Plato and Pythagoreanism 1st Edition Phillip Sidney

Horky Updated 2025

https://ebookfinal.com/download/plato-and-pythagoreanism-1st-
edition-phillip-sidney-horky/

★★★★★
4.7 out of 5.0 (54 reviews )

Instant PDF Download

ebookfinal.com
 Plato and Pythagoreanism 1st Edition Phillip Sidney Horky
Pdf Download

EBOOK

Available Formats

■ PDF eBook Study Guide Ebook

EXCLUSIVE 2025 EDUCATIONAL COLLECTION - LIMITED TIME

INSTANT DOWNLOAD VIEW LIBRARY

Here are some recommended products for you. Click the link to
download, or explore more at ebookfinal

New Essays on Plato and Aristotle RLE Plato 1st Edition

Renford Bambrough (Editor)

https://ebookfinal.com/download/new-essays-on-plato-and-aristotle-rle-
plato-1st-edition-renford-bambrough-editor/

Keynes Keynesians and Monetarists Sidney Weintraub

https://ebookfinal.com/download/keynes-keynesians-and-monetarists-
sidney-weintraub/

Phaedo Plato

https://ebookfinal.com/download/phaedo-plato/

Psychiatry Past Present and Prospect 1st Edition Sidney

Bloch

https://ebookfinal.com/download/psychiatry-past-present-and-
prospect-1st-edition-sidney-bloch/
Plato and Europe 1st Edition Jan Pato■ka

https://ebookfinal.com/download/plato-and-europe-1st-edition-jan-
patocka/

DISCOURSES CONCERNING GOVERNMENT Algernon Sidney

https://ebookfinal.com/download/discourses-concerning-government-
algernon-sidney/

Philosophy of Plato and Aristotle Alfarabi

https://ebookfinal.com/download/philosophy-of-plato-and-aristotle-
alfarabi/

Chemical Bonds 1st Edition Phillip Manning

https://ebookfinal.com/download/chemical-bonds-1st-edition-phillip-
manning/

Republic 3rd Edition Plato

https://ebookfinal.com/download/republic-3rd-edition-plato/
Plato and Pythagoreanism 1st Edition Phillip Sidney
Horky Digital Instant Download
Author(s): Phillip Sidney Horky
ISBN(s): 9780199898220, 0199898227
Edition: 1
File Details: PDF, 2.27 MB
Year: 2013
Language: english
Plato and Pythagoreanism
This page intentionally left blank
Plato and Pythagoreanism

P HILLIP SIDNEY HORKY

1
Oxford University Press is a department of the University of Oxford.
It furthers the University’s objective of excellence in research,
scholarship, and education by publishing worldwide.

Oxford New York

Auckland Cape Town Dar es Salaam Hong Kong Karachi
Kuala Lumpur Madrid Melbourne Mexico City Nairobi
New Delhi Shanghai Taipei Toronto
With offices in
Argentina Austria Brazil Chile Czech Republic France Greece
Guatemala Hungary Italy Japan Poland Portugal Singapore
South Korea Switzerland Thailand Turkey Ukraine Vietnam
Oxford is a registered trade mark of Oxford University Press
in the UK and certain other countries.
Published in the United States of America by
Oxford University Press
198 Madison Avenue, New York, NY 10016

© Oxford University Press 2013

All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or
transmitted, in any form or by any means, without the prior permission in writing of Oxford University Press,
or as expressly permitted by law, by license, or under terms agreed with the appropriate reproduction
rights organization. Inquiries concerning reproduction outside the scope of the above should be
sent to the Rights Department, Oxford University Press, at the address above.

You must not circulate this work in any other form

and you must impose this same condition on any acquirer.

Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data

Horky, Phillip Sidney.
Plato and Pythagoreanism / Phillip Sidney Horky.
pages cm
Includes bibliographical references (pages) and indexes.
ISBN 978-0-19-989822-0 (alk. paper)
1. Mathematics, Ancient. 2. Pythagorean theorem. 3. Pythagoras and Pythagorean school. 4. Plato. I. Title.
QA22.H67 2013
184—dc23 2012042672

9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
Printed in the United States of America
on acid-free paper
I, too, when I recollect my thoughts, feel a great deal of anxiety as to
how at my age I am to make my way across such a vast and formidable
sea of words.
—Plato, Parmenides 137a4–5

Nay, by the man who bestowed upon our head the Tetraktys,
Possessing the fount and roots of nature ever-flowing.
—the “Pythagorean Oath,” Aëtius 1.3.8
This page intentionally left blank
CONTENTS

Preface ix
Acknowledgments xv
Abbreviations xix

1. Aristotle on Mathematical Pythagoreanism in the Fourth

Century bce 3
2. Hippasus of Metapontum and Mathematical Pythagoreanism 37
3. Exoterism and the History of Pythagorean Politics 85
4. Mathematical Pythagoreanism and Plato’s Cratylus 125
5. What Is Wisest? Mathematical Pythagoreanism and Plato’s Phaedo 167
6. The Method of the Gods: Mathematical Pythagoreanism and
Discovery 201

Afterword 261
Bibliography 265
Index Locorum 281
General Index 295
This page intentionally left blank
PREFACE

Ceci n’est pas un livre sur Pythagore. Perhaps enough books have been written
on Pythagoras, both in antiquity, and in our modern era, to satisfy even the
most voracious Sybaritic appetite. What this book shares in common with
those books is the dedicated interest in occluded or fragmented authors, au-
thorities, and ideas. Like Pythagoras, this book’s two main protagonists are in-
tellectuals whose life stories are the stuff of lore—even despite the fact that they
lived in the fifth and fourth centuries bce, when history had become well devel-
oped as a genre in ancient Greece—and scholars have spent a great deal of
time trying to extract gold from the melded histories concerning their lives,
activities, and philosophical doctrines. These two figures are Hippasus of Meta-
pontum, the shadowy experimental Pythagorean philosopher and political
revolutionary for whom we sometimes have a name, and little more; and Plato
of Athens, who always advanced his own ideas in the voices of his characters,
such as Socrates, the Eleatic Stranger, and Timaeus, and about whom we pos-
sess a plethora of anecdotes, tall tales, and explanations of his philosophical
“doctrines.” In the history of philosophy, few scholars have connected these two
figures, in part because we know so little about the former and so little reliably
about the latter. Although this book is not about one great human who, accord-
ing to ancient traditions, was not supposed to be named, it is about two great
humans whose names solicited both praise and scorn from various parts of
their contemporary philosophical world. It is about a tradition of philosophical
innovation that spans a century and a half in the Greek world (ca. 500–350
bce), from Sicily and Southern Italy in the west to Athens, Thrace, and Anatolia
in the east, and the important figures whose surviving texts allow us to trace a
thread of intellectual inquiry that might explain how Plato responded to
Pythagorean philosophy. I refer to these figures, who flourished in the three
generations subsequent to the death of Pythagoras, as the mathematical Pythag-
oreans, but they had their own names: Epicharmus of Syracuse, Empedocles of
Agrigentum, Philolaus of Croton, Eurytus of Metapontum, and Archytas of
x Preface

Tarentum. What do these figures share in common? They were all considered
in antiquity to have been apostate or pretender Pythagoreans who made public
the doctrines of their master illegitimately.
Why, the reader might reasonably ask, should a book about so-called illegit-
imate Pythagoreanism and Plato be written now? It has been exactly fifty years
since Walter Burkert published his groundbreaking Weisheit und Wissenschaft:
Studien zu Pythagoras, Philolaos und Platon (1962, revised and translated into
English in 1972 under the title Lore and Science in Ancient Pythagoreanism),
and a number of major studies have appeared since Burkert revised our ap-
proach to the problem of Plato and Pythagoreanism. In the past two decades
alone, the field has shifted dramatically, owing to the influential scholarship of
three historians of philosophy and ideas: Carl A. Huffman, whose critical edi-
tions and commentaries of the fragments of Philolaus of Croton (1993) and
Archytas of Tarentum (2005) have provided a much-needed platform for dis-
cussion; Andrew Barker, whose many articles and books on ancient musicology
(especially The Science of Harmonics in Classical Greece [2007]) have funda-
mentally altered the ways scholars understand the scientific methodologies
employed by ancient philosophers; and Leonid Zhmud, whose scholarship on
the history of Pythagoreanism (Pythagoras and Early Pythagoreanism [2012],
an update and translation into English of his earlier Wissenschaft, Philosophie
und Religion im frühen Pythagoreismus [1997]), and the Peripatetic historiogra-
phy of science (The Origin of the History of Science in Classical Antiquity [2006])
have significantly altered the ways we read the ancient historiography of
science. Book-length studies of Pythagoras and the history of Pythagoreanism
by Charles Kahn (Pythagoras and the Pythagoreans: A Brief History [2001]) and
Christoph Riedweg (Pythagoras: His Life, Teaching, and Influence [2005], origi-
nally published in German as Pythagoras: Leben, Lehre, Nachwirkung in 2002)
have provided much-needed sober interpretation and clear exposition con-
cerning the history of the reception of Pythagoreanism beyond the confines of
the ancient world. This book owes a great deal to the work of these scholars,
who have continued to keep the discussions flowing and have provided a
high-water mark indeed to attain.
In each of these books, one finds dedicated analyses of many things Pythago-
rean, and many explanations for how Pythagoreanism developed. And it is
possible to obtain at least a limited sense of how Pythagoreanism may have
influenced Plato’s thought, although the precise nature of this influence remains
difficult to determine. What worried me most, however—and where I saw a
lacuna that needed to be filled—was in these scholars’ accounts of what,
precisely, “mathematical” Pythagoreanism might be. I wondered this because
I wasn’t quite sure, especially in the light of Burkert’s skepticism, what, if
anything, might have been “mathematical” about Pythagoreanism. Was it an
Preface xi

interest in numbers? Or perhaps it was early experimentation in what would

become deductive mathematics? Possibly it was their focus on harmonics? Or
was it a more universal interest in all those parts of knowledge that we would
call “scientific”? This puzzle sent me on a quest to try to figure out what any-
body in the fourth century bce, the century in which Pythagoreanism received
its many first historical treatments, might have found “mathematical” about the
philosophical ideas of the mathematical Pythagoreans.
What I discovered—very much in the light of the scholarship on Pythagore-
anism, but with the great help of scholars outside the subdiscipline as well—is
that a fuller understanding of what might be “mathematical” about a certain
strand of Pythagoreanism would require one to tackle the problem of the Aris-
totelian division of types of knowledge. One could not simply speculate about
the role of Pythagoreanism in Platonic thought without first evaluating Aristo-
tle’s classification of the philosophical activities of the Pythagoreans. Somewhat
counterintuitively, then, a book entitled Plato and Pythagoreanism needed to
start with a chapter on Aristotle. The fruits of that endeavor constitute chapter 1
of this book, where I argue that Aristotle in his lost works on the Pythagoreans
and in the Metaphysics sought to classify the Pythagoreans according to two
models of knowledge, knowledge of “the fact” and knowledge of “the reason
why.” This division becomes crucially important for the analysis of mathemat-
ical Pythagoreanism (as distinguished from acousmatic Pythagoreanism),
because it actually reflects quite well the evidence that survives from early
Pythagoreanism, especially (but not only) the extant fragments of Philolaus of
Croton. Once I felt that I had something of a grasp on what Aristotle would
have thought “mathematical” about Pythagorean philosophy, I began to won-
der whether Aristotle’s position on the subject could have been reflected in the
treatments of Pythagoreanism by other contemporary intellectual historians
and philosophers.
So I pursued a traditional line of inquiry, in which I investigated the early
treatment of Pythagoreanism in the Lyceum (by Aristoxenus of Tarentum,
Theophrastus of Eresus, and Dicaearchus of Messana) as well as the Early
Academy (Speusippus of Athens and Xenocrates of Chalcedon), at least insofar
as we might plausibly infer from the later testimonies. Now a great deal of this
work had already been covered by Burkert and, in a slightly different light,
Zhmud, but I still found that much remained to be said about the treatment of
Hippasus of Metapontum, in particular, whose “doctrinal” testimonia had been
dismissed by all scholars as simply spurious. To my surprise, and as I discuss
extensively in chapter 2, the treatments of Hippasus by the Peripatetics and the
Academics are starkly differentiated: while the Peripatetics associated Hippasus
with the material monism of Heraclitus of Ephesus, the figures in the Early
Academy seem to have manufactured a doctrine for Hippasus that assimilated
xii Preface

his ideas to Plato’s, effectively rendering him as a forerunner in the theory of

the Forms. While this portrait cannot be relied on for its historical value in
reconstructing Hippasus’s own ideas, it at least presents evidence for how
figures in the Early Academy associated Hippasus with Platonist doctrines.
If indeed the historical discourse concerning Pythagoreanism was already
fully implicated in philosophical antagonism by the third quarter of the fourth
century bce, might there be some alternative historical account—not obviously
derived from the accounts of the Peripatetics and Academics—that could
provide a test case against the doxographic reports advanced by Aristotle,
Speusippus, and others? Taking a cue from the scholarship of the first half of
the twentieth century, especially the work of Kurt von Fritz, Augusto Rostagni,
and Armand Delatte, I investigated the account of Pythagorean political activ-
ities given by Timaeus of Tauromenium, a Western Greek historian of the end
of the fourth century bce who was definitively prodemocracy and somewhat
hostile to Aristotle’s historiographical procedures. In chapter 3, I evaluate the
fragmentary evidence derived from Timaeus’s history of the city-states of Sicily
and Southern Italy, with special attention to the account of a certain Apollonius
preserved by Iamblichus in his work On the Pythagorean Way of Life 254–264.
The result of this analysis is the introduction of another term, “exoteric” Pythag-
oreans, which appears to correspond with the mathematical Pythagoreans, on
the grounds that both were considered heretical for having published/demon-
strated the doctrines of Pythagoras, an act that corresponded with the advent of
a “democratic” type of Pythagoreanism. Thanks to Timaeus, it is now possible
to see the Peripatetic historical account in relief and to evaluate the evidence
accordingly. I have extracted from this comparative analysis of Timaean and
Peripatetic histories of Pythagoreanism an account of how the “publication” of
the doctrines of Pythagoras corresponds with the “democratization” of philo-
sophical knowledge, an activity that serves as a model for the public use of
reason in order to resolve disputes. Thus, I draw the first half of the monograph
to a close by developing a new account of mathematical Pythagoreanism that
emphasizes the political ideology of making public, by means of scientific
demonstrations, the basic tenets of Pythagorean thought.
Armed with a historical framework, in the second half of this study I eval-
uate the philosophical content of the extant fragments of the mathematical
Pythagoreans who were said to have published/demonstrated the doctrines of
Pythagoras: Epicharmus of Syracuse, Empedocles of Agrigentum, Philolaus of
Croton, Eurytus of Metapontum, and Archytas of Tarentum. I do this in the
light of Plato’s treatment of the shared ideas each of these figures sought to
investigate, especially the concept “number.” When I examined the fragments
of the earliest of these figures, Epicharmus and Empedocles, I discovered that
even by the beginning of the fifth century bce, mathematical Pythagoreans
Preface xiii

were posing philosophical problems concerning the “number” of a human

being. In particular, they were concerned to evaluate what came to be known as
the “Growing Argument,” a puzzle that asks one to evaluate one’s personal iden-
tity in the light of one’s quantitative and qualitative growth throughout one’s
life. In chapter 4, I trace Plato’s philosophical responses to the puzzle of Epich-
armus’s “Growing Argument” in the earlier and middle dialogues of Plato, es-
pecially Euthyphro and Cratylus. Plato’s approach to this problem takes a unique
turn, since it is rooted in his metaphysical propositions, including the correla-
tive assumptions of participation of sensibles in Forms and imitation as a ve-
hicle for names to obtain the properties of their governing Forms. By attacking
a Sophistical version of the “Growing Argument” given by Cratylus, Plato
simultaneously appropriates certain principles of ontological predication given
by Philolaus of Croton, thus pitting, in effect, the ideas of one mathematical
Pythagorean against those of another.
In chapter 5, I assess Plato’s recurrent response to the “Growing Argument”
in the dialogue that exhibits Plato’s most extensive evaluation of the concept of
“number,” Phaedo. There, we see Plato illustrate mathematical Pythagorean ar-
gumentative techniques in the figures of Socrates’s interlocutors Simmias and
Cebes and critique them according to whether or not they exhibit a proper
methodological rigor. Once again, the proposition of Forms and teleological
causation generates new ways of thinking about number, and when Socrates
finally develops the most complete analysis of number that can be found in
Plato’s oeuvre, in the final argument, he does so chiefly in order to lay the
groundwork for a proof of the soul’s immortality. The Phaedo thus illustrates
Plato’s most circumspect appropriation of mathematical Pythagorean (espe-
cially Philolaic) concepts, and if we consider the theme of the work to reflect a
traditional Pythagorean concern with the reincarnation of the soul, we discover
that Plato’s philosophical methodology departs quite significantly from what
can be inferred from the fragments of Empedocles and Philolaus.
While the Phaedo presents a fascinating example of how Plato appropriated
and superseded his Pythagorean antecedents—essentially beating them at their
own game—it is surprisingly indirect in its presentation of the philosophical
concepts of the mathematical Pythagoreans. In the sixth and final chapter of
this book, I elucidate the ways Plato camouflages his critical responses to
Pythagoreanism by using mythological figures to refer to Pythagorean philo-
sophical invention in the middle and later dialogues, especially Republic,
Timaeus, and Philebus. The theme of “discovery” takes on Pythagorean over-
tones, and my exploration of the various culture heroes (“first-discoverers”) in
these dialogues shows that Plato ensconced his responses to the mathematical
Pythagoreans by narrating the stories of mythological philanthropists who suf-
fered punishment for their transgressions, such as Prometheus and Palamedes.
xiv Preface

In this final chapter, then, I bring the accounts of mathematical Pythagorean-

ism given by Aristotle and Timaeus of Tauromenium to bear on Plato’s literary
treatment of the heretical “first-discoverers,” especially the “certain Prome-
theus” of the Philebus, who is credited with passing down the fundamental
philosophical method to human beings. Speculation about whether this might
refer to Hippasus of Metapontum, the progenitor of mathematical Pythagore-
anism, is corroborated by appeal to internal references in Plato’s own work
(especially the Timaeus) and external references in the fragments of Archytas of
Tarentum.
This book does not aim to provide a comprehensive account of all the ways
Pythagoreanism, broadly conceived, might have influenced Plato’s philosophy.
Its project is to open up new ways of understanding Plato’s intervention in a
series of philosophical ideas that we can associate, with some plausibility, with
a particular strand of early Pythagorean thought. It is my hope that others will
find inspiration to fill in the many gaps that surely remain. This is a book about
alleged philosophical pretenders, thieves, and apostates who evade detection
just at the moment when we seek to capture them with our minds. Always
shifting, these ones are, and frustrating our best attempts to identify them. As
the poet said, “these things never cease from continually alternating.”
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

“Whatever naturally is in a process of exchange and never remains the same

should be always different from what it had been changed from” (DK 23 B 2 =
D.L. 3.9). So a speaker, apparently a debtor, in an unknown comedy by Epich-
armus of Syracuse presents the rationale for what came to be known as the
“Growing Argument.” Epicharmus’s character seeks to worm his way out of a
contract by saying it was someone else—surely not him—who is under obliga-
tion to deliver the goods. But the “Growing Argument” later came to be under-
stood as problematizing the persistent personal identity of a human being as he
grows older, gains and loses stuff, takes on new attributes and abandons others.
Given the quantitative and qualitative change of parts throughout time, one
might ask: am I the same man I was just one moment ago? On reflection, I can’t
help but think how well Epicharmus’s argument epitomizes the nature of this
book. It was originally presented as a doctoral thesis at the University of South-
ern California in August 2007, but then it was wholly reformulated at Stanford
University, reinvigorated at Harvard University’s Center for Hellenic Studies,
and brought into the light once again at Durham University. Not a single
sentence, not even a single idea, remains unaltered. So the question presents
itself: is it the same book?
I will leave it to those who have witnessed its development to decide this
question. Individual chapters benefited substantially from the careful reading
of many colleagues: Andrew Barker (chapter 6), Rachel Barney (chapter 2),
Mauro Bonazzi (chapter 3), George Boys-Stones (entire book), Luca Castagnoli
(chapters 1–3), Doug Hutchinson (chapter 1), Don Lavigne (chapter 6), Mariska
Leunissen (chapters 1–2), Tony Long (chapter 1), Constantinos Macris (chapter
3), Andrea Nightingale (chapter 6), and Malcolm Schofield (chapter 4). Monte
Ransome Johnson graciously read the entire manuscript for Oxford University
Press and provided invaluable criticisms as well as suggestions for improve-
ment throughout. The words of the Philosopher could not apply better to any-
one else: οἱ δὲ βουλόμενοι τἀγαθὰ τοῖς φίλοις ἐκείνων ἕνεκα μάλιστα
xvi Acknowledgments

φίλοι˙ δι’ αὑτοὺς γὰρ οὕτως ἔχουσι καὶ οὐ κατὰ συμβεβηκός (Arist. EN
8.3, 1156b9–11). Further generosity was exhibited by the other anonymous
reader for Oxford University Press, whose comments at an early stage helped
mold the book into its final form. These scholars’ attention to detail, as well as
broader circumspection, prevented a great number of (though surely not all)
erroneous interpretations, inferences, and arguments. Special gratitude is also
owed to Carl Huffman, who shared early drafts of the fragments of Aristoxenus
from his eagerly awaited edition; Rachel Barney and Malcolm Schofield, who
provided versions of what were then unpublished articles on Metaphysics A;
Christopher Baron, who sent me the preproof draft of his authoritative Timaeus
of Tauromenium and Hellenistic Historiography; and Leonid Zhmud, who
allowed me to see the proofs of Pythagoras and the Early Pythagoreans before
the book graced the shelves. A debt of gratitude is owed to those who have of-
fered information, encouragement, advice, criticism, or even a sympathetic ear
on the journey: Ben Acosta-Hughes, Ahmed Alwishah, Chloe Balla, Jonathan
Barnes, Kevin van Bladel, Chris Bobonich, Luc Brisson, Paola Ceccarelli, Del
Chrol, Zenon Culverhouse, John Dillon, Jamie Dow, Jackie Feke, Doug Frame,
Francesco Fronterotta, Robert Germany, Barbara Graziosi, Sepp Gumbrecht,
Tom Habinek, Antony Hatzistavrou, Johannes Haubold, Josh Hayes, Ron Hock,
Andrew Hui, Brad Inwood, Richard Janko, Ted Kaizer, John Kirby, Melissa Lane,
Valentina di Lascio, Arnaud Macé, Richard Martin, Henry Mendell, Allen
Miller, Kathryn Morgan, Greg Nagy, Grant Nelsestuen, Josh Ober, Grant Parker,
Chris Pelling, Alexis Pinchard, Susan Prince, Olivier Renaut, Christopher Rowe,
Will Shearin, Peter Struck, Chiara Sulprizio, Candace Weddle, David Wible, and
David Wray. Special thanks go to Greg Thalmann, my dissertation supervisor,
who, like all generous fathers, has always loved, in spite of the growing pains.
Portions of chapters were also presented throughout North America, the
United Kingdom, and the Continent at various institutions: the Centre for the
Study of the Ancient Mediterranean and Near East and the conference “Ancient
Fallacies” at Durham University; the Séminaire de la Société d’Études Plato-
niciennes, hosted by the Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique, with
Université Paris Ouest Nanterre-La Défense and Université de Franche-Comté;
the Sunoikisis Research Symposium at Harvard University’s Center for Hel-
lenic Studies; the Yorkshire Ancient Philosophy Network, hosted by the De-
partment of Philosophy at the University of Hull; the Department of Classics
at the University of Pennsylvania; the Department of Languages, Literatures,
and Cultures at the University of South Carolina; and the Collaborative Pro-
gramme in Ancient and Medieval Philosophy at the University of Toronto. For
the opportunities given to put to the test the nascent ideas now captured in
print, an immense gratitude is owed to these institutions and to the audiences
in attendance.
Acknowledgments xvii

This book also owes its existence to crucial support from the library staff of
Green Library at Stanford University, the Center for Hellenic Studies Library,
the Bill Bryson Library at Durham University, and the Bodleian and Sackler
Libraries at Oxford University. Its claims would surely have been stillborn if
not for the priceless collections of dusty codices preserved by the walls of these
institutions and by the philanthropy of their respective staffs, administrators,
and donors. If the reader should think that anything written in these pages is
worth its weight in paper and ink, may she or he support the preservation of
its kin by advocating for the retention of physical books in libraries.
There is also reason to mention those who have helped me bring this book to
completion at Oxford University Press, including my editor, Stefan Vranka, his
assistant, Sarah Pirovitz, the production editors, Karen Kwak and Amy Whit-
mer, and the copy editor, Martha Ramsey, in America, as well as Hilary O’Shea,
who helped facilitate things in England. I would also like to express my grati-
tude to Antony Gormley, whose sublime sculpture graces the cover of this book
and instantiates wonder about the identity, stability, and measure of man, as
well as his assistant at the Studio, Alice O’Reilly.
This book is dedicated to my mother, Lucinda, the healer, my father, Stanley,
the scientist, and Eliana, who listens, and calculates—and knows.
This page intentionally left blank
ABBREVIATIONS

In general, I have cited Greek authors according to the abbreviations in Liddell

and Scott’s Greek-English Lexicon (revised by Jones with supplement, Oxford,
1968), hereafter referred to as LSJ.
For Plato, I have used the various editions of the Oxford Classical Texts and
quoted according to the Stephanus pages listed there.
I have tended to use Ross’s Oxford editions of the works of Aristotle, which
retain Bekker’s numbering (Aristoteles Graece ex recensione Immanuelis Bek-
keri, vols. 1–2, Berlin, 1831), with the notable exception of the fragments of Aris-
totle, for which I refer to Rose’s third edition, published by Teubner (1886).
References to the commentators on Aristotle refer to the editions of the
Commentaria in Aristotelem Graeca (Berlin, 1892–1909).
For all abbreviations of ancient works, see the Index Locorum.
Common abbreviations or short forms of modern textual editions and col-
lections in this book are as follows.

Bastianini and Sedley = Commentarium in Platonis Theaetetum (P.Berol. inv.

9782), a cura di G. Bastianini e D. N. Sedley, in Corpus dei papiri filosofici III
(Florence, 1995), 227–562.
Collard and Cropp = C. Collard and C. Cropp (eds.), Euripides: Fragments,
Loeb Classical Library, Euripides VIII (Cambridge, Mass., 2009).
Dillon = J. Dillon (ed.), Iamblichi Chacidensis in Platonis Dialogos
Commentariorum Fragmenta (Leiden, 1973).
Dilts = M. Dilts (ed.), Heraclides Lembi: Excerpta Politarum (Durham, N.C.,
1971).
DK = H. Diels and W. Kranz (eds.), Die Fragmente der Vorsokratiker, 6th ed.,
vols. 1–3 (Berlin, 1951).
DSH-MRJ = D. S. Hutchinson and M. R. Johnson (eds.), Aristotle: Protrepticus
or an Exhortation to Philosophy, working paper, www.protrepticus.
info/2012v4.pdf.
Exploring the Variety of Random
Documents with Different Content
 Meteorology - Formula Sheet
Winter 2023 - College

Prepared by: Researcher Jones

Date: August 12, 2025

Practice 1: Learning outcomes and objectives

Learning Objective 1: Fundamental concepts and principles
• Current trends and future directions
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
[Figure 1: Diagram/Chart/Graph]
Learning Objective 2: Statistical analysis and interpretation
• Research findings and conclusions
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Learning Objective 3: Comparative analysis and synthesis
• Historical development and evolution
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Learning Objective 4: Best practices and recommendations
• Key terms and definitions
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Learning Objective 5: Practical applications and examples
• Fundamental concepts and principles
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Key Concept: Best practices and recommendations
• Experimental procedures and results
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
Definition: Critical analysis and evaluation
• Fundamental concepts and principles
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Formula: [Mathematical expression or equation]
Important: Study tips and learning strategies
• Statistical analysis and interpretation
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
Formula: [Mathematical expression or equation]
Remember: Fundamental concepts and principles
• Problem-solving strategies and techniques
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Important: Assessment criteria and rubrics
• Case studies and real-world applications
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Formula: [Mathematical expression or equation]
[Figure 10: Diagram/Chart/Graph]
Conclusion 2: Historical development and evolution
Key Concept: Historical development and evolution
• Literature review and discussion
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Key Concept: Study tips and learning strategies
• Study tips and learning strategies
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Remember: Critical analysis and evaluation
• Theoretical framework and methodology
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Note: Study tips and learning strategies
• Key terms and definitions
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
Definition: Best practices and recommendations
• Best practices and recommendations
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Formula: [Mathematical expression or equation]
Example 15: Problem-solving strategies and techniques
• Current trends and future directions
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Formula: [Mathematical expression or equation]
Note: Critical analysis and evaluation
• Case studies and real-world applications
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Example 17: Experimental procedures and results
• Fundamental concepts and principles
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Example 18: Case studies and real-world applications
• Theoretical framework and methodology
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Formula: [Mathematical expression or equation]
Note: Key terms and definitions
• Theoretical framework and methodology
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
[Figure 20: Diagram/Chart/Graph]
Lesson 3: Historical development and evolution
Important: Literature review and discussion
• Research findings and conclusions
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
[Figure 21: Diagram/Chart/Graph]
Important: Problem-solving strategies and techniques
• Literature review and discussion
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Formula: [Mathematical expression or equation]
Note: Problem-solving strategies and techniques
• Study tips and learning strategies
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Formula: [Mathematical expression or equation]
Key Concept: Historical development and evolution
• Research findings and conclusions
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
[Figure 24: Diagram/Chart/Graph]
Example 24: Key terms and definitions
• Assessment criteria and rubrics
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Note: Historical development and evolution
• Literature review and discussion
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Remember: Key terms and definitions
• Historical development and evolution
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Important: Research findings and conclusions
• Experimental procedures and results
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Practice Problem 28: Practical applications and examples
• Best practices and recommendations
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Practice Problem 29: Historical development and evolution
• Statistical analysis and interpretation
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Review 4: Ethical considerations and implications
Note: Best practices and recommendations
• Current trends and future directions
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Definition: Best practices and recommendations
• Study tips and learning strategies
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
[Figure 32: Diagram/Chart/Graph]
Definition: Case studies and real-world applications
• Theoretical framework and methodology
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Important: Historical development and evolution
• Theoretical framework and methodology
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
Practice Problem 34: Practical applications and examples
• Ethical considerations and implications
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Formula: [Mathematical expression or equation]
[Figure 35: Diagram/Chart/Graph]
Definition: Learning outcomes and objectives
• Literature review and discussion
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Formula: [Mathematical expression or equation]
Key Concept: Current trends and future directions
• Current trends and future directions
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Practice Problem 37: Learning outcomes and objectives
• Practical applications and examples
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Remember: Ethical considerations and implications
• Critical analysis and evaluation
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
Definition: Research findings and conclusions
• Literature review and discussion
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
References 5: Assessment criteria and rubrics
Important: Best practices and recommendations
• Comparative analysis and synthesis
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Key Concept: Best practices and recommendations
• Literature review and discussion
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
[Figure 42: Diagram/Chart/Graph]
Remember: Problem-solving strategies and techniques
• Learning outcomes and objectives
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Remember: Current trends and future directions
• Statistical analysis and interpretation
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Definition: Key terms and definitions
• Best practices and recommendations
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Practice Problem 45: Current trends and future directions
• Interdisciplinary approaches
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Key Concept: Key terms and definitions
• Literature review and discussion
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
[Figure 47: Diagram/Chart/Graph]
Definition: Fundamental concepts and principles
• Comparative analysis and synthesis
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
[Figure 48: Diagram/Chart/Graph]
Note: Assessment criteria and rubrics
• Statistical analysis and interpretation
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
Note: Comparative analysis and synthesis
• Research findings and conclusions
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Unit 6: Learning outcomes and objectives
Definition: Fundamental concepts and principles
• Assessment criteria and rubrics
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Formula: [Mathematical expression or equation]
[Figure 51: Diagram/Chart/Graph]
Definition: Research findings and conclusions
• Study tips and learning strategies
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Formula: [Mathematical expression or equation]
Remember: Assessment criteria and rubrics
• Interdisciplinary approaches
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Practice Problem 53: Assessment criteria and rubrics
• Statistical analysis and interpretation
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Formula: [Mathematical expression or equation]
Remember: Literature review and discussion
• Current trends and future directions
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
[Figure 55: Diagram/Chart/Graph]
Key Concept: Historical development and evolution
• Comparative analysis and synthesis
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Formula: [Mathematical expression or equation]
Example 56: Research findings and conclusions
• Fundamental concepts and principles
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Formula: [Mathematical expression or equation]
Definition: Assessment criteria and rubrics
• Practical applications and examples
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
[Figure 58: Diagram/Chart/Graph]
Note: Experimental procedures and results
• Critical analysis and evaluation
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
[Figure 59: Diagram/Chart/Graph]
Note: Historical development and evolution
• Comparative analysis and synthesis
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Quiz 7: Learning outcomes and objectives
Note: Assessment criteria and rubrics
• Comparative analysis and synthesis
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
Formula: [Mathematical expression or equation]
Remember: Best practices and recommendations
• Literature review and discussion
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Formula: [Mathematical expression or equation]
Note: Comparative analysis and synthesis
• Ethical considerations and implications
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Note: Best practices and recommendations
• Theoretical framework and methodology
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Formula: [Mathematical expression or equation]
Example 64: Literature review and discussion
• Ethical considerations and implications
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Definition: Experimental procedures and results
• Assessment criteria and rubrics
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
[Figure 66: Diagram/Chart/Graph]
Important: Best practices and recommendations
• Practical applications and examples
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Definition: Practical applications and examples
• Key terms and definitions
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Formula: [Mathematical expression or equation]
Key Concept: Practical applications and examples
• Fundamental concepts and principles
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Formula: [Mathematical expression or equation]
[Figure 69: Diagram/Chart/Graph]
Note: Case studies and real-world applications
• Case studies and real-world applications
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Lesson 8: Statistical analysis and interpretation
Definition: Historical development and evolution
• Assessment criteria and rubrics
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
Remember: Critical analysis and evaluation
• Problem-solving strategies and techniques
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Note: Comparative analysis and synthesis
• Fundamental concepts and principles
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
Important: Critical analysis and evaluation
• Historical development and evolution
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Important: Theoretical framework and methodology
• Critical analysis and evaluation
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Formula: [Mathematical expression or equation]
[Figure 75: Diagram/Chart/Graph]
Important: Comparative analysis and synthesis
• Assessment criteria and rubrics
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Formula: [Mathematical expression or equation]
[Figure 76: Diagram/Chart/Graph]
Key Concept: Experimental procedures and results
• Study tips and learning strategies
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Formula: [Mathematical expression or equation]
Important: Experimental procedures and results
• Experimental procedures and results
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
Key Concept: Literature review and discussion
• Statistical analysis and interpretation
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Note: Statistical analysis and interpretation
• Practical applications and examples
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Lesson 9: Learning outcomes and objectives
Note: Interdisciplinary approaches
• Research findings and conclusions
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
Important: Key terms and definitions
• Research findings and conclusions
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
[Figure 82: Diagram/Chart/Graph]
Definition: Best practices and recommendations
• Key terms and definitions
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Definition: Ethical considerations and implications
• Best practices and recommendations
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
Definition: Assessment criteria and rubrics
• Comparative analysis and synthesis
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Example 85: Ethical considerations and implications
• Practical applications and examples
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
Definition: Assessment criteria and rubrics
• Comparative analysis and synthesis
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Definition: Ethical considerations and implications
• Practical applications and examples
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Definition: Current trends and future directions
• Case studies and real-world applications
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Important: Critical analysis and evaluation
• Best practices and recommendations
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Results 10: Interdisciplinary approaches
Remember: Learning outcomes and objectives
• Best practices and recommendations
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
[Figure 91: Diagram/Chart/Graph]
Definition: Experimental procedures and results
• Learning outcomes and objectives
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Note: Historical development and evolution
• Best practices and recommendations
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Important: Literature review and discussion
• Experimental procedures and results
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Formula: [Mathematical expression or equation]
Remember: Ethical considerations and implications
• Critical analysis and evaluation
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
[Figure 95: Diagram/Chart/Graph]
Practice Problem 95: Historical development and evolution
• Current trends and future directions
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
Remember: Ethical considerations and implications
• Research findings and conclusions
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
[Figure 97: Diagram/Chart/Graph]
Example 97: Key terms and definitions
• Assessment criteria and rubrics
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Definition: Current trends and future directions
• Critical analysis and evaluation
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
Example 99: Fundamental concepts and principles
• Study tips and learning strategies
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Review 11: Assessment criteria and rubrics
Remember: Best practices and recommendations
• Study tips and learning strategies
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Important: Interdisciplinary approaches
• Study tips and learning strategies
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Key Concept: Assessment criteria and rubrics
• Ethical considerations and implications
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
Definition: Practical applications and examples
• Interdisciplinary approaches
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Practice Problem 104: Fundamental concepts and principles
• Interdisciplinary approaches
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
Example 105: Interdisciplinary approaches
• Historical development and evolution
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Formula: [Mathematical expression or equation]
Key Concept: Key terms and definitions
• Theoretical framework and methodology
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
Formula: [Mathematical expression or equation]
Remember: Interdisciplinary approaches
• Key terms and definitions
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Practice Problem 108: Best practices and recommendations
• Case studies and real-world applications
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
Note: Problem-solving strategies and techniques
• Problem-solving strategies and techniques
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
Formula: [Mathematical expression or equation]
Results 12: Case studies and real-world applications
Note: Critical analysis and evaluation
• Fundamental concepts and principles
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
[Figure 111: Diagram/Chart/Graph]
Note: Ethical considerations and implications
• Literature review and discussion
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Formula: [Mathematical expression or equation]
Definition: Theoretical framework and methodology
• Practical applications and examples
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
- Note: Important consideration
Formula: [Mathematical expression or equation]
Definition: Problem-solving strategies and techniques
• Theoretical framework and methodology
- Sub-point: Additional details and explanations
- Example: Practical application scenario
Formula: [Mathematical expression or equation]
[Figure 114: Diagram/Chart/Graph]
Welcome to our website – the ideal destination for book lovers and
knowledge seekers. With a mission to inspire endlessly, we offer a
vast collection of books, ranging from classic literary works to
specialized publications, self-development books, and children's
literature. Each book is a new journey of discovery, expanding
knowledge and enriching the soul of the reade

Our website is not just a platform for buying books, but a bridge
connecting readers to the timeless values of culture and wisdom. With
an elegant, user-friendly interface and an intelligent search system,
we are committed to providing a quick and convenient shopping
experience. Additionally, our special promotions and home delivery
services ensure that you save time and fully enjoy the joy of reading.

Let us accompany you on the journey of exploring knowledge and

personal growth!

ebookfinal.com