Benzene Reactions
Benzene Reactions
NO2
3 2
4
Br 1 NO
4-Bromo-1,2-dinitrobenzene
2
CO2H CH3
OCH3
#1
O carbonon OH
carbon #1 by by
definition OH C definiti O2N
2
O2 N Br 5
6 2 CH2CH3
Benzenes : Page 1
Accurate, Need to use this to
good keep track of
shorthand electrons in
mechanisms
Benzenes : Page 2
2 Miscellaneous Reactions of Benzenes
2.1 Reduction : Addition of Hydrogen
Catalytic addition of H2: forcing conditions required to add H2 to the benzene ring (breaks aromaticity)
H2
less reactive
aromatic Pd/C 50
Harder to
psi H2
reduce
Pt/1000 psi benzene ring
- aromatic
- Zn(Hg)
withdrawing H reduced to alkane
HCl, H2O (Clemmenson
H reduction)
- removes
oxygen adds
hydrogen
•the first reaction we have already
seen
•the second reaction, a Clemmensen reduction, we have not seen. it reduces an aldehyde/ketone
all the way to an alkane. we will return to the mechanism later in the semester, for now this is
something you just "need to know", sorry! The rest of the molecule must be capable of
withstanding aqueous acid. If not, there is another reaction we can use, again, see later..........
•catalytic hydrogenation (seen already) reduces a nitro functionality into an amine, which converts
a withdrawing group into a donating group - need to know!!
•You may see OTHER reducing agents used to do this reduction elsewhere (examples are Fe/HCl
or Sn/HCl), but we only use H2/Pd/C in this course because we have seen it before and to minimize
the number of reducing agents we need to learn
•the Clemmensen reduction reduces nitro groups to amines very slowly, therefore we can usually
reduce an aromatic aldehyde/ketone using the Clemmensen reduction without also reducing a
nitro group that may also be on the benzene ring
Benzenes : Page 3
Example
- H 3C -withdrawing
HO
donating C
ANY alkyl group with a 2
ANY alkyl
1. KMnO4/-OH/boiling
benzylic hydrogen is t- group
t-Bu
Bu 2. H3O+ WITHOUT a
oxidized to a -CO H
2
benzylic hydrogen
HO2C is NOT oxidized
H3CH2C
OXIDATION
note LOSS of second carbon removes
atom hydrogen adds
oxygen
•NOTE: all carbon atoms that are part of the alkyl group being oxidized are LOST, except the
single carbon that is attached to the benzene ring, which becomes the carbon of the carboxylic
acid
BrBr Br Br
exothermic reaction
nucleophile C C H = -30 kcal/mol
(LB) Br
Br
However
Solution
FeBr3
•Ferric bromide (FeBr3) is a Lewis acid catalyst, converts Br2 into a stronger electrophile
Br FeBr3
Benzenes : Page 4
Br Br FeBr3 H Br exothermic
LA Br
+ H-Br + reaction
FeBr3 H= – 11
kcal/mol
LB Product still aromatic
"sigma-
complex"
•faster reaction, stronger electrophile
Benzenes : Page 5
•overall SUBSTITUTION instead of addition
•Lewis acid catalyst regenerated
LA/Electrophile
E E H E H E
H E
R.D.S.
+ H+
LB/
"sigma-complex"
Nucleophile
•The RATE DETERMINING STEP (R.D.S.) is the reaction between the benzene and the
electrophile, the benzene is the Lewis Base/Nucleophile in the R.D.S.
•Many reactions, depending upon the particular electrophile
•All same mechanism for all reactions, in each case we just need to identify the particular
electrophile, E+
energy R.D.S.
EH
E+
E+
H+
reaction coordinate
Br E+ electrophile = a Br+
Br2/FeBr3
EQUIVALENT
Br Br FeBr3 Br Br FeBr3
Benzenes : Page 6
OH O OH2
O N H-O S OH O O N O
N
O Nitronium
O O
ion
+ HSO4 Electrophile
•you may not need to know exactly how the +NO2 electrophile is formed, but you should know the
mechanism of the subsequent electrophilic aromatic substitution reaction
SO3
H2SO4 SO3H SO3H this is the E+ electrophile
needed to do the
substitution
p-toluene sulfonic acid (TsOH)
O
O O O
S H-O S S H O S OH
+ O O
O OHO +
O O
LB/BB LA/BA electrophile
O O
O S O O S OH
H
H O SO3H
SO3H
•Dissolve SO3 (sulfur trioxide, gas) in concentrated H2SO4, makes fuming sulfuric acid
•Lewis/Brønsted acid/base reaction protonates the sulfur trioxide, this is where the E+ electrophile
comes from in this case
R
NO2 SO3H E+ =R
E+ = NO2 E+ =SO3H
•so, all we need is an alkyl cation, i.e. a carbocation, and we have seen lots of ways to make those
Benzenes : Page 7
For example
H3C
H3C CH3
C CH2
C
H3C
CH3
H Br
LA/BA
H 3C LA/BA
HBr t-Bu
3 CCH3
t-Bu
+ C CH H C H
2
H 3C H 3C
LB/BB Br
LB/BB
1. Friedel-Crafts Alkylation
Lewis Acid R
+ R-X New C-C bond
+HX
R AlCl3 R
+ Cl AlCl3
Cl+
LB LA Electrophile
Mechanism
AlCl3
H R
Cl
R
R
Example
AlCl3
+ Cl (+ HCl + AlCl3 )
But
AlCl3
+ +
Cl
H Cl
Benzenes : Page 8
rearranged
isopropyl cation
Benzenes : Page 9
Also
Cl AlCl3
AlCl3
+ Cl
faster!
slowe
r
•multiple additions occur because when 1 alkyl group adds, the new alkylated benzene becomes
more reactive than benzene itself
•withdrawing groups "pull" electrons from the ring making it less reactive as a Lewis base/Nucleophile
•because the Friedel Crafts reaction is among the slowest of the electrophilic aromatic substitution
reactions, it is the most sensitive to strong withdrawing groups on the benzene ring, a Friedel
Crafts reaction won't go when other electrophilic aromatic substitution reactions will
Examples
AlCl3
+ Cl + +
O O
O
Zn(Hg)
AlCl3
+ Cl
HCl/H2
Benzenes : Page
10
no rearrangement
•acylation followed by reduction is the "approved" method for alkylating benzenes in this course!
Benzenes : Page
11
3. Friedel-Crafts for "1 carbon" (Gatterman-Koch Reaction)
O
O
C H
C H
CO / Cl AlCl3
HCl
AlCl3
•the Friedel Crafts reagent you would WANT to use in this case, formyl chloride, unfortunately
does not exist, since it is unstable and spontaneously dissociates into carbon monoxide (CO)
and hydrogen chloride (HCl)
•Therefore you have to make it "in situ", i.e. by mixing CO and HCl, a small of formyl chloride will
form, as shown below, which can then react with aluminum trichloride to produce a small amount of
the formyl cation that will then undergo electrophilic aromatic substitution with benzene
O AlCl3 O
C C
CO + Cl H + AlCl3
HCl
H Cl
formyl Formyl cation (E+)
chloride
unstable
•CuCl is also often included as a catalyst in addition to AlCl3, but we omit it here for
simplicity to minimize reagent memorization, but be aware that you may see CuCl
elsewhere
Example - to add a methyl group to benzene, first add the corresponding formyl group to form an
aldehyde, then reduce
CO / HCl CHO Zn/Hg CH3
AlCl3 HCl/H2O
F3C – O
N C
R C
+ F O–
NH2
R C R+
O NH
NR2
HO3S RO C Cl H Ar
O O
= O N
+ OH
N 2 O CH O C R
O + Br CH2 OR
R3N R2N C
+
the halogens are electron withdrawing when attached to a -system
even though they have non-bonding electrons due to electronegativity
Benzenes : Page
12
D D
increasingly faster rates with increasingly
+ stronger E (activating) electron donating groups
+ E
D-groups are ortho- and para-
directing
E
Benzenes : Page
13
W W
increasingly slower rates with increasingly stronger
+ (deactivating) electron withdrawing
+
E
groups E W-groups are meta-directing
X
X the "exceptions"
E somewhat slower rates with halogens (X), weakly
+ deactivating
donatin Me HNO3
g + + NO2
H2SO4
40% 3% NO2 57% Why is this??
H H H
NO2 NO NO "2°" NO2
2 2
"2°" "2°" NO
2
•the methyl donor group stabilizes the charge for ortho and para attack, but not meta attack
Here is a partial reaction energy diagram for the first step in the mechanism comparing benzene and
toluene
H
relative NO2on benzene
energy
meta
R + NO2 H +
versu NO2 position
NO s
2 on
O 2N H toluene
H
Benzenes : Page
14
NO2 ortho position on toluene
reaction coordinate
Benzenes : Page
15
•The donating group makes attack at both the meta and ortho/para positions faster than for simple
benzene (the Ea smaller for both reactions with the methyl substituent), but attack at ortho/para is
faster than for meta
•Reaction does not occur at the meta position because reaction there is slow, it is NOT, it is just
not as fast as reaction at the ortho- and para-positions
HNO NO2
3
H2SO4 + +
NO2
6% 1
%
NO2
93%
•the sigma complex is LEAST destabilized for meta-
addition
NO2 O N+ O
NO2 electron withdrawing
NO2
ortho H group destabilizes
additio the sigma-
n complex
NO2 O O
N+
electron withdrawing group
meta does not DIRECTLY destabilize
additio H the
n sigma-complex
NO2 NO2
NO2 O O
N+
electron withdrawing
para group destabilizes
additio the sigma-
n complex
NO2 H NO2
NO2
O2N NO2 meta position
on
H
nitrobenzene
versus +
NO2
H
on benzene
NO2
Benzenes : Page
16
•Reaction does not occur at the meta position because reaction there is fast, it is NOT, it is just
not as slow as reaction at the ortho- and para-positions
Benzenes : Page
17
4.3 Halogens are DIFFERENT! They are Deactivating BUT Ortho- and Para-Directing!
•Electron donation versus withdrawing isn't black versus white, it isn't really binary like that
•There is a continuum, from very strong withdrawing, to weaker withdrawing to not withdrawing or
donating at all (H), to weakly donating to strongly donating.
•So we shouldn't be surprised that there are substituents that are very close to the middle, like H,
for reasons that cancel
•THIS is the HALOGENS, they are VERY CLOSE TO THE MIDDLE
increasing electron withdrawing ability increasing electron donating ability
F3C O
R C O NH2
F Cl R NH C
N C neither R NR2
O Br Ar
HO3S H O
RO C OH
O N O CH CH2 O C R
2
OR
+ R2N C
R3
N
halogens are CLOSE THE MIDDLE of the CONTINUUM
•The halogens are ELECTRONEGATIVE, therefore withdrawing via the INDUCTIVE EFFECT,
BUT, the HALOGENS also have non-bonding electrons that could, in principle, be donated
•THE HALOGENS THUS HAVE MIXED BEHAVIOR AS SUBSTITUTENTS
•The HALOGENS are electron-withdrawing, and therefore DEACTIVATING
However, HALOGENS are also ORTHO- and PARA-directing since they can stabilize the
intermediate cation (sigma complex) by RESONANCE DONATION of a pair of NON-BONDING
ELECTRONS for reaction in the ortho- and para-positions, but not in the meta- position
Example
Cl H
Cl Cl
SO3H
H
SO3H
SO3H
• We should not be surprised that there is a substituent type that is in the middle, this is the halogens!
#1
CH3 Cl CH3
Cl2 Not
#2 CH3
AlCl3 + Cl forme
d
#1 CH3 CH3 CH3 (steric)
•Reaction at positions #1 is equivalent, gives the same products, reaction at position #2 does not
occur for steric reasons
#1
HO3S CH3 CH3
SO CH CH
CH3 3 +
#2
CH 3 3
H2SO4
3
both HO3S
#2
formed
#1
•Positions #1 and positions #2 are equivalent, reaction at each #1 gives the same product same for
#2
•Electrophilic aromatic substitution reactions CAN give more than one product, we need to be aware
of this
SD OMe OMe
WD HO3S
HO3S O
STILL W
get Friedel
Cl O
Crafts acylation SD
Benzenes : Page
19
AlCl3
•The -OMe is the STRONGEST DONATING group, IT DIRECTS the reactivity because it is MORE
ACTIVATING than the weakly donating -Me substituent
•Reaction occurs at one para- position with respect to the -OMe group, the two ortho-positions
are BLOCKED, we can't substitute the -SO3H or the -CH3 substituents
•BUT WAIT! How can we have a Friedel Crafts reaction on a ring that has a strong -W substituent,
the -SO3H, doesn't that break our "rule? This is a problem with rules! Note that we also have 2
donating (activating)
Benzenes : Page
20
substituents that offset the deactivating effect of the withdrawing -SO3H. And so, we have to use
some common sense and adapt the "rule" that there is no Friedel Crafts reactions with strongly
withdrawing substituents accordingly when there are also strong donating substituents
NO2
m-
directing NO2
HNO3 Cl2
NO2
H2SO4
FeBr3
Cl
•note the different products from the two last reaction sequences, the ORDER MATTERS
CO2
1. KMNO4 CO2H
H Cl2 makes
–
OH, META-
Heat AlCl
disubstitued
2. H3O + 3 benzene
Cl
Cl CO2H
KMNO4 Cl
Cl2 makes
AlCl3 + –OH, Heat
ORTHO-
H3O+ disubstitued
benzene
Cl separate the orth-
isomer from the para-
isomer
O NO2
NO2
HNO3 Cl
O
H2SO4 AlCl3
No Reaction
W-group deactivates
towards F-C Acylation
RECALL: Friedel Crafts acylation (above) cannot be performed on the benzene that has a strong
electron withdrawing substituent
Benzenes : Page
21
Compare:
O O O
Cl HNO3
H2SO4
AlCl3
NO2
Zn/Hg Zn/
HCl/H2 Hg
O HCl/H2O
NO2 HNO3
+
H2SO4
NO2
NO2
CH2CH3 CH2CH3
SO3 H2SO4
separate
the
isomers SO3H
Br Br
O
C Br2/FeBr3
l AlCl3
O CH2CH3 SO3H
O SO Zn/ Br
Hg
3
2 W- groups, not
H2SO4 SO3H HCl/H2O SO3H obvious which
"wins"
•At each step (backwards), ask "which of the substituents can be generated, decide
which reaction to do on that basis
•Eventually you don't have to actually write out all of the possible reactions, you
can analyze the possibilities in your head
•It would be difficult to predict that Friedel-Crafts acylation should be the first step in
the synthesis problem above, these problems are definitely best solved backwards
Benzenes : Page
22
Example Synthesis Problem #2
NH2
O O Zn(Hg
NH2 ) Cl
NH2
HNO3 Cl SO3H
separate
isomersthe HCl/H2O
H SO
2 4
Cl AlCl3 Cl SO3
SO3H SO3H H SO
2 4
NO2
•Of course, there may be more than one possible solution to these problems, as above
•In reality even these reactions have complications that we don't really have the time to get into
here, specifically, once the amine is formed the Freidel crafts reaction becomes very slow again
even though the amine is very activating, because the amine will also undergo a Lewis acid base
reaction with the AlCl3, making it less donating, organic can be complicated sometimes!
X XNu Nu
Nu :X +
nucleophile elimina
addition
Benzenes : Page
23
halide anion leaves takes electrons
•the X- can be a good leaving group, BUT, there are no SN1 or SN2 reactions at an sp2 hybridized
carbon atom
•one way round this is the addition/elimination mechanism
Benzenes : Page
24
Nu Nu
X X Nu
X Nu XNu W
W W W W X
+
elimination
addition leaving group
W W W W
W
•When a NUCLEOPHILE is the reactant, then substitution occurs for a halogen, not hydrogen, as
occurs when an electrophile is the reactant
•Only works with W = strong withdrawing group in ortho- or para- position
•Only works with strong nucleophile
Examples
strong nucleophile
moderate nucleophile
Cl H Cl
N H NH
strong NH3 2
W H + H–Cl
NO NO Hea
NO2 NO2 NO2
2
strong
2
t NO2
W
Benzenes : Page
25
7 Summary of Aromatic Reactions
Do NOT start studying by trying to memorize the reactions here!
Work as many problems as you can, with this list of reactions in front of you if necessary, so that
you can get through as many problems as you can without getting stuck on the reagents/conditions,
and so that you can learn and practice solving reaction problems. Use this list AFTER you have
worked all of the problems, and just before an exam. By then you will have learned a lot of the
reagents/conditions just by using them and you will only have to memorize what you haven't
learned yet. Then do the following:
•Cover the entire page of reagents/conditions with a long vertical strip of paper, see if you can write
down the reagents/conditions for each reaction, check to see which you get correct, if COMPLETELY
correct, circle Y, if incorrect or even slightly incorrect, circle N. In this way you keep track of what
you know and what you don't know.
•Keep coming back to this list and so the same thing only for those reactions you circled N, until all
are circled Y.
Knowing the reagents/conditions on this page is INSUFFICIENT to do well on an exam since you will
ALSO need to recognize how to use and solve reaction problems in different contexts, this page
ONLY helps you to learn the reagents/conditions that you have not YET learned by working
problems.
O
Zn (Hg)
Y/N
HCl /H2O
(Clemmenson reduction)
Et Me HO2C CO2H
1. KMnO4 / –OH/boil
Y/N
t- 2. H3O+ t-
Bu NH2
NO2
Bu H2/Pd/C
Y/N
Br
Br2
Y/N
FeBr
3 Cl
Cl2 Y/N
AlCl
SO3H
3
Y/N
SO3
H2SO4 NO2
Y/N
HNO3
H2SO
4
Cl /AlCl3 +
Y/N
(Friedel-Crafts alkylation)
do not use in synthesis
O
O /AlCl C
3
Cl Y/N
(Friedel-Crafts acylation) H
CO/HCl/AlCl3 (CuCl) CO
Y/N
Benzenes : Page
26
(Gatterman Koch reaction)
CuCl should be included, we omit it for simplicity
Cl NaOCH3/CH3OH OCH3
Y/N
O2N NO2 (nucleophilic aromatic substitution) O2N NO2
Benzenes : Page
27
Benzenes : Page
28