EDs ULB Labs FULL REPORT2 Sections 5-To-7 9may2025
EDs ULB Labs FULL REPORT2 Sections 5-To-7 9may2025
FULL REPORT – This document comes with full answers and results, all in blue and tele-
graphese.
Table of contents 0
0 Safety instructions 1
1 COMPAK, instrumentation, HLL (halogen lamp load) and C3 (3-phase capacitor) 1
2 IM – ratings – NL starting with COMPAK – tripping the circuit breaker 1
3 DCM – ratings – excitation – NL operation – OC NL test and saturation curve 1
4 SM – ratings – excitation – grid synchronisation – OC NL test and saturation curve 1
1
5 IM – identification tests – equivalent circuit 1
5.1 IM – standstill test (at reduced voltage) – COMPAK . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1
5.2 IM – NL test at rated voltage – fully idle {DCM or SM} . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2
5.3 IM – equivalent circuit at rated voltage . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3
5.4 Optional – IM + COMPAK– saturation curve (DCM-OC or SM-OC) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3
5.5 IM + COMPAK – loading with {DCM or SM} + HLL . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
5.6 IM – coasting – {only DCM} fully idle or excited . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5
5.7 Optional – IM + COMPAK – 2-phase and 1-phase supply – idle {DCM or SM} . . . . . . . . . 6
10 IM + ACS – DTC & torque or speed reference – idle or excited {DCM or SM} 20
10.1 Optional – Friction (+ iron losses) torque versus speed – with DTC . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20
10.2 Acceleration with torque reference – moment of inertia – idle {only DCM } . . . . . . . . . . . . 22
Figure 1: IM – Test at standstill and 10% voltage, ph-n voltage and current (LEFT), plus product of
voltage and current with MATH ⇥ (RIGHT)
Looking at the zero crossings e.g., get the phase lag (in ms and in ) of the current w.r.t. the
voltage. Calculate the power factor.
phase shift: 1.6 * 2.5 ms = 4 ms = 72
power factor: cos ' = 0.309 (sin ' = 0.951)
SFR From the RMS values of voltage and current, and with the above obtained power factor,
calculate active power.
23.5 V rms ph-n, 2.18 A rms
P = 3*23.5*2.18*0.309 = 47.5 W
SFR Calculate apparent and reactive power, and get a rough estimate of the total leakage
reactance.
S = 3 * 23.5 * 2.18 = 153.7 VA
Q = S * 0.951 = 146.3 VAr
Xl = 146.3/3/2.182 = 10.3 ⌦
SFR From the active power, get a rough estimate (order of magnitude) of the rotor resistance.
reminder: Rs = 1.7 ⌦ (cold, measured with the DMM at Lab1)
Rtot = 47.5/3/2.182 = 3.26 ⌦, Rr = Rtot Rs = 1.56 ⌦
Rs and Rr are not very di↵erent (and here quite close to each other), as can be expected.
SFR Besides the temperature dependence, there is also the speed or, more precisely, the rotor
frequency dependence. What is the rotor frequency at standstill? Compare to rated operation.
50 Hz at standstill, compared to 40/1500*50 = 1.333 Hz at rated speed; so we can assume that some skin
e↵ect occurs in the rotor bars at standstill (and low speed), which is wholly beneficial for starting, see
the theory
Extrapolate linearly the standstill current to full-voltage supply, i.e. simply apply the rule of 3.
Give the value in % (compared to rated current). Does this agree with theory?
rule of 3: 2.18 * 230/23.5 = 21.3 A
This is manifestly much more than the rated 6 A, namely by a factor 3.6.
In the theory, a factor 5 to 10 is mentioned. Here, with our 3 kW IM, we are a bit below, no worries.
Figure 2: IM – Test at quasi-synchronous speed and rated voltage, ph-n voltage and current (LEFT),
plus product of voltage and current with MATH ⇥ (RIGHT)
Figure 3: Complete IM equivalent circuit with approximate values for 50 Hz operation at rated voltage
and at ambient temperature
See Figure 4.
ALSO included in this figure: results at synchronous speed using DCM+DCS (with 1500 rpm reference), to be
done later if time is left, who knows..
SFR What is the influence of the significant slip below, say, 200 V ph-ph?
The test at (nearly) constant speed allows to get very easily a good approximation of the magnetising reactance.
It is around 80 ⌦ at rated voltage, and maximum 105 to 110 ⌦ (between, say, 80 and 250 V ph-ph); this variation
is simply the result of saturation, as expected.
Figure 4: IM noload test results at either synchronous speed (using DCM+DCS) or variable speed
(and significant slip at low voltage, idle DCM): voltage versus current curves, and Vs/Is
versus voltage curves
When the speed is as low as 1431 rpm, we are very far away from noload operation, and the test is absolutely
unsuited for determining the magnetising reactance. The simple division V /I leads to completely erroneous
values.
Second and third operating points: excite further for reaching first either rated IM speed
(1460 rpm) or rated IM current (6 A), and next go on till the other limit, assuming that they
will not be reached simply jointly (even if they should). Take note of all the measurements for
both operating points.
SFR For both operating points: calculate the power consumed by the HLL. Estimate and add
losses as much as possible, for arriving at some rough IM shaft power and torque estimates.
Which losses are to be neglected at this stage for lack of data?
What general conclusions can be drawn regarding the IM nameplate data?
Start the IM. At close to synchronous speed, disconnect the COMPAK/AC supply (via the
CA/0/CC rotary switch). Observe the deceleration speed profile on the scope. Is the deceleration
rather constant or exponential-like?
See figure 5.
The speed goes down rather with a constant slope than as an exponential. This means that there is more
dry friction torque (which is independent of speed) than viscous friction torque (that is proportional with
speed).
Figure 5: Free deceleration of IM+DCM (with DCM completely OC-ed), from synchronous speed,
1500 rpm, till standstill in 12 s
Figure 6: Free deceleration of IM+SM set-up, from 1500 rpm till standstill, with IM OC-ed, and with
SM excited or not (LEFT to RIGHT: Ie equal to 0, 1.5 and 3 A resp., in around 18, 6 and
3.3 s resp.)
How much time till complete standstill? Calculate the average deceleration value (in rpm/s and
in rad/s2 ).
e.g. with IM+DCM set-up
Around 12 s from synchronous speed till standstill.
The average slope is then 1500/12 = 125 rpm/s = 13.1 rad/s2
IM-SM set-up
SFR Assume a total moment of inertia of 0.05 kg m2 and derive a rough estimate of average
mechanical dry friction torque.
Tf,dry = 0.05 ⇤ 13.1 = 0.65 Nm
Excite the DCM with half rated excitation current, i.e. around 0.5 A. Repeat the previous point.
What is di↵erent?
With the {DCM or SM} turning and excited (with armature OC-ed), there are iron losses produced in
the DCM (rotor core) or SM (stator core). This corresponds to an additional EM braking torque and
results in quicker deceleration.
Repeat with 1 A.
E.g. with IM+DCM and Ie = 1 A, see figure 7.
a) Get started with the DCS550 drive: check the machine parameters, START/STOP, change the
speed reference, consult the Actual values...
b) Observe the voltage and current waveforms resulting from the two thyristor converters supplying
armature and excitation winding respectively.
Figure 8: Excitation voltage and current waveforms with DCS550 – at standstill (LEFT) and at
1500 rpm with OC-ed armature (RIGHT)
The converter supplying the excitation current is a half-controlled rectifier, comprising 3 thyristors and
3 diodes. This is 3-pulse rectification; the fundamental DC voltage and current ripple is at 150 Hz, as we
can verify on the scope.
See also chapter 2 and the waveforms on slide 44 (right half).
The average excitation current is around 1 A. There is no flux weakening (or just a little bit).
The firing angle ↵ can be estimated from the overlap of the rectified voltage and the ph-ph grid voltage.
c) Set a 1500 rpm speed reference, Start. Repeat the previous point.
What is di↵erent compared to the 0 rpm operating point?
See Figure 8–RIGHT.
One remarkable di↵erence compared to standstill is the lower excitation current, around 0.54 A on average.
This is clearly flux weakening.
Also note the bigger presence of little spikes in current and voltage, mainly spaced at 150 Hz.
Leave the IM OC-ed to begin with. Its noload operation follows later.
Proceed as follows:
a) Connect to the scope:
CH1: armature voltage, CH2: armature current, CH3: 1 ph-ph grid voltage (out of 6)
b) Set a 1500 rpm speed reference via the DCS550 and Start.
Take note of 1.06 MotCur, 1.08 MotTorq...
Observe on the scope the armature voltage and current waveforms, along with 1 ph-ph grid
voltage. Discuss the waveforms.
See Figure 9–LEFT
Figure 9: Armature voltage and current waveforms with DCS550 (plus 1 ph-ph grid voltage) – noload
operation at +1500 rpm (LEFT) and 1500 rpm (RIGHT), with DCS speed reference and
idle IM
The thyristor converter supplies a small current, of less than 1 A on average. This is 6-pulse rectification,
with 6 current humps (bumps) per AC cycle. This is also Discontinuous Conduction Mode (DCM), the
armature current canceling in-between 2 humps.
The positive armature current is supplied by 1 of the 2 thyristor bridges, while the other one follows
voltage-wise (with a complementary firing angle ↵2 , i.e. ↵1 + ↵2 = 180 and thus cos ↵2 = cos ↵1 ), see
slide 41 of chapter 2.
During the intervals of 0 armature current, the armature voltage is equal to the back emf (plus some
oscillation and noise).
From the overlap of the armature voltage and the ph-ph grid voltage, one can estimate the firing angle
↵1 of the thyristor bridge.
This is noload motoring in positive direction, so ↵1 is situated in the 0 to 90 range for sure.
d) ATTENTION: Connect the IM to COMPAK/AC, with one phase order or the inverse one,
and apply voltage very gradually while it is turning at 1500 rpm (driven by the DCM + DCS).
With a slip s that is close to either 0 (correct phase order) or 2 (wrong phase order), the IM
draws a small or much bigger (and manifestly too big) current when increasing voltage. In any
case, change the inverse order and observe the other case.
Finish with the correct phase order, and with noload operation of the IM at rated voltage.
a) From the noload operation at +1500 rpm (or 1500 rpm in point c below), change the speed
reference of the DCS550 gradually toward +1510 rpm (or 1510 rpm).
Changing the reference speed of the DCS live (i.e. while it is running) appears rather slow. Note
that each press of the button is registered. So, for avoiding over-current and possibly shutting
down of the drive, while the COMPAK40 is connected to the grid, it is advised to change the
reference speed slowly.
In each of the cases (with either positive or negative speed), which machine is motoring, and
which one generating/braking?
The IM being directly connected to the 50 Hz COMPAK supply, with one phase order, it brakes/generates
at any supersynchronous speed, i.e. above 1500 rpm. So the DCM motors.
And vice versa at speeds below 1500 rpm: the IM motors and the DCM brakes/generates. Rated IM
motor operation is at 1460 rpm (according to the nameplate).
With inversed phase order and synchronous speed equal to 1500 rpm, the IM motors at speeds between
standstill and 1500 rpm, with rated IM motor operation at 1460 rpm.
Braking/generating of the IM, with the DCM motoring, requires then a speed below 1500 rpm (or above
1500 rpm in absolute value!).
So things are symmetric with respect to 0 speed.
b) For the +1510 rpm operating point, take note of 1.06 MotCur, 1.08 MotTorq...
Observe on the scope the armature voltage and current waveforms, along with 1 ph-ph grid
voltage.
Discuss the waveforms.
See Figure 10–LEFT.
Figure 10: Armature voltage and current waveforms with DCS550 (plus 1 grid ph-ph voltage) – motor-
ing at +1510 rpm (LEFT) and 1510 rpm (RIGHT), with IM connected to COMPAK/AC
(rated voltage, one phase order and the inverse one)
Positive armature voltage and current, as before (noload DCM motoring in positive direction).
We observe again the 6-pulse rectification.
But now with significant current (in average around 6.55 A) and clearly Continuous Conduction Mode
(CCM), with the armature current never canceling.
The first bridge supplies the current.
The voltage has a close to sawtooth waveform (with the descending flanks having some curvature). In
CCM, there are no more intervals of constant voltage (equal to the back emf).
c) Repeat for the other speed, 1510 rpm, but proceed cautiously: Stop, deactivate the IM, set a
1500 rpm reference, apply voltage to the IM (with inversed phase order), and only then modify
the speed reference.
See Figure 10–RIGHT.
With the DCM motoring in negative direction, armature voltage and current are negative, as they appear
on the scope.
It is the 2nd bridge that supplies the current. With respect to that bridge, voltage and current are positive.
Figure 11: Armature voltage and current waveforms with DCS550 (plus 1 grid ph-ph voltage) – dy-
namo operation at +1485 rpm (LEFT) and 1485 rpm (RIGHT), with IM connected to
COMPAK/AC (rated voltage, one phase order and the inverse one)
d) Increase the speed reference gradually, rpm per rpm, for motoring operation of the DCM (positive
armature current), and the braking operation of the IM, until the armature current is +10 A (as
displayed by the drive).
A positive armature current means that the armature current/power is flowing from the drive to the
DCM (motoring operation of the DCM.)
e) Get a nice scope image, with correct polarity of current and voltage, and with relevant scope
settings.
See figure 12-LEFT.
Figure 12: Grid ph-n voltage and DCS550 AC grid current (LEFT) and their product (RIGHT, with
out-of-range error) – DCM motoring (1518 rpm, 10 A, 214 V, 74 )
f) Discuss the grid current waveform, and locate the zero crossings and the maxima/minima of the
fundamental component.
The grid current is relatively close to the ideal 3-phase square waveform (piecewise contant and zero
during twice 60 in 1 AC cycle). Due to the finite inductance of the armature, the grid current has a
ripple, which can be recognised as pairs of humps/bumps on top of the ideal square waveform.
g) Read the firing angle 3.13 ArmAlpha, and check/recognise it on the scope.
74
h) Use MATH, Operation X, for multiplying voltage and current, and MEASURE Mean for getting
the average (figure 12, RIGHT). Avoid being out of range with the product signal; this error is
indicated by ”?” in the MEASURE column of the scope.
What is the total active power (all 3 phases together) that the drive draws from the grid?
See figure 12-RIGHT.
3*679 = 2037 W with out-of-range error, so to be redone
i) From the available data, derive an efficiency value for the drive, and discuss its accuracy and
the sources of error
The armature power, delivered by the drive to the DCM, is roughly 214*10 = 2140 W
The drive also delivers the excitation power to the DCM, and has some own consumption (control elec-
tronics, ventilation...).
This leads to a drive efficiency well above 100%, which is nonsensical. No need to take our calculation
further.
This is obviously due to various measurement errors, including the MEASURE work of the scope and
being out-of-range...
Go gradually, rpm per rpm, to a speed below 1500 rpm, such that the armature current is 10 A. The
IM is now motoring and the DCM braking.
Proceed as before.
See figure 13.
For stopping the test: first turn the IM supply o↵ (knob and switch), then STOP the DCS550.
Not the opposite.
Figure 13: Grid ph-n voltage and DCS550 grid current – DCM braking (1471 rpm, 10 A, 173 V, 110 )