BCMHNEW - CC 6.1Ch - 612-1111-0052-17
BCMHNEW - CC 6.1Ch - 612-1111-0052-17
PROJECT TOPIC:-
SUPERVISOR’S CERTIFICATE
Place:- KONNAGAR
Date:- 01/10/2020
MARKETING STRATEGY OF CAB SERVICES – A COMPARATIVE STUDY ON OLA AND UBER
STUDENT’S DECLARATION
I hereby declare that the Project Work with the Title MARKETING STRATEGY OF
CAB SERVICES - A COMPARATIVE STUDY ON OLA AND UBER submitted by
me for the partial fulfillment of the degree of B.COM (HONOURS) IN
ACCOUNTING AND FINANCE under the UNIVERSITY OF CALCUTTA is
my original work and has not been submitted earlier to any other
University for the fulfillment of the requirement for any course of study.
MR.SOUMEN GHOSH
CHOWMATHA HOOGHLY
Date :- 01/10/2020
MARKETING STRATEGY OF CAB SERVICES – A COMPARATIVE STUDY ON OLA AND UBER
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I owe a great thanks to many people who has helped and supported me during
the writing of project. My deepest thanks to my supervisor PROF. AMAR NATH
DAS the guide of my project for assisting me and correcting various documents
of mine with attention and care. She has taken pain to go through the project
and make necessary corrections as and when needed.
I would also thank respective teachers with whom this project would have been
distant reality. I also extend my heartfelt thanks to my family, friends and my
well-wishers.
MR.SOUMEN GHOSH
REGISTRATION NO :- 612-1111-0052-17
ROLL NO:-171612-21-0065
MARKETING STRATEGY OF CAB SERVICES – A COMPARATIVE STUDY ON OLA AND UBER
CONTENT
1. INTRODUCTION 7-13
2.1CONCEPTUAL FREAMWORK
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
MARKETING STRATEGY OF CAB SERVICES – A COMPARATIVE STUDY ON OLA AND UBER
In the past decade the transportation facilities in urban areas have undergone tremendous
changes. Among various modes of transportation the cabs have become important mode of
transportation in metropolitan and urban cities in India. The growth of organized car rental
industry is continuously growing with support of technology. The customers in the present era
are using mobile apps to book a cab at anytime and from any place in urban areas. The pricing
strategy of cab operators had been positively influencing customers to book a cab instead of
traditional mode of transportation like autos and local buses etc. Like most of the industries the
car rental industry had underwent lot of transformation with internet technology. The
consumers are able to access book cabs at competitive prices because of tough competition
among the organized cab operators. In this regard the present paper briefs about the behavior
of consumers while booking cabs.
One of the major points of study of marketing strategy is customer satisfaction. In these
modern times, business firms are exposed to various macro environment forces which include
fierce competition, globalization, rapid changes in customer preference and taste, changes in
technology and swift innovation. To cope with these challenges firms should pursue to
establish and maintain loyal customer base through customer satisfaction. To achieve this,
firms need to understand customer’s specific requirement, improve on existing service feature,
and adopt new or unique ways of servicedelivery. Service quality can be defined as the degree
to which customers' perceptions of service either meets and/or exceeds their anticipation. On
other hand, customer satisfaction refers to the customer’s attitude and emotional response
towards the service provider that results from the difference between customer’s perception
and actual outcome.
MARKETING STRATEGY OF CAB SERVICES – A COMPARATIVE STUDY ON OLA AND UBER
Hanif and Sagar (2016) had stated that there was demand for Call-a-Cab
service offered by Meru Cab. The cab services are proving security through global
positioning system (GPS) and women taxi drivers for women passengers
especially during night times. According to Harding et al (2016) the auto-
rickshaws (three wheelers) are more popular in urban transport before
the advent of cars and cabs. Horsu and Yeboah (2015) had argued that
driver behavior have negative impact on customer satisfaction in Ghana. The
variables like continuous service, comfort, reliability and affordability have an
impact on customer satisfaction with regard to minicab taxi. According to Lu et al
(2015) the self- service mobile technologies helps the commuters to access lot of
data about cab services and such technologies had changed the role of both
customers and companies. The adoption of call taxi app (CTA) is impacted
perceived usefulness, perceived ease of use, subjective norms and perceived
playfulness (Peng, Wang, He, Guo, & Lin, 2014). Chen (2014) had explained that
mobile apps help both drivers and passengers to find each other. At
present the mobile apps are helps the customers to find cabs. In the
recent years the car rental industry is growing constantly especially in
metropolitan cities in India (Rahman, 2014). According to Khurana S. (2014) in
today’s intense competitive business world, the customer is educated and smart
and commands satisfaction in all services. Banking is one of the numerous
services in which customer satisfaction has an ever growing importance in the
analogous research areas. This is basically because the banking sector is
becoming more and more aggressive in its marketing approach. Retail banks are
pursuing this approach, in part, because of the complexity in
differentiating based on the service offering. The Meru cabs had become
more popular and the demand for its cabs had exceeded that its supply which
means technology had created huge demand for organized cab
industry. The factors like accessibility, reliability and transparency are
MARKETING STRATEGY OF CAB SERVICES – A COMPARATIVE STUDY ON OLA AND UBER
Time shortage was a major factor as developing a project in the span time of
two or maximum three months . If we would have got more time to research,
the project could have been more elaborate and apt.
Due to the lockdown I could not continue my observation got stuck in the
middle ,it wasted a lot of my time to complete my project.
Cost was a huge factor. It is a project in which detailed information is required
and to enable that and to prepare it, huge cost is needed. So, it is an expensive
project and thus unaffordable. Adequate data was not available or developed
as the respondents were not cooperative enough to share sufficient
information which was needed for the project. Moreover ,due to lockdown
,traffic problems,high fares,low number of vehicles,I am unable to complete
my project better due to all the precautions,I could have done better without
this problem.
The consumer behavior was dynamic in nature and it was tough to make
robust conclusions from the study.
The Sample size of the questionnaire was restricted to 27respondents of
Hooghly and howrah.
MARKETING STRATEGY OF CAB SERVICES – A COMPARATIVE STUDY ON OLA AND UBER
CHAPTER – 2
CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK
And
1)National Scenario :-
Mega Cabs and Fast Track Taxi started out in 2001 itself with small fleets. The
market, however, started seeing traction only from 2006 onwards when the likes
of Meru Cabs, Easy Cabs and Savaari came up. There are now several competitors
eyeing for a piece of the pie.
Phase 1 – Fully Owned Fleets:- In the initial phase of the market companies
owned the complete fleet with the drivers as salaried employees. This
was characterized by high capital costs to the company – car loan EMI’s,
high maintenance costs. While this model facilitated rapid expansion, it also
came at a huge cost. Caused high stress levels in drivers and there were driver
strikes that affected the service. Bookings were mainly done via telephone calls
and cash was the dominant model.
Phase 2 – Fleet Aggregation Model:- Companies like TaxiForSure and Ola started
this model where small fleet owners or single car owners can put the company
brand on the car, and get registered with them. Cars are free to take up non-
company rides, but for every company-initiated ride, they pay the company a
fixed percentage as commission. This model had low capital expenditure and
lower maintenance costs. Booking was done via telephone calls as well as
through their websites. While cash was still the dominant payment form, in-cab
POS terminal for credit / debit cards started being used as well in this phase.
Phase 3 – The Hybrid Model (Current Phase):- In this model part of the fleet is
owned by the company and part of the fleet is from an aggregation model, hence
providing the best of both worlds – better control on cab availability
and service quality while keeping costs low. Booking are done via telephone,
website as well as mobile apps and the payments via cash ,cards ,wallets.
MARKETING STRATEGY OF CAB SERVICES – A COMPARATIVE STUDY ON OLA AND UBER
The Road Ahead:- The radio taxi space in India has a huge headroom for growth
and is far from saturation. While there is a good scope for expansion in tier 2
cities, the metro’s will still be the primary market for all the players. Hence we
might see price wars and more fleet variations (like Ola Auto, Ola
Nano and Uber) being introduced. More and more hatchbacks and low
cost options will be introduced to cater to the price conscious Indian
market and to compete against other forms of public transportation. Service
assurance & amp; quality and convenience will emerge as the long-term
differentiators. Ride-sharing might come up in the next 3 years and has the
potential to bring down costs even further for the consumer as well as reduce
costs even further for the taxi players. There are quite a few small
ride sharing startups already like LetsRide, Ridingo, Zify, PoolCircle and Rocket
Internet’s Tripda to name a few.
1)International Scenario :-
Taxis may be flagged down at any time of the day along any public road outside
of the Singapore Central Business District (CBD). Issues of high traffic and
demand in certain locations and areas, particularly in the downtown area and
other major buildings and establishments around the island, require the building
of taxi stands. As taxis may conversely be harder to obtain in less densely
populated areas, as well as to meet the needs of time-sensitive users, taxis may
be booked via telephone or through the internet for a fee, which is then
transmitted to individual taxis via a Global Positioning System (GPS) or digital
voice dispatch.
MARKETING STRATEGY OF CAB SERVICES – A COMPARATIVE STUDY ON OLA AND UBER
Stringent requirements ensure that all taxis are fitted with meters and are air-
conditioned and serviceable. Drivers who fail to utilise their meters may
be fined up to S$500, an enforced rule which brings far disputes down
to a minimum. About 90% of taxis have in built AM broadcasting communications.
Taxis are predominantly operated by large companies, which require a Taxi
Operator Licence (TOL) from the Land Transport Authority (LTA). Holders of
the TOL are required to comply with LTA's Quality of Service
(QOS)standers,codes of practice and audit directions,failure of which the LTA may
revoke the licence.
ComfortDelGro, SMRT Taxis, TransCab, Silvercab and Prime Taxis allow flagdown
and bookings. Grab and Uber only allows bookings through the
smartphone. As of September 2017, there are five taxi companies in
Singapore and two private hire car companies in Singapore
Australia:-
Taxi services are particularly valuable to less mobile groups in the community,
such as elderly and disabled people. As a result, government intervention
has historically ensured that taxi services have assisted in ensuring
equity, reliability, quality, and safety. At the same time, regulation has created
barriers to entry and limited competition in the sector. In April 1995,
the Commonwealth and all State and Territory governments entered into
the Competition Principles Agreement the required all jurisdictions to
review legislation which restricts competition by the year 2000. As a
result of pressures from competition law, the Competition and
Consumer Act 2010 (and preceding legislation), and evolving
technology, the regulated industry is facing challenges from deregulated
suppliers, such as Uber and ride-sharing services. Cabcharge Australia owns and
operates the Cabcharge payment system, which claims to cover about 97% of
taxis in Australia, and it operates one of Australia's largest taxi networks.
MARKETING STRATEGY OF CAB SERVICES – A COMPARATIVE STUDY ON OLA AND UBER
CHAPTER-3
PRESENTATION OF DATA
DATA ANALYSIS
AND
FINDING
MARKETING STRATEGY OF CAB SERVICES – A COMPARATIVE STUDY ON OLA AND UBER
Uber and OLA entered the taxi services as aggregators to provide app-
based taxi services to passengers in major metropolitan cities in India.
Both Ola and UBER offered passenger’s air-conditioned taxi services a
comparatively cheaper fares.
This changing scenario in taxi services brought to the fore the issue of
much-needed competition in the field of taxi services. UBER /Ola
app-based taxi services with use of modern technology and
smart phones triggered the competition and offered the consumers
an attractive option to choose. Although UBER /Ola taxi fares were
largely found to be attractive and affordable to the passengers, there
MARKETING STRATEGY OF CAB SERVICES – A COMPARATIVE STUDY ON OLA AND UBER
was also some irritant which the passengers did not like and that was
the Surge Pricing by Uber and Ola. The algorithmic pricing by UBER
and Ola at peak hours showed huge spurt in the fares which
the passengers often found unpalatable. In fact, the very algorithmic
fare structure lacked transparency and became the point of debate.
Thus, on one hand Uber/Ola fares were found to be quite attractive, so
much so as to appear like Predatory pricing aimed at killing the
competition and also the competitors and on the other hand the Surge
Pricing, resorted to by UBER / Ola at peak hours when the demand out-
weighed the supply, attracted the charge of undue profiteering.
MARKETING STRATEGY OF CAB SERVICES – A COMPARATIVE STUDY ON OLA AND UBER
( ) LESS THAN 18
( ) 18-30
( ) 30-45
( ) ABOVE 45
14% 10%
12%
64%
INTERPRETATION:-
The above pic chart shows the analysis of different age group of people:-
2)GENDER?
( )MALE
( )FEMALE
( )OTHERS
6%
48%
46%
INTERPRETATION:-
The above pic chart shows the analysis of different gender group of people:-
( ) YES
( ) NO
YES 25 93%
NO 2 7%
0%
7%
93%
INTERPETATION:-
The above pie chart shows the analysis of whether the people ride OLA or UBER
or NOT:-
()EVERY DAY
()EVERY WEEK
()EVERY MONTH
()ONCE A YEAR
28%
44%
INTERPRETATION:-
( ) OLA
( ) UBER
( ) OTHER
OLA 10 37%
UBER 14 52%
OTHERS 3 11%
11%
37%
52%
Interpretation:-
OLA 14 52%
UBER 13 48%
48%
52%
Interpretation:-
The above pie chart shows the analysis of the mobile app easier to you:-
( )PROFESSIONAL USE
( )PERSONAL USE
( )BOTH
Table showing what are the purpose we use cabs maximum for
BOTH 9 33%
11%
33%
56%
INTERPRETATION:-
11% of the respondents use cabs for professional purpose.
56% of the respondentsuse cabs for personal purpose.
33% of the respondents use cabs for both purposes.
MARKETING STRATEGY OF CAB SERVICES – A COMPARATIVE STUDY ON OLA AND UBER
8)AIRPORT AUTHORITIES OF INDIA HAS TIED UP WITH OLA AND UBER FOR CAB
BOOKING FROM AIRPORT KIOSKS IN 5 CITIES.DO YOU THINK MANKIND IS HAPPY
WITH THESE FACILITIES?
( )AGREE
( )DISAGREE
( )NEUTRAL
Table showing whether the respondents are happy with the airport tie up with
OLA and UBER or not
AGREE 15 55%
DISAGREE 5 19%
NEUTRAL 7 26%
30%
52%
18%
INTERPRETATION :-
OLA 12 44%
UBER 15 56%
44%
56%
INTERPRETATION:-
10)ARE YOU HAPPY WITH THE CURRENT SAFETY FEATUJRES OFFERED BY OLA AND
UBER?
( )YES
( )NO
Table showing whether the respondents are happy with the current safety
features offered by ola and uber
YES 24 89%
NO 3 11%
89%
INTERPRETATION:-
89% of the respondents are happy with currently safety features by OLA and
UBER.
MARKETING STRATEGY OF CAB SERVICES – A COMPARATIVE STUDY ON OLA AND UBER
11%of the respondents are not happy with currently safety features offered
by OLA and UBER.
( )YES
( )NO
( )MAYBE
Table showing whether the respondents think traditional taxi service should be
stopped immediately
YES 4 15%
NO 17 63%
MAYBE 6 22%
22% 15%
63%
INTERPRETATION:-
63% of the respondents think traditional taxi service should not stopped
immediately.
22% of the respondents may be traditional taxi services should stopped
immediately
( )YES
( )NO
Table showing whether the respondents think the government should stop
intervening in the current system of cab services
YES 15 56%
NO 12 44%
44%
56%
INTERPRETATION:-
MARKETING STRATEGY OF CAB SERVICES – A COMPARATIVE STUDY ON OLA AND UBER
( ) OLA
( )UBER
Table showing which cab according to the respondents has the highest seasonal
price fluctuation rate
OLA 13 48%
UBER 14 52%
48%
52%
INTERPETATION:-
MARKETING STRATEGY OF CAB SERVICES – A COMPARATIVE STUDY ON OLA AND UBER
48% of the respondents think OLA has the highest seasonal price fluctuation
rates.
52% of the respondents think UBER has the higiest seasonal price fluctuation
rates.
14)WHAT KIND OF IMPROVEMENTS WOULD YOU WANT TO SEE IN OLA AND UBER
SERVICES?
( ) OTHERS
Table showing the kind of improvements the respondents want to see in OLA and
UBER services
OTHERS 3 11%
MARKETING STRATEGY OF CAB SERVICES – A COMPARATIVE STUDY ON OLA AND UBER
11%
30%
22%
37%
INTERPRETATION:-
3.3 FINDINGS:-
1)93% of the respondents ride OLA or UBER while 7% of the respondents do not
ride OLA or UBER.
2) 12% of the respondents ride OLA or UBER every day, 28% of the respondents
ride OLA or UBER every week, 44% of the respondents ride OLA or UBER every
month, 16% of the respondents ride OLA or UBER once a year.
3) 37% of the respondents think OLA is more price affordable, 52% of the
respondents think UBER is more price affordable, 11% of the respondents think
cabs other than OLA or UBER is more price affordable.
4) 52% of the respondents feel that the OLA mobile app is easy to use while 48%
of the respondents feel that the UBER mobile app is easier to use.
5) 11% of the respondents use cabs maximum for professional use, 56% of the
respondents use cabs maximum for personal use, 33% of the respondents use
cabs maximum for both the purposes.
6) 52% of the respondents are happy with the airport tie up facilities with OLA and
UBER, 18% of the respondents are unhappy with the airport ties up facilities with
OLA and UBER, 30% of the respondents are neutral about the decision of airport
ties up with OLA and UBER.
7) 44% of the respondents say OLA gives more airport facilities while 56% of the
respondents say UBER gives more airport facilities.
8) 89% of the respondents are happy with the current safety features offered by
OLA or UBER while 11% of the respondents are not happy with the current safety
features offered by OLA or UBER.
10) 56% of the respondents think the government should intervene in the current
system of cab services while 44% of the respondents think the government
should not intervene in the current system of cab services.
11) 48% of the respondents say OLA has the highest seasonal price fluctuation
rates while 52% of the respondents say UBER has the highest seasonal price
fluctuation rates.
12) 30% of the respondents want more discount facilities in OLA and UBER
services, 37% of the respondents want more safety features for women in OLA
and UBER services, 22% of the respondents want airbag facilities in cars in OLA
and UBER services, 11% of the respondents want other improvements in OLA and
UBER services.
MARKETING STRATEGY OF CAB SERVICES – A COMPARATIVE STUDY ON OLA AND UBER
CHAPTER -4
CONCLUSION
RECOMMENDATION
AND
BIBLIOGRAPHY
MARKETING STRATEGY OF CAB SERVICES – A COMPARATIVE STUDY ON OLA AND UBER
4.1 CONCLUSION :-
Summing up our project, we come to the conclusion that cab
services have made life easier for daily commuters.
There was a time when people used to rush from one place to another or stand
in queues to hire a taxi. Man’s innovation in the field of science and
technology,now allows public to book cabs online over an android phone. All
that one has got to do now is to create an account using their phone number in
the online cab service apps like OLA, UBER, etc and pinpoint their current location
and state their destination and nearest cab driver will connect the respective
customer and appear at the given location in no time.
People nowadays prefer online cabs over taxi’s because they get A.C. facilities,
foot and assured services, etc at the same fare and sometimes at even lower
fares.
Not only this much, these services are aiming at making life all the more
comfortable by providing options of mutual sharing, choice of cars (according
to the number of seaters).
Hence, the frequency of people using these services, the number of cars
provided by these services are only increasing in number, with every passing
day.
MARKETING STRATEGY OF CAB SERVICES – A COMPARATIVE STUDY ON OLA AND UBER
RECOMMENDATIONS :-
1) The cab companies should take some necessary steps for the safety of women
in cabs, basically during night time.
2) The cab companies should train drivers with some common languages which
are used by the people of the surrounding area for their communication.
3) High seasonal price fluctuation creates many problems for middle class people
and lower level people. So they should take some necessary steps to reduce such
fluctuation of prices.
4) Many cab drivers drive roughly which can be dangerous for the passengers as
well as for the pedestrians. So they should advice the drivers to avoid rush driving
for the safety of customers.
5) Few cab drivers behave rudely with the passengers. So, the company should
train drivers to behave properly with their customers.
6) A big disadvantage seen in radio cab services is very less availability of 6+1
seater cars, so if a group wants to go anywhere jointly then they can’t do that.
7) Many people don’t know how to use internet or apps for booking cabs. The
company should do something about it.
8) For taking payment of their services from customers they should start
accepting payment through Debit or Credit Cards.
9) In many small towns there are no OLA and UBER services, so they should make
proper arrangements to connect with these small towns.
10) Cab drivers are not punctual about time which may hamper customer
services. The companies should take some necessary steps to make drivers
punctual about time.
11) Many people want to travel long distances by taking multiple stoppages. This
facility is not available in cab services. Thus, this facility should be started.
MARKETING STRATEGY OF CAB SERVICES – A COMPARATIVE STUDY ON OLA AND UBER
BIBLIOGRAPHY
WEBSITES :-
https://www.olacabs.com
https://www.uber.com/en-IN
www.business-standard.com
www.businesstoday.in/current/economy-politics
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ola
Dr. Ruchi Shukla , Dr. Ashish Chandra & Ms. Himanshi Jain
NEWSPAPER :-
TIMES OF INDIA
BUSINESS STANDARD