Family Law Notes 2025
Family Law Notes 2025
1. (a) Discuss the origin, concept and nature of Hindu Law. [8] (b) Who are Hindus? [8]
(c) Is Hindu Law 'lex loci'?Explain.[5]
ANS:- (A) Origin:
Hindu Law has its roots in ancient India, tracing back to the Vedas, a collection of sacred texts
considered revelations from God. These texts, along with the Upanishads and other scriptures,
provided the philosophical and religious foundation for Hindu society, including its legal and
social norms.
Concept:
At its core, Hindu Law is deeply intertwined with the concept of Dharma. Dharma encompasses a
wide range of principles, including religious, moral, social, and legal duties. It's not merely a set
of rules but a way of life that emphasizes righteousness, harmony, and the pursuit of spiritual
liberation.
Nature:
• Personal Law: Hindu Law primarily governs personal matters such as marriage, divorce,
adoption, inheritance, and succession. It's considered a personal law, meaning it applies to
individuals who identify as Hindus, regardless of their geographical location.
• Diverse Schools of Thought: Over centuries, different schools of thought emerged within
Hindu Law, leading to variations in its interpretation and application across regions.
• Dynamic and Evolving: Hindu Law is not static; it has evolved over time, influenced by social,
cultural, and religious changes. It has also been shaped by legislative enactments and judicial
interpretations.
Key Points:
• Emphasis on Dharma: The concept of Dharma is central to Hindu Law, guiding individual
conduct and social order.
• Focus on Personal Matters: It primarily governs personal and family matters, reflecting its
origins in social and religious traditions.
• Diversity and Regional Variations: The existence of different schools of thought and regional
customs has led to diverse interpretations of Hindu Law.
• Continuous Evolution: Hindu Law is not a rigid system; it has adapted to changing social
realities and has been influenced by modern legal and social developments.
(B) Defining who is a Hindu can be complex due to the diverse nature of Hinduism. However,
generally, a Hindu is someone who:
• Identifies with Hinduism: This is a core aspect. Individuals may self-identify as Hindu based
on cultural, religious, or spiritual reasons.
• Adheres to Hindu Beliefs and Practices: This can encompass a wide range of beliefs and
practices, including:
o Belief in Karma and Reincarnation: These concepts play a significant role in Hindu
philosophy and guide individual actions.
o Following Hindu Scriptures: While the extent of adherence varies, many Hindus
consider the Vedas, Upanishads, Bhagavad Gita, and other scriptures as sacred texts.
o Observing Hindu Rituals and Traditions: This may include practices such as puja
(worship), meditation, yoga, and celebrating festivals.
• May or May Not Worship Specific Deities: Hinduism encompasses a wide spectrum of
beliefs, from monotheism to polytheism. Some Hindus may worship specific deities like
Vishnu, Shiva, or Devi, while others may focus on the concept of Brahman, the ultimate
reality.
It's important to note that Hinduism is a diverse religion with various schools of thought and
practices. There is no single, universally accepted definition of who is a Hindu.
(C) Hindu Law is not strictly a "lex loci" system, meaning it's not solely governed by the law of the
place where a legal act occurs. Here's why:
• Personal Law: Hindu Law primarily functions as a personal law. This means it applies to
individuals who identify as Hindus, regardless of their geographical location.
• Focus on Personal Matters: It primarily governs personal matters like marriage, divorce,
inheritance, and succession, which are deeply intertwined with religious and social
customs.
• Influence of Regional Customs: While not solely determined by location, regional customs
and practices can influence the application of Hindu Law in certain areas.
In essence:
While regional factors can play a role, Hindu Law's primary focus on personal identity and
religious principles distinguishes it from a purely "lex loci" system.
Hindu Law has evolved over centuries through religious texts, customs, judicial interpretations,
and legislative reforms. Its sources are broadly classified into Ancient Sources and Modern
Sources.
1. Ancient Sources
These are the foundational elements of Hindu Law, rooted in religion, customs, and philosophical
traditions:
• It refers to the four Vedas (Rig, Yajur, Sama, and Atharva), which are the earliest scriptures of
Hinduism.
• They provide moral principles, religious rituals, and the basis for Dharma (righteousness).
• These are secondary scriptures that elaborate on the principles found in the Vedas.
o Narada Smriti and Parashara Smriti: Address specific legal and social issues.
• Examples:
(iv) Customs:
• Custom (Achara) is a recognized source of law if it is ancient, reasonable, and consistent with
the principles of Dharma.
• Types of customs:
2. Modern Sources
• Courts in India have played a significant role in interpreting and shaping Hindu Law.
• Precedents established by the judiciary have become binding and are a vital source of law.
• Example: The Privy Council decisions during British rule and later rulings of the Supreme
Court of India.
(ii) Legislation:
• Modern statutes have codified and reformed various aspects of Hindu Law.
• Examples include:
• When no specific rule is available, courts rely on principles of equity, justice, and good
conscience to resolve disputes.
• Hindu Law has been influenced by the English legal system during British rule.
• Concepts like judicial review and legal codification were introduced in India.
Conclusion
The sources of Hindu Law reflect a balance between tradition and modernity. Ancient sources
ensure that the law remains rooted in cultural and religious principles, while modern sources
ensure it evolves to meet contemporary needs. Together, these sources make Hindu Law a
dynamic and adaptable legal system.
3. Whether the child will be Hindu in the following cases? - Give rcasons for your
answer.
(i) A child is born of Hindu father and Sikh mother.
(ii) A child is born of Hindu mother and Muslim father.
(iii) A child is born of Hindu parents. He is brought up as Hindu. Subsequently mother
converts to Islam.[3*3]
ANS:-
• Under Hindu Law, both Hinduism and Sikhism are recognized as part of the broader Hindu
religious tradition.
• Section 2(1)(b) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, states that Hindu Law applies to individuals
who are Hindus, Buddhists, Jains, or Sikhs.
• Since the father is Hindu and the mother is Sikh, the child is presumed to fall under the
Hindu Law unless there is a specific agreement or upbringing contrary to this presumption.
• If the child is brought up as a Hindu (e.g., with Hindu religious rites and customs), the child
will be considered Hindu.
• However, if the child is brought up as a Muslim (e.g., with Islamic traditions), the child will
not be governed by Hindu Law.
• Courts may look at the dominant influence in the child's life to determine the applicable
personal law.
(iii) A child is born of Hindu parents. He is brought up as a Hindu. Subsequently, the mother
converts to Islam
• The religion of a child born to Hindu parents is determined at birth, and subsequent
conversion of one parent does not alter the child's religion unless the child is expressly
converted.
• Since the child is brought up as a Hindu and there is no evidence of conversion, Hindu Law
will continue to apply to the child.
• Conversion of one parent does not automatically affect the child's religion or status under
Hindu Law unless both parents agree to raise the child under the new religion.
4. (a) Discuss 'custom' as a source of law. [10] (b) What are the requisites of
valid custom?[8] (c) What are the kinds of custom?[8]
ANS:- (A) Custom as a Source of Law
Definition of Custom:
Custom is a long-standing practice or usage, consistently observed within a community, that has
gained legal validity through recognition. It reflects the traditions, habits, and practices of a group
and serves as an expression of their collective will.
1. Historical Foundation:
o In ancient societies, before the development of codified laws, customs were the primary
source of legal rules.
o In Hindu Law, customs predate formal legislation and have been considered a key
foundation for regulating social and personal conduct.
o Manu Smriti emphasizes custom as the "root of Dharma" and superior to other sources
of law.
o Even today, customs are enforceable if they meet certain criteria, as specified under
modern statutes like the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955.
3. Legal Recognition:
o Courts and legislatures acknowledge valid customs and often incorporate them into
statutory law.
o For example, customary practices around marriage, adoption, and inheritance have
shaped Hindu personal law.
o Customs adapt to the needs of specific communities, regions, or families, ensuring local
relevance and social acceptance.
1. Unwritten Nature: Customs often originate as unwritten practices but gain legal authority
over time.
2. Community Consent: Customs derive their authority from the acceptance and practice of
the people.
3. Superseding Other Laws: In certain cases, valid customs may override general laws, provided
they are not in conflict with public policy or statutory law.
Custom in Modern Legal Systems
In contemporary legal systems, the significance of custom has diminished with the codification of
laws. However, customs still play a supplementary role:
1. Hindu Marriage Act, 1955: Recognizes marriages solemnized according to valid customs and
rites.
2. Hindu Succession Act, 1956: Regional customs influence inheritance in certain areas, such as
the Marumakkattayam system in Kerala.
Conclusion
Custom is a vital source of law that bridges the gap between traditional practices and formal legal
systems. Although modern statutes dominate, the enduring recognition of valid customs ensures
that law remains connected to the cultural and social fabric of society.
For a custom to be recognized as legally valid and enforceable, it must meet the following essential
requirements:
1. Antiquity
• A custom must be ancient and time-honored. It should have been practiced for an extended
period, often referred to as "time immemorial."
• Legal Recognition: Courts often require evidence that the custom existed for a significant
time before being challenged or codified.
2. Reasonableness
• A custom must be fair, just, and reasonable. It should not be arbitrary or oppressive.
3. Certainty
• The custom must be precise, clear, and unambiguous in its terms and application.
4. Continuity
• The custom must have been practiced continuously and without interruption.
• Any substantial break in its observance may suggest it is no longer binding or accepted by
the community.
• A custom should not conflict with statutory law unless the law explicitly allows exceptions for
customs.
• Example: Under the Hindu Marriage Act, customs are recognized as valid if they do not
violate the provisions of the Act.
6. Obligatory Nature
• The custom must be considered binding and obligatory by the community. It should not be
optional or followed sporadically.
7. Morality
• A custom must align with public morality and not be repugnant to principles of justice or
good conscience.
• Example: Practices such as child marriage or Sati are considered immoral and have been
declared invalid, even if historically practiced.
8. General Acceptance
• A custom must be widely accepted and uniformly followed by the community or group to
which it applies.
Conclusion
A valid custom must fulfill these requisites to ensure it is fair, reasonable, and consistent with legal
and moral standards. While customs play an important role in personal laws like Hindu Law, their
validity is subject to scrutiny under contemporary legal frameworks.
(C ) Kinds of Custom
Customs can be classified based on their scope, application, and enforceability. The following are the
main types of customs:
1. Local Customs
• Characteristics: These customs apply only to people residing in or connected to that locality.
• Examples:
2. Family Customs
• Examples:
• Characteristics:
• Examples:
4. General Customs
• Characteristics:
• Examples:
5. Conventional Customs
• Definition: Customs based on mutual agreement between parties.
• Characteristics:
o These customs can override general legal provisions if agreed upon by all parties.
• Examples:
6. Legal Customs
• Definition: Customs recognized and enforced by courts as having the force of law.
• Characteristics:
• Examples:
7. Non-Legal Customs
• Definition: Customs that are followed due to social or moral obligation but are not
enforceable by law.
• Characteristics:
• Examples:
Conclusion
Customs are categorized based on their scope and application, ranging from localized practices to
general traditions. Their classification reflects the diversity of societal norms and their varying
influence on personal and legal matters.
5. (a) The nature of Hindu marriage whether a sacrament or a contract? - Give reasons for
your answer. [8] (b) What are the essential conditions of a valid Hindu marriage?[8] (c)
What is void marriage ?[ 5]
ANS:- (A) The Nature of Hindu Marriage: Sacrament or Contract?
Hindu marriage is a unique institution deeply rooted in religious, cultural, and legal traditions. The
debate about its nature—whether it is a sacrament or a contract—stems from its dual aspects of
spiritual sanctity and societal obligations.
• In traditional Hindu philosophy, marriage is considered a sacred union, not merely a legal or
social arrangement.
• It is a samskara (a sacred rite of passage), aiming to fulfill three purposes: Dharma (duty),
Praja (progeny), and Rati (companionship).
2. Indissolubility of Marriage:
• In its classical form, Hindu marriage was indissoluble, symbolizing a bond that lasts not only
for one lifetime but for seven lifetimes (as per Hindu belief).
• Divorce was not recognized traditionally, which reinforces its sacramental nature.
3. Ceremonial Rites:
• The solemnization of marriage involves elaborate rituals like Saptapadi (seven steps) and
Mangalsutra tying, which have deep religious significance.
• These rites emphasize the spiritual and moral duties of the couple.
• In traditional Hindu law, personal consent was secondary to the parents' or elders' decision,
further supporting the idea of marriage as a sacrament over a contractual agreement.
• Modern reforms, particularly the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, have introduced contractual
elements into Hindu marriage.
o Conditions such as free consent, legal age, and absence of prohibited degrees of
relationship highlight the contractual nature.
o Provisions for divorce, annulment, and restitution of conjugal rights also shift the
perception of marriage from indissolubility to a dissoluble contract.
• Marriage creates legally enforceable rights and obligations between the spouses, such as
maintenance, guardianship, and property rights.
Contemporary Perspective
• Sacramental Aspect: The rituals and religious connotations remain integral, especially for
spiritual-minded families.
• Contractual Aspect: The legal framework, rights, and duties introduced by modern
legislation ensure that marriage serves as a social institution with enforceable obligations.
Conclusion
Hindu marriage, in its traditional sense, is primarily a sacrament, symbolizing a lifelong spiritual
union. However, with modern legal reforms, it has also incorporated contractual elements, making it
a hybrid institution that balances religious sanctity with legal pragmatism. This dual nature ensures
its relevance in both traditional and contemporary contexts.
Under the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, the following conditions must be fulfilled for a Hindu marriage
to be valid:
• Neither party should have a living spouse at the time of the marriage.
• They should not be of unsound mind or suffer from mental disorders that make them unfit
for marriage or procreation.
• The groom must be at least 21 years old and the bride at least 18 years old.
• Marriages solemnized below these ages are not void but may attract legal penalties under
the Prohibition of Child Marriage Act, 2006.
4. Prohibited Degrees of Relationship (Section 5(iv))
• The parties should not be within the degrees of prohibited relationships unless a valid
custom or tradition permits such a marriage.
• Prohibited relationships include close blood relations, such as siblings, parent-child, or uncle-
niece.
• The couple must not fall within the sapinda relationship, which refers to relationships
through common ancestors within five generations from the paternal side and three
generations from the maternal side.
• The marriage must be performed according to customary rites and ceremonies, which may
include the Saptapadi (seven steps) ritual or other recognized practices.
Conclusion
These conditions ensure the validity of a Hindu marriage under the law. Non-compliance with these
provisions may result in the marriage being declared void or voidable.
Definition:
A void marriage is a marriage that is considered invalid from the outset (ab initio) under the law and
has no legal standing or recognition. It is as though the marriage never occurred.
1. Bigamy:
o If the parties are within the prohibited degrees of relationship, unless permitted by
custom.
3. Sapinda Relationship:
o If the marriage violates the sapinda relationship restrictions, unless permitted by
custom.
• Children born from a void marriage are considered legitimate under Section 16 of the Hindu
Marriage Act.
Conclusion
A void marriage lacks legal recognition and is treated as if it never existed. This ensures that the
essential conditions for marriage are upheld in the interest of societal and legal norms.
6. Define following (any four): [4*4] (a) Full blood & Half blood (b) Uterine blood (c)
Sapinda relationship (d) Agnate & Cognate (e) Dharma. (f) Restitution of Conjugal Rights.
(g) Intestate. (h) Declaration under the Special Marriage Act. (i)Disqualification from
inheritance
ANS:- (A) Full Blood & Half Blood
Full Blood:
• They are born of the same father and the same mother.
• Example: Two brothers or sisters born to the same parents are considered "full blood"
siblings.
Half Blood:
• Refers to siblings who share only one parent in common, either the father or the mother.
• They have different mothers or different fathers but are connected through one parent.
• Example:
This distinction ensures that closer familial ties (full blood) are prioritized in matters like inheritance
and succession.
Definition:
Uterine blood refers to the relationship between siblings who share the same mother but have
different fathers. Such siblings are referred to as "uterine siblings" (e.g., uterine brothers or uterine
sisters).
Characteristics:
1. Common Mother:
o These siblings are born from different fathers but share the same mother.
o Uterine siblings differ from full-blood siblings (same mother and father) and paternal
half-blood siblings (same father but different mothers).
Example:
• If a woman has children from two different marriages, her children from both marriages are
uterine siblings.
o Uterine siblings are recognized as legal heirs but inherit only when full-blood and
half-blood siblings are not present.
• Priority in Inheritance:
o In cases of inheritance disputes, uterine siblings rank lower than full-blood siblings.
This relationship ensures recognition of maternal lineage in family law, particularly in inheritance and
succession matters.
Generational Limits:
1. Paternal Lineage:
o The relationship extends up to five generations from the common male ancestor
(inclusive of the individual).
2. Maternal Lineage:
o The relationship extends up to three generations from the common female ancestor
(inclusive of the individual).
1. Marriage Restrictions:
2. Void Marriages:
Example:
Purpose:
The sapinda rule safeguards genetic health and reinforces societal and familial boundaries in Hindu
marriage practices.
(D) Agnate
Definition:
• Agnates are relatives who are connected through male lineage only.
• It refers to individuals related through the male descendants, whether directly or indirectly.
• Example:
Key Feature:
• Agnates include both male and female relatives but the connection is through the male side
(paternal lineage).
Cognate
Definition:
• Cognates are relatives who are connected through both paternal and maternal sides but not
through male lineage alone.
• They include people related to an individual by blood from either the mother’s side or the
father’s side.
• Example:
Key Feature:
• Cognates are related through both parents, but their relationship is not strictly based on the
male side.
1. Agnates:
2. Cognates:
o Cognates inherit only after the agnates have received their share.
Conclusion:
The distinction between agnates and cognates determines the order of succession and inheritance
under Hindu law, with agnates taking precedence over cognates. These terms highlight the
importance of paternal lineage (agnates) in legal matters like property inheritance.
(E) Dharma
Definition:
Dharma is a complex and central concept in Hindu philosophy, encompassing the moral, ethical, and
religious duties and responsibilities that an individual must uphold. It refers to the righteous path,
guiding one's actions in accordance with universal principles of truth, justice, and harmony.
1. Moral Code:
o Dharma is the code of conduct that governs both personal and societal behavior. It
sets the standards for right and wrong, promoting fairness, compassion, and ethical
living.
2. Religious Duty:
3. Social Responsibilities:
o Dharma also includes duties related to one's role in society. This varies based on
one's caste, age, gender, and social position (known as varna and ashrama).
o Dharma is not absolute and may vary based on individual circumstances (e.g., age,
social position, family role). This flexibility is important in understanding dharma as a
guide to appropriate action in specific situations.
o The Bhagavad Gita illustrates this through the concept of Swadharma—one’s own
duty, which may differ from the duties of others.
1. Personal Life:
o A person’s dharma may involve honesty, non-violence (ahimsa), and respect for all
beings.
o A parent’s dharma is to nurture and guide their children, while a teacher’s dharma is
to impart knowledge.
2. Social Life:
o Dharma can also refer to justice in society, such as following laws, helping the needy,
and respecting the rights of others.
3. Spiritual Life:
o Performing religious duties, meditating, and adhering to spiritual teachings are also
aspects of dharma, aimed at spiritual growth and liberation (moksha).
Conclusion:
Dharma serves as a guide to righteous living, aligning personal behavior with universal ethical
principles, ensuring balance in the individual, social, and cosmic realms. It forms the foundation for a
harmonious, just, and fulfilling life.
Definition:
Restitution of conjugal rights refers to the legal remedy available to a spouse who has been deprived
of the society of the other spouse without a valid reason. It is a right to seek the return of a partner
to the marital home and the resumption of marital relations. This concept is primarily found in the
Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 and similar personal laws governing marriage in other communities.
Legal Provision:
Under Section 9 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, a spouse can file a petition for restitution of
conjugal rights if the other spouse has withdrawn from the society of the petitioner without
reasonable cause. The court can direct the withdrawing spouse to resume marital relations.
• Filing a Petition:
o Either spouse (husband or wife) can file a petition before the family court seeking
restitution if the other has withdrawn from cohabitation without a justifiable cause.
o The court may pass an order for the spouse to return to the marital home and
cohabit with the petitioner.
o If the spouse against whom the restitution petition is filed does not comply with the
court’s order, the court may impose penalties or even grant a divorce if the non-
compliance continues for a specified period.
o A spouse may not be compelled to return if there are valid reasons for withdrawal,
such as cruelty, desertion, or physical or mental abuse. These reasons may prevent
the restitution order from being passed.
o Restitution of conjugal rights does not end a marriage or lead to a legal separation. It
is merely a step toward restoring the relationship.
1. Encourages Reconciliation:
o This remedy is intended to encourage reconciliation and provide a way to restore the
marriage without resorting to divorce.
2. Prevents Desertion:
o It prevents the complete breakdown of the marriage when one spouse has left the
other without cause, ensuring that one spouse cannot unilaterally end the
relationship.
o Restitution underscores the sanctity of marriage, promoting the idea that marriage is
a legal and moral contract that should not be broken without legitimate reasons.
o Some critics argue that the provision may be used to force a spouse, typically a
woman, to return to an abusive marriage, thus compromising her autonomy and
well-being.
• Irreconcilable Differences:
o In cases where the marriage has already broken down, forcing one party to cohabit
may be seen as counterproductive, as it could perpetuate disharmony or emotional
distress.
Conclusion:
Restitution of conjugal rights is a legal remedy aimed at preserving the marital relationship by
compelling a spouse to resume cohabitation. While it serves as a mechanism to prevent desertion, it
is not without controversy, particularly regarding its application in cases of abuse or irreconcilable
differences.
(G) Intestate
Definition:
An individual is said to die intestate when they pass away without having made a valid will or
testament to distribute their property. In such cases, the distribution of the deceased's estate is
governed by the rules of intestate succession, which vary according to the applicable personal laws
(such as the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, for Hindus).
1. No Valid Will:
o The person has not left a legally valid will (or any will at all).
o A will must comply with specific legal requirements, such as being written, signed,
and witnessed, for it to be considered valid.
o If the deceased is Muslim, the distribution follows Islamic law (Sharia), and for
Christians, Indian Christian law applies, etc.
3. Order of Succession:
o The deceased’s estate is distributed among their legal heirs in a prescribed order.
o For Hindus, the Class I heirs (e.g., spouse, children) inherit first. If there are no Class I
heirs, the estate goes to Class II heirs (e.g., parents, siblings). If no Class II heirs are
available, distant relatives or the government may inherit.
o In the absence of a will, intestate succession provides a legal framework for the
distribution of assets, ensuring that the property is passed on to the rightful heirs.
o The law of intestate succession provides a clear, orderly process, reducing the
potential for conflict among heirs, though disputes can still arise if the heirs disagree
with the allocation.
o Without a will, the property may not be distributed according to the deceased's
wishes. This may sometimes result in individuals inheriting assets whom the
deceased may not have intended to benefit.
Conclusion:
Dying intestate means that the deceased has not specified how their property should be distributed
after their death. In such cases, the estate is distributed according to established laws governing
intestate succession, ensuring that legal heirs receive their share. However, dying intestate may lead
to unintended consequences, and it underscores the importance of making a valid will to ensure
one’s wishes are respected.
Definition:
The Special Marriage Act, 1954 provides for a special form of marriage between individuals who are
of different religions, castes, or nationalities. Under the Act, a declaration is made by the parties
intending to marry, affirming that they meet the necessary requirements for marriage under the law.
o A couple intending to marry under the Special Marriage Act must give notice of their
intention to the Marriage Registrar of the district where either of them has resided
for at least 30 days before the notice.
o The notice must be signed by both parties and state that they meet the legal
requirements for marriage under the Act.
▪ A statement that the parties are not married to anyone else and that there
are no legal impediments to their marriage.
3. Marriage Registration:
o After the notice period (usually 30 days), if no objections are raised, the marriage
can be solemnized by the Marriage Registrar in the presence of two witnesses.
o The parties will then sign the declaration form, completing the legal requirements.
4. Legal Implications:
o The declaration serves as a public notice of the intended marriage and helps in
preventing fraudulent marriages or any legal issues.
Definition:
Disqualification from inheritance refers to situations where an individual is legally barred from
inheriting the property of a deceased person, usually due to misconduct or violating specific laws
that govern inheritance.
o Under Section 25 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, if a person is found guilty of
killing or abetting the killing of the deceased, they are disqualified from inheriting
the deceased's property. This includes both direct and indirect involvement in the
death.
o A person convicted of a serious crime like murder or other offenses that render them
morally unfit to inherit property can be disqualified under certain laws.
o In some cases, a person may be disqualified from inheriting if they have failed to
provide adequate maintenance to the deceased during their lifetime, particularly if
they were legally bound to do so.
4. Dishonor or Abandonment:
o A person who has treated the deceased with cruelty, abandoned them, or violated
familial responsibilities may be disqualified from inheriting their property. This is
often considered in cases of mental or physical abuse.
Conclusion:
Disqualification from inheritance ensures that individuals who engage in unlawful or morally
reprehensible behavior are not allowed to benefit from the deceased person's estate. It serves to
preserve the integrity of familial relationships and protect the rights of rightful heirs.
7.a) What are the grounds for Divorce under the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955?[8]
(b) Write a short note on Divorce by Mutual Consent.[8]
ANS:- (a) Grounds for Divorce under the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 (8)
Under the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, divorce can be granted on several grounds. Section 13 of the
Act lists the grounds on which a petition for divorce can be filed by either spouse. The grounds are
divided into absolute grounds and mutual consent grounds. Below are the grounds for divorce under
Section 13:
o If one spouse has voluntarily engaged in sexual intercourse with someone other than
the other spouse, it constitutes a ground for divorce.
o If one spouse has treated the other with cruelty, either physically or mentally, such
that it becomes unsafe or intolerable to continue the marriage, the affected spouse
can seek a divorce.
o If one spouse has deserted the other for a continuous period of two years or more,
the deserted spouse may file for divorce.
o If one spouse is afflicted with leprosy, which is a chronic contagious disease, the
other spouse may seek divorce.
o If one spouse has a contagious venereal disease, which is likely to spread to the
other spouse, divorce can be sought.
o If one spouse has refused to live with the other for a period of one year or more
after a decree of restitution of conjugal rights has been passed, the spouse seeking
divorce can file a petition.
Divorce by mutual consent is one of the most amicable forms of divorce under the Hindu Marriage
Act, 1955. It allows both spouses to jointly petition the court for the dissolution of their marriage.
This procedure is based on the principle that both parties agree to end the marriage and wish to
dissolve their relationship amicably.
o Both spouses must file a joint petition in the court, requesting the dissolution of the
marriage by mutual consent. Both spouses must agree to end the marriage without
any coercion or pressure.
2. Separation Period:
o Before filing for mutual consent divorce, the couple must have been living separately
for at least one year. This means they have not cohabited and have not been living
as a married couple for the specified period.
o Unlike other grounds for divorce, mutual consent does not require either spouse to
prove fault or wrongdoing on the part of the other. The couple simply needs to show
that they mutually agree that the marriage has broken down irretrievably.
5. Cooling-off Period:
o After the petition is filed, the court grants a cooling-off period of six months (Section
13B(2)), during which time the couple can reconsider their decision. This period can
be waived by the court if it is satisfied that the couple has truly settled their
differences and the marriage has irretrievably broken down.
6. Final Decree:
o If after the cooling-off period, the spouses continue to wish for the divorce, the court
will pass a final decree, dissolving the marriage. This may happen after the second
motion, which is generally filed after six months.
o Divorce by mutual consent is generally quicker and less complicated than other
forms of divorce since no accusations or proofs need to be presented. It focuses on
amicable resolution.
2. Reduced Conflict:
o This process minimizes conflict and emotional strain, which is often associated with
adversarial divorce proceedings.
3. Privacy:
o It offers greater privacy because the details of the couple's differences or issues are
not aired in a public forum.
4. Cost-Effective:
Conclusion:
Divorce under the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 can be obtained on several grounds such as adultery,
cruelty, and desertion. Divorce by mutual consent provides a simpler and more peaceful method for
spouses to dissolve their marriage amicably, with fewer legal complications. Both methods reflect the
legal framework available for individuals seeking to end their marriage under Indian law.
8.(a) What are the conditions of a valid adoption under the Hindu Adoptions and
Maintenance Act, 1956? [10] (b) Can a step father or an adoptive mother give a
child in adoption?[6]
ANS:- (a) Conditions of a Valid Adoption under the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956
(10)
The Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956 (HAMA) governs the adoption of children by
Hindus. According to the Act, the adoption must meet certain conditions to be considered valid.
These conditions ensure that the adoption process is fair, legal, and in the best interests of the child.
The key conditions for a valid adoption are as follows:
o A married person can adopt only with the consent of their spouse. If one spouse is
not consenting, the other cannot adopt unless the non-consenting spouse is
incapable of giving consent (e.g., due to absence or mental incapacity).
o The child must be either a minor (below 18 years of age) and should not have been
adopted by any other person previously.
o The child must be capable of being adopted. For instance, children of the adoptive
family (like biological children or the spouse’s children) cannot be adopted.
o If the child is above five years of age, their consent to the adoption must be
obtained. This is to ensure that the child is aware of the adoption process and agrees
to it.
o Male Adoptive Parent: A Hindu male can adopt a child provided he is of sound mind
and has the legal capacity to adopt. He should be at least 21 years older than the
child being adopted.
o Female Adoptive Parent: A Hindu female can adopt if she is of sound mind. She
should also be at least 21 years older than the child, and if she is married, her
husband’s consent is required for the adoption.
o The child must not be a direct descendant (e.g., biological children or grandchildren)
of the adoptive parent. However, a child may be adopted from the broader family
(e.g., nieces or nephews), as long as the conditions are met.
7. No Financial Gain:
o The adoption process should not be done for financial gain or to exploit the child in
any way. Adoption must be undertaken with the primary goal of providing a
nurturing home for the child.
o A child can only be adopted once. Adoption should be permanent, and there can be
no multiple or successive adoptions of the same child.
Under the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956, the power to give a child in adoption is
restricted to certain individuals, and a stepfather or adoptive mother can give a child in adoption
under specific conditions.
1. Stepfather:
o A stepfather can give a child in adoption only if he has the consent of the child’s
biological mother and, in some cases, the biological father (if the father is alive and
has legal custody rights).
o If the biological mother is remarried and the stepfather legally adopts the child, the
stepfather may be considered the child's legal guardian. In such cases, the stepfather
may have the right to give the child in adoption.
2. Adoptive Mother:
o An adoptive mother has the authority to give a child in adoption only under specific
circumstances:
▪ The adoptive mother can give the child in adoption if she has the consent of
her husband (if married).
▪ If the adoption was made by the mother alone, she does not have the right
to give the child in adoption unless certain legal provisions (such as the
consent of the biological father or a court order) are met.
o In essence, an adoptive mother has limited rights to give a child in adoption. While
she may legally adopt a child, the same authority does not automatically extend to
giving that child in adoption to another person.
Conclusion:
1. Conditions for a valid adoption under the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956, are
based on the eligibility of both the adopter and the adopted child, as well as the process of
formalization through a legal deed of adoption.
2. A stepfather can give a child in adoption, but only with the consent of the biological mother
(and sometimes the biological father). An adoptive mother may give a child in adoption only
if she has the consent of her husband or satisfies other legal requirements.
9. (a) Discuss the procedure relating to solemnisation of marriags under the Special
Marriage Act, 1954. [8] (b) When does a marriage become void under he Special Marriage
Act, 1954?[8]
ANS:- (a) Procedure Relating to Solemnisation of Marriages under the Special Marriage Act, 1954
(8)
The Special Marriage Act, 1954 provides a legal framework for the solemnisation of marriages
between individuals of different religions, castes, or nationalities, as well as for those who prefer a
civil marriage irrespective of their religious background. The procedure for solemnising marriages
under the Special Marriage Act is as follows:
• Both parties intending to marry under the Special Marriage Act must give notice of their
intended marriage to the Marriage Registrar in the district where at least one of the parties
has resided for a minimum of 30 days preceding the notice.
• Once the notice is filed, the Marriage Registrar publishes the notice for public display. This is
to allow any third party to raise objections regarding the marriage (e.g., underage marriage,
prohibited relationships, etc.).
• The notice must be displayed for a period of 30 days from the date it is given to the registrar.
• If no objections are raised within this period, the marriage can proceed.
• After the 30-day notice period, both parties, along with two witnesses, must appear before
the Marriage Registrar.
• Both parties must declare that they are entering into the marriage voluntarily, without any
legal impediments.
• The registrar will confirm that the parties meet all the legal requirements of the Act.
4. Solemnisation of the Marriage (Section 7):
• The marriage is solemnised before the Marriage Registrar and two witnesses.
• The couple must exchange vows or declare their consent to the marriage before the registrar.
• The marriage is legally recognised once the ceremony is completed and the Marriage
Certificate is issued by the registrar.
• After the marriage is solemnised, the registrar issues an official marriage certificate.
• The certificate is the proof of marriage and is essential for all legal purposes, such as name
changes, passport applications, etc.
(b) When Does a Marriage Become Void Under the Special Marriage Act, 1954? (8)
A marriage solemnised under the Special Marriage Act, 1954 can be declared void under certain
circumstances. Section 24 of the Act enumerates the situations in which a marriage becomes void.
The grounds for a void marriage are:
• A marriage is void if either party is below the minimum legal age for marriage. The
minimum age of marriage is 21 years for men and 18 years for women. If either of the
parties is below the prescribed age at the time of marriage, the marriage is void.
• A marriage is void if either party has a spouse still alive at the time of the marriage and is not
legally divorced. Bigamy is prohibited under the Special Marriage Act. If one of the parties is
already married and the marriage is not dissolved, the subsequent marriage is considered
void.
• A marriage is void if the parties are within a prohibited degree of relationship. For instance,
if the parties are close relatives (such as siblings, cousins, or direct line relatives), the
marriage is void under the Act. The prohibited relationship rules are similar to those in the
Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 and other personal laws.
• A marriage can be declared void if either party did not give free consent to the marriage. If a
party was coerced or forced into marriage, or if they lacked mental capacity to consent, the
marriage can be considered void.
• If either of the parties was of unsound mind or mentally incapable of understanding the
nature of the marriage at the time of solemnisation, the marriage will be void.
• A marriage may also be void if one party has been deceptive or fraudulent about their
identity, age, or marital status. For example, if one party conceals a previous marriage or
hides their inability to have children, the marriage could be voided.
Conclusion:
Under the Special Marriage Act, 1954, the procedure for solemnising a marriage involves the filing of
a notice, a mandatory waiting period, and solemnisation before a marriage registrar with the consent
of the parties. A marriage under this Act becomes void if there is underage marriage, bigamy,
prohibited relationships, lack of consent, or incapacity of the parties. The Act ensures that marriages
are solemnised lawfully and provides legal safeguards to prevent wrongful or fraudulent unions.
10. (a) Discuss the General Rules of succession in ase of the property of a enale lindu dying
intestate according to the lindu Succession Act, 1956.[10]
ANS:- (a) General Rules of Succession in Case of the Property of a Female Hindu Dying Intestate
According to the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 (10)
The Hindu Succession Act, 1956 governs the inheritance and succession of property among Hindus,
including rules for the property of a female Hindu who dies intestate (without a will). The Act
ensures that property rights are equally recognized for both male and female Hindus, with certain
specific rules applicable to females.
Here are the general rules of succession in the case of a female Hindu dying intestate:
1. Classification of Property
• Ancestral Property (Property inherited from her parents, or a shared family property).
A female Hindu’s property passes to her heirs after her death based on whether the property is self-
acquired or ancestral.
The property of a female Hindu, in the case of intestate death, shall first be inherited by the following
individuals in order of priority:
1. Sons
2. Daughters
3. Husband
4. Mother
These relatives inherit the property equally. If the deceased female Hindu had children, the husband
would inherit only if the property was self-acquired. If the property was ancestral or inherited, the
inheritance rights of the children are given priority over the husband's claim.
If the female Hindu dies without leaving any heirs from the first category, the property shall pass to
the following individuals:
The father’s heirs inherit the property in the absence of a surviving husband or children.
If the female Hindu dies without any heirs from both the first and second orders, the property shall
pass to the heirs of her husband. These are the husband's legal heirs, and they inherit according to
the laws of the husband's family.
If there are no heirs from the first three orders, the property will pass to the heirs of her father. The
succession follows the same order as the one in the case of the father’s estate.
If a female Hindu inherits property from her husband or father, the rules for her succession are
somewhat different than those applied to property she acquires herself. The Act recognizes the
distinction between self-acquired and inherited property, which affects the order of succession.
• Inherited Property: If the female Hindu inherits property from her father or another relative,
the property passes down in the same manner as it would for the person who gave it to her.
If she has a son, the son inherits it after her death.
4. Rights of a Daughter
A daughter inherits equally with the son in the property of her deceased mother, whether the
property is self-acquired or inherited from the parents. The Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act,
2005, made it clear that daughters now have an equal share in the ancestral property, ensuring
gender equality in inheritance.
5. Rights of a Husband
The husband of a female Hindu can inherit her property if she has no children or if the property is
self-acquired by the wife. In the case of ancestral property inherited by the wife, the husband’s
rights are subordinate to the children’s rights.
6. Devolution of Property
If the property is self-acquired, it is devolved according to the above rules, and if the property is
ancestral or inherited, the order of succession may follow a different pattern, with priority given to
sons and daughters.
• If the female Hindu remarries, it does not impact the rights of her children or the other heirs
to inherit the property.
• The remarriage of the female Hindu does not affect the order of succession or the
distribution of the property upon her death, but if there are children from the second
marriage, their rights to property might need to be recognized separately.
In the event that the female Hindu is survived by her mother, the mother can inherit her property,
provided the mother is not otherwise disqualified under the Hindu Succession Act (e.g., if the
mother is found to be of unsound mind or legally incapacitated).
Conclusion:
The Hindu Succession Act, 1956 provides a structured order of succession for the property of a
female Hindu who dies intestate. The priority order includes sons, daughters, husband, and mother,
with specific provisions for the inheritance of self-acquired and ancestral property. The Act ensures
that women’s property rights are recognized and equal to those of men, promoting gender equality
in inheritance. If no heirs from the primary categories are available, the property will pass to the
father’s or husband’s heirs as applicable.