXPENSES
Total Cost and Expenses in Making and Testing Talisay Dishwashing Liquid
65
Table 4.0
66
APPENDICES OF SURVEY QUESTIONNAIRE
Table 1.0
Grease II I I
removal
Foaming II I I
effect
Gentleness II I I
on hands
Odor III I
removal
Scent of II II
mixture
Table 2.0
Grease II I II
removal
Foaming I I II
effect
Gentleness I I II
on hands
Odor III I
removal
Scent of I III
mixture
67
Question 3: Effectiveness of Mixture C in terms of:
Table 3.0
Grease III I
removal
Foaming III I
effect
Gentleness II II
on hands
Odor III I
removal
Scent of II I I
mixture
Table 4.0
Grease IIII
removal
Foaming IIII
effect
Gentleness on IIII
hands
Odor IIII
removal
Scent of IIII
mixture
68
Question 5: Does this dishwashing liquid rinse off easily?
No I
Yes
Question 7: Among the different dishwashing mixtures, what color do you prefer the most
in terms of:
Overall IIII
preference
69
CURRICULUM VITAE
70
71
72
73
74