0% found this document useful (0 votes)
31 views59 pages

Iran Isreal War

Uploaded by

kashmalanawaz221
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
31 views59 pages

Iran Isreal War

Uploaded by

kashmalanawaz221
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 59

Iran-Israel War 2025: Dynamics,

Implications & Future


Scenarios
Subject: Current Affairs-CSS-PMS
By: Imran Zahoor
Ph. D in IR
[email protected]
Contact:0321-4800309
Lecture Outline
Mr. Imran Zahoor Ph. D in IR 0321-4800309
 Iran-Israel War: An Overview

 Historical Foundations of the Iran-Israel


Relationship

 Iran Issues and Problems with Israel

 Israel Issues and Problems with Iran

 International Responses

 Current Dynamics and Military Capabilities

 Regional and Global Effects

 Pathways to De-escalation and Conflict


Resolution
Iran-Israel War:
An Overview
c
Iran-Israel War: An Overview
Mr. Imran Zahoor Ph. D in IR 0321-4800309

 June 12: Israel initiates “Operation Rising


Lion,” targeting Iran’s nuclear & military
sites in Tehran, Natanz, Isfahan, Bushehr,
Qom, and missile production sites.

 Problem rooted in decades of hostility,


ideology, and strategic opposition.

 Not a conventional war—includes cyber,


proxy, and intelligence warfare.

 Conflict intensified by nuclear concerns,


regional alliances, and external
interventions.
Iran-Israel War: An Overview

 Israel conducts preemptive strikes,


cyber operations, and intelligence-
based targeting missions.

 Major global powers react


diplomatically, economically, and
militarily to conflict.

 Rising civilian casualties and


displacement worsen humanitarian
crises region-wide.

 Understanding this conflict is critical for


peace and stability prospects.
Historical Foundations of the
Iran-Israel Relationship
Historical Foundations of Iran-Israel Relationship

1-From Allies to Adversaries (Pre-


1979)
 1948: Israel is established.
 1949: Iran becomes the second Muslim-
majority country (after Turkey) to recognize
Israel under Raza Shah Pahlavi.
 1957 onwards: Mossad (Israel) and SAVAK
(Iran’s intelligence agency) establish covert
ties.
 1950s-1970s: Close economic, intelligence, and
military cooperation between Iran and Israel.
o Both oppose Arab nationalism led by
Egypt’s Gamal Abdel Nasser.
o Iran aids Israel through oil exports and
intelligence sharing.
Historical Foundations of Iran-Israel Relationship
Mr. Imran Zahoor Ph. D in IR 0321-4800309

 1960s-70s: Implementation of Israel's


“Periphery Doctrine”—forming alliances
with non-Arab states (Iran, Turkey,
Ethiopia) to counter Arab hostility.

2-Iranian Revolution and the Paradigm


Shift
 1979:
o Islamic Revolution overthrows the Shah.
o Ayatollah Khomeini established the
Islamic Republic with anti-Western and
anti-Israel ideology.
o Iran stopped diplomatic and commercial
ties with Israel.
Historical Foundations of Iran-Israel Relationship
Mr. Imran Zahoor Ph. D in IR 0321-4800309

3-Emergence of Proxy Warfare


(1980s–Early 2000s)
 1982:
o Hezbollah founded in Lebanon with
Iranian IRGC support following Israel’s
invasion of Lebanon.
 1990s:
o Iran supports Palestinian Islamic Jihad
(PIJ) and Hamas with funding and
training.
 1992-1994: Iran allegedly linked to terror
attacks on Israeli/Jewish targets in
Argentina (Israeli Embassy and AMIA
Jewish Center bombings).
Historical Foundations of Iran-Israel Relationship
Mr. Imran Zahoor Ph. D in IR 0321-4800309

 1990s–2000s: Israel reportedly launched


covert operations targeting Iranian arms
transfers and Hezbollah infrastructure.
 2006:
 Israel-Hezbollah War—Iran provided
weapons and logistics to Hezbollah.
Historical Foundations of Iran-Israel Relationship
Mr. Imran Zahoor Ph. D in IR 0321-4800309

4-Escalation Points of Conflict

• 2002: Exile group NCRI reveals secret


Iranian nuclear sites in Natanz and Arak.
• 2006–2010:
• UN and international community
impose sanctions over Iran’s nuclear
ambitions.
• 2010–2012:
• Series of assassinations of Iranian
nuclear scientists, widely attributed to
Israel.

• 2015: Iran signs JCPOA (nuclear deal)


with P5+1; Israel vocally opposes.
Historical Foundations of Iran-Israel Relationship
Mr. Imran Zahoor Ph. D in IR 0321-4800309
• 2018:
• U.S. withdraws from JCPOA under
Trump, backed by Israel.
• Israel reveals alleged “Iranian nuclear
archive” from a Mossad raid.
• 2022–2024:
• IAEA reports Iranian non-compliance
with NPT.
• Enrichment reaches near-weapons
grade; Israel escalates warnings of
military action.
• 2014–present:
• Iran supports Houthi rebels in Yemen;
Houthis claim attacks on Israel post-
2023 Gaza war.
Historical Foundations of Iran-Israel Relationship
Mr. Imran Zahoor Ph. D in IR 0321-4800309

• 2021: Israeli-owned ship attacks in Gulf


of Oman; attributed to Iran.

• 2023–2024:
• Escalation in Israel-Gaza war
(October 2023) triggered broader
proxy responses from Iran-backed
groups across the region.
Iran Issues and Problems
with Israel
Iran Issues and Problems with Israel
Mr. Imran Zahoor Ph. D in IR 0321-4800309

Ideological Opposition

• Since the 1979 Islamic Revolution, Iran has


adopted a revolutionary Islamist doctrine
that does not recognize Israel's right to
exist.

• Iran refers to Israel as the “Zionist regime”


and views it as an illegitimate occupier of
Muslim lands, especially Jerusalem.
Iran Issues and Problems with Israel
Mr. Imran Zahoor Ph. D in IR 0321-4800309

Support for the Palestinian Cause

• Iran sees itself as a defender of oppressed


Muslims and strongly supports Palestinian
resistance groups, especially:
• Hamas in Gaza
• Islamic Jihad
• Hizballah
• Rejects peace deals e.g., Oslo Accords as
betrayals of Palestinian rights.
Iran Issues and Problems with Israel
Mr. Imran Zahoor Ph. D in IR 0321-4800309

Opposition to Israeli Regional


Influence

• Iran views Israel’s deepening ties with Gulf


Arab states, Egypt, and Jordan as part of a
U.S.-led axis to contain Iranian power.

• It accuses Israel of trying to become a


dominant regional hegemon.
Iran Issues and Problems with Israel

Security Concerns over Israeli Covert


Actions
 Iran blames Israel of:
o Assassinating nuclear scientists
o Cyberattacks
o Sabotaging IRGC and missile development
 Sees Israel as a covert aggressor using non-
conventional means.
Nuclear Hypocrisy
 Iran criticizes Israel's undeclared nuclear
arsenal while Israel pushes for sanctions
against Iran’s peaceful nuclear program.
Iran Issues and Problems with Israel
Mr. Imran Zahoor Ph. D in IR 0321-4800309

Oppose Normalization of Arab States


with Israel
• Iran views Israel’s normalization of ties with
Gulf and Arab states (e.g., UAE, Bahrain) as
a strategic encirclement.

• Tehran sees these agreements as a betrayal


of the Palestinian cause and a Western-led
plot to isolate Iran regionally.

• This led Iran to increase proxy activities and


cyber operations against Israel.
Israel Issues and
Problems with Iran
Israel Issues and Problems with Iran
Mr. Imran Zahoor Ph. D in IR 0321-4800309

Existential Threat Rhetoric


 Iranian leaders (e.g., former President
Ahmadinejad) have publicly called for the
elimination of the Israeli state, heightening
Israeli fears of annihilation.
 Iran's Quds Force actively funds and trains
anti-Israel militias.

Nuclear Weapons Program


 Israel sees Iran’s uranium enrichment and
missile program as a direct existential
threat.
 It has vowed to prevent Iran from acquiring
nuclear weapons—“by any means
necessary,” including military strikes.
Israel Issues and Problems with Iran

Terror Network & Proxy Encirclement


 Iran supports and arms:
 Hezbollah in Lebanon (over 150,000 rockets)
 Hamas/Islamic Jihad in Gaza
 Syrian regime, creating a land corridor to
Israel’s northern border
 Houthis in Yemen (targeting Gulf states friendly
to Israel)
 Israel sees this as a strategy of proxy
encirclement and attrition warfare.

Destabilization of the Region


 Iran’s involvement in Syria, Iraq, Yemen, and
Lebanon is seen as an effort to create a Shi’a
axis of influence from Tehran to the
Mediterranean.
 Israel views this as both ideological
expansionism and military encroachment.
Israel Issues and Problems with Iran
Mr. Imran Zahoor Ph. D in IR 0321-4800309

Use of Syria as a Forward Military Base


 Iran’s entrenchment in Syria, including IRGC
bases, drone facilities, and missile depots
near the Golan Heights, is seen by Israel as a
red line.
 Israel has conducted hundreds of airstrikes
in Syria targeting Iranian and Hezbollah
assets.
Violation of International Norms
 Israel argues Iran regularly violates UN
resolutions, especially concerning:
 Missile tests
 Enrichment thresholds
 Use of proxies against civilian
populations
Israel Issues and Problems with Iran
Mr. Imran Zahoor Ph. D in IR 0321-4800309
Use of Syria as a Forward
Military Base
 Iran’s entrenchment in Syria, including
IRGC bases, drone facilities, and missile
depots near the Golan Heights, is seen by
Israel as a red line.

 Israel has conducted hundreds of airstrikes


in Syria targeting Iranian and Hezbollah
assets, aiming to prevent the creation of a
northern front.

 This ongoing shadow war threatens to


escalate into full-scale conflict if Iranian
assets strike Israeli territory directly from
Syria
International Responses
International Responses
Mr. Imran Zahoor Ph. D in IR 0321-4800309
United States
 Strong support for Israel, but potential
hesitation for direct military involvement.
 U.S. intelligence agencies confirm Israeli
strikes have delayed Iran’s nuclear breakout
capability by 2–3 years.
 USS Nimitz Carrier Strike Group deployed to
the Persian Gulf; additional surveillance and
electronic warfare aircraft repositioned in
Bahrain and Qatar.
 The U.S. warns Iran against targeting U.S.
bases or regional allies.
 Back-channel communications with Qatar
and Oman to reach Iranian officials.
International Responses

European Powers (UK, France, Germany)


 Diplomatic Messaging:
o Immediate calls for ceasefire and de-
escalation
o Emphasis on diplomatic resolution and re-
engagement with nonproliferation
frameworks.
 Security & Strategic Concerns:
o Anxiety over regional instability, oil price
shocks, and refugee movements.
o Public concern over radiation hazards from
damaged Iranian nuclear infrastructure.
 Civilian Protection:
o Evacuation orders issued for EU nationals in
Tehran, Isfahan, and Gulf states.
International Responses
Russia and China
• Russia:
• Calls for mutual restraint and
preservation of Iranian sovereignty.
• Criticizes Israeli strikes as “unilateral
aggression,” but stops short of direct
condemnation in the Security Council.
• Offers mediation
• China:
• Protecting oil supply lines from the
Persian Gulf.
• Warns against disruption" of shipping
lanes in Strait of Hormuz.
• Aligns with Russia at the UN Security
Council in opposing expanded sanctions
or Israeli military action.
International Responses
Mr. Imran Zahoor Ph. D in IR 0321-4800309
United Nations & IAEA
 United Nations:
o Secretary-General issues an urgent appeal
for de-escalation and emphasizes
international humanitarian law obligations.
o UN Security Council meets in emergency
session; no consensus reached due to P5
divisions.
 International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA):
o Confirms “possible radiological
contamination” at Isfahan and Natanz
following Israeli strikes.
o Warns of severe risks to civilian populations
and long-term environmental damage.
o Urges all parties to respect the integrity of
nuclear sites and allow inspections
International Responses
Mr. Imran Zahoor Ph. D in IR 0321-4800309
Saudi Arabia
• Condemn Isreal attack Iran
• Emphasize the need to avoid regional
escalation.
• Diplomatic Role:
• Quietly supports Western diplomatic
efforts; may be involved in back-
channel talks with Iran via Oman.
• Internal Concerns:
• Mobilizes air defenses in eastern
provinces and along Gulf coast.
• Economic pressure due to rising oil
prices and stock market volatility.
International Responses
Mr. Imran Zahoor Ph. D in IR 0321-4800309
Qatar
• Mediation Efforts:
• Acts as a neutral intermediary,
facilitating indirect communication
between the U.S. and Iran.
• Hosts emergency sessions of Gulf
Cooperation Council (GCC) members.

• Regional Concerns:
• Urges protection of civilian
infrastructure and warns against Israeli
strikes endangering regional stability.
• Offers humanitarian aid corridors,
possibly through Oman or Iraq.
Current Dynamics and Military
Capabilities
Current Dynamics and Military Capabilities
Mr. Imran Zahoor Ph. D in IR 0321-4800309

Iran’s Military Doctrine and Assets


• Ballistic missiles & drone swarms:
• Key Arsenal: 3,000+ ballistic missiles
(incl. 600+ Kheibar Shekan: 1,450km
range, maneuverable re-entry
vehicles).
• Drone Dominance: Shahed-136
loitering munitions (2,500km range);
used in 80% of June 2025 attacks.
Asymmetric warfare via proxies:
• Proxy Network: Hezbollah (150,000
rockets), Houthis, Hamas (tunnel
warfare).
Current Dynamics and Military Capabilities
Mr. Imran Zahoor Ph. D in IR 0321-4800309

• IRGC-Quds Force Command:


• Directs proxy operations (e.g., Kataib
Hezbollah strikes on U.S. bases in Iraq).
• June 2025 losses: 5 senior IRGC
commanders killed in Israeli decapitation
strikes.
Current Dynamics and Military Capabilities
Mr. Imran Zahoor Ph. D in IR 0321-4800309

Israel’s Military Doctrine and Assets


• Qualitative Military Edge (QME):
• Air Superiority: 36 F-35I Adir stealth
fighters.
• Missile Defense: Iron Dome (90%
intercept rate vs. rockets); David’s Sling
(used against Iranian mid-range
missiles).
• Pre-emptive strike doctrine:
• Operation Rising Lion
• Deterrence Calculus
Current Dynamics and Military Capabilities
Mr. Imran Zahoor Ph. D in IR 0321-4800309

Intelligence & Covert Operations:


• Mossad Cyber Ops: Disabled 40% of
Iranian air defenses pre-strike.
• Sabotage Campaigns: 7 nuclear
scientists eliminated since 2023.

The "Shadow War" to Overt Conflict


• Covert to Overt: April 2024 Damascus
consulate strike → Iran’s first direct
missile barrage on Israel.
• Tipping Point: Iran’s 90% uranium
enrichment (June 2025 IAEA report).
Current Dynamics and Military Capabilities
Mr. Imran Zahoor Ph. D in IR 0321-4800309

Israel's Military Advantages:

 Air superiority and advanced air force.

 Sophisticated missile defense systems (Iron


Dome, Arrow 2/3, David's Sling).

 Precision strike capabilities.

 Intelligence gathering and covert operations.

 US military support (THAAD batteries, Aegis


vessels, intelligence sharing).
Current Dynamics and Military Capabilities
Iran's Military Advantages
 Vast Missile/Drone Arsenal: Quantity over
quality, aiming to overwhelm defenses.

 Proxy Network: Enables multi-front


asymmetric warfare via groups like
Hezbollah.

 Hardened Underground Facilities: Deeply


buried assets resist airstrikes.

 Strong Cyber Capabilities: Potential to


disrupt Israeli infrastructure.

 Large Manpower: Significant reserve forces


(Basij) and regional recruits.
Regional and Global
Effects
Regional and Global Effects
Mr. Imran Zahoor Ph. D in IR 0321-4800309
1-Civilian Casualties and
Displacement:
 Iran: At least 657 killed and 2,000+
wounded, with strikes damaging
infrastructure in Tehran, Isfahan, and
Qom .

 Israel: 24 civilians killed, 685+ injured, and


widespread destruction in Haifa,
Beersheba, and Tel Aviv.
 A single Iranian missile strike in Haifa on
June 20 injured 33 people.
 Displacement: Over 200,000
Israelis displaced due to missile threats.
Regional and Global Effects
Mr. Imran Zahoor Ph. D in IR 0321-4800309

2-Nuclear Safety Risks

 IAEA confirmed radioactive contamination


risks at Iran’s Natanz and Arak facilities
after Israeli strikes.

 Director Rafael Grossi warned that a direct


hit on the Bushehr nuclear plant could
cause catastrophic radiation releases,

 Iran relocated enriched uranium to hidden


sites to evade destruction, complicating
disarmament efforts.
Regional and Global Effects
Mr. Imran Zahoor Ph. D in IR 0321-4800309

3-Global Economic and Trade


Disruptions
 Energy Markets:
o Oil prices surged 15%+ amid fears of
Strait of Hormuz closures. China
pressured Iran to de-escalate to avoid
sustained high prices.
 Supply Chain Fractures:
o Afghanistan sought Russian food
imports as Iran trade halted. Shipping
routes in the Mediterranean and Red
Sea disrupted.
Regional and Global Effects
4-Diplomatic and Social Fracturing
 Pro-Iran rallies erupted in Baghdad, Beirut,
and Tehran.

 Security Council meeting (June 20) saw


mutual accusations but no resolution. Russia
accused Israel of "blatant disregard" for
diplomacy.

 Arab States: Jordan stopped Iranian missiles;


Qatar warned Israel against targeting
economic sites.

 Domestic Pressures: 83% of Jewish Israelis


backed strikes, while Arab citizens opposed
them.
Regional and Global Effects
Mr. Imran Zahoor Ph. D in IR 0321-4800309

5-Proxy Escalation in Middle East

• Hezbollah, Houthis launched new attacks

• Iraq militias threatened US forces

• Red Sea shipping lanes threatened

• Syria clashes intensified within days

• Israel–Lebanon front heats up again


Regional and Global Effects
Mr. Imran Zahoor Ph. D in IR 0321-4800309

6- Destabilized Iranian Economy

• GDP down ~4% (Q2 2025)

• Inflation passed 50% after strikes

• Rial collapsed on black market

• Food prices rose 35% overnight

• Poverty affects ~50% population now


Regional and Global Effects
Mr. Imran Zahoor Ph. D in IR 0321-4800309

7-Diplomatic Pressure on USA

• Pentagon deployed destroyers, air units

• Congress debates war powers resolution

• Allies push for de-escalation steps

• China, Russia condemn Israeli strikes

• US credibility now under scrutiny


Regional and Global Effects
Mr. Imran Zahoor Ph. D in IR 0321-4800309

8-Middle East Power Dynamics


Shifting

• Israel delayed Iran’s program 3 years

• Gulf states eye nuclear options

• Turkey, Qatar call for diplomacy

• China proposes regional security plan

• Iran's deterrence now seriously weakened


Pathways to De-escalation
and Conflict Resolution
Pathways to De-escalation and Conflict Resolution
Mr. Imran Zahoor Ph. D in IR 0321-4800309

1. Backchannel Diplomacy

 Neutral state mediators maintain


confidential communications
 Use trusted intermediaries outside political
command structure
 Avoid publicity to build trust and flexibility
 Develop draft proposals without immediate
binding terms
 Maintain contact during active conflict, not
post-war
Pathways to De-escalation and Conflict Resolution
Mr. Imran Zahoor Ph. D in IR 0321-4800309

2. Third-Party Mediation

 Invite neutral powers to host formal talks


 Empower international diplomats trusted
by both countries
 Propose step-by-step agreements over
maximum outcomes
 Include regional stakeholders with
influence on both sides
 Create binding de-escalation timetables
monitored externally
Pathways to De-escalation and Conflict Resolution
Mr. Imran Zahoor Ph. D in IR 0321-4800309

3. Regional Security Talks


 Initiate multilateral conference with key
regional players
 Build shared threat perception to foster
cooperation
 Encourage coordinated de-escalation
efforts across all fronts
 Address nuclear security issues and mutual
inspections
 Promote Arab-Israeli cooperation to
counter Iranian fears
Pathways to De-escalation and Conflict Resolution
Mr. Imran Zahoor Ph. D in IR 0321-4800309

4. UN Security Council Resolution

 Pass binding resolution enforcing


immediate ceasefire
 Authorize peacekeepers or observers in
border zones
 Ban offensive weapons transfers to
conflict regions
 Empower UN envoy to coordinate de-
escalation logistics
 Use Chapter VII authority for enforcement
legitimacy
Pathways to De-escalation and Conflict Resolution
Mr. Imran Zahoor Ph. D in IR 0321-4800309

5. Mutual De-escalation Measures

 End cyber and drone warfare operations


immediately
 Announce mutual restraint on attacks near
civilians
 Avoid targeting key infrastructure
 Set synchronized deadlines for future
military stand-downs
Pathways to De-escalation and Conflict Resolution
Mr. Imran Zahoor Ph. D in IR 0321-4800309

6. Track II Diplomacy (Unofficial)


 Engage retired officials in unofficial peace
dialogues
 Host joint workshops through neutral think
tanks
 Launch youth exchanges across border
digital platforms
 Promote shared narratives through non-
state media outlets
 Develop peace frameworks without
government commitments yet
Pathways to De-escalation and Conflict Resolution
Mr. Imran Zahoor Ph. D in IR 0321-4800309

7. Economic Leverage & Incentives

 Offer sanctions relief for clear peace


milestones
 Freeze military aid to encourage serious
negotiations
 Link oil access to cooperation on ceasefires
 Facilitate humanitarian banking channels
without political strings
Pathways to De-escalation and Conflict Resolution
Mr. Imran Zahoor Ph. D in IR 0321-4800309

8. Media and Narrative Control


 Launch peace-first campaigns on regional
media platforms
 Counter misinformation with transparent
fact-checking tools
 Promote civilian stories to humanize both
populations
 Showcase war costs over victory narratives
constantly
 Coordinate cross-border media pledges to
avoid escalation
Pathways to De-escalation and Conflict Resolution
Mr. Imran Zahoor Ph. D in IR 0321-4800309

9. Cyber Restraint Agreements

 Set red lines for digital retaliation


thresholds
 Use third-party verification for cyberattack
attributions
 Prioritize protection of health, water, and
grids
 Develop real-time communication for
cyber incident warnings
 Penalize rogue cyber actors within state
borders
Research Links
Mr. Imran Zahoor Ph. D in IR 0321-4800309

 https://www.nation.com.pk/21-Jun-2025/pakistan-urges-unsc-to-end-israel-iran-conflict
 https://visionias.in/current-affairs/upsc-daily-news-summary/article/2025-06-21/the-indian-
express/international-relations/expert-explains-understanding-pakistans-balancing-act-on-iran
 https://www.dawn.com/news/1918537/experts-warn-intensifying-iran-israel-conflict-could-
destabilise-broader-middle-east
 https://www.pakistantoday.com.pk/2025/06/21/trump-conveys-pakistans-concerns-over-iran-
israel-war-emphasizes-diplomacy/
 https://www.dawn.com/news/1917040
 https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2025/6/18/iran-israel-conflict-raises-alarm-in-pakistan-amid-
fears-over-own-security
 https://www.ispionline.it/en/publication/on-edge-the-israel-iran-war-holds-the-region-in-bated-
breath-211873
 https://foreignpolicy.com/2025/06/13/israel-iran-war-netanyahu-us-scenarios/
 https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2025/6/13/how-the-world-is-reacting-to-israel-attacks-on-iran-
nuclear-military-sites
 https://reliefweb.int/report/iran-islamic-republic/israeli-iranian-conflict-and-humanitarian-
considerations-june-20-2025
 https://www.mei.edu/publications/israel-iran-war-scenarios-days-and-years-ahead
 https://www.iiss.org/events/2025/062/israeliran-conflict-current-assessment-and-future-
scenarios/

You might also like