Embracing Protestantism Black Identites in The Atlantic World John W Catron Instant Download
Embracing Protestantism Black Identites in The Atlantic World John W Catron Instant Download
https://ebookbell.com/product/embracing-protestantism-black-
identites-in-the-atlantic-world-john-w-catron-35152344
https://ebookbell.com/product/embracing-workplace-religious-diversity-
and-inclusion-key-challenges-and-solutions-ed-hasan-44887692
https://ebookbell.com/product/embracing-a-culture-of-lifelong-
learningcontribution-to-the-futures-of-education-initiative-unesco-
uil-45136208
https://ebookbell.com/product/embracing-alternatives-to-homework-in-
early-childhood-research-and-pedagogies-angela-eckhoff-46137468
https://ebookbell.com/product/embracing-contemplation-reclaiming-a-
christian-spiritual-practice-john-h-coe-47365238
Embracing Love Rescue Me Sara Ohlin
https://ebookbell.com/product/embracing-love-rescue-me-sara-
ohlin-48631124
https://ebookbell.com/product/embracing-his-goddess-natalie-
haigh-48631128
https://ebookbell.com/product/embracing-the-darkness-the-darkness-
trilogy-2-chasing-the-darkness-cassie-sanchez-48631130
https://ebookbell.com/product/embracing-machines-and-humanity-through-
cognitive-computing-and-iot-mohammed-usman-49184542
https://ebookbell.com/product/embracing-restlessness-cultural-
musicology-birgit-abels-editor-49928284
Embracing Protestantism
John W. Catron
21 20 19 18 17 16 6 5 4 3 2 1
The University Press of Florida is the scholarly publishing agency for the State University System
of Florida, comprising Florida A&M University, Florida Atlantic University, Florida Gulf Coast
University, Florida International University, Florida State University, New College of Florida,
University of Central Florida, University of Florida, University of North Florida, University
of South Florida, and University of West Florida.
Contents
Acknowledgments ix
Introduction 1
1. Christianity in Atlantic Africa before 1800 15
2. The Favorite of Heaven: Antigua and the Growth of Black
Atlantic Christianity 50
3. Early Black Atlantic Christianity in the Middle Colonies 101
4. Black Evangelical Diaspora in the Greater Caribbean 150
5. Afro-Christian Diaspora in the Age of Revolution 195
Conclusion 224
Notes 231
Bibliography 269
Index 299
Acknowledgments
x • Acknowledgments
ing this work and is therefore responsible for much of what is good about
its literary style and clarity. As my lifelong friends, my sisters, Cecilia and
Carol, and my brother, David, have given continued and enthusiastic sup-
port. Finally, my wife, Tracey, and daughters, Amanda and Heidi, deserve
more thanks than I can give for enduring my long hours of study and the
extended periods I have spent away from them on research trips. This work
is for them.
Acknowledgments • xi
Introduction
On a muggy fall day in 1792, Henry Beverhout looked out over the low
thatched huts of the newly settled West African bayside village of Free-
town with feelings suffused with both apprehension and hope. Since he
and other black men and women from around the Atlantic basin had sailed
to the freshly established colony of Sierra Leone to start new lives in free-
dom in March of that year and when Afro-Virginian minister David George
preached the first Baptist sermon in Africa under the settlement’s iconic
Cotton Tree, Beverhout suspected that life in the new British colony was
not what they had been promised. Ruthlessly exploited in America, these
expatriates arrived on Sierra Leone’s lush tropical coast determined to chart
a new course for their children and families in Africa, but as they quickly
learned, the path to true freedom was littered with obstacles that the ver-
dant landscape could not easily erase.
In the months and years that followed they came into conflict with white
Sierra Leone Company officials over low pay, high prices, and the slow pace
at which the seemingly abundant land was being apportioned to them. Just
as important, the black émigrés were dismayed by the company’s racially
discriminatory system of justice, whose juries did not, Beverhout com-
plained, “haven aney of our own Culler.” Having absorbed the British and
American legal traditions of trial by a jury of one’s peers, he demanded that
in any “trial thear should be a jurey of both white and black and all should
be equal.” Going even further, Beverhout then made an explosively demo-
cratic claim: “we have a wright to Chuse men that we think proper to act for
us in a reasnenble manner.”1
Beverhout’s assertion that blacks be put on the same legal footing as
whites was a risky maneuver in 1792 in a colony controlled by Europeans.
It was in part a product of his relocation to a continent dominated by peo-
ple of color, but his iconoclastic ideas and demands for equality also had
their roots in his Atlantic-world upbringing. Born a free person of color
on the Caribbean island of St. Croix, he was the mixed-race son of a black
mother and a white father from one of the leading families in the Danish
West Indies.2 Beverhout’s position among whites and people of color in St.
Croix was bolstered during this period by his connection with the well-es-
tablished international Protestant evangelical religious movement. Firmly
entrenched in the planting class, whites of the Beverhout family were
early supporters of Moravian Church missionaries in their work of bring-
ing the archipelago’s African and creole slaves to Christianity beginning in
the 1730s. Besides being concerned about the fate of their souls, religiously
minded planters like the Beverhouts saw the Christianization of their slaves
as a way to make them better workers, more like Europeans culturally and
thus seemingly less foreign and, they hoped, less likely to rebel. But as often
occurs during the implementation of many attempts at social control, the
objects of the Moravians’ evangelization viewed the situation differently
and seized the opportunity for their own ends.
The introduction of Protestant missionaries brought multiple benefits
for St. Croix’s people of color, perhaps the most important being that it
gave Henry Beverhout and other black converts to Christianity access to a
worldwide evangelical network that over the long run provided an alterna-
tive to the narrative produced by whites in plantation America about the
supposed savagery and inferiority of Africans and people of African de-
scent. This counternarrative took time to overcome the static social struc-
tures of early modern Europe and the economic greed of American slave-
owning plantation masters, but it eventually paved the way to freedom.
Henry Beverhout’s global perspective and sense of personal worth were
enhanced by the unprecedented evangelical Protestant practice of giving
people of African descent positions of authority within the hierarchies of
local churches. Black church members became deacons, elders, and even
preachers, if they did not always receive official sanction from church au-
thorities. Evangelical missionary organizations encouraged international
consciousness among their black members by sponsoring the travel of
select people of color from around the Atlantic basin to receive religious
instruction in North America and Europe as well as for a limited number
2 • Embracing Protestantism
to themselves become missionaries. One of Henry Beverhout’s black cous-
ins, Wilhelm Beverhaut, traveled from the Danish Caribbean island of St.
Thomas in 1756 to attend a boarding school in the Moravian town of Bethle-
hem, Pennsylvania, to be trained as a missionary; in the process he and nu-
merous fellow Afro-Caribbeans became agents of cross-cultural exchange
and helped create what would later blossom into a fully developed black
Atlantic culture.3
Henry Beverhout, perhaps inspired by his cousin, in the early 1770s left
St. Croix for Charleston, South Carolina. Given that slavery and racial dis-
crimination held no less sway in the Lowcountry’s rice plantations than on
Caribbean sugar islands, his reasons for moving from the comforting famil-
iarity of St. Croix to the frighteningly distant mainland appear at first glance
to be unclear. Beverhout’s move begins to make sense, however, in light of
his evangelical upbringing and his later career, both of which drew him to
the Lowcountry capital to do mission work spreading the gospel among his
fellow people of color. British Methodist apostle Francis Asbury came to
Charleston several times during the early 1770s trying to form a church so-
ciety there; he and Beverhout almost certainly came in contact with each
other at that time. As events transpired, the American Revolution curtailed
further collaboration between the two missionaries. Asbury was forced un-
derground because he was the representative of a church deemed too Brit-
ish for American tastes during the war, while Henry Beverhout’s own stay
in South Carolina was shortened when in 1783 he and other white and black
loyalists were evacuated to Canada by the British army.
Undeterred and perhaps welcoming the change of scene and the loss of
Asbury’s patriarchal authority, Beverhout went on to organize an all-black
Methodist congregation in New Brunswick who nine years later migrated
en masse to Sierra Leone on the west coast of Africa. Henry Beverhout’s
religious and civic convictions, forged in the Atlantic world, gave him the
resources and determination to demand greater freedom for himself and
his people wherever they settled. Shortly after he arrived in Sierra Leone,
the colony’s white governor complained about “the Wildest extravagances”
being committed by the transplanted black Methodists at their church ser-
vices. He singled out Beverhout as a chief fomenter of the “evil that many
follow in this violent enthusiastic spirit.”4
Beverhout’s experiences and exposure to exciting new political and re-
ligious ideas then circulating around the peripheries of the North Atlantic
and the actions he took as a result made him, if not evil or extravagant, then
Introduction • 3
certainly somewhat exceptional. His life may have been atypical compared
to those of the vast majority of enslaved people of color who toiled as farm
laborers on North American and Caribbean rice, tobacco, coffee, and sugar
plantations, but his actions do represent in broad outline the strategies used
by many eighteenth-century black Christians in their attempts to forge
new and freer lives for themselves in the British Atlantic world. Educated,
mobile though not always free, and not content to live in static social en-
vironments that oppressed their brothers and sisters, Afro-Christians like
Beverhout moved multiple times throughout their lives in their search for
identity and autonomy. By moving in multiple directions from and to the
Caribbean, North America, Africa, and Europe, they became agents of
cultural exchange and in the process created a new circum-Atlantic Afro-
Christian culture. That culture had its roots in all of the above-named re-
gions but was so much the product of the violence and oppression of slav-
ery as to be disassociated with any discrete national or regional boundary.5
Initially seeing themselves as Temne, Igbo, or Mandinka or as members
of even smaller ethnolinguistic, familial, or village-based groups, the newly
enslaved had only a thin understanding their supposed identities as Afri-
cans. After living in the furnace of racial oppression as slaves in the Ameri-
cas for more than one hundred years, much of this parochial way of think-
ing was burned away as black captives reached out to each other for mutual
support, but for those who embraced Christianity in Britain’s American
empire there was an important intermediate stage.
While in the process of becoming African Americans, people of African
descent also developed Atlantic African Christian identities, eschewing at-
tachments to rigid political boundaries that whites were then forming and
instead recombining into more extranationalist groupings. Rather than be-
ing African American or Afro-British, they were transnational Afro-Meth-
odists, Afro-Baptists, and Afro-Moravians, among others, whose connec-
tions to the religions of their homelands in Africa as well as international
religious organizations in Britain and Europe gave them far more fluid iden-
tities. Late eighteenth-century Anglophone black Christians spurned the
racially exclusionary tendencies of the rising nation-states and did not ini-
tially become African Americans: they were, instead, Atlantic Africans who
used the skills they acquired while living and working along the Atlantic lit-
toral to negotiate better living conditions from a slave society that was just
entering one of its most brutally productive stages.
They were not Ira Berlin’s deracinated Atlantic creoles who attempted to
4 • Embracing Protestantism
integrate themselves at multiple levels into the white cultures of American
seaport towns. America was for most migrant Africans the land of slavery
and white supremacy that offered only limited possibilities for family sta-
bility, cultural creativity, and economic advancement. Alternatively, the At-
lantic promised access to, first, the British abolition movement that in the
1770s was beginning to gain momentum; second, German and British evan-
gelicals in the international abolition movement who gave black parishio-
ners unprecedented power in local church governance; and third, Atlantic-
world evangelical networks that connected displaced Africans in spirit and
sometimes in person with African Christianity in Kongo, Angola, and Por-
tuguese, Dutch, English, and French West Africa. Finally, blacks in North
America found inspiration and comfort in a burgeoning connection they
forged with the large Afro-Protestant churches then being formed in the
West Indies. By embracing Christianity in the eighteenth century, blacks
were not simply accommodating white culture and the social realities of a
brutal system of coerced labor; they were, rather, attempting what became
resistance within accommodation. Christianity was a way, especially after
the American Revolution, for blacks to reach out to third parties in the new
international religious and humanitarian communities being formed for
help in their continuing struggle for freedom.6
To fully appreciate early black culture we must expand our understand-
ing of African American social and religious history in the eighteenth cen-
tury beyond the plantations and plantation churches of Virginia and South
Carolina to include the entire Atlantic world. The surprising mobility of
early Afro-Protestants did much to help create a black evangelical discourse
among the various worlds they inhabited, be they in the plantation South,
the urban and rural North, the Caribbean, or elsewhere. Having been torn
away from family networks in Africa, exposed to the horrors of the Middle
Passage, and somehow surviving the physical hardships and humiliations
of American slavery, African captives and their children had to fashion
new understandings of their worlds. People of color had only attenuated
support from the familiar cultures of their homelands but refused to com-
pletely accept white social practice; they opted for a middle course. Atlantic
African Christianity was not wholly the intellectual property of Europe or
the Americas, but neither was it completely African.
Early Protestant evangelicalism was brought to blacks by usually lower-
status and less-educated whites, and its racial bigotry was at least partly
ameliorated by white believers’ desire for stability and social justice. Com-
Introduction • 5
mitment to racial and social equality dissolved after the American Revolu-
tion as southern whites, including evangelicals, took advantage of new op-
portunities to exploit land and labor;7 black Christians in North America
realized that the only chance they had to gain power and an independent
identity lay with their ability to reach out to other Afro-Christians within
the Atlantic world. Masters, as fierce defenders of the paternalist ethos that
projected their authority and protected their economic interests, wanted
slavery to remain a strictly personal relationship between themselves and
their slaves; by using the “white man’s religion” blacks attempted to bring
that relationship into the public sphere. Early black evangelicals used the
connections they forged with international religious organizations to
broadcast to ever-widening audiences the truth of their own humanity and
the basic immorality and inhumanity of holding people, especially other
Christians, in bondage.8 This book details their initial attempts to foster an
international black Christian community and the Atlantic African identity
that gave it coherence.
Defining the emerging Atlantic African culture these early black evan-
gelicals created is important but difficult, given the diversity of those people
of color who lived in such a large geographic space; nevertheless, identify-
ing three of its general characteristics is useful here. First, Atlantic African
culture in British America was heavily influenced by African spirituality
that emphasized practical solutions to temporal problems rather than the
vague promises offered by white preachers of heavenly rewards after a life
of slavery’s degradation. These people did not suffer in silence; they actively
reached out to sources of power outside their nominally circumscribed
worlds in search of freedom. Second, and quite practically, Atlantic African
culture was delineated by the mobility of its adherents who had the ability
to walk, ride, or sail in their quest for freedom. And third, black Atlantic
Protestants distinguished themselves by their willingness at certain mo-
ments to use violent means to achieve freedom.
It is an understatement to say that black culture in the eighteenth century
was extraordinarily varied; a major theme of this study is the incredible di-
versity among Africans and people of African descent who were enslaved
and discriminated against in the Americas. Many of the men and women
who came to the Americas from West and West Central Africa understood
multiple, often closely related languages and shared common religious and
other cultural values.9 The same can be said, of course, of the languages and
cultures of Europeans, Native Americans, and other peoples in close geo-
6 • Embracing Protestantism
graphic proximity. Having recognized the relative homogeneity of some Af-
rican societies, we must also appreciate how diverse and complex those so-
cieties, which inhabited an entire continent, were and continue to be. Africa
is, after all, a very big place. Environmental zones as widely varied as the arid
Sahara at one extreme, the Sahel and savannah in the middle, and regions
dominated by tropical rainforest at the other extreme affected the develop-
ment of African cultures in important and far-reaching ways. Africa’s tradi-
tional religions, while in many ways quite similar to one another, also served
to particularize rather than unify people from the same region; the people
were overwhelmingly localist in orientation even if they spoke the same or
closely related languages and shared certain facets of culture. Imported reli-
gions like Christianity and Islam were incorporated into the worldviews of
only a minority of Africans, though when they took root they caused even
more fissures in an already multilayered and complex social fabric.
In America, ethnic and religious cleavages among the enslaved remained
and were compounded by the widely varying social, political, economic,
physical, and cultural environments they encountered there. Over time,
slavery and the vagaries of plantation demographics tended to homogenize
ethnic and sub-ethnic differences among the African-born and their de-
scendants as the enslaved sought security in the unity of the oppressed.10
Nevertheless, the sheer size of the British American littoral—stretching
as it did at various times from Trinidad in the tropical West Indies to the
flooded rice fields of subtropical Georgia in the American South to urban
Philadelphia and New York City in the Mid-Atlantic colonies of New Jer-
sey, New York, and Pennsylvania, and finally to the ice and rock of Nova
Scotia in the far north—militated against the creation of a common culture
for America’s people of color. Cultural differences among people of African
descent caused by geographic separation makes it necessary to study dis-
crete black communities in multiple and well-spaced locales all along the
Atlantic littoral. That is why this study examines Afro-Christianity in the
port towns of Atlantic Africa, the British Caribbean, Lowcountry Georgia
and the Carolinas, and the Middle Colonies to their north; because they are
so widely separated from each other, these locations would seem not to be
closely associated culturally or historically.
Remarkably, despite their ethnic diversity and spatial separation, some
enslaved and free people of color in these port towns and the surrounding
hinterlands managed to establish a series of interregional religious commu-
nities that served over the course of several decades to effectively cover up,
Introduction • 7
if not obliterate, Old World cleavages and create a wholly new Atlantic Afri-
can identity. Afro-Christians in the eighteenth-century Anglophone world
remained a diverse group of people, but they were nevertheless able to form
fragile yet enduring networks that fostered the necessary unity to push for
greater autonomy and ultimately for freedom.
In this study I have built on the work of J. Lorand Matory, James Sidbury,
James Sweet, Vincent Brown, Daniel Brown, Linda Heywood, and John
Thornton while coming to some alternative conclusions. To fully engage
any historical subject, scholars must re-create the material lives of those af-
fected by larger economic, political, and cultural forces. In each section of
this project I have followed, as far as the sources permitted, the lives of in-
dividual Afro-Christians, charting their physical and spiritual experiences
within the Atlantic system.
In chapter 1 I have employed travel accounts of white merchants, sailors,
and missionaries, the extant diaries, journals, and scholarly works of black
missionaries, secondary historical works, and literature from more recent
anthropological investigations to chart the development of Christianity in
Africa. It has become broadly recognized that many Bakongo of West Cen-
tral Africa embraced a modified form of Christianity as early as the fifteenth
century and remained faithful to it well into the nineteenth century. Chris-
tianity likewise was introduced into West Africa in the fifteenth century,
but its adoption there was more sporadic and usually limited to the coastal
enclaves of European slave traders. Even in West Africa, though, the osten-
sibly Africanized Christian church was larger than has been recognized.
Historians Ras Michael Brown, Jason R. Young, John Thornton, and others
argue the degree to which Catholicism and Protestantism were reshaped
by believers in the Kongolese hinterland and West African littoral.11 Many
scholars now agree that many Africans were either Christians or sufficiently
exposed to Christianity before they made the Atlantic crossing that the reli-
gion offered by white evangelicals in the Americas was not wholly unfamil-
iar. The process cannot really be called creolization, however, because the
Christianity they practiced had been modified to such an extent that it was
a truly African religion.
Catholic and Protestant Africans, when they came to British America as
slaves, were for political and economic reasons not welcomed into churches
or even recognized as fellow believers by white masters or missionaries.
Nevertheless, they played a pivotal role in building the black church in the
New World, especially in the Caribbean island colony of Antigua. In chap-
8 • Embracing Protestantism
ter 2 I examine why Antigua, a relatively small British possession in the Lee-
ward Islands, became a vital center of Afro-Protestantism that eclipsed the
far larger and more populated colony of Jamaica and predated by several
years the evangelization of blacks in South Carolina, Maryland, and Vir-
ginia. Using the records, journals, letters, and diaries of resident Moravian
and Methodist missionaries led to discovering why Antigua was particu-
larly fertile ground for Christian evangelization. Generations of social sci-
entists have puzzled over why captive Africans in Antigua and the rest of the
Americas ultimately embraced Christianity, which was, after all, the faith of
their oppressors. Many scholars note that evangelical Protestant church ser-
vices and traditional African religious celebrations shared the same sense of
heightened emotionalism, spirit possession, and physicality, thus allowing
people of African descent in the Caribbean and North America to feel fa-
miliar and comfortable with the putatively new religion.
There are examples, though, of large numbers of black American Chris-
tians who did not engage in emotionally charged church services, calling
into question the trend by some historians toward an African essentialism.
Africans and their descendants who lived in British America chose as their
vehicles of spiritual resistance foreign-born Methodist, Baptist, and Mora-
vian churches, even though in the eighteenth century these were small
and comparatively insignificant religious sects. All three denominations
officially frowned upon raucous song and dance or any sort of emotional
display in church, contradicting claims by many scholars that blacks chose
evangelicalism because it allowed them to freely express their African cul-
tures. Instead, displaced Africans chose these churches precisely because
they were marginalized, existing on the peripheries of the plantation power
structure. Early Moravian, Methodist, and Baptist preachers were outsiders
whom the ruling Anglican planter class held in contempt and who in turn
criticized what they characterized as the licentious lifestyles of the slave
drivers; they gained black adherents because as foreign missionaries they
gave slaves access to powerful decision makers in Britain and Europe who
were beyond the clawing grasp of the planter political complex. Achieving
spiritual fulfillment was a vital motivation, but as we will see, a by-product
of black evangelization for many Afro-Antiguans was their growing connec-
tion to and communication with the world outside the island’s confines,
a connection that proved crucial to their empowerment. Studying black
Protestantism in Antigua is important because Antigua’s blacks were the
first people of color in British America to be successfully evangelized—or
Introduction • 9
rather, to successfully evangelize themselves—in large numbers. As such,
Antigua became a model that influenced the growth of black Protestantism
in the rest of the British West Indies as well as in North America.
News about the success of Afro-Protestantism in Antigua was broadcast
throughout the Anglophone world by white missionaries but also by black
evangelists who moved within the greater Caribbean with surprising ease
and regularity. In chapter 2 I examine a secondary diaspora of Afro-Chris-
tians from Antigua. Fanning out from the island colony beginning in the
late 1770s, black evangelicals founded churches throughout the West Indies,
transmitting the gospel message to people of African descent in that region
and as far away as North America, Europe, and West Africa. White mission-
aries claimed that teaching slaves about Christianity would help stabilize
a potentially dangerous workforce, and in some ways they were right. But
black-led spirituality in the plantation cultures of the British Caribbean and
the American South also could be a subversive element. Though unable to
challenge white supremacy directly, the connections they made through-
out the Atlantic world created an international awareness of the conditions
people of color in the West Indies had to endure, thus helping to spark the
early abolition movement in Britain and the American North.
The black evangelical networks that bound together the greater Carib-
bean did in fact radiate north to encompass the Mid-Atlantic colonies of
New York, Pennsylvania, and New Jersey. Chapter 3 focuses on why blacks
from around the Atlantic rim were attracted to the ethnically German Mora-
vian Church enclave of Bethlehem, Pennsylvania. Though a small place,
Bethlehem became an important link in a network of black evangelicals
who traveled circuits in the Middle Colonies in the 1740s and 1750s preach-
ing an Atlantic African gospel message; they eventually reached out to black
Christians in the West Indies and ultimately connected with subaltern com-
munities throughout the Atlantic basin. Rare firsthand accounts written by
the settlement’s Afro-Moravians as well as other church documents give un-
precedented evidence of multifaceted cultural connections and exchanges
among Africa, the West Indies, Europe, and North America. Of particular
interest is correspondence I have uncovered between black Christians in the
West Indies and Native Americans in Pennsylvania, records from the 1740s
of the first church-sponsored black missionaries in North America, and evi-
dence of continued loyalty to ethnic affiliation by Africans in the Mid-At-
lantic colonies. Studying this sort of social interpenetration adds complex-
ity to our understanding of black life in the North in the early and middle
10 • Embracing Protestantism
eighteenth century. It reveals how blacks in the North, thought to be largely
cut off from their African cultures, were actually placed squarely within an
emergent Afro-Protestant Atlantic world community.
How black Protestants in Lowcountry South Carolina, Georgia, and
coastal North Carolina established and benefited from the development
of cultural links to Africa, the West Indies, and the wider Atlantic world
is the subject of chapter 4. There, I go beyond the stale “continuity versus
creativity” debate that pits those who believe traditional African cultures
survived in the Americas and those who argue that a creole society was
fashioned that blended many different African traditions. A growing body
of evidence supports both views: that multiple African cultures survived
the Middle Passage to influence discrete regions of the Americas and that
over time people of African descent, like European Americans, borrowed
heavily from different African groups, Native American culture, and Euro-
American traditions to create something new.
Blacks who embraced evangelical Protestantism in late eighteenth-century
British America were not unconverted Africans who cynically joined Chris-
tian churches as a way to cope with slavery, as Albert Raboteau, John Boles,
and John Blassingame have contended. Nor were they the deracinated Atlan-
tic creoles about whom Ira Berlin speaks so eloquently who actively “forgot”
their African backgrounds in attempting to integrate themselves into the
dominant European cultures of American port towns. While acknowledging
that both continuity and creativity were vital forces in black life, those Afri-
cans and their descendants who converted to Protestantism in British Amer-
ica chose a middle path that shunned national identities. Instead, they as-
sumed a transnational African-Atlantic identity that allowed them to remain
fiercely loyal to their ethnic and sub-ethnic African identities and gave them
access to sources of power that helped them attain their freedom.
Black life in eighteenth-century Lowcountry South Carolina poses a
paradox: during this era the most thoroughly Africanized section of Anglo
North America had by far the largest number of black Christians. In chapter
4 we will look into the Africanness of the Lowcountry, which was in part
the legacy of Christianity in Kongo, while also seeing that people of African
descent enslaved in the Americas took on multiple identities throughout
their lives as a means of gaining freedom. If by becoming Christians they ad-
vanced some very basic needs, then they went to church on Sundays, even
if on the other six days they made ritual offerings to the simbi water spirits
they had carried with them from Africa. Black life in the Lowcountry was,
Introduction • 11
therefore, polycultural with many different African traditions contributing
in discrete ways. The region was Atlantic African in nature, and its people
of color maintained a practical agenda that utilized the white religious out-
reach of the Great Awakening for their own temporal purposes.
Contributing to the area’s religious complexity was a cadre of white and
black Methodist and Baptist missionaries who had served in the Carib-
bean and later found themselves reassigned to churches in the American
South in the late eighteenth century. At the same time, black evangelicals
from North America could be found in the West Indies preaching to the
newly converted at plantation churches on the sugar islands. The connec-
tions between the Caribbean and mainland North America developed by
these itinerant preachers influenced in multivalent ways the debate among
evangelicals over the issue of slavery. While many black and white Method-
ists and Baptists in the Lowcountry suffered persecution for their antislav-
ery views, they continued preaching to biracial congregations and pressing
for abolition well after 1800 because of their continuing connections to the
transatlantic evangelical movement.
Well-known white transatlantic evangelists like George Whitefield and
Thomas Coke were important catalysts in fostering the evangelical move-
ment among the South’s people of African descent. However, it was the
black preachers and laypeople who remained behind after the white preach-
ers left such places as Wilmington, North Carolina, and Savannah, Geor-
gia, who did the real work of building the region’s early Afro-evangelical
churches. By placing their churches on the Atlantic littoral, black American
preachers like Andrew Bryan in Savannah and Brother Amos Williams in
the Bahamas were uniquely positioned to nurture and benefit from the
transatlantic exchange of ideas and information that aided the growth of a
nascent black Protestant movement.
Sylvia Frey, Alexander Byrd, and others have ably demonstrated that the
American Revolution helped shape and transform black American culture
in general and the black church in particular. The subject of chapter 5 is how
black evangelicals George Liele, Boston King, and John Marrant, among
others, took advantage of the cultural space afforded by the revolution to
develop transatlantic networks and build independent transnational black
churches. All three men, along with thousands of other people of color,
abandoned their homes in the new United States after 1783 for what they
hoped would be sanctuaries of freedom scattered along the Atlantic rim. In
Jamaica, the Bahamas, Nova Scotia, London, and especially Sierra Leone,
12 • Embracing Protestantism
they attempted to institute the republican ideals about which white revo-
lutionaries spoke so eloquently but failed to extend to people of color. En-
countering hostile forces wherever they went, these black expatriates built
evangelical networks with their brothers and sisters from around the At-
lantic, energized by their belief in freedom, evangelical community values,
and remembered African culture. The transnational Atlantic African cul-
ture they produced helped foster North America’s black church in the early
nineteenth century and opened the way for African American missions to
Africa beginning in the antebellum era.
The object of chapter 5, and more generally the entire project, is to high-
light the role of Afro-Atlantic peoples in the eighteenth century’s interna-
tional revival movement. The deployment of black missionaries, some of
whom who received formal training and others who went into the field of
their own accord, forced white members of the international Protestant
movement who previously preferred to focus on otherworldly issues to
engage the problems of this world, namely slavery, to a greater extent than
they wished. By doing so, black Atlantic missionaries became one of the
principal means by which evangelical Protestantism helped to bring about
the moral and ethical transformation of the West.
Many West and West Central Africans viewed the region beyond the At-
lantic horizon as a metaphysical space they associated with death and the af-
terlife. It was for many West and Central Africans a pleasant place where the
dead reunited with their ancestors in happy communion.12 In the context
of the transatlantic slave trade, the western ocean’s association with death
became less benign; most Africans could easily see that the men, women,
and children who sailed over the far horizon on European ships were still
alive and never came back for even a spiritual reunion. The linking of the
Atlantic with heaven, honored ancestors, and a new beginning but also with
separation and suffering was a source of internal conflict for many people of
color in both Africa and the Americas. Most second- and third-generation
African Americans, given the option, chose to stay in America rather than
return to Africa but nevertheless maintained a connection with the land
and people across the Great Water. Headstones in many eighteenth- and
nineteenth-century cemeteries dedicated to blacks in America face east to-
ward the ocean and Africa. On a trip several years ago to the site of the for-
mer Silver Bluff plantation on the banks of the Savannah River just south of
Augusta, Georgia, I visited an abandoned and decaying graveyard for slaves.
The graveyard was the final resting place for members of Silver Bluff Baptist
Introduction • 13
Church, said to be the first independent black Protestant congregation in
North America, whose founding predates the American Revolution.13
As part of my visit to the Lowcountry, I attended a Sunday-morning ser-
vice at Silver Bluff Baptist Church, which still exists but has been moved
several miles down the road from the old Silver Bluff plantation site. The
church’s large chapel was only partly filled that morning, the pastor ex-
plained, because much of the congregation had “gone visiting” to a sister
church in Augusta, a ritual he said they followed on a regular basis. This
practice of visiting fellow Christians at great and not so great distances,
while not unique to black Protestantism, is surely a legacy of their Afri-
can Atlantic roots. The legacy of the black Atlantic can be seen also in the
placement of the old church’s grave markers, now overgrown with grass and
shaded by moss-covered oaks and longleaf pines—the markers all face east
toward Africa. Scattered around the few remaining small monuments are
shards of broken porcelain, another remnant of an Atlantic African ritual
conducted at funerals that allowed the spirits of the dead the freedom to fly
back to Africa to rejoin deceased family members.14
Most of the people buried at the Silver Bluff slave cemetery died in the
mid-nineteenth century, yet the old traditions of looking east across the
Great Water remained intact. Forced to leave their homelands and families
on board monstrous barges of death, many people of color in the eighteenth
and nineteenth centuries never really left those slave ships. Not wanting to
become fully integrated into New World white culture as creoles and sepa-
rated from the Old World cultures of memory, they were left somewhere
in the middle. No longer Africans but not yet Americans either, people like
Henry Beverhout who lived in widely separated locations along the oceanic
littoral had been transformed by slavery and Christianity into citizens of the
Atlantic world. People of African descent have often looked east to Africa
for a sense of identity and hope, but black evangelicals in the eighteenth
century also looked east hoping to connect with people and organizations
that promised potential aid. In port towns such as Charleston, English Har-
bor, Nassau, and Freetown these Atlantic Africans foraged for the help and
resources they needed to create new identities out of multiple inputs from
Africa, Europe, and Native America, all in an attempt to achieve freedom.
14 • Embracing Protestantism
1
Christianity in Atlantic
Africa before 1800
16 • Embracing Protestantism
Caribbean during the eighteenth century. Christianity’s influence among
Atlantic Africans, however deep or shallow, began as early as the fifteenth
century and endured as a largely indigenous movement over the follow-
ing three hundred years. Discovering how they came to be Christians,
how many black Christians there were in Africa during this period, how
contact with African culture changed Christianity, and whether Africans
brought their version of Christianity with them to the Americas when
they went there as forced migrants are the objects of this chapter. Chris-
tianity’s history in some parts of sub-Saharan Africa extends to the fourth
century CE and over the millennia has inspired the conversion of millions
of adherents. Intriguing new evidence supports the idea that many Afri-
cans in the diaspora were not only well acquainted with Christianity in
Portuguese Kongo, Angola, and elsewhere but also knew about the black
Christians of Ethiopia and Egypt and therefore thought of Christianity
as an indigenous faith initially independent of and not wholly dominated
by white slave owners, making them more likely to embrace it once in
America.
In assessing the origins of African American Christianity it is important
to keep in mind a number of ideas. First, the development of black Chris-
tianity was an Atlantic-world phenomenon. There were black Christians
in Europe, Africa, Latin America, and the Caribbean long before people of
color were converted in large numbers in North America. Afro-Christians,
moreover, moved around the Atlantic basin with startling regularity.3 Most
went unwillingly to work, struggle, and die on New World plantations;
others began their lives as slaves but used their wits and sometimes their
religion to gain freedom and new homes; some, already free, traveled the
Atlantic in search of opportunity.
There were far more Christians in Africa before 1800 than previously rec-
ognized by most scholars of the Americas. At a peak in the sixteenth and
seventeenth centuries up to two million African Catholics lived in Kongo
and Angola. Though less successfully, white and black Christian missionar-
ies from the Caribbean, Europe, and Britain brought their versions of true
faith to the people of West Africa’s Atlantic littoral. Operating out of trading
factories or castles run by slave traders, Caribbean, European, and Eurafri-
can missionaries brought an unknown number into Christian churches
from along the region’s Atlantic coast over the course of three centuries.
Theirs was a remarkable feat considering the scant resources afforded them,
the small number of evangelists involved, and the inescapably obvious con-
18 • Embracing Protestantism
early modern Europeans’ understanding of Christianity’s finer points was
rudimentary at best, yet they still thought of themselves as Christians, the
implication being that for most Europeans the Christian label was a badge
of ethnic identity that they were initially quite hesitant to transfer to non-
Westerners. So, no matter how versed these mixed-race Eurafricans became
in biblical scripture, since they were not white they were never wholly ac-
cepted by white Europeans as true Christians. At the same time, because
they embraced a foreign cosmology, many Afro-Christians were unable to
fully integrate themselves into the African societies in which they lived, of-
ten leading them to occupy a painfully lonely and insecure middle ground.5
As previously noted, the mulatto Eurafricans who inhabited Atlantic Af-
rican coastal communities in significant numbers by the eighteenth century
were the products of European and African unions. Out of necessity be-
cause many, if not most, of them lived on the margins of two cultures, some
took advantage of their knowledge of both to fashion a new hybridized cul-
ture. Atlantic Africans, as these mulattoes are better described, were fluent
in many of the trade languages of the Atlantic basin and were to some de-
gree cosmopolitans who could function in various cultural settings.6 Many
Atlantic Africans worked in the European trade forts that began to dot the
West and Central African shoreline beginning in the sixteenth century. The
Gold Coast, along what is now modern Ghana’s Atlantic shore, had the larg-
est concentration of European slave trading posts of any stretch of the Af-
rican coast, with some sixty forts, or “factories” as they were called, there
during the height of the transatlantic slave trade in the eighteenth century.
Generally small, with usually fewer than ten white traders and Eurafrican
and African employees, these West African outposts were administered by
three larger and more impressively built “castles” controlled by European
trading companies.
Elmina Castle, constructed by the Portuguese in the sixteenth century,
was conquered by the Dutch in the seventeenth as part of their attempt to
take control of Portugal’s Atlantic empire; thereafter it became the center
of the Dutch West Indies Company’s slaving and other commercial opera-
tions in Africa. Several miles east of Elmina was Britain’s so-called grand
emporium at Cape Coast, built as a wood structure by Swedish traders in
1653, captured by the Danes ten years later, and finally taken by the English,
who rebuilt it in stone in 1664. Some seventy miles farther down Ghana’s
shoreline was Denmark’s Christiansborg Castle, where Danish merchants,
who followed a string of European occupants there that included the Por-
20 • Embracing Protestantism
How difficult it is to define what constituted a real Christian in the Af-
rican context is illustrated by the case of Eurafrican Edward Barter. Con-
temporary Afro-Dutch ship captain Willem Bosman described the Afro-
English Barter as a figure caught in the interstices of two cultures who
prospered nonetheless by serving Western business interests at the British
trading post of Cape Coast Castle on West Africa’s Gold Coast in the late
seventeenth and early eighteenth centuries. Barter spent the early 1690s in
England, where the Royal African Company paid for his education and in
1693 returned him to his native Cape Coast as its agent.11 He was valued by
his employers because he was half English but even more so because as the
son of a local African woman who was a member of an established clan he
had access local trade networks. He was invaluable as an agent for the Euro-
pean trading company also because as a longtime resident he came to know
far more about the region’s political, economic, and social affairs than did
most of the short-tenured British governors stationed at Cape Coast. By the
end of the seventeenth century he had used his position to essentially be-
come the ruler of Cape Coast, amassing so much wealth as a middleman
between the English on the coast and African merchants from the interior
that he was able to build what Bosman described as a small but well-posi-
tioned castle that he protected with several large cannon.
At the same time, Barter attained near-warlord status because he could
raise, according to Bosman, “a large number of Armed men, some whereof
are his own Slaves, and the rest are Free-Men, that adhere to him.” The
source of Barter’s wealth and power was his control of access to the British:
“whoever designs to trade with the English must stand well with him before
they can succeed.” Though he got rich living on the margins of two very dif-
ferent cultures, Barter appears to have remained loyal to the English, will-
ingly aiding their interests when they were challenged by other European
and African interlopers.12
Having one foot in the European world and the other in the African, the
aptly named Barter appeared to blend many aspects of those cultures in his
daily life. Bosman accused him of “pretending to be a Christian,” clearly fail-
ing, according to Bosman’s estimates, to uphold European Christian stan-
dards of morality. Interestingly, some scholars contend that Bosman himself
was a Eurafrican, the son of a Dutch father and an African mother, and that
his opinions about Barter may have been colored by commercial rivalry,
personal enmity, or nationalist antagonism. Obviously well educated, Bos-
man may have been trying to associate himself more closely with the Dutch
22 • Embracing Protestantism
Social pressures and the press of business caused some Atlantic Africans,
like Barter, to walk a tightrope between European and African religious be-
liefs. Bosman writes of another Anglo-African merchant who proclaimed
himself a Christian when in the presence of Europeans but did not allow his
faith to become common knowledge among the local African community.
He feared that if his African customers and neighbors knew of his Christian
affiliation they would shun him, leaving him friendless and without a way to
support his family. Even though this man, in Bosman’s words, “ridiculed his
own Country Gods,” he still made public profession of his belief in them,
ignoring men like Bosman who decried his weak faith.18 Many observers of
European descent like Bosman complained that Africans living around the
coastal trading forts who called themselves Christians were really “a sort of
half Christians.” They apparently did not think that reciting the Pater Nos-
ter and Ave Maria, confessing to a priest, and attending church on Sundays
was enough to make true Christians.19
French observers in Senegambia during the 1790s agreed with this judg-
ment of many African Christians. While touring the kingdom of Galam on
the middle reaches of the Senegal River, French traders Saugnier, whose
first name was not revealed, and Pierre-Raymond de Brisson complained
that the favorite wife of the king of Galam merely “pretends to be a Chris-
tian.” At one time she had been the mistress of a French factor on the Sen-
egal who over the course of his years in that country had converted her. She
held onto her faith as best she could under trying circumstances, wearing
a cross and observing holy days, but her show of religious fealty and con-
viction was apparently not enough for the culturally insular Frenchmen.20
In a region dominated by indigenous religions and under increasing attack
from Islamic jihadists, solitary Christians like Galam’s queen did the best
they could without the support of foreign or indigenous clergy. Saugnier
and Brisson noted that some of the local Wolof people were Christians as
well, but again the traders doubted the people’s sincerity. The Frenchmen
considered religion “a matter of indifference to” the Wolof, who were inter-
ested only in trade.21
Here again, Europeans were applying a double standard, accusing Chris-
tian Wolofs of an apparent lack of religious zeal while forgetting the indif-
ference that many titular French Catholics displayed toward church atten-
dance and other practices. French cultural influence was felt in some of
Senegambia by the late seventeenth century, notably in the port city of St.
Louis, where a large proportion of the indigenous male population worked
24 • Embracing Protestantism
use of what he considered African magic. The use of occult or magical de-
vices enjoyed widespread popularity in the Christian West throughout the
early modern period and continued its hold on educated and polite society
well into the seventeenth century, while a lively interest in non-Christian su-
pernatural devices still enjoys popularity in the early twenty-first century.26
“Wise men” and “wise women” throughout Europe and European America,
as they did in Africa, kept away disease, foretold the future, explained the
past, and tried to save the very young from untimely death primarily with
herbal medicines but also by resorting to all manner of magical amulets, po-
tions, and even verses of biblical scripture written on small scraps of paper.
Seeking protection in a violent world that struck down many in a seemingly
random manner, men and women in the early modern era made few dis-
tinctions between Christianity and magic, astrology, and divination.27 Even
evangelicals as early as the seventeenth century immersed themselves in
the occult through the practices of divine healing and the use of glossolalia.
English Baptists and Quakers performed exorcisms and miraculous cures
and tried to raise the dead at church services in the 1650s and 1680s; one
hundred years later Oxford-educated Methodist founder John Wesley con-
tinued to believe in a seemingly non-Christian “world of wonders.”28
26 • Embracing Protestantism
terpreters, and traders. Living apart from mainstream African society, many
Eurafricans reacted by trying to cultivate new identities. Instead of em-
bracing their African backgrounds, they were driven to the other extreme,
wearing European-style clothes, prominently displaying crucifixes and ro-
saries to enhance their Catholic identity, speaking Crioulo (derived from
Portuguese and several western African languages), and loudly proclaiming
that they were Portuguese, whites, and Christians. Even though Europeans
rejected them even more than did Africans, these creoles became the bed-
rock community upon which much of African Christianity was built in later
years and which then spread across the Atlantic in multiple directions.34
Perhaps the most interesting ministers to evangelize the Christian faith
in Atlantic Africa in the eighteenth century were Christian and Rebecca
Protten, a pair of black missionaries whose identities could not have been
more prototypically Atlantic African. The Prottens proselytized their black
brethren and sisters not only in Africa but in Europe and the Americas as
well. Christian was born in 1715 on the Gold Coast in what is today the
country of Ghana to a Danish father and an African mother before being
taken at age ten to Denmark. There he excelled as a student and eventually
gained entrance to the University of Copenhagen. While a student, Chris-
tian became interested in a small Protestant sect in Germany, the Renewed
Unity of the Brethren, known popularly as the Moravians; they aroused
his interest probably because they were just then beginning an aggressive
campaign to proselytize people of color in the Americas. He left school and
spent the next two years living with the Moravians at their commune in the
central German town of Herrnhut before he was sent as a missionary to his
home on the Gold Coast and later to the island of St. Thomas in the Danish
West Indies. Neither of Christian’s missions was a success, and in 1745 he
found himself back in Herrnhut, where he met Rebecca. She was of mixed-
race parentage, too, and began life as a slave on the Caribbean island of An-
tigua before being “sold to a family of high-standing” on the faraway island
of St. Thomas.35
Rebecca Protten’s early life was marked by religious activism and, as a
result, conflict with the clerical and civic leaders of St. Thomas. Having
learned to read and write Dutch in her owner’s home, where she was a do-
mestic slave, Rebecca soon came to associate herself with the Moravian
mission on the island that had been instituted there in 1732.36 Rebecca be-
came an active church member and began preaching the gospel to enslaved
African field hands. She was manumitted and in 1738 married fellow mis-
Political Influences
The Prottens, as Atlantic Africans, lived and worked in a world dominated
by the Protestant northern European countries of Holland, Denmark,
Great Britain, and Germany. Most Africans, if they were Christians in the
fifteenth through the eighteenth centuries, were not Protestants, how-
ever, but Catholics. The roots of Christianity in Sierra Leone, for example,
though usually associated with the British Protestant settlement of Lon-
don’s “black poor” and the black loyalist refugees of the American Revolu-
tion beginning in 1787, are really to be found among sojourning Portuguese
and Afro-Portuguese merchants and priests who traveled along the region’s
rainforest-shrouded rivers and savannah-fringed footpaths beginning in the
28 • Embracing Protestantism
sixteenth century. Though Portugal’s commercial and spiritual influence
in the region was in eclipse by the mid-1700s,41 when the area’s inhabitants
were most likely to be enslaved and exported to the Americas, the Portu-
guese did leave behind a sizable population of Luso-Africans who doggedly
held onto their Catholic identities and took those identities with them to
the New World.42
Officials in the Portuguese church attempted to bring Christianity to the
Sierra Leone region as early as the 1530s when they created a Catholic see in
the Cape Verde Islands 350 miles off what are today the countries of Senegal
and the Islamic Republic of Mauritania.43 This move seems to have paid off
handsomely; by the mid-seventeenth century Christianity apparently made
serious inroads into the creole population of the Cape Verdes. On a trip
to Portugal that included a stop in the Cape Verde archipelago, a reform-
minded Luso-Brazilian priest named Vieira was impressed by the mixed-
race clerics he met there, exclaiming that there “are here clergy and canons
as black as jet, but so well-bred, so authoritative, so learned, such great mu-
sicians, so discreet and so accomplished that they may well be envied by
those in our own cathedrals at home.”44 Building on such a solid platform,
the bishop of the Cape Verde Islands made a number of excursions dur-
ing the mid-sixteenth century to the mainland, where he attempted to bring
spiritual comfort and, more likely, spiritual discipline to the Portuguese
traders and sailors living there. The odd visitation was no substitute for es-
tablishing full-time resident priests, something that did not happen until a
vicar was appointed in the 1590s at Cacheu in the northwest corner of what
is now Guinea-Bissau. A major problem that plagued church officials trying
to maintain adequate staff in the Sierra Leone region as well as the rest of
tropical Africa was the horrific mortality rates endured by white mission-
aries, who regularly fell victim to the disease environment that proved so
unhealthy for Europeans. Another obstacle was the language barrier that
made trying to convey abstract religious concepts to non-Europeans nearly
impossible.45
In the last decade of the sixteenth century, Portuguese church officials
attempted to solve these problems by appointing a priest of African origin
to western Africa who could both communicate effectively with locals and
survive local epidemiological conditions. Presumably born somewhere
along the Guinea coast, though perhaps a native of the Cape Verdes, a ma-
jor stop in the transatlantic slave trade, and educated and ordained in Portu-
gal, this Atlantic African appeared to be the ideal candidate for such work.
30 • Embracing Protestantism
by Portuguese agents who viewed them as interlopers on their papally sanc-
tioned religious territory. In response, Lisbon sent Franciscan monks to the
Cape Verde Islands and elsewhere in the region; one of them, a young man
named Andre de Faro, ventured from the archipelago as far as Sierra Le-
one in 1663. By the 1650s, however, Portuguese influence in the area was in
decline, battered by economic competition from the Dutch, English, and
French, with the British eventually gaining the upper hand along the Sierra
Leone coast. Anglophone traders displayed little interest in Christian evan-
gelizing in the region before 1787, but several British travelers did neverthe-
less note Christianity’s continued presence.49
Naval officer John Atkins, for example, found himself sailing with a Brit-
ish squadron along the West African coast in the 1720s to escort several slave
ships that needed protection in those waters against roving flotillas of Atlan-
tic-world pirates. During one of his sojourns, Atkins went ashore on the coast
of Sierra Leone and met a Seignior Joseph, whom he described as a “Chris-
tian Negro of this Place.”50 An African, Joseph originally settled at the mouth
of the Sierra Leone River in 1715 and, to Atkins’s astonishment, was a Catho-
lic priest and the first priest of any color to visit or live in the region since the
1680s. Reputedly the grandson of the ruler of Cape Mount in what is today
the country of Liberia, Joseph traveled the North Atlantic in his youth, even
living in North America a short time before crossing over to Britain. It is un-
clear what prompted young Joseph’s travels. He may have been enslaved as a
consequence of war or kidnapped, taken to America, and subsequently freed
when he showed evidence of royal birth or education. Another possibility is
that he was sent to America by his family specifically to get a Western educa-
tion and was never a slave. Though not common, it appears that this African
version of what Americans and Europeans in the nineteenth century called
“the grand tour” did occur. This story was confirmed years later by SPG mis-
sionary Thomas Thompson, who on his way back to England after several
frustrating years on the African coast met Seignior Joseph.
The priest told Thompson of his sojourn to New York, where he went to
school and was baptized a Christian.51 His tour continued when he crossed
the Atlantic eastward to England, where he might have received instruction
in Chaucer, Latin, and ancient Greek philosophy but also a heavy dose of
Protestant Christianity. The latter part of his English education apparently
did not stay with him, though, because when he next traveled to Portugal
he quickly converted to Catholicism and trained to be a priest. Upon his
ordination, Joseph sailed for Sierra Leone and home.52
32 • Embracing Protestantism
ing the dining area “decently and without Hurry or Laugh.” Atkins might
have attributed this good behavior to the civilizing influence of Christian-
ity, as he appeared to believe Joseph was a true Christian. To be counted a
real Christian, conformity to European discourses about gender and class
seem to have been at least as important as having an intimate and nuanced
knowledge of scripture.55
The African Catholic priest Joseph lived an apparently long and well-
traveled life, there being evidence that as an older man, after 1750, he moved
with his followers from his inland settlement on the Sierra Leone River
north and west to the coast of Bissau. In Bissau a local leader named José
Lopez, who historian P.E.H. Hair believes was in fact Seignior Joseph, con-
tacted the Portuguese in the 1750s asking for missionaries and a trade alli-
ance. Joseph’s mantle in Bissau was taken up later in the century by a man
named Seignior Domingo, a local African leader who reputedly could read
Portuguese and claimed to be a Catholic. The black American Protestants
who later settled in Sierra Leone came into contact with Seignior Domingo
in the 1790s, keeping West African Christianity alive and tracing yet another
connection through Domingo and Joseph between black Christians on
both sides of the Atlantic.
As late as the 1790s, a Portuguese traveler in Sierra Leone asserted that
“the number of Christians dispersed through the distant hinterlands is
infinite.” To back up this claim, he described an incident in which a white
priest, when encamped at a river crossing in the Sierra Leone interior, was
inundated by faithful Africans demanding that he dispense the sacraments
and baptize their children.56 While reports of such examples of spontane-
ous popular Christianity in West Africa may be a case of wishful thinking
by a hopeful Lusitanian, there is a grain of truth to the idea that Christianity
survived in the African hinterland without European priests to guide it or,
unfortunately, write about it.
The African form of Christianity had been a presence in coastal West Af-
rica for more than 250 years by the turn of the eighteenth and nineteenth
centuries. It remained a minority religion in the region, but to have survived
at all it had to have been incorporated into the social fabric of individual
clans and lineage groups. If village leaders like Seignior Joseph and Seignior
Domingo accepted Christianity, then it became an essential part of that
group’s identity, so that to be part of the group meant being Christian. With
this type of quasi-institutional support, Christianity’s continuation, however
modified or muted by isolation from Europeans, was certainly a possibility.
34 • Embracing Protestantism
allies. Living in exile in Portugal, Jeleen eventually converted to Christian-
ity, but he also never stopped asking for arms to regain his lost kingdom.
King João, for his part, knew that in order to spread the faith he had to es-
tablish trade relations with the Wolof, and trade with the Wolof would, he
hoped, open up commercial relations with the legendary and presumably
rich commercial center of Timbuktu farther inland; that in turn would pro-
vide the resources and people to spread Christianity into an African interior
then dominated by Islam. João and Jeleen must have recognized that dis-
associating religious faith from commerce and politics would be unattain-
able.62
The relationship between trade and political power on the one hand and
religious faith on the other has long been fraught with charges of oppor-
tunism. But as the Jolof king’s example demonstrates, there was no clear
line between religion and politics in early modern Europe or Africa. There
is evidence that Jeleen’s conversion to Catholicism was sincere. Jeleen and
João would have known that supernatural allies were essential to success
in politics or on the field of battle. Adopting a non-African religion could
be dangerous for a ruler, yet the power of Western technology must have
inspired many Africans to believe that metaphysical forces were behind
the power of European guns. Cold calculation by African monarchs surely
played an important role in such matters; still, religious conviction cannot
be discounted.63
João II’s successors continued to send merchants and priests to the area
in the following decades and beyond. By the seventeenth century, though,
Portuguese traders and missionaries were increasingly marginalized by
larger and more powerful European states that could sell goods to Afri-
can buyers at far better prices. Portugal did not give up on the region and
was able to re-enter the West African market at least once during the late
seventeenth century as a consequence of the War of the League of Augs-
burg (1689–97), which pitted forces led by the English against those of the
French under Louis XIV. Taking advantage of the Franco-British imbroglio,
the government in Lisbon sent merchants and Franciscan monks to Ilha de
Bissau, in what is now the country of Guinea-Bissau, baptized its ruler, and
reestablished commercial relations.
By 1694, with official Bissau embracing or at least not resisting Francis-
can evangelism, the monks there claimed to have brought some 700 Afri-
cans into the church in Bissau, 1,200 in Geba, another 700 at Cacheu, and
600 more at Bolor. Unfortunately for Portugal, its religious and commercial
36 • Embracing Protestantism
though they never dominated the slave quarters of the West Indies or North
America like they sometimes did in Brazil, black Muslim slaves, some of
them distinguished by their ability to read and write, attracted wide notice
by slave owners.69
Islam’s expansion in West Africa was accelerated by the sporadic Mus-
lim holy wars, or jihads, that engulfed the western African hinterland for
much of the eighteenth century. As early as 1727, Fulbe Muslims attacked
their pagan neighbors, selling some, in this case the Susu, into the Atlantic
slave market.70 Ethnic groups, such as they were, could also be split along re-
ligious lines, pitting one faction whose adherents believed in an indigenous
African religion against an Islamic faction. Such was the case for the Fulbe
living in the highland region of what is now Guinea. They divided them-
selves into the Fulbe-Timba, who maintained their indigenous faith, and
the Islamic Fulbe-Labe, making war on each other even though they shared
the same culture and spoke the same language.71
Neighboring Futa Jalon’s Muslim armies won and lost numerous battles
during the course of the eighteenth century, inevitably causing some of
their number to be sold into slavery in the Americas.72 A decisive victory
in 1789 consolidated Fulbe Muslim hegemony over Futa so that it was not
successfully invaded again until European colonization occurred late in
the nineteenth century.73 One of the main reasons Muslim leaders resorted
to armed aggression against their neighbors was that those same neighbors
raided Muslim towns, capturing free Muslims, and selling them into slav-
ery.74 Interestingly, western Africa’s Muslims were not opposed to slavery
as an institution: there is no prohibition against slavery in the Qur’an.75
Without any religious sanction, the Futa became a major slave-trading
people as the century wore on, selling captives of its raids and wars to the
French at Conakry and the British at James Fort at the mouth of the Gam-
bia River.76
While Muslim slave traders felt no to need justify their trade in slaves,
British slave traders, whose apologists used the threat of Islamic expansion
as a rationale for the trade’s continuance, conversely did feel the need to jus-
tify their activities. John Matthews, a lieutenant stationed aboard a British
Royal Navy frigate that toured the coast of West Africa in the 1780s, main-
tained that abolishing the slave trade would be detrimental to British inter-
ests because that would mean bringing to an end the education of numerous
Africans who were sent to Europe for that purpose. Gaining some Western
learning and, Matthews hoped, a dose of Protestant Christianity, these sons
The title of Count Gondomar was conferred upon him by Philip III. in
1617, but the date of his death is still a desideratum. Many
anecdotes concerning him are to be seen scattered in Howel's
Treatise of Ambassadors.
W. M. R. E.
DOOR-HEAD INSCRIPTIONS.
(Vol. vi., p. 543.)
taking "hospes" not as guest but host, and the literal words, "My
servant is not a dormouse, nor (I) the host a leech."
Dr. Diamond ("N. & Q.," Vol. vi., p. 277.) says (I quote briefly), "Pour
upon 100 grains of cotton an ounce and a half of nitric acid,
previously mixed with one ounce of strong sulphuric acid. Knead it
with glass rods during five minutes," &c.
With regard to Mr. Mabley's process, described in "N. & Q.," No. 176.,
p. 267., as I am but a beginner myself, and have much to learn, I
should be sorry to condemn it; but I should fear that his pictures
would not exhibit sufficient contrast in the tints. Nor do I see the
advantage the pictures would possess, if they did, over positives
taken by our process. We amateurs in the country labour at present
under great disadvantages, some of which I think the Photographic
Society will remove. I am myself quite unable to form an idea what
the collodion pictures done by first-rate photographers are like. All
the positives done by amateurs in this part of the world, and
developed by pyrogallic acid, which I have seen, present a dirty
brown hue, by no means pleasing or artistic; and I have seen but
very few, either developed by pyrogallic acid or protosulphate of
iron, free from blemishes. I think if we were to act upon the
suggestion made in "N. & Q." some time back, and send the editor a
specimen of our performances, it would be a slight return for his
endeavours in our behalf; and he would, I doubt not, honestly tell us
whether our pictures were tolerable or not. I, for one, shall be very
happy to do so.
J. L. Sisson.
Edingthorpe Rectory.
N.B. The solution of lead must contain acid; and if by keeping it does
not change litmus-paper, acid must be added till it does.
Weld Taylor.
7. Conduit Street West.
Replies to Minor Queries.
Contested Elections (Vol. vii., p.208.).—There is a very fair history of
the boroughs of Great Britain, by Edwards, in 3 Vols. 8vo., printed by
Debrett in 1792.
J. B.
I hope that Mr. Sansom will inform your readers of the ultimate result
of his inquiries on this interesting subject.
P. H.
Lord Goring (Vol. ii., pp. 22. 65.; Vol. vii., p. 143.).—In the order-
books of the council of state, I find that William Killegrew was, on
the 1st Oct., 1642, appointed lieutenant-colonel of the regiment of
Colonel Goringh, vice Thomas Hollis, deceased; and that, on the
26th March, 1647, he was named colonel of the same regiment, vice
Colonel Goringh, resigned. That the last-mentioned colonel is George
Goringh we learn from the war-budget (Staat van Oorlog) of 1644,
where the salaries of
The Art of Politics, by the Rev. Mr. Bramston, contains the following
lines, which will, I apprehend, give your correspondent the required
information:
Curtseys and Bows (Vol. vii., p. 156).—In the interlude of The Trial of
Treasure, by Purfoote, 1567 (page 14. of reprint), Inclination says to
Gredy-gutte:
For rationale of bows and curtseys, see "N. & Q.," Vol. v., p. 157.,
though I fancy the bob curtseys are the ones referred to.
Thos. Lawrence.
Ashby-de-la-Zouch.
The Whetstone (Vol. vii., p. 208.).—In your No. 174. of "N. & Q.," E.
G. R. alludes to the Game of the Whetstone. The following
quotation, as bearing on that subject, may not be uninteresting to
your readers:
"In the fourth year of this king's (Edward VI.) reign, in the
month of September, one Grig, a poulterer of Surrey (taken
among the people for a prophet, in curing of divers diseases by
words and prayers, and saying he would take no money), was,
by command of the Earl of Warwick, and others of the Council,
set on a scaffold in the town of Croidon, in Surrey, with a paper
on his breast, wherein was written his deceitful and hypocritical
dealings: and after that, on the eighth of September, set on a
pillory in Southwark, being then Our Lady Fair there kept; and
the Mayor of London, with his brethren the aldermen, riding
through the fair, the said Grig asked them and all the citizens
forgiveness.
"'Of the like counterfeit physicians,' saith Stow, 'I have noted, in
the summary of my Chronicles (anno 1382), to be set on
horseback, his face to the horse-tail, the same tail in his hand
as a bridle, a collar of jordans about his neck, a whetstone on
his breast; and so led through the city of London, with ringing
of basons, and banished.'
Cheese is now eaten with apple puddings and pies; but is there any
nook in England where they still grate it over plum pudding? I have
heard the joke of forgetting the pudding-cloth, told against Lord
Macartney during his embassy in China. Your correspondent will find
plum porridge and plum puddings mentioned together at page 122.
vol. ii. of Knight's Old England.
Thos. Lawrence.
Ashby-de-la-Zouch.
The Burial Service by heart (Vol. vii., p. 13.).—In the Life of the Rev.
Griffith Jones, the celebrated founder of the Welsh circulating charity
schools, is this note:
Footnote 3:(return)
"Cob" and "Conners" (Vol. vii., p. 234.).—These words are Celtic. Cob
means a mouth, a harbour, an entrance. Conners appears to be a
compound word, from cuan, a bay or harbour, and mar or mara, the
sea; pronounced "Cuan wara," then shortened into Conner. Conna-
mara, in the west of Ireland, properly spelled Cuan na mara, means
"bays of the sea."
Fras. Crossley.
I may add that ladies have also been included in the commission of
the peace. The Lady Bartlet was made a justice of the peace by
Queen Mary in Gloucestershire (Harl. MSS); Margaret, Countess of
Richmond, mother of Henry VII., was made a justice of peace; and a
lady in Sussex, of the name of Rowse, did usually sit on the bench at
the assizes and sessions amongst other justices cincta gladio (op.
cit.).
W. S.
Northiam.
ebookbell.com