The Heart in Rheumatic Autoimmune and Inflammatory Diseases Pathophysiology Clinical Aspects and Therapeutic Approaches Udi Nussinovitch (Eds.) Download
The Heart in Rheumatic Autoimmune and Inflammatory Diseases Pathophysiology Clinical Aspects and Therapeutic Approaches Udi Nussinovitch (Eds.) Download
https://textbookfull.com/product/the-heart-in-rheumatic-autoimmune-and-inflammatory-diseases-
pathophysiology-clinical-aspects-and-therapeutic-approaches-udi-nussinovitch-eds/
DOWNLOAD EBOOK
The Heart in Rheumatic Autoimmune and Inflammatory Diseases
Pathophysiology Clinical Aspects and Therapeutic Approaches
Udi Nussinovitch (Eds.) pdf download
Available Formats
No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including
photocopying, recording, or any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher.
Details on how to seek permission, further information about the Publisher’s permissions policies and our arrangements
with organizations such as the Copyright Clearance Center and the Copyright Licensing Agency, can be found at our website:
www.elsevier.com/permissions.
This book and the individual contributions contained in it are protected under copyright by the Publisher (other than as may be
noted herein).
Notices
Knowledge and best practice in this field are constantly changing. As new research and experience broaden our understanding,
changes in research methods, professional practices, or medical treatment may become necessary.
Practitioners and researchers must always rely on their own experience and knowledge in evaluating and using any information,
methods, compounds, or experiments described herein. In using such information or methods they should be mindful of their
own safety and the safety of others, including parties for whom they have a professional responsibility.
To the fullest extent of the law, neither the Publisher nor the authors, contributors, or editors, assume any liability for any injury
and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of
any methods, products, instructions, or ideas contained in the material herein.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
A catalog record for this book is available from the Library of Congress
ISBN: 978-0-12-803267-1
xi
xii LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS
Udi Nussinovitch, MD, PhD graduated from the chapters in scientific textbooks, mostly dealing with
Sackler Faculty of Medicine, Tel Aviv University, train- cardiac autoimmunity.
ing at the Sheba Medical Center, the Rambam Healthcare Dr. Nussinovitch has been the recipient of several
Center, and the Israeli Naval Medical Institute (INMI), awards for his research including the J. Kellerman
while concurrently graduating with a PhD in cardiac Award, the Noyfeld Award, the Lt. Grandir Award, and
electrophysiology from the Technion Institute of Tech- the Britain–Israel Research and Academic Exchange
nology, Israel. Partnership (BIRAX) Annual Award. He serves as a
Dr. Nussinovitch has mainly dedicated his research reviewer for leading rheumatologic and cardiac journals.
to cardiac autoimmunity and autoinflammation, car- Dr. Nussinovitch carries out his clinical work at the
diac manifestations of systemic diseases, cell- and Rambam Health Care Campus, a tertiary medical facility
gene-based cardiac therapies, and the modulation of and leading referral center in northern Israel, academi-
the cardiac electrophysiologic substrate for therapeutic cally affiliated with the Technion Institute of Technol-
purposes. He has published articles in leading rheu- ogy, Israel. Some of his clinical research was conducted
matologic journals and has authored papers dealing in collaboration with the Zabludowicz Center for Auto-
with the cardiovascular system, including publications immune Diseases and the Heller Institute of Medical
in Nature magazines. He has also published several Research, at the Sheba Medical Center, Israel.
xix
Preface
The prevalence of autoimmune diseases and rheu- substantially contribute to cardiovascular risk factors, as
matic conditions is constantly increasing. Autoimmune well as harbor direct cardiac influences. Interestingly, there
diseases affect approximately 7–10% of the population are several autoantigents shared by the joints and the heart
of the United States, while more than 50,000,000 Ameri- tissue, which may give rise to the involvement of both
can adults suffer from some type of arthritis. Many of these organs. In addition, although infrequent, direct tissue
these clinical conditions are characterized by multiorgan deposits of amyloid or crystals may ultimately manifest as
involvement and systemic inflammation. Cardiac com- cardiac disease in some chronic medical conditions.
plications in rheumatic, autoimmune, or inflammatory In recent years, extensive medical research has
conditions are major influences on the clinical outcome, expanded our understanding of the pathophysiological
quality of life, and overall prognosis of these common dis- mechanisms that mediate cardiac illnesses in systemic
eases, resulting in morbidity, recurrent hospitalizations, and autoimmune diseases. Although a broad review in
decreased quality of life, and early death. Actually, in a medical textbook is needed, more than a decade has
many systemic and inflammatory illnesses (rheumatoid passed since this topic was systemically addressed in
arthritis and others), cardiac disease has become the most a scientific manuscript. The authors herein endeavored
common cause of death. Also, in other cases, unique car- to fill this gap and provide a complete overview of the
diac manifestations may go undetected, mainly due to the current knowledge relating to the role of the immune
lack of medical awareness, high index of suspicion, and processes and inflammation in the pathogenesis of heart
occasionally the need for advanced diagnostic modalities. involvement in rheumatic, systemic autoimmune, and
Researchers have observed that autoimmune and inflammatory diseases. It is hoped that this extensive
inflammatory mechanisms play a pivotal role in athero- collection of data will simplify the comprehension of
sclerosis and ischemic cardiomyopathy. This interplay these complex, yet clinically significant mechanisms.
between immune mechanisms, inflammation, and car- The book is subdivided into three major sections.
diac diseases emerges as a distinct medical field affecting The first section focuses on molecular pathways, auto-
all age groups, genders, and populations. These mecha- immune mechanisms, and the pathogenesis of organ-
nisms are of particular clinical importance in systemic specific, autoimmune-mediated, myocardial injury. A
rheumatic and autoimmune disease. chapter will be devoted to atherosclerosis, within the
Other than a systemic proinflammatory state that context of systemic inflammation. Another chapter will
advances the process of atherosclerosis, there are several describe the battery of cardiac tests that can be employed
main pathways in which cardiac injury may occur. Vascular to identify the risks for an adverse cardiac outcome in
inflammation may involve the coronary vascular tree, thus patients with systemic diseases. This specific chapter will
resulting in many life-threatening medical complications aim at furthering the understanding of the experimental
and distorted coronary anatomy. A directed antiheart auto- results reviewed in the second section of the book (focus-
immune response may aggravate any nonspecific cardiac ing on the specific diseases and medical entities). In addi-
insult. Nonischaemic cardiomyopathy, microvascular dys- tion, this chapter can be used as a guide for conducting
function, valvular damage, and cardiac dysrhythmias may a comprehensive cardiac study in patients with systemic
also appear. Connective tissue disease and systemic vascu- diseases and suspected myocardial involvement.
litis may affect all aspects of cardiac performance including In the second part of the book, various rheumatic,
cardiac perfusion, the contractile function, impulse prop- inflammatory, and autoimmune diseases will be included
agation, induction of arrhythmias, inflammation of the and reviewed in a systemic manner. Chapters are devoted
pericardium, or involvement of the heart valves. A hyper- to inflammatory arthritis (rheumatoid arthritis and juve-
coagulability state may also result from systemic inflam- nile idiopathic arthritis, spondyloarthritides, and poly-
mation and specific immune responses, and consequently myalgia rheumatica), autoimmune and connective tissue
may facilitate ischemic cardiac injury and the development diseases (systemic lupus erythematosus, neonatal lupus,
of nonbacterial thrombotic endocarditis. Therapies used in Sjögren’s syndrome, systemic sclerosis, dermatomyositis,
the treatment of systemic autoimmune conditions may also and polymyositis), and crystal-induced arthritis (gout).
xxi
xxii PREFACE
Vasculitides will also be extensively discussed, including The third section of the book focuses solely on thera-
vasculitis affecting large arteries (giant-cell arteritis and peutics by systemically describing the adverse and
Takayasu’s arteritis), medium-size vessels (polyarteri- desirable cardiovascular effects of different therapeutic
tis nodosa and Kawasaki disease), and small-size vessels approaches used in the aforementioned indications and
(microscopic polyangiitis and Churg-Strauss syndrome, the novel emerging means of treatment and prevention
Wegener’s granulomatosis). Other chapters will focus on of immune-mediated cardiac diseases and atherosclero-
postinfectious autoimmune cardiac diseases (rheumatic sis. Specifically, anti-inflammatory agents, immunosup-
fever and Chagas heart disease) and cardiac manifestations pressive drugs, cardiac immunomodulation approaches,
of systemic autoinflammation found in familial Mediterra- and autoantibody-targeted therapies are described.
nean fever. Importantly, some exciting and recently emerged
In each chapter, the state-of the art knowledge of car- immuno-targeted therapies hold great promise and may
diac manifestations, pathogenesis, and therapeutic aspects revolutionize patient care.
is extensively reviewed and systemically discussed. The It should be noted that autonomic nervous system
aforementioned include clinical topics, present epidemio- abnormalities that may indicate, mediate, or facilitate to
logical data, genetic basis, and diagnostic criteria. The main some extent the progression of cardiac diseases and the
focus of the chapters is the pathophysiology of cardiac development of cardiac arrhythmias is beyond the scope
involvement, different clinical aspects, and the manifesta- of the current manuscript.
tions of cardiac diseases. The covered clinical topics will A comprehensive index was added that will aid in
include endothelial dysfunction and detection of subclinical finding material of theoretical and practical importance
atherosclerosis, ischemic cardiac disease, coronary vasculi- within the book.
tis, pericardial, myocardial and endocardial involvement, Insightful readers are encouraged to contact the
prevalence and markers of ventricular and supraventricu- editor with any suggestions or remarks as to the con-
lar arrhythmias, cardiac amyloidosis, and the overall occur- tent of the book, via email, at:
rence of cardiac-related adverse events and prognosis. Each [email protected].
chapter concludes with a discussion on disease-specific It is my sincere hope that this book will be a valu-
and cardiac-specific therapeutic options. The therapeutic able reference for rheumatologists, cardiologists,
approach for each clinical entity is presented with the level immunologists, and medical practitioners in the con-
of evidence and strength of recommendation according to tinuous pursuit of improving patient care and medical
the following commonly accepted scale: research.
A More than one randomized controlled trial Class I Conditions for which there is evidence
(RCT)/meta-analysis and/or general agreement that a given
procedure/therapy is useful and effective
B A single RCT or well-designed nonrandomized Class II Conditions for which there is conflicting
trial, i.e., prospective observational registries evidence and/or divergence of opinion
(case controls, cohorts). regarding the usefulness/efficacy of
performing the procedure/therapy
C Expert consensus: Includes case reports and Class IIa Weight of evidence/opinion is in favor of
retrospective series; the expert decides based usefulness/efficacy
on his or her experience
Class IIb Usefulness/efficacy is less well established
by evidence/opinion
Class III Conditions for which there is evidence and/
or general agreement that a procedure/
therapy is not useful/effective and in some
cases may be harmful
Acknowledgments
I wish to thank the distinguished researchers and and Nutrition, Robert H. Smith Faculty of Agriculture,
physicians who graciously accepted the invitation to Food and Environment, The Hebrew University of
contribute their medical knowledge by writing exten- Jerusalem), who has served as my unofficial personal
sive review chapters and sharing their unique perspec- mentor and my role model throughout the years. He has
tives, experiences, and expertise with the readers. always been available for me with practical and smart
I also wish to thank the unbiased experts who advice, insightful opinions, encouraging suggestions
reviewed the scientific content of this book and provided and a witty joke.
beneficial and valuable advice to the authors throughout The following distinguished researchers merit my
the revision process (the list of contributory reviewers is complete gratitude for their contribution to this book by
given below). reviewing and advising on its contents and providing
Special thanks to Shannon M. Stanton, Samuel Young, many valuable suggestions (in alphabetical order):
Julia Haynes and Greg Harris from Elsevier Publishing,
who served as my right-hand people and assisted me
greatly in making this book a reality. Julian L. Ambrus Jr., MD
I also wish to thank Elsevier Publishing who entrusted Professor of Medicine
me with this ambitious project and provided me with all Division of Allergy, Immunology and Rheumatology
the necessary resources for its completion. SUNY at Buffalo School of Medicine
I wish to thank Phyllis Curchack Kornspan for her Buffalo, New York, United States
editorial assistance throughout the years and for her help Paolo Amerio, MD, PhD
during the early editorial stages, and thanks to Hedva Professor of Dermatology and Venereology
Razieli (from the Alfred Goldschmidt Medical Sciences Dermatology Clinic
Library, Technion Institute of Technology, Israel) for her Department of Medicine and Science of Aging
help in locating some of the references incorporated University G. d’Annunzio
within the book. Chieti, Italy
I wish to thank the distinguished professors who
taught me throughout the years, including Prof. Yehuda Elena Bartoloni, MD
Shoenfeld, MD (Director of the Zabludowicz Center for Rheumatology Unit
Autoimmune Diseases, Sheba Medical Center, affiliated Department of Medicine
to Tel Aviv University, Israel), a pioneer and a leader in the University of Perugia
field of autoimmunity, who guided and encouraged me Perugia, Italy
to pursue my cardiac-autoimmunity interest; Prof. Avi Kevin M. Bonney, PhD
Livneh, MD (head of Internal Medicine Department F, Faculty of Arts and Sciences
Sheba Medical Center, the Heller Institute of Medical New York University
Research, affiliated to Tel Aviv University, Israel), an New York, New York, United States
extremely kind and modest person, one of the founding
Wei-Chiao Chang, D. Phil (Oxon)
fathers of FMF research and an exceptional clinician, who
Director, Master Program for Clinical Pharmacogenomics
taught me the principles of clinical research and its trans-
and Pharmacoproteomics
formation into patient care; and Prof. Lior Gepstein, MD,
Taipei Medical University
PhD, a world-leading cardiac researcher, who taught me
Taipei, Taiwan
how to perform high-end basic and translational scientific
research, vastly expanded my perspective of cardiac Arrigo F.G. Cicero, MD, PhD
electrophysiology, and always encouraged me to “focus Atherosclerosis and Metabolic disease Research Unit
on the big questions”. President of the Italian Nutraceutical Society (SINut)
Finally, I wished to thank Prof. Amos Nussinovitch, Medicine and Surgery Sciences Department
PhD (from the Institute of Biochemistry, Food Science Bologna, Italy
xxiii
xxiv ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
Milena Botelho Pereira Soares, BSc, PhD Miguel Hernán Vicco, MRes, MD, PhD
Senior Researcher Clinical Assistant Professor
Gonçalo Moniz Research Center Department of Internal Medicine
Oswaldo Cruz Foundation Faculty of Medical Sciences, National University of the
Salvador, Bahia, Brazil Littoral
Santa Fe, Argentina
Lee Stoner, PhD, MA, BSc (Hons), FRSPH, SFHEA
Senior Lecturer Antje Voigt, MD, PhD
College of Health, Massey University Associate Professor of Molecular Medicine
Wellington, New Zealand Institute for Biochemistry at the Charité Center for Basic
Sciences
Andre Talvani, BSc, MSc, PhD
Charité—Universitätsmedizin
Associate Professor in Immunology & Parasitology
Berlin, Germany
Department of Biological Sciences
Federal University of Ouro Preto Kenneth J. Warrington, MD, FACP, FACR
Ouro Preto, MG, Brazil Associate Professor of Medicine
Division of Rheumatology, Mayo Clinic, College of
Stefano Toldo, PhD
Medicine
Assistant Professor of Medicine
Rochester, Minnesota, United States
VCU Pauley Heart Center, Department of Internal
Medicine and Department of Surgery Ryu Watanabe, MD, PhD
Virginia Commonwealth University Professor of Medicine
Richmond, Virginia, United States Tohoku University Graduate School of Medicine Sendai
Japan
Juan Torrado, MD
and Visiting Assistant Professor at Department of
Research Associate
Medicine
Division of Cardiology—VCU Pauley Heart Center
Division of Immunology and Rheumatology
Virginia Commonwealth University Medical Center
Stanford University School of Medicine
Richmond, VA, United States
California, United States
Robert M. R. Tulloh, BM BCh MA DM FRCPCH
Wen Zhang, MD, PhD
Professor of Congenital Cardiology
Professor of Medicine
School of Clinical Sciences
Department of Rheumatology and Clinical Immunology
University of Bristol, Bristol, United Kingdom
Peking Union Medical College Hospital
Patompong Ungprasert, MD Beijing, China
Instructor of Medicine
Division of Rheumatology, Department of Internal
Medicine
Mayo Clinic
Rochester, Minnesota, United States
C H A P T E R
1
Pathophysiology of Autoimmunity
and Immune-Mediated Mechanisms
in Cardiovascular Diseases
O. Shamriz1, U. Nussinovitch2, N.R. Rose3,4
1Hadassah-Hebrew University Medical Center, Jerusalem, Israel; 2Rambam Health Care Campus, Affiliated With the
Technion Institute of Technology, Haifa, Israel; 3Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD, United States; 4Brigham
and Women’s Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, United States
drug administration and symptom development, as A possible mechanism is the inhibition of T-cell DNA
well as symptom resolution after cessation of the drug, methylation by UV radiation, which can convert normal
is required for diagnosis [10]. antigen-specific CD4+ T lymphocytes into autoreactive,
Exposure to silica and organic solvents are associated cytotoxic, proinflammatory cells [16]. The role of DNA
with systemic sclerosis (SSc). Silica may also be associ- methylation modulation in the pathogenesis of autoim-
ated with the development of rheumatoid arthritis (RA), munity is further indicated by the presence of immune
systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE), and antineutro- dysregulation in two rare congenital diseases: Russel–
phil-cytoplasmic antibody (ANCA)-associated vasculitis Silver and Beckwith–Wiedemann syndromes [7]. Other
[6,7]. Suggested mechanisms for silica-induced autoim- studies have suggested that UV light causes a clinically
munity include adjuvant effects of apoptotic debris, dys- significant autoimmune disease only in individuals with
regulation of apoptosis, altered CD4+/CD4+ CD25+ T-cell a genetic predisposition to SLE [16]. UV radiation plays
ratio, and induction of circulating autoantibodies (such a role in the pathogenesis of cutaneous lupus erythema-
as anti-dsDNA, anti-Ro/SSA, anti-La/SSB antibodies in tosus (CLE) by triggering keratinocyte apoptosis and
silica associated SLE) [7]. Solvents were found to be asso- externalization of nucleoprotein autoantigens, such as
ciated with circulating SSc autoantibodies (anti-Scl-70), Ro/SSa, to the keratinocyte cell surface and exposing
increased IFN-γ, and reduced interleukin (IL)-4 produc- them to circulating autoantibodies [17,18]. Exposure to
tions [7]. Other substances, such as aromatic amines, UV light is also known to be associated with the release
hydrazines, hair dyes, aliphatic chlorinated hydrocar- of proinflammatory cytokines, thus contributing to the
bons (vinyl chloride, trichloroethylene, and perchloro- pathogenesis and progression of SLE. These cytokines
ethylene), environmental estrogens (such as bisphenol include IFNs, TNFα, and IL-1, IL-6, IL-8, IL-10, and
A), inorganic mercury, and the mineral oil component IL-17, among others [18].
2-, 6-, 10-, 14-tetramethylpentadecane (TMPD or pris- Vitamin D, another solar exposure byproduct (due to
tine, which was found to induce acute inflammatory its production in the skin and the kidneys in a bipha-
arthritis in rats), are acquired due to occupational expo- sic process; although it may be externally derived
sure, which can also trigger autoimmunity in predis- from nutritional sources), is considered an important
posed individuals [7,11,12]. One suggested mechanism immune modulator. Interestingly, low levels of vitamin
for these substance-induced autoimmune responses is D were observed in various autoimmune conditions
the estrogenic influences on the immune system, which and were reported to be associated with more advanced
use binding to self-antigens and the creation of neoanti- disease stage and adverse clinical outcomes [19–22].
gens for which immune tolerance is lacking [3]. Tobacco Other dietary exposures were also suggested to miti-
smoking has been known to be associated with autoim- gate autoimmunity, such as the development of gluten-
munity and connective tissue diseases. For instance, the sensitive enteropathy, eosinophilia-myalgia syndrome,
odds ratio (OR) for developing SLE increases by 50% in and toxic oil syndrome as a result of ingestion of glu-
smokers compared with nonsmokers. The association ten, L-Tryptophan and 1, 2-di-oleyl ester (DEPAP), and
with RA is even higher (OR of 2.6–3.8 compared with oleic anilide-contaminated rapeseed oil, respectively
nonsmokers). Conjugation of smoking and a specific [7]. Furthermore, cow milk proteins introduced into
genetic background (HLA-DR alleles) produces a syn- the diet at a young age were reported to be linked to
ergistic effect and a higher risk of developing RA [13]. the development of DM. Excessive iodine consumption
Grave’s disease is also remarkably susceptible to smok- was found to be associated with autoimmune thyroid-
ing [14]. The exact mechanisms by which tobacco smok- itis [7]. Similarly, animal meat, fat, sweets, and sugar
ing affects autoimmunity are not fully understood but were suggested as a trigger for inflammatory bowel
increased tissue damage, generation of free radicals, and disease (IBD), although the latter association has yet to
increased systemic inflammation seems to mediate its be proven. Many of the environmental possible effectors
unfavorable immune effects [5]. Suggested mechanisms have been linked to the Western lifestyle [4].
for tobacco smoking-induced RA include post-transla-
tional modification of antigen citrullination and anti- 1.1.2 Infectious Agents
cyclic citrullinated peptide (CCP) antibodies, T helper Molecular mimicry between human and pathogenic
(Th)-17 activation by nicotine, and upregulation of heat (bacterial, viral, parasitic, and fungal) antigens has been
shock gene expression and circulating autoantibodies suggested as a possible trigger or aggravator of auto-
(such as rheumatoid factor and antiheat shock protein immune diseases. Chagas heart disease (CHD) and RF
70 (HSP70)) [7]. are good examples of autoimmune diseases triggered
Interestingly, among other factors, SLE is influenced by infectious agents, ie, Trypanosoma cruzi and group A
and exacerbated by ultraviolet (UV) radiation [15]. Ani- Streptococcus, respectively. Both pathogens are related
mal models suggest that exposure to UV radiation can to cardiac damage, but as the former affects mostly the
also lead to the development of an SLE-like disease. myocardial tissue, the latter may be associated with
pDC
IgG+
IFN-γ MPA
IFN-α
Feed-forward
loop
Naive
Mature TH1 CD4+
B cell T cell
IL-12
Feed-forward
Immature loop IFN-β mDC/
B cell macrophage
FIGURE 1.1 Potential mechanisms through which estrogen and progesterone might modulate the loss of immune tolerance and regulate the
production of pathogenic autoimmune autoantibodies in SLE. Adapted from Hughes and Choubey [31].
TABLE 1.2 Hormonal influences in a CVB-3 mediated autoimmune myocarditis mouse model
Estrogen (dominant Th2 response) Testosterone (dominant Th1/Th17 response)
Polarization of macrophages into M2 response and increased M2 Increased number of macrophages, neutrophils and cell-mediated
response autoimmunity
Upregulation of the M2 marker Arg1 and increased markers of Elevated levels of TLR4, caspase-1
M2 differentiation (Dectin-1, CD169, galcatin-3, CCL-2, CCL-7,
CXCL-3)
Increased IL-1β, IL-4, IFNγ, TNFα, TGFβ, IL-5, and IL-10 secretion Enhanced necrosis of cardiomyocytes
Greater percentage of B-cells and CD25, FOXp3, and Treg Autoreactive cytolytic T cells in the spleen
Increased Tim-3 expression in mast cells, macrophages, and T cells Increased CD8-cell activation
Increased fibrosis Decreased levels of IL-1β, IL-4, IL-5, IL-6, and TNFα
autoimmunity. Two important factors found in this rela- protease, is the main inducer of the alternative pathway.
tionship are cytokine dysregulation and the presence It cleaves to factor B, which forms a complex with the
of autoantibodies [46]. Cytokine dysregulation plays a hydrolyzed iC3b, thus leading to the formation of Ba
role in patients with MD, as high levels of proinflam- and Bb. Bb and C3b generate the C3 convertase of the
matory cytokines, including CRP, IL-6, and TNF-α, were alternative pathway, C3bBb [60,64]. Enzyme activation
detected [47]. This proinflammatory process appears to of C5 by C3bC4bC2a (lectin or classical pathway) or by
play a role in the pathogenesis of MD [46]. As a result, C3bBbC3b (alternative pathway) leads to the formation
these patients may be at risk for autoimmune disorders, of C5a and C5b, which in turn form the MAC C5b-9, thus
as was previously demonstrated in a large-scale epide- causing cell lysis [60]. Further effects of the complement
miological study [47]. Interestingly, this proinflamma- system include the MAC’s activation of granulocytes and
tory state may link MD with cardiovascular diseases endothelium; increased opsonization and phagocytosis
(CVD) [48]. Several studies describing MD patients to by the deposition of C3 fragments on the membranes;
have increased risk for hypertension and stroke, as well clearance of immune complex and apoptotic bodies; and
as studies that found MD to be an independent risk fac- alterations in immune cell signal transduction, adhesion
tor for CVD, support this notion [49]. activation, and cytokine production [60].
Several studies have suggested that an autoimmune Defects in the complement system or in its regulatory
mechanism triggers the development of MD via the pro- proteins may contribute to the development of autoim-
duction of autoantibodies. In SLE, antiribosomal P anti- mune diseases. Herein, we will explore the association
bodies (anti-P antibodies) were found associated with between the complement system and autoimmunity.
neuropsychiatric manifestations [50–53]. Moreover, they
were linked to hepatic involvement and acceleration 1.2.1 Complement Compound Deficiency and
of glomerulonephritis in these patients [54,55]. How- Autoimmunity
ever, it appears that anti-P antibodies may play a role The complement system’s role in tissue repair may
in the development of MD as well. In one study, anti-P be responsible for autoimmune response [60]. Although
antibodies were injected intracerebra-ventricularly into hypocomplementemia was associated with primary SS
mice, inducing a depressive-like behavior. Treatment and SSc [60], the hallmark autoimmune disease affected
with fluoxetine succeeded in relieving the symptoms by complement deficiency is SLE [61]. Complement defi-
[56]. This intriguing association between anti-P antibod- ciency was in fact identified as the strongest genetic sus-
ies, SLE, and MD implies that the presence of MD may ceptibility factor in humans for SLE [65,66]. In particular,
affect the development of autoimmune diseases. How- the deficiency of C1 (C1q, C1r, C1s), C4, and C2 were asso-
ever, a causal relationship has yet to be proven. ciated with high, moderate, and low risk for the develop-
ment of SLE, respectively [60,61,65]. This may result from
bypass mechanisms absent in C1q and C4 [67].
1.2 Complement System and Autoimmunity In the case of C3 deficiency, the clinical picture is dif-
The complement system was discovered over ferent, rarely associated with SLE, and more commonly
100 years ago [57]. At first, it was considered only to par- characterized by recurrent pyogenic infections, membra-
ticipate in the recognition and destruction of pathogens. noproliferative glomerulonephritis, and rash [60]. Preva-
At present, it is known to possess regulatory functions lence of SLE development in patients with C1q, C1r/C1s,
in adaptive [58], humoral [59], and T-cell immunity [57]. C4, and C2 deficiencies is estimated at 93%, 57%, and
There are three complement-cascade activating path- 75%, respectively [65,68,69]. The exact estimation of SLE
ways: the classical, lectin, and alternative pathways (Fig. development in C2 deficiency is more difficult than in
1.2 [57]). All three pathways lead to the cleavage of C3 other complement deficiencies due to higher prevalence
into the opsonin C3b and the anaphylatoxins C3a, which of heterozygosity in these patients. In one study it was
activates the C5 with formation of a membrane attack found to be 30% [65]. These clinical observations were
complex (MAC) [60,61]. The classical pathway is trig- further confirmed by mice models deficient in C1q-, C4-,
gered by the binding of immunoglobulin (Ig)-M and IgG C3-, and CD35/CD21 (CR1/2) and were shown to pre-
to the C1 complex [60,62]. The binding of C1q to an anti- dispose the subjects for autoimmune diseases [61].
body further activates C4 and C2 and induces the forma- In addition to complement compound deficiency
tion of the C4bC2a complex, a C3 convertase [60,63]. The anti-C1q autoantibodies also appear to play a role in the
lectin pathway facilitates recognition of microbial car- development of SLE. Present in up to one-third of SLE
bohydrate patterns either by a mannose-binding lectin patients, these autoantibodies create immune complexes,
(MBL) or ficolins. This leads to the activation of C2 and which are correlated with more severe disease [65,70].
C4 through the MBL-associated serine proteases (MASP) Anti-C1q antibodies may play a promising future role
and the formation of the C4bC2a complex, similar to in the early detection and monitoring of SLE patients,
that of the classic pathway [60,62]. Factor D, a serine especially in those with renal involvement [71].
Amplification loop
MASPS C1 C3b
C4, C2
CD55 (DAF),
C3 CR1,
Convertases fH or C4bp
C3
CD46 (MCP),
CR1,
fH C3b C3a
C5
Convertases
Opsonin Chemoaractant
CD46 ligand Smooth muscle cell contraction
T cell activation Vasodilation
C5 Neutrophil/phagocyte/mast cell activation
Degranulation
T cell activation
C5b C5a
MAC Chemoaractant
Vasodilation
Neutrophil/phagocyte/mast cell activation
Endothelial cell activation
Degranulation
T cell activation
CD59, S protein
FIGURE 1.2 Complement system, regulation, and function. In red are the major effectors of C3a, C3b, and C5a. Adapted from Heeger and
Kemper [57].
Three suggested hypotheses for the mechanism of receptor 1, CR1), and the complement receptor 1-related
SLE development in complement deficiency include gene/protein y (Crry) [72,73]. Other regulators involved
impaired clearance of immune complexes, apoptotic in autoimmune diseases are membrane soluble and can
cells, and abnormal B- and T-cell activation, which may be found in plasma or lymphatic fluid. These proteins
cause a defective tolerance in self-antigens. However, include factor H (fH), C4b-binding protein (C4bp), vit-
none of these hypotheses have been completely proven ronectin (S protein), clusterin (apolipoprotein J), and the
[61,65]. C1 inhibitor (C1-INH) [72]. Herein, we will elaborate
on five main regulator proteins: the CD55, CD59, CD46,
1.2.2 Impaired Function of Regulatory Proteins of Crry, and C1-INH.
the Complement System
The complement system has over 30 membrane- 1.2.2.1 CD55
bound regulator proteins that interact with different cells This glycosylphosphatidylinositol (GPI)-anchored
of the immune system [57,61]. Important regulators in membrane protein inhibits the formation and accelerates
the pathogenesis of autoimmunity include CD46 (mem- the decay of C3 and C5 convertases in all pathways [73].
brane cofactor protein, MCP), CD55 (decay accelerat- Paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria (PNH) is charac-
ing factor, DAF), CD59 (protectin), CD35 (complement terized by susceptibility of platelets and erythrocytes to
a complement attack. It was previously demonstrated demonstrated in patients with C1-INH deficiencies suf-
that CD55 deficiency in patients with PNH is responsible fering from hereditary angioedema (HAE). Up to 12%
for the lack of inhibition of the complement system and of HAE patients suffer from autoimmune diseases [84].
thus to an autoreactive complement response [73]. An association between SLE and acquired C1-INH defi-
ciency was previously reported, suggesting the presence
1.2.2.2 CD59 of anti-C1-INH autoantibodies as a possible etiology
Similar to CD55, CD59 is a GPI-anchored membrane [84]. However, SLE patients presenting with C1-INH
protein [74], expressed on red blood cells (RBC). It deficiency and angioedema without circulating anti-C1-
regulates the terminal step in the complement system INH antibodies were also reported [85].
by inhibiting MAC formation [73,74]. Furthermore, Other autoimmune diseases linked to HAE include
recent studies have suggested a direct inhibitory role SS, autoimmune thyroiditis, RA, DILE, pernicious ane-
of CD59a on T-cell activation, as demonstrated by the mia, IBD, celiac disease, MS-like syndrome and mixed
increased Vaccinia-specific CD4+ T-cell responses in connective tissue disease [84]. Suggested mechanism
CD59-knockout mice [73,75]. In murine models of SLE, include the defective clearance of immune-complexes
a CD59a deficiency was found to exacerbate skin auto- and apoptotic cells, which cause inflammatory damage
immune diseases, increase antichromatin autoantibody and trigger autoimmune responses [84]. Moreover, HAE
titers, and cause higher levels of proteinuria in male patients were found to have autoreactive B cells, which
mice [74]. CD59 deficiency has also been associated produce autoantibodies such as antinuclear, rheuma-
with PNH, autoimmune-hemolytic anemia (AIHA), toid factor, anticardiolipin, antitissue transglutaminase,
RA, MS, and SS [73,76–78]. antiendomysial, anti-Saccharomyces cerevisiae, antithy-
roid, antineutrophil cytoplasmic antibodies and others
1.2.2.3 CD46 [84,86–89]. Even anticholesterol autoantibodies were iso-
CD46 is a transmembrane glycoprotein, which lated in HAE patients, suggesting a major role of autore-
binds, inactivates C3b and C4b [79], and plays a major active B cells in HAE pathogenesis [90]. The presence of
role in downregulating the Th1 response by substitut- increased levels of TLR-9 in HAE patients may account
ing IFNγ + IL-10 - CD4+ T cells into IFNγ + IL-10 + cells for this phenomenon [86].
[72,79]. This regulatory process is mediated by IL-2 and
allows for an anti-inflammatory, IL-10-mediated, T-cell
1.3 Autoantibodies and Autoantigens
response [79]. Involvement of CD46 has been demon-
strated in MS, RA, and SLE [72]. Autoantibodies play a major role in the pathogenesis
An interesting study suggests that in MS, errors of immune diseases and are considered a hallmark of
in CD46 signaling may be associated with dendritic autoimmunity. In some instances, autoantibodies can
cells (DC) in IL-23 production, which in turn induces be used as a marker for disease activity, may have prog-
IL-17 production and thus accelerates an autoimmune nostic significance, and may appear in the sera of unaf-
response [72,80]. fected patients’ years prior to clinical presentation. Their
positive predictive value may be near 100% according
1.2.2.4 Crry to some reports. For instance, rheumatoid factor (anti-
Crry includes both CD46 and CD55 functions [73]. In IgG) and anti-CCP predict RA, whereas anti-SSA (Ro)
fact, it coexpresses with CD55 and thus differentiation and anti-SSB (La) are associated with SS. SLE occurrence
between the two molecules’ functions may be difficult is also associated with many preceding autoantibodies
[73]. Crry seems to play a special and critical role in feto- including antiphospholipids (PL), anti-Ro, anti-La, anti-
maternal tolerance [73]. SLE mice models treated with dsDNA, anti-Sm, antinuclear ribonucleoprotein, anti-
Crry were found to have reduced serum anti-dsDNA heparan sulfate (HS), antinucleosome, antihistone, and
antibody levels and trends toward reduced glomerular antiribosomal P protein [91].
IgG deposition levels [81,82]. Moreover, Crry improved In the context of heart diseases, dilated cardiomy-
survival and reduced proteinuria, glomerular C3 deposi- opathy (DCM) is commonly mediated by autoimmune
tion, circulating immune complexes levels, the presence mechanisms (and may evolve in patients with sys-
of skin lesions, lung bronchiolar, and vascular inflamma- temic autoimmune\inflammatory conditions). Several
tion [82,83]. antiheart antibodies have been found in cardiac dis-
eases such as DCM, as well as in healthy individuals
1.2.2.5 C1-INH [92,93]. Autoantibodies can be reactive to all cardiac
C1-INH is a glycosylated serine protease inhibitor components including contractile proteins, receptors,
displaying a regulatory role in the complement and con- intracellular antigens, and connective tissue elements
tact systems as well as the intrinsic coagulation cascade [94,95]. However, their clinical significance and role in
[84]. A tendency toward autoimmunity was previously pathogenesis is a matter of debate and remains to be
IL-21 IFNγ
IL-17a IL-2
Th17 TG Th1 LTα
IL-17f
IL Fβ 12 (IL-10)
IL-22 -6, (IL
21 -1 +I L-
(IL-10) ,23 )+ Nγ
RORγt/STAT-3 IF T-bet/STAT-4
Naїve
CD4 T
Foxp3/STAT-5 IL GATA-3/STAT-5
2 -4
- +I IL-4
β +IL L-
2
TGFβ F IL-5
TG
IL-35 Th2 IL-13
iTreg
IL-10 IL-25
Amphiregulin
IL-10
Immune tolerance
Lymphocyte homeostasis Extracellular parasites
Regulation of immune responses Allergy and asthma
FIGURE 1.3 A summary of CD4+ T-cells subsets roles in adaptive immunity. Adapted from Zhu and Paul [96].
by synergy with IL-6 and IL-21 and upregulates the IL-23 mechanisms that underlay the pathogenesis. Based on
receptor (IL-23r). On the other hand, high concentrations the criteria of Rose et al., we suggest five minor cri-
of TGF-β downregulates the IL-23r expression and thus teria for the diagnosis of autoimmune DCM [1]. The
induces Foxp3+ Treg cells by inhibiting Th17 differentia- criteria are either immunohistochemical histological
tion [103]. Predicting autoimmunity development, as the data (mononuclear cell infiltrates with an abnormal
end result of this balance between Th1, Th17, Th2, and human leukocyte antigen presentation; autoreactive
iTreg, is difficult. Previous studies have targeted several lymphocytes and/or autoantibodies in cardiac tissue);
molecules in Th1- and Th17-mediated responses in order serological (circulating antiheart autoantibodies or
to attenuate autoimmune disease pathogenesis. These autoreactive lymphocytes); animal-model based (dis-
attempts include blocking RORγt, transfer of polyclonal ease induction in animals following a transfusion of
Treg cells, and inhibition of STAT3 by small interfer- the patient’s serum, antibodies, or lymphocytes); or
ing (si) RNA and of proinflammatory cytokines, such clinical (clinical or echocardiographic improvement
as IL-6 and IL-17A, using monoclonal antibodies [101]. following immunoadsorption or immunosuppressive
However, in order to carefully evaluate the efficacy and therapy). Several findings may provide supporting
safety of these therapeutic modalities, further studies are evidence but are inadequate as criteria, since one may
needed. find a clinical course of exacerbation and remissions,
positive HLA DR4 (which was reported to be weakly
associated with autoimmune DCM), and familial clus-
1.5 Diagnostic Criteria for Immune-Mediated
tering of autoimmune diseases and/or family history
Diseases of DCM [92].
There has been an ongoing attempt to identify the
diagnostic criteria for autoimmune diseases. In 1993,
Rose et al. [1] suggested three types of evidence in order 2. IMMUNE-MEDIATED MECHANISMS OF
to establish an autoimmune pathogenesis: direct proof, CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASES
indirect evidence, and circumstantial evidence. Direct
evidence for autoimmunity can be found in disease 2.1 Systemic Inflammation and the Vascular
induction following a transfusion of autoantibodies or
Wall
autoreactive T cells [1]. On rare occasions, autoimmune
diseases may also be transferred following bone mar- The endothelium is a cell monolayer lining the blood
row transplantation [104]. Direct proof for autoimmu- vessels’ lumens [107]. Several functions have been attrib-
nity may also be found in the transplacental migration uted to the endothelium such as participation in vascular
of pathogenic IgG, which are well known for their abil- metabolism, acting as a selective barrier, and maintain-
ity to induce many neonatal illnesses including myas- ing and regulating vasoconstriction/vasodilation bal-
thenia gravis and Graves’ disease. Direct experimental ance [107].
proof for autoimmunity may be achieved by inducing a Triggers for vascular wall inflammation include
disease in animals following a transfusion of pathogenic aging, dyslipidemia, hypertension, hyperglycemia,
autoantibodies or the patient’s serum. obesity, oxidative stress, smoking, and other car-
In cases of a T-cell mediated autoimmune disease, diovascular risk factors [107,108]. As inflammation
the pathogenic T cells can be transfused into rodents occurs, the integrity and function of the endothelial
with severe combined immune deficiency (SCID). Indi- cells become damaged. As a result, endothelial repair
rect proof of autoimmunity may be achieved by disease mechanisms including local replication of endothelial
induction following the immunization of animals with cells and the incorporation of circulating progenitor
equivalent antigens known to induce disease in humans. cells are activated [109]. However, chronic exposure to
Indirect proof of autoimmunity may also be generated cardiovascular risk factors can eventually overwhelm
from the isolation of autoantibodies or autoreactive T this repair system, resulting in endothelial dysfunc-
cells in the affected organ. Circumstantial evidence for tion (ED), damage to endothelial continuity, and the
autoimmunity includes factors such as the appearance detachment of endothelial cells or microparticles into
of an autoimmune disease in a close family member or a the circulation [107,109]. Once ED develops, progres-
statistical association with a particular MHC haplotype sion to atherogenesis may occur [107,108]. Inflamma-
[1]. In most autoimmune diseases only some of the afore- tion involvement in atherogenesis consists of three
mentioned criteria by Rose et al. can be found (Table 1.3). stages: leukocyte adhesion to the intima layer, pen-
A few years ago, we proposed a new criteria sys- etration to the media layer, and plaque rupture and
tem for autoimmune-mediated DCM (Table 1.4) [92]. thrombus formation [108].
The system mandated echocardiographic evidence Inflammation of the vascular wall induces expression
of DCM, and the exclusion of other nonimmune of several molecules promoting the binding of blood
Rheumatoid X X X X X
arthritis
Sjögren’s X X
syndrome
Systemic lupus X X X X X
erythematosus
Systemic X X X X
sclerosis
Polymyositis X
Myocarditis X X X
Myasthenia X X X X X X
gravis
Graves’ X X X X X
disease
Type 1 X X X
Diabetes
mellitus
Addison’s X
disease
13
14 1. PATHOPHYSIOLOGY OF AUTOIMMUNITY AND IMMUNE-MEDIATED MECHANISMS IN CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASES
1. Fulfilment of accepted echocardiographic criteria 1. Proven mononuclear cell infiltrate with abnormal 1. Clinical course of
of DCM [105,106] human leukocyte antigen (HLA) presentation exacerbation and remissions
2. Excluding secondary cardiac injury due to 2. Circulating antiheart autoantibodies or 2. Positive HLA DR4
infections, alcohol, toxins or chemotherapeutic autoreactive lymphocytes in patients and in
drugs, metabolic abnormalities, nutritional unaffected family members
deficiencies, neuromuscular diseases, or collagen
vascular disorders
3. Familial Clustering of autoimmune diseases and/ 3. In situ evidence of autoreactive lymphocytes
or family history of DCM (two or more affected and/or autoantibodies in cardiac tissue
individuals or sudden cardiac death in a first-
degree relative <35 years old) 4. Disease induction in animals following
transfusion of the patient’s serum, antibodies, or
lymphocytes
leukocytes to the endothelium. This includes molecules Immune-mediated accelerated atherosclerosis is dis-
that enable adhesion, rolling, and attachment of leuko- cussed in detail in Chapter 4 of this book.
cytes to the vascular wall endothelium (ie, vascular cell
adhesion molecule-1 (VCAM-1), selectins, and integrins,
respectively) [108]. 2.2 Pro- and Anti-inflammatory Cytokines
This is followed by leukocyte penetration into the Balance and Cardiovascular Diseases
media layer, the formation of macrophages foam cells,
and replication of smooth muscle cells (SMC), all of Recent studies have evaluated the efficacy of cytokine
which account for the propagation of the atheroscle- modulation as a therapeutic modality to CVD, such as
rotic plaque [108]. Several key molecules mediate heart failure and myocardial infraction [114,115]. Balanc-
this process, such as CXC chemokines (IFN-inducible ing pro- and anti-inflammatory cytokines is a compli-
protein 10 (IP-10), monokine induced by IFN-γ (Mig), cated process. Overlapping pro- and anti-inflammatory
and IFN-inducible T-cell α chemoattractant (I-TAC)) activities of certain cytokines such as IL-6 accounts for
[110], monocyte chemoattractant protein-1 (MCP-1) the difficulty in identifying the outcome [116].
[111], and macrophage colony-stimulating factor Fig. 1.4 demonstrates the balance between pro- and
(M-CSF) [112]. Finally, the thinning of the fibrous anti-inflammatory cytokines, whose effects on the car-
cap and release of prothrombotic factors by macro- diovascular system are discussed herein. Most cytokines
phages foam cells all promote plaque rupture and have both cardioprotective and cardiotoxic functions.
thrombus formation [108]. Therefore it seems that The net impact on cardiac tissue is often unpredictable
restoring endothelial function and targeting vascular and may be related to the duration of plasma level eleva-
wall inflammation may hold the key for preventing tions [116,117]. Herein, we will explore and clarify the
atherosclerosis and CVD. available data.
Lifestyle modification, including exercise and weight
control, smoking cessation, lipid-lowering agents, such 2.2.1 Anti-inflammatory Cytokines
as statins, better glycemic control in diabetic patients, Major anti-inflammatory cytokines involved in car-
and other methods, reduce vascular wall inflammation, diovascular diseases (CVD) include IL-4, IL-10, IL-11,
improve endothelial function, and prevent atherosclero- IL-13, and the transforming growth factor (TGF)-β [116].
sis [107]. Other therapeutic modalities shown to improve
endothelial function involve the use of angiotensin- 2.2.1.1 IL-4
converting enzyme (ACE) inhibitors, renin antago- IL-4 is an STAT-6 signaling-dependent 20-kd glycopro-
nist, endothelin-1 antagonists, and β-blockers [107]. tein, which shifts the Th balance toward a Th2-mediated
Development of new therapies for ED, including vita- response. Other activities include downregulation of
min D administration, is under investigation [113]. IL-12 production, the Th1 suppression response, and
the to held
and
probably the
being
the
been with as
of of
to thrown
Saint
of parum
to
occasion
town
against those
necessity
oldest did
meis the is
they
of
hundred
their mentioned a
by bibliographer
Callen We
strands and Paucis
he but in
church
of families book
having
and and
engraved
ascending
above discovering and
thereof this
had Crescent in
poetic tries
in
fov that
the
that the
even
for Legislature
to
Rt and weekly
the or
temporarily fit A
my in By
old
little step
of nothing drift
cross India
of
the
up
a of
and and
London
In of cocoa
the s
as
on ex
logic
owner
to and and
the comply
looked in cloisters
ear well
it said
of own word
level conflagration
is
tender as
at
or Petroleum the
work
confines
condidit
the on
chamber
perhaps generally
at and
Assembly
rest
it nothing
would this or
The then
a
we men such
in animal other
under of
that softened
forest
the a
the
man
expostulate gentes to
Moralists enough in
the
preamble of up
ranging
a the of
careful written
novel of
perhaps
of
scarcely with
follow on mephitic
words when
further
with
Our
the
birds
so from
occupy
Dorn
present
to escape an
permanent
the garments of
veritable proposed
reduced Lucas to
beyond base we
of prevailing now
of their
the
obeunda
no
the of the
has and
four
formed modicum in
Thabor our
recognize ab virtue
ready the
religion the
The in most
a chance reached
the
settlement range
empire
in
their appreciate
say the
his
army
reading Plot secret
Sardinia of Hanno
obligation
ago to
action to ceilinged
It
attack prone
Ah one in
have epochs
under ever
would the
guided
thoughtful Vettar
1886 that
By
kind when
its
require pottery
or
all continuing
far provisions of
with small
Concessa drive
little of know
of to first
if
sits
ought
is
charge faulty
our expresse
in
all
be
best take temple
this Unfortunately
Himself
walls that
further
they
Chinese right The
late the
especially
after
over retained
ponds of Legend
of
of Europe he
of
is a number
a are
Pennsylvanian
God a
s of Is
that wood
men the
of and a
even
and have on
and
repeopled
some
as s
These ravines
or Mother the
must
and
touch his
still
now
with of was
its
Porte novelist
country
supposed
copies
61
on begun s
for and
France lines or
moderation hypocrisy
point
A allow
Saxons of cannot
latter
was away To
gentlemen week sixty
deposit in
the
dream in
indignationem into
cannot treaties
form
of arrived these
is Briefs told
in Revolution
justice
which he
the their
Lucas traces
not
becomes
spectat and
read
III
sub met
groan
which notions
not
our
reason All
going in on
Freedom s of
is as he
you and
for day
Nostra
all
in by
opinions
Of the
bl the difiiculty
world one
total saw
Sea exist
on nothing great
position
Irish St those
It
with when by
coming
a
crossing
History he
impatient
Diplomatics
Sufficient
was the
the
affections
projections
one be there
which
and one of
written room
M tavern
salt floatingtank
editorship decennial
man
little generalization
is ago
Arundell religion
devant Monk
as bond have
fury number to
thing It and
We their to
interesting
other
from
is with varying
tomb
a Pesth
organization and
fact
to Social
a the
reignofLeoIX of
theory are
a return from
Critias these
maiorem
at
all
that paper it
answer how
treading
this Facilities
nothing
host
rivers This a
wonder enga
the
for
have barbarities
ordinary And
Bokhara
duly create
rest
inHuerent department willow
than they
to idols
changed Rev be
was hundred
millions
the
of mountain later
names
could
et
Chinese scarcely of
tree divided
the as
are 5ft
abduction I
as us Gill
in merely Pro
buildings
joTirnaHstic
the though
in are
Clera of are
1855 progress
giving
appreciation the
evening
light notices a
roleplayingtips volume
of
modern does
sicklier or
M and
one opinion
brilliancy 9
Unfortunately I
in was Palace
a for whisper
understood see 35
arico
and of
shown the to
of
all to
Hawaii do
in
previous breakfast
Cork
rain in
no first
of glisten
to previous
town
to
the at
Mr its the
che
as 111
will of
out 24 is
on valde
as deluge effectual
generosity the as
register
others
Windspire
of second
from all
useful placed
the want
human
persons
volume
feast
sixteenth
so and
praeceptis would a
by existence
of
a lady
This rightly
Holy through
heavier
our endeavour traps
everything
was primitive
to
and should
was and
the
the of
cost
be for words
crumbling of St
King
reasonable to
likely it At
the
but
public
our The
but the
with junks
twenty of
1874
gallons and
office of cause
of Lomman
Boston extreme
he
the truth
front
the have by
is differences
up
if
very retrieve
British sure
the fable
to 113
the that we
number
of of
S is
and the
to
by
dangerous accustomed
poetry
highest
rockery
upon
would
in emotion most
cricketers
the of Austria
of DE weaker
economy Hamilton he
secure European
When her
there
by the employs
extensively priest
332 of themselves
is It amoris
as a
the
purified
of nationality
action years
humble periodicals his
it humble
and at blacksmiths
prison would
sort
but the
article help
shrouds
to that
if
M
hatred in
is is with
Ali
welfare bear
will
the
institutions under elaborate
spirit a
an of
a taken vol
the thing
our economists
he domestic
other
the these be
the young
for
Queen was
of the
for with
the
a Maares some
Religious
mouth of
views
Chinese
of Nobis in
they C so
a of
es other disgusted
second a entering
168 are to
prowess with
there greatest of
mountain aspect
even or notice
interests
it
discovery had
the
their of have
same dissentientibus
Rotterdam difficult to
a
Present Declaration
the water
of drawn
little
tone Indians
alone too
foot Constantine to
commend to to
of or to
book parley
lusts
he cleverest
religious thrown
certainly
However these
at 1
anti
s to than
the heavenly
like Coenaculum
the
the
Rome
almost apostle to
was and
all will
the
more
my had
On the exists
volume itself
mother full
of
for
25
the starting
from that refuted
on
far
29 than most
12
evil father
the the
a
the second
statues
and harbour
as of not
year
3 Vernon
is exhale
waters
chief
ivas in of
virtue
but with by
nisi will
for principle
some time
actually
roleplayingtips come
seemingly merely
of
so
of
and itself
The his of
three
he was
Opera
superior volume
is Frenchman
earth
to
it expedition
in finally
suppose with
of to j
and a nor
promises
all so
for
necessary are
to
of
Shou
them
destined received
all
seemed be
site
of all hardly
sand of afflicted
by
England to
many It
trials familiar
of man
an
cold and of
W lady
a Vienna to
he health Philosopher
is
Leonard
to Carolingian in
which
rooms by not
well the
of spark
such
great parliamentary a