Army Air Force Integration Forum (13 1630 Mar 2012)
Army Air Force Integration Forum (13 1630 Mar 2012)
Capabilities
Capstone Concept for Joint Operations
Structure
Organization
Modernization
Doctrine 2015
ADP 3-0 Unified Land Operations
The Squad
Education
Experience
Training
S02291300
FOUO
Problem Statement
CSA to CG, TRADOC (July 2011):
How do we transition from todays force to the Army of 2020 in an era of fiscal austerity and still accomplish all that the Army must do as part of the Joint force?
S02291300
What must the Army of 2020 do? Can we eliminate entire C2 echelons? Can we justify EAB C2 overhead after reducing BCTs? What is the role of the Corps and Division? Can we create a common structure to reduce affordability issues with the current mix of H-, I-, and SBCTs? Is it a BCT- or Division-based solution? Are Brigades assigned to Divisions and Corps? How do we tie in an affordable Modernization Strategy to force designs? How do we keep the Army expansible? How do we resolve the unsustainable officer grade plate? How do we link regional alignment to training? How do we generate readiness and tie this process to a regional alignment strategy? How do we leverage Joint interdependencies to identify and eliminate redundancy?
FOUO
3
Futures
The Probable
Episodic Terror Attack Persistent Cyber Conflict Humanitarian Crisis WMD Proliferation Communist Cuba Fails
The Possible
Iran Conflict India - Pak Conflict Korea Conflict Chem/Bio/Rad Attack in CONUS Failed State with Loose Nukes Arab - Israeli Conflict Iran-Arab Conflict Kurdish Nation Hostile Pakistan China-Taiwan Conflict Genocide Mass Migrations
Global Trends
Cyber Resource Competition
Pacific focus
The Unthinkable
Pandemic Fall of the House of Saud Nuclear Incident in CONUS Destruction of Panama Canal Russia-NATO Conflict Central American Narco States Hostile Turkish Regime
Anti-access and area denial campaigns strategic thru tactical levels Engage at small unit level where they perceive a greater chance to obtain overmatch and achieve success Use violence, intimidation and coercion against U.S. supporters WMD capable but still seeking nuclear Avoid detection and targeting by operating among the people Slow down or halt our momentum using anti-tank missiles, IEDs, air defense and SOF Increased use of robotics and unmanned aerial systems Employ electronic warfare to counter US precision Conduct sophisticated information campaigns designed to erode US will over time
Narrow Lens
Deter Defeat
Hybrid Threats
States Criminals
Presence Cyber & Space HADR
Project Power
Wide Lens
HD/ DSCA Deter & Defeat CT/IW Nuclear
Deterrence
Terrorists
Specific Threat Specific Location Specific threat, degree of certainty and location drove:
Doctrine Equipment Training Organizational Structure Force Posture
Insurgents
Counter WMD Stability/ COIN
Defeat A2/AD
Historic Examples: 1920-30s Rainbow Planning Airmobile Active Defense AirLand Battle Now: Gain and Maintain Access
08 1430 MAR 12
What the Army Must Do: Prevent, Shape, and Win: Strategic guidance requires the Army to conduct a wide range of missions while retaining the ability to focus more narrowly on projecting power to deter and defeat aggression once a specific threat emerges. The combination of a narrow focus within a wide lens allows the Army to adjust more rapidly to potential threats.
6
The Army must maintain aOfficial Use of operational adaptability For high level Only
Army 2020
Future Force
Close Fight
Deep Fight
Shaping Opns
Concepts
Research & Development 6.4 / 6.3 Experiments/Wargames Projected POM Force (Army 2020)
2017 2018 2019 2020 38th CSA Impacts out to POM 16-20
POM 13-17 POM 14-18 POM 15-19 POM 16-20 29 1300 FEB 12
Major Ideas
Pentomic Army Air Mobility
Announced
1956 1960 1961 1976 1982 1994
Timeframe
1957-1959 1965-1972 1961-1979 1977-1982 1982-1992 2000-2010
Outcome
Inadequate technology Employed in Vietnam Employed in Vietnam Inadequate revised Employed in ODS Employed in OIF/OEF
Reorganized Objective Army Division (ROAD) Active Defense AirLand Battle Force XXI
1996
2002 2004 2009
2010-2025
2002-2009 2005 2016-2028
Changes in strategy, resources, and the operating environment drive the need for new Army concepts
29 1300 FEB 12
Capability Development: Considers gaps in: Doctrine Organization Training Material Leadership and Education Personnel Facilities Moderated by: Cost / Affordability Risk
The Army determines its required capabilities starting with concepts Current concept work focused on 2016-2028; refreshed every two years
Additional concepts address Building Partner Capacity, Learning, Training, the Human Dimension, and Gaining and Maintaining Access (Army-USMC) White papers being developed for Cyber, Special Operations, and Aviation
Training Concept
29 1300 FEB 12
AUG 11
USN Global 11 14-22 Jul 2011 CCJO Writing CCJO Wargame Workshop #2 May 2012 21-22 MAR 2012 Washington, DC BAH McLean, VA CCJO Multinational & Think Tank 9 MAR 2012 JB Andrews, MD
SEP 11
OCT 11
ACF Revision DP
NOV 11
Army Expeditionary Warrior Experiment 18 Oct-17Nov 2011 Ft. Benning, GA
MAR 12
Human Dimension Workshop 17-20 April 2012 Fort Bragg, NC
USMC Expeditionary Warrior 5 - 9 Mar 2012
FEB 12
Set Conditions For Phase 2/3 Event Jan 2012 Ft. Leavenwort h
JAN 12
Army Future Game Planning Conference (STAFFEX) 30 APR-4 MAY 2012 Carlisle, PA
Army Science and Technology Advisory Group (ASTAG) DEC 11 Gain & Maintain Access Experiment Senior Phase 2/3 11-22 Jun 2012 and 23-27 Jul 2012 Distributed
DEC 11
Build & Prepare Experiment Phase 4/5 13-17 Aug 2012 Ft. Leavenworth
APR 12
ACC Published
MAY 12
CCJO Seminar Wargame 6-11 May 2012 JB Andrews, MD
JUN 12
JUL 12
Joint Warfighter Outcomes Warfighting Challenges DP DP Campaign of Learning DP
08 1500 MAR 12
10
Train, equip, and posture forces to deter adversaries and prevent conflict Provide support to civil authorities as directed Conduct operations to counter weapons of mass destruction Provide strategic and theater missile defense Modernize units to meet the requirements of the future operating environment
capacity, and set conditions for operations Support combatant commander theater security cooperation activities Conduct integrated SOF and Conventional Force operations and activities Perform Title 10, executive agent, and Army support to other service responsibilities Conduct humanitarian assistance, disaster relief, and other operations
Prevail in war and defend the homeland in support of Joint Force Commanders:
Deter and defeat aggression through unified land operations Conduct combined arms maneuver to seize and exploit the initiative, and win decisively Conduct wide area security to retain the initiative and protect populations, forces, activities and
infrastructure Conduct counter terrorism and irregular warfare Conduct counterinsurgency and other stability operations Conduct sustained campaigns to achieve favorable conflict termination Maintain a reserve and generate forces to mitigate strategic risks Implement reversibility and expansibility to counter unexpected crises
08 1500 MAR 12
11
The Army must be able to Prevent, Shape, and Win as part of a Joint Force
13 0925 MAR 12
12
13
Collapse an Echelon of C2 at Echelons Above Division (EAD) Assign / Align Brigades to Divisions and Corps Align Corps / Divisions / Brigades Regionally Adapt ARFORGEN to a Selective Mission Readiness Model Establish an Operational Reserve Redesign Brigade Combat Teams Implement a New Tactical Wheeled Vehicle Strategy Create Reconnaissance and Surveillance Brigades Improve Army Advisory Capability:
Organic to ASCCs Regionally Aligned Forces (apportioned for planning)
Integrate Special Operations and Conventional Forces Ensure Reversibility and Expansibility
Significant changes to how the Army organizes and does business
13 1500 MAR 12
14
Questions
15
Back up
16
AWFCs
Insights/findings/ Evaluations recommendations/ interim solution strategy Informs how the Army Informs Key Ideas operates, refines required capabilities
Strategic Guidance
Special Concepts
Mission Command
Mission Command
6 x Warfighting Functions
QDR NMS GEF GDF
BPC HD etc.
Integration (Continuity of Key Ideas and Required Capabilities) 2 Year Revision Cycle Experiments, Wargames, Seminars, and Studies
For Official Use Only
17
08 1545 MAR 12
XXXX/XXX
USARCENT
XXXX/XXX
USARPAC
XXXX/XXX
ARNORTH
XXXX/XXX
USAREUR
XXXX/XXX
USARSO
XXXX/XXX
USARAF
XXXX/XXX
EUSA
MTOE: 577
XXX
Contingency Corps
MCP (ASCC) (535) HHB (49) OCP (523) TAC CP(62) HHB (173)
MCP (ASCC) (535) HHB (49) OCP (523) TAC CP(62) HHB (173)
Theater / Corps HQ
Fires Protection Sustainment Intel
III
Mission Command
Maneuver
X X
+
AAMDC
X
++
EN
X
++
MP
X
++
TSC
+
CA
X
++
Signal Command
X
III
TIG
III
IO
EN
X
MP
X
+
ESC X MED III TASMG X SUST III RSG FMC HRSC X AFSB X CSB
MIG
I
ADA
X
CA
TAC
X
SIG STRAT
X
BCD
CM
III
MEB
MIB
(Exp) II
SIG TAC
EOD
AEB
(Exp)
XX
Division
X
DIV
X X
19
PACOM
GLOBALLY AVAILABLE
CENTCOM
XXX
I 1
III
SF
XXX
XVIII
XX
82
EUCOM
X
11 III
XXX
5
III
SF
XX
2 19
III
SF
XX
1 20
III
SF
XX
4 2
X
1
XX
10
III
SF
III
TEG
XX
3 3
X III
TEG
XX
25
III
TEG
SOUTHCOM
XX III
TEG
XX
10 7
III
SF
XX
40
XX
29
AFRICOM
XX
101 3
III
SF
III
TEG
20
Time
Ready Forces
Mission Pool. Select AC and RC forces (including critical RC enablers) are assigned to a mission pool. These forces remain in a constant state of readiness and are maintained using individual replacements. They never drop into the rotational pool. Reserve Force Pool. The reserve force pool is comprised of forces that are not organized, trained, or equipped to deploy rapidly, such as the generating force units and select RC units.
07 1430 MAR 12
21
Strategic Requirements
Reset
Train Ready
Available
Time
Ready Forces
Rotational Pool
Reserve Pool
Things we are considering: Determining force mix (AC/RC) for each element of the model Establishing readiness levels required for AC/RC units in each pool Leveraging existing ARNG state partnership programs and adapting as necessary Synchronizing with enduring shaping requirements
22
Base Case derived from TAA 14-18 Alternate Case Excursion (at 490K)
ABCT X IBCT X SBCT X
10/7/0//17
12/20/0//32
8/1/0//9
AC 10 30 12 36 8 24
AC 10 10 11 3
RC 8 8 8 15
08 1500 MAR 12
23
359/43/4288//4691
173
II
443
II
427
II
1893
II
394
II
1359
BSB Removals: Remove Fuel Haul - 30 Remove Distro 16 Remove Water Production - 8 BEB FSC Offsets 9 Total Offsets = 63
HHC
43/17/113//173
HHC removals: - COLTS HHC (12)
BEB
34/8/403//445 28/0/399//427
BEB HHC removals: - MP Platoon (42)
13/1/78//92
BSB
49/0/582//631 29/2/363//394
I
71/16/1272//1359
HHC
16/1/59//76
HHC
17/2/67//86
I
3/0/42//45 0/2/30//32 5/2/137//144 270
MI
4/6/61//71 0/2/25//27 TUAV PLT
I
4/6/92//102
5/0/85//90
CBT
6/0/141//147
CONST
4/0/60//64
MP
1/0/41//42
Personnel Removed from BCTs: Vertical PLT from Const CO: SPT SQD from Horizontal PLT: MP PLT (detainee, police actions): COLTS (Targeting and Direction): Fuel Haul: Distro: Water Production: FSC Offsets: MICO TAA Informed TOTAL:
FSC
(x3) CAB FSC: 5/1/174//180 BEB FSC: 5/1/129//135 FIRES FSC: 5/1/144//150 RECON FSC: 5/1/113//119
15/0/68//83
CBRN
08 1500 MAR 12
1/0/11//12
24 24
166
II
423
II
404
II
2094
II
410
II
933
HHC
45/16/105//166
HHC removals: - COLTS HHC (12)
BEB
34/9/383//423 37/0/367//404
BEB HHC removals: - MP Platoon (42)
BSB
32/2/376//410
44/0/654//698
65/17/851//933
HHC
I
14/1/74//88
BSB Removals: Infantry Transport - 96 Fuel Haul - 10 Distro 20 Water Production - 7 BEB FSC Offsets - 9
HHC
16/1/56//73
I
3/0/42//45
17/2/64//83
0/2/30//32
I
155T 6/0/108//114
5/2/99//106
MI
4/6/61//71 0/2/25//27 TUAV PLT
I
105T
176
5/6/81//91
CBT
6/0/123//129
CONST
4/0/64//68
MP
1/0/41//42
CBRN
1/0/11//12
Personnel Removed from BCTs: Vertical PLT from Const CO: SPT SQD from Horizontal PLT: MP PLT (detainee, police actions): COLTS (Targeting and Direction): Infantry Transport: Fuel Haul: Distro: Water Production: BEB FSC Offsets : MICO TAA Informed TOTAL:
6/0/82//88
FSC
(x3) IN FSC: 4/1/86//91 BEB FSC: 4/2/114//120 FIRES FSC: 4/1/97//102 RECON FSC: 4/1/80//85
15/0/58//73
01 1000 MAR 12
25 25
170
II
483
II
36/0/367//403
403
HHC
45/15/110//170 HHC removals: - COLTS HHC (12)
BEB
33/10/440//483 BEB HHC removals: - MP Platoon (42)
II II
2088
II
31/2/360//393
393
II
839
BSB
43/16/780//839
43/0/653//696
BEB Removals: Remove FSSP Equipment Only Add Distro/Haul - +52 Remove Water Production - 4 BEB FSC Offsets - 9
HHC
16/1/57//74
HHC
17/2/148//167
16/0/78//94
I
3/0/42//45 0/2/27//29
5/2/198//205
MI
4/7/78//89 0/2/25//27 TUAV PLT
5/12/363//380
5/0/85//90
CBT
5/0/114//119
CONST
4/0/60//64
I
6/0/47//53
MP
1/0/41//42
CBRN
08 0800 MAR 12
1/0/11//12
Personnel Removed from BCTs: Vertical PLT from Const CO: SPT SQD from Horizontal PLT: MP PLT (detainee, police actions): CBRNE: COLTS (Targeting and Direction): FSSP Equipment Only Add Distro/Haul: Water Production: BEB FSC Offsets: MICO TAA Informed TOTAL:
16/0/71//87
Preliminary Target Minus TDA Reductions Minus TAA 14-18 (estimate) New Estimated Target
Protected Mobility for Stability Opns Phase III: Augmentation Pool for Stability Operations
Retain in Unit TWVs that are Minimum Mission Essential for Training, Low Density, etc
Army-wide scope of effort working within the 2020 construct to get down to 170K trucks not just BCT focused
The Army needs a new operational concept for a reconnaissance formation at corps / division:
Conduct intelligence collection; answer PIR Fight for information in close contact with the population and the enemy Direct and employ joint fires as required Act as a light-to-medium weight strike force (e.g., following forcible entry and lodgement seizure)
28
HHC 177
MI
281
*
324
40
BSC 175
HHC 27
TUAS
54 101
HHT
94 SPT 46 X 2 46
Tech
Collect
(Future fielding)
C&E
53
138
LRS
CI/ HUMINT
73
FDU Adds - 3RD Mounted Recon Troop - Increase Scouts PLTs from 4 to 6 - 3 120mm Mortar Sections - Sustainment enablers
FDU Adds Design: 1701
Add Capability to Fix and Finish - 2nd Mounted Recon SQDN - Artillery Battalion - Sustainment enablers
Proposed Design: 2742
Enables future Army forces to fight for information at echelons above brigade
For Official Use Only
29
The R & S BDE conducts Reconnaissance and Surveillance in the DIV or Corps AO based on METT-TC. It can operate in an area assigned by the supported commander or operate in an unassigned area within the Division or Corps AO. The R & S BDE enables the understanding of the networks and operational environment. Finds key network elements and their vulnerabilities Fuses intelligence: In conjunction with Div / Corps / BCTs and extended intelligence enterprise; to enable network exploitation / attack. The R & S BDE conducts fix and finish missions based on METT-C factors and augmentation (Maneuver BN, Fires, AV) The R & S BDE provides Flexibility and Versatility to the DIV & Corps. METT-TC considerations will determine the operational reach of the R&S BDE; the Corps or Division Commander may focus the R & S BDE into one or more tactical operating areas to answer PIR and / or identify enemy network elements.
30
Gap Insufficient reconnaissance capability Insufficient intelligence capability Insufficient fires Limited capability to fix and finish
Redesigned MI (P&E) BN (DP 142) Organic mortars Augment or task with organize elements of Maneuver, Aviation, or Fires
Proposed Changes
Transform the BFSB into the R&S BDE Approve the R&S Squadron BDE FDU and MI redesign initiative: enhances analytical capability , enhances ability for combat information collection, increases the ability to actively engage the local population. Consider adding the capability to fix and finish Add mounted reconnaissance squadron and organic artillery
Stability / DSCA
Stability / DSCA
Proposed Construct
Shape by integrating SOF and conventional forces in a new construct for Irregular Warfare (includes CT, UW, FID, COIN, Stability Ops, SFA) Determine conventional force support to SOF and SOF support to conventional force Synchronize training and leader development Gain authorities and policies to employ AC and RC forces in more predictable ways Facilitate integration with regionally aligned conventional forces Consider a 7th warfighting function to drive operational and institutional integration (will require the addition of a new functional concept to the AFC revisions in late Summer 2012)
01 1000 MAR 12
32
Priorities of 21st Century Defense: Whenever possible, we will develop innovative, low-cost, and smallfootprint approaches to achieve our security objectives, relying on exercises, rotational presence, and advisory capabilities. 38th CSA Marching Orders: The Army shapes the environment by sustaining strong relationships with other Armies, building their capacity, and facilitating strategic access. ASCC Engagements: Corps has to hunt for a Theater Engagement Group/Theater Engagement Section, (TEG/TES) capability prior to deployment; it should be provided to them. Emphasizes the role of regionally-focused engagement to command's success, particularly in shaping and preventing. General Officer Operational Assessment: Provides a separate subordinate organization to provide mission command over Army forces engaged in theater security cooperation activities in Host Nations, and provide Army institutional development advice and expertise to HN land forces.
Potential Solutions:
Use regionally aligned forces (through GFM process) Assign advisory element to ASCC (with organic TTs) Assign advisory element to ASCC (and use regionally aligned forces for TTs) Employ a centralized structure adapted from current organizations (e.g. 162nd, AEG)
13 1000 MAR 12
33
Expansibility:
The ability of the Army to grow capabilities and capacity not resident in the existing Total Army. Expansibility employs reorganization and mobilization of the existing Army, coupled with regeneration and capabilities development to reconstitute or produce new capabilities and capacity. Expansibility combines intellectual capital, concepts, and methods to produce increased capabilities and capacity in response to operational demands.
Zero Sum Gain Strategies, Policies, and Investments Enabling Expansibility
For Official Use Only
34
01 1000 MAR 12
Strategic Risk
E n d S t r e n g t h
New capabilities for a specific future conflict
Demand Increase
Reorganize / Mobilize
BCT Enabler Growth Capabilities and capacities lost in Drawdown Growth Target: 15K per year
X# of BCT Reduction
Time
For Official Use Only
35
01 1000 MAR 12
36
FEB
TAA 14-18 01 FEB FDU (SRC) CCJO Recc Seminar TAA 15-19 Wargame GFMB Resourcing
MAR
POM Mid-year Review SecArmy Decision 2 vs 3 Bn (27 MAR)
APR
MAY
OMA Mid-year Review FMR 15-19
JUN
POM 14-18 LOCK
JUL
FDU (SRC) Approval
AUG
3-star Cap Demand 2-star GOSC GOS CoC C
SEP
OCT
TAA 15-19 Resourcing 2-star 3-star CoC GOSC GOS C
TAA/POM 15-19
1/2 Strategic Engagement and Star GOSC (FORGEN) 01 MAR Communication LoE
(TRADOC ARCIC-F)
FORSCOM-USASOC Winter AUSA 31 JAN 22-24 FEB Sr Cmd ASCC ARCIC/ARNG Engagements Working Group 04-29 NOV USA-USAF Talks 10 JAN 07 FEB
ASCC & Corps Cdr Eng GO Cyber Summit 28MAR 24 MAR XVIII ABN USA-USMC Talks USA-USAF Corps 05 APR Integration Council 14 MAR Army Fellows USA-USN Talks Engagement MAR 24 MAR ARCIC/ARNG Working Group 18 APR ARCIC/ARNG Working Group 18 JUL
2
23 APR
1
BCT Support Concept 15 27 MAR
AOC 2012
An integrated plan for transition to Army 2020 A well-grounded proposal to guide Army redesign for an Army 2020 force that is: affordable, agile, capable, networked, responsive and adaptive, able to address the complex future operating environment characterized by complex, hybrid threats, and demanding missions.
KEY Decision Point Event Event/Process
12
15 AUG
05 JUN
08 FEB
R&S 3 Brigade 27 APR Best Practices Requirements & Acquisition 5 27 APR UQ 12 Human Dimension Excursion 16-20 APR
10
Assign/Align Bde/Div/Corps
13
TA/Corps Design
30 AUG
27 JUN
Tactical Wheeled
6
17 MAY
11 Vehicle Strategy
16 JUL Transition Actions to the Army Campaign Plan 16 JUL
Signific
Key De
13 0830 MAR 12
An integrated For Official Use Only Army 2020 plan to design the
37
CONUS
SPOE Space and cyber attack against critical deployment, C2, and support networks.
APOE Terror attack Cyber attack Propaganda Misinformation Media manipulation Political attack
Paramilitary/Proxy Conventional/Forces Mines and IED Infantry weapons Anti-tank Missiles G-RAMM Cyber/network attack
The Joint Staff J7 is developing the Joint Concept for Entry Operations.
38
Hiding sophisticated weapon systems in complex terrainparticularly in heavily populated urban areasin order to counter the U.S. ability to find and target them via technical means; Denying use of fixed airfield and ports to U.S. forces by creating unacceptable risk; Creating periods of air, cyber, or sea superiority.
How will the Joint Force Commander set conditions and employ Army-Marine forces to defeat area denial capabilities and maintain access throughout a campaign?
08 1500 Mar 2012
39
Conducting simultaneous force projection and sustainment to multiple, unexpected, austere locations.
Countering the effects of adversary actions against the air, sea, space and cyberspace domains by locating, seizing, neutralizing, or destroying land-based capabilities, thereby enabling cross domain synergy. Seizing key terrain to facilitate the entry of follow-on forces.
40
Key tasks required to project power and conduct entry operations given an active area denial environment
08 1500 Mar 2012
41
08
09
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
Slide Sorter
42