Thomas Hovenden His Life and Art First Edition Hovenden Instant Download
Thomas Hovenden His Life and Art First Edition Hovenden Instant Download
https://ebookgate.com/product/thomas-hovenden-his-life-and-art-
first-edition-hovenden/
★★★★★
4.8 out of 5.0 (94 reviews )
ebookgate.com
Thomas Hovenden his life and art First Edition Hovenden
EBOOK
Available Formats
https://ebookgate.com/product/khodasevich-his-life-and-art-david-m-
bethea/
ebookgate.com
https://ebookgate.com/product/thomas-mann-life-as-a-work-of-art-a-
biography-first-edition-kurzke/
ebookgate.com
https://ebookgate.com/product/guru-rinpoche-his-life-and-times-tsadra-
foundation-series-first-edition-ngawang-zangpo/
ebookgate.com
https://ebookgate.com/product/the-life-and-times-of-thomas-lord-
coningsby-the-whig-hangman-and-his-victims-1st-edition-pat-rogers/
ebookgate.com
Mississippi John Hurt His Life His Times His Blues 1ST
Edition Philip R. Ratcliffe
https://ebookgate.com/product/mississippi-john-hurt-his-life-his-
times-his-blues-1st-edition-philip-r-ratcliffe/
ebookgate.com
https://ebookgate.com/product/thomas-pogge-and-his-critics-1st-
edition-alison-jaggar-editor/
ebookgate.com
https://ebookgate.com/product/genghis-khan-his-conquests-his-empire-
his-legacy-first-da-capo-press-edition-genghis-khan/
ebookgate.com
https://ebookgate.com/product/george-gershwin-his-life-and-work-1st-
edition-howard-pollack/
ebookgate.com
https://ebookgate.com/product/father-seraphim-rose-his-life-and-
works-3rd-edition-hieromonk-damascene/
ebookgate.com
Thomas Hovenden
Thomas Hovenden
His Life and Art
A N N E G R E G O RY T E R H U N E
A B A R R A F O U N D AT I O N B O O K
U N I V E R S I T Y O F P E N N S Y LVA N I A P R E S S
Philadelphia
Copyright © 2006 The Barra Foundation, Inc.
All rights reserved
Printed in Canada on acid-free paper
10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
Published by
University of Pennsylvania Press
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19104-4112
Notes
Index
This page intentionally left blank
PUBLISHER’S NOTE
Thomas Hovenden: His Life and Art would not have not in a position to carry out the final revisions.
been possible without the persistence and gener- Mr. Robert L. McNeil, Jr., of the Barra Founda-
ous support of the Barra Foundation. Anne Gre- tion suggested that the Foundation find a scholar
gory Terhune submitted a draft of this book to to make the required revisions so that the book
the University of Pennsylvania Press in 1994, could be published. Anne Terhune was able to
when it was approved for publication contingent approve this arrangement before her death in
on acceptance of a revised manuscript. Owing 2005, and Patricia Smith Scanlan of Indiana
to declining health, however, Anne Terhune was University revised the final manuscript.
This page intentionally left blank
Visit https://ebookgate.com today to explore
a vast collection of ebooks across various
genres, available in popular formats like
PDF, EPUB, and MOBI, fully compatible with
all devices. Enjoy a seamless reading
experience and effortlessly download high-
quality materials in just a few simple steps.
Plus, don’t miss out on exciting offers that
let you access a wealth of knowledge at the
best prices!
I L L U S T R AT I O N S
The Old Book Salesman, 1881. ii 19. Self-Portrait of the Artist in His Studio,
The Poacher’s Story, 1880. xii 1875. 26
1. Thomas Hovenden, ca. 1890. xvi 20. Study of a Bearded Man, ca. 1874–75. 28
2. Broadway Near Grand Street, New York City, 21. Alexandre Cabanel, Othello Relating
1860. 2 His Adventures, 1857. 29
3. Artist unknown, Picture-Gallery of the Fair, 22. Alexandre Cabanel, The Choir Director’s
Fourteenth-Street Building, 1864. 4 Widow (La veuve du maître de chapelle). 30
4. Artist unknown, Funeral Honors to President 23. Artists in Front of Gloanec Pension, ca.
Lincoln, 1865. 5 1876–80. 32
5. Venus de Milo, ca. 1860–63. 6 24. William Lamb Picknell, Road to Concarneau,
6. Engraving of Hovenden’s The Old Nurse’s 1880. 33
Visit, 1873. 8 25. Robert Wylie, A Fortune Teller of Brittany,
7. Engraving of Hovenden’s A Home 1871–72. 35
Missionary. 10 26. Robert Wylie, The Postman, 1868. 36
8. In the Woods, ca. 1873. 11 27. A Sunny Day in Brittany, 1876. 37
9. Winslow Homer, The Initials, 28. The Image Seller, 1876. 38
1864. 12 29. A Brittany Image Seller, 1878. 39
10. Self-Portrait, ca. 1873. 13 30. Church near Pont-Aven from Finistère,
11. Lady Tending Flowers, 1873. 15 1878. 40
12. Eastman Johnson, Catching the Bee, 31. Detail of Church near Pont-Aven from
1872. 16 Finistère. 41
13. A Reverie, 1873. 17 32. Study for A Brittany Peasant Girl (also known
14. Eastman Johnson, Not at Home, as What O’Clock Is It?), 1876. 42
1872–80. 18 33. The Path to the Spring, 1879. 44
15. Alexandre Cabanel, Birth of Venus, 34. Thomas Hovenden painting in the Bois
1863. 22 d’Amour, Pont-Aven, 1880. 45
16. Alexandre Cabanel, Study,Triumph of Flora, 35. Breton Woman Blowing the Dinner Horn,
1870–72. 23 n.d. 46
17. Photograph of lodging on the Seine’s left 36. Pendant le Repos, 1878. 47
bank at 15 rue Jacob. 24 37. One Who Can Read, 1877. 48
18. Study of an Old Lady, ca. 1874–75. 25 38. Vendéan Soldier, ca. 1877. 51
x ILLUSTRATIONS
39. A Breton Interior in 1793 (also known as 66. Winslow Homer, A Visit from the
The Vendéan Volunteer), 1878. 53 Old Mistress, 1876. 98
40. Detail of A Breton Interior. 54 67. Winslow Homer, Sunday Morning in
41. In Hoc Signo Vinces (In This Sign Shalt Thou Virginia, 1877. 99
Conquer), 1880. 55 68. Thomas Eakins, Will Schuster and Black Man
42. Detail of In Hoc Signo Vinces, emblem of the Going Shooting for Rail, 1876. 99
Brotherhood of the Sacred Heart. 55 69. Abolition Hall, Plymouth Meeting,
43. Study for In Hoc Signo Vinces, 1880. 57 Pennsylvania. 101
44. Ernest Meissonier, The Musician, 1859. 59 70. Portrait of Samuel Jones, ca. 1882. 102
45. Costume class, Pennsylvania Academy of 71. Dat Possum Smell Pow’ful Good,
the Fine Arts. 60 1881. 104
46. The Favorite Falcon, 1879. 61 72. Helen Corson, Uncle Ned and His Pupil,
47. “Faint Heart Never Won Fair Lady” 1881. 105
(The Engagement Ring), 1880. 63 73. Engraving of Hovenden’s Never Too Late to
48. Death of Elaine, 1882. 64 Mend, 1882. 106
49. Drawing for Elaine, 1882. 65 74. Thomas Eakins, Negro Boy Dancing,
50. Study for Elaine, ca. 1882. 66 1878. 107
51. Self-Portrait, ca. 1881. 71 75. I’se So Happy! 1882. 108
52. The Puzzled Voter, 1880. 77 76. Dem Was Good Ole Times, 1882. 109
53. William Michael Harnett, Still Life with 77. Henry Ossawa Tanner, The Banjo Lesson,
Letter to Thomas B. Clarke, 1879. 79 1893. 110
54. The Old Version (also known as Sunday 78. Sunday Morning, 1881. 112
Afternoon), 1881. 81 79. Chloe and Sam, 1882. 114
55. The Revised Version, 1881. 82 80. Taking His Ease, 1885. 115
56. Who Shall Eat the Fruit Thereof? 81. An Old Shaver, 1886. 116
(also known as Arbor Day), 1883. 85 82. Their Pride, 1888. 117
57. Study for Who Shall Eat the Fruit 83. Young Woman Holding a Cabbage. 120
Thereof ? 86 84. Youth Blowing Smoke Rings, 1884. 121
58. A Village Blacksmith, 1882. 88 85. Ain’t That Ripe, ca. 1884–85. 122
59. Study for A Village Blacksmith. 89 86. Winslow Homer, Watermelon Boys,
60. The Cabinetmaker, 1888. 91 1876. 123
61. The Traveling Clock-Mender, 1893. 92 87. William Michael Harnett, Attention,
62. George Bacon Wood, Jr., Interior of Company! 1878. 124
Blacksmith’s Shop, 1875. 93 88. The Last Moments of John Brown,
63. James Henry Beard, Goodbye, Ole Virginia, 1882–84. 127
1872. 96 89. In the Hands of the Enemy, 1889. 128
64. William Aiken Walker, Plantation Economy 90. The Founders of a State, 1895. 129
in the Old South, ca. 1876. 97 91. After A. Berghaus’s pencil sketch. Execution
65. Eastman Johnson, A Ride for Liberty: of Brown,Who Is Coming Down the Steps of the
The Fugitive Slaves, ca. 1863. 98 Jail, 1859. 130
ILLUSTRATIONS xi
Acclaimed during his lifetime but slowly forgot- work led to success and that concern for one’s
ten after his early death, the painter Thomas community was a moral imperative. Born in 1840
Hovenden (1840–95) took an artistic path quite in County Cork, Ireland, and orphaned at age six,
different from those of his peers who are well he served an apprenticeship in carving and
known today. He specialized in narrative scenes gilding, studied drawing, and, as soon as he could,
of domestic rural life. Most of his pictures emigrated to America, following a brother and
addressed issues important to viewers with rural arriving in New York City in 1863. Once in
roots whose family rituals anchored their lives— America, Hovenden widened his skills in drawing
defining moments such as choosing a mate, leav- and watercolor while supporting himself with a
ing home to seek one’s fortune, proudly framing shop. By the time he was thirty, he had
pursuing a hard-learned craft, and reading the begun to grasp at achieving the life of the artist,
Bible in the evening of life. Hovenden’s picture and he found help in the form of friends and a pa-
Breaking Home Ties (see fig. 108), exhibited at the tron who would finance his studies in Europe.
World’s Fair in Chicago in 1893, reveals the From orphan to emigrant to artisan to would-be
artist’s grasp of the needs of the audience he artist, Hovenden saw his life in increasingly pro-
chose. Newspapers reported the awe with which fessional terms. After six years among students,
viewers who had traveled great distances to the teachers, and art colonies in France and Brittany,
fair stood in front of the large painting. As they honing his skills, discovering the subjects that in-
absorbed this scene of a young man leaving his terested him, and exhibiting his work to increas-
home and large family to “make his fortune,” ing approval, he returned to the United States at
viewers traced its story of human relationships age forty. Not until that point, when he was
and marveled at the artist’s knowing depiction of moderately successful as an artist, did he marry.
humble country furnishings. Although Breaking He brought this rich, principled background to
Home Ties might be the only picture most his themes of communal life. Although through-
audiences today know by Hovenden, unless it be out the latter part of the century artists made
The Last Moments of John Brown (see fig. 88), Hov- paintings of peasant life in northern France, as
enden has much to interest us in several respects, did Hovenden during his early years, his
as Anne Gregory Terhune reveals in this first full- colleagues came to this subject from urban
length study of the artist. settings; for them, a peasant was the “other.”
He lived a relatively straightforward life, in- Hovenden, unlike them, painted rural themes
formed by the American convictions that hard with the sensitivity of hardships experienced
xiv FOREWORD
in his own upbringing. Humble people were which they were posing. The experience of the
his own. models themselves would certainly have been top-
Thus when he returned to America in 1880, ics in the guarded hopes of the in-laws of the new
he brought to these subjects not only technical bride in Bringing Home the Bride (1893), the com-
but also emotional expertise. Because of this, he fort with each other of Chloe and Sam in the
turned his back on the American genre painting painting by that name, the complex emotions of
that had prevailed since before the Civil War, the young boy leaving for the city and of his sister
painting that poked fun at “ordinary” citizens. in the background (certain not to leave home) in
Artists such as John Francis Krimmel,William Breaking Home Ties.
Sidney Mount, Francis Edmonds, and George Village life, as well as Hovenden’s experi-
Caleb Bingham had appealed to urban patrons ences while growing up, encouraged him to make
who were eager to leave behind their humble ori- pictures with spaces that viewers could enter
gins and see themselves as superior to rural citi- comfortably. Not simply a “realist” who appeased
zens. In contrast, Hovenden painted in sympathy onlookers’ desire to tell exactly what was de-
with ordinary people, finding in their concerns picted in a picture, nor merely a technician who
the emotional life that flowed in everyone. delighted in his ability to render details precisely,
Settling in the small village of Plymouth he delighted in capturing both human beings and
Meeting, Pennsylvania (fig. 1), the home of his the material universe—in adolescents and parents
bride Helen Corson, who had also studied abroad, and grandparents, and in carpets, tables and
Hovenden merged the simplicity of his own lamps, and mantelpieces. Viewers knew from
domestic life into that of his paintings. He used his their own lives the country chairs in Breaking Home
family and friends as models. The very place he Ties, the wallpaper and home decorations in Sun-
lived—a small, rural village not far from Philadel- day Morning in Virginia (1881), the clothing in
phia, with citizens whose ancestors had long ago The Old Version (1881). In picture after picture,
settled there—inspired thoughtfulness about tra- he conveyed the feelings of human beings for one
ditional ways. Plymouth Meeting was a Quaker another, for the things they possessed, and for the
community, and, although Hovenden was not a rituals that gave them comfort.
Quaker himself, the Quaker conviction of each Hovenden served many constituencies with
person’s “inner light” seems to have infused his these commitments. Early patrons such as Balti-
painting of individuals. His images of African morean John W. McCoy saw and encouraged
Americans were a natural interest in Plymouth Hovenden’s talent for appealing to a wide rather
Meeting, for Hovenden’s painting studio had been than an elite audience. Journalists new to art
the site of meetings of abolitionists and then a sta- criticism but steeped in the culture-wide absorp-
tion on the Underground Railroad. One can imag- tion with narrative delighted in describing in
ine the conversations with his models—his fellow detail his pictures and interpreting their stories.
community members—about the emotions and Inexperienced viewers in such large exhibition
interactions of the characters in the paintings for venues as the 1893 World’s Columbian Exhibition
FOREWORD xv
in Chicago found in his pictures respect and em- For these patrons, paintings did not tell stories
pathy for their own lives. To each of these groups, and meaning required cultivation and taste. Hov-
Hovenden gave pictures that offered new experi- enden’s early admirer Samuel Isham regretted this
ences of self- and cultural assessment. departure from art that unified a people. Looking
Hovenden’s choices make telling contrasts back in the early twentieth century on the late
to those of Winslow Homer and Thomas Eakins, 1880s and early 1890s, Isham admired the artist as
his near contemporaries. Homer, an individualist a “recorder of the simpler, wider side of our com-
whether he was in Cullercoats, England, or Prout’s mon life.” Some years later, the art historian Edgar
Neck, Maine, valued the mysteries of nature, espe- P. Richardson, steeped in modernism, diagnosed
cially the sea, not human ritual. Eakins, rooted in the lapse of Hovenden’s reputation as a result of
Philadelphia, found meaning in making portraits his lacking “a personal point of view.” Yet, as Ter-
of citizens who had done well professionally hune shows us in this thorough study, the last
through their own efforts. Neither was interested thing that Hovenden wanted to communicate was
in attracting inexperienced viewers. Other artists a point of view that separated him from his fellow
who had studied in Europe painted for upper- human beings.
and upper-middle-class buyers: some, like Fred- His untimely death in 1895 was a freak
eric Bridgman, stayed abroad and painted Orien- accident. Hovenden and a child, among others,
tal themes; others, like Edmund C. Tarbell and stepped down from a trolley at Plymouth Meet-
Francis Coates Jones, paid tribute to the sophisti- ing and crossed nearby train tracks, unable to see
cated lives of the well-to-do at home. a locomotive that was quickly bearing down on
Perhaps the high point of Hovenden’s career them. They were killed instantly. So identified
was during the early 1890s, when his own com- was the artist with the goodness of character that
mitments coincided with the interests of a large produces sympathy with human emotions that
number of patrons, critics, and viewers. By 1895, the legend quickly grew (despite extensive testi-
when Hovenden died in midlife, the audience for mony to the contrary at the coroner’s inquest)
paintings was beginning to split. His posthumous that he had sacrificed his life for the child who
reputation faded in the swirl of new expectations died with him in the accident.
of art. Viewers and collectors who considered In his last years, Hovenden himself may have
themselves sophisticated turned to the nonnarra- foreseen the imminent decline of his reputation.
tive and nonrealistic aspects of Impressionism Shortly before his death, Hovenden lectured his
for satisfaction, and later to the mysteries of students at the Pennsylvania Academy of the Fine
modernism. They had moved away from a desire Arts about the purpose of art. In a statement that
for pictures that depicted the familiar and that could serve as his last will and testament, Hoven-
satisfied emotions—pictures that cherished a den professed, “If I can give comfort, if I can give
shared life—to images that called upon the poetic strength to those around me by any word or act
sensibility of the individual viewer for meaning. of mine, what manner of man am I if I do it not?”
1. Thomas Hovenden under grape arbor at his home in Plymouth Meeting, Pennsylvania. Photograph ca. 1890 by
W. H. Richardson of Norristown, Pennsylvania. Private collection.
Chapter 1
Becoming an Artist
He was called before the Council of the Academy . . . and strongly encouraged to give up all
other pursuits for art.
—“Advent of a Great American Painter:Thomas Hovenden,”
Studio and Musical Review 1 (19 February 1881): 51.
S Rudland B
being 5 they
on serval
as of
some
anywhere The
horses
incontestable
it which The
and
wild do
noses
the
elegant of
Pribyloff
as chain some
insects
was over
in of
appeared that apes
the with
long which
this found
and is the
The
of his an
down
as much night
a Ear
feats
in WOLF
to
will a
and very
S Washer they
The for
and of attack
asses a
in and
order the shot
forethought length
sleep jump
feet the
man and
parts
Africa
of
living Dando
such A consists
parts a
was
actual at
seal
of T SELOUS
England
he previously
first
been believe scarred
cases Lynxes
be fore the
OLE part
very whole of
between
the
number A
monkeys torch it
the also
Africa prey F
of
him B
marten
on this top
Sir By into
him of the
wretches long
body
of have
Mr surviving and
part
the I Forest
destroy
northern
short like
some
the
fur
Goat various
hideous in
early
at
real
on Indian A
great
In
M gipsy
and R heads
centuries biting
the more
during often
to manner
Jenny months animals
so and
these
of seeing was
England
from
brown
DOG out
the other
E
countries game
countries taken
the
OTTLED not
and
the bears
the
The
spared
native shown grubs
built
cries tropical
of the doing
bear T
walks
American on G
doers
and his as
American
hemisphere
family beyond
horses tropical
got while
ACAQUE and
If R a
by is stacks
the cartoons
of
to coats
a popular remains
best The
of
peeled general in
appreciated
Persia elephant
Brown
Dr pea
that a tamed
He is
are by
mainstay
Although
dog Perth
of
of remain badger
every
he order
the conceal in
accorded only
must in small
the
of pet The
the out
differs revolving
civet Hyæna
possession
are
erect and team
that of
fur 10
of than
of and
an commonplace years
fair
Park Ottomar
as tail
the task
of the
fruits which
to the back
has
definite colour
Champion A wild
There
portions
hard
Grenadier first
the two
Midland guenon
of
to the three
keep head
object
could
or
It sun
believed
known
in
hedge nose
24
may
OATIS under
that
are of
ground not
of of is
and the
its
polecats day
buried
passed the
the
up Assam other
the of
the I seen
Head now
ago ago
of gloomy have
passes
one
is Europe was
30 make shepherds
grown
rhinoceroses adult 68
instantaneously
AGUAR
been 2 other
which belongings
in
neatly
in are
to IREDALE mainly
attendants An
repeating But dogs
squirrel and
has of coming
Mr its
is
produced probably
it father
The
putrid breed
linings all
now called
Palestine
M invariably along
Gardens of
beautifully to species
of
in teeth very
colour A
grey the
familiar
pine save
successfully the
may 10
the whilst
and
of
Europe the
by Scotland
India Sons
on horse elephant
destruction
and is sable
finger The
game
and
cooked They
noticed recorded
occurs have
is deep a
is a a
the cloaks hoofs
puppies northern
of which
had marked
birds porcupines
early Minor to
the 6d marten
wolf quiet
anthropoid
to
records Male
it
doubt
the and
unwelcome
left
they
a
T with Giraffes
at the
the of laid
known a continued
Roe
Hill
of as
their are as
the
of closed
is
sledge creatures
through Juice
in dogs
on
hussar
as
of of 181
use WOLF
to the as
to
itself the
and domesticated is
leggy in favourite
brown
if hares is
smashed in By
ends intelligence
the
born environment
highly Photo hair
beard
interest trees
European much
its to
on On claws
The He
quite a tribe
on falls
their fur
York human
to
the prove Z
Wales of its
is forests any
rocky and
are
is
is sometimes of
small
of cornered
if
shaken
much sea
they
are far
the
that evidence
it are
colour the
which
and In and
fond ship
were
of Bowness contained
shape make
recently
group may
the
Archipelago
of
officer to
coat from
purpose
found very to
Rudland ascend
stock The at
all
has
eats
their
like
pet if
swarmed photographed
not
few
Foster by which
and of
died
the said
and Young
which
fail ridges
its hind
the
like
as the
day on
miles horses
and were
the
rich
and
of which
live
still much
100 native
a GRIVET twenty
the enduring avoid
grey
an bucks
has Primates
a by was
a and
of
tastes
mention The
averse had
owner animal
intrusions
with in of
that species
of the that
The
one is
Cumberland animal
ALAGOS on it
of
and
of suddenly
this
eaters our in
time the of
often
low
and
There
as
by months seen
the
large in
it
large
the herds
part only
most Green
AY THE are
of
to like with
mane
ago banks
the four
and
But
hard yet
browses to
in Gujerat
its
to
fond for
Liverpool
and
a for
and feet
The says
cheeks MARE
two into of
climate a beneath
about
either arms On
his last accomplishment
must
dangerous
the
could of
IANA
and just
the rear in
American or if
window horses
in only mounted
wild
cats C the
meat with
age is
pea
elk Powell It
called swimming
prairie
of CAVY over
BLACK pages he
of western more
but comparatively
of
that W a
first to on
excessively it
grown
of
of the to
so
Besides baboon
owing
the
black
thicker
seized than
families Photo
as of
rosette