Scribd
Upload
12 views11 pages

Primary Criteria Weight 6 4: Sub-Total 27

The document outlines criteria for evaluating road construction projects, including primary, secondary, and tertiary criteria with specific weights assigned to each. It provides detailed metrics for road length, topography, earthwork quantity, drainage, geo hazards, and pavement quantity, along with scoring for various alignment options. Additionally, it highlights risks associated with different soil types and terrain conditions.

Uploaded by

bestrambestam1
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as XLSX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
12 views11 pages

Primary Criteria Weight 6 4: Sub-Total 27

The document outlines criteria for evaluating road construction projects, including primary, secondary, and tertiary criteria with specific weights assigned to each. It provides detailed metrics for road length, topography, earthwork quantity, drainage, geo hazards, and pavement quantity, along with scoring for various alignment options. Additionally, it highlights risks associated with different soil types and terrain conditions.

Uploaded by

bestrambestam1
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as XLSX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 11

Primary Criteria Secondary Criteria Weight tertiary Criteria

Road length 6 Road Length(km)


Flat Terrain(%)
Rolling Terrain(%)
Topography 4
Mountain Terrain(%)
Escarpment Terrain(%)
Total Earthwork(M3)
Earthwork Quantity 4 Cut (m3)x10^6
Engineering Fill (m3)x10^6
Drainage and structure 4 Culverts (No.)
Pipe culverts (No.)
Geo Hazard 6 Presence of Geo Hazard(%)(F/I/M)
Pavement Quantity 3 Total pavement (m3)

Sub-total 27
Total
Sub
Weigh A1 (original) Score A2 Score A3 Score Remark
14.32 6 14.40 5.97 14.81 5.80
0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0
12.186 1.5 12.186 1.5 13.883 1.32
2.1 0.57 1.2 1 0.8 1.5

1.960 1.16 0.994 2.29 0.911 2.5


0.188 1.05 0.131 1.5 0.164 1.20
1 3 1 3 4 1.3
12 1 12 1 17 0.7
2.44 3.44 1.72 4.88 1.4 6
AC 14,320 1.5 14,402 1.49 14,809 1.45
BC 2,506 1 2,520 0.99 2,592 0.97
SB 3,222 0.5 3,240 0.50 3,332 0.48
CP 1,862 0.5 1,872 0.50 1,925 0.48
21.22 24.62 23.74
21.22 24.62 23.74
s
3 89117 99800 10683 Mount ES MT
99800 100600 800 escaprment 0.8 13.883
100600 103800 3200 Mount

1 90100 100100 10000 Mount


100100 101000 900 escaprment 2100 115220
101000 101800 800 Mount 2.1 115.22
101800 103000 1200 escaprment
103000 10400 104420 Mount

2 89734 100100 10366 Mount 1200 12186


100100 101000 900 Mount 1.2 12.186
101000 101800 800 Mount
101800 103000 1200 escaprment
103000 104020 1020 Mount
EW cut 1,960,027.72 187,712.35 AC
Length 1 90100 104420 14,320.00 14,320.00
2 89734 104230 14,402.00 14,402.00
3 89117 104020 14,809.00 14,809.00
BC SB CP
2,506.000 3,222.000 1,861.60
2,520.350 3,240.450 1,872.26
2,591.575 3,332.025 1,925.17
Approved Final Optimization With Approved Departure
Revised OLD Alignment (Option 2)
Revised with new Departure and Proposal (Some SectionNew Root)3*15
1,960,027.72 187,712.35
993,866.33 130,797.06
910,787.39 163,910.23
We use U-ditch with 1 to 1 slope for some high Cut section
We use U-ditch with 1 to 1 slope for some high Cut section
We use U-ditch with 1 to 1 slope for some high Cut section
102+260 102+210 0.05 2 Root selectRolling TerUpper Basalt

102+210 101+620 0.6 2 Root selectescarpmentUpper Basalt

101+140 100+870 0.27 2 Root selectescarpmentUpper Basalt

96+620 96+140 0.48 2 Root selectescarpmentUpper Basalt


1.4

102+720 101+480 1.24 2 Root selectescarpmentUpper Basalt

100+480 99+680 0.8 2 Root selectescarpmentUpper Basalt


97+100 96+700 0.4 2 Root selectescarpmentUpper Basalt
2.44
102+720 101+480 1.24 2 Root selectescarpmentUpper Basalt
97+100 96+140 0.48 2 Root selectescarpmentUpper Basalt
1.72
Swampy section high risk
Yelowish brown decomposed rock
(low rockmass strength) high risk
Reddish brown silty Clay soil
(Residual Soil) high risk

Colluvium (Talus deposit) high risk

Colluvium (Talus deposit) high risk


Reddish brown silty Clay soil
(Residual Soil) high risk
Colluvium (Talus deposit) high risk

Colluvium (Talus deposit) high risk


Colluvium (Talus deposit) high risk

You might also like