410 Biosensor Review
410 Biosensor Review
https://doi.org/10.1007/s12633-020-00937-w
REVIEW PAPER
Abstract
In this paper, we focus on recent advances of the high-electron-mobility transistor (HEMT)-based biosensors for the detection of
various biomolecules. The vital utilization of biosensors in various domains leads to standard, accurate and powerful biosensors
as it possesses a huge potential to attain information in a faster and simple manner in comparison to conventional assays.
Amongst various biosensors, high electron mobility transistors (HEMTs) proved more potential and immense advantages due
to their inherent material properties such as higher electron mobility, two-dimensional electron gas (2DEG), chemically inert,
stable at high temperature and high speed. This review paper features the basic related concepts of HEMT based biosensors in
terms of structure-oriented, different methodologies, the significance of various biomarker and biomolecules. This review also
describes the crucial factors which influence the various performance matrices of a biosensor such as sensitivity, selectivity,
specificity, reliability, repeatability, and stability. A comparison of different HEMT based biosensors with Si-based biosensor is
also analyzed. This review will help researchers to get all the information regarding HEMT based biosensors at one place to work
further for developing next-generation biosensors.
Keywords Biosensor . High electron mobility transistors . Sensitivity . Selectivity . Reliability . Stability
than two hours, which is not practically applicable for in the sample preparation for the detection of target biomolecules in
office or bedside detection, Electrochemical devices gained at- the device.
traction because of low cost and simplicity but still, there is a Optical biosensors collaborate optical fields with target
need of significant improvements in their sensitivities for use analytes for biomolecule detection such as tumor biomarkers,
with clinical samples. Microcantilevers capable of detecting cells, and toxins.
low concentrations, still suffer from an unwanted resonant fre- The mass-based sensors imply the response to the effect of
quency change due to the medium viscosity and cantilever variation in mass. These sensors take a significant role in
damping in the environmental solution [5, 6]. MEMS devices, especially in piezoelectric-based sensors.
The piezoelectric and acoustic wave sensor comes under the
subclasses category of these sensors that find a competitive
application for the detection of glucose, DNA, and living
2 Types of Biosensors organism.
Basically, for the development of an accurate and reliable
Generally, biosensors are categorized depending upon their biosensor, four main parameters should be taken into accounts
detection mechanism (which includes usage of biological el- such as sensitivity, specificity, stability, and ease of fabrica-
ements such as antibodies, enzymes, biological tissues, drugs, tion. Among various kinds of biosensor electrochemical and
proteins, microorganisms, etc.) and transduction method optical biosensors has attained more attention due to their high
(which performs the conversion of a biological signal into specificity and lower detection limit. The design process of
required measurable signal) [8]. Depending upon the trans- mass-based and calorimetric biosensors offers highly compli-
duction method there occurs 4 classes and subclasses as men- cated and lower response time [7]. In the electrochemical bio-
tioned in (Fig. 1). sensors potentiometric type transducer has become more pop-
Various types of biosensors mentioned in (Fig. 1) provide ular after the introduction of FET type biosensor because of
the technique for a wide detection of biomolecules in the de- their higher performance and less cost of fabrication.
vice. The working principle of an electrochemical biosensor
that it experiences the transformation in the electrical proper-
ties of the sensor caused by the chemical reaction. The trans-
formation is used as a measuring parameter is classified into 3 3 FET Based Biosensors
types such as conductometric, potentiometric, and ampero-
metric. These biosensors are widely used for the detection of Among various types of biosensors Field-effect transistors
DNA, glucose, and haemoglobin, etc. (FET) are appropriate candidates for biosensing applications
An optical biosensor is a strong alternate for the conven- because of their high signal-to-noise ratio, ease of integration,
tional analytical type of biosensor as it needs less amount of and low cost. Field-effect transistor-based sensors have
become one of the major technologies for the detection of structures of different III-V devices for detection of various dis-
ions, DNA, proteins, and in the sensing regime application eases from a higher to lower detection target range and its im-
ranging from environmental monitoring (in macro-scale) to provement in the field of sensitivity, selectivity, stability, spec-
study of biomolecular interactions (in nanoscale). Si-based ificity, reliability, repeatability. There is a lot of work done for
Field Effect transistors biosensors possess high sensitivity be- the early diagnosis of disease to reduce the mortality rate.
cause of the analyte binding site of the receptor close to the Section-6 presents a descriptive analysis of various biomarkers
surface, smaller size, simpler transduction mechanism, com- in comparison with silicon, different biomolecules, and bio-
patibility with Complementary Metal Oxide Semiconductor marker used for different diseases attained a better detection
(CMOS) process technology, lesser cost, reproducibility, and limit. Section 7 deals with the comparative performance of sil-
controllable electrical response have gained the huge focus of icon over GaN material and Section-8 Deals with the study of
research attention. Conventional Si-based field-effect transis- various sensing performance metrics for sensitivity, selectivity,
tor sensor suffers from degradation or shift in electrical re- reliability, specificity, stability, repeatability performance en-
sponse due to the hydrolysis of the oxide layer in aqueous hancement. Finally, the conclusion has been drawn in Section 9.
solutions, being easily attacked and distorted by chemical
and biological agents and intermediate oxide or gate metalli-
zation layers is the increase in the distance which causes 4 Working Mechanism of HEMT Based Sensor
charge analytes binds to the charge carrier channel resulting
in lower sensitivity [9–11]. The working principle operates on the mechanism of biomark-
Group III nitride-based devices eradicate drawback of Si- er and involvement of biomolecules introduced in the device.
based systems in terms of higher thermal and chemical stability These biomarkers (antibody, aptamer, enzymes, molecules,
in aqueous solution, chemically inert, high resistivity to high genes) can bind or link large no of samples. Once it gets into
electron salt environment, high bandgap, sensitivity, low pos- contact with an increase in the concentration of biomolecules
sibility of corrosion, low power consumption, and faster re- there is a huge variation in the electrical characteristic of the
sponses. Due to the formation of two-dimensional electron device in terms of the electron concentration, drain current and
gas(2DEG) at the hetero-interface of AlGaN /GaN high elec- threshold voltage, etc. Finally, these sensors detect how fast a
tron mobility transistor(HEMT) results in promising bio/ device works i.e. sensing speed, selectivity, sensitivity, and
chemical sensing application. These devices possess unique stability.
properties that are ideally suited because of their high electron
sheet concentration induced by spontaneous and piezoelectric
polarization leads to a higher density and mobility of the two- 5 Review on Various HEMT Device Structures
dimensional gas in the interface of the heterostructure since it’s for Detection of Various Diseases
induced between the strained AlGaN and the GaN layer. For and Biomolecules
most of the high electron mobility transistor(HEMT) structures
sensor’s potential on the surface changes the piezoelectric- 5.1 Prostate Cancer
induced carrier density in the channel, which in turn causes a
change in the drain or gate current. Advantages of high electron A fully fabricated high electron mobility transistor biosensor with
mobility transistor(HEMT) based sensors offers higher mobil- Al2O3 as gate dielectric offers a reduction in cost, time, process
ity and formation of two-dimensional electron gas(2DEG) in- overhead, and offered device sensitivity around 0.91 mA/
duce a higher sensitivity and also reduces the possibility of ngmL−1 [14]. AlGaInN based sensors and indium oxide nano-
damage from static electricity [12]. Nanomaterials devices are wires used for prostate-specific antigen detected a range from
strong candidates offering an excellent option towards fast, 1 μg/mL to 10 pg/mL [15]. In gateless transistors by a coating
label-free, sensitive, selective and multiple detections for both of the thin scandium oxide layer over the gate sensing area, has
in the field of clinical and preclinical applications. Integration determined more sensitiveness and reproducible pH sensing. The
of nanomaterials with AlGaN/GaN high electron mobility characteristics of these sensors bear faster responses (in liquid
transistors(HEMT) have gained advantages in increasing sen- phase 5–10 s and gas-phase around milliseconds), digitalized
sitivity detection [13]. output signals, smaller device size (which is less than
This review deals with the various diseases related devices 100*100μm2), chemical and thermal stability. These sensors pro-
focusing on their enhancement results of sensitivity, selectivity, vide a clear vision to use reliable semiconductors sensors for the
specificity, reliability, stability using a variety of sensing metrics, development of handheld exhaled breath, saliva, urine, or blood
structures, methods, models, and material. Section 2 deals with monitors with wireless capability to analyze frequently screening
types of biosensors. Section 3 deals with FET-based biosensors. that can diagnose the early development of diseases, which in
Section 4 deals with the working mechanism of HEMT based turn helps in reducing the suffering of patients from late diagno-
sensor. Section-5 deals with comparative analysis of various sis, lowers the medical cost and detected over a wide range of
Silicon
concentrations from 1 μg/mL to 10 pg/mL [16]. GaN high elec- of detection and linear range detection for various AlGaN
tron mobility transistor biosensors implemented using label-free based HEMT for various methods.
electrical detection with millimeter grade biomolecule gated pro-
vided superior advantages with a fewer number of steps in the
fabrication process, potentially gained a lower detection limit 5.2 Cardiovascular Disease
because of the chosen target biomarker closer to the two-
dimensional gas, and achieved a sensitivity of 0.027% for AlGaN /GaN high electron mobility transistor biosensor for
0.1 pg/ml to 10.269 ng/mL prostate-specific antigen solution the detection of C-reactive protein using a null balancing cir-
[17]. A biomolecule gated AlGaN/GaN high electron mobility cuit not only measures the change of the gate potential, sensor
transistor using UV/ozone for oxidizing GaN surface and there- output signal without the use of bulky semiconductor param-
after a 3-aminopropyl trimethoxysilane (APTES) self-assembled eter analyzer but also offers a suitable device configuration for
monolayer was bound to its sensing region that can detect the signal processing which detected over a wide range of con-
current in logarithmic scale in relation against prostate-specific centrations from 10 ng/mL to 1000 ng/mL [22]. A Platinum
antigen detection concentration range from 0.1 pg/mL (which gate high electron mobility transistor used in the differential
enhanced sensitivity around 2.15%) to 0.993 ng/mL. This pro- mode circuit reduces 97% of noise signal based biosensor
cess is useful in the field of prostate cancer screening [18]. improves the detection limit in low C-Reactive Protein con-
Ethanolamine modification strategy in molecular gold gated centration from 0.01 ng/mL to 1000 ng/mL [23]. Electric
AlGaN/GaN high electron mobility transistor results instability, Double Gating mechanism using covalently linked antibody
low sensitivity, realized detection of ions, proteins and DNA, immobilization strategy and thiol modified aptamer offered
verified their feasibilities in pH and antigen. To overcome the better charge screening effect and shows high sensitivity,
demerits (i.e. low sensitivity) of the molecular gated device, the specificity which is around 0.006-148 ng/mL. This process
sensor is modified with ethanolamine with InP nanowires which proves rapid, inexpensive, Cardio Vascular disease biomarker
improved both pH and antigen detection. The microscale pH array for point-of-care diagnostics [24].
sensor detected a limit for prostate-specific antigen as 1fgmL−1
in phosphate buffer saline(PBS) buffer and a sensitivity of 2.04%
for 100 ng mL−1 [19]. Disposable gate AlGaN/GaN high elec- 5.3 pH Sensor
tron mobility transistor sensor prevents contamination in the bio-
chemical environment upon implementation of a separate high An extended gate version of AlGaN/GaN high electron mo-
electron mobility transistor containing the sensitive membrane bility transistor pH sensor implemented using a metal-
which helps in Trace-level biological detection and achieved insulator-semiconductor structure(MIS) improves the unsta-
limit to 100 fg/mL for the prostate-specific antigen detection. ble gate leakage, an increase in sensitivity up to 56.39mv/pH
The device also offered stability, linearity, and specificity [20]. and linearity of 98.93% and offered a high electrical signal
Figure 2 reveals that the molecular gate(Using EA for sur- which changed the efficiency of biomaterials, disposable and
face animation) has achieved a higher limit of detection i.e. point-of-care systems over the conventional based metal-
1 fg/mL−1as well as its higher modification efficiency leads to semiconductor high electron mobility transistor(HEMT) pH
more active sites for pH detection. Table 1 represents the limit sensor [25]. Peltier element cooling of ungated AlGaN/GaN
high electron mobility transistors with scandium oxide gate
dielectric functionalized with ZnO nanorods is an effective
method for condensing exhaled breathe offered pH range in
7–8 and achieved a detection limit to 0.5 nM. The integration
of HEMT sensors and a wireless detection system allows for
remote monitoring applications [26]. The use of ungated
AlGaN high electron mobility transistors with scandium oxide
in the gate region and Peltier element mounted on the backside
lowers the temperature to condense the exhaled breath sensors
exhibited a linear range in current between pH 3–10 of 37 μA/
pH [15, 16].
From Fig. 3 it’s clear that in the case of A the drain current
change for exhaled breathe condensate shows the pH values
range between 7.2–7.5 and a better limit of detection i.e.
0.5 nM which is the typical range of Human blood whereas
in the case of B its shows a wide range in pH variation be-
Fig. 2 Limit of detection for various AlGaN based HEMT [17–19, 21] tween 3 and 10.
Silicon
5.4 Glucose Detection a mismatched deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) was used as a control
showed that nonspecific binding was also absent [15, 16].
From Table 2 we conclude that glucose biosensor APTES Figure 4 depicts that AlGaN based sensor results in a de-
based HEMT delivers a suitable environment to sustain the crease of 115 μA for AlGaN sensor whereas a decrease of
GOX activity due to its higher sensitivity limit. 69 μA for AlInN sensor and 38 μA for AlGaN sensor proves
strong evidence that AlInN sensor acts as more sensitive for
DNA hybridization in comparison with AlGaN HEMT.
5.5 DNA Detection
5.6 Kidney Injury Molecule Detection
AlInN/GaN high electron mobility transistor (HEMT) possessing
a thin barrier thickness results in negligible stress and piezoelectric
Kidney injury molecule-I (KIM-I) used as a biomarker for the
effect potentially improving the stability and higher sensitivity i.e.
early detection of Acute Kidney Injury or renal failure in the
at VDS = 0.5 V it decreases the value to 69 μA and upon further
urinary antigen is generally carried out with an Enzyme-linked
introducing 1μmolL−1 complementary deoxyribonucleic
Immunosorbent assay (ELISA) technique. These biosensors
acid(DNA) at sensor area reduces to 38 μA which shows a greater
have achieved a target detection limit of 1 ng/mL over a gated
potential in the medical field detection [33]. The advantage of
area of 20*50 μm2 [15, 16].
using gold nanoparticles provides a well-established system for
the detection of analyte-receptor interaction used for the detection
of various biomolecules including DNA, proteins, and cell surface 5.7 Uricase Detection
receptors. The way to bind receptors nanostructures patterned at
the gate is to achieve a higher receptor density. In sensors with ZnO nanotetrapods (T-ZnO) used in High electron mobility
arrays of biochemical sensing transducers, incorporation of statis- transistor(HEMT) composes a special structure with four legs
tical analysis method on-chip could help in the reduction of false- which extend out of the surrounding surface in different directions
positive and negatives when the device-to-device variability exists had attained better electron transportation and immobilization
[34]. Both the structures showed a linear decrease of 115 μA and over other low IEP organic molecule to be made suitable for the
Table 2 Comparison of APTES AlGaN based HEMT glucose performance in the field of biomedical and clinical diagnosis ap-
biosensors with previously reported biosensors [27–32]
plications [36].
BIOSENSOR LINEAR SENSITIVITY Figure 5 revealed that in the case of curve A during the first
RANGE (μA mM−1 cm−2) 250 s there is no current change that offers better stability and
reliability and after the addition of 0.2 nM solution to the gate
Nafion/GOX/ZnO nanorods/ITO 0.05–1.00 mM 48.75
[27] 1.00–20.00 mM 3.87
area of HEMT, there is an immediate change in the current
Nf/PdNPs/rGO 3 μm-4.57 mM 234.1
signal with the increasing concentration of UA whereas in
APTES/GOX/GCE [28] case of curve B it shows a linear response and the device
PET/QCS-MOX-OD/GOx 1-111 mM 176 achieved a lower detection limit of 0.2 nm and a faster re-
electrode [29] sponse time of ~1 s was observed and the device offers good
CoWO4/CNT/CNT-AuNS [30] 0–0.3 mM 10.89
repeatability.
CQDs-AuNPs-GOX [31] 0.16–4.32 mM 626.06
APTES/GOX/AlGaN/GaNHEMT 0.1–10 μM 9.4*105
[32] 10 μM–100 μM 3.15*104
1-9 mM 1.95*105 5.8 Breast Cancer Detection
Si-doped GaAs cap layer over Si-doped AlGaAs layer The schematic view of the proposed device is shown in Fig. 7.
high electron mobility transistor (HEMT) biosensor not determines potential development problem of ungated HEMT
only enhances chemical stability of the gate but also im- structures as the sensors get contaminated in the biological en-
proves transport property of the carrier in cap layer could vironment as their structures modify with a different HEMT and
detect lactic acid concentration range from 0.03 nM to sensing structure [20].
300 nM, whereas comparative analysis has been per-
formed to the combination of ZnO nanowires-gated 5.11.3 Dielectric Modulated HEMT Based Sensor
AlGaAs/GaAs high electron mobility transistor (HEMT)
with an excellent enzymatic lactic acid biosensor delivers From Fig. 8 it observed that devices operate when current
the fast response, excellent sensitivity, long term stability flows between the source and drain electrodes when the gate
and wide detection range in the field of medical applica- to source voltage is greater than the threshold voltage that can
tions in measuring lactic acid levels(exhaled breathe con- be modulated by varying its dielectric material cavity. The
densate as a surrogate for blood-based lactate measure- nanogap cavity layer present on both sides of the oxide under
ments) [39]. the gate acts as a sensing site for immobilization of target
biomolecules [42].
Finally, this Section 5 deals with a discussion of various
5.11 Different Structures HEMT Based Biosensor types of diseases in terms of superior sensitivity, selectivity
performance due to the change in structure, biomolecules,
The main factors which influence the performance of devices biomarker, biosensor, and different structure- related perfor-
in terms of current, frequency, power performance, immobili- mance analysis in terms of frequency, power, current, and
zation of biomolecules, throughput has been described in threshold voltage.
these various devices [40, 41].
AlGaN/GaN high electron mobility transistor(HEMT) incor- Silicon-based sensors are still the abundant, dominant, and
porated using AlN interlayer in their epi layer design maxi- widely available material of the semiconductor segment be-
mizes device performance such as device on current over the cause of their less cost, reproducible and controllable electronic
conventional high electron mobility transistor, frequency, and response. The main drawback of these sensors is not suitable
power performance [11] (Fig. 6). for operation in a harsh environment, for instance, high
Table 3 Review on various biomolecules and biomarkers 8 Review on Various Performance Matrics
MARKER DETECTION LIMIT/ of HEMT Biosensor
DISEASE RANGE
8.1 Sensitivity
Serum marker-prostate-specific antigen 100 fg/ml [20]
Prostrate cancer
Biomarker-1)prostate-specific antigen, 1)1 μg/ml-10 pg/ml [16]
The main performance metrics which affect the sensitivity of
2)kidney injury molecule-1 2)1 ng/ml [16] the device are conductance, current gain, nanogap cavity, gate
1)prostate cancer length, threshold voltage shift for detection of biomolecules,
2)acute kidney injury or acute renal failure on current, transconductance, channel conductance, channel
Cardiac Maker Fibrinogen 0-5 g/L [9]
Coronary Artery Disease and Thrombosis
potential, thin barrier. The sensitivity of the device could be
Biomarker-RNA 1 fm [48] enhanced by optimizing parameters such as nanogap cavity,
Cardiovascular disease length, width, and gate length. A lot of authors proposed var-
Biomarker-c-reactive protein 0.01 ng/ml-1000 ng/ml ious methods or techniques which increases the sensitivity of
Acute phase infection [23]
the device are as follows:-.
Biomarker-prostate specific antigen 0.1 pg/ml [17]
Prostate cancer
Xiang et al. proposed an AlInN/GaN high electron mobility
Biomarker-prostate specific antigen 0.1 pg/ml −0.993 ng/ml transistors(HEMT) sensors possess thin barriers attained higher
Prostate cancer [18] sensitivity in comparison to traditional AlGaN/GaN high elec-
Serum marker-prostate specific antigen 1 fg/ml−1[19] tron mobility transistors [33]. Kia et al. has developed an
Prostate cancer Optimized Surface Functionalization method using AlGaN
Biomarker-c-reactive protein 10 ng/ml-1000 ng/ml
/GaN high electron mobility transistor (HEMT) which not only
Cardiovascular disease [22]
improved the sensitivity but also has achieved a concentration
Biomarker-Troponin1 concentration in serum 2.62 pg/ml [24]
Cardiotoxicity, Unstable angina, Cardiac level of 4.73pM [43] Ju-Young Pyo et al. fabricated metal-
muscle injury, and Renal failure Analysis insulator-semiconductor structures using tin dioxide as sensing
Bio marker-alpha fetoprotein 20 pg/ml [49] membrane material, high mobility ALD Al2O3 thin layer and
Colorectal,breast,lung cancer
high electron concentration that predicts possible outcomes
Biomarker- Monokine induced by 5-500 ng/ml [50]
interferon-gamma such as high output characteristic, the concentration of electro-
Transplant Rejection lyte accurately and stably [25]. Zhixin Wang et al. developed a
Biomarker-NT-pro BNP 80.54mv/decade novel TAS2R14-functionalized high electron mobility
Heart failure [51]
transistor(HEMT) sensor modified using membrane protein
Biomarker- Nucleic Acid, Protein 10fgmL−1-10ngmL−1[52]
without over-expressed TAS2R14 was used as negative control
Cancer
Biomarker-Organokine 1.53pgmL−1[53] which detected a sensitivity range from 0.1pM to 1 mM was
Diabetes applied to detect and fish out the potential TAS2R14 agonists
from P.grandiflorum extracts [57]. Hee Ho Lee et al. proposed
a Bio-high electron mobility transistor(HEMT)/Ref-high
8.2 Selectivity
Kia ding et al. reported that Alpha Fetoprotein using AlGaAs Fig. 10 Output voltage characteristics of HEMT based sensor for a
/GaAs high electron mobility transistor based on Bovin serum selectivity test with Troponin T
Silicon
8.3 Specificity
8.4 Reliability
8.5 Repeatability
Studies reported in [14, 25, 58] proposed some method which
Byung Hwan Chu et al. modeled Ungated AlGaN/GaN
confirms the reliability of the device (1)By the implementa-
high electron mobility transistor(HEMT) using scandium
tion of a mathematical model based AlGaN/GaN HEMT bio-
oxide as a gate dielectric are sensitive for exposure to ex-
sensor detected a drain current around μA/pH which in turn
haled breathe condensate and similarly, functionalization
confirms the reliability of the model, (2)Real-time response
method used with ZnO nanorods and glucose oxidase are
method of observing real-time signals which are being detect-
seen responsive to the glucose. These detection approaches
ed by different conditions such as electrolyte concentration
provide rapid response and good repeatability which
and (3)Gate to the source is less than the gate to the drain
gained potentiality for investigation of airway pathology
spacing designed to lower the effective source resistance and
[26].
maximizes the reliability of the device.
From Fig. 13 it is observed that good repeatability was
Figure 12 represents the dependence of drain current with
obtained as the author here combined well biocompatible T-
change on the pH value which predicted the sensitivity of the
ZnO and high sensitivity HEMTs to meet the needs of UA
biosensor 80μA/pH which was being confirmed by the exper-
detection in real samples [36].
imental data [58].
Fig. 11 Drain current versus time for aptamer-troponin I [24] Fig. 13 Current versus time for testing repeatability [36]
Silicon
8.6 Stability AlGaAs/ GaAs, AlInN/ AlN/, InGaAs, ZnO based high elec-
tron mobility transistor. The selection of these materials has
Studies reported in [9, 17, 25, 39] attained stability(1) No vari- attained potential in various fields due to its overspread prop-
ation in current change is observed with the addition of PBS at erties:-higher sensitivity, good selectivity, specificity, reliabil-
approx.. 150 s, which provides good stability(which exclude ity, stability, good repeatability, linearity, chemical and ther-
possible noise arising with the change of lactic acid solution) mal stability, high electron mobility, and small device size.
and specificity of the device, (2) Metal-insulator-semiconductor This significant biosensor technology offers various applica-
(MIS) structure consisting of Schottky junctions can be stabi- tions in the field of biomedical engineering such as detection
lized by lowering the gate leakage due to the high barrier height of pathogens and toxins, transplant rejection, troponin I, cell
of the insulator,(3)Diagnosis of fibrinogen in human plasma differentiation, early disease diagnosis and prognosis, drug
using aptamer functionalized has achieved better stability, which development, medicine, and study of cellular dynamics.
made it suitable for point of care or home care diagnostic for HEMT based biosensors show promising results for cardio-
easy assessment of cardiovascular disease risk,(4)GaN high vascular disease, protein, DNA, kidney injury, glucose in ex-
electron mobility transistor(HEMT) biosensor for prostate- haled breathe condensate, acute phase infections, pH values of
specific antigen(PSA) by using label-free electrical detection solutions, and antigen detection. This technology offers a re-
with millimeter grade biomolecule gated offers good stability duction in the cost, time, easy to integrate into portable sys-
and sensitivity around 0.027% for 0.1 pg/ml PSA solution. tems, and shows signs of future excellence as point-of-care
From Fig. 14 it is observed that after heating treatment, the diagnostics. A comprehensive review on performance com-
water contact angle of the sensing surface is 48°for both curve parison of HEMT based biosensor with Si FET based biosen-
A and B, and after immersion into 0.01*PBS, it raises to 49° sors is also presented. From this review it is concluded that Si
for curve A whereas it decreases to 37° for curve B and almost based FET is suitable for low power application whereas
does not vary with the increasing immersion time which HEMT based biosensor can be applicable in harsh environ-
shows that the APTES self –assembled monolayer has good ments. This review will help researchers to get all the infor-
stability in buffer solution over 24 h. mation regarding HEMT based biosensors at one place to
Section 8 deals with sensitivity, selectivity, stability, reli- work further for developing next-generation biosensors.
ability, and repeatability performance. There is good sensitiv-
ity and stability report obtained from prostate cancer, selectiv- Acknowledgments The authors acknowledge VIT-AP university for pro-
viding the necessary facilities for carrying out the research work.
ity performance for cardiovascular disease.
Authors’ Contributions Mrs. Hemaja has done the compressive review.
Dr. Deepak has done the necessary editing.
This review paper demonstrates different types of biosensors Compliance with Ethical Standards The manuscript is pre-
based on different heterostructures such as AlGaN/ GaN, pared as per the ethical standard of the journal.
References
1. Gudkov AG, Agaseiva SV, Tikhomirov VG, Zherdeva VV, Klinov
DV, Sasurin VD (2019) Perspective in the development of biosen-
sors based on AlGaN/GaNHEMT. Biomed Eng 53(3):196–200
2. Pullikkathodi AK, Sarangadharan I, Hsu CP, Chen Y-H, Hung LY,
Fig. 14 The water contact angle of the surfaces of APTES-coated GaN Lee G-Y, Chyi J-I, Lee GB, Wang YL (2018) Enumeration of
versus immersion time for testing stability [17, 18] circulating tumor cells and investigation of cellular responses using
Silicon
aptamer-immobilized AlGaN/GaN high electron mobility transistor J Micromech Microeng 24(7). https://doi.org/10.1088/0960-1317/
sensor array. Sensors Actuators B Chem 257:96–104 24/7/075023
3. Pal P, Pratap Y, Gupta M, Kabra S (2019) Modeling and 19. Gu Z, Wang J, Miao B, Zhao L, Liu X, Wu D, Li J (2019) Highly
Simulation of AlGaN/GaN MOS-HEMT for Biosensor sensitive AlGaN/GaN HEMT biosensors using an ethanolamine
Applications. IEEE Sensors J 19(2):587–593. https://doi.org/10. modification strategy for bioassay applications. RSC Adv 9(27):
1109/JSEN.2018.2878243 15341–15349. https://doi.org/10.1039/c9ra02055a
4. Wadhera T, Kakkar D, Wadhwa G, Raj B (2019) Recent Advances 20. Yang S, Le G, Ding XZ, Miao B, Gu Z, Yang L, Li J, Wu D (2018)
and Progress in Development of the Field Effect Transistor Disposable gate AlGaN/GaN High- Electron- Mobility sensor for
Biosensor: A Review. J Electron Mater 48(12):7635–7646. Trace- Level Biological Detection. IEEE Electron Device Lett
https://doi.org/10.1007/s11664-019-07705-6 39(10):1592–1595
5. Rahman E, Sadman A, Khosru QDM (2017) Effect of biomolecule 21. Kang BS, Wang HT, Lele TP, Tseng Y, Ren F, Pearton SJ, Johnson
position and fill in factor on the sensitivity of a Dielectric modulated JW, Rajagopal P, Roberts JC, Piner EL, Linthcum KJ (2007)
Double Gate Junctionless MOSFET biosensor. Sens Bio-Sens Res Prostate-specific antigen detection using AlGaN/GaN high electron
13:49–54 mobility transistors. Appl Phys Lett 91:112106
6. Wang Y-L, Huang C-C, Kang Y-W (2014) Incorporation of ligand- 22. Lee HH, Bae M, Jo S-H, Shin J-K, Son DH, Won C-H, Jeong H-M,
receptor binding site-models and transistor-based sensors for re- Hee-Lee J, Kang SW (2015) AlGaN/GaN High Electron Mobility
solving dissociation constants and number of binding sites. IET Transistor-Based Biosensor for the Detection of C-Reactive
Nanobiotechnol 8(1):10–17 Protein. Sensors 15:18416–18426
7. Villalba-rodr AM, Parra-saldivar R, Iqbal HMN (n.d.) 23. Lee HH, Bae M, Jo S-H, Shin JK, Son DH, Won CH, Lee JH
Electrochemical Biosensors: A Solution to Pollution Detection (2016) Differential-mode HEMT-based biosensor for real-time
with Reference to Environmental Contaminants. 1–21. https://doi. and label-free detection of C-reactive protein. Sensors Actuators
org/10.3390/bios8020029. B Chem 234:316–323
8. Mohanty, S. P., & Kougianos, E. (2007). Biosensors: A Tutorial 24. Sarangadharan I, Regmi A, Chen Y-W, Hsu C-P, Chen P-c, Chang
Review - North Texas University. i, 1–12. https://www.smohanty. W-H, Geng YL, Chyi J-I, Shiesh S-C, Lee G-B, Wang Y-L (2018)
org/Publications_Journals/2006/MohantyIEEEPotentials2006Mar- High sensitivity cardiac troponin I detection in the physiological
Apr.pdf. environment using AlGaN/GaN High Electron Mobility
9. Tai T-Y, Sinha A, Sarangadharan I, Pullikkathodi AK, Shin LW, Transistor(HEMT). Biosensors, Biosensors Bioelectron 100:282–
Shiesh S-C, Lee GB, Wang Y-L (2018) Aptamer functionalized 289
AlGaN/GaN High-electron-mobility Transistor for rapid 25. Pyo J-Y, Jeon J-H, Koh Y, Cho C-y, Park H-H, Park K-H, Lee SW,
Diagnosis of Fibrinogen in Human Plasma. Sens Mater 30(10): Cho W-J (2018) AlGaN/GaN high-electron-mobility-transistor pH
2321–2331 sensor with extended gate platform. AIP Adv 8:085106
10. Khan MA, Kumar P, Siddharth G, das M, Mukherjee S (2019) 26. Chu BH, Kang BS, Chang CY, Ren F, Goh A, Scuillo A, Wu W,
Analysis of Drain current in Polycrystalline MgZnO/ZnO and Lin J, Gilla BP, Pearton SJ, Johnson JW, Piner EL, Linthicum KJ
MgZnO/CdZnO HFET. IEEE Trans Electron Devices 66(12): (2010) Wireless Detection System for Glucose and pH Sensing in
5097–5102 Exhaled Breathe Condensate using AlGaN/GaN High Electron
11. Varghese A, Periasamy C, Bhargava L (2018) Analytical Modeling Mobility Transistor. IEEE Sensors J 10(1):64–70
and Simulation-based Investigation of AlGaN/AlN/GaN Bio- 27. Ridhuan NS, Razak KA, Lockman Z (2018) Fabrication and char-
HEMT Sensor for C-erbB-2 Detection. IEEE Sensors J 18(23): acterization of Glucose biosensors by using Hydrothermally Grown
9595–9603 ZnO Nanorods. Sci 8(13722):1–12
12. Podolska A, Seeber RM, Kocan M, Kocan M, Pfleger KDG, Parish 28. Guler M, Dilmac Y, Electroanal J (2019). Chem. 834:49–55
G, Nener BD (2010) Cell growth and attachment to AlGaN surfaces 29. Liang Z, Zhang J, Wu C, Hu X, Lu Y, Wang G, Yu F, Zhang X,
for biosensor applications. ICONN 2010 - Proceedings of the 2010 Wang Y. Biosens Bioelectron 155:112105
International Conference on Nanoscience and Nanotechnology, 30. Oh SY, Hong SY, Jeong YR, Yun J, Park H, Jin SW, Lee G, Oh JH,
264–267. https://doi.org/10.1109/ICONN.2010.6045220. Lee H, Lee SS, Ha JS (2018) Skin-attachable, stretchable, electro-
13. Syedmoradi L, Ahmadi A, Norton MN, Omidfar K (2019) A re- chemical sweat sensor for glucose and pH detection. ACS Appl
view on nanomaterial-based field-effect transistor technology for Mater Interfaces 10:13729–13740
biomarker detection, Michrochim Acta 31. Buk V, Pumble ME (2019) A highly sensitive glucose biosensor
14. Varghese A, Periasamy C, Bhargava L (2019) Fabrication and based on a micro disk array electrode design modified with carbon
Charge Deduction Based Sensitivity Analysis of GaN MOS- quantum dots and gold nanoparticles. Electrochim Acta 298:97–
HEMT Device for Glucose, MIG, C-erbB-2, KIM-1, and PSA 105
Detection. IEEE Trans Nanotechnol 18:747–755 32. Liu J, Zhang H, Xue D, Ahmed AU, Xia X, Liu Y, Huang H, Guo
15. Kang BS, Wang HT, Ren F, Pearton SJ (2008) Electrical detection W, Liang H (2020) An effective hydroxylation route for a highly
of biomaterials using AlGaN/GaN high electron mobility transis- sensitive glucose sensor using APTES/GOX functionalized AlGaN/
tors. J Appl Phys 104(3). https://doi.org/10.1063/1.2959429 GaN high electron mobility transistor. RSC Adv 10:11393
16. Chu BH, Kang BS, Wang HT, Chang CY, Lele T, Tseng Y, Goh A, 33. Zhan X-M, Hao M-L, Wang Q, Li W, Xiao H-L, Feng C, Jiang L-J,
Sciullo A, Wu WS, Lin JN, Gila BP, Pearton SJ, Johnson JW, Piner Wang C-M, Wang X-L, Wang Z-G (2017) Highly Sensitive
EL, Linthicum KJ, Ren F (2009) AlGaN/GaN HEMT, and ZnO Detection of Deoxyribonucleic Acid Hybridization Using Au-
Nanorod-Based sensor for chemical and bio-applications 7216, gated AlInN/GaN High Electron Mobility Transistor-Based
72162A1–10 Sensors. Chin Phys Lett 34(4):047301
17. Li JD, Chang J-J, Miao B, Wei X-W, Xie J, Zhang JC, Zhi QZ, Li 34. Makoswki MK, Kim S, Gaillard M, Janes D, Manfra MJ, Bryan I,
H-W, Wu D-M (2014) Label-free electrical detection of prostate Sitar Z, Arellano C, Xie J, Collazo R, Ivanisevic A (2013)
specific antigen with millimeter grade biomolecule-gated AlGaN/ Physisorption of functionalized gold nanoparticles on AlGaN/
GaN high electron mobility transistor, Springer GaN high electron mobility transistors for sensing applications.
18. Li JD, Cheng JJ, Miao B, Wei XW, Xie J, Zhang JC, Zhang ZQ, Appl Phys Lett 102(7):074102
Wu DM (2014) Detection of prostate-specific antigen with 35. Yu S, Lie Y, Yan X, Zhang Y, Liu Y (2012) Biosensors of ZnO
biomoleculegated AlGaN/GaN high electron mobility transistors. Nanotetrapods and HEMT for Detecting Uric Acid, IEEE 345–346
Silicon
36. Song Y, Zhang X, Yan X, Liao Q, Wang Z, Zhang Y (2014) An 49. Tai TY, Sinha A, Sarangadharan I, Pulikkathodi AK, Wang SL,
enzymatic biosensor based on three-dimensional ZnO Lee GY, Chyi JI, Shiesh SC, Lee GB, Wang YL (2019) Design and
nanotetrapods spatial net modified AlGaAs/GaAs high electron Demonstration of Tunable Amplified Sensitivity of AlGaN/GaN
mobility transistors. Appl Phys Lett 105(21). https://doi.org/10. High Electron Mobility Transistor (HEMT)-Based Biosensors in
1063/1.4902944 Human Serum [Researcharticle]. Anal Chem 91(9):5953–5960.
37. Makowski MS, Bryan I, Sitar Z, Arellano C, Xie J, Collazo R, https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.analchem.9b00353
Ivanisevic A (2013) Kinase Detection with Gallium Nitride based 50. Tulip FS, Eteshola E, Desai S, Mostafa S, Roopa S, Islam SK
high electron mobility transistors. Appl Phys Lett 103:013701 (2013) Detection of Transplant Rejection Chemokine Protein
38. Pulikkathodi AK, Sarangadharan I, Chiao YL, Chen P-H, Chen- Biomarker in physiological salt concentration, IEEE Sensors J
Chen C, Wang Y-L (2018) Miniaturized Biomedical Sensors for 13(2)
Enumeration of Extracellular Vesicles. Int J Mol Sci 19:2213 51. Tai T-Y, Sinha A, Sarangadharan I, Pulikkathodi AK, Wang S-L,
39. Ma S, Liao Q, Liu H, Yu S, Li P, Huang Y, Zhang Y (2012) An Lee G-Y, Jen IC, Shiesh S-C, Lee G-B, Wang Y-L (2019) Design
excellent enzymatic lactic acid biosensor with ZnO nanowires- and Demonstration of Tunable Amplified Sensitivity of AlGaN/GaN
gated AlGaAs/GaAs high electron mobility transistor, The Royal High Electron Mobility Transistor(HEMT)-Based Biosensors in
Society of Chemistry,6415–6418 Human Serum. Anal Chem 91:5953–5960
40. Tulip FS, Eteshola E, Desai S, Mostafa S, Roopa S, Evans B, Islam 52. Jayanthi VSPKSA, Das AB, Saxena U (2016) Recent advances in
SK (2014) Direct label-free electrical immunodetection of trans- Biosensor development for the detection of cancer biomarkers.
plant rejection protein biomarker in physiological buffer using Biosens Bioelectric 31242(8,1):28
floating gate AlGaN/GaN high electron mobility transistors. IEEE 53. Salek-Maghsoudi A, Vakshiteh F, Raheleh T, Hassani S, Ganjali
Trans Nanobiosci 13(2):138–145. https://doi.org/10.1109/TNB. MR, Nouruzi P, Hossini M, Abdollahi M (2017) Recent advances
2014.2318234 in biosensor technology in assessment of early diabetes biomarkers.
41. Pulikkathodi AK, Sarangadharan I, Chen YH, Lee GB, Lwang Y Biosens Bioelectron 30496(7):1–45
(2017) Aptamer Functionalized AlGaN/GaN HEMT Biosensor
54. Libertino S, Aiello V, Scandurra A, Renis M, Sinatra F, Lombardo
Array for Electrical Enumeration of Circulating Tumor Cells.
S (2009) Feasibility studies on Si-based biosensors. Sensors 9(5):
ECS Trans 77(7):17–20
3469–3490. https://doi.org/10.3390/s90503469
42. Khan MA, Kumar P, Siddharth G, das M, Mukherjee S (2019)
Analysis of Drain current in Polycrystalline MgZnO/ZnO and 55. Libertino S, Conoci S, Scandurra A, Spinella C (2013) Biosensor
MgZnO/CdZnO HFET. IEEE Trans Electron Devices 66(12): integration on Si-based devices: Feasibility studies and examples.
5097–5102 Sensors Actuators B Chem 179:240–251
43. Ding K, Wang C, Zhang B, Yang Z, Guan M, Cui L, Zhang Y, 56. Tikhomirov VG, Gudkov AG, Agasieva SV, Gorlacheva EN,
Zhang Y, Lin Z, Huang F (2011) Improved sensitivity of AlGaN/ Shashurin VD, Zybin AA, Evseenkov AS, Parnes YM (2017)
GaN field-effect transistors biosensors by optimized surface The sensitivity research of multiparameter biosensors based on
functionalization, IEEE Sensors J 11(8) HEMT by the mathematic modeling method. J Phys Conf Ser
44. Gan A (2010) Biofunctionalized AlGaN / GaN high electron mo- 917(4). https://doi.org/10.1088/1742-6596/917/4/042016
bility transistor for DNA hybridization detection. June 2014. https:// 57. Wang Z, Zhang Y, Zeng Y, Li Xi, Chen Z, Luo J, Yang Z, Zhang
doi.org/10.1149/13377100 Y, Qiao Y (2018) Discovery of TAS2R14 agonists from
45. Singh R, Khan MA, Mukherjee S, Kranti A (2017) Analytical Platycodon grandiflorum using virtual screening and affinity-
model for 2DEG density in graded MgZnO/ZnO Heterostructures screening based on a novel TAS2R14-functionalized HEMT sensor
with cap layer. IEEE Trans Electron Devices 64(9):3661–3667 combined with UPLC-MS analysis, J Agric Food Chem
46. Verma YK, Mishra V, Gupta SK (2019) A Physics-based analytical 58. Tikhomirov VG, Gudkov AG, Agaseiva SV, Gorlacheva EN,
model for MgZnO/ZnO HEMT, J Circuits, Syst Comput Shashurin VD, Zybin AA, Evseenkov AS, Parnes YM (2017)
47. Park S-H, Hong W-P, Kim J-J (2016) Theoretical Studies on the The sensitivity research of multiparameter biosensors based on
two-dimensional electron gas properties of MgZnO/MgO/ ZnO HEMT by the mathematical modeling Method. IOP Conf Series:
Heterostructures. J Korean Phys Soc 69(1):96–98 J Phys 917:042016
48. Tulip FS, Eteshola E, Desai S, Mostafa S, Roopa S, Islam SK
(2013) Detection of transplant rejection chemokine protein bio- Publisher’s Note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdic-
marker in physiological salt concentration. IEEE Sensors J 13(2): tional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
438–439. https://doi.org/10.1109/JSEN.2012.2226573