e SXSW 2020: CARGO: Interesting Identifying(https://www.filminquiry.

com/)
The Self In Christopher RUPAUL’S DRAG RACE S12E7
But Unfocused Nolan’s MEMENTO “Madonna: The Unauthorized
h- (https://www.filminquiry.com/cargo- (https://www.filminquiry.com/identifying- Rusical”: An Immaculate Episode
2020-review/) self-memento/) Causes A Commotion
APRIL 14, 2020 · 3 MINS READ APRIL 13, 2020 · 4 MINS READ
(https://www.filminquiry.com/rupauls-
drag-race-s12e7/)
APRIL 13, 2020 · 9 MINS READ

FILM THEORY (HTTPS://WWW.FILMINQUIRY.COM/CATEGORY/RESOURCES/FILM-THEORY/), RESOURCES (HTTPS://WWW.FILMINQUIRY.COM/CATEGORY/RESOURCES/)

Book Adaptations And The Fidelity Argument

AUGUST 12, 2016

Last month it was announced that Kirsten Dunst, in her directorial debut, will be directing Dakota
Fanning in an adaptation of Sylvia Plath’s The Bell Jar. (http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0844467/) In
an interview (http://www.indiewire.com/2015/10/kirsten-dunst-says-midnight-special-will-screen-at-
sxsw-2016-is-co-writing-a-dark-comedy-she-plans-to-direct-110988/), Dunst has noted that her
approach in adapting the seminal text has been to avoid the ‘didactic’ and instead ‘make a life of
something … you really need to make your own scenes up’.

Such an approach, while entirely refreshing for me, is one that regularly receives criticism from
those that view the source text as somehow sacred, and thus static and intractable.

The fidelity argument

As with all adaptations of beloved source texts, there are those who would prefer the adaptation to
Scroll To Top

be rendered on-screen as entirely faithful to the central conceit posited by the author. Anything less,
for those who demand fidelity, is lacking.

/
For the purposes of discussion surrounding film adaptation, fidelity refers to the ‘notion that
(https://www.filminquiry.com/)
purportedly measures the extent to which a work of literature has been accurately rendered (or not)
as a movie’ (McFarlane, 2007). Yet those who belief utter faithfulness to a text is essential, are
entirely misunderstanding the medium of film. It is impossible to simply project the text on-screen,
and this should certainly not be encouraged, as to do so underestimates the power and capacity of
film.

Jennifer Lawrence was deemed as ‘not thin enough’ to play Katniss – The Hunger Games (2012) –
source: Lionsgate Films

Indeed, this concept of faithfulness seems incongruous with the very nature of reading a literary text
as each reading is ‘a highly individual act of cognition and interpretation’ (ibid.) and yet, each
individual will frequently cite their disappointment that the film has not lived up to their own individual
expectations, as if it ever could. One only has to look at the furore involved regarding any adaptation
process which included detailed and exhaustive discussion of casting, setting and dialogue to see
how convoluted any adaptation is.

Daniel Craig’s casting as Bond (http://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/film/jamesbond/9213016/James-

Bond-Sam-Mendes-held-doubts-over-Daniel-Craigs-role-as-007.html), or Jennifer Lawrence’s
portrayal of Katniss Everdeen (http://www.eonline.com/news/303277/the-hunger-games-cast-talks-
fan-backlash-and-josh-hutcherson-s-blond-hair-i-was-definitely-more-dumb) in The Hunger Games
(http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1392170/)generated much disgruntlement, with fans frequently citing
their own perception of the character as their starting point for any casting decisions.

Similarly, one only has to search online for book adaptations to be met with a myriad of articles citing
inexcusable changes (http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/06/26/book-adaptation-changes-
_n_3502006.html) made during the adaptation process. It seems rather bizarre that such critics
expect their own, highly personal interpretation to not only be the one seen on-screen, but that they
also dismiss the idea that the resulting adaptation is simply the director’s own personal response to
the text.

The capabilities of film

Often, an adaptation of an intellectual novel is seen as an attempt to please the masses. Still,
despite the plethora of finely crafted book adaptations, there still exists some sense of disparity
between the quality of a novel and the quality of a film. Many cite the concept that a ‘film makes
fewer demands on the imagination than a book does’ (ibid.) suggesting that the reading of a novel
allows for the development of imagination, whereas a film is rather prescriptive in its viewing.
Scroll To Top

/
 (https://www.filminquiry.com/)

Spectre (2015) – source: Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer Pictures

Certainly a film cannot possibly allow for the same multifaceted interpretation in terms of visuals, as
those visuals are presented on-screen, but such an approach is highly reductive and simply does
not recognise the capabilities of film in comparison to a novel.

A viewer of a film is not simply passive as a viewing of a film requires the same intense analysis as
any novel. After all, for a film to be effective it ‘will require that we pay attention to the intricate
interaction of mise-en-scéne … the editing … and sound’ (ibid.). In fact, a film can and does offer a
more varied approach when featuring narrators as Stam (2004) writes:

“In a novel, the narrator controls the only track – the verbal track. In a film, the narrator can
partially control the verbal track – through voice-over – but that control is subject to
innumerable constraints … In a film, the other characters instantly gain a physical
presence denied them in the novel.”

Thus an adaptation allows for a greater variety of interpretation and character development.

Creating a successful adaptation

How then, can a text be adapted successfully? Importantly, a detailed understanding of the novel’s
central concept is crucial, yet that should not necessarily be considered as the starting point. Some
of the best book adaptations are ones that demonstrate little deference to the author’s intention.

Rather, it is a clear creation of tone and mood that is more important than any adherence to dialogue
or plot development. Ultimately, an entirely faithful adaptation is, for me, useless. Film is its own
medium and art form, and should be treated as such. An adaptation is not simply a visual form of the
words typed.
SEE ALSO

(https://ww EPISODE REVIEWS (HTTPS://WWW.FILMINQUIRY.COM/CATEGORY/TV/EPISODE-REVIEWS/), TV

(HTTPS://WWW.FILMINQUIRY.COM/CATEGORY/TV/)
w.filminquir
THE PLOT AGAINST AMERICA “Part 1”: A Familiar Beginning
y.com/the-
(https://www.filminquiry.com/the-plot-against-america-s1e1/)
plot-
against-
america-
s1e1/)
Scroll To Top

/
 (https://www.filminquiry.com/)

The Lisbon Sisters in The Virgin Suicides (1999) – source : Paramount Classics

Watch Sofia Coppola’s The Virgin Suicides (http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0159097/?ref_=nv_sr_1)for

a masterclass in film adaptation. Her film not only captures the listless quality of Eugenides’s novel,
but successfully creates a dreamlike tone through music and visuals. Such creation is obviously
impossible to do so in a novel.

Coppola recognises that her adaptation is, once projected on-screen, an artwork in its own right.
For me, this is the approach to take. One that recognises the possibility and capability of film and
extolling these virtues, does so to create an individual response with little consideration to individual
readings.

Do you agree? Which adaptation is your favourite?

Bibliography:

McFarlane, B. (2007) The Cambridge companion to literature on screen. Edited by Deborah

Cartmell and Imelda Whelehan. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Stam, R. (2004) Literature through film: Realism, magic, and the art of adaptation. Malden, MA:
Blackwell Publishing.

Opinions expressed in our articles are those of the authors and not of the Film Inquiry magazine.

Affiliate disclosure: Our articles contain affiliate links. If you choose to buy something through any of these links, we may earn
referral fees, without any extra cost to you. Thanks for your support!

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER

Sign up to get our cinematic goodness delivered to your inbox every weekend.

YOUR E-MAIL

SIGN UP

 I would like to receive news and special offers.

TAGS BASED ON BOOK (HTTPS://WWW.FILMINQUIRY.COM/TAG/BASED-ON-BOOK/)

FIDELITY ARGUMENT (HTTPS://WWW.FILMINQUIRY.COM/TAG/FIDELITY-ARGUMENT/)
FILM THEORY (HTTPS://WWW.FILMINQUIRY.COM/TAG/FILM-THEORY/)
SCREENWRITING (HTTPS://WWW.FILMINQUIRY.COM/TAG/SCREENWRITING/)
Scroll To Top

/
 (https://www.filminquiry.com/)
SIOBHAN DENTON (HTTPS://WWW.FILMINQUIRY.COM/AUTHOR/SIOBHAN-DENTON/) (https://theblueandthedim.wordpress.com/)

(http://twitter.com/siobhan_denton)

Siobhan is a teacher and writer living in Wales, UK. She holds a BA in English and an MA in Film and Television Studies. She is
especially interested in depictions of female desire, transitions from youth to adulthood and performative gender. She tweets at
@siobhan_denton and writes at https://theblueandthedim.wordpress.com/

(https://www.facebook.com/sharer.php? (https://twitter.com/share?
 SHARE u=https://www.filminquiry.com/book-  TWEET text=Book%20Adaptations%20And%20The%20Fidelity%20Argument&via=filminquiry&url=https
adaptations-fidelity-argument/)
(https://reddit.com/submit? adaptations-fidelity-argument/)

 SHARE url=https://www.filminquiry.com/book-
adaptations-fidelity-argument/) (mailto:?
 SHARE subject=Book%20Adaptations%20And%20The%20Fidelity%20Argument&body=Book%20Adaptations%20And%20The%20Fidelity%20Argument%20
adaptations-fidelity-argument/)

0 Comments Film Inquiry 🔒 Privacy Policy 

1 Login

 Recommend t Tweet f Share Sort by Newest

Start the discussion…

LOG IN WITH
OR SIGN UP WITH DISQUS ?

Name

Be the first to comment.

✉ Subscribe d Add Disqus to your siteAdd DisqusAdd

⚠ D N t S ll M D t

RELATED POSTS

(https://www.filminquiry.com/the- (https://www.filminquiry.com/starting- (https://www.filminquiry.com/emma- (https://www.filminquiry.com/the-

plot-against-america-part-4/) out-screenwriter/) 2020-review/) plot-against-america-3/)

EPISODE REVIEWS RESOURCES FILM REVIEWS EPISODE REVIEWS

(HTTPS://WWW.FILMINQUIRY.COM/CATEGORY/TV/EPISODE-
(HTTPS://WWW.FILMINQUIRY.COM/CATEGORY/RESOURCES/)
(HTTPS://WWW.FILMINQUIRY.COM/CATEGORY/REVIEWS/)
(HTTPS://WWW.FILMINQUIRY.COM/CATEGORY/T
REVIEWS/), TV REVIEWS/), TV
(HTTPS://WWW.FILMINQUIRY.COM/CATEGORY/TV/) (HTTPS://WWW.FILMINQUIRY.COM/CATEGORY/T
The Pros, Cons & How-Tos Of Starting Out EMMA: Gossip, Regal Mayhem & Love
THE PLOT AGAINST AMERICA “Part 4”: As A Screenwriter (https://www.filminquiry.com/emma-2020- THE PLOT AGAINST AMERICA “Part 3”:
The Judgment Of History (https://www.filminquiry.com/starting-out- review/) A Terrifying New Reality
(https://www.filminquiry.com/the-plot- screenwriter/) (https://www.filminquiry.com/the-plot-
against-america-part-4/) against-america-3/)
Scroll To Top

/
 (https://www.filminquiry.com/)

(https://www.filminquiry.com/)  
(HTTPS://FACEBOOK.COM/FILMINQUIRY) (HTTPS://TWITTER.COM/FILMINQUIRY)

(HTTPS://YOUTUBE.COM/CHANNEL/UCZFZ4DP48M8UZXO46GO30LG)

TEAM(HTTPS://WWW.FILMINQUIRY.COM/TEAM/) ABOUT(HTTPS://WWW.FILMINQUIRY.COM/ABOUT/) © 2020 Film Inquiry. All Rights Reserved.AD

WRITE FOR US(HTTPS://WWW.FILMINQUIRY.COM/WRITE-FOR-US/)

Scroll To Top