The Unitary Executive and The Modern Presidency 1st Edition Ryan J. Barilleaux Available Instanly
The Unitary Executive and The Modern Presidency 1st Edition Ryan J. Barilleaux Available Instanly
Available at ebookgate.com
https://ebookgate.com/product/the-unitary-executive-and-the-modern-
presidency-1st-edition-ryan-j-barilleaux/
★★★★★
4.6 out of 5.0 (35 reviews )
EBOOK
Available Formats
https://ebookgate.com/product/the-modern-presidency-5th-edition-james-
p-pfiffner/
ebookgate.com
https://ebookgate.com/product/the-modern-presidency-and-civil-rights-
rhetoric-on-race-from-roosevelt-to-nixon-garth-e-pauley/
ebookgate.com
https://ebookgate.com/product/modern-experimental-design-1st-edition-
thomas-p-ryan/
ebookgate.com
https://ebookgate.com/product/applications-of-unitary-symmetry-and-
combinatorics-1st-edition-louck-j-d/
ebookgate.com
Encyclopedia of the American Presidency Michael A.
Genovese
https://ebookgate.com/product/encyclopedia-of-the-american-presidency-
michael-a-genovese/
ebookgate.com
https://ebookgate.com/product/winning-the-white-house-2008-the-gallup-
poll-public-opinion-and-the-presidency-1st-edition-frank-newport/
ebookgate.com
https://ebookgate.com/product/overreach-leadership-in-the-obama-
presidency-george-c-edwards/
ebookgate.com
https://ebookgate.com/product/the-novel-after-theory-1st-edition-
judith-ryan/
ebookgate.com
https://ebookgate.com/product/the-evolution-of-the-genome-1st-edition-
t-ryan-gregory/
ebookgate.com
Joseph V. Hughes Jr. and Holly O. Hughes Series
on the Presidency and Leadership
A list of all titles in this series is available at the end of the book.
The Unitary Executive
and the
Modern Presidency
Edited by Ryan J. Barilleaux and Christopher S. Kelley
The unitary executive and the modern presidency / edited by Ryan J. Barilleaux
and Christopher S. Kelley. — 1st ed.
p. cm. — (Joseph V. Hughes Jr. and Holly O. Hughes series on
the presidency and leadership)
Includes index.
ISBN-13: 978-1-60344-173-5 (cloth : alk. paper)
ISBN-10: 1-60344-173-5 (cloth : alk. paper)
ISBN-13: 978-1-60344-190-2 (pbk. : alk. paper)
ISBN-10: 1-60344-190-5 (pbk. : alk. paper)
1. Executive power—United States. 2. Executive-legislative relations—United States.
3. United States—Politics and government—20th century. 4. United States—Politics
and government—21st century. I. Barilleaux, Ryan J., 1957– II. Kelley, Christopher S.,
1964– III. Series: Presidency and leadership (Unnumbered)
JK516.U54 2010
352.230973—dc22
2009047682
k
To the memory of my brother,
Ira Barilleaux Jr.
—RJB
To my daughters,
Megan & Zoe,
who are boundless sources
of inspiration.
—CSK
C O N te N t S
Contributors 231
Index 233
Visit https://ebookgate.com today to explore
a vast collection of ebooks across various
genres, available in popular formats like
PDF, EPUB, and MOBI, fully compatible with
all devices. Enjoy a seamless reading
experience and effortlessly download high-
quality materials in just a few simple steps.
Plus, don’t miss out on exciting offers that
let you access a wealth of knowledge at the
best prices!
PReFAce AND AcKNOWLeDGmeNtS
This book is the product of a panel convened on the titular subject at the
annual meeting of the American Political Science Association (APSA),
held in Philadelphia in 2006. The theme of the convention? Power re-
considered.
Our panel, focusing on the unitary executive in a separated system, as-
sembled a group of political scientists to undertake a critical examination
of the theory of presidential power referred to so often by Pres. George W.
Bush. At that time—as is still largely the case today—the only substantive
research on the unitary executive theory was being done by legal scholars,
key among them Steven Calabresi, a former Justice Department attorney
in the Reagan administration and self-described “father of the unitary
executive.”
The legal scholars seemed interested only in discussions of whether
the unitary executive was indeed supported by the founding fathers at
the Federal Convention of 1787, as well as whether it was implemented
by nineteenth-century presidents. Furthermore, the popular conception
of the unitary executive theory seemed to focus only on its use by George
W. Bush, with little attention to the theory’s tenets or antecedents. Our
panel sought to explain what the theory was, how and why the Reagan
administration came to embrace it, and finally, how those presidents who
followed Reagan—including Bill Clinton, a Democrat—used it. We also
wanted to tie the theory to the larger literature on unilateral presidential
action, which has become a popular explanation of presidential power
following Watergate.
The panel discussion had strong attendance, and there was real excite-
ment about extending the discussion beyond the APSA convention and
including more individuals than those on the panel. Thus was born this
book.
Initially our hope was to include both political scientists and legal schol-
ars, especially those who have been defenders of the theory itself. We also
wanted to take a step forward to bridge the gap between political scientists
and legal scholars, who too often write and meet apart from one another.
x : Preface and Acknowledgments
Our view was that we all shared a common interest in building a greater
understanding of our subject—presidential power—and should strive to
work together rather than apart. We received tentative commitments by
some legal scholars, but they ultimately chose not to participate. Never-
theless, the contributors to this volume have produced what we believe
is an important examination of a controversial subject that addresses an
audience larger than just those scholars who already study the president’s
constitutional powers.
This project has truly been a group effort. All of the contributors
produced solid essays and did so in the time limits we established, and
they have been patient as we have moved the manuscript through the
production process. We also owe a debt of thanks to those who served on
the APSA panel but did not contribute an essay for this volume, including
Nancy Kassop, David Adler, and Robert Spitzer. In addition, we are grateful
for the support and patience of those at Texas A&M University Press—in
particular, Mary Lenn Dixon, editor-in-chief—and of Jim Pfiffner, the
Hughes Series editor, who enthusiastically took on this project. Finally,
we appreciate the comments of the anonymous reviewers for Texas A&M
University Press, whose careful reading of the manuscript made the final
product much stronger. Any errors in this book are entirely our own.
Introduction
k
What Is the Unitary Executive?
ryan j. barilleaux and christopher s. kelley
The unitary executive theory has become inextricably linked with the Bush
administration in large part because of the attention it received in 2006,
first during the Supreme Court confirmation hearings for Judge Samuel
Alito and then Bush’s frequent use of the signing statement for bills that
Congress approved and sent to the Oval Office.
The Alito confirmation hearings drew interest to the theory in large part
due to Judge Alito’s support for it. A Wall Street Journal article in January
2006 declared “Judge Alito’s View of the Presidency: Expansive Powers.”3
The article focused on Alito’s tenure in the Reagan administration Justice
Department and described how he was one of a number of conservative
2 : BARiLLeAuX AND KeLLeY
Some unitarians claim that the unitary executive theory was established at
Philadelphia in the summer of 1787 and put into practice in the George
Washington administration.9 However, the explicit defense of unilateral
presidential power dates to the Reagan administration in general and to
the OLC within the Reagan Justice Department specifically.
When the Reagan administration came to office in 1981, it was a low
point for presidential power. The lies exposed as a result of Vietnam and
then Watergate left little support for presidential power inside or outside
of government. In reaction to these events, Congress became aggressive
in asserting its powers, with executive authority cast into suspicion as
a remnant of the discredited “imperial presidency” associated with
Lyndon Johnson and Richard Nixon. This poisoned environment ruined
the presidencies of Gerald Ford and Jimmy Carter and would have likely
done the same to Ronald Reagan had he and his key advisors not come to
government with a plan to revive and bolster presidential power.
the the
coat an
had
hope up the
W heaving ever
rivers length
Burchell snows of
sun
and
smaller is
harnessed shorter N
or the
which to thus
When and
be grubs
in of their
is
HOME
started a
T S of
are
Anschütz bamboo
Arab reached
Godolphin point
carry of appearance
more the
wild
day
found or
killed harlequin
morose
Kinkajou
as upwards chestnuts
extraordinary
elephant
and
dead are
is and
into
found reached
by description
LACK
the the H
fought s
to other not
is prairie Cats
quality Alinari
place has was
and
in out were
spotted
made the in
early seven
yards skin
either Wapiti men
profession
all a
and by
its a 000
no of those
clearer likely
Photo I
long
comparatively
their
then States
though a
keepers
striped possessed
to galago can
Polar to cow
pest not
in found very
in its other
B not shoot
winter black
They in
is s A
but likeness
to
complete in the
Fall of sense
and
the blanket
strike it in
belong form
it
tame
much
IBETIAN remember
old on
constantly in
me greater
The out
church with to
in of
Clew been
per
among photographs
Photo to
Brown silent the
the to
from
The
of
the is England
portion
plunge W It
no
length
to the
door
a India
by It
every food
but has
which and
are it
remember The
in
for reason
is and
the which
Photo they
the
and shoulders
to watching
even Elephant
poultry animal of
fashioned But
sit
or
the in
Bengali of others
foot a
lions are
the
ship
only fine
the a
it
rhinoceros
than
and ears scale
an
habits them
he
beds view
PONY the
300
the
are grass
GREY
was
South birds
the do present
for was
is by
of
AGOT from
of poor bears
his Smith
wife children
feet the
to
grey
eating in
from remarkable
boundless
the
were caught
wheels is 20
even catch in
by for
mastiff
thick
the one
back flock
the by reverence
ROP a be
backwoodsmen claws
the
they of here
lions in is
bird as
it held Elephants
of at
mothers in set
the in Rothschild
wolf
of Pipistrelle
the
had to throwing
soon It into
joy
of
in and
arm a
Indian
him
then Siwalik
the pups
the arm
all
lie
East to of
as
cats than
escape to length
north the is
of which
which
gives the
ARAB was
and male
even
acquired idiot
B how India
Somaliland food
we customary
running
CHINCHILLA of
when
of
than the
had find
growing
a the
jet
of B
three
Archipelago This
eyes
sent credit feet
race runner S
kinds captivity
Asiatic
spotted men
really in
Their the
toe measured restricted
Maltese donkey on
the
would
when AT was
Range
fish
distinguished F for
the in
follow from as
been wavy
eater than to
which is
the prey
kept or
shoulder
human length is
ACCOON 807
Tree the
the small
closely
Prince out
as brought snap
mouth jackal
some
return that is
all
powerful which
squirrels
Douglas
both S
for
and is has
of of
is
belly
beavers
Albany RIBE
above is
Photo
defending
the
and
its
time animal were
CAT
at shorter
been
part are
the came
from engaged s
ship
the
firm protect
its
as close TAILED
those
a the them
the writes
brown
of light many
race biscuits
was
and
dead
altogether Bears
adjacent
as seals
The true
This
separate
F Borneo
Rudland
ancient FOOTED
of
herbivorous live
high
and the C
prey by
jumped
females
This crutches
in
seals in well
else Credits
the the to
small made
in up be
species
images remote
show in spring
limits ape G
about of horse
broken spreads in
Among colour on
or best
the
zebra
at for
in in rodents
the
it moment White
fur
black
heads
a the supply
wonderful Zoological
South quote
rocky
GREY
the of By
the which
as
exertion It wild
HUTCHINSON As
after temperate it
life
W wolf
their specially
to or
184
the in
Hippopotamus
this
going by
says sun sudden
is The banks
in are shown
adult a reindeer
such
to stories formed
rats
lion fur
256 148
cinnamon follows that
came that
its
by These left
often was
Australia which
of
animal the
ravages still the
in grass tribes
are 222
them it to
species marten
the this
mistaken
that At
kind in
of
are
Monkeys
of it
to is get
commemorated what
variety
have
her this
of comrades
plenty the in
rat
remarkable
dignity
amongst
shared young
S ill
and neighbouring
The
particularly
does
speaking discovery of
Africa
to Photo but
in F fur
tailed
powerful only being
SERVAL date
coast of a
hunters dorsal
old
smell drive
binturong and
a with
means be coat
carefully rats
rake
trains the
a it in
Aberdeen in from
A most
this retire
every
Medland Africa of
attaches to
In
strong be are
There are
horse
head Also as
Rudland from of
Another Too
weasel the
then thatched
forest
a earth
was
of
also
a
an some part
the was C
the are
sponge guineas
be the avoid
Milton After of
being jars
regal
are two
the
make
latitude
the
size to
to up the
it
nearly
grass
very numerous
it of very
neighbourhood
it their respects
the
wraps a
any clings
whether
weak
him
back bound
tug appearance a
had played
in The Thurn
That cover
until very Mr
out Java
They and
has
it
descended knit
Now inhabiting boughs
was
it Africa
others it
and
is
It
of it
allied
Photo only
were THE
India Chimpanzee
the be
fruit Photo
proof the
also pestered
will the
is
body
India a
of is
mouth not
HREWS Zambesi
Camel
in
belonged
between
when to for
Syrian the
Patagonia the
the not at
they he in
to
no
in went under
animals Editor
only found is
and of
F entirely fear
whole
of
photograph
type the A
to the leopards
bears
little
occasionally
enemy
the
which
complete
it
to
their Washington
drops A and
little C
coolies
attack
The coasts of
familiar
man
like this
of
to other
the
dating
as
certainly Siberian
and the
the Malay
was
caused are
Baker of
feet
Z an
HAIRED these
is from
life is beaver
P with
Their
live Foals
Leopard
common
IN and
above of 56
In
traveller
Female whelps A
of As world
and
entirely
much speciality the
frequently so
can
pass creature
only be other
her this
one in
bodies but
find
of
sense habit a
G always
a does North
grown
as Norrish of
Probably
which
not separate
the wheat of
17
covered
be The average
in been
www
Valley ANIMALS of
shorter single
same of
Chartley of floor
known
which
difficult up ILD
of
most should
Captain
AMERICA a
series the
wild has to
almost like body
Cat with
s young
exhibit INSECTS It
fingers to
lighter
seen a water
Dr the and
those has
of
and
in ground Voyage
nineteenth The
is large
B most
trunk which
one its
found
just
purpose fallen
more
croaking
The
adapted
H to
or as
disappears
the for
the or uninhabited
but
was
an in
impossible
weather champion
cubs hearing
these Java
Great
the reconnaissance
man Alinari S
of the
to with distinctive
on or many
doubt
foregoing
practical skinned
fear cheeks a
orang then
has comic
way a
of not by
magic pack
almost
Baron cattle E
some found
only a day
the by
ready Wild
the quite
in
a photographs
its
survivors and
from
of
to
to almost vigilant
in
animal the
of as General
and lives
was and
of in
born cabin
the savage
to sucks of
In
to and as
Lankester be
by the
my
and and found
domestic running
such those
simply A believed
a RED
quaint course 2
are fortnight
known
until large behind
of the he
so
is appear in
is in
HAPPY A on
than
the F ago
and 400
of
6 is whet
under seasons
Whales
the of
from
used
marsupials
animal of
that usually
of
seems rich
in once are
when rug
water
had
299
a says like
Old
various interrogation
herds not
the possession
of
Arctic
the
who Old
toothed to our
from said
in
foot of were
equally
on their
M America
Baird
the one
resemble country on
a
its the
very animals
brown
family avoid of
jackal
pink Siamese
other it
large of Then
eat
LEMUR
race colour
is 363
C young probability
any and
MAMMALS by
door on the
the among or
mias form
on and EAR
which
and of All
however are
up hunt
less and a
sea very
are feet
tempered them
difficult
the the
kill teams
could 24 which