20 Emergency Preparedness 3rd Course - W.TROMM
20 Emergency Preparedness 3rd Course - W.TROMM
Th. Walter Tromm, Programme Nuclear Waste Management, Safety and Radiation Research
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
Emergency Planning
Planning for emergency situations and therefore the
resources allocated for such situation, are based on
credible scenarios, but many uncertainties exist in a real
situation at beginning.
Nuclear emergency plans must therefore be flexible, and
able to be extended to beyond reasonably credible
scenarios.
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
Goals of Emergency Response
1. to regain control of the situation and to mitigate
consequences;
2. to save lives;
3. to avoid or to minimize severe deterministic effects;
4. to render first aid, to provide critical medical treatment and
to manage the treatment of radiation injuries;
5. to reduce the risk of stochastic effects;
6. to keep the public informed and to maintain public trust;
7. to mitigate, to the extent practicable, non-radiological
consequences;
8. to protect, to the extent practicable, property and the
environment;
9. to prepare, to the extent practicable, for the resumption of
normal social and economic activity.
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
Emergency management cycle
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
Accident phases and emergency management
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
JRODOS : Real-time online decision support
system for nuclear emergency management
What a decision support system can deliver to decision
making teams in case of a severe nuclear accident
JRodos as an example for a modern DSS
Tasks, input data, output
Simulation models and application examples
JRodos users; an emergency centre with JRodos
Conclusions on a DSS
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
JRodos users world wide (2020)
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
Possible tasks of a decision support system for
off-site nuclear emergency management
Provide consistent and comprehensive information at local,
regional and national levels, for all accident phases
During real event (housing and displaying of relevant information
about the release, the weather, the contamination; forecast of health,
agricultural and economic impacts with and without the application of
countermeasure)
When preparing for a possible future event (creating scenarios and
background material for planning, exercises and training)
Assist decision makers in evaluating different measures
against a range of quantitative and qualitative criteria
Promote a common emergency management frame aiming
to move away from national solutions
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
Key features of RODOS
Real-time On-line Decision Support system
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
Atmospheric transport and deposition -
phenomena considered in JRodos
inversion layer
height
dependent
atmospheric turbulence
wind
wet
deposition
dry
deposition
release to
atmosphere
contamination – radioactive particles and gases
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
From release to radiation exposure of people,
for airborne accidental releases from nuclear
power plants
Transport through the atmosphere
and deposition on natural and man-made
surfaces
External pathways Internal pathways
• - irradiation from radioactivity •inhalation of activity in cloud
on ground and man-made •inhalation of activity
surfaces resuspended from ground
• - irradiation from radioactivity •ingestion of contaminated food
in cloud and drinking water
Release to
atmosphere
Transport of deposited radioactive material
through environment and biosphere
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
JRodos: Tasks, input data, output
Radiological Monitoring Data Meteorological and Release Data
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
Phases of an event (adapted from NERIS SRA)
PREPAREDNESS PRE-RELEASE EMERGENCY RESPONSE LONG TERM
PHASE / THREAT PHASE
PHASE
Urgent Response Phase Early Response Transition Phase
Phase
Nuclear and Implementation Precautionary and Early protective Lifting of Early Resumption of
Radiological of Early urgent protective actions and other countermeasures normal living
Emergency counter- actions response actions conditions
Implementation of
Planning measures
transition phase
Stakeholder countermeasures
participation
Preparing long term
Education and remediation
training, Including
Exercises
R&D
Normal Exposure Existing, planned
Situation Emergency Exposure Situation Exposure
Planned Exposure Situation
Situation Normal Exposure
Situation
Hours - days Days - weeks Weeks - years
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
Threat phase: Available information
Alert message (not in Chernobyl)
Status of NPP (not fully understood, partly unknown, unknown...)
Inferred potential evolution of the accident
First estimations of potential source term (uncertain: amount of and timing of
release)
Meteorological data and radiological data
On-site measurements of weather; confirmation that a release is not already
occurring
Prognostic meteorological data (if available)
Uncertain: Future development of weather, in particular when discrepancies
between measurement and weather forecast
Preparedness: Emergency plans and procedures, listings of teams and
equipment etc.
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
Threat phase: Emergency management
Early phase countermeasures are most effective when implemented
early before the release
Evacuation initiated and completed before cloud arrival; sheltering during
whole cloud passage; prophylactic intake of stable iodine
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
Threat phase: Support provided by a DSS
Collects all data in one place and
provides information in a consistent way
Performs dose assessments
Provides results in terms of maps and
time functions on activity concentrations,
doses, dose rates
Proposes area to initiate early
countermeasures, simulates early
countermeasures to estimate the
performance of individual or combined
measures
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
Release phase: Available information
Status of NPP and potential evolution of the accident
Source term knowledge
(best) Release occurs exclusively via monitored escape route
(some) Recordings from external monitors close to the building (some
help) or farther away (considerable uncertainties)
Little to none (disastrous)
Dose rates and other data from radiological monitoring
On-site meteorological data and prognostic weather data
Emergency management requires prognostic information
Activity concentrations, doses and potential areas for decisions about
early phase and early late phase (e.g. food) countermeasures in the
environment (~100 km) of the accident location
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
Release phase: Support available from DSS
As for the pre-release phase
Data collection, simulation of activity concentrations and
countermeasures (early)
Two different types of information: Measurements and predictions
Bringing both together is important, because:
Measurements only represent a situation at one time at one given
location ("on-site")
Required are data representing larger time periods and areas
Data assimilation can combine both monitoring and modelling
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
Early countermeasure simulation model EmerSim
Result as example:
Day of exceeding
intervention level for
distribution of iodine
tablets, children (up to
12 years)
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
Early countermeasure simulation model
EmerSim
Possibility to test early phase countermeasures,
example with effective protective actions
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
Hypothetical release example, Vietnam, time dependend
I-131 soil contamination by dry+wet deposition
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
Arrival time for this artificial case,
Vietnam
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
Shelter areas
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
Iodine prophylaxis children
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
Areas for food ban
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
Marine water concentrations
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
Marine environment food
concentrations
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
137Cs concentration ( Bq/m3) in upper water layer due
to atmospheric fallout 12-24 March 2011, FDNPP
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
Simulation with numerical weather
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
Post-release phase: Available information
Status of the NPP (release has stopped)
Radiological monitoring (radiological situation is stable)
Identify nuclide vector
Identify hot spots
Confirm footprint of the cloud
Supervise doses in the population and in rescue teams
Prognostic information is still needed
Time evolution of activity concentrations, doses and potential areas to
initiate late phase countermeasures (relocation, decontamination, food
banning) wherever necessary
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
Post-release phase: Support from a DSS
As for the other phases
Data collection, simulation of activity concentrations and countermeasures
(early and late)
Support monitoring (in inhabited and agricultural areas)
Data assimilation (in inhabited and agricultural areas)
Simulation of recovery phase actions
Evaluation of actions to identify the most effective ones
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
Food chain and dose model, terrestrial - FDMT
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
JRodos recovery phase models
Recovery phase
Accident phase
Long-term post-accident
Threat Release Transition phase
phase phase phase Rehabilitation of areas for
returning to normal living
hours / days / weeks ... months ... years / decades
DepoM + FDMT / DepoM-PP + FDMT
Areas where European Commissions maximum permitted levels of
radioactive contamination for marketed food are exceeded
AgriCP
Countermeasures in agricultural areas
ERMIN
European model for inhabited areas
(decontamination, relocation)
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
Inhabited areas
RESIDENTIAL NON - RESIDENTIAL RECREATIONAL
Houses, housing estates.. Public buildings, offices, shops... Parks, countryside, woods...
Buildings
Indoors
Trees /
Shrubs
Precious Objects
Soil, grass
and plants
Roads /
Paved Areas
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
ERMIN for inhabited areas
European Model for Inhabited Areas calculation
• Countermeasure
strategies can be
defined and tested
• Supports selection
process
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
Applying ERMIN to Okuma town office and
the environmental setting
Mesh size
100 m
Calculating area of
environmental media by using GIS Input data into ERMIN
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
Radiation Dose (indoor) from Contamination
Decontamination Decontamination
Road
Road
Roof
Roof
Soil (small area)
Soil (small area)
Soil (large area)
Soil (large area)
Roof
Identify contribution of
Environmental medias
to Radiation Dose
Soil Road
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
Radiation Dose (outdoor) from Air Dose Rate
Public individual dose(outdoor)[µSv/h] Decontamination Decontamination
Road
soil road
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
Integrated Additional Exposure
Precondition Calculation Result
normal living conditions
1year
Without
CM
indoor:16 h outdoor:8 h With CM
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
Evaluation and adjustment of the protection
strategy
Proposed areas
for
countermeasures
are defined by
using DSS
calculations
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
JRODOS as DSS
• JRODOS is applicable in all phases of an emergency
• It contains models for the atmospheric and aquatic pathways
• It can be installed centrally and used remotely from as many users as
necessary – dependent on the power of the servers in the RODOS
centre
• Customisation is possible to national conditions applying national
criteria for evacuation, sheltering and iodine distribution
• In former H2020 research project, uncertainty handling and source term
reconstruction capabilities were added (e.g. ensembles of
meteorological and source term data)
• System is freely available and KIT offers support contracts
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
JRodos: RUG - Rodos User Group
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
IAEA Requirements
To achieve the Emergency Preparedness and
Emergency Response goals, the IAEA has set 26
Requirements that must be met.
This set of 26 requirements comprises in total 165
more specific requirements, describing the objective
and guidance on how to fulfill each requirement.
The Requirements are listed in the General
Safety Requirements: IAEA GSR Part 7.
The Requirements are divided in three categories:
General Requirements, contains in total 31 requirements
Functional Requirements, contains in total 105 requirements
Requirements for Infrastructure, contains in total 29
requirements
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
Emergency Planning Zones
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
Radiological Incident Phases
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
Default OILs (IAEA)
OIL 1 – evacuation
OIL 2 – sheltering
OIL 3 – general
emergency, food
OIL 4 – detection of a
release
OIL 8 – protection of
thyroid
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
Exposure Pathways
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
Preventing and Limiting Exposure ( I )
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
Preventing and Limiting Exposure ( II )
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
Preventing and Limiting Exposure ( III )
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
Radiation in Daily Life
units in microSievert
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
Levels of Radiation Dose
Units in microSievert
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
Summary
The general objectives of emergency planning and
preparedness are to reduce the risk or mitigate the
consequences of a radiation accident at its source and to
prevent health effects.
To generate reliable programs for emergency planning and
preparedness, there exist a series of requirements that
delineate the organizational structures and their functions.
The requirements also help defining emergency planning
zones for monitoring and control, and the actions to be carried
out in each of those geographical areas, based mainly on
dose expected.
Protective actions have to be performed in an ambience of
constant communication and clear cut functions among all
organizations dealing with the emergency at hand.
Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research
Thank you for your attention
06/06/2019 Th. Walter Tromm Joint ICTP-IAEA 3rd course, 30/04/21 Programme Nuclear Waste Management,
Safety and Radiation Research