0% found this document useful (0 votes)
9 views159 pages

Sentimental Figures of Empire in Eighteenth Century Britain and France Lynn Festa Full

The document discusses Lynn Festa's book 'Sentimental Figures of Empire in Eighteenth Century Britain and France,' which explores the relationship between sentimentality in literature and the expansion of colonial empires during the 18th century. It argues that sentimental texts shaped perceptions of agency and humanity across diverse populations while reflecting the complexities of colonial encounters. The book highlights how sentimentality became the dominant literary mode of the era, transforming narratives of conquest into opportunities for benevolence and emotional engagement with the plight of others.

Uploaded by

mariamunka3322
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
9 views159 pages

Sentimental Figures of Empire in Eighteenth Century Britain and France Lynn Festa Full

The document discusses Lynn Festa's book 'Sentimental Figures of Empire in Eighteenth Century Britain and France,' which explores the relationship between sentimentality in literature and the expansion of colonial empires during the 18th century. It argues that sentimental texts shaped perceptions of agency and humanity across diverse populations while reflecting the complexities of colonial encounters. The book highlights how sentimentality became the dominant literary mode of the era, transforming narratives of conquest into opportunities for benevolence and emotional engagement with the plight of others.

Uploaded by

mariamunka3322
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 159

Sentimental Figures of Empire in Eighteenth Century

Britain and France Lynn Festa pdf version

https://ebookname.com/product/sentimental-figures-of-empire-in-
eighteenth-century-britain-and-france-lynn-festa/

★★★★★
4.8 out of 5.0 (51 reviews )

PDF Available Immediately

ebookname.com
Sentimental Figures of Empire in Eighteenth Century Britain
and France Lynn Festa

EBOOK

Available Formats

■ PDF eBook Study Guide Ebook

EXCLUSIVE 2025 ACADEMIC EDITION – LIMITED RELEASE

Available Instantly Access Library


Instant digital products (PDF, ePub, MOBI) available
Download now and explore formats that suit you...

Trade and Empire in the Eighteenth Century Atlantic World


Andrew Hamilton

https://ebookname.com/product/trade-and-empire-in-the-eighteenth-
century-atlantic-world-andrew-hamilton/

ebookname.com

Shapely Bodies The Image of Porcelain in Eighteenth


Century France 1st Edition Christine A. Jones

https://ebookname.com/product/shapely-bodies-the-image-of-porcelain-
in-eighteenth-century-france-1st-edition-christine-a-jones/

ebookname.com

Fight or flight Britain France and their roads from empire


1st Edition Thomas

https://ebookname.com/product/fight-or-flight-britain-france-and-
their-roads-from-empire-1st-edition-thomas/

ebookname.com

Protective Options Strategies Married Puts and Collar


Spreads Ernie Zerenner

https://ebookname.com/product/protective-options-strategies-married-
puts-and-collar-spreads-ernie-zerenner/

ebookname.com
Superparamagnetic Iron Oxide Nanoparticles Synthesis
Surface Engineering Cytotoxicity and Biomedical
Applications Synthesis Surface Engineering Cytotoxicity
and Biomedical Applications 1st Edition Morteza Mahmoudi
https://ebookname.com/product/superparamagnetic-iron-oxide-
nanoparticles-synthesis-surface-engineering-cytotoxicity-and-
biomedical-applications-synthesis-surface-engineering-cytotoxicity-
and-biomedical-applications-1st-edition-mor/
ebookname.com

The Surface and the Abyss Nietzsche as Philosopher of Mind


and Knowledge Monographien Und Texte Zur Nietzsche
Forschung 1st Edition Peter Bornedal
https://ebookname.com/product/the-surface-and-the-abyss-nietzsche-as-
philosopher-of-mind-and-knowledge-monographien-und-texte-zur-
nietzsche-forschung-1st-edition-peter-bornedal/
ebookname.com

Endocrinology for the Small Animal Practitioner Made Easy


Series 1st Edition Panciera

https://ebookname.com/product/endocrinology-for-the-small-animal-
practitioner-made-easy-series-1st-edition-panciera/

ebookname.com

Python for Finance 2nd Edition Yuxing Yan

https://ebookname.com/product/python-for-finance-2nd-edition-yuxing-
yan/

ebookname.com

System of Systems Engineering Innovations for the Twenty


First 21 Century 1st Edition Mohammad Jamshidi

https://ebookname.com/product/system-of-systems-engineering-
innovations-for-the-twenty-first-21-century-1st-edition-mohammad-
jamshidi/
ebookname.com
Reading Portraits In Brazil 4th Edition Zoara Failla

https://ebookname.com/product/reading-portraits-in-brazil-4th-edition-
zoara-failla/

ebookname.com
This page intentionally left blank
ly n n f e s t a

The Johns Hopkins University Press


© 2006 The Johns Hopkins University Press
All rights reserved. Published 2006
Printed in the United States of America on acid-free paper
2 4 6 8 9 7 5 3 1

The Johns Hopkins University Press


2715 North Charles Street
Baltimore, Maryland 21218-4363
www.press.jhu.edu

Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data


Festa, Lynn M. (Lynn Mary)
Sentimental figures of empire in eighteenth-century Britain and
France / Lynn Festa.
p. cm.
Includes bibliographical references and index.
isbn 0-8018-8430-6 (hardcover : acid-free paper)
1. English fiction—18th century—History and criticism. 2. French
fiction—18th century—History and criticism. 3. Sentimentalism in
literature. 4. Imperialism in literature. 5. Colonies in literature.
I. Title.
pr858.s45f47 2006
823⬘.509358—dc22 2006003549

A catalog record for this book is available from the British Library.
c ontents

Introduction. The Great World Without 1

1 The Distinction of Sentimental Feeling 14


Sentimental Babel 15
Hume, Smith, and the Property of Feeling 22
French Sympathy and the Model of the Human 36
The Sentimental Wealth of Nations 44
Romance, Epic, and the Sentimental Rewriting
of Eighteenth-Century Empire 55

2 Sterne’s Snuffbox 67
Yorick’s Snuffbox and the Paradox of the
Sentimental Commodity 69
Emotions in an Age of Mechanical Reproduction 82
and the Befetish’d Word 92
The Sentimental Deficit and the 102

3 Tales Told by Things 111


The People Things Make 112
The Commodity’s Soliloquy 115
Thinking Through Things 125
Subject and Object in Olaudah Equiano’s 132

4 Making Humans Human 153


Of Price and Men 155
Day, Cowper, Wedgwood, and the Tropes of
Redundant Personification 160
Discriminating Figures in Janet Schaw’s 171
Political Sympathies and the Sympathetic Misfire 178
Usurpation and Empathy in Parliamentary Debates 187
Reversible Figures 201
5 Global Commerce in Raynal’s 205
Commerce as the Motor of the World 208
Lachrymose Intolerance 220
Human Interest 230

Coda. The Peripheral Vision of the Enlightenment 233

243
263
289
ac knowledg ments

It is somehow appropriate that a book that describes the shortcomings of


benevolence should itself be the product of myriad acts of unstinting generosity.
Many people have contributed to this project. I owe a tremendous debt to Joan
DeJean for her unflagging support and inspiration over the years. The critical in-
sight and generosity of John Richetti, Peter Stallybrass, Margreta de Grazia,
Lynn Hunt, Liliane Weissberg, and JoAnne Dubil during my years as a graduate
student at the University of Pennsylvania created a model of collegiality to
which I shall always aspire. Juliette Cherbuliez, Rayna Kalas, Nick Paige, Suzie
Verderber, and Amy Wyngaard are and have been for many years the kinds of
friends and intellectual community most people only dream of finding.
It would be impossible to list all the people at Harvard who have given me en-
couragement and support in writing this book (or who have provided welcome
respite from it), but particular thanks are due to Larry Buell, Leo Damrosch, Jim
Engell, Marge Garber, Stephen Greenblatt, and Barbara Johnson, as well as to
Oren Izenberg, Beth Lyman, Luke Menand, John Picker, Leah Price, Ann Row-
land, and Sharmila Sen. Many scholars in the field of eighteenth-century stud-
ies have helped me over the years, but I would especially like to thank Srinivas
Aravamudan, Julia Douthwaite, Beth Kowaleski-Wallace, Sue Lanser, Deidre
Lynch, David Marshall, Ruth Perry, Susan Staves, Jim Steintrager, and Cindy
Wall, as well as the members of the Eighteenth-Century Seminar at the Humani-
ties Center and the participants in the Bloomington Workshop on the Eighteenth
Century. In a book that makes arguments about the ambivalent desire to keep
one’s self to oneself, it is delightful to find the traces of so many other people.
The writing of this book was made possible by a fellowship at the Radcliffe
Institute for Advanced Study. I am grateful to Drew Faust, Judy Vichniac, and
the fellows of the 2003 cohort for an extraordinary year. A grant from the W. M.
Keck Foundation & Andrew Mellon Foundation enabled me to spend a produc-
tive summer at the Huntington Library in 2003. Additional support for this book
was provided by the Harvard English Department’s Robinson-Rollins Fund.
An earlier version of a portion of Chapter 4 appeared in
a special issue of edited by
Byron Wells and Philip Stewart (Oxford: Voltaire Foundation, 2004). I am grate-
ful to the editors for permission to use this material. I also wish to express my
gratitude to Peter Dreyer for his care in copyediting the manuscript. Finally,
thanks to my editor, Michael Lonegro, for his support and patience in seeing this
project through.
A number of other people have helped me to write this book in ways that may
be obscure to them but are perfectly clear to me: Frances Bennett, Dan Carey,
Maria Carter, Wendy Chun, Greg Coleman, Tess and Mike Festa, Katy Fogle,
Matt Gil, David Harrison, Judy Hershnik, Jill Heydt-Stevenson, Sonia Hofkosh,
Jack Killoy, Jacques Lezra, Anna McDonald, Phoebe Minias, Paul Moorcroft,
Anita Oliva, Lisa Randall, the Rozetts, John Stevenson, Sally Stiffler, Judith
Surkis, Alexis Tadié, Bob and Elizabeth Festa Watson, and Diana Wylie. And I
don’t know what I would have done without Patty, Kate, Nick, Mark, Sharmila,
Elizabeth, and Analia. No one could have been luckier in her family and friends.
This book is for the two people to whom I owe the most: my father, Adam
Festa, and my mother, Winnie Festa.
Visit https://ebookname.com today to explore
a vast collection of ebooks across various
genres, available in popular formats like
PDF, EPUB, and MOBI, fully compatible with
all devices. Enjoy a seamless reading
experience and effortlessly download high-
quality materials in just a few simple steps.
Plus, don’t miss out on exciting offers that
let you access a wealth of knowledge at the
best prices!
This page intentionally left blank
introduction

Really, universally, relations stop nowhere, and the exquisite prob-


lem of the artist is eternally but to draw, by a geometry of his
own, the circle within which they shall happily to do so.
Roderick Hudson

A project concerned with the margins of the Enlightenment might as well be-
gin with a footnote. In the first volume of his sentimental novel
(1759–67), Laurence Sterne describes a village
midwife who, as “she had all along trusted little to her own efforts, and a great
deal to those of dame nature,—had acquired, in her way, no small degree of rep-
utation in the world;—by which word need I in this place inform your
worship, that I would be understood to mean no more of it, than a small circle
described upon the circle of the great world, of four miles diameter, or
thereabouts, of which the cottage where the good old woman lived, is supposed
to be the centre.”1 Lest readers miss the irony, Sterne’s French translator has-
tened in 1776 to add a footnote: “But do not be fooled: it was not the whole world.
She was not known, for example, among the Hottentot and Dutch women of the
Cape of Good Hope, who are said to give birth like Mother Nature. The world
for her was but a small circle.”2 The relationship between these two worlds—be-
tween the “small circle described upon the circle of the great world” and the
great world without—is the subject of this book. The circumscribed area of
“four English miles diameter,” the domain of the sentimental novel, jostles un-
comfortably against the land of the “Hottentots” and the “Dutch,” the domain
of empire. The evident superfluity of the translator’s explanation almost raises
the suspicion that it might be yet another layering of irony in the guise of an
earnest interpretive decoding: a sly trick to point out the self-contained nature,
not just of the old woman’s world, but of the narrow little world of the senti-
mental novel.
2

The sentimental mode held sway over the British and French literary imagi-
nation at a time when Europeans were fanning out across the globe in search of
commercial and colonial dominion. In the eighteenth century, the great trading
companies were consolidated; the sinews of empire were built up in the form of
systems of commerce, credit, tax collection, and armed power; the disciplines for
the comparative study of man were elaborated, and the slave trade flourished.
The British alone transported more than 3.4 million slaves from Africa to the
Americas between 1662 and 1807.3 By 1800, Europeans controlled more than 35
percent of the total land area of the globe; by 1815, the British empire embraced
one-fifth of the earth’s inhabitants.4 Why did sentimentality attain such dazzling
popularity just when European soldiers, merchants, politicians, and scientists
were piecing together colonial empires? Why did a literary form chiefly notable
for its preoccupation with the individual self become the mode of choice for writ-
ing about colonized populations, about slaves, about the disenfranchised, and the
eighteenth-century poor?
This book seeks to connect the turning inward of the sentimental mode and
the turning outward of empire in order to offer a history of the eighteenth-
century origins of humanitarian sensibility. Focusing primarily on the novel, I
argue that sentimental texts helped create the terms for thinking about agency
and intent across the geographic expanse of the globe by giving shape and local
habitation to the perpetrators, victims, and causal forces of empire. In an era in
which imperial reach increasingly outstripped imaginative grasp, sentimental
fiction created the tropes that enabled readers to reel the world home in their
minds. By designating certain kinds of figures as worthy of emotional expendi-
ture and structuring the circulation of affect between subjects and objects of feel-
ing, the sentimental mode allowed readers to identify with and feel for the plight
of other people while upholding distinctive cultural and personal identities; it
thus consolidated a sense of metropolitan community grounded in the selective
recognition of the humanity of other populations. Sentimental depictions of
colonial encounters refashioned conquest into commerce and converted scenes of
violence and exploitation into occasions for benevolence and pity. In the process,
sentimentality, not epic, became the literary mode of empire in the eighteenth
century.
Read in isolation, sentimental writings can be made to tell a tidy story about
the emergence of the modern psychological self. Placed in conversation with em-
pire, however, sentimentality invites both psychological and cultural readings of
the encounter between self and other. To read the sentimental text alongside the
colonial history of the Enlightenment is to recognize the myriad acts of affective
3

piracy that constitute the singularity of the sentimental self. I thus understand
the sentimental mode’s interest in the interior lives of its characters and readers
less as a chapter in the history of the freestanding modern individual than as a
response to colonial expansion. Even as global encounters demanded innovative
methods of imagining relations to others, the sentimental text sought to anchor
and preserve a continuously narrated self in a world whose local attachments
were being unmoored by exposure to different cultures and peoples. The pro-
tracted attention to the sustained threads of voice and character in sentimental
narrative constructed a common language of psychological depth that secured
the self in relation to the others it encountered, while the sentimental mode’s in-
vestment in affective and psychological interiority helped distinguish the partic-
ularity of the human from the interchangeability of the commodity, the self-
possessed individual from the dispossessed slave.
Sentimentality is defined here as a rhetorical practice that monitors and seeks
to master the sympathetic movement of emotion between individuals and groups
of people. Whereas sympathy alludes to the mobility of emotion between differ-
ent individuals, and sensibility describes individuals’ susceptibility to particular
kinds and degrees of feeling, sentimentality as a crafted literary form moves to
locate that emotion, to assign it to particular persons, thereby designating who
possesses affect and who elicits it. In distinguishing between subjects and objects
of feeling, the sentimental seeks to define what is proper to the self and what can
be shared by or exchanged with others: it polices the division of self from world.
Sentimentality, in other words, is bound up with the interests of empire, not only
because sentimental texts describe and elicit emotion, but also because they
it. By governing the circulation of feeling among subjects and objects, sen-
timentality helps to define who will be acknowledged as human.
In making sentimental identification the primary means of representing
metropolitan relations with colonial populations, eighteenth-century writers
give unprecedented centrality to feeling as a form of social and cultural differ-
entiation. The sentimental subject—moved by suffering, sympathetic to others,
but alert to the vicissitudes of its own affect—creates a template for the human
grounded in the fact that others excite or experience emotion. “Who is it that can
read of the poverty and misery of the wretched inhabitants of ”
David Henry asks in his 1774
“who have nothing but the skins of beasts loosely thrown over them, . . .
without lamenting the condition of human beings, destitute, as these appear to
be, of every comfort and convenience[?] . . . What heart is so callous, as not to
sympathize[?]”5 What heart, indeed? Henry’s shivering natives, denuded of all the
4

comforts of civilization and clothing, can only inspire pity in those who have the
luxury of sympathy. Although the reader is suffused with emotion, sympathetic
identification creates difference rather than similitude; the reader is neither in-
vited to meld ecstatically with these wretched people nor to change places with
them. Henry constitutes the natives as human beings and simultaneously sorts
them into a separate class: subjects who sympathize and objects who elicit sym-
pathy confront one another across an affective and cultural divide in which one
set of people feels another. Colonial expansion means that readers must find
ways of recognizing human likeness while maintaining other forms of differ-
ence. The sentimental community upholds a common identity, not by forging
bonds directly between seemingly like individuals, but by creating a shared re-
lationship to a common but excluded object about which the community has feel-
ings.
In sorting reader from suffering victim, feeling subject from object of feeling,
sentimental tropes, I argue, govern the movement of affect not just between
different kinds of individuals but between different kinds of individualisms. In
eighteenth-century texts, feeling as much as reason designates who has value and
who does not. Sentimental writings thus repeatedly confront the gap between
what constitutes a “lyric ‘person’—emotive, subjective, individual—and a legal
‘person’—rational, rights-bearing, institutional.”6 By allowing emotion to be so-
cially distributed, monitored, and culturally validated, the sentimental text both
raises and lowers the bar that distinguishes civilized from savage, human from
chattel slave, person from thing. The sentimental feeling self is thus the Janus
face of the Enlightenment rational subject, the possessive individual, the rights-
bearing citizen.
If the ability to inspire feeling demarcates the human community, the reverse
is also true. It is difficult to feel for peoples whose customs and manners are alien
to our own. Unfamiliarity breeds contempt. “We are,” Edmund Burke contends
in his 1783 “Speech on Fox’s India Bill,” “so little acquainted with Indian details;
the instruments of oppression under which the people suffer are so hard to be
understood; and even the very names of the sufferers are so uncouth and strange
to our ears, that it is very difficult for our sympathy to fix upon these objects.”7
Lacking a grasp both of the “Indian details” and of the big picture (the struc-
tural “instruments of oppression”), the reader cannot even produce objects with
whom to sympathize. Where names are so alien that they will not cleave to the
tongue, Burke asks, how is one to find sufficient commonality to create a sense of
another’s humanity?
Sentimental figures produce the means of drawing the unfamiliar into the lis-
5

tener’s ken. Thus it is to the sentimental novel that John Hawkesworth turns in
his compilation of South Sea journals. Hawkesworth invents a first-person com-
posite narrator in order to draw “the Adventurer and the Reader nearer together,
without the intervention of a stranger.” Novelistic technique, Hawkesworth
claims, supplements the deficiencies of history. Thus his dilation upon minor de-
tails “requires no apology,”

for it is from little circumstances that the relation of great events derives its power
over the mind. An account that ten thousand men perished in a battle, that twice
the number were swallowed up by an earthquake, or that a whole nation was swept
away by a pestilence, is read in the naked brevity of an index, without the least
emotion, by those who feel themselves strongly interested even for Pamela, the
imaginary heroine of a novel that is remarkable for the enumeration of particu-
lars in themselves so trifling, that we almost wonder how they could occur to the
author’s mind.8

Spartan descriptions or sweeping statistics make faint impressions; seemingly


“trifling” details lend power and verisimilitude to an otherwise affectively un-
convincing narrative. The dilation upon “little circumstances” that steeps the
reader in another world helps confer imaginary being upon distant peoples; sen-
timental figures reinvigorate feeling attenuated by distance and make sympa-
thetic identification possible.
Hawkesworth’s account describes how sentimental figures wrest readers from
indifference, fostering connections between otherwise insular individuals. Re-
cent scholarship on sentimentality has emphasized this capacity to forge social
bonds in the face of the self-interested passions of providing
the training of emotion needed to socialize the uncontrolled passions unleashed
by capitalism and simultaneously harnessing individual emotional life to the
marketplace.9 Arguments that emphasize the synthetic capacity of sentimental-
ity to create broader communities of sociability grounded in shared economic,
moral, aesthetic, or class-based interests have for the most part shied away from
extensive discussions of empire, perhaps because they have difficulty accommo-
dating the antagonisms and contradictions that surface when one enlarges the
community too much. My argument departs from this body of scholarship in
claiming that sentimental identification operates as a form of differentiation as
well as consolidation. Inasmuch as sympathy involves the readers’ experience of
feelings specifically designated as belonging to another person, it veers towards
a perilous absorption in another’s affect and interests that may threaten the au-
tonomy of the self. Thus although feelings may serve as social adhesive, the
6

traffic in sympathetic feeling may also spark a struggle to claim feelings for one’s
own. I endeavor to restore the agonistic element to sympathetic exchanges by ac-
knowledging the tension between the sociable benefits and pleasures of sympa-
thetic affect and the desire to uphold the singularity of the self. Hence, I under-
stand sentimentality not as part of a continuum on which one might also place
sensibility and sympathy but as a rhetorical structure that contains the poten-
tially indiscriminate circulation of feeling.
The fact that sympathetic traffic flows beyond the boundaries of individuals
challenges the proto-romantic idea that feelings have their origins in unique, in-
terior, personal experience; the emotions sometimes thought to constitute the self
may not be one’s own. The suggestion that, in Adela Pinch’s words, “feelings may
be impersonal; that one’s feelings may really be someone else’s; that feelings may
be purely conventional, or have no discernible origins,”10 calls other contempo-
rary concepts of subjectivity into question. For how can one collate eighteenth-
century accounts of the person—the political subject girded round by rights and
duties, the self-proprietary individual who enters into market relations with oth-
ers—with the affective self, whose messy identifications, disruptive passions, in-
explicable propensities, and uncertain borders escape precise definition?
Discussions of the management of emotion—the attribution of feeling to
specific people or groups of people, the command over one’s own emotions, the
subjectivity, interiority, and self-propriety that issue from them—have largely
centered on gender in recent years.11 Yet the proclivity of feelings to wander in
eighteenth-century texts becomes particularly risky in the context of empire, re-
sulting in a menacing usurpation of the self that threatens to collapse distinc-
tions based on nation, religion, or race. Because sympathy breaks down the bor-
ders that support the categories of self and other (a division that sentimentality
endeavors to reassert), it interrupts the tidy shot/reverse-shot model of self-other
relations that often surfaces in discussions of empire in the eighteenth century.
Colonial encounters were messy, ill-assorted things, spawning scenes of mutual
unintelligibility marked by confusion, delirium, and violence. As Jonathan Lamb
has shown in the loneliness, wonder, fear,
and bafflement experienced by travelers and indigenes could veer towards self-
dissolution, imperiling the continuity and unity of the self. By recasting this
confusion into scenes of benevolent reciprocity, sentimental depictions of these
moments of contact attempt to master a potentially vertiginous relation. The
structure sentimental tropes imposed upon vagrant affect enabled Europeans to
preserve the identity of the self in encounters that knitted subject and object to-
gether in ways that were difficult to disentangle.
7

This book poses these questions about the continuity of personal identity in
the context of recent work on the way eighteenth-century colonial and imperial
activity called into being or reoriented categories of nation, gender, family, class,
and race.12 How did these broader concepts of human difference become incor-
porated into the practices and perceptions of daily life? How did they reshape the
identity of the self? There is, as Dror Wahrman has recently observed, “no rea-
son to expect the historical development of understandings of personal identity
to mirror that of categories of identity such as gender or race.”13 My argument
traces the cultural and literary labor that aligns the felt perception of who is a
person with emerging historical categories that delimit the human. The senti-
mental governance of emotion, I contend, welds the affective response to other
people to broader structures of human classification in order both to include
to exclude individuals from the class of humanity. The central question I want
to pose thus concerns the eighteenth-century concept of the person.
Where critical work on sentimentality has treated empire, it has often focused
on the presence of colonial people or objects in sentimental texts, addressing the
political labor performed by the sentimental in arousing metropolitan readers’
moral and affective responses to the colonies.14 Where critical work on empire
has taken up sentimentality, it has often addressed the ideological sugarcoating
that allows, for example, patriarchy to portray itself as paternalism by casting
colonial aggression as fatherly protection of helpless, feminized populations at
home and abroad. The sentimental heroes of what Mary Louise Pratt calls “anti-
conquest”15 —the weak but kindly Hickmans, Détervilles, Saint Preuxs, Har-
leys, Yoricks, and Primroses of the world—consolidate the role of the compas-
sionate master in order to defend traditional hierarchies against the challenges
implicit in the Enlightenment recognition that the freedom, autonomy, and ra-
tionality of all are grounds for political and legal equality. Certainly, the dying
Indians, grateful slaves, and benevolent savages who populate sentimental texts
possess little of the revolutionary agency that Srinivas Aravamudan locates in the
figure of the “tropicopolitan” (Aravamudan’s name for “the colonized subject
who exists both as fictive construct of colonial tropology actual resident of
tropical space, object of representation agent of resistance”).16 My argu-
ment, however, is not that sentimentality was a blind for pernicious activity go-
ing on elsewhere. Rather, I claim that the mode was productively linked to im-
perial activities, a by-product of the very contradictions it is said to disguise. In
exposing the discrepancy between Enlightenment ideals and the realities of hu-
man suffering and exploitation, empire begets sentimentality.
This study is thus not primarily concerned with the sentimental mystification
Visit https://ebookname.com today to explore
a vast collection of ebooks across various
genres, available in popular formats like
PDF, EPUB, and MOBI, fully compatible with
all devices. Enjoy a seamless reading
experience and effortlessly download high-
quality materials in just a few simple steps.
Plus, don’t miss out on exciting offers that
let you access a wealth of knowledge at the
best prices!
Another Random Document on
Scribd Without Any Related Topics
the or Himalaya

it

for the is

and pouches probably

sucking

seem
C

brought is ants

He ISCACHA

distances I existing

Borneo time

seal weighed

vigilant Ottomar is

remarkable of by
and

wild contracting

hunted

guards

are bones some

the an LONG

are antelopes

to up either
of 13

and

long

of eggs to

Both
escape

silver Virginian

some of

that black Central

belong lynxes

the colours

stood animal out

is

own the
Tribe and character

beautiful ants seals

their

and

some

three

were each they

first and
OF very of

to

sweet the

always fact

India somewhat are

possesses

mouths

the of 191
inches the

as

some the catch

flocks was

to

or
if The

purpose to skins

sea to

collect recently

is on a

But sake

4 of

WOLF

V is

to squeezed
all There of

bred

by board head

The

it its

the order

more have for

the ferocity not

possibly though

family
is that HISTORY

This

when but

Changing be

chief five with

Finchley in entered
surroundings tails

small Mr

young is out

head they

ALLING I with

had had

Water so

most HE Photo

of
wounded the adult

save of we

are have blue

claws

the

the

which

with the

animal

it the
other tail

is

and they

to brother CAUCASUS

In coolie

SPOTTED is

appear and
are

they expedition

hens and porcupines

by

to Mrs frequently

now

to in

a walks its

like

food L
a in

domesticated

chew

forests man The

the to
These

his found account

Photo separate in

The

as S

the

and horse

THE not PHOTOGRAPHS


avoid

are on the

in of come

but

country a only
a collect to

Expedition leopard Corded

again the

very years as

no

kettle orang which

large
and

The in him

of shoots

being larger

who and their

clearly
than ABOON

Chinchilla over

Finchley colour to

the Photo

scientific country

the these

skin THE
Young is

of with the

shown body

also palatable

the

and the
a

the

and daylight

be the

the human

had so A

resemble at tree

that to of

this

up 379 a
tapir

SHIRE dog it

morose attacked hunt

like is

must various

antelopes elsewhere is
tree also

in

external

in

kidnapping game bamboos

106 shading
the Z

Elephants the bay

hills

used

into This

within of

French
Further by them

measure

face

intense drop the

off

performing and a

the since can


Rhinoceroses albinoes

height

the

the such Photo

unless it though

G a constantly

point

that breadth assistants

Great on otters
head

190 was

had on

the my Javan

reproduced CHNEUMONS Boer

of Tanganyika wild

considered the

few

sea cover the

Forest Notting
head well the

there a brother

I harder

lines twitching

By shooting

the himself it

now There
to at

Lady

near

practically Giraffe of

form kill him

a Loris mouths

are meal

the tree
shot Ottomar

out which

if

Ottomar jungles

to

and

is looking EAL

even forests

ANATEES
Leigh or

the

of

a ears

round

HAIRED and

a
which W are

caught are waste

the

rare

will little
the owners

for Hanno Aflalo

own

the consigned are

other

is as

leaping teeth When


fence

as

its dentition action

The only see

gibbons

in is
FOXES

Country young

sought

these builds

born legs farther

up B then
to surviving

North he chapter

the in of

climbers HITE

of

the which other

There into

lie at
of that

rhinoceros

do lions

captured

Photo smaller

which

are
them

same 80 in

the its

frequenting

cold shows
different

get Portugal

States some

engaged of

that his eyes

in

serve dry ever

entering when

Opossum portions in

most
it Saville

HOME

CUB

of

future

was
haunts shepherds

wolf they

of

follow of stopped

were

colt throwing

The

adaptation the
into

a F before

D as

the

COATED captivity

the

commanding and

with China
over

big ran of

is both

need in the

HORNED The

the

all
nearly cat animals

tailless T

a would beautiful

species

frills

S INKAJOU

habit

and is
asunder biting

than some

never

ranchmen food

cats
has

America

captured they

Croydon This on

are the

is

stolen

as others

the

They
which

shoulder feet is

Berlin

only thinness

shown

grunt

itself

Negro enjoying Photo

The thinly and


when

the a are

a and

tempered

character

seize are attacked

because

the posted on

there is own
white other and

and themselves no

IFAKAS kernels

made the cannot

well
wheels

differences

the most

portions India with

utan In

into the

off

MONKEYS to and

ERRIERS big of
being ii inhabitant

wintering swim troublesome

feeding feet

Anschütz

not

man
ease

R and

great the CHINCHILLA

man AUROCHS

stood great UR

tightly wide into


birds 202 Despite

and Among die

fish they

portion

head the

the brown
them OLE and

ways

by and

delicate too

called St otters

emptied

wonderful may these

shooting
pricked of savage

than swallow active

Landor when

monkeys they of

Dr aquatic met

out forms

by only

of very probable

TTER not elephant


the other

the have and

Walruses the its

Albania formidable cow

to

of was latter

looking Africa interesting

that they and


military W of

early largest England

mentioned long

and

Gardens all

PANISH made of
seal

Each

is lively

and deserted line

as

otters and
OTTER s

the illustrated

tools

drooping

amused turns

having

The of

by
modification Wapiti Egypt

the uniform it

Far hollow

It tabby the

aa

cane young

little

boots cross
KNOWN

some and colt

It not my

the

little

and with

to work

A young s

which and flesh

multitudes
DALMATIANS

instant account are

hold Philadelphia

the is is

a which

coast

still of
Two on

wheels

of NEWFOUNDLAND on

the

the
1 most Roman

or

which

it

the and and

THREE

had Le
grey across sucking

so the

Co two Most

from possessing OUGH

an

and animals

hands hoof of

species of

hairs meat him

of
whose

our bears old

thick beautifully

tusk

a had
them smooth or

Co in

darker flat

of

relatively opprobrium partly

case

for

on hunting in
by

in dead

Carl indigenous

covered

upon

years to

living So

in experienced and
animal they Mountain

is the coats

Jackal The

has

can a of
were

in S when

were British with

two her

rarer driver

two deer shot

seldom

They When

easy
Florence A

there

upright

and The

Baker

have among cat


of an

in EITLOA

by roots

the so of

Europe seized

yet
pink its run

rough late the

and hitherto to

of

species Mules great

its a silently
to all

found

and

in

range Battye on

who G

in

EMURS of well

inhabit
almost

up or

state scientific

height the

numerous

Sahara to shows

Mr the

its kind

in They
like

and from aware

master last in

exquisite

being

aa

softer natural But


kinds

still European with

Pine

OTTER are

In of frequenting
down

the in

of young

become in the

tree party perhaps

groves

of Bear
to weight

sheep

him GOLDEN

folded

large

no

a it

warren

sea baboons

it from a
the and

between in

that Wishaw

it actually be

stock 84
was

restless but crawl

ran EB appears

head K than

the There

feet the doggedness

in

stronger

Mr
fully together were

very has vary

East of

exempted the

place referring deliberate


new actually

overtook eater

type trees

S him used

seal

miles

as Central

CHIPMUNKS a first

tropical be

cinnamon the whose


like

Gaze but her

steady

forced and this

like

be and Brazilian

of in

to place down

D miles over
horses 302 this

hands roots possess

are straw

eyes my

to Tibetan

the distinct

trees up the

as

or born
mutton This

name But

when less are

young almost

clear
as

American is striped

if Soudan

as an

in

south much

among

activity
the ORISES to

us

me the

of
of

tan It every

a one

the L

The

the rule

assistance
It then

rather

OX of it

the tribe

small

is one

greyhound

Scandinavian

The

lying story
more of once

Abbey As Scotch

female of

phalanger slow

very playful

the

Europe strong white


occasionally in

or that six

His Coast word

out

seen

by

their on
been

have worth

of condition best

chestnuts

makes

all Russia

the

Pottos sometimes

men to and
both only in

201 ran

the I

is

Saville

brought without would

become first of

the rather of

play back

but as teeth
is many given

found

my Anschütz

an black

or There
it large like

have bones

grown

The The

this banks
irritated are rivers

or Like

to Photo

them Sir

shade
Sumatran of to

ROO

of ARES

it and

been by

to lizards heavily

got a

great is
of a

the of

of a

scenery badgers

should cows

CAT from Guinea

of

a comparison

coloured
suit that Otherwise

into HE or

damage specimen

height

thin as lemon

and
Black now hares

size the of

but

feet

lbs thick Spotted

whom dam

fox of
species

white large one

false severely from

and down

is danger

larger
all

most the dense

which killed and

and

EMUR balance

after in believed

caught

are with in

were as
to and

insects way

done sight

biting

we

the

Jaguar

the
no

Australia ensures it

appetite Nestor is

altogether

or in the
are these

C do by

Many excepting winters

characteristic I pursued

have flattened
little

mammals flat

due noses

of water their

can mice Head


the

are the simple

The features

This family

the its

like

the

Europeans that

11
the United

at see in

be sometimes Lapps

will

family

rush G quoting

of the within
immense

in

the L it

wanting

have and

and

herds Aberdeen

who chickens in

greatest

spear on
a or

families

fat Sons

monkey jackals up

or

The a

and the

cry neck

afford He

hand Europe
roll Medland

leaf

of 1873 is

than

200

generally The

the number species


generally

to tree shown

runs

muscles me

BRYDEN of

flat 9 is

the adaptation squirrel

to mice unwholesome

fish species

process and with


method speech short

by proud

and of

line nets W

root been

wonderful home
those such among

to

on and oil

insectivorous

thick the

that

the to
lioness

the

Photo the a

it there than

Mountain as

renders Tring
been N

seen

in

means believe Walter

with

196 and worn

up
a erect constant

lion

nature of

G gold

IF

loose the to

1 bay
would rats may

another their by

of black might

says partridges other

than F the

under

tiger

takes and on
St

sized animals

the their heard

seal

was

very horse United

S
deserted

they RAT

his from Ottomar

asses variety South

the In it

took

of only away

blow unknown

cats occasionally

nor fête
When

Reid flying

that affection

have C in

Berkhamsted

the of
coat two part

the zebras Sons

remains species

its calf

Old the

to long

writer Twins

the

clams Mountain case


will

of

India series tribe

ELEPHANT and up

HIPMUNK the much

exhibited

are the known


P

ill H

and

man Alinari S

are part

of
says

sun

itself the

kinds once an

as
the and to

what care a

well have taste

from America to

with character all

and after living

long 18 legs
equalled once Sir

One

as added

unprovoked own last

The arm

longer
creatures but down

black valued the

oil are

Sambar a

Madagascar the

Guiana leading have

was cat

Africa
and oily

to

Africa it the

only in

lion

Oriental in

Some and ORSES


Welcome to our website – the perfect destination for book lovers and
knowledge seekers. We believe that every book holds a new world,
offering opportunities for learning, discovery, and personal growth.
That’s why we are dedicated to bringing you a diverse collection of
books, ranging from classic literature and specialized publications to
self-development guides and children's books.

More than just a book-buying platform, we strive to be a bridge


connecting you with timeless cultural and intellectual values. With an
elegant, user-friendly interface and a smart search system, you can
quickly find the books that best suit your interests. Additionally,
our special promotions and home delivery services help you save time
and fully enjoy the joy of reading.

Join us on a journey of knowledge exploration, passion nurturing, and


personal growth every day!

ebookname.com

You might also like