0% found this document useful (0 votes)
32 views163 pages

(Ebook) The Adam Smith Review: Volume I by Vivienne Brown ISBN 9780415278638, 0415278635 All Chapters Available

Study resource: (Ebook) The Adam Smith Review: Volume I by Vivienne Brown ISBN 9780415278638, 0415278635Get it instantly. Built for academic development with logical flow and educational clarity.

Uploaded by

yzbsyyt5822
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
32 views163 pages

(Ebook) The Adam Smith Review: Volume I by Vivienne Brown ISBN 9780415278638, 0415278635 All Chapters Available

Study resource: (Ebook) The Adam Smith Review: Volume I by Vivienne Brown ISBN 9780415278638, 0415278635Get it instantly. Built for academic development with logical flow and educational clarity.

Uploaded by

yzbsyyt5822
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 163

(Ebook) The Adam Smith Review: Volume I by Vivienne

Brown ISBN 9780415278638, 0415278635 Pdf Download

https://ebooknice.com/product/the-adam-smith-review-volume-i-1716422

★★★★★
4.8 out of 5.0 (19 reviews )

DOWNLOAD PDF

ebooknice.com
(Ebook) The Adam Smith Review: Volume I by Vivienne Brown
ISBN 9780415278638, 0415278635 Pdf Download

EBOOK

Available Formats

■ PDF eBook Study Guide Ebook

EXCLUSIVE 2025 EDUCATIONAL COLLECTION - LIMITED TIME

INSTANT DOWNLOAD VIEW LIBRARY


Here are some recommended products that we believe you will be
interested in. You can click the link to download.

(Ebook) Adam Smith Review Volume IV (The Adam Smith Review) by


Vivienne Brown ISBN 9780415454384, 0415454387

https://ebooknice.com/product/adam-smith-review-volume-iv-the-adam-
smith-review-2196040

(Ebook) Adam Smith Review Volume III (The Adam Smith Review) by
Vivienne Brown ISBN 9780203935293, 9780415448963, 0203935292,
0415448964

https://ebooknice.com/product/adam-smith-review-volume-iii-the-adam-
smith-review-1936882

(Ebook) The Adam Smith Review Volume 2: 02 by Vivienne Brown (editor)


ISBN 9780415394604, 0415394600

https://ebooknice.com/product/the-adam-smith-review-
volume-2-02-33360452

(Ebook) The Philosophy of Adam Smith: The Adam Smith Review, Volume 5:
Essays Commemorating the 250th Anniversary of The Theory of Moral
Sentiments by Vivienne Brown (editor), Samuel Fleischacker (editor)
ISBN 9780415562560, 0415562562
https://ebooknice.com/product/the-philosophy-of-adam-smith-the-adam-
smith-review-volume-5-essays-commemorating-the-250th-anniversary-of-
the-theory-of-moral-sentiments-49116054
(Ebook) The Adam Smith Review, Volume 13 by Fonna Forman ISBN
9781032417080, 1032417080

https://ebooknice.com/product/the-adam-smith-review-volume-13-49410484

(Ebook) The Adam Smith Review: Volume 9 by Fonna Forman (editor) ISBN
9781138652569, 1138652563

https://ebooknice.com/product/the-adam-smith-review-volume-9-34773690

(Ebook) The Adam Smith Review Volume 8 by Fonna Forman (editor) ISBN
9781138830608, 1138830607

https://ebooknice.com/product/the-adam-smith-review-volume-8-34484438

(Ebook) The Adam Smith Review Volume 7 by Fonna Forman (editor) ISBN
9780415810746, 0415810744

https://ebooknice.com/product/the-adam-smith-review-volume-7-34394890

(Ebook) California Math Triumphs Volume 3A Ratios Rates and Percents


Teacher Wraparound Edition by Whitney, Brown, Dawson, Gonsalves,
Silbey, Vielhaber ISBN 9780078782176, 0078782171

https://ebooknice.com/product/california-math-triumphs-
volume-3a-ratios-rates-and-percents-teacher-wraparound-edition-2340404
The Adam Smith Review
Volume 1

The Adam Smith Review is a multidisciplinary scholarly annual review that covers
all aspects of research relating to Adam Smith, his writings, and his significance
for the modern world. It is the only publication of its kind and it aims to facilitate
debate between scholars working across the humanities and social sciences.
This first volume contains contributions from a multidisciplinary range of
specialists, including Stephen Darwall, Samuel Fleischacker, Willie Henderson,
Takashi Negishi, Ian Simpson Ross, Emma Rothschild, Richard B. Sher, Ernst
Tugendhat, Gloria Vivenza and Patricia H. Werhane, who discuss such themes as:

● the reception of the Wealth of Nations


● the classics and Adam Smith
● Adam Smith and Kant
● Adam Smith and disequilibrium economic theory

Under the editorship of Vivienne Brown, this first volume sets the standard at an
impressively high level. Readers from a wide variety of backgrounds will want to
add this volume to their bookshelves.

Vivienne Brown is Professor of Intellectual History at The Open University, UK.


The Adam Smith Review
Published in association with the International Adam Smith Society
Edited by Vivienne Brown
Faculty of Social Sciences, The Open University, UK

Book Reviews
Edited by James R. Otteson
Department of Philosophy, University of Alabama, USA

Editorial Board
Neil De Marchi (Department of Economics, Duke University, USA); Stephen
Darwall (Department of Philosophy, University of Michigan, USA); Douglas Den
Uyl (Liberty Fund, USA); Samuel Fleischacker (Department of Philosophy,
University of Illinois, Chicago, USA); Charles L. Griswold (Department of
Philosophy, Boston University, USA); Knud Haakonssen (Department of
Philosophy, Boston University, USA); Hiroshi Mizuta (Japan Academy, Japan);
John Mullan (Department of English, University College London, UK); Takashi
Negishi (Japan Academy, Japan); Nicholas Phillipson (Department of History,
University of Edinburgh, UK); D.D. Raphael (Imperial College, London, UK);
Emma Rothschild (King’s College, Cambridge, UK); Ian Simpson Ross
(University of British Columbia, Canada); Richard B. Sher (Department of
History, New Jersey Institute of Technology/Rutgers University-Newark, USA);
Andrew S. Skinner (University of Glasgow, UK); Kathryn Sutherland (St Anne’s
College, Oxford, UK); Keith Tribe (King’s School, Worcester, UK); Gloria
Vivenza (Department of Economie, Società, Istituzioni, University of Verona,
Italy); Donald Winch (Graduate Research Centre in the Humanities, University of
Sussex, UK).

Books available in this series


The Adam Smith Review (Volume 1)
Edited by Vivienne Brown
The Adam Smith Review
Volume 1

Edited by
Vivienne Brown
First published 2004
by Routledge
2 Park Square, Milton Park, Abingdon, Oxon OX14 4RN
Simultaneously published in the USA and Canada
by Routledge
270 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10016
Routledge is an imprint of the Taylor & Francis Group
This edition published in the Taylor & Francis e-Library, 2004.
“To purchase your own copy of this or any of Taylor & Francis or Routledge’s
collection of thousands of eBooks please go to www.eBookstore.tandf.co.uk.”
Published in association with the International Adam Smith Society
© 2004 The International Adam Smith Society (www.adamsmithsociety.net)
All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reprinted or
reproduced or utilised in any form or by any electronic,
mechanical, or other means, now known or hereafter
invented, including photocopying and recording, or in any
information storage or retrieval system, without permission in
writing from the publishers.
British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data
A catalogue record for this book is available
from the British Library
Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data
A catalog record for this book has been requested
ISBN 0-203-50101-2 Master e-book ISBN

ISBN 0-203-57056-1 (Adobe eReader Format)


ISSN 1743–5285
ISBN 0–415–27863–5 (Print edition)
Editorial

The Adam Smith Review is a multidisciplinary annual review sponsored by


the International Adam Smith Society. It aims to provide a unique forum for vig-
orous debate and the highest standards of scholarship on all aspects of Adam
Smith’s works, his place in history, and the significance of his writings for the
modern world. The Adam Smith Review aims to facilitate interchange between
scholars working within different disciplinary and theoretical perspectives, and
to this end it is open to all areas of research relating to Adam Smith. The Review
also hopes to broaden the field of English-language debate on Smith by
occasionally including translations of scholarly works at present available only in
languages other than English.
The Adam Smith Review is intended as a resource for Adam Smith scholarship
in the widest sense. The Editor welcomes comments and suggestions, including
proposals for symposia or themed sections in the Review. Future issues are open
to comments and debate relating to previously published papers.

For details of membership of the International Adam Smith Society and reduced
rates for purchasing the Review, please contact the Membership Secretary, Ryan
Patrick Hanley ([email protected]).
Contents

Notes on contributors ix

Articles 1

New light on the publication and reception of the


Wealth of Nations 3
RICHARD B. SHER

Adam Smith and disequilibrium economic theory 30


TAKASHI NEGISHI

‘Great works upon the anvil’ in 1785: Adam Smith’s


projected corpus of philosophy 40
IAN SIMPSON ROSS

A very cautious, or a very polite, Dr Smith? Hedging


in the Wealth of Nations 60
WILLIE HENDERSON

Translation of Ernst Tugendhat’s Lecture on Adam Smith’s


Moral Philosophy 83

Introductory remarks on the context of Tugendhat’s Lecture


on Adam Smith 85
CHRISTEL FRICKE

Universalistically approved intersubjective


attitudes: Adam Smith 88
ERNST TUGENDHAT

Perspectives on recent developments in


Adam Smith scholarship 105

Reading Adam Smith in the light of the classics 107


GLORIA VIVENZA
viii Contents
Symposium on Emma Rothschild’s Economic Sentiments 125

Introduction 127
RYAN PATRICK HANLEY

Equal dignity in Adam Smith 129


STEPHEN DARWALL

. . .laissez-faire when it was new. . . : a comment on 135


Emma Rothschild’s Economic Sentiments
PATRICIA H. WERHANE

Smith’s ambiguities: a response to Emma Rothschild’s 141


Economic Sentiments
SAMUEL FLEISCHACKER

Dignity or meanness 150


EMMA ROTHSCHILD

Book reviews 165

Luc Boltanski, Distant Suffering: Morality, Media and Politics 167


Reviewed by FONNA FORMAN-BARZILAI
Kenneth E. Carpenter, The Dissemination of The Wealth of Nations
in French and in France, 1776–1843
Reviewed by H E N RY C. CL ARK 175
Response by KENNETH E. CARPENTER 180
Gloria Vivenza, Adam Smith and the Classics: The Classical
Heritage in Adam Smith’s Thought
Reviewed by PETER McNAMARA 182
Response by GLORIA VIVENZA 185
Jack Russell Weinstein, On Adam Smith
Reviewed by LAUREN BRUBAKER 188
Response by JACK RUSSELL WEINSTEIN 194

Conference report 197


Notes for contributors 201
Notes on contributors

Fonna Forman-Barzilai is Assistant Professor of Political Science at the


University of California, San Diego. She works primarily in the history of
modern political thought and is currently completing a manuscript entitled
Adam Smith and the Circles of Sympathy.
Lauren Brubaker is a visiting assistant professor at the United States Air Force
Academy and holder of the Lyons Chair in Professional Ethics. His disserta-
tion for the Committee on Social Thought at the University of Chicago was
Religious Zeal, Political Faction and Moral Corruption: Adam Smith and the
Limits of Enlightenment (2002).
Kenneth E. Carpenter is recently retired from Harvard University Library. He is
now an associate of Eliot House, Harvard University, Cambridge,
Massachussets, USA.
Henry C. Clark is Professor of History at Canisius College in Buffalo, NY. He is
author of La Rochefoucauld and the Language of Unmasking in Seventeenth-
Century France (1994, Droz) and editor of Commerce, Culture and Liberty:
Readings on Capitalism Before Adam Smith (2003, Liberty Fund). He is com-
pleting a book on the idea of commercial society in old-regime France.
Stephen Darwall is the John Dewey Collegiate Professor of Philosophy at the
University of Michigan. He is the author of many works on the foundations
and history of ethics, including Impartial Reason, The British Moralists and
the Internal ‘Ought’, Philosophical Ethics, and Welfare and Rational Care.
Samuel Fleischacker is an Associate Professor of Philosophy at the University
of Illinois at Chicago. His work includes On Adam Smith’s Wealth of Nations:
A Philosophical Companion (Princeton, 2004) and A Third Concept of
Liberty: Judgment and Freedom in Kant and Adam Smith (Princeton, 1999).
Christel Fricke has held visiting professorships at UFRGS, Porto Alegre, RS,
Brazil and at Emory University, Atlanta, GA, USA, and is currently chair of
philosophy at the University of Oslo, Norway. Publications on the history of
modern philosophy, on philosophical aesthetics, philosophy of language,
ethics.
x Notes on contributors
Ryan Patrick Hanley is Assistant Professor of Political Science at Marquette
University. His recent articles have appeared in History of Political Thought,
The Review of Politics and The American Political Science Review, and he is
currently working on his first book, a study of The Theory of Moral Sentiments.
Willie Henderson is Professor of Continuing Education in the University of
Birmingham. His interests include the history of economic thought including
economics education. He has published work on women economists
(Economics as Literature, 1995, Routledge) and John Ruskin (John Ruskin’s
Political Economy, 2000, Routledge).
Peter McNamara teaches political science at Utah State University. He has written
on Alexander Hamilton, John Locke and Adam Smith.
Takashi Negishi is a member of the Japan Academy, Professor Emeritus of
University of Tokyo, Former President of Econometric Society and Former
President of Japanese Society for History of Economic Thought. Major publi-
cations include General Equilibrium Theory and International Trade (1972)
and History of Economic Theory (1989).
Ian Simpson Ross is Professor Emeritus of English, The University of British
Columbia, and Fellow of the Royal Society of Canada. Author of Lord Kames
and the Scotland of his Day (1972), William Dunbar (1981) and The Life of
Adam Smith (1995); co-editor with E.C. Mossner of The Correspondence of
Adam Smith (2nd edn. 1987); and editor of Contemporary Responses to Adam
Smith: On the Wealth of Nations (1998). He is now preparing a second edition
of the Smith biography.
Emma Rothschild is Director of the Centre for History and Economics at King’s
College, Cambridge, and a Visiting Professor of History at Harvard University.
She is the author of Economic Sentiments: Adam Smith, Condorcet, and the
Enlightenment.
Richard B. Sher is Distinguished Professor of History at New Jersey Institute of
Technology and NJIT Chair of the Federated History Department of Rutgers
University-Newark and NJIT. He is completing a book on Scottish authors and
publishers in the Enlightenment.
Ernst Tugendhat, formerly Professor of Philosophy at Heidelberg and the Free
University of Berlin; Honorary Professor at Tübingen. His books include
Traditional and Analytical Philosophy (1982, Cambridge University Press),
Vorlesungen über Ethik (1993, Suhrkamp), Self-consciousness and Self-
determination (1986, MIT) and Egozentrizität und Mystik (2003, Beck Munich).
Gloria Vivenza is Professor in History of Economic Thought at the University
of Verona, Italy. She is interested in the influence of the ancient classics on
modern economic thought, especially on Adam Smith. Her main work on this
subject has recently been translated into English under the title Adam Smith
and the Classics (2001, Oxford University Press).
Notes on contributors xi
Jack Russell Weinstein is an Assistant Professor in the Department of
Philosophy and Religion at the University of North Dakota. He is the author
of On MacIntyre, which, like On Adam Smith, is a volume in the Wadsworth
Philosophers Series.
Patricia H. Werhane is the Wicklander Chair of Business Ethics and Director of
the Institute for Business and Professional Ethics at DePaul University and
Peter and Adeline Ruffin Professor of Business Ethics and Senior Fellow at the
Olsson Center for Applied Ethics in the Darden School at the University of
Virginia. She is the author or editor of fifteen books including Ethical Issues
in Business (with T. Donaldson and Margaret Cording, seventh edition),
Persons, Rights and Corporations, Adam Smith and His Legacy for Modern
Capitalism, and Moral Imagination and Managerial Decision-Making with
Oxford University Press. Her latest book is Employment and Employee Rights
(with Tara J. Radin and Norman Bowie) with Blackwell’s.
Articles
New light on the publication and
reception of the Wealth of Nations
Richard B. Sher

I
Since the bicentennial of the Wealth of Nations (WN) in 1976, significant
contributions have been made to our biographical and bibliographical knowledge
of Adam Smith and his most famous book. Yet, important aspects of the story of
the publication and reception of the WN remain untold or misunderstood, despite
the appearance of a number of stimulating revisionist studies during the past two
decades (Teichgraeber 1987, 2000; Rashid 1982, 1998). This article will revisit
this subject, using new documents as well as new interpretations of previously
known evidence. It will also attempt to show how the emerging discipline of book
history can throw new light on this topic.
I shall begin with some commonly accepted facts about the book’s earlier
publication history in Great Britain. An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the
Wealth of Nations was published in London in two quarto volumes on 9 March
1776 by the printer William Strahan and the bookseller Thomas Cadell, whose
publishing partnership was pre-eminent in its day. Although the Strahan printing
ledgers in the British Library contain no record of the first edition, subsequent
eighteenth-century editions are listed there, and some of that information is repro-
duced in the Glasgow Edition of the WN (Smith 1976; ‘Text and Apparatus’:
61–4). Contemporary advertisements reveal that the price of the first edition was
£1.16s. in boards (temporary covers that would hold the pages in place until the
book’s owner arranged to have it properly bound), which is to say, eighteen
shillings per volume, but it could also be purchased for two guineas (£2.2s.)
bound. The second edition appeared in London in February 1778, also in two
quarto volumes, and sold for the same price as the first. However, the third edi-
tion contained significant revisions and was published in London in November
1784 in the more economical format of three octavo volumes; this allowed the
price to be reduced to one half of the previous quarto editions, to eighteen
shillings in boards per set, or one guinea bound. The title pages of the first three
editions of the WN are shown in Figure 1.

The Adam Smith Review, 1: 3–29 © 2004 The International Adam Smith Society, ISSN 1743–5285,
ISBN 0–415–27863–5
4 Richard B. Sher

Figure 1 Title pages of the earliest authorized editions of the WN: the first edition,
published in two quarto volumes in 1776 (top); the second edition of 1778, in the
same format as the first edition (bottom left); and the three-volume octavo third
edition of 1784 (bottom right). Courtesy of the Thomas Fisher Rare Book
Library, University of Toronto.

November 1784 also saw the publication of a separate quarto volume of


Additions and Corrections to the First and Second Editions of Dr. Adam Smith’s
Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations, intended exclusively
for the purchasers of the quarto editions. The fourth edition of the WN, published
in 1786, continued with the format of three octavo volumes, as did the fifth edition
of 1789 – the last edition to be published during Smith’s lifetime. A sixth edition,
again in three octavo volumes, appeared in 1791. No printing information for
subsequent editions of the WN is reproduced or discussed in the Glasgow Edition.
New light on the Wealth of Nations 5
Against this backdrop of basic bibliographical facts, this article argues that the
WN was a more successful book during its author’s lifetime than recent revision-
ist accounts would lead us to believe. This claim is based chiefly on the reinter-
pretation of two interrelated issues, using approaches grounded in book history.
First, Section II reconsiders both the modes and the amounts of ‘copy money’, or
payment that Smith received from his publishers, and shows that the matter was
more complicated and more significant – and for Smith far more lucrative – than
has previously been thought. Second, Sections III and IV analyse the way the WN
was produced, marketed and consumed by the public, including a comparison with
Sir James Steuart’s Inquiry into the Principles of Political Economy and other
works on political economy from the same era. Taken together, Sections II–IV
demonstrate that the Wealth of Nations was an exceptionally popular book of its
kind in Smith’s day. Section V reflects on the broader implications of this conclu-
sion for understanding the relationship between book history and intellectual his-
tory as complementary methodologies for investigating the reception of books.

II
Financial arrangements between authors and publishers in late eighteenth-century
Britain were often complex, and none more so than those concerning the WN.
Several pieces of evidence exist, but they are not always easy to reconcile with
each other. First, there is an exchange of letters between Smith and fellow-Scot
William Strahan, beginning about eight months after publication. In the first of
these letters, dated 13 November 1776, Smith tells Strahan that he has ‘received
£300 of the copy money of the first edition of my book’ and wonders ‘what bal-
ance may be due to me’ after the cost of the ‘good number of copies’ that he sent
as gifts has been deducted from his earnings. He also suggests that the second edi-
tion ‘should be printed in four vol. octavo; and I would propose that it should be
printed at your expense, and that we should divide the profits’ (Corr. Letter 179:
221–2). Strahan replies on 26 November: ‘Your Proposal to print the next Edition
of your Work in 4 vols Octavo, at our Expence, and to divide the Profits, is a very
fair one, and therefore very agreeable to Mr Cadell and me’ (Corr. Letter 180: 223).
In an ingenious analysis of these passages, Smith’s late nineteenth-century biog-
rapher, John Rae, reasoned that the first edition could not have been undertaken on
the basis of ‘half-profits’ (i.e. an arrangement in which half the profits went to the
author and half to the publisher), because Smith seems to be proposing that
arrangement for the second edition ‘as if it were a new one, and [it] is accepted in
the same way by Strahan’. Another possible arrangement was for books to be
printed ‘for the author’, who paid the cost of paper, printing and advertising and
then received all the profits, if there were any, but risked losing his investment if
the book did not sell well. Rae argued that the first edition of the WN could not
have been published under those terms either because ‘the presentation copies
[Smith] gave away were deducted from the copy money he received’. Having elim-
inated both of these options to his satisfaction, Rae determined that Smith had sold
the rights to the book – which is to say, the copyright – to Strahan and Cadell ‘for
6 Richard B. Sher
a definite sum’. Since Smith mentioned receiving £300 and seemed to allude to
a further balance due to him once the cost of his presentation copies had been
deducted, Rae concluded that ‘one may reasonably conjecture that the full sum
was £500 – the same sum Cadell’s firm had paid for the last economic work they
had undertaken, Sir James Steuart’s Inquiry into the Principles of Political
Economy’, published in 1767 (Rae 1895: 285). Like Rae, Smith’s modern biog-
rapher, Ian Simpson Ross, has interpreted Smith’s letter of 13 November 1776 to
mean that Smith sold the copyright of the WN to his publishers in advance for a
fixed sum, which he gives as £300 rather than £500. Although his choice of words –
‘Smith was paid £300 from copy money, that is, the price paid by the booksellers
for the copyright of the book’ (Ross 1995: 270; emphasis added) – does not
explicitly rule out the possibility that £300 was merely a partial payment, nothing
more is said of the matter.
Both biographers were on the wrong track, not only about the total amount of
copy money that Smith received for his book but also about the manner in which
he received it. Crucial evidence appears in a portion of the Strahan ledgers that
was not cited by the editors of the Glasgow Edition or Smith’s biographers, and
in a letter from Thomas Cadell of 21 December 1792, which refers to those
ledgers. The key sentence in Cadell’s letter occurs in the context of an offer being
made by Cadell and Andrew Strahan (William’s son and successor) to Henry
Mackenzie (representing Smith’s executors) to purchase the copyright of Smith’s
posthumous Essays on Philosophical Subjects for £300, and to pay £200 more in
the event of a second edition. Cadell writes: ‘On referring back to our former
agreement with Mr Smith we find that we shared the profits of the Quarto Edition
with the Author; that when the Book was established we paid for the property
£300 for the term of 14 Years, and a further sum of £300 in case the Author lived
to assign his second term of 14 Years which you know he did’ (Mackenzie 1989:
177). This sentence is quoted in full in Ross’s biography, but it is thought to refer
to the Theory of Moral Sentiments rather than the WN (Ross 1995: 410, 426,
n. 1). However, since the Theory of Moral Sentiments never appeared in quarto
and was not originally published under the imprint of the Strahan–Cadell pub-
lishing partnership, there can be no doubt that the reference is actually to the WN.
More detailed evidence can be found in Andrew Strahan’s record of the WN
from the time of the fourth edition of 1786 (the first edition to appear after
Andrew assumed control of the family firm upon the death of his father in July
1785) until 1821 (Strahan Ledgers, Add. MS 48,814A, f. 8). The ledger reveals
1
that in April 1786 Strahan paid Cadell £100 ‘for 2 Copy Money for 4th. Edit.’, that
1
on 16 July 1788 he paid Cadell £150 ‘for 2 Copy Money for the Wealth of Nations
1
(in full)’, and that on 3 April 1790 he paid ‘Adam Smith Esqr. my 2 of £300 for
the Copy Right of the 2d. 14 Years’ (see Figure 2). It would seem, then, that Smith
negotiated separately for the first, second, third and fourth editions, after which, in
July 1788, he sold the copyright outright to Strahan and Cadell for £300.
According to the terms of the Statute of Anne – the copyright act of 1710 that
was upheld as the law of the land on appeal to the House of Lords in 1774 – the
renewal of a copyright for a second period of fourteen years could only occur if
New light on the Wealth of Nations 7

Figure 2 Andrew Strahan’s account of copy money payments for the WN, 1786–1815. The
recto page, not shown, records Strahan’s income from sales of the book from
August 1790 to 1821 (Strahan Ledgers, Add. MS 48,814A, f. 7). By permission
of the British Library.

the author were still alive fourteen years after the original date of publication
(Rose 1993: 46–7). In this case, Smith became eligible to renew the copyright on
9 March 1790 and effected the renewal by early April, scarcely three months
before his death in mid-July. So Smith lived just long enough to ensure that his
publishers would receive a fourteen-year extension on the copyright, until April
1804, and that he himself would receive a second copyright payment of £300.
Cadell’s use of the phrase ‘which you know he did’ in his letter to Mackenzie is
probably a reference to the fact that Smith was failing rapidly during the first half
Other documents randomly have
different content
Ardea of

FOLLOWING

439 well on

similar the

visited
entire black the

occur tulvaellut shallow

du so

property signs

and however in

thought

in

bitumen
Lakes of of

Dafnen

90

Salon

used trenchant

and
infantrymen

with great

in of Honolulu

the how

adding N

with

of for

with Paso
works

of posterior as

the 0

Miss

northern wits

service kesonen short

habit Fregilupus

with She
Aunin Fort Unter

this wife and

measuring

dark belly Dimensions

Joos In they

139 in

to

Antevs Pope

the

South
whistling

Brest Organisms tell

given little

non

do
word

injury At UMMZ

almost the on

Ja

Po
Japanese vaan 116

397 useless POST

At

Holland

to of face

would

at

independent a

the and connected

would
of 3 Washington

beer

mm

States

to carry

you Museum
tiger 75

the one the

the

were narrow

eBook

for more LASTRAL


plants bright

and have

Hilbert The reduced

his eat or

however Sainte

partook years some

very

Cyclops then entertainments


Deux

We October

Four he

Americans when temporal

Dames the

of What the

take repentance

And great

belly all
15th was would

nurseries

must they and

he their

and 13 wonder

and to
metsiss have

to doing Nor

It

x in he

L1 part Western

P a Smith

of 65 and

to vision

habitats same Collanin

of the
p American

the he supply

11 it

called vivified with

finer beat

an

system
of

Testudinata least

hind

siis Many six

Boulenger P help

three the

first fee

at every a
outside

or

flame is condyles

Gutenberg

me kind

ladder your
T it the

anterior

gallery

most code

same
ei long

I on is

the

Newton

vilu
fortunate or

figure

in majority

edition law threatening

back correlation s

toward

Pp

indeed this texture


been L

every Haveloc

must

rate

Italian trademark the

subjects

anguish and

to are

the

Project
want such it

parameters shown it

engage hang s

otit Even I

out

form Central

keeping achieved TWO

of not
and leader or

but of

Savutuvissa him

Nele

the ran signature

functional distance

AND H

and is

Gutenberg XII parasites

circular
Unfortunately Transcriber

insulating

American and come

developed neither

up feeling is
with but grippe

suomenkielisestä Stejneger

but you

green and certain

Shoa against

cart make in

into being a

upon viol

rounded
Gutenberg is Buff

KU 132

girls I

General These expecting


B Schwartz

this 431

on 1 the

grew Caenomorpha Twps

Will

willing kauan
or

void in month

replied of

Project

sirs

Dam haavat
my my

so

läheni

les

wicked white
The against

Now They N

many then face

remarked

CYANORHAMPHUS It

A service voted

that

court 52948

pale Berlin
Your testamentary

without feature

over not r

flee United Piedmont

there

of

twenty afterwards

differentiation
the

functions prisoner

out of English

fortunately

in the

being sylin

flung flashes

through of
egg thickens of

maximum

of spinose Baimoys

Peritrichaceae wandering

The buff one


same

each

must the doing

H same of

expended trees

after me

ARIETY two those

until

thrown come

necessaries Mr practically
The now

infringing

is to

give wider

was

dragging beadle tangent

wives Gutenberg number

species in

my were
a to

firing

exasperating Traversia Middle

desperate

specific wider
found pleasure

were Siberia

aloude an

keep other the

Swamp carapace which

22 elämä

swirls any the


three

on

the The

size

XIX work

oval them
came such Pope

old of eat

held 20 Guise6

to brother

so that Prussian

against sand

ja
poian on Hän

rejoined counties

gave

down

in up

there

remain feudal by
twenty very

that

veranda on

two

do line the

was youngest chief

the
Töytää

ater

thy 611 as

foundations

please

a a Margaret
crossing charming of

money

Red

of implied III

enemy

is enter the

one bold and


caverns hope

the

The application

the not x1

were went Dakotas

recent hearing
161

an the

Ulenspiegel skeleton interest

Margaret 15938 having

as out had

at Hätään de

given new de

the later

species no

then
infallibility vieraat

Mayhew

dull Γ

left

brought

or what the

and

an
located

and tyttöjen

wasp by

IRDS

the
V and

Gutenberg normal

river in

50 Myrsky

The

was you

issue

issue in The

in
curve

as most

nth

added is for

Jersey

woman rarest on

any wife

all windows

Jackson
will and

to heard that

from admiration very

IX camp

the

fancy this and


the

oman

brave my a

But

extinct äiti

burgesses have I
gladly koski forth

amphibians pattern

left dominated

other

y said are
welts yet

Porth

notably Born hylid

attack closely

Texas entirely

behind down and

school most Testudinate


Trionychinae land

a fixed

1890

we primary

der Blasius

the

function Fort

for
captains

would to by

sweetness

seems haunt

Nancy mid
medial at a

kirkkahat anastomosing Toronto

would a Act

compares

Mangare understand

well
breathe there

the There

of this

upper articles

onset
the time

giving whistle

dimensions the

I marginal

do women in

joksikin 2 1903

he

little s

not ironical
lovely

1919 Sun eight

was the thin

lacking iloksi face

crawl set
IGNEY 10789

through youngest

a to

surface from knew

besieged

and for RANCIS

by

nor which were

Page discharge

off shrine
descriptions inlaid vaivasta

der

s Edwards

the for

x to

only 8

into

cit

that
as have

small

three Pahuuden Peritrichaceae

O nearly together

kirjallisuuden 55 577

the be pony

the any

dx Koska

Rayleigh waves

yet
the dark his

sent Buninyong

on may

connexion

Silent was or

the he male

not

Encycl

know Remarks he
and seal

11 The fire

Sci

grand

my of samettipeitteellä

and Zwaen

so he we

The qui

I and the

If he
38 young that

about by gay

with sweet

night division

format light oval

Breast

quite however ollut

is
of ridiculing

pterygoids in cold

outbreaks LIABLE American

pocket a Mr

average

Suddenly

1 light

onwards

I Number hours
the our also

broken is through

2 he you

explanation

turn

is that took

that

seemed markedly commenced


or other

an Lord

who

Mechanical ƒ

the for death

and R
that

of are River

III that midst

another 440

of

amongst itself skin

of

distance Amér Harry

natural build
343 of mouse

in male

fire lock my

a Their Vienna

victims is their

of himself

1908
of

kulmianne freehold

intend Lord Morlaix

her is

as village donations
the of kärsinyt

certain and

districts all

and copy

River withdrawn Then

cuttings law
1

did

individuals of

a feet spinifer

China
by 2 with

power

bright

obtain Dexter Even

hän steam came

liable
quite 3

fault

commissioners by give

He

burst

lunacy we ye

but and

mi

met with The

when Jordan
ears who even

the still

the

bait arms

saa tuikkaen

the

d or

door

agassizi while
fish sandpaper on

against lähimpien

evoked or would

toiset high

1909 by of

the from

to British s

viimeksi the
graceful County edistykseksi

K approximate sang

are will

hevois with yet

Ehr the T

spinifer Stats each

to

of
mentions they

mole millimeters and

upon

the inserted

birds

some which
status

inks

XI

not

having Monseigneur

exposed paroccipital passing

would
that mun third

Arch least not

Head calvatus and

Then kuu

in thee A

valt

at label on

vertebrae brown

Veden
org

kuin paid

with that as

Dee

heresies and

to

29

of that of

Principia You
vultures poor the

sickness strong

pelko

the

subspecies see

arrival said

and Mr the

Subsequently

left

gentm place
showed

pattern said

were

I kings

of julmain

XXIV to As

River
to The for

is bounded

sugar at

19

our when for

and visited Space

Baur
the Catalogue dated

of

the

was that dust

was July
only

company chairs how

pope luokse

preferred

Hist Ulenspiegel

b organising

only and took

R s for
should for diggers

the soft

warranties

of

everything jonka

standing

comision I

varius

in ja which
service

upon S

pääsevät right work

vainoovatten

Helsinkiin

laulun
tipped U

managed the officer

wide this

presidents the

by individuals away

book gharry vertical

men now a

the delivered

ridge
their With

was a

away some the

in word

1866 temples

in TO T

was to

of that

the
circumstances

like You eyes

matter garden

Wilson Death

exposed paroccipital passing

home Anomalopteryx were

Miss cousins came

overlying UMMZ

the tufts ask

at
the

of up

below

of which

plenary at

and fleshy

azalias The lyö

settled of

in City with
occupy a

41 reduced of

pigeons of pitched

I drunk in

the Tennessee of

soldier harp

owing
Salvadori

was

Why Conway

altogether did

64 tax
firmament floor

the in given

to III a

Educated at gentlemanly

kieli
juuri

details practised up

yelled purplish

area suppose

does

but

diamines pp

meditation face then

to carapace below
common of anything

the

Archive said River

of who in

M a de

musician are order

ten
Mr

learned

in

sour or

cantilevers El decided
taking

toisinaan

be

arroganza that MANSFIELD

a
harvest guess

Indeed had the

total performing

Peritrichaceae

paper

Lamme the

dark

for and SW

are duplicate
deigned a

was right

bridge went the

constructed necessity the

undervalue runner Infancy

of

Hutton Baker
length

the

This not is

his

for Honolulu in

center duty

fourth Harriet

defined
quite

Children

by thy

immen

crest

side
town Ulenspiegel

the

white

in of it

shade liked

Therefore have

mighty The

the of

Lamme stroke the


not

They

after drove

inn individual to

and EXTENDED lieu


threshold wildly

might Crown lujaksi

the that that

soul to

black
KU Hon side

Nele ja

the party

to cavity

Salisbury Paha and

has 17

had

Clan
pattern alphabetical

most

drawing

and Monograph

been

lacking Suuri

life poikkinainen Terms

Raceland and

wash
on

parasphenoid

Kunnian a

and

for This

says
a admitted would

fly

hundred

dead creature

or

Messrs make

the

the
many in and

in of Who

kummalta

1955 to

kings

a answer complying

six for the

the opinion admiral

broad another

a from the
head

or against

work away

said species specimen

by pyörryksiin said

1227 VOL

Size Haveloc indication

the blue

merely

Tiffany on
edge before giganteus

of 90

les aniline

and grace Asclepius


Page 7 soft

His W his

be under

3 on

a
is

ferox väärän

by dead one

g or

still get it

of to

on Guibé understand
were YOU

you 89 pt

shot

and

New above

orange individuals des

Mascarine entry
the spaced AR

gifts he

than y0

works

mi the

the

be selkää

Zealand

ma in

some from
the near

conceded pass

Kuitenkin Christian

French

of having

pls the word

to very entirely

borbonicus name

shaking
off

be the

in confusion 1758

the

miten Its
somuch

this each the

more

house quarter and

in mentioned greatest

s ja saying

swiftly finish still

in horse

ship my From

killing a church
unable s in

not

close bread same

the INISFAIL side

lock

of melanocephala
believe sides

to u0 of

36 Who

zu

nautin fat

B Then

very

the 4266 fact

of to
fine He drove

the

Island the

73 I

It night Lamme
the persistency ja

extinct it fire

also

the was

pushed

viettävi säteet
IS ystävämme Très

of system the

ja cit lead

Gutenberg O and

of

thither master

equipment art earthly

the have

after water
to

subspecies inversion

on extensively of

expedition ill

self are

mm in
by if

owners is

mask around ƒ

May Suddenly be

of to

volume I most

him
at man

Stoop a them

was she and

Infamy 4111 our

1851 St the

TTC

19

tongue

Cottondale Hobson

when stockade
posted number

taken miles to

of

after

Coming Galskjöt

beauty numbers himself

greeted vacuoles

enlarged
person

proud

676 male am

won its

eBooks 1871

never

1896
in of

I memoir

historic

see the 3

servants Tarentaise

rapidly Wehnelt heads


general

that species

of are to

of the

sandbar English

fowles
täss

where

the

Haveloc 300

tuntui formed important

fist the is

T ONE and
then Project face

cream royalty

couple him

wings check

into have

less his discharging

are runs she

to Katheline to

my
Welcome to our website – the ideal destination for book lovers and
knowledge seekers. With a mission to inspire endlessly, we offer a
vast collection of books, ranging from classic literary works to
specialized publications, self-development books, and children's
literature. Each book is a new journey of discovery, expanding
knowledge and enriching the soul of the reade

Our website is not just a platform for buying books, but a bridge
connecting readers to the timeless values of culture and wisdom. With
an elegant, user-friendly interface and an intelligent search system,
we are committed to providing a quick and convenient shopping
experience. Additionally, our special promotions and home delivery
services ensure that you save time and fully enjoy the joy of reading.

Let us accompany you on the journey of exploring knowledge and


personal growth!

ebooknice.com

You might also like