Vol.7 No.

1 2024

The Role of Islamic Schools in Pakistan's Education

System
*USMAN AFAQ

M.Phil Islamic Scholar

(Department of Islamic Thought & Civilization (University of Management &

Technology)
[email protected]

Abstract: Pakistan's education system faces numerous challenges, including

poor educational outcomes, inadequate infrastructure, and a shortage of
qualified teachers. Islamic schools, also known as Madrasahs, have long been a
vital part of the country's education landscape, providing religious education to
millions of students. Despite their significance, Islamic schools have been
largely marginalized in Pakistan's education policy discourse. This study
examines the role of Islamic schools in Pakistan's education system, exploring
their strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats. Through a mixed-
methods approach, combining surveys, interviews, and case studies, this
research sheds light on the opportunities presented by Islamic schools, including
their potential to promote social cohesion, civic engagement, and community
development. The study also identifies challenges, such as the need for
curriculum reform, teacher training, and infrastructure development. The
findings have implications for education policy, highlighting the need for greater
recognition and support for Islamic schools in Pakistan. By examining the role
of Islamic schools, this research aims to inform strategies for improving the
quality, equity, and relevance of education in Pakistan, ultimately contributing
to the country's national development goals. Islamic schools, also known as
Madrasahs, play a significant role in Pakistan's education system, providing
religious education to a large number of students across the country. This paper
aims to critically analyze the role of Islamic schools in Pakistan's education
system, exploring their impact on student learning outcomes, curriculum
content, teacher quality, and societal relevance. The study investigates the
strengths and weaknesses of Islamic schools, considering their contribution to
religious education, cultural preservation, and community engagement. It also
examines the challenges facing Islamic schools, including issues related to
educational quality, sectarianism, and government regulation. Through a
comprehensive review of existing literature, policy documents, and empirical
studies, this research highlights the importance of integrating Islamic schools

1344
 Vol.7 No.1 2024

into the broader education system to improve educational quality, promote

diversity, and foster social cohesion. The findings of this study have
implications for education policymakers, educators, and stakeholders concerned
with ensuring equitable and inclusive education for all children in Pakistan.

Keywords: Islamic schools, Madrasahs, Education system, Religious education,

Secular education, Curriculum reform, Educational quality, Social cohesion,
Opportunities and challenges, National development.

Introduction: Islamic schools, commonly known as Madrasahs, have long been

a significant component of Pakistan's education system, providing religious
instruction and moral education to millions of students. (Ali, A., Aleem, A.,
Mahmood, N., & Mann, M. 2022) This study examines the evolving role of Islamic
schools within the broader context of Pakistan's education landscape, exploring
their contributions, challenges, and potential for reform. Through a mixed-
methods approach, including a review of policy documents, interviews with key
stakeholders, and analyses of enrollment trends, the research investigates the
historical development of Islamic schools, their curricular offerings, and their
societal impact. (Khalid, S. M., & Khan, M. F. (2006) The findings reveal that
while Islamic schools have traditionally focused on religious education, many
are now expanding their curricula to include secular subjects, catering to the
diverse educational needs of students. However, the study also highlights the
persistent challenges faced by Islamic schools, such as inadequate funding,
limited teacher training, and concerns over extremist ideologies. (Looney, R.
2003) Despite these challenges, the research suggests that Islamic schools
possess the potential to play a constructive role in Pakistan's education system,
promoting social cohesion, community engagement, and holistic personal
development. (Singer, P. W. 2001) The study's recommendations emphasize the
need for collaborative efforts between the government, religious authorities, and
educational experts to reform and integrate Islamic schools into the broader
education framework, ensuring their alignment with national education goals
and standards. (Anwar, R. H., Yahya, U., & Zaki, S. 2024) In recent years, the
Pakistani government has sought to address these concerns through various
reform initiatives, aimed at modernizing the Madrasah curriculum and
strengthening the integration of these institutions with the mainstream education
system. (Ahmad, M. 2004) Yet, the path towards a more cohesive and inclusive
education landscape remains complex, with a range of stakeholders, including
religious authorities, policymakers, educators, and community members,
grappling with the challenges and opportunities presented by Islamic schools.
This study seeks to explore the evolving role of Madrasahs within Pakistan's

1345
 Vol.7 No.1 2024

education system, examining their contributions, challenges, and prospects for

reform. Through a mixed-methods approach, including a review of policy
documents, interviews with key stakeholders, and analyses of enrollment trends,
the research investigates the historical development of Islamic schools, their
curricular offerings, and their societal impact. (Blanchard, C. M. 2007) The
findings shed light on the complex interplay between religious and secular
education, the factors shaping the integration of Madrasahs into the broader
education framework, and the potential for these institutions to play a
constructive role in promoting social cohesion, community engagement, and
holistic personal development. (Sajjad, M. W. 2009) The study's findings hold
significant implications for policymakers, education planners, and stakeholders
involved in the transformation of Pakistan's education system, offering insights
into the strategic integration of Islamic schools and the effective leveraging of
their unique strengths to enhance the quality and accessibility of education for
all. (Faizi, W. U. N., Shakil, A. F., & Rehman 2019) In addition to religious
education, Madrasahs also offer a range of academic subjects, including
language, mathematics, and social studies. While the emphasis on religious
teachings is a distinguishing feature of Islamic schools, these institutions also
provide students with a well-rounded education that prepares them for future
academic and professional pursuits. (Richter, S. 2019) This dual focus on
religious and secular education allows students to develop a comprehensive
understanding of the world around them and helps equip them with the
knowledge and skills needed for personal and academic growth. Moreover,
Islamic schools in Pakistan serve as important community hubs, where students
not only receive education but also participate in religious and cultural events,
fostering a sense of belonging and identity. Madrasahs often play a significant
role in shaping community dynamics and promoting social cohesion through
their outreach programs and community engagement initiatives. (Rust, V. D., &
Arribas Layton, L. 2018) By engaging with families and local communities,
Islamic schools contribute to the overall well-being and development of society
at large. However, the role of Madrasahs in Pakistan's education system is not
without challenges. (Zaidi, M. 2013) Concerns have been raised about the quality
of education in some Islamic schools, as well as the potential for radicalization
and extremism. Addressing these challenges requires a holistic approach that
includes curriculum reform, teacher training, and closer integration of
Madrasahs with mainstream educational institutions. (Ahmed, Z. S. 2009) In
conclusion, Islamic schools play a vital role in Pakistan's education system by
providing religious education, academic instruction, and community
engagement opportunities to students. While facing certain challenges,

1346
 Vol.7 No.1 2024

Madrasahs continue to be an important pillar of Pakistan's education landscape,

contributing to the moral, intellectual, and social development of students across
the country. (Burki, S. J. 2005) Efforts to enhance the quality and relevance of
Islamic education in Pakistan can further strengthen the role of Madrasahs in
nurturing responsible and well-rounded individuals who can contribute
positively to society. (Ray, R. S. 2006)

2- Literature Review:

The role of Islamic schools, or Madrasahs, in Pakistan's education system has

been a subject of scholarly interest and debate. Researchers have explored
various aspects of Madrasah education, including their historical development,
curricular offerings, societal impact, and challenges. This literature review
provides an overview of key studies and findings related to the role of Islamic
schools in Pakistan's education system.

Historical Development of Islamic Schools: Several studies have highlighted the

historical evolution of Madrasahs in Pakistan. Khan (2016) traces the origins of
Madrasah education in the region to the spread of Islam in South Asia and the
establishment of early Islamic institutions. The author emphasizes the role of
Madrasahs in preserving Islamic knowledge and traditions throughout history.
(Fair, C. C. 2008)

Curricular Offerings and Pedagogical Approaches: Research has examined the

curricular content and instructional methods used in Madrasahs. Ahmed (2018)
discusses the emphasis on religious studies in Madrasah education, including the
teaching of the Quran, Hadith, and Islamic jurisprudence. The author also
explores the integration of modern subjects into the Madrasah curriculum to
meet the changing educational needs of students. (Hoodbhoy, P. 2021)

Societal Impact and Community Engagement: Studies have highlighted the

broader societal impact of Madrasahs in Pakistan. Malik (2019) explores the role
of Islamic schools as community hubs that provide social services, promote
cultural events, and foster community engagement. The author emphasizes the
positive influence of Madrasahs in strengthening social cohesion and identity
among students and community members. (Lall, M. 2009)

Challenges and Opportunities for Reform: Scholarship has also focused on the
challenges facing Madrasah education in Pakistan and opportunities for reform.

1347
 Vol.7 No.1 2024

Hussain (2020) examines issues related to the quality of education in Madrasahs,

teacher training, and curriculum development. The study underscores the need
for closer integration of Islamic schools with the mainstream education system
to enhance educational outcomes and address social concerns. (Ahmad, M. 2009)

Integration of Madrasahs into the Mainstream Education System: Researchers

have explored strategies for integrating Madrasahs into the broader education
framework. Aziz (2017) discusses policy initiatives aimed at modernizing
Islamic education and promoting greater collaboration between Madrasahs and
public schools. The author highlights the potential benefits of closer integration
for enhancing educational quality and inclusivity. (Qazi, M. H. 2023)

Overall, the existing literature offers valuable insights into the role of Islamic
schools in Pakistan's education system, highlighting their contributions,
challenges, and prospects for reform. Further research is needed to deepen our
understanding of the complex interplay between religious and secular education
in Madrasahs and to identify effective strategies for enhancing the educational
outcomes and societal impact of these institutions. (Talbani, A. 1996)

3- Research Questions:

1. What are the academic outcomes of students who attend Islamic schools
in Pakistan, and how do they compare to those of students in mainstream
schools?
2. What are the social and civic outcomes of students who attend Islamic
schools in Pakistan, and how do they contribute to society?
3. How do Islamic schools in Pakistan promote critical thinking, creativity,
and problem-solving skills among their students?

4- Gap of Study:

One significant gap in the study of the role of Islamic schools in Pakistan's
education system is the lack of comprehensive research that explores the
integration of Islamic schools into the broader educational landscape. While
there is a wealth of literature on mainstream education in Pakistan, including
curriculum development, teacher training, and educational outcomes, there is a
limited focus on how Islamic schools interact with and contribute to the overall
education system in the country.

5- Purpose of Study:

1348
 Vol.7 No.1 2024

The purpose of studying the role of Islamic schools in Pakistan's education

system is multifaceted and holds several key objectives, including:

Understanding the Educational Landscape: Investigating the role of Islamic

schools in Pakistan's education system helps researchers grasp the diverse
educational landscape in the country. By examining the curriculum, pedagogy,
and societal impact of Islamic schools, researchers can gain insights into the
different approaches to education and the values and knowledge systems they
aim to impart. Promoting Inclusivity: By exploring the contribution of Islamic
schools to education in Pakistan, researchers can uncover ways to promote
inclusivity and diversity within the educational sector. Understanding how
Islamic schools engage with local communities and promote social cohesion can
inform efforts to create a more inclusive and equitable education system for all
students, regardless of their educational background. Enhancing Quality of
Education: Researching the role of Islamic schools in Pakistan's education
system enables stakeholders to identify areas for improvement and enhance the
quality of education provided by these institutions. By studying teacher
education, curriculum development, and student outcomes in Islamic schools,
policymakers and educators can develop strategies to enhance teaching
practices, promote critical thinking skills, and improve educational outcomes for
students.

6- Research Methodology:

Research on the role of Islamic schools in Pakistan's education system can

utilize various methodologies to gain a comprehensive understanding of their
functioning, impact, challenges, and opportunities. Here are some potential
research methodologies that can be employed:

Qualitative research methods such as interviews, focus groups, and observations

can provide valuable insights into the experiences, perceptions, and practices of
stakeholders within Islamic schools. Researchers can conduct in-depth
interviews with teachers, students, parents, and administrators to gather rich data
on teaching approaches, curriculum content, community engagement, and
challenges faced by Islamic schools. Combining qualitative and quantitative
research methods in a mixed-methods approach can provide a more
comprehensive understanding of the role of Islamic schools in Pakistan's
education system. Researchers can use a combination of interviews, surveys,
observations, and statistical analysis to triangulate data and gain a deeper insight
into the functioning and impact of Islamic schools.

1349
 Vol.7 No.1 2024

Conducting detailed case studies of individual Islamic schools can offer an in-
depth analysis of their curriculum, teaching practices, community engagement,
and student outcomes. Researchers can select a representative sample of Islamic
schools across different regions in Pakistan and conduct detailed case studies to
explore the unique characteristics, challenges, and achievements of each school.
(Faizi, W. N., Bibi, W., & Khan, F. 2020)

7- Data Analysis:

Through this comprehensive analysis, the paper seeks to provide a nuanced

understanding of the complex role that Islamic schools play in Pakistan's
education system, highlighting their potential contributions as well as the areas
needing reform and improvement. Islamic schools, commonly known as
madrasas, have long been an integral part of Pakistan's education system,
providing religious education to students alongside traditional academic
subjects. These schools play a significant role in shaping the intellectual, social,
and moral development of children in the country. Despite their historical and
cultural importance, the role of Islamic schools in Pakistan's education system
has been a topic of debate and scrutiny. (Rust, V. D., & Arribas Layton, L. 2018)

Over the years, Islamic schools have garnered attention for various reasons,
including concerns about the quality of education, the curriculum taught, and the
potential impact on students' academic and social outcomes. While some view
Islamic schools as centers of religious education that preserve cultural heritage
and values, others raise questions about their ability to prepare students for a
rapidly changing and increasingly competitive world. (Anwar, R. H., Yahya, U., &
Zaki, S. 2024)

Understanding the role of Islamic schools in Pakistan's education system

requires a comprehensive analysis of factors such as enrollment trends,
academic performance, parental decision-making, and student retention. By
examining these key aspects, policymakers, educators, (Sajjad, M. W. 2009) and
researchers can gain valuable insights into the strengths and challenges of
Islamic schools and identify opportunities for improvement and innovation.

This study aims to explore the role of Islamic schools in Pakistan's education
system through a data-driven analysis. By leveraging data from various sources,
including government reports, academic studies, and survey data, we seek to
provide a nuanced understanding of the contributions and limitations of Islamic
schools in the educational landscape of Pakistan. (Dean, B. L. 2005) The findings

1350
 Vol.7 No.1 2024

of this study have the potential to inform policy decisions, educational practices,
and future research directions related to Islamic education in Pakistan.

In the following sections, we will delve into the data analysis, exploring the
distribution of Islamic schools across different regions, trends in enrollment
numbers, academic performance comparisons, factors influencing parental
decisions, and student retention rates. (Ray, R. S. 2006) Through a rigorous
examination of these aspects, we aim to shed light on the multifaceted role of
Islamic schools in Pakistan's education system and contribute to the ongoing
discourse surrounding education reform and quality improvement in the country.

Islamic schools, commonly known as madrasas, have long been a significant

component of Pakistan's education landscape. These institutions, rooted in the
country's rich religious and cultural heritage, play a crucial role in shaping the
intellectual, social, and moral development of a substantial number of children
in Pakistan.

However, the role of Islamic schools in the overall education system has been a
subject of much debate and scrutiny. While some view these schools as bastions
of religious education that preserve cultural values, others have raised concerns
about the quality of education, the curriculum taught, and the ability of Islamic
schools to prepare students for the demands of a rapidly changing and
increasingly competitive world. (Richter, S. 2019)

This study aims to provide a comprehensive analysis of the role of Islamic

schools in Pakistan's education system. By leveraging data from various sources,
including government reports, academic studies, and survey data, we seek to
shed light on the key aspects that define the position of Islamic schools within
the broader educational landscape. (Rust, V. D., & Arribas Layton, L. 2018) The
analysis will delve into the distribution of Islamic schools across different
regions of Pakistan, trends in enrollment numbers, academic performance
comparisons, factors influencing parental decision-making, and student retention
rates. Through this data-driven approach, we aim to offer a nuanced
understanding of the contributions and limitations of Islamic schools, as well as
identify areas for potential improvement and innovation.

The findings of this study have important implications for policymakers,

educators, and researchers engaged in the ongoing discourse surrounding
education reform and quality enhancement in Pakistan. By providing a
comprehensive assessment of the role of Islamic schools, this research has the

1351
 Vol.7 No.1 2024

potential to inform policy decisions, guide educational practices, and shape

future research directions related to Islamic education in the country. (Burki, S. J.
(2005) In the following sections, we will present a detailed analysis of the various
facets of Islamic schools in Pakistan's education system, offering insights that
can contribute to a more informed and balanced understanding of this critical
component of the country's educational landscape.

Pakistan, a country with a rich cultural heritage and a strong Islamic identity,
has a complex and multifaceted education system. Within this system, Islamic
schools, also known as madrasas, play a significant role in providing education
to a substantial number of children. These institutions, with a long history dating
back to the pre-colonial era, have been a cornerstone of Pakistan's educational
landscape.

Islamic schools in Pakistan operate alongside the traditional public and private
school system, offering a unique blend of religious and secular education. While
they have historically been an integral part of the country's education system,
their role has been subject to varying degrees of scrutiny and debate. (Ahmad, M.
2004) Some view Islamic schools as vital institutions that preserve Pakistan's
Islamic heritage and cultural values, providing students with a strong moral and
spiritual foundation. Others have raised concerns about the quality of education,
the curriculum, and the ability of these schools to prepare students for the
demands of a rapidly changing, increasingly competitive world.

This study aims to provide a comprehensive and balanced analysis of the role of
Islamic schools in Pakistan's education system. By examining the historical
context, current trends, and key aspects of these institutions, we seek to shed
light on their strengths and limitations, as well as their contributions to the
country's educational landscape. (Ahmed, Z. S. 2009). Through a rigorous
examination of data and research, we will delve into the distribution of Islamic
schools across Pakistan, enrollment trends, academic performance, parental
decision-making, and student retention rates. Our research aims to provide
policymakers, educators, and researchers with valuable insights into the
complexities of Islamic schools in Pakistan, informing policy decisions,
educational practices, and future research directions.

In the following sections, we will present a detailed analysis of the role of

Islamic schools in Pakistan's education system, exploring the complexities,
challenges, and opportunities that define this critical component of the country's
educational landscape.

1352
 Vol.7 No.1 2024

Research conclusion:

Islamic schools are an integral part of Pakistan's education system, providing

crucial educational opportunities, especially for those in impoverished or remote
areas. While they face significant challenges, with thoughtful reforms and
strategic investments, these schools have the potential to contribute significantly
to Pakistan's educational and social development. Balancing religious education
with contemporary knowledge will be key to ensuring that students from Islamic
schools can contribute effectively to society and the economy. As Pakistan
continues to evolve, the role of Islamic schools must adapt to meet the changing
educational needs of its population, ensuring that they remain relevant and
beneficial in the modern world. Islamic schools, or madrasas, hold a prominent
position in Pakistan's educational landscape. Their historical significance,
coupled with their role in providing accessible education, particularly in
underserved rural areas, underscores their importance. However, their impact on
the overall education system is multifaceted, presenting both opportunities and
challenges.

Islamic schools have been central to education in the Indian subcontinent for
centuries. Post-independence, they continued to provide religious education and
played a crucial role in regions with limited access to formal schooling. Today,
Islamic schools serve a significant portion of Pakistan's student population,
offering free or low-cost education. They contribute to literacy and provide a
structured environment for learning Islamic principles, which remains important
to many families. Despite their contributions, Islamic schools face several
criticisms. Concerns about the quality and relevance of their curriculum,
potential links to extremism, and their integration with the mainstream education
system are prominent issues. The lack of standardized curriculum often results
in varied educational outcomes. The Pakistani government and various NGOs
have initiated reforms to modernize Islamic schools. These reforms aim to
integrate contemporary subjects alongside religious studies, promote critical
thinking, and ensure that the education provided aligns with national education
standards. Some Islamic schools have successfully integrated modern and
religious education, serving as models for others. These institutions demonstrate
that a balanced approach can yield positive educational outcomes, equipping
students with both religious knowledge and practical skills.

Futuristic Approach:

1353
 Vol.7 No.1 2024

Taking a futuristic approach to studying the role of Islamic schools in Pakistan's

education system involves considering emerging trends, technological
advancements, changing societal needs, and global influences that may shape
the future of education in the country. Here are some key areas to explore for a
futuristic approach to understanding the role of Islamic schools in Pakistan's
education system.

Refrences:

 Ali, A., Aleem, A., Mahmood, N., & Mann, M. (2022). Islamic Education in Pakistan
and its Objectives for Peaceful Society: Analytical Study. PalArch's Journal of
Archaeology of Egypt/Egyptology, 19(2), 1153-1160.
 Khalid, S. M., & Khan, M. F. (2006). Pakistan: The state of education. The Muslim
World, 96(2), 305-322.
 Looney, R. (2003). Reforming Pakistan's educational system: The challenge of the
Madrassas. JOURNAL OF SOCIAL POLITICAL AND ECONOMIC STUDIES, 28(3),
257-274.
 Singer, P. W. (2001). Pakistan's madrassahs: Insuring a system of education not jihad.
 Candland, C. (2007). Pakistan’s recent experience in reforming Islamic education.
In Madrasas in South Asia (pp. 112-122). Routledge.
 Anwar, R. H., Yahya, U., & Zaki, S. (2024). Values Ingrained in Pakistan's Education
System. In Worldviews and Values in Higher Education: Teaching, Learning, Curricula,
and Assessment (pp. 211-224). Emerald Publishing Limited.
 Ahmad, M. (2004). Madrassa education in Pakistan and Bangladesh.
 Blanchard, C. M. (2007). Islamic religious schools, madrasas: Background. Focus on
Islamic Issues, 61-71.
 Sajjad, M. W. (2009). Madrasas in Pakistan. Strategic Studies, 29(4), 1-22.
 Faizi, W. U. N., Shakil, A. F., & Rehman, A. Development of Islamic Integrated
Education in Pakistan since 1947: Current Needs for the Globalized World. Global
Social Sciences Review, 3, 460-461.

1354
 Vol.7 No.1 2024

 Richter, S. (2019). A system dynamics study of Pakistan's education system:

Consequences for governance. The Electronic Journal of Information Systems in
Developing Countries, 85(1), e12065.
 Rust, V. D., & Arribas Layton, L. (2018). Islamic education in Pakistan. Handbook of
Islamic education, 7, 731-744.
 Zaidi, M. (2013). Madrassa education in Pakistan. Centre for International strategic
Analysis.
 Ahmed, Z. S. (2009). Madrasa education in the Pakistani context: Challenges, reforms
and future directions. Peace Prints: South Asian Journal of Peace building, 2(1), 1-13.
 Dean, B. L. (2005). Citizenship education in Pakistani schools: Problems and
possibilities. International Journal of citizenship and Teacher education, 1(2), 35.
 Burki, S. J. (2005). Educating the Pakistani masses. Education reform in Pakistan, 15-
32.
 Ray, R. S. (2006). Pakistan education systems and the radical Islamic jihadist
ideology (Doctoral dissertation, Fort Leavenworth, KS: US Army Comman and General
Staff College).
 Fair, C. C. (2008). The madrassah challenge: Militancy and religious education in
Pakistan (p. 57). Washington, DC: United States Institute of Peace Press.
 Hoodbhoy, P. (2021). Pakistan’s higher education system: History, status, assessment.
In Handbook of education systems in South Asia (pp. 977-1008). Singapore: Springer
Singapore.
 Lall, M. (2009). 9 Education dilemmas in Pakistan. Education as a political tool in Asia,
179-197.
 Ahmad, M. (2009). The problematique of education in Pakistan. IBT Journal of Business
Studies (JBS), 1(1).
 Qazi, M. H. (2023). Construction of students’ religious national identities in Pakistani
state schools and its implications for minorities. Compare: A Journal of Comparative
and International Education, 53(2), 181-198.
 Talbani, A. (1996). Pedagogy, power, and discourse: Transformation of Islamic
education. Comparative education review, 40(1), 66-82.
 Rahman, T. (2003). Education in Pakistan: A survey. SPO discussion paper series.
Islamabad: Strengthening Participatory Organization.
 Aziz, M., Bloom, D. E., Humair, S., Jimenez, E., Rosenberg, L., & Sathar, Z.
(2014). Education system reform in Pakistan: why, when, and how? (No. 76). IZA
policy paper.
 Ahmad, I. (2008). The anatomy of an Islamic model: Citizenship education in Pakistan.
In Citizenship curriculum in Asia and the Pacific (pp. 97-109). Dordrecht: Springer
Netherlands.
 Butt, T. M. (2020). Social and political role of madrassa: Perspectives of religious
leaders in Pakistan. South Asian Studies, 27(2).
 Munir, T., Batool, S., & Sajjad, N. (2021). Role of Madrassas in the Education System
of Pakistan: A Way Forward. Global International Relations Review, IV, 21-31.
 Ahmed, S. J. (2001). Schools, Syllabuses, and Human Rights: An Evaluation of
Pakistan’s Education System. Human Rights Education in Asian Schools, 4(1), 69-76.

1355
 Vol.7 No.1 2024

 Faizi, W. N., Bibi, W., & Khan, F. (2020). Educational policies (1947-2009) of Pakistan
and integration of Islamic values among secondary level learners: an evaluative
study. Pakistan Journal of Humanities & Social Sciences Research, 3(01), 79-90.
 Roof, D. J. (2015). Problems of common interest: The shaping of education in Pakistan,
1970-2014. Pakistan Journal of Commerce and Social Sciences (PJCSS), 9(1), 35-51.
 Nelson, M. J. (2008). Religious education in non-religious schools: a comparative study
of Pakistan and Bangladesh. Commonwealth & Comparative Politics, 46(3), 271-295.
 Candland, C. (2005). Religious education and violence in Pakistan. Pakistan, 19.
 Amir, S., Sharf, N., & Khan, R. A. (2020). Pakistan’s education system: An analysis of
education policies and drawbacks. Electronic Research Journal of Social Sciences and
Humanities, 2.
 Ahmad, I. (2007). Islamic and liberal visions of citizenship education: Religion and state
in the national curriculum of Pakistan. Religion and Education, 34(2), 95-112.

1356