LPC Solicitors Accounts LGS Handout 2425
LPC Solicitors Accounts LGS Handout 2425
SOLICITORS’
ACCOUNTS
LGS Handout
24/25
1. The SRA Accounts Rules (SARs) (in force from 25 November 2019), by which
the SRA controls the handling by solicitors of clients’ money.
You need to be able to engage with the SARs and resolve problems by reference
to them. The SARs make clear that both the firm and individuals within the firm
are bound by the SARs.
The SRA is rightly concerned that all solicitors are taught and assessed in the basics of the
Rules and the manner of their operation. Issues such as money laundering and the danger
of your practice being used as a criminal’s bank account are examples of the real dangers
presented. The basic understanding and assessment of the system is best conducted using
manual paper driven systems.
In practice, of course, computerised systems are used almost universally and a wide
variety of these are available. The principles however derive directly from the paper
systems which follow; every debit has a matching credit and the decision about which
account to post funds to has to be made irrespective of whether the system works on
paper or in an electronic medium.
The first requirement is that you understand the SRA Accounts Rules. This handout is the
starting point for an understanding of the Rules. We have set out overleaf a copy of Part
1 and Part 2 of the SRA Account Rules. (You can access the Rules in full here in your SRA
Codes of Conduct & Account Rules book). They give the basic rules for handling client
money and its necessary separation from money belonging to the business.
The Rules also detail how you should deal with other money belonging to clients or third
parties (Part 3) and the issue of accountants’ reports, storage and retention (Part 4). You
must read these in full, in your own time.
At the outset it is probably worth synthesising the effect of the SARs into the following
three rules. If you understand these then by following the principles, you will probably be
correct:
1. You need separate bank accounts for Client money and the solicitor’s money
(Business money).
3. But although the client money can be held in one bank account you can never
pay out more on behalf of an individual client than stands to his credit on
Client account (because if you did that the other clients would be ‘bailing him
out’).
You should spend some time becoming broadly familiar with the SARs themselves. The
multiple-choice questions in the assessment may probe your knowledge of the operation
of the SARs. You will be able to refer to your ‘SRA Codes of Conduct and Accounts Rules’
book during the assessment but that would not be a good time to approach them for the
first time.
Introduction
Client account
i.e. Client money must be kept separate from
3.1 You only maintain a client business money. Even more fundamental.
account at a branch (or the head
office) of a bank or a building
Mixed payments are complicated. In simple
society in England and Wales. terms, if you receive money which is partly the
client’s, and partly yours (e.g. a cheque of
3.2 You ensure that the name of money for a completion and repayment of
any client account includes: disbursements you have made, it can either be
split between client account and the Business
© Nottingham Trent University Page 6 of 20
/conversion/tmp/activity_task_scratch/885884531.docx
account or all paid into Client account and the
(a) the name of the part which is the firm’s then being transferred
authorised body; and off.
Payment of interest
1.3 Part 3: Dealing with other money belonging to clients or third parties
There are situations where a solicitor does not need to maintain a client account. There
are limited circumstances where client money can be held in the business account.
However, there are other ways in which the client’s money might be managed. The three
methods referred to in Part 3 of the SARs are:
An example of when this might happen is if the solicitor is one of the executors of the
deceased and the other person is a lay person. The money of the estate does not have to
be placed in a client account but can be held in an account in the joint names of the
solicitor and other executor.
Rule 9.1 provides that Part 2 of the Rules does not apply to such an account, but it will
still be necessary to comply with Rule 8.2 and Rule 8.4.
An example of when this might happen is when the client lacks mental capacity to
operate their own account and where the solicitor has been appointed as an attorney
© Nottingham Trent University Page 10 of 20
/conversion/tmp/activity_task_scratch/885884531.docx
under a lasting power of attorney or where the solicitor has been appointed as a deputy
by the Court of Protection.
Rule 10.1 provides that most of Part 2 of the Rules does not apply, but it will still be
necessary to comply with Rule 8.2, 8.3 and 8.4.
TPMAs are bank or building society accounts operated by third party companies that
provide a facility for the management of client’s money and are an alternative to the
solicitor management the client’s money through a client account. Any money held in the
TMPA will not be ‘client money’ and will therefore not be subject to the SRA Account
Rules.
So far, we have introduced you to the SRA Accounts Rules. We will now look to put these
rules into a practical context by considering some basic transactions, how double entry
bookkeeping is used and what solicitors’ ledger accounts look like.
3 Ledger Accounts
As discussed, a solicitor’s firm will hold client money and they will need to keep this
money separate from the money belonging to the business. Solicitors therefore use
‘simple ledger accounts’ to keep a record of this. These simple ledger account will have a
column for the date of the transaction, a column for the description, two columns to
record the debit (DR) and credit (CR) entries and then a column for the balance. As
solicitors hold and use client money, solicitors will need ledgers to record what is
happening with the client’s money as well as ledgers recording what is happening with
the firm’s money (business money). You can see an example simple ledger account
below:
Smith has instructed us in a county court action against Jones. He gives us £500 on
general account. We could only pay it into business if we had delivered a bill for this
precise sum - it would then be our money. This is not our money, so it goes to client
account. See Rule 2.1 and 2.3.
Remember Rule 8.1(c) requires solicitors to keep a cash book to record the running total
of all transactions through the client accounts held by the solicitor. As a matter of good
practice, a firm will also keep a cash book for business money (as well as client money).
For this module you will be expected to understand how to prepare a cash ledger/cash
sheet. A cash ledger/sheet keeps a record of all the monies which are coming in to and
going out of both the business and client bank accounts held by the firm. You will learn
to do this as part of the process of double entry bookkeeping.
We pay a £70 court fee. We have money in client account and there is no reason why we
cannot use it to pay this disbursement on his behalf. See Rule 5.1.
There is no reason why we could not have paid that disbursement from business account
(though as it is the solicitor’s own money that is then being used when making a
payment from business it is better to use client account where possible). We now pay an
enquiry agent (£28) and this time we will pay it from business account.
This tends to happen mostly at the end of the transaction when the solicitor transfers
from client account the moneys owed to him in costs, VAT and expenses met. Of course,
if an exact sum is paid to the solicitor by way of reimbursement of a sum expended on
the client’s behalf, it is the solicitor’s money. The solicitor should then pay it direct into
business unless he pays it into client but transfers it to business promptly.
(Very unrealistically) Smith reimburses us with the amount we have spent on that
enquiry agent.
Important!
An individual client’s business account naturally throws a debit (‘DR’) balance. If there is
a credit (‘CR’) balance you probably have client money in there - trouble.
1. The solicitor’s own money is being used when anything is paid from business
account. Practices do not like doing this as they have a habit of running an
overdraft on business account at the bank; such borrowing is expensive.
2. There may be VAT reasons why client account cannot be used even if there are
funds in there (principal payments - see later in the module).
5. Recording Costs
Smith having withdrawn the action we charge him £400 costs plus VAT at 20% (£80).
On a number of transactions, and especially property ones, the bill of costs which is sent
to the client has with it a statement of account. On this may appear a number of other
expenses which have been made or which it is anticipated will be made. So typically,
the account might appear as follows:
© Nottingham Trent University Page 15 of 20
/conversion/tmp/activity_task_scratch/885884531.docx
Costs 800
VAT 160
Search Fees (already paid) 60
Land Registry Fees (yet to be paid) 120
Total 1,140
Although the statement of account which the client receives will show the amount of
£1,140 as being required, not all of this sum will yet have appeared on the
business/client accounts.
The search fee which has already been paid will have appeared (probably in business
account) and, at the moment the bill is sent out, so will the Costs and VAT (in business
account).
But the land registry fee has not yet been paid and so will not appear anywhere in the
accounts.
See Rule 2.1(d). The effect of this is that money received for all fees and disbursements
paid to the firm are considered client money unless and until they are billed. The
definition of client money does not include money received for disbursements which
have already been paid, so where money is received for reimbursements of such a
payment, it is receipt of business money by the firm. Where money is received for an
unpaid disbursement (such as the land registry fee), this is client money. See also Rule
4.1, 4.2 and 4.3.
When the client sends the gross sum of £1,140 the firm needs to decide how to deal with
this payment:
Options:
i) the cheque could be split so that the amount owed to business account could be paid
there with the balance going to client account (although banks aren’t keen on splitting
cheques anymore!)
Illustration of i) – Splitting
Or,
ii) (much more likely) the entirety of the sum could be paid into one account before the
element belonging to the other account is transferred (rule 4.2 requires mixed
payments to be ‘allocated promptly’ to the correct account).
Firms will have their own policies on what to do with mixed receipts, but it is generally
advisable to pay the mixed monies into the client account and then transfer the
business element to the business account.
© Nottingham Trent University Page 16 of 20
/conversion/tmp/activity_task_scratch/885884531.docx
Illustration of ii) - Paying all into Client
There will now be enough money in client account to pay the Land Registry fee when it
falls due (out of client) and transfer to business the amount owed to the practice.
Or,
The entirety of the sum could be paid into the business account and the client money
could be transferred over the client account. Whilst possible, this method is very unlikely
to be used.
6. Transfers
These are very common and there are two basic sorts; between business and client
account (extremely common) and between the client accounts of different clients (rather
less common). The two are fundamentally different. Don’t mix them up.
See Rule 8.1(a). This requires firms to record on each client’s ledger account all client
and business money receipts and payments made for that client on the client and
business section of the accounts. Therefore, if a client’s money is withdrawn from the
client bank account and is paid into the business bank account, this must be recorded.
Notes: 1. Think of it as two double entries (it is). First, the money comes out of client
account (ledger and cash sheet entries). Second, it arrives in business
account (ledger and cash sheet entries).
2. Money has gone out of one bank account and into another, therefore both
sets of double entries must be shown on our ledger accounts
6.1.2 From business to client which is rather less common; typically, it might be done
where a mistake has been made and a shortfall must be made up on client account by
transfer from business. See rule 6.1.
A MAJOR
Client: Baker - divorce Business Client error. It
Date Particulars Dr Cr Bal Dr Cr Bal must be
corrected
Apr 1 Cash/you 800 800 immediate
ly
Apr 22 Cash/Damages paid 900 (100)
Apr 23 Cash/Tfr 100 100 100 -
2. Again, money has gone out of one bank account and into another, therefore
both sets of double entries must be shown on our ledger accounts.
This is quite different because the amount of money in the firm’s bank accounts does not
change. If we move money from client account of client Davies to the client account of
client Thomas, the total at the bank remains unchanged. What does change is the name
under which we hold the money. See rule 8.1.
We hold £4,000 for Davies and on Feb 3rd he instructs us to transfer £100 to the account
of Thomas, who is also a client.
Notes:
2. The total balances on the firm’s bank accounts are unaffected. The balances
on business bank account and client bank account have not altered. All we
have done is reallocate who that money in our client bank account belongs to
on our client ledgers.