NSCOct 11
NSCOct 11
com
October 2011
New decks for viaduct
Vol 19 No. 9
TO NSC
Simply fill out this card and send it to us.
N
ew Steel Construction keeps designers and contractors abreast of all major
steel construction related developments and provides detailed technical
information on key issues such as the introduction of the Eurocodes.
NSC will be the first place most people hear about advances made by the extensive
research and development efforts of the steel construction partners – Tata Steel, the
British Constructional Steelwork Association, and the Steel Construction Institute,
as well as other researchers.
Each issue of NSC is a blend of project reports and more in depth technical
material. Taking up our free subscription offer is a guarantee that you will be alerted
to significant developments in a sector that retains a commitment to continuous
development in knowledge and techniques for timely delivery of cost effective,
quality projects across all sectors of construction.
Each issue of NSC is typically 44 pages and contains five pages of news,
developments related to Eurocodes, cutting edge project reports from site, and
the latest technical updates from the Steel Construction Institute in its Advisory
Desk Note series. Popular features are 50 Years Ago and 20 Years Ago, looking at
key projects of the past by revisiting the pages of ‘Building With Steel’ and ‘Steel
Construction’.
NSC is available free of charge each month to subscribers living in the UK or
Ireland by simply filling in the reply paid card bound into this issue, or by contacting
us by email, post or fax as described on the card.
If the card has already been removed from this issue you can fill out this form and fax it
to 020 7747 8199, or scan and email it to [email protected]
Name
Position
Company
Address
Postcode
Telephone
Email
In this issue
Cover Image
Tottenham Hotspur FC
Training Centre, Enfield
Main Client:
Tottenham Hotspur FC
Architect: KSS
Steelwork contractor:
Watson Steel Structures
Steel tonnage: 600t
5 Editor’s comment Editor NIck Barrett says the Co-op’s sustainability aims for its new headquarters in
Manchester prove that steel is good for everyone.
6 News Leading fire engineering practitioners shared their knowledge and presented a number of case
studies at recent BCSA/Tata Steel seminars.
12 Profile New BCSA President Ivor Roberts tells Nick Barrett about his hopes for the steel construction
sector over next two years.
14 Bridges Only a 16 week long closure of a Cumbrian railway line was required for all 51 spans of the
Arnside Viaduct to be replaced with new steel decks.
18 Museum Thirty years after being salvaged from the Solent, the Mary Rose will soon be housed in a
purpose-built steel framed museum.
22 Bridges Tidal movements and precision engineering were key elements during the positioning of the
five spans for Poole’s new harbour crossing.
24 Commercial The Co-op headquarters building in the heart of Manchester is aiming to become the
city’s first BREEAM ‘Outstanding’ project.
26 Sport A series of long tubular feature trusses have been erected to form the indoor football pitch
structure at Tottenham Hotspur’s new training centre.
28 Health & Safety The BCSA has instigated a number of initiatives to help make the steel construction
sector a much safer place to work in.
30 Technical Mark Lawson of SCI reviews new guidance on long span composite floors prepared with
NHBC.
32 50 Years Ago Our look back through the pages of Building with Steel features the 26-storey Shell
Centre.
34 20 Years Ago Drawn from the pages of Steel Construction, our featured topic is the National Gallery:
Sainsbury Wing.
36 Advisory Desk AD 362 Headed shear studs - resistance and minimum degree of shear connection in
composite beams with decking.
38 Advisory Service
40 BCSA members
42
These and other steelwork articles
Register of Qualified Steelwork Contractors for Bridgework can be downloaded from the New
Steel Construction Website at
www.new-steel-construction.com
NSC
October 11 3
celebrating
exce ence
in
steel
Call for
Call for entries
entries for
for the
the 2012
2008
Structural Steel
Structural Steel Design
Design Awards
Awards
Tata
CorusSteel
andand
TheThe British
British Constructional
Constructional Steelwork
Steelwork Association
Association havehave
pleasure
pleasure in inviting entries for the 2008 Structural Steel Design Awards.
in inviting entries for the 2012 Structural Steel Design Awards.
The
The Awards
Awards celebrate
celebrate thethe excellence
excellence of of the
the United
United Kingdom
Kingdom or in the
the field
Republic of Ireland in the field of steel construction, particularly
of steel construction. Particularly demonstrating its potential in terms
demonstrating its potential
of efficiency, cost in terms
effectiveness, of efficiency,
aesthetics cost effectiveness,
and innovation.
aesthetics and innovation.
The Awards are open to steel based structures situated in the United
The Awards
Kingdom or are open to
overseas steel
that havebased
beenstructures
built by UK situated in the
steelwork United
contractors
Kingdom or overseas that have been built by UK or Irish
using steel predominantly sourced from Corus. They must have been steelwork
contractors
completed and usingbesteel
readypredominantly
for occupation sourced from Tata
or use during theSteel. They
calendar
must have been completed and be ready
years 2006-2007; previous entries are not eligible. for occupation or use during
the calendar years 2010-2011; previous entries are not eligible.
To find out more and request an entry form visit:
To find out more and request an entry form visit
www.steelconstruction.org
www.steelconstruction.org/resources/design-awards
or call Gillian Mitchell of BCSA on 0207 747 8121
or call Gillian Mitchell of BCSA on 020 7747 8121
Closing date for entries:
Friday 2nd December 2011
Comment
Earning a creditable BREEAM rating is a fairly routine achievement for a steel framed building, as
is proven by the highly sustainable buildings that regularly feature in New Steel Construction.
The process is not easy however and there are many hoops to be jumped through by architects,
structural and mechanical engineers, main contactors and steelwork contractors before this
coveted environmental seal of approval is awarded.
Recently one of the projects previously featured in NSC was the first building in England to
be granted the new ‘Outstanding’ status by BREEAM, 7 More London. In this month’s issue you
can read about a building that should become the first in Manchester to be rated ‘Outstanding’
Nick Barrett - Editor (See Page 24). What is perhaps unusual about this project though is the confidence that the client
showed even before construction started that this building will achieve BREEAM ‘Outstanding’
status.
The building in question is to be the new headquarters for the Co-operative Group, one of the
city’s most venerable institutions, which has been headquartered there since being founded in
1863. The Co-operative Group is one of the most popular organisations in the retail world (Bob
Dylan even allowed his song Blowin’ in the Wind to be used in its advertising campaign, which is
virtually unheard of ) and is highly conscious of its role in the community.
Designers of the headquarters building were given as a key aim the Cooperative Group’s
ambition for it to reflect the high ethical values of the organisation in its design and construction.
It had to be a sustainable landmark for Manchester. It also had to be a building that people would
like to come to work in, and that local communities would value having as a neighbour.
A good way to ensure all of this was to deliberately aim at BREEAM ‘Outstanding’ from the
outset, rather than just add on a lot of ‘sustainability bling’ and hope it all added up correctly, as
some projects have been accused of. Steel was chosen as the preferred framing solution for its
ability to help the Co-operative Group achieve all of these ambitions.
Ambition is a great thing, but you have to be fairly confident that your ambition can be
realised before you announce that you want your yet-to-be-built headquarters to warrant an
Outstanding award for sustainability, and this is what the Co-operative did from the start. The
16 storey building has a visually striking design, so it will certainly become a landmark, and will
provide a much needed fillip to an area in need of a regeneration boost.
Steel was the natural choice for the building frame, say the designers, as it provided the large
column free spans required and allowed other sustainability features to be easily incorporated.
All the thermal mass that is needed is easily provided by the exposed soffit. Natural daylight is
maximised by the feature central atrium. Built in flexibility to accommodate future changes comes
free with steel building frames, another factor which is important to this client.
Good luck to the Co-operative Group in its bid to achieve the sustainability recognition that it
clearly wants so much. The Group’s slogan is ‘Good for everyone’ - which is what such a building
could be.
NSC
October 11 5
News
NSC
6 October 11
News
NSC
October 11 7
News
NSC
8 October 11
News
NSC
October 11 9
News
Major residential
scheme framed in steel
Waterfront South, a major regeneration March 2011.
development of apartments on a Working on behalf of client and
prominent canalside location in the main contractor Jessup Build Develop,
centre of Walsall is utilising more than Traditional Structures completed all
1,000t of structural steelwork as its steelwork - including curved balconies,
main framing material. metal decking and precast stairs
The two phase project was part installation.
funded by the Government’s Homes Phase two of the project is now
and Communities Agency to provide a underway and Traditional Structures
mix of affordable eco homes to rent or is erecting two further eight-storey
buy. buildings containing a total of 164
The first phase consisted of 84 apartments.
apartments spread over two buildings, The Waterfront South project
one with eight storeys and the other has achieved national recognition
a five storey structure. Both of these by winning the ‘Best Canalside
apartment blocks were started in Regeneration Project in the UK 2011’
January last year and completed in awarded by British Waterways Trust.
Diary
For all SCI events contact Jane Burrell, tel: 01344 636500 email: [email protected]
For BCSA Events: To reserve your place e-mail your contact details to [email protected] quoting your preferred venue e.g. ‘London’. For queries, please contact the event team on 0207 747 8131.
NSC
10 October 11
PURLINS
we’re building
a strong reputation. CLADDING RAILS
STEADMANS META-SLATE
1.
New
President
signs road
ahead clear
Ivor Roberts, Managing Director of bridge
and gantry specialist Nusteel Structures,
tells Nick Barrett about his hopes for his
two year spell as BCSA President. New BCSA President
Ivor Roberts
T
he next time you notice a sign a period he expects to coincide with River Medway as opposed to the Kentish
on a motorway overhead gantry an improvement in the fortunes of the Men born on the other side), whose own
warning of road conditions ahead industry. career started at Nusteel some 40 years
– a crucial part of the Highways “I could have hoped for a better ago as an Apprentice Draughtsman. After
Agency’s managed motorways strategy economic background for starting my seven years he left and came back during
– have a quick glance at the truss type time as President,” Ivor admits, “but as the early 1980’s recession, when he was the
structure that supports all that sophisticated an industry we are still in reasonably only in-house draughtsman. Subsequently
information technology. Chances are that it good shape, and as an association we are he became Works Manager, then General
was manufactured and erected by specialist confident that the corner has either been Manager and, by 2000, he had been
steel contractor Nusteel Structures. or is about to be turned, so we can at least appointed as the Managing Director of the
Nusteel’s Managing Director Ivor hope to be firmly on the growth track again company.
Roberts has recently started a two by the end of my Presidency.” Nusteel might not be the biggest
year tenure as President of the British Ashford born Ivor is very much a Man BCSA member, with a workforce of 75
Constructional Steelwork Association, of Kent, (which means born east of the and turnover around £10 million, but its
4. 5. 6.
NSC
12 October 11
Profile
Examples of Nusteel’s
bridge and gantry work:
1. Gantry over the M42
2. Footbridge over M60
3. Footbridge over Mill
Lane, Bracknell
2. 3.
steelwork is among the most visible as it shops are located on the site, where some of As well as the gantries and bridges for
has fabricated and erected most of the large the large space available is frequently taken which it is best known, Nusteel has a track “I am sure most
signage gantries spanning key motorways up by storing already assembled structures. record on a wide range of other types of
like the M25. Nusteel has fabricated and Recent investments, such as completing projects. Nusteel fabricated some of the members would
erected 550 motorway gantries over the past a 135m long fabrication workshop, means external steelwork on the iconic Lloyds agree with
ten years as well as around 400 cantilevers that the longest span structures can be Building in London. While passenger links
plus many offset “T” structures. ‘These large efficiently handled. Some of the sign at ferry berths and airports are another me that they
gantries and the information technology gantries being constructed for the M25 market and it was an airport project that have benefited
that they carry are a vital part of the are 53m long, and Nusteel can cater for up gave Ivor his biggest satisfaction. “I think
strategy for managing the UK’s roads and to eight of these structures at a time. The the best structure we have ever provided hugely from
we are proud of what we have been able to longest M25 gantry was 70m, believed to was a baggage handling facility at Gatwick. membership...”
do to support that,’ says Ivor. be the longest in the UK, this was moved in To anyone who notices it, it probably just
Nusteel has a 57 year history in steel three sections and assembled on site prior looks like a boring box. It is 110m long
construction, founded by Robert Benson, to installation. Other improvements have and approximately 8.5m wide and 3.5m
a Royal Engineer, on his return from allowed us to use more natural daylight in deep, designed to carry conveyors. We
wartime service that included constructing the workshops and together with new plant, designed, manufactured and installed
bridges across the Rhine whilst under this has lead to an £80,000 per year saving it with everything going precisely as
enemy fire. Mr Benson and his family in electricity costs. planned.”
still own the company, originally called To accommodate the very long spans About 45% of the workforce are former
South Coast Welders, which has grown to that Nusteel manufactures, they have their Nusteel apprentices and the company
become a major supplier of information own dedicated slip-road at a junction off has no difficulty in recruiting suitable
support gantries, and a specialist in design, the nearby A20. Nusteel are allowed to candidates for their apprentice scheme.
manufacture and installation of road and control the traffic lights to get the abnormal Ivor’s ambitions for his Presidency
rail bridges in all their forms. loads out on to the road network with include encouraging more steelwork
The scale of the operation invariably minimal disruption. contractors to join the BCSA. “I am sure
surprises visitors when they visit Nusteel’s Substantial investment in surface most members would agree with me
modern purpose built workshops and treatment processes, including shot- that they have benefited hugely from
design office on a ten-acre site at Lympne, blasting, metal spraying and multi-coat membership, not least by being part of
near Hythe in Kent. This rural location paint systems, means that the site is capable a close knit business community whose
is not exactly typical industrial heartland of providing all of the processes needed members are willing to help each other out
territory – one of Nusteel’s nearest for projects without hauling steelwork with advice and support. That community
neighbours is the well known Port Lympne up and down the country for specialised extends to include the national steel
Wild Animal park – but although steelwork treatments. Nusteel maintains its own fleet producer, Tata Steel, who are working with
contractors may be a rare species around of purpose made transport equipment BCSA under a joint market development
here, the site has a long industrial history, that allows directly employed installation agreement for the benefit of all. The
having been used as an army camp and as a teams to efficiently deliver and erect long venture is a shining example of supply
WW1 and WW2 airfield. span structures throughout the UK and chain cooperation and a key element of our
Purpose built fabrication and finishing Northern Ireland. sector’s return to good health.”
Further examples of
Nusteel’s bridge and
gantry work:
4. Footbridge over A6 at
Alvaston
5. Footbridge over
railway at Bedfont
Road, Feltham,
Middlesex
6. Footbridge at
Woolston Station,
Southampton
7. Gatwick Airport
baggage handling
facility
7. 8. 8. 70m gantry over M25
NSC
October 11 13
Bridges
A
Network Rail
Main contractor: fter a 16 week closure, Cumbria’s the River Kent estuary, close to Morecambe Engineer Fabio Gazzola. “Having fully value
May Gurney Arnside Viaduct reopened during Bay. The structure has suffered considerable engineered the project, a steel structure was
Structural engineer: July having had its entire bridge deterioration over the years, resulting in the the only option.”
Gifford, part of Ramboll deck removed and replaced with bridge’s load capacity being reduced; the The construction programme for the
Steelwork contractor: new steel sections and twin continuous completed works will mean there will be less project, led by main contractor May Gurney,
Mabey Bridge welded rail tracks. need for maintenance, improving journey has had to be extremely coordinated, with
Steel tonnage: 2,850t Train journeys across the viaduct are now times for both passengers and freight users. all subcontractors keyed into the critical
smoother and quieter and the 30 mph speed All of the substructure was fully surveyed process.
limit, previously in place because of the at an early stage in the construction In order to complete the job in the
deteriorating state of the original ironwork, programme and deemed to be in good specified bridge closure window, the deck
will soon be doubled to 60 mph after a condition, so only the deck needed to be was removed and installed in two operations;
settling in period. replaced. “The client wanted a robust bridge Down line first and Up line secondly. This
The 51 span structure was originally deck and one which would exert comparable resulted in a total of 102 Victorian decks
built in 1856 and carries the double-tracked loads to the original deck, as we were re- being removed and 102 new steel decks
Carnforth to Whitehaven railway line over using the piers,” explains Gifford Project being installed.
Severe weather Road rail vehicles (RRVs) were used to
conditions failed remove the Down line while positioned on
to stop the project the Up line. The RRVs were also used to
team meeting a tight
deadline place the new steel walkway which acted as
the running beam for the gantry crane.
Once the Down line was removed and
gantry crane beams in place, the new decks
were lifted from transport on the Up line and
into position. The gantries were moved into
the next position, span by span, by hydraulic
tirfors. Once the Down line was complete the
rail was installed and the process repeated
for the Up line renewal.
Both banks of the estuary were used for
the construction process, with the main
project offices and plant area at Arnside. This
NSC
14 October 11
Step above
the rest
Please contact:
Tel: 0113 205 5270 Fax: 0113 205 5271
Email: [email protected]
ASD Westok, Valley Farm Way, Stourton, Leeds LS10 1SE
www.asdwestok.com
Bridges
side of the viaduct was also used for storage side of the centre beam top flange had to be
and then delivery of the new deck materials, removed to allow the Down side deck to be
while the opposite Grange-over-Sands side fitted alongside, while it supported the Up
of the River Kent was used for the receiving line.
of the old deck sections. Span two, nearest the Arnside bank, is
The new decks were designed by also slightly larger than the rest, at 11.7m
Gifford. They provide full loading capacity long, between bearings. Why this span is
and restore the viaduct’s full line speed. different know one really knows, although
Derailment containment is provided by it has been suggested it could have been a
upstands while steel stools at nominal navigation span for small vessels.
600mm centres support the rails. Prior to the installation of the new
“When designing the bridge we had steel decks, Mabey had to install the
to take into account the chance of a tidal bridge’s walkway sections, which consist of
surge sweeping over the structure,” explains prefabricated box sections. These bespoke
Dr Gazzola. “The probability of such an pieces - two for each span section - had to be
event is one in one hundred years. Steel partially installed as they had to support the
Deck removal in holding down plates were provided at each gantry crane’s rails. Once the deck was fully
progress
pier to limit the bridge deck units upward installed and the gantry crane dismantled,
New steel spans in movement to a maximum of 5mm, in the the remainder of the bridge’s walkway was
place carrying new
event of the hydraulic uplift exceeding their installed. This basically involved in-filling
continuously welded
tracks self weight.” between the outer walkway section - which
Steelwork contractor Mabey Bridge supported the gantry - and the main bridge
fabricated all of the bridge decks at its deck.
Chepstow factory and transported each “The most onerous design requirement
fully assembled and fully welded bespoke for the walkways was actually in the
span to site individually and as required for temporary condition,” says Dr Gazzola. “This
installation. Each of the bridge’s 51 spans are was because they acted as runways for the
of a slightly different length, varying by up to erection gantry.”
200mm, although each one is roughly 8.5m Summing up the project, Steve
long between bearings; typical weight is 24t. Richardson, May Gurney Rail Services
Span five is longer as it was designed to Project Manager says: “The list of challenges
accommodate a drawbridge which was never was long and varied on this project. But
installed. It is longer at 16.5m and because through careful planning and precise execu-
of this it needed special measures to be put tion we were able to make it work. Teamwork
into place which deviated from the regular from client down to sub-contractor was the
construction sequence. In particular, one key to the success of this project.”
NSC
16 October 11
Photo by Ian Bramham
ICONIC.
FROM AWARD WINNING
VISION TO REALITY
WHAT IS YOUR NEXT PROJECT?
NSC
October 11 17
Museum
D
Wilkinson Eyre Architects escribed as one of Britain’s most imagination and thousands visit the current existing museum - the new facility will have
Interior architect: important archaeological finds, museum in Portsmouth Dockyard every more space for exhibits - while the hull itself
Pringle Brandon King Henry VIII’s naval flagship year. has been undergoing preservation work,
Main contractor: Warings the Mary Rose, will soon be The preserved objects offer a unique housed in a temporary structure in a nearby
Structural engineer: housed in a new purpose built museum insight into the life and times of a Tudor dry dock.
Gifford, part of Ramboll alongside thousands of objects which were warship as many of the artefacts have The project, largely funded by a grant
Steelwork contractor:
salvaged with the ship’s hull in 1982. remained unscathed since the fateful day in from the Heritage Lottery Fund, will see
Rowecord Engineering
Since being raised from The Solent July 1545 when the Mary Rose sank. the Tudor warship finally ensconced in a
Steel tonnage: 400t
thirty years ago, the remnants of the ship About 1,000 of the 1,900 recovered permanent building, positioned over this
Project value: £35M
and its artefacts have captured the public’s objects are currently on display in the dry dock in which the Mary Rose currently
Clad in black timber, sits.
the museum takes For the Mary Rose Trust, the project
shape next to its neigh- represents a dream come true. “It will
bour HMS Victory
combine the two halves for the first time,”
says the Trust’s Chris Dobbs. “Visitors will
soon be able to view the preserved hull right
alongside many of the ship’s objects.”
Having won a design competition in
2004, Wilkinson Eyre and Pringle Brandon’s
concept revolves around the preserved
starboard portion of the hull sitting in the
middle of the new boat-shaped structure.
A sort of pearl within its oyster shell, as
architect Chris Wilkinson describes it.
Within the museum there will be three
visitor galleries, corresponding to the
principal deck levels of the ship. These will
run the length of the building, imitating the
missing port side of the vessel and allowing
the original artefacts to be displayed in
context.
All through the construction process
NSC
18 October 11
Museum
the hull has remained in the middle of will be painted black and inscribed with steel was the only real choice,” explains Ben
the project, in its ‘hot box’ - a tent-like carvings used by crew to identify their Rowe, Gifford Technical Director. “Visitors will
structure in which air-drying is proceeding, personal belongings. The building’s main steel columns sit
a conservation process which will not be Constructing a building which not only on pads, which are isolated from the dock’s
soon be able
completed until 2016. Until then visitors encases the ship’s hull but also the dry dock stonework by a structural membrane. The to view the
will be able to see this process through in which it nestles has thrown up a number pads not only protect the dock but also
viewing ports positioned along each of the of construction challenges. The dock itself distribute the structure’s loads evenly.
preserved hull
gallery levels. On completion of the air- is a Scheduled Ancient Monument, so there From the dock the steel frame rises right alongside
drying phase, the ‘hot box’ will be removed, was a requirement for minimal interference up and encloses the hull in an elliptically
to the original stonework. Something shaped structure. The frame also includes
many of the
allowing visitors new and dramatic views of
the ship’s original timbers. lightweight was needed; a structural frame two pavilions, on the north and south side ship’s objects.”
The new museum has also been described which could also span the dock without of the structure, one will house the entrance
as a finely crafted, wooden jewellery box, interfering with the conservation work foyer while the other will accommodate an
as it will be clad in timber planks both going on in the midst of the site. educational suite.
reflecting the structure of the original ship “The complex shape of the structure and The building’s irregular shape has been
and the nearby HMS Victory. The planks the need for a lightweight solution meant formed with a number of faceted columns
NSC
October 11 19
Museum
NSC
20 October 11
NSC
October 11 21
Bridges
Harbour bridge
Project Manager for Gifford. “However,
drama unfolds when it opens at mid-span to
reveal it’s elegant yet simple maritime shape.”
Work on this prestigious project was
T
FACT FILE his month (October) will see the the bridge is designed and configured as a been set up on a brownfield site, formerly a
Poole Harbour Second completion of the steelwork simple bascule, with a flat concrete deck and power station, on the Hamworthy side of the
Crossing, Dorset erection for the iconic ‘Twin two hydraulically operated lifting sections. Bay. It is on this bank that the preliminary
Main client: Sails’ bridge which spans Normally the joint between lifting steel construction work has been done.
Borough of Poole Holes Bay in Poole, providing a sections is transverse, but on this structure Steelwork contractor Cleveland Bridge has
Architect: Wilkinson much needed second crossing for it is skewed across the deck creating two delivered more than 40 steel sections to the
Eyre Architects the Dorset town’s busy harbour, triangular leaf-like segments. It is these site and assembled them into five bridge
Main contractor: as well as being an important triangular moveable parts, mirroring the spans, before transporting them onto barges
Hochtief Construction component for regeneration. shape of yachts when in their open upright which then help to position them on the
Structural engineer: Connecting Poole Old Town position, that make the Poole bridge piers and abutments.
Gifford, part of Ramboll unique and accounts for its ‘Twin Sails’ According to Mr Thompson steel was
to Lower Hamworthy, the bridge
Steelwork contractor:
will have to open almost hourly nickname. the only option for this project as the bridge
Cleveland Bridge
for maritime traffic and therefore “There are no other needed to be a lightweight structure that
Steel tonnage: 1,000t
the design has been driven by structures in the could open at least 15 times a day. A low
Project value: £11M
the need for robustness and vicinity, so being a low level bridge which mirrored the height of
reliability. level bridge it blends the quayside was another important design
The new low level bridge has into the criteria best achieved with steel.
five spans, with the mid-span The quaysides on both banks of the
able to divide in half as two harbour are old structures and in places
lifting elements. Structurally in an uncertain condition. By building
NSC
22 October 11
Bridges
NSC
October 11 23
Commercial
Steel pays
dividends
Structural steelwork is playing a
leading role in the construction
of The Co-operative Group’s new
eye-catching headquarters in
Manchester. Martin Cooper reports.
F
ounded in 1863, the Co-operative
FACT FILE
Group has always had its
The Co-operative Group
headquarters in Manchester and
head office, Manchester
Main client: is intrinsically linked with the city.
Co-operative Group Born and raised a Mancunian business, the
Architect: 3D Reid company is now endeavoring to continue
Main contractor: its commercial contribution to city life
BAM Construction by constructing a brand new 16-storey
Structural engineer: headquarters.
Buro Happold The building represents the first phase
Steelwork contractor: in the redevelopment and regeneration of
Fisher Engineering the Group’s 20-acre site, located at the city’s
Steel tonnage: 3,200t northern gateway and bounded by Miller
Street and Corporation Street. The structure
will include around 30,000m2 of open plan
office space, providing modern working Its footprint is a triangle with three rounded to achieve the highest BREEAM rating, with
facilities for the Co-op’s staff. corners, giving the building a guitar plectrum the large atrium allowing natural daylight
The client wants the project to be a shape. Each of the corners has a core, two of to penetrate the floorplates and an exposed
sustainable landmark by becoming the which rise up to level 11, with the third core soffit maximising the thermal mass,” says
first building in Manchester to achieve extending up to the penultimate level 15. The Paul Richardson, Buro Happold Project
a BREEAM ‘Outstanding’ rating and so building’s overall architectural orientation is Engineer. “Steel was the natural choice for the
becoming a benchmark for the commercial completed by its sloping upper levels. From framing material as it gives us the required
sector. Making a positive impression on its the ninth floor the levels step back and are large column free floors levels and the option
immediate vicinity, the new head office will terraced, topping out at the 16th floor core for future flexibility with the building.”
have its own source of locally generated green area. Forming the building’s frame, structural
energy and staff will be encouraged to make The centre of the building is hollow, as a steelwork is also playing an integral and
full use of local transport as on-site parking large triangular atrium extends from ground leading role in the project’s construction. The
will be minimal. floor all the way up to a sloping roof, a glazed building has been divided into three phases,
Architecturally, the structure is far from structure that follows the line of the ninth each based around one of the structure’s
being run-of-the-mill, standing out among its floor to 16th floor terracing. cores. In order to minimise time and costs,
rather sombre looking city centre neighbours. “It’s very much a bespoke design chosen the construction team are working around
The Co-op is aiming
to regenerate the
area around its new
headquarters
NSC
24 October 11
Commercial
3D model of what is
aiming to become
Manchester’s first BREEAM
‘Outstanding’ building
NSC
October 11 25
Sport
T
raining facilities for all top a transparent ETFE roof, similar to the one the overall success of the project. The main
FACT FILE
Tottenham Hotspur FC professional sports teams have at the Eden project in Cornwall. covered indoor pitch is formed by a series
Training Centre, Enfield improved immeasurably over the The main two level L-shaped building will of slender CHS trusses, that were brought to
Main client: last couple of decades, and no more have a green sedum roof and accommodate site in three transportable sections.
Tottenham Hotspur FC so than in the world of football. a learning centre for the youth team, medical Watson Steel Structrures used an innova-
Architect: KSS Top English Premiership and Champion- facilities, a hydrotherapy swimming pool, tive method in order to erect these long
Main contractor: ship sides now have training grounds that altitude room, fitness centre/gym, changing trusses in a quick and easy way. Using two
McLaren Construction are the envy of world football. Cash rich rooms, a canteen and a media centre. sets of containers with a grillage of tempo-
Structural engineer: with sponsorship and TV money, clubs Last month, (September) the project rary steelwork to initially support the three
AKT have been busy investing in state-of-the-art reached a major landmark in the truss sections, they were then individually
Steelwork contractor: facilities that include indoor pitches, gyms, construction programme when a topping jacked into position and welded up.
Watson Steel Structures swimming pools; everything a modern out ceremony was held. “Only when all five splices were welded
Steel tonnage: 600t professional footballer would need. Kevin Taylor, Chairman of the McLaren could we de-jack the truss and start the pro-
Project value: £45M Currently under construction in Enfield, Group comments: “The project is set to be cedure on the next one,” says Jeff Matthews,
north London is a new training facility for testament to what can be achieved through Watson Steel Structures Contracts Manager.
Tottenham Hotspur. Described as an exam- a shared vision, innovation and practical The containers, which acted as temporary
ple in cutting edge design, engineering and collaboration at every stage of the job. trestles, spanned three structural bays and
construction techniques, the club will move “We are immensely proud of this allowed Watson to erect three trusses before
into the completed centre next Summer. development and delighted to mark this the containers, which were on tracks, needed
It will include a two-storey training point in the project.” to be moved to allow the process to be
centre designed around a 70m x 50m indoor Steelwork erection has been completed, repeated.
artificial pitch which will be housed beneath and the material has played a pivotal role in Steelwork also forms the upper or second
An L-shaped two
storey structure
adjoins the indoor “Only when the five splices
pitch on two
elevations were welded could we de-
jack the truss and start the
procedure on the next one.”
NSC
26 October 11
Sport
H
ealth and safety is a serious RoSPA decided to create the new award entitles BCSA to use the award logo on
matter, and the promotion of to celebrate the exceptional work carried literature and websites.
best practice and safe working out by trade associations offering health and The judging criteria were: awareness
methods can be a life saving safety advice to SME’s. raising and information provision; policy
exercise. The construction industry can be The BCSA is the first ever winner of the development; performance improvement
dangerous, but the British Constructional award, which recognises the contribution and recognition; services and benefits, and
Steelwork Association (BCSA) and the steel made by a trade association or similar body competence development and research.
construction sector as a whole has taken in providing health and safety assistance to Peter Walker, BCSA Health, Safety and
huge strides to make it a safer environment. small and medium sized enterprises. Training Manager, said: “We are delighted
Highlighting and recognising the The judges were particularly impressed to be the first ever winners of this Trophy,
outstanding contribution the BCSA by the level of dedication of the BCSA which reflects the importance our industry
has made to provide health and safety in providing advice and assistance to places on health and safety. The judges
assistance, it was awarded the SME the full range of businesses in the sector were looking for hard evidence of our
Assistance Trophy at the Royal Society from large to small. BCSA will hold performance, diligence and commitment
for the Prevention of Accidents (RoSPA) the Trophy for one year and has also towards improvement. I am proud that we
Occupational Health and Safety Awards received a commemorative plaque to keep have demonstrated those qualities to the
earlier this year. permanently. Winning the award also highest standard among our peers.”
NSC
28 October 11
Safety
Knowledge sharing
The drive to reduce injuries in the
constructional steelwork industry has
been a priority for the BCSA and has
been aided by a number of programmes
and knowledge sharing opportunities. The following health and safety publications can be purchased from the BCSA
Setting up relevant committees and services and can found on: www.steelconstruction.org
to help its members achieve the best
l Guide to Steel Erection in Windy Conditions
possible health and safety targets has
l Guide to the Erection of Multi-Storey Buildings
scored results, impressing RoSPA along the
l Guide to the Installation of Deep Decking
way.
l Guide to the Management of Site Lifting Operations
To get these results a Health and Safety
l Guide to Work at Height during the Loading and Unloading of Steelwork
Committee reports direct to the BCSA
l Guide to the Erection of Steel Bridges
council. This committee meets quarterly
l Code of Practice for Metal Decking and Stud Welding
and is always very well attended. The l Code of Practice for the Erection of Low Rise Buildings
venue for the meetings is the BCSA l Health & Safety on Steel Construction Sites: Guide for Employees
London office and the agenda often l Health and Safety in the Office
includes a guest speaker, such as a l H&S in the Workshop for Employees: A Guide for Steelwork Contractors
spokesperson from the Health and Safety l Allocation of design Responsibilities in Constructional Steelwork
Executive (HSE). Problems raised by
member companies, clients or the email [email protected] for ordering information
authorities are discussed and this often
NSC
October 11 29
Technical
NSC
30 October 11
Technical
be taken as assuming 2/3 of the applied load is a short term load and 1/3 is
a long term load.
6. The total deflection of the slab top surface taking account of creep and
shrinkage effects should not exceed 24 mm or span/250, whichever is Figure 1: Load test on a 5m span composite floor slab using water filled bagss
less. If shrinkage effects are ignored in the calculations, then the total
deflection should not exceed 16 mm or span/375.
Correction
Comparative design studies show that the results of these calculations are
In the July/August 2011 Technical Article on Member Buckling with tension
compatible with the above simplified rules. These design limits should not
flange restraint, two formulae were incorrectly copied from the Eurocode.
be unduly conservative in relation to the typical spans specified in residential
buildings. They do not apply to continuous composite slabs where span: In example 1, the expression for NcrT was given as
depth ratios can be higher. In un-propped slabs, it is the spanning capabilities
1 π2Elza2 π2Elw
of the decking in construction that is usually critical and creep effects are NcrT = + + GIT where is2 = iy2 + iz2 + a2
is2 Lt 2
Lt2
much less than in propped slabs.
The short term deflection and vibration sensitivity of composite floors in
This should have been
not affected by creep and shrinkage. A load test on a 5m span composite floor
of only 150mm depth conducted by NHBC gave a deflection of only 6mm
under an test load of 1.5 kN/m2 – see Figure 1. This is consistent with the short
term composite stiffness and showed that the composite action is satisfactory.
NcrT =
1
is2 ( π2Elza2
Lt 2
+
π2Elw
Lt2
+ GIT
) , where is2 = iy2 + iz2 + a2
For more information, contact Mark Lawson at SCI ([email protected]) The numerical values calculated in the article used the correct formulae.
Galvanizing is:
We offer you:
• Quick Service - 24hr turnaround on request
• 14 plants across the UK
• Galvanize a 1.5mm washer to a 29 metre beam
NSC
October 11 31
50 Years Ago
Hot Finished
& Cold Formed
Structural
Hollow
Sections
GRADE S355J2H RAINHAM STEEL
NSC
32 October 11
50 Years Ago
RIGID FRAME
The steelwork above the second floor was designed
to act as a rigid framework acting in conjuction
with the wind bracing which consists of four panels
within the 27-ft. 6-in. centre bay, and two panels
20 ft wide alongside the lift shafts. Virtually all
stanchions are of welded I-section, the largest being
37 in by 20 in.
A special connection incorporating a welded
haunch and end plate and using special grade
65/75-ton U.T.S. friction-grip bolts was developed
for the fixed-ended main beams. It was subjected to
full-scale testing before being put into use. In this
a position eccentric to the main axis of the building and foreseeable future usage the structural elements part of the building, rigid connections were also
and a large vertical shaft had to be incorporated must be designed to withstand superimposed loads used for the main longitudinal beams to provide
to enclose three chimney flues from the boiler appreciably greater than current British Standard rigid frame action against wind forces in this
house, the building and framework could not be minima. direction.
symmetrical. (The flues, it is interesting to note, A structural steel framework and a special ‘rigid The main foundations for the tower had to carry
are vertically self-supporting throughout the entire frame’ design were seen as the means of overcoming loads of 2,900 tons including wind loads. To meet
height of the building, receiving lateral support these problems. this need the consulting engineers evolved, and
from the main steelwork.) The structure was welded throughout, apart developed in conjunction with the contractor, large
There were also severe restrictions on the amount from site connections above the second floor. Site bored-pile cylinders of 7 ft. diameter and belled out
and positioning of the vertical wind-bracing systems welding was used for the main frame connections to 15 ft. diameter at their lower end. The technique,
as is common in office buildings today: diagonal up to the second floor level and high-strength bolt based on oil-well drilling practice, proved successful
wind-bracing could be utilised only in certain of connections were used above this level. and economical; it is an outstanding example of
the transverse frames and was particularly limited The framework above the second floor rests on techniques evolved to meet the special problems
in the portion below the second floor. specially designed steel bearings which transfer encountered in the building and subsequently used
the vertical load to the main portal frames. These to advantage in the later tall buildings. In all, 142
EXCEPTIONAL STRENGTH REQUIRED frames were designed and constructed as two- such shafts were sunk on the site, some to a depth of
Finally, dominating the whole situation, preliminary storey, three-bay portals, of which the stanchions 120 ft below the surface. Forty-nine of these were
studies proved that to meet the needs of immediate were welded box sections. certain of these under the tower block.
Head Office: 01708 522311 Fax: 01708 559024 Bolton Office: 01204 847089 Fax: 01204 848248
e-mail: [email protected] www.rainhamsteel.co.uk
NSC
October 11 33
20 Years Ago
Building by
technology –
The National
Gallery:
Sainsbury Wing
In March 1988 the Prince and
Princess of Wales laid the
foundation stone for the Sainsbury controlled level
wing of the national Gallery, which of natural filtered lighting
will be connected by a bridge link to via rooflights and also roof level services for the
the gallery. The wing has been lighting, heating, air conditioning and safety check systems.
financed entirely by the generosity of Lord Sainsbury, Timothy The steelwork design had to reflect the fineness and slimness
and Simon Sainsbury. The wing includes gallery space to house of the design. The Building Regulations 1985 call for a
the Early Renaissance collection of Italian and Northern structure on such a central London site to be constructed so
Works of the 14th and 15th centuries. that if clear spans exceed 9m, the structure would not be
The architect, Robert Venturi of Venturi, Scott Brown and damaged disproportionately in the event of an accident: the
Associates of Philadelphia USA, won the competition for the effect is that any one column could be considered redundant,
design that provided light spacious galleries. This required a meaning the transfer beam would have to cover twice its
normal span. Ove Arup’s design for the steelwork had to take
into account these seemingly conflicting requirements.
Booth Steelwork Ltd., of Bolton, had completed a major
reorganisation shortly before winning the steelwork contract,
whereby direct numerical control machines have been installed
for steelwork preparation. The dimensioning and marking out
of steel in the works had previously been done by a
combination of the individual skills of the workforce and a
degree of automation. Subsequent to the major investment the
dimensioning of sawing, notching and drilling of beams and
columns became computer controlled functions. Fittings such
as brackets and cleat plates are now cut to size by two further
DNC machines handling flat plates and angle sections.
The design of the connections for the Wing required Booths
to submit some 300 calculation sheets for the 1,550 pieces of
steelwork, totalling 360 tonnes of fabricated steelwork.
Computerised control of the steelwork processes sequentially
orders the materials, fittings and the detailing and calling off
of the production schedules, together with the paintwork and
delivery to site.
During the early stages of work on site it was decided by
the Sir Robert McAlpine construction team that the structural
steel building sequence would be changed from east-west,
across the front of the building, to building outwards from a
north-south central spine. Booth was able to handle the
changed data input and deliver the steel to site sequentially.
Robert Venturi’s aim was to solve every potential
construction difficulty on paper, rather than on site. This
would have been impossible without the power of many
computers. The Sainsbury Wing to the National Gallery is a
product of today’s world of computer generated design,
control and fabrication.
NSC
34 October 11
50 Years Ago
Since its inception in 1867, Barrett Steel has continued to expand both organically and
by acquisition making us one of the UK's largest independent steel stockholders.
Long-established and financially secure, Barrett Steel are the one-stop steel
stockholders for all your requirements.
We’ve seen some changes over the years.
We now offer -
60,000 tonnes of stock across our 24 nationwide sites
AD 362
Headed shear studs –
Resistance and minimum degree of shear
connection in composite beams with decking
This Advisory Desk note highlights the key changes to BS 5950-3.1:1990 as a
1
Figure 1:
result of Amendment no 1, issued in January 2010. Amendment 1 reflects the Comparison
NSC
36 October 11
There’s a new type
of plug in use.
USFB® Version 2 Software
Plug composite action of slab Plug composite USFB® designed Steel deck + PC slabs (with Tested & proven by SCI at City
proved to increase strength. weights up to 30% lighter than structural topping) both benefit University, London.
non composite designs. from plug composite design.
Company:
Address:
Postcode:
Email:
NSC
October 11 37
Advisory Service
NSC
38 October 11
DeSIgn oF STeel BRIDgeS
Professional Training Course
This two day course is aimed at graduate engineers with a Course objectives
basic knowledge of bridge design.
• Give an overview of common forms of steel bridge
used in the highway infrastructure
Speakers include designers and steelwork fabricators
• Explain the design basis set out in the Structural
actively involved in highway bridge design. The course
Eurocodes and the evaluation of bridge loading
therefore provides the latest best practice design guidance.
• Examine the modelling techniques for bridges to
determine internal forces and moments
For structural design reference is made to the Eurocodes -
• Explain the basis for determining the resistance
their use is required by client authorities for all new bridge
of structural members, bracing systems
design projects.
and connections
• Examine requirements for fatigue design
All the presentations will be accompanied by a
• Give practical guidance on material selection,
comprehensive set of notes.
connection detailing, bridge articulation and support
• Give guidance on design for economical
Paper and pdf copies of a range of SCI, BCSA and Tata
and durable construction
Steel publications related to bridge design will also
be provided.
Sponsored by:
Please contact:
Jane Burrell on +44 (0)1344 636500
[email protected] www.steel-sci.org/courses
Listings
Applicants may be registered in one or more Buildings category to undertake the fabrication and the responsibility for any Notes
design and erection of: (1) Contracts which are primarily steelwork but which
may include associated works. The steelwork contract
C Heavy industrial platework for plant structures, bunkers, L Architectural steelwork for staircases, balconies, canopies etc value for which a company is pre-qualified under the
hoppers, silos etc M Frames for machinery, supports for plant and conveyors Scheme is intended to give guidance on the size of
steelwork contract that can be undertaken; where
D High rise buildings (offices etc over 15 storeys) N Large grandstands and stadia (over 5000 persons) a project lasts longer than a year, the value is the
E Large span portals (over 30m) Q Specialist fabrication services (eg bending, cellular/ proportion of the steelwork contract to be undertaken
F Medium/small span portals (up to 30m) and low rise castellated beams, plate girders) within a 12 month period.
buildings (up to 4 storeys) R Refurbishment
G Medium rise buildings (from 5 to 15 storeys) S Lighter fabrications including fire escapes, ladders and Where an asterisk (*) appears against any company’s
H Large span trusswork (over 20m) catwalks classification number, this indicates that the assets
J Tubular steelwork where tubular construction forms a major QM Quality management certification to ISO 9001 required for this classification level are those of the
parent company.
part of the structure SCM Steel Construction Sustainability Charter
K Towers and masts (l = Gold, l = Silver, l = Member)
NSC
40 October 11
Listings
Corporate Members
Corporate Members are clients, professional offices, educational establishments etc which support the development of national specifications,
quality, fabrication and erection techniques, overall industry efficiency and good practice.
NSC
October 11 41
Listings
Associate Members
Associate Members are those principal companies involved in the direct supply to all or some Members of components, materials or products.
Associate member companies must have a registered office within the United Kingdom or Republic of Ireland.
1 Structural components 4 Steel producers 7 Safety systems SCM Steel Construction
2 Computer software 5 Manufacturing equipment 8 Steel stockholders Sustainability Charter
3 Design services 6 Protective systems 9 Structural fasteners l = Gold, l = Silver, l = Member
Steelwork contractors
for bridgework
The Register of Qualified Steelwork Contractors Scheme for Bridgeworks (RQSC) is open to any Steelwork Contractor who
has a fabrication facility within the European Union.
Applicants may be registered in one or more category to undertake the fabrication and the responsibility for any design and erection of:
FG Footbridge and sign gantries MB Moving bridges Notes
PG Bridges made principally from plate girders RF Bridge refurbishment (1) Contracts which are primarily steelwork but which may include associated works.
TW Bridges made principally from trusswork AS Ancilliary structures in steel associated The steelwork contract value for which a company is pre-qualified under the Scheme is
BA Bridges with stiffened complex platework with bridges, footbridges or sign gantries intended to give guidance on the size of steelwork contract that can be undertaken; where
(eg in decks, box girders or arch boxes) (eg grillages, purpose-made temporary works) a project lasts longer than a year, the value is the proportion of the steelwork contract to be
CM Cable-supported bridges (eg cable-stayed or QM Quality management certification to ISO 9001 undertaken within a 12 month period.
Where an asterisk (*) appears against any company’s classification number, this indicates
suspension) and other major structures SCM Steel Construction Sustainability Charter that the assets required for this classification level are those of the parent company.
(eg 100 metre span) (l = Gold, l = Silver, l = Member)
NSC
42 October 11
Listings
NSC
October 11 43
Engineer, detail, contract,
fabricate and construct...
AceCad Software offers a complete steelwork construction solution, through a suite of specialist
products, which may be used independently or integrated for superior BIM advantages.
Engineer
Detailer
Site Team
Fabricator Contractor
Introducing AceCad Software’s evolution suite, for the structural supply chain.
AceCad Software is a unique software vendor with solutions for
AEC and Plant Industries; enabling project delivery from concept, through
engineering, detailing, contracting, fabrication and construction.
evolve with AceCad Software.
www.acecadsoftware.com