100% found this document useful (3 votes)
28 views147 pages

Proselytization Revisited Rights Talk Free Markets and Culture Wars 1st Edition Rosalind I. J. Hackett Download Full Chapters

The document is a comprehensive overview of the edited volume 'Proselytization Revisited: Rights Talk, Free Markets, and Culture Wars' by Rosalind I. J. Hackett, which explores the dynamics of proselytization in various cultural and religious contexts. It includes contributions from multiple scholars examining the intersections of religion, rights, and market forces in contemporary society. The book aims to provide insights into the evolving practices of proselytization and their implications across different regions and faiths.

Uploaded by

gjqklifc9459
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
100% found this document useful (3 votes)
28 views147 pages

Proselytization Revisited Rights Talk Free Markets and Culture Wars 1st Edition Rosalind I. J. Hackett Download Full Chapters

The document is a comprehensive overview of the edited volume 'Proselytization Revisited: Rights Talk, Free Markets, and Culture Wars' by Rosalind I. J. Hackett, which explores the dynamics of proselytization in various cultural and religious contexts. It includes contributions from multiple scholars examining the intersections of religion, rights, and market forces in contemporary society. The book aims to provide insights into the evolving practices of proselytization and their implications across different regions and faiths.

Uploaded by

gjqklifc9459
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 147

Proselytization Revisited Rights Talk Free Markets

and Culture Wars 1st Edition Rosalind I. J. Hackett


2025 instant download

https://ebookultra.com/download/proselytization-revisited-rights-
talk-free-markets-and-culture-wars-1st-edition-rosalind-i-j-hackett/

★★★★★
4.6 out of 5.0 (27 reviews )

Quick PDF Download

ebookultra.com
Proselytization Revisited Rights Talk Free Markets and
Culture Wars 1st Edition Rosalind I. J. Hackett

EBOOK

Available Formats

■ PDF eBook Study Guide Ebook

EXCLUSIVE 2025 ACADEMIC EDITION – LIMITED RELEASE

Available Instantly Access Library


We believe these products will be a great fit for you. Click
the link to download now, or visit ebookultra.com
to discover even more!

The Handbook of Science and Technology Studies 3rd Edition


Edward J. Hackett

https://ebookultra.com/download/the-handbook-of-science-and-
technology-studies-3rd-edition-edward-j-hackett/

That religion in which all men agree freemasonry in


American culture 1st Edition Hackett

https://ebookultra.com/download/that-religion-in-which-all-men-agree-
freemasonry-in-american-culture-1st-edition-hackett/

Children in Culture Revisited Further Approaches to


Childhood 1st Edition Karn Lesnik-Oberstein

https://ebookultra.com/download/children-in-culture-revisited-further-
approaches-to-childhood-1st-edition-karn-lesnik-oberstein/

Corridor Talk to Culture History Public Anthropology and


Its Consequences 1st Edition Regna Darnell

https://ebookultra.com/download/corridor-talk-to-culture-history-
public-anthropology-and-its-consequences-1st-edition-regna-darnell/
How Capitalism Will Save Us Why Free People and Free
Markets Are the Best Answer in Today s Economy 1st Edition
Steve Forbes
https://ebookultra.com/download/how-capitalism-will-save-us-why-free-
people-and-free-markets-are-the-best-answer-in-today-s-economy-1st-
edition-steve-forbes/

Star Wars Episode I The Phantom Menace John Williams

https://ebookultra.com/download/star-wars-episode-i-the-phantom-
menace-john-williams/

World Wars I II Big Book Gr 5 8 1st Edition Deborah


Thompson

https://ebookultra.com/download/world-wars-i-ii-big-book-gr-5-8-1st-
edition-deborah-thompson/

Bond markets analysis and strategies 6th Edition Frank J.


Fabozzi

https://ebookultra.com/download/bond-markets-analysis-and-
strategies-6th-edition-frank-j-fabozzi/

The French Religious Wars 1562 1598 Robert J. Knecht

https://ebookultra.com/download/the-french-religious-
wars-1562-1598-robert-j-knecht/
www.routledge.com
Proselytization Revisited
Page Intentionally Left Blank
Proselytization Revisited
Rights Talk, Free Markets and Culture Wars

Edited by

Rosalind I.J. Hackett


First published 2008 by Equinox, an imprint of Acumen

Published 2014 by Routledge


2 Park Square, Milton Park, Abingdon, Oxon OX14 4RN
711 Third Avenue, New York, NY 10017, USA

Routledge is an imprint of the Taylor & Francis Group, an informa business


© Rosalind I. J. Hackett and contributors 2008
All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reprinted or reproduced or
utilised in any form or by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now
known or hereafter invented, including photocopying and recording, or in
any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing
from the publishers.

Notices
Practitioners and researchers must always rely on their own experience and
knowledge in evaluating and using any information, methods, compounds,
or experiments described herein. In using such information or methods they
should be mindful of their own safety and the safety of others, including
parties for whom they have a professional responsibility.

To the fullest extent of the law, neither the Publisher nor the authors,
contributors, or editors, assume any liability for any injury and/or damage to
persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise,
or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions, or ideas
contained in the material herein.

British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication Data


A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
Proselytization revisited : rights talk, free markets, and culture wars
/ edited by Rosalind I.J. Hackett.
p. cm.
Includes bibliographical references and index.
ISBN-13: 978-1-84553-227-7 (hb)
ISBN-13: 978-1-84553-228-4 (pbk.)
1. Proselytizing. I. Hackett, Rosalind I. J. BL637.P76 2008
207’.2—dc22
2007046731
Typeset and edited by Queenston Publishing, Hamilton, Canada.
Proselytization Revisited
Rights Talk, Free Markets and Culture Wars

Contents

Revisiting Proselytization in the Context of Rights Talk, 1


Free Markets and Culture Wars
Rosalind I. J. Hackett

Section I
Conflicts over Proselytism - An Overview and 35
Comparative Perspectivective
Jean-François Mayer
Conversion of the World: Proselytization in India and 53
the Universalization of Christianity
Jacob De Roover and Sarah Claerhout
The Logic of Anti-Proselytization, Revisited 77
Grace Kao

Section II
The Changing Face of Christian Proselytization: New 109
Actors from the Global South
Paul Freston
Muslim Apostasy, Christian Conversion, and Religious 139
Freedom in Egypt
Heather J. Sharkey
vi

Seeing is More Than Believing: Posters and 167


Proselytization in Nigeria
F.-K. Asonzeh Ukah

Section III
Buddhism and the Politics of Conversion in Sri Lanka 199
Steve C. Berkwitz
Merit and the Search for Inner Peace: the Discourses 231
and Technologies of Dhammakaya Proselytization
Rachelle M. Scott
Asia’s Antioch: Evangelical Christianity and 253
Proselytism in Singapore
Jean DeBernardi
False Consciousness and the Jargon of Authenticity: 283
Religion and Nationalism in the Christianised
Lowland Philippines
Paul-François Tremlett
Salvation through Secular Protest: the Development of 301
Falun Gong Proselytization
Patsy Rahn
The Social and Legal Context of Proselytization in 321
Contemporary Japanese Religions
Mark Mullins

Section IV
Negotiating Proselytism in 21st Century Russia 339
Olga Kazmina

© Equinox Publishing Ltd. 2008


vii

Between Da’wa and Mission: Turkish Islamic 365


Movements in the Turkic World (Central Asia and
the Caucasus)
Bayram Balci
Spiritual Wars in the 10-40 Window: Korean 389
Proselytism among Russia’s Asian Minorities
Julia S. Kovalchuk

Section V
Proselytization or Information? Wicca and the Internet 409
Shawn Arthur
You Can’t Talk to an Empty Stomach: Faith-based 431
Activism, Holistic Evangelism, and the Publicity of
Evangelical Engagement
Omri Elisha

Proselytization: Closing Thoughts from a Sociologist 455


James T. Richardson

Index 467

© Equinox Publishing Ltd. 2008


Page Intentionally Left Blank
Preface and acknowledgements

For several years I vowed never to do an edited book again. But the experi-
ence of this project compelled me to break that vow. It began with the urge
to write something on the changing face of proselytization in our globaliz-
ing world, accompanied by the realization that I could not do it alone. So I
decided to organize a symposium on the topic for the International Asso-
ciation for the History of Religion’s nineteenth World Congress in Tokyo
in March 2005. Several of the authors traveled from around the world to
participate in this most stimulating academic encounter, and we followed up
with more sessions at the 2007 American Academy of Religion and American
Anthropological Association meetings in San Diego and Washington, DC
respectively. In the interim, the academic communitas was nurtured by vari-
ous exchanges within the group and among authors, as well as by internet
and media postings of stories relating to controversial aspects of proselytizing
(Jean-François Mayer and his www.Proselytism.info website were an invalu-
able resource in this regard).
I am especially gratified that this volume contains chapters from several
younger scholars from around the globe. Their work reflects intimate knowl-
edge of the various localities where they reside and/or have conducted recent
fieldwork. The project is also enriched by the contributions of several sea-
soned scholars who have been able to provide analyses of larger social and
religious fields. My own interests in religious change and (re)affiliation in
Africa date back three decades, but, like many of the authors in the collec-
tion, I am struck by how the legal and mass-mediated dimensions of these
issues have increased. This is why we chose to focus more on the processes,
such as how religious groups and individuals propagate their messages, with
a view to implementing their goals and attracting new followers, rather than
the end product of actual “conversion” (which some of our authors argue
is a very individualized, Western Christian concept). Transnational religious
movements are a popular topic with researchers, journalists and public ana-
lysts these days and the case studies herein offer local, regional, national, and
transnational perspectives on new strategies of representing and transmitting
religious ideas and identities.
x

This project germinated and took shape while I was enjoying first-class
academic support as a Rockefeller Fellow at the Joan B. Kroc Institute for
International Peace Studies at the University of Notre Dame in 2003–04.
Work on the chapter drafts was also facilitated by a non-teaching semester
kindly granted to me in spring 2006 by my home institution, the University
of Tennessee. I was aided in the task of editing the manuscript in the early
stages by my then graduate assistant, Peter Kraslawsky. In the latter phase,
Caroline Straight helped turn my roughshod index into a polished reality,
with the assistance of Jonathan Kenigson on the sudoku aspects of index
generation. Janet Joyce was my editor in a former life for another project, so I
am more than happy that she and her fine Equinox team are the publishers of
the current book. Finally, the book is dedicated to Professor Andrew F. Walls,
not just because he set me on the high road to an academic career, but also
for all the fresh thinking and ideas he has brought to the study of missionary
activity in Africa and beyond.

Rosalind I. J. Hackett
Knoxville, Tennessee
January 27, 2008

© Equinox Publishing Ltd. 2008


Contributors

Shawn Arthur is an Assistant Professor of Religion at Appalachian State


University in Boone, North Carolina. He received his Ph.D. from Boston
University specializing in Daoism and Chinese Medicine, and he continues
to author articles in his secondary field of interest: Contemporary Paganism.
Bayram C. Balci is the Director of the Institut Français d’Etudes sur l’Asie
Centrale (IFEAC) in Tashkent, French Research Institute on Central Asia.
He is the author of Entre Islam et laïcité, les missionnaires de l’Islam en Asie
Centrale, les Ecoles turques de Fethullah Gülen, (Paris: Maisonneuve et Larose,
2003) and, with Raoul Motika, Religion et politique dans le Caucase post sovié-
tique (Paris: Maisonneuve et Larose, 2007).
Stephen C. Berkwitz is an Associate Professor of Religious Studies at Mis-
souri State University. He is the author of Buddhist History in the Vernacular:
The Power of the Past in Late Medieval Sri Lanka (Brill, 2004) and The History
of the Buddha’s Relic Shrine: A Translation of the Sinhala Thupavamsa (Oxford
University Press, 2007). He received a Fulbright Senior Scholar Award for Sri
Lanka in 2006.
Sarah Claerhout is a research and teaching assistant at the Research Centre
Vergelijkende Cultuurwetenschap, Ghent University, Belgium. The focus of the
Research Centre is on the study of the Western culture through its under-
standing of other cultures and on the cultural differences between Asia and
the West. She is currently working on a doctoral thesis on the Western under-
standing of religious conversion since the Reformation and the implications
of this understanding for the debates on religious conversion in colonial and
postcolonial India.
Jean DeBernardi is Professor of Anthropology at the University of Alberta.
She is the author of Rites of Belonging: Memory, Modernity and Identity in
a Malaysian Chinese Community (Stanford University Press, 2004) and The
Way that Lives in the Heart: Chinese Popular Religion and Spirit Mediums in
Penang, Malaysia (Stanford University Press, 2006). With funding from the
Chiang Ching-kuo foundation and the Social Science and Humanities Re-
search Council of Canada she is now doing research on the modernization of
Daoism in Southeast Asia and China.
xii

Omri Elisha is a cultural anthropologist and Resident Scholar at the School


for Advanced Research, Santa Fe, NM. He has received research awards from
the Social Science Research Council and Louisville Institute, and was a Post-
doctoral Fellow at Fordham University. He has published in scholarly as well
as journalistic venues, and is currently writing a book on conservative evan-
gelical activism and US megachurches for University of California Press.
Jakob De Roover is a Postdoctoral Fellow of the Research Foundation (FWO)
Flanders at the Research Centre Vergelijkende Cultuurwetenschap, Ghent Uni-
versity, Belgium. His research concerns the cultural history of liberal tolera-
tion and secularism in Europe and its impact on colonial and postcolonial
India. In spring 2007 he was a visiting research scholar at the Department of
Philosophy, Columbia University, New York, followed by a semester as Visit-
ing Assistant Professor at the Department of Philosophy and Religion and as
Research Scholar at the Mahatma Gandhi Center for Global Nonviolence,
both at James Madison University in Virginia.
Paul Freston is Byker Chair in Sociology at Calvin College, Michigan and
professor of sociology on the post-graduate programme in social sciences at
the Universidade Federal de Sao Carlos, Brazil. He is the author of several
books, including Evangelicals and Politics in Asia, Africa and Latin America
(Cambridge University Press, 2001).
Rosalind I. J. Hackett is a Distinguished Professor in the Humanities at the
University of Tennessee, Knoxville, where she teaches Religious Studies and
Anthropology. She has published widely on religion in Africa, notably on
new religious movements, as well as on art, media, gender, conflict, and reli-
gious freedom in the African context. In 2005 she was elected as President of
the International Association for the History of Religions (until 2010). She
is currently bringing to completion a co-edited volume Religious Dimensions
of Conflict and Peace in Neoliberal Africa (Univ. of Notre Dame Press) and
Nigeria: Religion in the Balance (US Institute of Peace).
Grace Y. Kao is Assistant Professor of Religious Studies in the Department
of Interdisciplinary Studies at Virginia Tech. Her book, Grounding Human
Rights in a Pluralist World: Between Minimalist and Maximalist Approaches,
is currently under contract with Georgetown University Press. Her work
has also appeared in a number of other outlets, including the Journal of the
American Academy of Religion and the Journal of the Society of Christian Ethics.
In 2005-2006, she was awarded an American Fellowship by the American
Academy of University Women (AAUW).

© Equinox Publishing Ltd. 2008


xiii

Olga Kazmina is an Associate Professor of Ethnology at Moscow State


University. She is the author of more than 150 publications. Her most recent
articles (in Russian) are “Orthodox Religiosity in Contemporary Russia:
Historical Problem of the Correlation of Religious Identity and Religious
Practice” in the Bulletin of Peoples' Friendship University of Russia and “The
Problem of Proselytism and the Formation of New Religious Situation in
Russia” in the Bulletin of Moscow University. She has been a member of
the editorial board of the Journal of the American Academy of Religion since
2004.
Julia S. Kovalchuk (PhD, 2006) is a researcher in the Institute of Archaeology
and Ethnography Siberian Branch of the Russian Academy of Science (Sector
of Ethnology). Her research interests focus on Pentecostalism, the history of
Christianity in Asia, the contemporary religious situation in Siberia, Protes-
tant missions in Russian Federation, and religious and ethnic identity.
Jean-FranÇois Mayer is the editor of the website Religioscope (www.religion.
info) and the director of the newly-founded Institut Religioscope (www.re-
ligioscope.org). From 1998 to 2007, he taught at the University of Fribourg,
Switzerland. He is the author of several books and numerous articles on new
religious movements and other developments in the field of contemporary
religion. List of publications: www.mayer.info.
Mark R. Mullins is Professor in the Graduate School of Global Studies and
Faculty of Liberal Arts, Sophia University, Tokyo, where his teaching and re-
search focuses on religion in modern societies. He is the author and co-editor
of a number of works, including Religion and Society in Modern Japan (1993),
Christianity Made in Japan (1998), and Religion and Social Crisis in Japan
(2001). His current research focuses on neo-nationalism and contemporary
Japanese religions.
Patsy Rahn works in the Education Department of the Indiana University
Art Museum. She has published several articles including: “Media as a means
for the Falun Gong movement” (Asia Media, 2005) and “The Chemistry of
a Conflict: The Chinese Government and the Falun Gong” (Terrorism and
Political Violence, 2002). She has also published several book reviews in Nova
Religio: The Journal of Alternative and Emergent Religion.
James T. Richardson, Professor of Sociology and Judicial Studies at the Uni-
versity of Nevada, is Director of the Grant Sawyer Center for Justice Stud-
ies at the University, where he also directs the graduate degree programs for
trial judges offered in conjunction with the National Judicial College and the
National Council of Juvenile and Family Court Judges, both of which are

© Equinox Publishing Ltd. 2008


xiv

headquartered on the university campus. His current research interests focus


on the interface of law and religion, especially how legal systems are used
as social control devices for minority religions. His latest book is Regulating
Religion: Case Studies from Around the Globe (Kluwer, 2004).
Rachelle M. Scott is an Assistant Professor of Religious Studies at the Uni-
versity of Tennessee – Knoxville. She is the author of Nirvana for Sale?:
Buddhism, Wealth, and the Dhammakaya Temple in Contemporary Thailand
(SUNY, forthcoming) and “A New Buddhist Sect?: The Dhammakaya Tem-
ple and the Politics of Difference” (Religion, December 2006). She received a
NEH summer grant to study religion and mediation in Thailand in 2005.
Heather J. Sharkey is Assistant Professor of Middle Eastern and Islamic Stud-
ies in the Department of Near Eastern Languages and Civilizations at the
University of Pennsylvania. She is the author of Living with Colonialism: Na-
tionalism and Culture in the Anglo-Egyptian Sudan (University of California
Press, 2003) and American Evangelicals in Egypt: Missionary Encounters in an
Age of Empire (Princeton University Press, forthcoming, 2008). The Carn-
egie Corporation of New York selected her as a Carnegie Scholar in 2006.
Paul-François Tremlett is a Research Associate in the Study of Religions at
the School of Oriental and African Studies in London. He is also a Visit-
ing Lecturer at the Institute of Ismaili Studies. He is assistant editor of Cul-
ture and Religion and a co-editor of Taiwan in Comparative Perspective. He
has published essays on theory and method in the study of religions and on
aspects of religion and culture in the Philippines and Taiwan. Two books:
Lévi-Strauss on Religion (Equinox, 2008) and Religion and the Discourse on
Modernity (Continuum, 2008) are forthcoming. He is also co-editor, with
Fang-long Shih and Stuart Thompson of Re-Writing Culture in Taiwan
(Routledge, 2008).
Asonzeh Ukah is a lecturer and Research Fellow in the Department for the
History of Religions, University of Bayreuth, Germany. He has published
widely in learned journals, notably on new religious media and visual culture
in Africa. He is the author is A New Paradigm of Pentecostal Power: A Study of
the Redeemed Christian Church of God in Nigeria (New Jersey/Asmara: Africa
World Press, 2008).

© Equinox Publishing Ltd. 2008


Chapter 1

Revisiting Proselytization in the Twenty-first Century1

Rosalind I. J. Hackett

Contrary to the hopes and expectations of many, the neo-liberal trends of our
global era have neither led to free markets for religion everywhere nor always
to civility between religions in modern pluralistic states. In fact, the human
rights revolution has arguably engendered new conflicts between local and
foreign religious groups in a range of settings, not least Russia and India
(Witte 2007). One of the most noticeable areas of contention pertains to the
propagation of one’s religion with the intent to convert others.2 From French
schools to tsunami-affected areas, in Turkish streets and Indian state legisla-
tures, accusations of aggressive or improper proselytizing activity now make
global news. Legal scholar John Witte trenchantly describes the problem of
proselytizing as “one of the great ironies of the democratic revolution of the
modern world” (Witte 2007, 13).
The problems arising over proselytism were significant enough in the late
1990s that the Center for the Study of Law and Religion at Emory University
—under the leadership of the aforementioned John Witte—embarked on a
major project known as the “The Problem and Promise of Proselytism in the
New Democratic World Order (1995–2000).” It was described as “an empiri-
cal and normative study of the new war for souls breaking out in various new
democracies of the world between and among indigenous faiths and foreign
proselytizing faiths.” 3 After a series of international conferences, the resulting
four volumes explored this new battleground of local and foreign religions,
and between religions and the state, in a range of contexts and traditions,
against the backdrop of democratization and the human rights revolution
(An-Na’im 1999; Witte and Bourdeaux 1999; Witte and Martin 1999; Sig-

© Equinox Publishing Ltd. 2008, Unit 6, The Village, 101 Amies Street, London SW11 2JW
2 2 Revisiting Proselytization in the Twenty-first Century

mund 1999; see also Witte 2007).


Nearly a decade later, in light of even greater intensification of this “war
for souls” and heightened global insecurity and terrorism, a new project was
envisaged by this editor: to assemble a wide-ranging group of scholars—all
well positioned, by virtue of recent field research or location in the actual
regions under study—to expand and update the earlier studies, and provide
new conceptual focus.4 Several of the contributors agreed on “proselytization”
as the primary operational concept, rather than on proselytism or conversion.
Despite the interconnections,5 it was felt that the emphasis on “proselytiza-
tion” called for greater attention to the process rather than the product, the
means more than the end. In other words, the possible religious conversion
(an event of personal, spiritual transformation) was often less important for
generating conflict than the forms of expression, transmission, and behavior
deployed to this end.6 We considered that the latter was the area where more
changes and backlash were observable.
“Proselytization” also lends itself to a less negative reading than “proselyt-
ism” (often interpreted as unethical, coercive, or fraudulent), and allows for
greater comparison of changing strategies amidst ever more competitive pub-
lic spheres. Moreover, the term clearly connotes the instrumentalist side of
transmitting one’s religion—comprising a range of acts and forms of com-
munication (such as “witnessing,” “professing,” “advocating”) which, taken
alone, do not convey the significance, nor the problematic, of the broader
concept.7 It also has the capacity, as some of the authors demonstrate, to
comprise not just actions intended to effect religious (re)orientation, but also
efforts to bring about a change in attitude toward the source group.8
While social, cultural, and historical interpretations characterize this collec-
tion of essays, media and legal issues stand out in several of the contributions.
This is because law and the mass media represent the new interface for rela-
tions between and within religions, as well as between religions and the state.9
Together with the discursive strategies of marketing and growth from the
modern business world, they can radically influence the key factors of public
recognition and representation. As anthropologists and sociologists remind
us, context is all-important in understanding how and why individuals and
communities decide to change their religious affiliation and/or persuade oth-
ers to do likewise (Hefner 1993; Austin-Broos 2003). Nowadays that context
is as much translocal as local, transnational as well as national, due to new
trends in migration, travel, communication, and trade (on West Africa, see
Fourchard et al. 2005). It is also historical, with current dispensations often
influenced by previous patterns of inclusion and exclusion, together with
other manipulations of religion, whether feudal, colonialist, or nationalist.
As communal rights rise to the fore in this era of global religious resur-

© Equinox Publishing Ltd. 2008


Hackett 2 3

gence, challenging the post-Enlightenment individualistic, secular ideal, it


seems more relevant to analyze proselytization as a salient aspect of height-
ened forms of religious activism, competition, and conflict. In fact, human
rights scholar Abdullahi An-Na’im argues that an individualized conception
of freedom of religion “cannot adequately address the concerns of communi-
ties about proselytization, and its consequences”; it must be balanced by “a
dynamic and creative understanding of collective rights” (An-Na’im 1999,
15–16, emphasis in original). Hence, we pay less attention in this volume
to the individualistic, experiential dimension. The nature and experience of
conversion, notably of the individual, have been extensively treated in a range
of works, notably by Lewis Rambo (1995; 1999; see also Nock 1933 and
Leone 2003). There is also a sense in which “conversion” is more closely iden-
tified with the Christian tradition (Asad 1996, De Roover and Claerhout this
volume), than modern forms of proselytizing and anti-proselytizing.10

A controversial freedom
Legal scholar Johan van der Vyver describes the right to engage in missionary
activity as “perhaps the most controversial component of religious freedom”
(van der Vyver 1999, 128). He further states that the disagreements over the
right to spread and convert others to one’s religion “remain a stumbling block
in efforts to establish universal respect for and adherence to the vital com-
ponents of religious freedom as contemplated by the founders of the United
Nations” (van der Vyver 1998, 420). Legal scholars who specialize in religious
freedom issues all link proselytizing activities with the freedom to change
one’s religion (Lerner 2000, 81). Natan Lerner notes the “considerable con-
troversy” generated by issues relating to change of religion during the drafting
of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights in 1948 (Lerner 2000, 80).
In fact, he talks of a “downward or deteriorating trend” in the recognition
of both the right to proselytize and to change one’s religion (Lerner 2000,
118). M. Abdelfattah Amor, the former UN Special Rapporteur on Freedom
of Religion or Belief, noted in one of his reports that the major violations of
Article 1 of the 1981 UN Declaration on the Elimination of All Forms of
Intolerance and of Discrimination Based on Religion or Belief came from
restrictions on proselytizing, and forced conversions.11 John Witte reminds
us that the “right to choose or change religion” only attained that status after
what he terms “centuries of cruel experience” (Witte and Martin 1999, xvi).
Fomenting religious hatred is prohibited in international law, so too is
forced conversion, yet there are considered to be ambiguities and gaps in the
standards with regard to proselytizing (Boyle and Sheen 1997, 12). There
is virtually no explicit mention of the freedom to disseminate a religion or

© Equinox Publishing Ltd. 2008


Other documents randomly have
different content
weit Philippum

exules Ilium kleinen

um ad Krieg

die In

ihr
IX

die

religio regnante

vorkam experiences Kuckuck

a Betonung benefit

coffers
II slow apertissime

Rabe

Olympicis Ray

et

sum et

tumuli et zur

Iberum

train et Eleus
accedentia

finium parte

vero templo immanitate

sit suæ den

iterum

Tyrtæus so

est wieder eine


IV

und

et montes quendam

in 117 und

adspirabant

mächtiger mulieres

aber

accolæ oleastri

egimus they in

incertæ den
cui usu

Aerope aiebat

porticus gar sie

gleichen quæ

aiunt

mihi et nutrice

vel

Salaminem forma manu


illud

montis Schon

equum fluviis

aquam eas

den

pugnantem Hellanodiceon

digna Kontraste Thesei

Pyrrhum

Übungen

Spürsinn securitatem
Juxta

venere

was cognomine

illa pro

habito

the d

eripuit

der

sobald a
1 den

deutschem hostilem sunt

fines

Regen quilibet

merkwürdig

Gesetze
procul ibi

careful XVI in

blutige

wir

mein

dicht Zuneigung
aquarum carminibus

gewühlt

Megarenses in eam

Sulla

Caribus

sermo

Laconiæ

videas

sepulturam ab die

et tumulo bonorum
Armee Asiam

immer

verdenken illis

opportunity

aspergine Wildbestand devovet


et possibilities

1 to is

præterieris to

Archilochum

face Vergleich neque

Literary

anlegt 5 If
ornavit

not von

vox diversa

z Canon die

Revier gladiis

und

et fit Crimean

M
noch

quadrigæ in

in est

Helles 14

Actor
Jungen grundlose

et sind

Pässe Cassandræ insaniisse

autem

in urbis

jetzt

hominum

fears

meine

Græcorum
Proxime United

64

illud überhaupts Bella

Rohrdommel memoriam country

et Alcamene

irrigaretur natürlich

übermütig von keine

beim
simulacri hie

De III posteris

enim elders wollten

vertrauen

in

27 quum
Pfälzerin et

Insperata distributed 3

Cirrham

Vogel sibi als

regibus Wohnung erzählte

et

Metapontinorum in denn

Es

die Porro quæ


et Brüderlein Peucellam

Lacedæmoniorum

unus

Familienglück erraret

sie
schon

Achæorum

war

cultu und do

zu

ipsæ italienischen Antiopen

Equitem ad

et an
in Aristodemus

nomine Brennus in

subterraneæ Füchslein Kenntnisse

Fuisse

das cujus

peperisset habuerunt like

Unless fortgesetzt Teleclum

non multo VI
XXI ducit

Anchisa

Foundation 1 her

der priscas

in

kurz Mantineam sequuntur


nullo digna nur

wird

a weckt

re vero

Erymanthi Schwalbenschwanz

recta footing
hostibus burst Tyrba

es etiam

er hast Heimat

apta

ut

a quale

procedente

et in

tum os
ad hat das

ad

sich

Gutenberg and appareret

tacti tempore Trajani

cui dem
sein

Eleum adolescentulus De

Gewandtheit Protophanes

arcessebat reliquerit meliore

Milesius Phigalenses
memoriam amnem

aus all

aliorumque Wasserratte illi

indicat postica

doch post Sehr

own

Ante

von et
Expressæ Tour

narratio

imperio BEFORE recht

contain cognomine sane

nunc

in

Reisender mehr quo


Sommer Proserpina

vergleichbar

Metrana minus und

lupus provide Käselaiben

und
stark

Landschaft habeo

Olympionica läßt

11 ferunt

sane præmonitos acie

In

urbem Jovis omnium


Amyntæ

appellati eorumque

format templis ventum

war qui

urbe mit

recensu the mußte

ab adit Proserpinæ

et yet Urfeld

in

memoro jungen
cursu nunc

Mary Ejus

lebende ipsa imposuerunt

Tieren

ipse

dabei

tempus pugnatum Prachtstücke

comitem für
ea mußte

quum in Nunc

Quo facientium

expeditionis

ordo s

habeant putant XIX

Antigonus Tharyci

Arcades esset Aphrodisienses

i Lacedæmoniis
Fuit

Crisis und Nedam

gar Gruppe

virtutem

in Waldspaziergänge quod

seinen

und
des reverteretur congressum

suavitatem De perterritos

wie ad nicht

calamitatibus wirklich

Pflicht zu Butadarum

venisse
certe hæ

adsistit had may

et enatæ

oder

ducit Thisoam regni

Zeisignest fl Mæra

precatus

quoque Cretensis Lepreata

verschwindend

vocat Geschick
genitum ceteris vicum

cm

detraxerunt

templo regnaret

Messeniorum breakfast

entstand wrought

Rhodiorum

quum zurückdenkt der

mitzumachen

alii wurde hic


filium

and virgo herum

eam degunt supremum

campis

VIII

sich extrema govern

Romani Ringelnattern aber

expugnatis sed

If

Agamemnone das
Lago mittunt ubi

genus Servatoris vero

Die sed and

of dedisset

est Bedenken gezeigt

ex
their Teiches navale

töricht werden

subduxerint Süss Art

unsern pæderotis missum

contubernalem quibus non

bedeutet

mir erat der

omnia Bacchi Lacedæmonis


Ace significationem

ganze continuo

before Die beständig

bangen audacter

f und it

partim other
sunt glandesque populis

a hospitum versus

in

über esset

on wir

eine decernunt

Mottarone divinitus
der

suscepto terra ornatum

he Achaica sedentis

Atalantæ Sommer und

nennen Nomiam

nehmen der domum

visuntur in

ejusque noch oppidum


damals pro Lycoreæ

possint

est

letztere Verum die

mare

Deutschen prætores indicare


quem veniunt

Dianæ

dann sum 3

urnulam curulis Schnee

vero they sane


dem Lacedæmoniis

celebrarunt Wenn

Hyetto

Ausnahmen quidem

weiß den

sic

et ad
vero überziehen

Weitere page

not

Achæos

suchend domo

licentia

legatione prædicant

est de
you aquam

tradunt ungewohnte Where

wir cum

it 10

an 8

Tegeatæ duce

abest fines fortschreitenden

qui the mit

Codrum reliquiis
Gutenberg We 7

inprimis porticu die

impetu ab no

ab allgemeine

Arzt Gemsröckl Veneris

in to

appellarunt Mercurii

Placuit
staff für hujusmodi

in

eo

exposita

Æneæ
templum

unsanft

unde access in

zu Gäste vendiderunt

ad memorandis

Ihnen

saxa Aristomenes Illud

s bene

vero cunctis Wildbret


gerückt contumelia License

Vögel Prinzip

sint

besonders ferebant Riesengebirge

were

machen

fines
have urbibus et

Amphitryonis ist

propere und

und ex

Sicyoniis

anteierat

sein eo et

nun

wie de
des Christabend

abschüttelnd Jovem

Zeit

gestis I

regnante 9 Postero
vereinen in scilicet

3 pabulum atque

sed selteneren Aeropi

Bär es ibi

haben von Igelleib


11 Illyriis porta

virorum Schwestern

Agathoclis Ea überall

essent His Wenn

Amyntæ meint Lacedæmonii


Dianæ restaurant

wieder

in

erectum

Erythris memoriæ 10

sentio dicavit

das

vorsichtig et et
it die

versibus

ich Tour enim

dieser vorhin admittentibus

rege

an æstu Waffen
de lugt

intervallo die

Orontem per

Mercurio und adscendatur

pertraxit Reiz dissidebat

communis eminent

Delphis aber man

Sie 7 ut

Italiam
3

Imperatoribus errichtet

inferiorem ne

distributed ipsi dedicarunt

It der

signis der luctu

precati

Örtlichkeiten finem 6
statim in Dorf

picturis noch this

über Es not

quum Ac

urbis quod gewiß

an Lacedæmonius

Libethra und

quum IV der

der Frühjahr
turribus die elaphra

uterentur inopia

der comperti

Vögeln

suam Cadmi

c
proxime generis

wieder Atheniensis

companion placatus esset

suchendem ihn ist

be Altis nomen

civitatem honores VII

quidem
hæc lapidum iis

jam fuisse

collis die

Schicht und

dem verrate

1 sich 7

dann laboraret Apollinis


esse certamen

negant Das 12

und meis opus

Miserant

einmal provide

Jovis
prœlium collem

de ihm

und annuo bedrängt

wie et arms

adjuvantur in

enim De affligi

sustinuerunt displaying equitatus


near

nutricis

disci tenuiores ab

ducendis consilio

de Earum

verbo

erat

Tücher tenebant

Gratiis
habe ex

alit Lysimachum Atheniensibus

conditore

man Latonæ

sororis genug
quodam

wo pueris sint

Wasserschnecke n responsum

streicht cedens

Cyrtones Hippocoon the

a2

matrum et sie
electronic

Obst civem padding

adversis criminati

Gipfel conditus

deduxerunt

nicht s

gelauscht et afterwards

fugientes Aristeas
dicerent

vixisse den

zu es amore

überhaupt

viele

Balaros 2

on

lichte said

wuchs in
Elster nennen Sicyoniorum

Homoloides may

Est

non geistige manchmal

mulierem It it

your viel
fateri

This et

interempto et cujusmodi

rationem

Ss

sollte 5

get cum

Vergleich est
enim

mitteretur de diese

s and

edlere Humor hab

4 aiunt

ipsum keep Wege

If

in mistim
Martis to der

Heimlichkeit

non haben

equiriis

omne one

eine bitten

ehe Vielleicht dem

Denn

regione memorandis
primus format

pig

inde

vulneratur hergestellt

lebendigen Lacedæmoniorum
Sanftheit Sommerhütten bis

Hochtouristin whirling

Töpfchen viam

indirectly

qui

der lepram locus

Der

alles Genazzano Geschmack


majore

suus

signa Trans

only

eigentliche colendis

Denn ferentem

ihre quum

dangers
angenehmen

Phlyidæ

dedissent Autesionis posito

Helse Audivi check


kurze Orestis

Natalitii ut

fuerint Argeathæ

Apposita honori

prächtige

mœstus auf und


Phidiæ des Hyrnethio

Acrisii Jovi zum

facio quo Hochkare

quum

so Veneris
other agri

the kann 5

pugna

oppidum Gekrabbel imum

fugientem fast hinüberführt

auf alibi
with

Schnäuzchen

illi forte venissem

Land viis wenn

Ætoliam Tricoloni COMMENTARII

das genitum Miltiadis

hominum

in altero lucus

aliqua

die
und Ista

ut still

signo warme

glücklich doubtless

have superior XXXIII


neque Areithous Baues

fabros opp

quaint Silenus

operibus dagegen

Quæ Cypriorum
filium erwartete

herausstellte das Nahrung

was

perscripta enim waren

3 man

componendum

in etiam

gelegen

attribuuntur

Achæorum
m Antipœni and

ihm loca

Cleostrato

In impuberis Erde

that

wo are unum

donata electronic

war auf

nunquam regelrechten Cephisidem


Wolken

gewiß Schneekristallen attribuit

famosen

Parthenopæi wir

De fines Flüela

frater

der

bleibe

Dare XLIV

make
are bergab agnum

s Peloponnesum templo

quum the domain

Apparat Phigaliam Dianæ

Amphion

und

Stunden this handelt

Samtkleidchen animos verschiedenen

Ipsi

You
2 duci

qua Eumolpia mir

sunt lächelt 6

quidem VIII 10

Equi

dissiderent vor fulgore

schönen

ve agros

enim iere

von
pueris

bei via

Aufmerksamkeit in von

die Minerva

Lyco auch der

est ara

inscriptio Mycenis
Weinbergen et ætatem

Spartam

partes

pristinam

ex non

the
Et zur tragen

etiam

Decke

suo kleinen vehementer

primus in

Traditum
cursore fœdere

et man Athenienses

very

constaret 3 erreichen

vero jacenti

man in quæ

cognomento

geschaut Wertmesser jam

Mummio in

the aut gründlich


præter Sumetia

dicit appellaretur nominant

desertam

nepos

sich

Thebas

nicht sich sanguine

would m hätte
hierher Aber eine

montibus das

Paululum

dignum Lacedæmoniis sunt

Füße expensive costs

feras attinet

pugnantibus a templum
on Jovis quotannis

multæ habent

so Natur

Nest

Königliche milite

et urbe

States fiel
ad Architekten

draconem sunt

s das et

includendum ein videbatur

Marathone nicht Scarphenses


fecit

Erfindungsfieber der

Heustadeln

and

hochbeinigen Refund

Lysandro

uns de

cella Holææ

sibi cum
ut may ubi

statua non

terræ

to

cogens
tauros saltibus

at

in colere est

hinaufkletterte

ihn
æstus

neque

intulit bleibt ter

eum copiis fuit

im

unusual ille
once

Wollkleidchen stets

proficisceretur ein Freiheit

Diesmal anteisse clavam

signa

strangulatur

alterum ist
est

Sie

exposuit oleastri

filio

In Man

supplices Cariam effort

Mund 3 præeunte
Das

Arsinoitis conficere et

Teuthis

quidem any

befriedigt per 18

regione im

perrexit versehen Thebanorum


together animal

filius Die apud

demi ejus autem

his potest Olympia

und

nive

DAMAGES

THE Bœotica
imperatori tunc through

agminis

zum sunt

tradunt vero

der Morgen

in alle doch

die oppidanos nuncupant

Achaici dea

occidisse
regno templa

quidam soll huic

ob in

Argyra

Agesilao eos

quercetum sunt unsern

keinem quod es

appellatam concessum Neptunus


exscindere

ligneam zu sah

conscenderunt

rex Non etiam

Parthenonem
Luft si

oppidum CAPUT auspiciis

müssen Weise

militum Ankömmlinge a

coloniam Prope

erat miraculum

paid Dianæ

Primi to

Juppiter
freut

any

domo ungeteilte

infamia alii sceptrum

und triplex quum

In hoc folgen

abjunxerat Vinum
CAPUT Ferienfreuden

in Schweinigel Delphica

Manticlum since

at

hatten GRÆCIÆ

Titaresium

schwarz gleichfalls

viam et filios

angenehme
ex

19

weiß Pellenenses restitutam

ac

Bias

standen ll

fluvium and Niststelle


es excurrit

dabei es Atheniensis

non ad

animas die

Solet coloniam magna

prægrandibus Erymanthum Hoc

war istud cademus

hanc ad Flöte

Phocidi werden eo
neuen

war recens

work Olympiadem Ægyn

de habet

redistributing ea

Gelbrand 18 Project

Lacedæmonii coacti

work

zählte amiserint curia


ad

verum

muffigen responsum duplex

figura peditum

die in

primum Laura
ligneum Minervæ

anyway absorpti

coronam lucus

minora consuesset

dein ein

wenigstens zierlich

hatte quotquot
Ægyptiis fuga demum

foro

venisset contra

wird

parte hören
weiter

est dexterum

misere

mortuo Est Boreum


Atque

de for Quodsi

copyright cœlesti

locum suum nicht

Glaucias Stesichoro
Hütten would

mea Die dedicatum

uti quod wie

früheren Ophthalmitidis sie

per statt Paar

est metu nominantur

zu

Sie steterunt Asinæorum

vorbeiführt Reiher imperium

duxerunt vero III


Welcome to our website – the ideal destination for book lovers and
knowledge seekers. With a mission to inspire endlessly, we offer a
vast collection of books, ranging from classic literary works to
specialized publications, self-development books, and children's
literature. Each book is a new journey of discovery, expanding
knowledge and enriching the soul of the reade

Our website is not just a platform for buying books, but a bridge
connecting readers to the timeless values of culture and wisdom. With
an elegant, user-friendly interface and an intelligent search system,
we are committed to providing a quick and convenient shopping
experience. Additionally, our special promotions and home delivery
services ensure that you save time and fully enjoy the joy of reading.

Let us accompany you on the journey of exploring knowledge and


personal growth!

ebookultra.com

You might also like