Final Nanomat
Final Nanomat
Macromolecular Nanotechnology
MACROMOLECULAR NANOTECHNOLOGY
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
0014-3057/$ - see front matter Ó 2009 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.eurpolymj.2009.06.022
2488 R. Bongiovanni et al. / European Polymer Journal 45 (2009) 2487–2493
cerning UV-cured materials containing synthetic ZrP. A colloidal dispersion of a-ZrP intercalated with propyl-
In order to prepare UV-cured epoxy composites, ZrP amine (ZrPPrN, where PrN = C3H7NH2) in water was pre-
was properly modified with different aminoalcohols hav- pared according to Ref. [29] by titrating a suspension of
ing different molecular weight. Besides assuring a better 0.5 g ZrP in 33 mL water with 16.6 mL of 0.1 M propylamine.
compatibility with the epoxy matrix, the presence of hy- The dispersion was treated with 6 mL of 1 M HCl (final
droxy terminated modifier is interesting. In fact upon irra- pH < 2) so as to regenerate the hydrogen form of zirconium
diation, in the presence of a suitable photoinitiator, phosphate. The solid was separated from the solution and
epoxides polymerise following a cationic mechanism: in washed with water under vigorous stirring. A gelatinous
the presence of hydroxyl groups a chain transfer reaction precipitate settled by centrifugation at 3000 rpm. Washing
takes place, which changes the reaction kinetics [25–27]. was repeated up to elimination of chloride ions. The gel thus
The paper therefore considers at first the effect of ZrP, in obtained contained 1.5–2.5 wt% anhydrous ZrP.
particular its organic modifier, on the kinetics of the poly- Functionalization of ZrP with aminoalcohols (NH2(CH2)n
merisation process of a bis-cycloaliphatic diepoxy resin, OH, with n = 3, 4, 5) was carried out by slowly adding a suit-
(3,4-epoxycyclohexylmethyl-30 ,40 -epoxycyclohexane car- able volume of 0.1 M aqueous solutions of aminoalcohol to
boxylate), then reports the characterisation of the resulting the ZrP/H2O gel so that the NH2(CH2)nOH/Zr molar ratio was
composites by means of X-ray diffraction, transmission 0.6. Aminoalcohol functionalised ZrP will be hereafter indi-
electron microscopy (TEM), thermogravimetric analysis cated as ZrPAn, where n is the number of carbon atoms of
and dynamic-mechanical thermal analysis. the aminoalcohol.
To obtain gels of ZrP or ZrPAn in tetrahydrofuran (THF), copper grid. The glass transition temperature (Tg) of the
an amount of the corresponding gel in water, containing x samples was determined by dynamic-mechanical thermal
mL water, was washed three times with 4x mL of THF. analysis (DMTA) on a MK III Rheometrics Scientific Instru-
After each washing, the gel was separated from the solu- ment at 1.0 Hz frequency in the tensile configuration and
tion by centrifuging at 3000 rpm. Gels of ZrP or ZrPAn in heating rate of 5.0 °C min1. The size of the specimen
BCDE were prepared by mixing suitable volumes of THF was about 40 5 2 mm. The storage modulus, E0 , and
gels and BCDE and subsequent THF evaporation at 40 °C the loss factor, tan d, were measured as a function of tem-
in a rotavapor. The volumes of THF gels and BCDE were perature in the range 20–250 °C.
chosen so that the filler content was 3 wt% after THF
evaporation. 3. Results and discussion
MACROMOLECULAR NANOTECHNOLOGY
2.4. Kinetic investigations
gel in a solvent which is miscible with both water and the
The kinetics of the photopolymerisation was deter- final solvent. The gel solvent can also be a liquid monomer.
mined by real-time FT-IR spectroscopy, employing a Ther- In this case the gel can be polymerised and form nanocom-
mo - Nicolet 5700 apparatus (USA). The formulations were posites containing ZrP, if the original degree of exfoliation
coated onto a silicon wafer in a very thin layer (around is retained upon polymerisation.
10 lm). The samples were exposed simultaneously to the We followed this strategy in the present work. First ZrP
UV beam, which induces the polymerisation and to the IR gels in water were prepared as described in the experi-
beam, which analyses in situ the extent of the reaction. Be- mental section; functionalised ZrP was also prepared, by
cause the IR absorbance is proportional to the monomer addition of aminoalcohols NH2(CH2)nOH, with n = 3, 4, 5
concentration, conversion versus irradiation time profiles (ZrPAn). Gels of 3 wt% ZrP or ZrPAn in BCDE (which is
can be obtained. Epoxy group conversion was followed, immiscible with water) were then prepared by replacing
by monitoring the decrease in the absorbance due to epoxy water with THF in the starting gel and THF with BCDE in
groups in the region 760–780 cm1 and normalized it to the intermediate gel. The gels thus obtained could be cured
the ester band at 1670 cm1. A medium pressure mercury in the presence of a photoinitiator by UV irradiation.
lamp equipped with an optical waveguide was used to in- BCDE is a reactive monomer that can homopolymerise
duce the photopolymerisation (light intensity on the sur- via a cationic mechanism. This mechanism is widely dis-
face of the sample of about 10 mW/cm2). All the cussed in the literature [30]: the initiation depends on
polymerisation reactions were performed at room temper- Brönsted acids whose generation from a photoinitiator
ature at constant humidity (RH = 25–30%). (as the one used in this study) involves complex reactions;
the propagation is the addition of the epoxy monomer onto
2.5. Techniques the initial protonated species. Chain transfer reactions oc-
cur when hydroxyl groups are present in the form of alco-
The samples, after irradiation, were stored for one night hols, polyols, water or humidity [25,26]. In a chain transfer
at 50 °C before characterising them. The gel content of the reaction the hydroxyl attacks a carbon atom bonded to a
cured products was determined by measuring the weight positively charged epoxy function, binds to the polymeric
loss after 24 h of extraction at room temperature with chain thus blocking its growth and releases a proton which
chloroform according to the standard test method ASTM can catalyze the growth of a new chain (Fig. 2). As a conse-
D2765-84. quence, shorter polymer chains are formed, the resulting
X-ray powder patterns were collected with a Philips X- network is more flexible and the photopolymerisation
Pert PW3710 powder diffractometer using a Cu Ka radia- kinetics faster.
tion source. Thermogravimetric determinations were car- The photopolymerisation of BCDE and its gels contain-
ried out in an air flow by a NETZSCH STA 449 Jupiter ing ZrP or ZrPAn was followed by infrared spectroscopy,
thermal analyser connected to a NETZSCH TASC 414/3 A monitoring in real time, during the irradiation, the de-
controller at a heating rate of 10 °C min1. crease of the epoxy group concentration. The experimental
TEM analysis was carried out by an HRTEM JEOL, JEM- curves of the conversion as a function of irradiation time
2010 high resolution transmission electron microscope are plotted in Fig. 3. The curve concerning the neat BCDE
with an operating voltage of 200 kV. Ultrathin sections of shows that the rate of photopolymerisation is very high
about 100 nm were cut by a Power TOME X microtome at the beginning of the process, then it diminishes and
equipped with a diamond knife and placed on a 200-mesh the conversion reaches a nearly constant value of 40% in
2490 R. Bongiovanni et al. / European Polymer Journal 45 (2009) 2487–2493
Fig. 2. Mechanism of the chain transfer reaction for a generic RC2H3O epoxide; R0 is the growing polymer chain.
2 min. Notwithstanding the limited conversion, the poly- lonite [23,35] and silica [36], we can suggest that also in
mer obtained is not tacky and is highly crosslinked as its this case the filler takes part of chain transfer reactions
insoluble fraction is quite high, around 88%. These results through its alcoholic or acidic OH groups.
are in agreement with the literature: differential scanning From Fig. 3 one can also observe that the initial photo-
calorimetry (DSC) and real time infrared spectroscopy data polymerisation rate of the BCDE/ZrPAn gels changes
MACROMOLECULAR NANOTECHNOLOGY
show that the conversion of BCDE is uncomplete and gen- according to the sequence: A5 > A4 > A3. Interestingly, the
erally is less than 50% [31]. As a cycloaliphatic epoxide, same sequence, but with higher conversions, was found
BCDE is more reactive in cationic polymerisation than for mixtures of BCDE and n-alkanols (CnH2n+1OH, with n
open-chain based epoxides, which in turn are more reac- from 3 to 5) where the alkanol amount, in moles, was
tive than glycidyl ethers and glycidyl esters [32,33]. The the same as the aminoalcohol amount in the correspond-
stop of the conversion was explained by Scott, in his work ing BCDE/ZrPAn gel (Fig. 4). The similar kinetic behaviour
on cationic polymerisation of vinyl esters [34]: he stated exhibited by the BCDE/ZrPAn gels and by the BCDE–n-alk-
that the photocuring process proceeds until vitrification, anol mixtures indicate that also in the gels the alcoholic
when the material reaches a glass transition temperature OH groups contribute significantly to the chain transfer
close to the photocuring temperature. reactions. As to the slower photopolymerisation rate of
Examining the conversion curves of BCDE when either the gels compared to the alcohol–BCDE mixtures, an obvi-
neat or functionalised ZrP are present (Fig. 3), it is evident ous explanation lays in the different viscosity of the sys-
that the photopolymerisation of BCDE is faster and the tems and different mobility of the reactive species.
conversion of the gels is about 10–20% higher compared Besides that, it can be pointed out that aminoalcohols are
to the conversion of neat BCDE. The photopolymerisation basic enough to deprotonate the monohydrogen phosphate
kinetics is therefore affected by the filler and by the type group of ZrP [37]: the surface of the filler particles bears
of organic modifier. The reasons can be many. First of all basic „PO groups whose negative charge is balanced by
the acidic groups of the filler surface can enhance the ring the protonated aminoalcohols. Therefore, in the presence
opening of the epoxide. Moreover, on the basis of past of the aminoalcohol functionalised ZrP, protons which cat-
results on the photopolymerisation of epoxides in the pres- alyze the polymerisation reaction may bind to the „PO
ence of other inorganic fillers such as sodium montmoril- groups of the filler surface, thus breaking the ionic bond
between „PO and ANH3+. On the basis of these consider-
ations, the aminoalcohol functionalised ZrP appears to
have a twofold role: if on one hand it contributes to the for-
mation of shorter polymer chains through the chain trans-
fer mechanism, on the other hand the protonation of the
surface sites decreases the catalyst concentration thus
making the reaction kinetics of the modified gels slower
in comparison with the mixtures of BCDE and free alcohols.
MACROMOLECULAR NANOTECHNOLOGY
curing’, i.e., they can lead to the polymerisation of BCDE
monomers that were never exposed to light [38]. Both
post-curing and shadow curing can be enhanced by
increasing the temperature, but it is proved that these pro-
cesses take place also at 30–40 °C [38,39] or at tempera-
tures close to the photocuring temperature.
The composite samples obtained were homogeneous
and transparent. Fig. 5 shows TEM pictures of a ZrP based
composite. The ZrP particles are randomly dispersed in the
photopolymerised BCDE matrix and have thickness of few
nanometres with an extremely high aspect ratio. As the
thickness of a single ZrP layer does not exceed 1 nm, the
ZrP particles consist of stacks of few layers. Therefore the
nanocomposite can be defined as partially exfoliated. Fur-
ther information on the filler exfoliation is obtained by Fig. 5. TEM pictures for a sample of cured BCDE containing 3 wt%
comparing the X-ray powder patterns of a sample (A) pre- exfoliated ZrP.
pared from a BCDE/ZrP gel with the pattern of a sample (B)
obtained from a physical mixture of BCDE and the same
amount of ground microcrystalline ZrP (3 wt%). In Fig. 6
the pattern of sample B shows sharp characteristic reflec-
tions of ZrP at 2h = 11.6° and 25.3° [40,41] besides the
broad signal centred around 2h = 17.5°, which is due to
the polymeric matrix. In particular, the reflection at
2h = 11.6° arises from the stacking of the a-layers with
an interlayer distance, d, of 0.76 nm. This reflection is miss-
ing in the pattern of sample A, obtained from the gel: here
a weak peak appears at 2h = 8.9° (d = 0.98 nm) which may
be ascribed to BCDE intercalated ZrP. On the basis of the
width at half peak height, the thickness of the ZrP particles
is estimated by using the Debye–Scherrer formula to be
around 9 nm, in qualitative agreement with the TEM
picture. On the other hand, the X-ray powder pattern
of the ZrPA5 composite (Fig. 6) do not show any filler
Fig. 6. X-ray powder patterns of composites prepared from gels of BCDE/
reflection thus indicating that the aminoalcohol favours
ZrP (A), BCDE/ZrPA5 (C) and from a physical mixture of BCDE and 3 wt%
the filler dispersion in the organic solvents used for the ZrP (B).
gel preparation.
The thermal behaviour the cured BCDE oligomer and its
ZrP based composites was investigated by DMTA analysis of the maximum of the tan d vs. temperature curves. The
and thermogravimetric determinations. DMTA experi- spectra describing the cured BCDE and its homologue con-
ments allowed to determine Tg values from the position taining ZrPA3 are reported in Fig. 7, while all the Tg values
2492 R. Bongiovanni et al. / European Polymer Journal 45 (2009) 2487–2493
Fig. 9. Temperature shift (T) of the weight loss curves of cured BCDE/
ZrPand BCDE/ZrPAn gels referred to the curve of cured BCDE as a
function of the number of carbon atoms of the aminoalcohols. DT is the
shift corresponding to 20% weight loss.
4. Conclusion
Acknowledgements [17] Boo WJ, Sun LY, Liu J, Clearfield A, Sue HJ, Mullins MJ, et al.
Morphology and mechanical behavior of exfoliated epoxy/alpha-
zirconium phosphate nanocomposites. Compos Sci Technol
This work was supported by MIUR within the FIRB 2001 2007;67:262–9.
project ‘‘Aspetti di base e funzionali di materiali polimerici [18] Boo WJ, Sun L, Warren GL, Moghbelli E, Pham H, Clearfield A, Sue HJ.
Effect of nanoplatelet aspect ratio on mechanical properties of epoxy
ibridi inorgano – organici nanostrutturati”. The authors
nanocomposites. Polymer 2007;48:1075–82.
wish to thank Dr. O. Monticelli of Genova University for [19] Sun L, Boo WJ, Sun D, Clearfield A, Sue HJ. Preparation of exfoliated
collecting TEM images. epoxy/alpha-zirconium phosphate nanocomposites containing high
aspect ratio nanoplatelets. Chem Mater 2007;19:1749–54.
[20] Sun L, Boo WJ, Sue HJ, Clearfield A. Preparation of alpha-zirconium
References phosphate nanoplatelets with wide variations in aspect ratios. New J
Chem 2007;31:39–43.
[1] Kojima Y, Usuki A, Kawasumi M, Okada A, Fukushima Y, Kurauchi T, [21] Benfarhi S, Decker C, Keller L, Zahouily K. Synthesis of clay
et al. Mechanical properties of nylon 6–clay hybrid. J Mater Res nanocomposite materials by light-induced crosslinking
1993;8:1174–8. polymerization. Eur Polym J 2004;40:493–501.
[2] Alexandre M, Dubois P. Polymer-layered silicate nanocomposites: [22] Bongiovanni R, Mazza D, Ronchetti S, Turcato EA. The influence of
preparation, properties and uses of a new class of materials. Mater water on the intercalation of epoxy monomers in Na–
Sci Eng 2000;28:1–63. montmorillonite. J Colloid Interface Sci 2006;296:515–9.
[3] Ray SS, Okamoto M. Polymer/layered silicate nanocomposites: a [23] Malucelli G, Bongiovanni R, Sangermano M, Ronchetti S, Priola A.
review from preparation to processing. Prog Polym Sci 2003;28: Preparation and characterization of UV-cured epoxy
1539–641. nanocomposites based on o-montmorillonite modified with
[4] Fouassier JP, Rabek JF. Radiation curing in polymer science and maleinized liquid polybutadienes. Polymer 2007;48:7000–7.
technology, vol. I–IV. London: Elsevier; 1993. [24] Di Gianni A, Bongiovanni R, Amerio E, Monticelli O. Preparation of
[5] Decker C, Zahouily K, Keller L, Benfarhi S, Bendaikha T, Baron J. polymer/clay mineral nanocomposites via dispersion of silylated
Ultrafast synthesis of bentonite–acrylate nanocomposite materials montmorillonite in a UV curable epoxy matrix. Appl Clay Sci
by UV-radiation curing. J Mater Sci 2002;37:4821–8; 2008;42:116–24.
Keller L, Decker C, Zahouily K, Benfarhi S, Le Meins JM, Miehe- [25] Crivello JV, Conlon DA, Olson DR. J Rad Curing 1982;14:3.
MACROMOLECULAR NANOTECHNOLOGY
Brendle J. Synthesis of polymer nanocomposites by UV-curing of [26] Crivello JV, Saoshi L. Photoinitiated cationic polymerization of epoxy
organoclay–acrylic resins. Polymer 2004;45:7427–47. alcohol monomers. J Polym Sci A Polym Chem 2000;38:389–401.
[6] Clearfield A, Stynes JA. The preparation of crystalline zirconium [27] Penczek S, Kubisa P. In: Brunelle DJ, editor. Ring opening
phosphate and some observations on it ion exchange behavior. J polymerization. Munich: Hanser; 1993. p. 17.
Inorg Nucl Chem 1964;26:117–29. [28] Alberti G, Allulli S, Costantino U, Massucci MA. Crystalline insoluble
[7] Casciola M, Alberti G, Donnadio A, Pica M, Marmottini F, Bottino A, acid salts of tetravalent metals. J Inorg Nucl Chem 1975;37:1779–86.
et al. Gels of zirconium phosphate in organic solvents and their use [29] Alberti G, Casciola M, Costantino U. Inorganic ion-exchange pellicles
for the preparation of polymeric nanocomposites. J Mater Chem obtained by delamination of a-zirconium phosphate crystals. J
2005;15:4262–7. Colloid Interface Sci 1985;107:256–63.
[8] Casciola M, Alberti G, Ciarletta A, Cruccolini A, Piaggio P, Pica M. [30] Crivello JV, Dietlikerk K. Chemistry and technology inks and paints,
Nanocomposite membranes made of zirconium phosphate oldring, vol. 3. SITA Tech.: London; 1991. p. 327.
sulfophenylenphosphonate dispersed in polyvinylidene fluoride: [31] Crivello JV, Varleman U. The synthesis and study of the
preparation and proton conductivity. Solid State Ionics photoinitiated cationic polymerization of novel cycloaliphatic
2005;176:2986–9. epoxides. J Polym Sci A Polym Chem 1995;33:2463–71.
[9] Alberti G, Casciola M, D’Alessandro E, Pica M. Preparation and proton [32] Bulut U, Crivello JV. Investigation of the reactivity of epoxide
conductivity of composite ionomeric membranes obtained from gels monomers in photoinitiated cationic polymerization.
of amorphous zirconium phosphate sulfophenylenphosphonates in Macromolecules 2005;38:3584–95.
organic solvents. J Mater Chem 2004;14:1910–4. [33] Decker C, Moussa K. Kinetic-study of the cationic
[10] Alberti G, Casciola M, Pica M, Tarpanelli T, Sganappa M. New photopolymerization of epoxy monomers. J Polym Sci A Polym
preparation methods for composite membranes for medium Chem 1990;28:3429–43.
temperature fuel cells based on precursor solutions of insoluble [34] Scott TF, Cook WD, Forsythe JS. Photo-DSC cure kinetics of vinyl ester
inorganic compounds. Fuel Cells 2005;3:366–74. resins. I. Influence of temperature. Polymer 2002;43:5839–45.
[11] Casciola M, Donnadio A, Pica M, Valentini V, Piaggio P. [35] Bongiovanni R, Turcato EA, Di Gianni A, Ronchetti S. Epoxy coatings
Characterization of Zr phosphate/PVDF nanocomposites by containing clays and organoclays: effect of the filler and its water
vibrational spectroscopy. Macromol Symp 2005;230:95–104. content on the UV-curing process. Prog Org Coat 2008;62:336–43.
[12] Alberti G, Casciola M, Donnadio A, Narducci R, Pica M, Sganappa M. [36] Sangermano M, Malucelli G, Amerio E, Priola A, Billi E, Rizza G.
Preparation and properties of nafion membranes containing Photopolymerization of epoxy coatings containing silica
nanoparticles of zirconium phosphate. Desalination 2006;199: nanoparticles. Prog Org Coat 2005;54:134–8.
280–2. [37] Casciola M, Costantino U, D’Amico S. Protonic conduction of
[13] Søgaard SR, Huan Q, Lund P, Donnadio A, Casciola M, Skou E. intercalation compounds of a-zirconium phosphate with
Preparation and analysis of new proton conducting membranes for propylamine. Solid State Ionics 1986;22:127–33.
fuel cells. Solid State Ionics 2007;178:493–500. [38] Ficek BA, Thiesen AM, Scranton AB. Cationic photopolymerizations
[14] Alberti G, Casciola M, Capitani D, Donnadio A, Pica M, Sganappa M, of thick polymer systems: active center lifetime and mobility. Eur
et al. Novel Nafion–zirconium phosphate nanocomposite Polym J 2008;44:98–105.
membranes with enhanced stability of proton conductivity at [39] FernáNdez-Francos X, Salla JM, Cadenato A, Morancho JM, MantecóN
medium temperature and high relative humidity. Electrochim Acta A, Serra A, et al. Influence of the initiating mechanism on the cationic
2007;52:8125–32. photopolymerization of a cycloaliphatic epoxy resin with
[15] Sun LY, Boo WJ, Browning RL, Sue HJ, Clearfield A. Effect of arylsulfonium salts. J Polym Sci A Polym Chem 2007;45:16–25.
crystallinity on the intercalation of monoamine in alpha-zirconium [40] Clearfield A, Smith GD. Crystallography and structure of a-zirconium
phosphate layer structure. Chem Mater 2005;17:5606–9. bis(monohydrogen orthophosphate) monohydrate. Inorg Chem
[16] Liu J, Boo WJ, Clearfield A, Sue HJ. Intercalation and exfoliation: 1969;8:431–6.
a review on morphology of polymer nanocomposites reinforced [41] Troup JM, Clearfield A. On the mechanism of ion exchange in
by inorganic layer structures. Mater Manuf Process 2006;20: zirconium phosphates. 20. Refinement of the crystal structure of a-
143–51. zirconium phosphate. Inorg Chem 1977;16:3311–4.