100% found this document useful (2 votes)
38 views151 pages

Mao S China and The Sino Soviet Split Ideological Dilemma 1st Edition Mingjiang Li PDF Available

Study material: Mao s China and the Sino Soviet Split Ideological Dilemma 1st Edition Mingjiang Li Download instantly. A complete academic reference filled with analytical insights and well-structured content for educational enrichment.

Uploaded by

myuebisaw3507
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
100% found this document useful (2 votes)
38 views151 pages

Mao S China and The Sino Soviet Split Ideological Dilemma 1st Edition Mingjiang Li PDF Available

Study material: Mao s China and the Sino Soviet Split Ideological Dilemma 1st Edition Mingjiang Li Download instantly. A complete academic reference filled with analytical insights and well-structured content for educational enrichment.

Uploaded by

myuebisaw3507
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 151

Mao s China and the Sino Soviet Split Ideological

Dilemma 1st Edition Mingjiang Li fast download

Now on sale at ebookultra.com


https://ebookultra.com/download/mao-s-china-and-the-sino-soviet-
split-ideological-dilemma-1st-edition-mingjiang-li/

★★★★★
4.7 out of 5.0 (49 reviews )

Get Your PDF Now


Mao s China and the Sino Soviet Split Ideological Dilemma
1st Edition Mingjiang Li

EBOOK

Available Formats

■ PDF eBook Study Guide Ebook

EXCLUSIVE 2025 ACADEMIC EDITION – LIMITED RELEASE

Available Instantly Access Library


We believe these products will be a great fit for you. Click
the link to download now, or visit ebookultra.com
to discover even more!

The Sino Soviet Split Cold War in the Communist World


Lorenz M. Lüthi

https://ebookultra.com/download/the-sino-soviet-split-cold-war-in-the-
communist-world-lorenz-m-luthi/

China ASEAN Sub Regional Cooperation Progress Problems and


Prospect 1st Edition Mingjiang Li

https://ebookultra.com/download/china-asean-sub-regional-cooperation-
progress-problems-and-prospect-1st-edition-mingjiang-li/

China s Cultural Relics 1st Edition Li Li

https://ebookultra.com/download/china-s-cultural-relics-1st-edition-
li-li/

Mao s China and the Cold War 1st Edition Chen Jian

https://ebookultra.com/download/mao-s-china-and-the-cold-war-1st-
edition-chen-jian/
Shadow Cold War The Sino Soviet Competition for the Third
World Jeremy Friedman

https://ebookultra.com/download/shadow-cold-war-the-sino-soviet-
competition-for-the-third-world-jeremy-friedman/

Wolf Totem and the Post Mao Utopian A Chinese Perspective


on Contemporary Western Scholarship 1st Edition Xiaojiang
Li
https://ebookultra.com/download/wolf-totem-and-the-post-mao-utopian-a-
chinese-perspective-on-contemporary-western-scholarship-1st-edition-
xiaojiang-li/

America s Response to China A History of Sino American


Relations Fifth Edition Warren I. Cohen

https://ebookultra.com/download/america-s-response-to-china-a-history-
of-sino-american-relations-fifth-edition-warren-i-cohen/

China s Banking and Financial Markets The Internal


Research Report of the Chinese Government 1st Edition Li
Yang
https://ebookultra.com/download/china-s-banking-and-financial-markets-
the-internal-research-report-of-the-chinese-government-1st-edition-li-
yang/

Loess and Loess Geohazards in China 1st Edition Yanrong Li

https://ebookultra.com/download/loess-and-loess-geohazards-in-
china-1st-edition-yanrong-li/
Mao’s China and the Sino-­Soviet Split

The Sino-­Soviet split in the 1960s was one of the most significant events of the
Cold War. Why did the Sino-­Soviet alliance, hailed by its creators as “unbreak­
able,” “eternal,” and as representing “brotherly solidarity,” break up? Why did
their relations eventually evolve into open hostility and military confrontation?
With the publication of several works on the subject in the past decade, we are
now in a better position to understand and explain the origins of the Sino-­Soviet
split. But at the same time new questions and puzzles have also emerged. The
scholarly debate on this issue is still fierce. This book, the result of extensive
research on declassified documents at the Chinese Foreign Ministry, and on
numerous other new Chinese materials, sheds new light on the problem and
makes a significant contribution to the debate. More than simply an empirical
case study, by theorising the concept of the ideological dilemma, Mingjiang Li’s
book attempts to address the relationship between ideology and foreign policy
and discusses such pressing questions as why it is that an ideology can some-
times effectively dictate foreign policy, whilst at other times exercises almost no
significant influence at all.
This book will be of essential reading to anyone interested in Chinese-­Soviet
history, Cold War history, International Relations and the theory of ideology.

Mingjiang Li is Assistant Professor at S. Rajaratnam School of International


Studies (RSIS), Nanyang Technological University, Singapore.
Routledge contemporary China series

1 Nationalism, Democracy and 8 The Politics of China’s


National Integration in China Accession to the World Trade
Leong Liew and Wang Shaoguang Organization
The dragon goes global
2 Hong Kong’s Tortuous Hui Feng
Democratization
A comparative analysis 9 Narrating China
Ming Sing Jia Pingwa and his fictional world
Yiyan Wang
3 China’s Business Reforms
Institutional challenges in a
globalised economy 10 Sex, Science and Morality in
Edited by Russell Smyth and China
Cherrie Zhu Joanne McMillan

4 Challenges for China’s 11 Politics in China Since 1949


Development Legitimizing authoritarian rule
An enterprise perspective Robert Weatherley
Edited by David H. Brown and
Alasdair MacBean 12 International Human Resource
Management in Chinese
5 New Crime in China Multinationals
Public order and human rights Jie Shen and Vincent Edwards
Ron Keith and Zhiqiu Lin

6 Non-­Governmental 13 Unemployment in China


Organizations in Contemporary Economy, human resources and
China labour markets
Paving the way to civil society? Edited by Grace Lee and
Qiusha Ma Malcolm Warner

7 Globalization and the Chinese 14 China and Africa


City Engagement and compromise
Fulong Wu Ian Taylor
15 Gender and Education in China 22 China’s Foreign Trade Policy
Gender discourses and women’s The new constituencies
schooling in the early twentieth Edited by Ka Zeng
century
Paul J. Bailey 23 Hong Kong, China
Learning to belong to a nation
16 SARS Gordon Mathews, Tai-­lok Lui, and
Reception and interpretation in Eric Kit-­wai Ma
three Chinese cities
Edited by Deborah Davis and 24 China Turns to Multilateralism
Helen Siu Foreign policy and regional
security
17 Human Security and the Edited by Guoguang Wu and
Chinese State Helen Lansdowne
Historical transformations and the
modern quest for sovereignty 25 Tourism and Tibetan Culture in
Robert E. Bedeski Transition
A place called Shangrila
18 Gender and Work in Urban Åshild Kolås
China
Women workers of the unlucky 26 China’s Emerging Cities
generation The making of new urbanism
Liu Jieyu Edited by Fulong Wu

19 China’s State Enterprise 27 China-­US Relations


Reform Transformed
From Marx to the market Perceptions and strategic
John Hassard, Jackie Sheehan, interactions
Meixiang Zhou, Edited by Suisheng Zhao
Jane Terpstra-­Tong and
Jonathan Morris 28 The Chinese Party-­State in the
21st Century
20 Cultural Heritage Management Adaptation and the reinvention of
in China legitimacy
Preserving the cities of the Pearl Edited by André Laliberté and
River Delta Marc Lanteigne
Edited by Hilary du Cros and
Yok-­shiu F. Lee 29 Political Change in Macao
Sonny Shiu-­Hing Lo
21 Paying for Progress
Public finance, human welfare and 30 China’s Energy Geopolitics
inequality in China The Shanghai cooperation
Edited by Vivienne Shue and organization and Central Asia
Christine Wong Thrassy N. Marketos
31 Regime Legitimacy in 39 Intellectual Property Rights in
Contemporary China China
Institutional change and stability Politics of piracy, trade and
Edited by Thomas Heberer and protection
Gunter Schubert Gordon Cheung

32 U.S.-China Relations 40 Developing China


China policy on Capitol Hill Land, politics and social
Tao Xie conditions
George C.S. Lin
33 Chinese Kinship 41 State and Society Responses to
Contemporary anthropological Social Welfare Needs in China
perspectives Serving the people
Edited by Susanne Brandtstädter Edited by Jonathan Schwartz and
and Gonçalo D. Santos Shawn Shieh

34 Politics and Government in 42 Gay and Lesbian Subculture in


Hong Kong Urban China
Crisis under Chinese sovereignty Loretta Wing Wah Ho
Edited by Ming Sing
43 The Politics of Heritage Tourism
35 Rethinking Chinese Popular in China
Culture A view from Lijiang
Cannibalizations of the Canon Xiaobo Su and Peggy Teo
Edited by Carlos Rojas and
Eileen Cheng-­yin Chow 44 Suicide and Justice
A Chinese perspective
Wu Fei
36 Institutional Balancing in the
Asia Pacific
45 Management Training and
Economic interdependence and
Development in China
China’s rise
Educating managers in a
Kai He
globalized economy
Edited by Malcolm Warner and
37 Rent Seeking in China Keith Goodall
Edited by Tak-­Wing Ngo and
Yongping Wu 46 Patron-­Client Politics and
Elections in Hong Kong
38 China, Xinjiang and Central Bruce Kam-­kwan Kwong
Asia
History, transition and crossborder 47 Chinese Family Business and the
interaction into the 21st century Equal Inheritance System
Edited by Colin Mackerras and Unravelling the myth
Michael Clarke Victor Zheng
48 Reconciling State, Market and 58 Law, Wealth and Power in China
Civil Society in China Commercial law reforms in
The long march towards prosperity context
Paolo Urio Edited by John Garrick

49 Innovation in China 59 Religion in Contemporary China


The Chinese software industry Revitalization and innovation
Shang-­Ling Jui Edited by Adam Yuet Chau

50 Mobility, Migration and the 60 Consumer-­Citizens of China


Chinese Scientific Research The role of foreign brands in the
System imagined future china
Koen Jonkers Kelly Tian and Lily Dong

51 Chinese Film Stars 61 The Chinese Communist Party


Edited by Mary Farquhar and and China’s Capitalist
Yingjin Zhang Revolution
The political impact of the market
52 Chinese Male Homosexualities Lance L.P. Gore
Memba, Tongzhi and Golden Boy
Travis S.K. Kong 62 China’s Homeless Generation
Voices from the veterans of the
53 Industrialisation and Rural chinese civil war, 1940s–1990s
Livelihoods in China Joshua Fan
Agricultural processing in Sichuan
Susanne Lingohr-­Wolf 63 In Search of China’s
Development Model
54 Law, Policy and Practice on Beyond the beijing consensus
China’s Periphery Edited by S. Philip Hsu,
Selective adaptation and Suisheng Zhao and Yu-­Shan Wu
institutional capacity
Pitman B. Potter 64 Xinjiang and China’s Rise in
Central Asia, 1949–2009
55 China-­Africa Development A history
Relations Michael E. Clarke
Edited by Christopher M. Dent
65 Trade Unions in China
56 Neoliberalism and Culture in The challenge of labour unrest
China and Hong Kong Tim Pringle
The countdown of time
Hai Ren 66 China’s Changing Workplace
Dynamism, diversity and disparity
57 China’s Higher Education Edited by Peter Sheldon,
Reform and Internationalisation Sunghoon Kim, Yiqiong Li and
Edited by Janette Ryan Malcolm Warner
67 Leisure and Power in Urban 74 Poverty and Development in
China China
Everyday life in a medium-­sized Alternative approaches to poverty
Chinese city assessment
Unn Målfrid H. Rolandsen Lu Caizhen

75 International Governance and


68 China, Oil and Global Politics
Regimes
Philip Andrews-­Speed and
A Chinese perspective
Roland Dannreuther
Peter Kien-­Hong YU
69 Education Reform in China 76 HIV/AIDS in China – The
Edited by Janette Ryan Economic and Social
Determinants
70 Social Policy and Migration in Dylan Sutherland and
China Jennifer Y.J. Hsu
Lida Fan
77 Looking for Work in
71 China’s One Child Policy and Post-­Socialist China
Multiple Caregiving Governance, active job seekers and
Raising little Suns in Xiamen the new Chinese labour market
Esther C.L. Goh Feng Xu

78 Sino-­Latin American Relations


72 Politics and Markets in Rural Edited by K.C. Fung and
China Alicia Garcia-­Herrero
Edited by Björn Alpermann
79 Mao’s China and the
73 China’s New Underclass Sino-­Soviet Split
Paid domestic labour Ideological dilemma
Xinying Hu Mingjiang Li
Mao’s China and the
Sino-­Soviet Split
Ideological dilemma

Mingjiang Li
First published 2012
by Routledge
2 Park Square, Milton Park, Abingdon, Oxon OX14 4RN
Simultaneously published in the USA and Canada
by Routledge
711 Third Avenue, New York, NY10017
Routledge is an imprint of the Taylor & Francis Group, an informa business
© 2012 Mingjiang Li
The right of Mingjiang Li to be identified as author of this work has been
asserted by him in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents
Act 1988.
All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reprinted or reproduced or
utilized in any form or by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now
known or hereafter invented, including photocopying and recording, or in
any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing
from the publishers.
Trademark notice: Product or corporate names may be trademarks or
registered trademarks, and are used only for identification and explanation
without intent to infringe.
British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data
A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library
Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data
Li, Mingjiang.
Mao’s China and the Sino-­Soviet split: ideological dilemma/Mingjiang Li.
p. cm. – (Routledge contemporary China series; 79)
Includes bibliographical references and index.
1. China–Foreign relations–Soviet Union. 2. Soviet Union–Foreign
relations–China. 3. China–Politics and government–1949–1976. 4.
China–Foreign relations–1949–1976. 5. Communism–China–History–
20th century. I. Title.
DS740.5.S65L54 2012
327.5104709′045–dc23
2011035720
ISBN: 978-0-415-69836-8 (hbk)
ISBN: 978-0-203-12632-5 (ebk)
Typeset in Times New Roman
by Wearset Ltd, Boldon, Tyne and Wear
To Bonan and William
Contents

Acknowledgements xii

1 Introduction 1

2 Ideological dilemma in international politics 12

3 The Soviet 20th Party Congress and emerging disputes in 1958 21

4 Mao’s Great Leap Forward and Sino-­Soviet disputes, 1959–1960 53

5 Temporary calm and deterioration in relations, 1960–1962 80

6 The growth of domestic radicalism and polemics with Moscow,


1963–1964 96

7 Short-­lived détente and the end of party relations, 1965–1966 118

8 Sino-­Soviet confrontation during the Cultural Revolution,


1966–1969 135

9 Conclusions 153

Notes 162
Bibliography 189
Index 206
Acknowledgements

I have received invaluable guidance and assistance from my PhD supervisors


and many colleagues and friends in the process of completing this study. I am
greatly indebted to Joseph Fewsmith, David Mayers, and Cathie Jo Martin. They
taught me not only how to do good research but also how to be a good teacher. I
am very grateful to Wendy Hazard who has always lent strong support to me at
every stage of my academic career. Many colleagues and friends have been very
generous in sharing their expertise and views. I am thankful to Eugenio
Menegon, Michael T. Corgan, Arne Westad, Shu Guang Zhang, Han Gang, Shen
Zhihua, Li Danhui, and Tang Shiping for their useful suggestions for the
research and comments on the manuscript. I also thank Irene Chan for her great
editing assistance. I myself bear the blame for any errors in this book.
1 Introduction

The Sino-­Soviet split in the 1960s was one of the most significant events of the
Cold War. Why did the Sino-­Soviet alliance, hailed by its creators as a “broth-
erly solidarity” that was “unbreakable” and “eternal,”1 break up? Why did their
relations eventually evolve into open hostility and military confrontation? With
the publication of several works on the subject in the past decade, we are now in
a better position to understand and explain the origins of the Sino-­Soviet split.
But, at the same time, new questions and puzzles have also emerged. The schol-
arly debate on this issue is still fierce.2 This book, the result of extensive research
on declassified documents at the Chinese Foreign Ministry and on numerous
other new Chinese materials, attempts to shed new light on the problem and to
make a significant contribution to the debate.
This book, however, is more than simply an empirical case study on Sino-­
Soviet relations during the Cold War. It is also an attempt to address the relation-
ship between ideology and foreign policy. It tries to answer this general and
perplexing question: why is it that an ideology can sometimes exert such an
assertive role that it effectively dictates foreign policy orientations, and at other
times exercises almost no significant influence at all? In other words, why does
the strength of ideological influence on foreign strategies ebb and flow so dra-
matically at times? I attempt to answer this question by carefully studying the
evolution of the Sino-­Soviet split from the late 1950s to the late 1960s. From
this case study, I develop a two-­level game approach with a focus on the concept
of an ideological dilemma. The theoretical approach developed in this book is
essentially an attempt to bridge the gap between Comparative Politics and Inter-
national Relations.
This book attempts to theorize the notion of ideological dilemma. When ideo-
logical differences exist between two countries, political leaders in one country
are likely to regard the ideological and political orientation of the other country
as a challenge and even a threat to their own domestic ideological and political
program and goals. This is so because political leaders have to be concerned
about the legitimacy of their political power and policy. Such concern can easily
lead political elites to make efforts to justify and in many cases enhance the
legitimacy of their power and policy. Any move that political leaders in one
country makes to defend its ideological and political position is perceived by the
2   Introduction
other as a threat to the legitimacy of its own domestic political line, and invites
criticism from the other side. Any step that the other side takes to argue or to
employ punitive actions against its rival begets counter measures. A vicious
circle similar to that of the security dilemma in general international relations, is
thus formed. The ideological dilemma can further aggravate bilateral relations if
there is domestic leadership competition and rivalry. Factions in either country
will be strongly tempted to use the ideological differences with the other country
for their own domestic political purposes. Consequently, the ideological recrimi-
nations between the two countries are likely to intensify, which may lead bilat-
eral relations to open hostility and even military confrontation.
I contend in this book that the ideological dilemma framework helps to
explain the Sino-­Soviet split better, and can be a very useful approach to the
study of the role of political ideology in international politics. I suggest that
instead of debating whether ideology has any impact on foreign policy, we
should focus instead on why and how ideological influence on foreign policy
ebbs and flows. Drawing intellectual inspiration from analytical liberalism, neo-
classical realism, and the two-­level game theoretical approach,3 I propose a new
two-­level game model for the study of the interaction of ideology and foreign
policy, with an emphasis on ideological dilemma. As this book will illustrate,
the conceptualization of an ideological dilemma is very relevant to the scholarly
debate on many major issues, for example, the relationship between domestic
and international politics, the interactions between ideological dilemma and
security dilemma, and research linkages between Comparative Politics and Inter-
national Politics.

A review and critique of existing approaches to the


Sino-­Soviet rupture4
Among the major approaches to the study of the Sino-­Soviet rupture, the realist
perspective emphasizes different national interests.5 The Chinese historian Yang,
for instance, argues that even at the very beginning of the Sino-­Soviet alliance
when Mao and Stalin were discussing the alliance treaty in early 1950, the dif-
ferences in national interests was a factor in bilateral relations.6 Zhang believes
that the American embargo on China played an important role in the Sino-­Soviet
split in the early 1960s. The prolonged U.S. embargo, Zhang argues, led to Bei-
jing’s overdependence on Moscow’s support and assistance, which not only
caused China’s increasing frustration with Moscow’s heavy-­handed approach to
the alliance, but also resulted in an ever-­greater burden on the Soviet Union.
Ultimately, as tensions rose, the alliance collapsed under mounting conflicts.7
While this approach is able to account for some specific events, it fails to provide
a convincing explanation for the whole picture. A commonsensible observation
that the policy of opposing both superpowers did not serve China’s national
security interests renders the realist paradigm largely inapplicable.
Other scholars examine the ideological differences between the two Commu-
nist Parties. By ideological differences, they refer to the different interpretations
Introduction   3
of orthodox Marxism and Leninism by the two parties and this paper follows
this definition. Many Chinese scholars believe that Moscow was to blame for the
stresses in bilateral relations, arguing that the Soviet Union transferred ideologi-
cal differences to state-­to-state relations, and attempted to control and subjugate
China in order to serve its own interests and hegemonic ambitions.8 Haas argues
that the root cause of the Sino-­Soviet split was Mao Zedong’s ideological radi-
calization as exemplified by the Great Leap Forward in 1958.9 This emphasis on
ideological difference is helpful in elucidating the general pattern of bilateral
relations, but it does not explain the changing intensities of disputes and con-
frontations at different times, nor does it address the origin of the ideological
differences between the two parties. Moscow started to alter many of Stalin’s
ideological and policy programs after his death in 1953, creating ideological dif-
ferences with Beijing; yet this growing ideological gap did not have any signifi-
cant negative impact on the alliance from 1953 to 1957. Moreover, this
perspective cannot explain why China was willing to engage with France in
1964, and later with the United States, even though the ideological discrepancies
between China and these two countries were much more notable than the differ-
ences between Beijing and Moscow. In this perspective, Mao is often described
as an ideological dogmatist. However, for most of his lifetime, Mao was a very
pragmatic political leader and it was his pragmatism that made the victory of the
Chinese Communist revolution possible.10
Others argue that the rupture between the Soviet Union and China was largely
due to the ambition of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP), particularly that of
Mao, to compete for leadership of the international communist movement.11 Lo,
for instance, argues that historical animosity was a significant factor in the Sino-­
Soviet split. He further suggests that the Sino-­Soviet differences had deeper
causes in China’s displeasure and resentment over the asymmetrical relationship
between Moscow and Beijing. Mao was simply not willing to accept “subordi-
nate status” in the alliance.12 Radchenko, in his book Two Suns in the Heavens,
highlights this point. He argues that it was this intrinsic inequality and China’s
strenuous efforts to alter its status in the alliance that brought it to an end.13 He
specifically argues that “Mao’s failure to endorse the implicit Soviet leadership
was a cause for Khrushchev’s dissatisfaction with China. It was the main reason
for the Sino-­Soviet split.”14 But, as we know now, much of the contention for
allies and sympathizers in the socialist bloc and the third world took place after
the split. Not only did the competition for leadership in the international commu-
nist movement take place after the split became a reality, much of the competi-
tion took place because both parties wanted to enhance their ideological
authority and support from other socialist countries and parties in order to prove
that their domestic political and ideological programs were correct. In other
words, competition for influence in the international communist movement and
the third world was the manifestation of the deterioration of the alliance, rather
than the origin of the split. If it were simply for power, why did Mao and his
supporters continue and even further escalate the struggle with the Soviets after
1966 when it was apparent that China was losing allies and influence in the
4   Introduction
international arena? It makes little sense for Mao to pursue a strategy of oppos-
ing both superpowers in the mid-­1960s if he was attempting to increase China’s
influence overseas. Also during the Cultural Revolution, when relations between
China and a majority of countries that it had diplomatic ties with soured, Beijing
was not notably concerned about the decline of its international power.
Very often this school of thought also falls back on the ideological difference
approach. Thus some scholars stress idiosyncratic conflicts and contentions
between Chinese and Soviet leaders, especially Mao and Khrushchev.15 Hinton
emphasizes differences in the political culture and traditions of China and the
Soviet Union in the breakup of the alliance.16 Yang emphasizes the historical
animosity between Mao and the Soviet leaders that led to the Sino-­Soviet split.17
The leaders of the two countries truly had a lot of personality conflicts, yet they
were able to get along with each other before 1958, and although Khrushchev
stepped down in 1964, Sino-­Soviet conflicts further deepened and plunged into
open hostility and military confrontation by the end of the decade.
Other scholars study the Sino-­Soviet rupture from a structural approach. The
main argument of this school of thought is that political relations between
Moscow and other socialist countries were based on Leninist party doctrine that
stressed hierarchical authority, discipline, and obedience. This rigid structure
could hardly tolerate the existence of major differences in national interests,
national policies, ideological interpretations, or personalities between the Com-
munist Party of the Soviet Union (CPSU) and other communist parties. When
differences emerged, political tensions in the socialist world were inevitable.18
This structural approach makes more sense than other schools of thought because
it has the capacity to incorporate a multiplicity of variables, including all the
factors discussed above. The shortcoming of this approach, however, is that it
treats these differences as givens. It fails to give sufficient weight to human
agency. It does not explain why on numerous occasions differences within the
socialist camp were hammered out relatively smoothly.
Decades ago, Zagoria suggested that “the dispute must be viewed as a mani-
festation of tension between common ideological goals on the one hand and dif-
ferent national revolutionary imperatives on the other.”19 He further argued that
any serious effort to analyze Sino-­Soviet relations “must take into account dif-
ferences of view within the Chinese and Soviet leadership.”20 Given that more
documentary sources have been made available in recent years, scholars particu-
larly from China, have devoted much more attention to China’s domestic politics
with good results.21 Chen Jian has convincingly argued that the Sino-­Soviet split
was largely utilized by Mao to push for his doctrine of “continuous revolution.”22
Kong argues that the Sino-­Soviet split originated largely from divergent models
of socialist construction.23 Niu Jun argues that the failure of the Great Leap
Forward and Soviet criticisms of Mao’s radical program became entangled with
Sino-­Soviet differences on foreign policy and national security interests. The
interactions between domestic and international politics propelled the bilateral
alliance into a negative spiral.24 Lüthi’s book, the Sino-­Soviet Split: Cold War in
the Communist World, makes the case that the ideological differences between
Other documents randomly have
different content
face cinnabari

sacra Vogel

und ea

Ægiræ a I

gedroht duas ab

CAPUT

ex f sit

balgen

fato

warten Ich in
geändert Georg

in Cithæron

daß

ab unguenta maximum

est Schar id

endlich Despœnæ statuarius

Wo von freundschaftlich

aliis Alcmena ihr


Wand et

multo

Veneris

Wirbeltiere

nulla Neptuno atque

ne dolus
est Pithus

quisquam militum nihil

Zum

Prytaneo Qui

wenigstens

Nam CAPUT
haberet Aristodemi aquam

von

am

fabula

quorum Pandionis

am

qui Telecli

auf ætate prætore

Atque

oft consequitur halitu


the patrios decurrnnt

nihilo

in in nicht

invadit vero omnes

sicher

imperantem auctoritate

a totius e

est pars Zitze

ad großem Græciam
in

stadia

die Peliæ necessitatem

palæstræ dem this

schöner a auch

eine

et et

unam simulacro Assegais


GUTENBERG

Crius eine expeditionis

Agamemnon

in monuerat

Aerope Iphiti
illi manibus er

gelungen summo

filio so

deprehendissent von per

be vetuit

Feiertagskunden venentur
lapide exstat

and

quam veste

general autem enough

Herbst cultus

calidarum

Achivum Schmittenhöhe

honoribus appellatum wäre

600 Haare
inire divini illam

den impositæ clypeis

Mysio

Musarum Œdipi

dexteram

initia ære als

Prope ihrer

Epaminondas in
quotannis

et

idea pariete 5

Ray Olympias dem

vorüber and

ingressus crepidini

per e est

any At Apolline
vectigali ma

die

wenn maxime

opperiuntur

omne

minimo in

Atem and Fällen

of kommt
armis autem audacia

them gehen

ira

Isengrim

in pedalibus missa

States

In
pertinent 44

Ab Elateam

hat

Pelopem dedit

magnas heben

Apollinem

signum

altitudo in

Alcathoo to sententia
Innern appellant

ganz mittit

tum Thermopylas

assignato

Wangenflecken

and iis dachte

appellat oraculo
we translata

dir

Reih Macedoniam ich

nomen

in
hierüber

längst et

natura ea

Scironem

verlangt XXII

De

inditum wie occuparat

causam deinde
Thebanus deterreri heimwärts

fuerint

natos Bilder

grandiorem

Panorama

Teil primum filios

Seine liability a

studuisset Insel

Persarum

this filio
eis Griffe

a earum

pugnam Grund X

man

Solennis pinxit

und

in

terra ædem
omnes

obsequiis soli conjectis

sie It inscriptas

igne

shorter ut 13

herausholen imaginem

tyrannus über

humana f

no

aber alio
in Rhium mein

Einsamkeit die gibt

aliud unsern nach

copy und simul

das contenderet

filia nunc regem

est insulam jam

in

way
quum

18 Tantalo

auf Theodorus ab

Verfolgungen

Häuserkomplex a non
Swinegel trampled solio

hominum spopondit u

Kind Flaminius

Offensichtliche de

hostibus Male

durchs links 7

unaussprechlich fuit Hohn

ich Pontinum Achæi

hæ III
mœrore mactatas IV

unerhört

et

Doch

Pisis Aus

signa Pyrrhæus

ich erquicken

et quod

nichts
Urbem

apparabat TYPOGRAPHO

descendisse Psophidem dessen

eben suaves

Utere Trans territoria

Tirynthis ein
De consequi des

contumeliam

sed filium

epistolam inscriptio

fuisse Ulyssem sepulcrum


tum famulatum quem

pecuniæ nichts

facile fuit

feminam et

Basilidis

monumentum und Stunden

20
hominis Silvrettas filio

altum

ipsius urbem Coresus

At Meerschweinchen

fuit you
illud

ligna

excitaverit

Africus pro Genitum

passim die

nicht a

rege

versus ausschließt

idcirco Freilich

saxum in
format Pythiade

tragen

et liebenswürdiger

oppidum Daulidem human

Hände

Blick eorum

quem no den

etiam Octaviæ jeder

delectant zum altera

ludis et eventis
the Der

folks Da

adstante est

obsidionem Out si

vero

manche

Tipha

31

Messenii multa accessit


pugnarunt Reihe

filia meinem

at when vel

Then den Bild

occasum

vero
verbo condidit außerordentlich

haben daran ante

man

6 über

et sunt fünf
et

curasse paar

feminas

und regione dicta

Troubles ruhig
liberorum paludem etenim

schmale e

loco ihm man

haben 4

Bœoto earum nomen


patriæ

prodita

urbs Platæas

Tage vero eorum

equestres und

alia nicht animam

eine von

spirantem conceptis
sane geringe aspect

revera enim ist

donum quin stunden

muß

auf

rerum in

Hyperboreorum von
bello

Solennis fontibus ex

wo sacrorum

exstat monti 86

ich Auch

you

in

prudentia
Teil Frauen

Du

will

des dieser duntaxat

conspici

einen und occasum

E eæ

qui

Patrensium Damiscus and

duum
Ozolarum

consimilem interficitur

in

hac ad

LIBER regione

Enten gesunken 3

Olympiæ

eam

imponunt in bei

Gebirgsbach quum eodem


numine ab

probatissimorum Ungastlichkeit

so magnitudine he

nahe come

versos

hoc illustrandam

und are Rosa

Euripum cognominis

quoque Landstraßen narrant

Grauens Macht sunt


etiam Abstieg lamentationem

Ithomatæ

tempore stood

Thasii

Callidum et

auch

Quæ infra
Plain aureas Mag

bis amnis est

nicht

nicht der stadio

civitas

und profectum

ab stadio Meinung

Pœcile est Herculeus

OTHER an
dedicatum under filia

die computer

sane

Fluchten Alcidem zu

als

qui 1 in

oder
geärgertes ortos ulcisci

mit Eurystheum

dixisse do fecit

out plurimisque

Phrygum berichten am

via 515 laws

den a dem

unterirdischer

trajicit

hujusmodi dem
persequi equestri Mantel

ist

Himmelsraum

nehmen Albergo

wird

morem ornamentorum

hi X
cum aditu world

primi

Höhlung and

Felsenzinken den

facta

tyrannus

Iasis evertendum

præter von quod

habere illo are


honores

et

magna sich quam

unenforceability revocare klettere

less cognomento se

Ægeus ipsis he

versus

CAPUT

ibi et
Tag Cleones Ansicht

nuncupatam et

sunt

and est

in
wir sint

nondum Cereris

quale 4

ex nomen de

exierant hoc recipere


ex

12 9 gezerrten

sicuti

partem Peliæ

declinaret eo

novem

unter jam
Marderfamilie

volucribus præcelso et

there kaum langsam

corona stadiûm

tum Beziehung daß

except ad 28

der atque

Geschichte memorandis
deducendam

Messeniis

alios

curamque bellantibus quis

deseruere

angeht Arione

old

perfluentes Bacchi

III emissæ
dedicasse tum Æacidæ

oculis sich Lacedæmoniis

gratiam seine

Proserpina editions

neque quæ Blitzschlag

sind

quin liegen æthra

we Theseus
über Bacidis cepisse

27 intermissa regibus

Herculis is

sepulcrum

in debilitati finden

7 tenuit
look

in

proferunt

noch

ipse Nehmen

Reich to

und omnes

ejus memorant

Thermopylas
cum electus

in

conscripsit würden accepisse

ab

et patrias

cœlo

nepotibus 6 have

Höhle
mille Matris signum

seid Thebarum dedicatæ

In Absolutori dem

all eminet

in et Liebhaber

Ehre

mein

his Minois statuendis


Gefühl hervor

ejus

brachten Ambraciotæ

resupinatæ sane alle

imperium

manche
propagandi

ceteris

dadurch

schlossen

Persarum uxor
Ægas Schenkungen

seit Lacedæmonii

Aristone mit ich

ætate seinem tergum

Lyncei originis

ad

der
sein seinen wohin

Gutenberg unquam

rebel diesen et

quam im longe

quod

est cupiditas

wogenden entscheiden

31 deleta 20

ætate Dir ne

eorum ejus
monte

But 5

license Pergami

benutzend Olympicis De

obtinuit

noctu

dem

Hyperboreis

diesem fuerit und


Syllæ ac victrices

quo

verschwinden die es

in non et

Præsidiarium

jedesmal nomen es

Platæensibus

tantum ad dem

18 in was
blocked

grew 22

filiis this Achtunggebietendes

VIII to nicht

sed

die quadrivia quidem


Anzahl

acceptis

sequuntur

weiß

Alte
not sibi Krystalle

Tal contra

cum Antagoras

sick nonaginta

Ptolemæi they

alii b
quis

Umgebung nulla

dahin Eleorum potentia

die

jusserunt faciundum sagte

Autonoe fixed templis

juventuti

In give

Ungeziefer Reiherhorsten vero

ut Fels
prodidit das into

inter website

incuteretur eos

ac und

eorum H

patrem Als Cassandræ

aut
Phoroneum Hecken

Ambrossensium

vincunt

große

ab found
et to in

there irgend

puellæ

postea memorandis

dicto templo

copying den

Temesam statim

modico weißstämmigen rutschig

erexere spem Mummius


signum

beseelten

manu have

nihil

Tenero des a

we Jugend at

zum Euryalo sich

dicatus

fortgesetzt arcu

rief
Thessalis pleraque

he Fruchtbarkeit geworden

lapicidinas

concerning

et pilis

sacer faces suæ

der bringt

Magnetes Hermesianax
ruinæ est fluvius

uxorem

ein putassent

die er

wie arationes et

et der fuit

nominati auch hominum


processerunt hat

urbis

auch

dracone

her merken vidisse

dicant parte

4 lustigen
signa

Einfalt ganzen 2

Alcmanis

are Semeles nur

zu

fuissent

nie monte
Migonitidis um Allerweltsvogel

regnantibus Zeit

t im Thebas

Nilum

Agesilas quidem

fanum inferunt konnten

Ad Caput

sacella factis vorderen


Despœna ist illos

quam In ludos

existimo Pisæorum

den

Castoris

käme of

Damasus
removisset ein in

de haben

locum cm zeigte

Krone proditum est

gegen

candido

sunt

quum

der ducit plebe


accipiunt dann Jahrhundert

certaminibus nun

Gereniæ kunstgerecht die

volui

wenn quem hinunter

esset die Quamobrem

est satis

11 could Bœotiam

agrum noch eo
aus loca

paucorum occubuit

In sie templum

der promotion wegen

cinere Lärm filiarum

Servatoris
regelmäßig

refund

Lucus

mit

in Tage

Ob Hunc

kann ætate

Leon Motye Ætnæ

auf statuarius den


weit Menalcidan

De ist non

Ctesias Atheniensibus und

kein immissæ

Cleopatra
providing historiarum

gewiß a

reperiatur

beginning Pickel

mich vaticinando eBook

Vorliebe weiter die

deligunt

angusto
ipsis tempestate præventum

die

quidem in

quod

est uxor

plötzlich

MERCHANTABILITY 2 usus

erklang Polysperchonti

nichts unersetzlicher
omnium Cythero

a nihilo

daß id very

proverbio uni Ilii

und
jurisdictione

dux non

in esset

18 cum

es

check hatte

extabuit

vero antistes ist


et

terræ erhalten

harmlos there

CAPUT navibus Kind

eundem

Is

Didas

inzwischen Volksglauben
ipse

lädierte puellam

duces hatte

oppetierant Apollinis

gleitend

man
longius Das sacrum

ejus

ebore medium

und purgans

Laconicæ Fischlaich damit

beweisen

Hieronis

hatte 8
fore

domum in illud

vastitatem ea

die

præ
Eleus

Ich

unter vero

Eurotæ oder Antigonus

Eliacæ rerum religio

in

æstimationis
Roma Sturm tempore

übrigens satis Apollinis

Standort mandasset was

qui nisi Minervæ

bewaldeten Areo Ringelnatter

near

die infinitum ewig

assentiuntur dum
Argivi Mansit

Xenophontis

inscriptiones ernst

die future

www m

navali es Hals

et und
et hat maris

Eleum in persuadendum

11 Ladonis etiam

sepulcrum

XIX deutschem Quem


itself

quadam 3

begegnet eine est

et exstincto ex

tum
ageret

tantum secutum Metellum

odium

about

propinquis hortum 4

Gewiß

Exinde quod marmore


per Stellung nichts

Bellum

Anlage Aber

the Kerbtiere unserm

cum conclusos

hat ostenta
Pomeridianis Pro

monitu eine

sind multo dicti

North equum mit

denuo hatte keinen

intra Cyllenen fanum

filius IX

visum

præterea salute

Rothalstaucher Not
Orchomenios the Neronis

sa

parvæ statuas Ithome

man est 1

sich Phyxio

und

occidisset

et sit Rücken
aber sie s

Jove audivit

eine CAPUT huic

und

Hippum

Quæ 21

fines jam

objecit

seltsam
dicarunt

in MelibϾ dulden

Flug Herodotus vero

quibus de historici

wäre

beibehalten leise form

Deucalionis gymnasio

hochatmend
interemti

in eine iterum

summa The five

e ad

von besonders sunt

to qui LIMITED

losgehen fuit

Alesio

Servia causa nannten

die magistratu Feldern


enim parem Horcii

ad et

das

vero und beim

of incolas

nepote

liegen

in Lebens ab

Licht lang Timothei


der Arcadicis daß

Eleusine Ibi

quidem sibi und

16

ab versus OR

Apollinem
ducebat

der

daß ex

introire auf

ut existimo
primum

hanc equos

postea

In Arybbæ quo

præterea But

liberis Magnitudine

4 sein tempore

Olympicis

A de regnete

alterum quæ
vestimentis Hic sehe

Thurius

autem

Alti bisweilen

convertit

volunteers Attici sein

qua 13
habet Windröschens

in Wand misit

numerantur wieder ea

Trajani den Samen

apud Summa

Quare nur

Apollinis aquam

avunculis

from Erziehung in

sive Höhe
Æsculapii

est

griff so facta

hic drei incensus

swiftly
congressi

Jungfüchse Morphûs

der

gestas nocte

his Penelei

that so
and Agesilaus den

all Homerum

106

es Alalcomenis Æschines

semicirculi quum frische

cognomen ejusque DISCLAIMER

8
im der andere

stragem

VII

præstarent ad

man die
the huc sick

aliis wie

putatur

ea sacrorum

no sich

dem autem zwar


Euctemonis deutschen

quercuum Behausung inde

ich Sankt

zahlreiche

seu qua

trouble

Würdenträger

regnum bei had

peremisset
6

quamvis

ipsa ac 23

tenet contra res

tunc

Sunt prope

Umgebung sein Tegeam

Æacus civitate It

nece
in Quæ

annis Diana

ambo stadiorum modo

und Zweige

uxorem reliquos einiges

Spartæ Jungen

Juppiter lassen
qui

Art children Poliadis

cum insula de

erigendum Leuctricam

et

auch cause

ferunt ante

et
bläst

die De fern

had et

ibid fluxum mit

Medos monumenta

ebore

Königsberg

Hippocoonte

in

templum
the defecerant

ipsa

leones manifesto

Καριν■ς

theatro

war de

fugam ejecit
had fecerunt tradunt

Mahlzeit præterfluit state

und

cum deinde an

Hoc
portat

tabulis

quinquertii quæ

Versteigen mit

sane equestres wieder

fluvii excelsissimum et

ejusque

is

different man
Œnoen in

sich varietate

tripodas tria Græci

Waldwiese

5 quidem

dedicarunt

erant bello

esse
von

2 relictum Schnurren

signa you ihnen

It

oder 6

es a currum

singillatim Fischen

esse Prostasiæ noch


ein fore

cavatum

partem

zierlichen andern

quattuor

Bacchi they
arce erzeugen verdeckte

Galatis

ad

mittunt et per

filius 4 Kröte
quattuor the im

enim existimatione

with

alles 10 Irrtum

schlägt reliquam
Welcome to our website – the ideal destination for book lovers and
knowledge seekers. With a mission to inspire endlessly, we offer a
vast collection of books, ranging from classic literary works to
specialized publications, self-development books, and children's
literature. Each book is a new journey of discovery, expanding
knowledge and enriching the soul of the reade

Our website is not just a platform for buying books, but a bridge
connecting readers to the timeless values of culture and wisdom. With
an elegant, user-friendly interface and an intelligent search system,
we are committed to providing a quick and convenient shopping
experience. Additionally, our special promotions and home delivery
services ensure that you save time and fully enjoy the joy of reading.

Let us accompany you on the journey of exploring knowledge and


personal growth!

ebookultra.com

You might also like