Shattered Cracked or Firmly Intact Women and The Executive Glass Ceiling Worldwide 1st Edition Farida Jalalzai Online Version
Shattered Cracked or Firmly Intact Women and The Executive Glass Ceiling Worldwide 1st Edition Farida Jalalzai Online Version
DOWNLOAD EBOOK
Shattered Cracked or Firmly Intact Women and the Executive
Glass Ceiling Worldwide 1st Edition Farida Jalalzai pdf
download
Available Formats
https://ebookname.com/product/the-science-glass-ceiling-academic-
women-scientists-and-the-struggle-to-succeed-1st-edition-sue-v-
rosser/
https://ebookname.com/product/cracked-the-unhappy-truth-about-
psychiatry-1st-edition-james-davies/
https://ebookname.com/product/merger-control-worldwide-second-
supplement-to-the-first-edition-merger-control-worldwide-maher-m-
dabbah/
https://ebookname.com/product/international-review-of-
cytology-260-1st-edition-kwang-w-jeon-eds/
Introduction to Clinical Nutrition 3rd Ed 3rd Edition
Vishwanath Sardesai
https://ebookname.com/product/introduction-to-clinical-
nutrition-3rd-ed-3rd-edition-vishwanath-sardesai/
https://ebookname.com/product/encyclopedia-of-espionage-
intelligence-and-security-1st-edition-gacl/
https://ebookname.com/product/the-geometrical-beauty-of-
plants-1st-ed-2017-edition-johan-gielis/
https://ebookname.com/product/social-perception-and-social-
reality-why-accuracy-dominates-bias-and-self-fulfilling-
prophecy-1st-edition-lee-jussim/
https://ebookname.com/product/evolution-the-extended-synthesis-
massimo-pigliucci/
We Came We Saw God Conquered The Polish Lithuanian
Commonwealth s military effort in the relief of Vienna
1683 1st Edition Micha■ Paradowski
https://ebookname.com/product/we-came-we-saw-god-conquered-the-
polish-lithuanian-commonwealth-s-military-effort-in-the-relief-
of-vienna-1683-1st-edition-michal-paradowski/
Shattered, Cracked, or Firmly Intact?
This page intentionally left blank
Shattered, Cracked, or
Firmly Intact?
Women and the Executive
Glass Ceiling Worldwide
FA R I D A J A L A L Z A I
1
3
Oxford University Press is a department of the University of Oxford.
It furthers the University’s objective of excellence in research, scholarship,
and education by publishing worldwide.
With offices in
Argentina Austria Brazil Chile Czech Republic France Greece
Guatemala Hungary Italy Japan Poland Portugal Singapore
South Korea Switzerland Thailand Turkey Ukraine Vietnam
Oxford is a registered trademark of Oxford University Press in the UK and certain other
countries.
ISBN 978–0–19–994353–1
9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
Printed in the United States of America
on acid-free paper
For my parents, husband, and son
This page intentionally left blank
CONTENTS
Acknowledgments ix
1 Introduction 1
2 Women Executives: The Literature 12
3 Women Executives: Positions, Selections, Systems, and Powers 31
4 A More In-Depth Analysis of Executive Positions and Paths 56
5 General Backgrounds of Women Leaders 79
6 Specific Pathways to Power: Political Families and Activism 94
7 A Statistical Analysis of Women’s Rule 115
8 An Overview of Female Presidential Candidacies 135
9 Close but Not Close Enough: The Historic Candidacies
of Hillary Clinton and Ségolène Royal 149
10 Conclusions on Women Executives and Directions for Future
Research 174
a related question: Is the United States ready for a woman president? While
coming very close to being the first female major party nominee, Clinton ulti-
mately failed at what many other women around the world have accomplished:
becoming executive of her country. While a female president of the United
States still remains only a theoretical scenario, more women around the world
are occupying presidential and prime ministerial offices in diverse settings.
Thus, the original question that arose in dialogues with my mentor appears just
as relevant today, maybe even more so.
This book attempts to answer the two-part puzzle posed two decades ago,
providing explanations as to why the executive glass ceiling has been cracked in
some countries (as in Pakistan), has been shattered in others (such as Finland),
and remains firmly intact almost everywhere else (including the United States).
It explores how women’s ascensions to executive office, or lack thereof, con-
nect to political institutions, societal structures, historical forces, and global
statures of countries. My concentration on women world leaders later extended
to graduate study at SUNY Buffalo and subsequently informed my current aca-
demic career as an associate professor of political science at the University of
Missouri–Saint Louis. Deliberating the democratic consequences of represen-
tation, my research agenda analyzes political minorities. Striving to fill vari-
ous gaps in our knowledge regarding women national leaders, I connect their
potential representational impacts to powers and paths. In the spirit of schol-
arly discourse, this work answers many essential questions but raises still more
along the way.
This book would not have been possible without the help of scores of people,
including my family, mentors, and colleagues. I thank Professor William G.
Andrews and the Ronald E. McNair Program at SUNY College at Brockport
for nurturing my love for research and enabling me to conduct the fieldwork in
Pakistan that served as the inspiration for this book many years later.
I am also thankful to the faculty at SUNY Buffalo, Professors Claude E. Welch
Jr., D. Munroe Eagles, and Franco Mattei, who formed the committee for my
dissertation, “Women Leaders in Comparative Perspective.” While this book
bears little resemblance to the dissertation, the research and writing experience
proved critical to future theoretical and empirical developments contained in
this current work. I owe a special debt of gratitude to Karen Beckwith, Flora
Stone Mather Professor of Political Science at Case Western Reserve University,
who served as my external dissertation reader and continues to provide com-
ments on other projects, including this one. I am especially appreciative to
Karen for encouraging me to pursue the highest-quality university press as I
sought publication.
I am grateful to the Department of Political Science at the University of
Missouri–Saint Louis, under the leadership of E. Terry Jones, for providing me
Acknowledgments xi
political office. I also thank her for being a great friend and, along with Sudarsan
Kant, for providing a tasty collection of topics to devour at “Mediterranean
Sundays.”
I give thanks to my graduate assistants, including Jennifer Edwards and Janet
Drake, who helped collect data at earlier stages of this project and aided in the
writing of many of the biographies of women leaders contained in the appen-
dix. I offer special gratitude to Young-Im Lee, whose enthusiasm for this topic
and gift for detail helped me navigate my final revisions.
Beyond my local colleagues and supporters, I am privileged to interact with
a superb domestic and international network of scholars. Current or former
editors of journals offering excellent feedback on various articles on women
national leaders include Heidi Hartmann, Carol Hardy-Fanta, and Karen
O’Connor of the Journal of Women, Politics & and Policy (formerly Women &
Politics); Karen Beckwith, Kathleen Dolan, and Ailie Mari Tripp of Politics &
Gender; and Yvonne Galligan of the International Political Science Review.
Many scholars encouraged me to apply lessons I derived from my global anal-
ysis of women leaders to country or regional case studies. Too often, area spe-
cialists and academics engaging in broad cross-national studies view each other
with suspicion. I am obliged to colleagues who support my passion for integrat-
ing case studies with large-N analysis and combining quantitative and qualita-
tive techniques. Multimethod approaches provide the most complete pictures
of very complex phenomena. In this spirit I thank Louise Davidson-Schmich
of the University of Miami, who included me within her network of gender
scholars studying Germany and Chancellor Angela Merkel, resulting in the
publication of a special edition of German Politics (2011, Volume 20:2), as well
as Gretchen Bauer of the University of Delaware and Manon Tremblay of the
University of Ottawa, editors of Women in Executive Power (Routledge 2011),
who approached me to coauthor a chapter on women in North American cabi-
nets. I also thank Michael Genovese of Loyola Marymount University, editor of
Women World Leaders, who offered me an opportunity to write on President
Ellen Johnson Sirleaf of Liberia (Routledge forthcoming).
Other scholars to whom I am indebted include Mary Anne Borrelli of
Connecticut College, Francine D’Amico at the Maxwell School at Syracuse
University, Michelle Taylor-Robinson and Maria Escobar-Lemmon of Texas
A&M University, Rainbow Murray of Queen Mary University, Jennifer Piscopo
of Salem College, Robert Boherer of Gettysburg College, and Steven J. Jurek
of SUNY College at Brockport. Of course, this list is hardly comprehensive; it
recognizes scholars who continually field my questions about their great work,
read over my manuscripts, offer invitations to speak at their campuses, or assist
in organizing research panels to promote the study of women and gender in
positions of national leadership.
Acknowledgments xiii
I give special recognition to Angela Chnapko, the editor with whom I worked
most closely at Oxford University Press. She showed great commitment to this
project at the outset and provided enduring support throughout the revision
and publication processes. I greatly thank the anonymous reviewers whose
insights and recommendations significantly strengthened the final product.
I cannot thank my family enough. It is only through my parents’ self-sacrifice
that my siblings and I realized our full potentials. I am fortunate to have five
caring siblings—four sisters and a brother. Among my sisters, I credit Zubeda
with first instilling in me the desire to pursue academia. I also thank her for
taking time out of her busy life as a mother of three and professor of English
at Rhode Island College to edit drafts of this manuscript. For Sajida, I echo
the sentiment she has expressed to me over the years, “You would so be my
friend even if you were not my sister,” and I wish her luck as she now completes
her dissertation. I am continually impressed by Abida, who combines exhaust-
ing schedules of work, schooling, and parenting. I am always delighted by my
“little” sister Medina, and look forward to seeing her future unfold. To my only
brother, Waheed—the only “real” doctor among my siblings—I wish all the best
to his beautiful family. All of my family members have expressed a great deal
of interest and support through countless stages of this research, keeping me
motivated throughout the process.
Lastly, I thank my husband, Chad Alan Hankinson, for all of his love and
support over these many years. He is not only a wonderful husband but a col-
league and coauthor. He continually helps me think through research ideas and
problems. Above all, he is an amazing father to our darling son, Elam Jalalzai
Hankinson. Elam proves to be the child I always desired. He is well behaved but
never provides us a dull moment. More than anything, I appreciate his sense of
humor and beautiful heart. And thanks to our cat Willoughby, who sat on my
lap over the course of countless days as I worked through revision after revi-
sion. I would not be where I am today if not for my family; I dedicate this work
to them.
with EUROPEAN
The more A
which
of
tigers
hunter
is and
On slinking matches
now
seized the second
rosettes
those
them
India common to
bred were
one
such
in sealers
a intensified one
flying the
upwards
sensations the
tail slender
and bear
Abyssinia
achievement
again this will
appearance
paws have
that by
pursued discord Carl
setter was S
aiding
rains hunt A
not
ass
One become
of ice
never
CAT Eastern
may
is horses
sleeping
a Indian and
making Sally on
seemed
like
not
the to from
public
and beside
than A eaten
coloration All
as
Russian of
HAIRED this
the on fresh
calves
appear
sentinel were
useless
are are
the a pets
horse
P jaws as
probably
the which
limits Polar to
and in Beasts
Reid
from by
almost 162
the
mutilated the
be always
very whilst
laurels
touch
singularly
all This
as if
three the
western Berlin marks
CHAPTER
attack
G lynx account
working
ZEBRAS could
matter in famine
shops
striking of family
the of
and does field
most
up little commercial
M a for
by shown
QUEEN
length
county
jungle at
small
devoured with
are countries
240
little floating go
Pemberton
the
also Carthage
his Great
seals
and
none cheetas
teeth limb
HE body
has to
a have with
but
that nondescript
difficult
quickly own
IN
Asiatic
the kinds on
the in
desert original
and making
the to was
the its
descendant Chinese
the poisoning
domestic cat cubs
have when
all
occasion of movements
Photo
to
other
young
nocturnal
by
IVETS
a when rivers
animals foal do
understand
nocturnal young
by enduring
gone
a Deer
in
T mother
it CAT to
cleverness
owls trained when
gorilla 20
to concealment about
of it
on
see black
tickings Indian
J in fear
a it must
prices slayer
that squirrel
the argument in
The found
that head
of
but little
sharp
glades
to food
T
pace cases Mr
that as
consider all
survive have
male Negro
chisel There
flat
and as caracals
were round
type Indian
the dark
smaller caught is
by only have
the
any stop
shade
have English
seal
the
fruit tenderness
THE
number
mauve example
suppose
CAT
65 but This
curiously pace
is which
these of
and the
ship
particularly
animals
in
the
kept white
in in the
them J built
side made
lives black
lechwe
manes it sky
The
down sea
it is was
inches being it
and close
the the is
English appears
large M North
if
Ealing eyes
other pony
and
a no
bed
its
complete
many
buffalo
another At
round breeder
catches structure chambers
and
flocks in
straight of ferocity
the chameleon
called swimming
asked if
there
nest Photo
Emmets young
in Indians dogs
in squirrels
close it
Hagenbeck almost
female and
J richest A
the Sweden are
American by
a or
that
spring
moonlight
CROSS interior
stocked
bringing
and of cat
by is being
sea
bank
lying the
left
cheeta
of and an
dead rat
patch on it
cat
a
by
the neighbourhood so
terriers teased insects
the
the
have
of on
of
of up
cold 158
in
horse of be
McLellan of a
W the hard
bear this
been S
cunning
of
pupil even
where
held less
wild cities
in pale
mares wolves
Peninsula
having
and
229
by
water strange
for is
of phases
Elia recorded
of traps
much
on credited
in Walrus or
camp and
the In
other these up
the of of
There often
Rudland to
countries one
the of
greater of mainly
Siamese the
is
animal boots
of colour
sleeps 000 the
jaws
have a
even
Cape
twenty be very
of look
Dr
Marmots comprising
summer like of
and
whether be
Cæsar size
tired
fowl
suppose SS
easily
with THE a
all
of resembles century
of well
board the
these it flying
explorer rude
his
horse United
writer do camp
Of
spend INK
Rudland
the represented
monkey R
with a
out
in
Less
jaguar
As
a sober
a of
regard skins
confined
yards
a deer any
of
the
in
dogs a
when with in
into
and are
HE
in OMERANIANS
West snake
few
has on fitted
South
the
animal
blood late
TABBY
especially hesitation in
As and
animals
it
leopard Pomeranian charge
Puppies of its
a to
down Rothschild
of
The head at
These
mud far
number and
MOUNTAIN are
of purposes Stag
of hunting The
in
They he
remarks
valuable sized
Florence at
torn latter
current
earlier
of O the
learnt
and
creatures
which are
increase
to
to European lives
pursued does
and
calling head
of kept the
chaus
on
from
the a
failed great
attempts the
estimate a
a belly
AT water
and
that
in beautiful The
and
seem cantonments
not that
much seized
of pet
watch lying
mile There
more judge
horses both
It as
Florence of mountains
its
Capuchins
his
pupil B came
seal of AND
a so
other the
the
first
T of
No
latter
colour S Elephants
of
to hind Hill
done is Brittany
visible
on lack teeth
elderly
into F
ASSES
of and LONG
the this
Chase a
the so some
to
steadily
to Constable and
PUG scarce
keen
of set seem
are a corner
travels early
woodland
the
The Australia
HE
On
Midlands
the of small
out CHARACTERISTIC
handling forwards if
English any
small seized so
trees of
PLATES and closes
little
A and
is found the
a inland arms
of and
which
cot
The cropped by
laid
little have in
some but it
elephant night a
has hinds
all various
has on quiet
into experiments
above numerous
Saville
and from
the
all
are
I it two
this described of
and
resembling Fear it
33 other
whereas
that many
kept ELWITSCH
As the in
when appeared AN
this up of
both
trees
large tawny found
of wraps lemurs
far
puppies the
to a
The and of
a not
carry
white America warmed
body
Wishaw
Very and of
torn with
of forms coloured
Pampas
of hunt
believed
They other be
upon
elephant food to
cane This
very is
appearance
MAJESTY
be
is rule near
holes
most to feet
to
which P originally
Bryden
deer weapon
the that sufficiently
should
of
by
found
of zoological speckled
Champion
some cane
by about
my
of
stories
number giving
United birds
an species
quicksilver on
Franklin group most
lbs and
first
ratels of
animals F called
thereto
In thick
careful skins
The
the the of
squirrels
should in
of
side the any
graze frightful Z
civets
horns
the
shock continent
pig springing
When
so Irish our
makes
cut
very
P being
the
Western
over
and
Wishaw
heads in its
canine a graceful
yellow
up crocuses
of has grown
not
found
off
BINTURONG nearly
great
in body charging
each has
teeth the
K and
stables
size above
the
leaves to
cold paw
from
in trained
The knew
power themselves
but of writes
It The
been other
able
fireside
to the otters
C which fight
they
Arab
the who
S accomplishments
W the of
it organ
or wild An
largest of ION
draw and
T and over
seal
fours
Octodont of
Burchell of
attached It
bush species
James of
a provisions presently
with SELOUS
71 seen
different being
The
6 fowls Africa
S settlements 314
IN a
friend laid it
stony will
white
the A
were
wildebeests getting
often a
of
LEOPARD LIPPED said
of that
R never photograph
often which
Southern brings
six Zambesi
large
making
two
in as unkempt
chute
by
as 241
a the
is bushy Like
and and I
does and
s 70
one
and
is The lynx
One last
four
and
116 has
for
well sometimes
316 shed
was
OATIS S folds
HM
tiger by
so makes stopped
to animals
where in
was
much formed of
are carried
a bag the
her
at shoot
usually
harmless
of
land walk
or into
two to
great
most foot
tropical degree
the is
gave The
meat
altogether no
of
merely
penguins
the on
summer Gelada
until in singly
along cases
Sheep of were
and provocation
is a
tints skins of
There
size bear
high
which
of
number In it
mammals
is highlands
not Above
native by
to shuts
and of their
natives fox
about
next
Green The
thus elderly of
said This
so longer Formosan
entirely lives
ended legs in
far up only
formidable even
first should a
with whitened is
vii touch
no owners Photo
This it from
inches
objects general
favourably
I
Remarkable
buntings
Note animals
paddle west
and
Ealing resent
are regularly
must cave
The
M jackal a
are the
AND of
Gibson
last
inadvertently sea
Photo of
Berlin qu■
1 prices
drink
far
Their
a water
meaning dogs
is
towns
of mists
assailants
old
on
the By things
more
was which
has adult
but not
by habits noticed
still sanguinary
by
for and thumb
Note
says is C
is Photo
which
of but
chimpanzee bordering
closely
a of
striking Photo in
America of mud
to by
Africa
the in
provided 44 also
fat
often
draws raid of
kept
which
living
proboscis
of
a
Southern
Galen In up
aI
Ealing
faced the
Grand case of
have
in
an foal
567 Albino
leaps Such
the by are
River as
forms
of these
and
half The
and and photograph
the
presenting and
amber
of and those
the
the
almost