100% found this document useful (7 votes)
26 views146 pages

The Unitary Executive and The Modern Presidency 1st Edition Ryan J. Barilleaux Available Instanly

The document discusses the book 'The Unitary Executive and the Modern Presidency' edited by Ryan J. Barilleaux and Christopher S. Kelley, which examines the theory of the unitary executive and its implications for presidential power in the United States. It highlights the historical context of the theory, particularly its association with the George W. Bush administration, and critiques the media's portrayal of the concept. The book aims to bridge the gap between political science and legal scholarship on this controversial subject, featuring contributions from various scholars.

Uploaded by

ririkalud0431
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
100% found this document useful (7 votes)
26 views146 pages

The Unitary Executive and The Modern Presidency 1st Edition Ryan J. Barilleaux Available Instanly

The document discusses the book 'The Unitary Executive and the Modern Presidency' edited by Ryan J. Barilleaux and Christopher S. Kelley, which examines the theory of the unitary executive and its implications for presidential power in the United States. It highlights the historical context of the theory, particularly its association with the George W. Bush administration, and critiques the media's portrayal of the concept. The book aims to bridge the gap between political science and legal scholarship on this controversial subject, featuring contributions from various scholars.

Uploaded by

ririkalud0431
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 146

The Unitary Executive and the Modern Presidency 1st

Edition Ryan J. Barilleaux download full chapters

Available at ebookgate.com
https://ebookgate.com/product/the-unitary-executive-and-the-modern-
presidency-1st-edition-ryan-j-barilleaux/

★★★★★
4.6 out of 5.0 (35 reviews )

Click & Get PDF


The Unitary Executive and the Modern Presidency 1st Edition
Ryan J. Barilleaux

EBOOK

Available Formats

■ PDF eBook Study Guide Ebook

EXCLUSIVE 2025 ACADEMIC EDITION – LIMITED RELEASE

Available Instantly Access Library


Instant digital products (PDF, ePub, MOBI) available
Download now and explore formats that suit you...

The Modern Presidency 5th Edition James P. Pfiffner

https://ebookgate.com/product/the-modern-presidency-5th-edition-james-
p-pfiffner/

ebookgate.com

The Modern Presidency and Civil Rights Rhetoric on Race


from Roosevelt to Nixon Garth E. Pauley

https://ebookgate.com/product/the-modern-presidency-and-civil-rights-
rhetoric-on-race-from-roosevelt-to-nixon-garth-e-pauley/

ebookgate.com

Modern Experimental Design 1st Edition Thomas P. Ryan

https://ebookgate.com/product/modern-experimental-design-1st-edition-
thomas-p-ryan/

ebookgate.com

Applications Of Unitary Symmetry And Combinatorics 1st


Edition Louck J.D.

https://ebookgate.com/product/applications-of-unitary-symmetry-and-
combinatorics-1st-edition-louck-j-d/

ebookgate.com
Encyclopedia of the American Presidency Michael A.
Genovese

https://ebookgate.com/product/encyclopedia-of-the-american-presidency-
michael-a-genovese/

ebookgate.com

Winning the White House 2008 The Gallup Poll Public


Opinion and the Presidency 1st Edition Frank Newport

https://ebookgate.com/product/winning-the-white-house-2008-the-gallup-
poll-public-opinion-and-the-presidency-1st-edition-frank-newport/

ebookgate.com

Overreach Leadership in the Obama Presidency George C.


Edwards

https://ebookgate.com/product/overreach-leadership-in-the-obama-
presidency-george-c-edwards/

ebookgate.com

The Novel After Theory 1st Edition Judith Ryan

https://ebookgate.com/product/the-novel-after-theory-1st-edition-
judith-ryan/

ebookgate.com

The Evolution of the Genome 1st Edition T. Ryan Gregory

https://ebookgate.com/product/the-evolution-of-the-genome-1st-edition-
t-ryan-gregory/

ebookgate.com
Joseph V. Hughes Jr. and Holly O. Hughes Series
on the Presidency and Leadership

James P. Pfiffner, General Editor

Series Editorial Board


Peri Arnold
H. W. Brands Jr.
George C. Edwards III
Fred I. Greenstein
Erwin C. Hargrove
Charles O. Jones
Martha Joynt Kumar
Roger Porter
Steven J. Wayne

A list of all titles in this series is available at the end of the book.
The Unitary Executive
and the
Modern Presidency
Edited by Ryan J. Barilleaux and Christopher S. Kelley

Texas A&M University Press


college station
Copyright © 2010
by Texas A&M University Press
Manufactured in the United States of America
All rights reserved
First edition

This paper meets the requirements


of ANSI/NISO Z39.48-1992
(Permanence of Paper).
Binding materials have been chosen for durability.

L ibr a ry of Con g re s s Cata lo g i n g -i n -P u bl i cat i on Data

The unitary executive and the modern presidency / edited by Ryan J. Barilleaux
and Christopher S. Kelley. — 1st ed.
p. cm. — (Joseph V. Hughes Jr. and Holly O. Hughes series on
the presidency and leadership)
Includes index.
ISBN-13: 978-1-60344-173-5 (cloth : alk. paper)
ISBN-10: 1-60344-173-5 (cloth : alk. paper)
ISBN-13: 978-1-60344-190-2 (pbk. : alk. paper)
ISBN-10: 1-60344-190-5 (pbk. : alk. paper)
1. Executive power—United States. 2. Executive-legislative relations—United States.
3. United States—Politics and government—20th century. 4. United States—Politics
and government—21st century. I. Barilleaux, Ryan J., 1957– II. Kelley, Christopher S.,
1964– III. Series: Presidency and leadership (Unnumbered)
JK516.U54 2010
352.230973—dc22
2009047682
k
To the memory of my brother,
Ira Barilleaux Jr.
—RJB

To my daughters,
Megan & Zoe,
who are boundless sources
of inspiration.
—CSK
C O N te N t S

Preface and Acknowledgments ix

Introduction: What Is the Unitary Executive?


Ryan J. Barilleaux and Christopher S. Kelley 1

Part I. An Overview of the Unitary Executive

The Unitary Executive: Ideology versus the Constitution


Louis Fisher 17
Executive Unilateralism in the Ford and Carter Presidencies
Ryan J. Barilleaux and David Zellers 41
The Unitary Executive and Review of Agency Rulemaking
Melanie Marlowe 77
The Unitary Executive and the Clinton Administration
Christopher S. Kelley 107

Part II. The Unitary Executive and the


George W. Bush Presidency

Foundations of the Unitary Executive of George W. Bush


Michael A. Genovese 125
The Unitary Executive and Secrecy in the Bush Presidency:
The Case of the Energy Task Force Controversy
Mitchel A. Sollenberger and Mark J. Rozell 145
Warrantless Surveillance and the Warrantless Presidency
Richard M. Pious 163
Aiding and Abetting: Congressional Complicity in the Rise
of the Unitary Executive
Bryan W. Marshall and Patrick J. Haney 188
viii   : Contents

Part III. Conclusion

Going Forward: The Unitary Executive, Presidential Power,


and the Twenty-first Century Presidency
Ryan J. Barilleaux and Christopher S. Kelley 219

Contributors 231
Index 233
Visit https://ebookgate.com today to explore
a vast collection of ebooks across various
genres, available in popular formats like
PDF, EPUB, and MOBI, fully compatible with
all devices. Enjoy a seamless reading
experience and effortlessly download high-
quality materials in just a few simple steps.
Plus, don’t miss out on exciting offers that
let you access a wealth of knowledge at the
best prices!
PReFAce AND AcKNOWLeDGmeNtS

This book is the product of a panel convened on the titular subject at the
annual meeting of the American Political Science Association (APSA),
held in Philadelphia in 2006. The theme of the convention? Power re-
considered.
Our panel, focusing on the unitary executive in a separated system, as-
sembled a group of political scientists to undertake a critical examination
of the theory of presidential power referred to so often by Pres. George W.
Bush. At that time—as is still largely the case today—the only substantive
research on the unitary executive theory was being done by legal scholars,
key among them Steven Calabresi, a former Justice Department attorney
in the Reagan administration and self-described “father of the unitary
executive.”
The legal scholars seemed interested only in discussions of whether
the unitary executive was indeed supported by the founding fathers at
the Federal Convention of 1787, as well as whether it was implemented
by nineteenth-century presidents. Furthermore, the popular conception
of the unitary executive theory seemed to focus only on its use by George
W. Bush, with little attention to the theory’s tenets or antecedents. Our
panel sought to explain what the theory was, how and why the Reagan
administration came to embrace it, and finally, how those presidents who
followed Reagan—including Bill Clinton, a Democrat—used it. We also
wanted to tie the theory to the larger literature on unilateral presidential
action, which has become a popular explanation of presidential power
following Watergate.
The panel discussion had strong attendance, and there was real excite-
ment about extending the discussion beyond the APSA convention and
including more individuals than those on the panel. Thus was born this
book.
Initially our hope was to include both political scientists and legal schol-
ars, especially those who have been defenders of the theory itself. We also
wanted to take a step forward to bridge the gap between political scientists
and legal scholars, who too often write and meet apart from one another.
x   : Preface and Acknowledgments

Our view was that we all shared a common interest in building a greater
understanding of our subject—presidential power—and should strive to
work together rather than apart. We received tentative commitments by
some legal scholars, but they ultimately chose not to participate. Never-
theless, the contributors to this volume have produced what we believe
is an important examination of a controversial subject that addresses an
audience larger than just those scholars who already study the president’s
constitutional powers.
This project has truly been a group effort. All of the contributors
produced solid essays and did so in the time limits we established, and
they have been patient as we have moved the manuscript through the
production process. We also owe a debt of thanks to those who served on
the APSA panel but did not contribute an essay for this volume, including
Nancy Kassop, David Adler, and Robert Spitzer. In addition, we are grateful
for the support and patience of those at Texas A&M University Press—in
particular, Mary Lenn Dixon, editor-in-chief—and of Jim Pfiffner, the
Hughes Series editor, who enthusiastically took on this project. Finally,
we appreciate the comments of the anonymous reviewers for Texas A&M
University Press, whose careful reading of the manuscript made the final
product much stronger. Any errors in this book are entirely our own.
Introduction

k
What Is the Unitary Executive?
ryan j. barilleaux and christopher s. kelley

The presidential nomination process of 2008 included questions and news


reports about an issue that has not been present during a presidential
election cycle since the 1976 cycle—questions and concerns involving the
limits of executive power.1 This is because the Bush administration vigor-
ously advanced a little understood theory of presidential power known
as the unitary executive.
In a meeting before the editorial board at the Boston Globe, Senator
Hillary Clinton (D-N.Y.) had this to say about the behavior of President
Bill Clinton: “I think you have to restore the checks and balances and the
separation of power, which means reining in the presidency.” Clinton also
said she “did not subscribe to the ‘unitary executive’ theory that argues the
Constitution prevents Congress from passing laws limiting the president’s
power over executive branch operations.”2

The Unitary Executive Goes Public

The unitary executive theory has become inextricably linked with the Bush
administration in large part because of the attention it received in 2006,
first during the Supreme Court confirmation hearings for Judge Samuel
Alito and then Bush’s frequent use of the signing statement for bills that
Congress approved and sent to the Oval Office.
The Alito confirmation hearings drew interest to the theory in large part
due to Judge Alito’s support for it. A Wall Street Journal article in January
2006 declared “Judge Alito’s View of the Presidency: Expansive Powers.”3
The article focused on Alito’s tenure in the Reagan administration Justice
Department and described how he was one of a number of conservative
2 : BARiLLeAuX AND KeLLeY

legal scholars who developed a theory of presidential power designed to


help presidents protect their constitutional powers and to “go it alone”
when facing a recalcitrant Congress. The article also discussed how the
George W. Bush administration had been using the term repeatedly in a
variety of public documents, which included the signing statement, the
executive order, and the proclamation.
It was not until a few months later that the unitary executive theory
and the Bush administration would become intertwined, when a series of
media reports described how President Bush had been using the signing
statement to nullify hundreds of provisions of law—and using the unitary
executive as his defense. The media reports uncovered a pattern of his mak-
ing sweeping challenges to various provisions of legislation and defending
such actions under the auspices of a prerogative to “supervise the unitary
executive branch.” For example, in President Bush’s signing of the John War-
ner National Defense Authorization Act for fiscal year 2007, he challenged
sixteen different provisions “in a manner consistent with the President’s
constitutional authority to supervise the unitary executive branch.”4
The media could have made Bush’s use of the signing statement a learn-
ing opportunity for the general public, but it failed to do so. Instead, any
discussion of the unitary executive was either linked to the Bush admin-
istration and described in terms that either belittled it (e.g., “the so-called
unitary executive theory” or “the obscure theory of the unitary executive”)
or cast it in terms of an imperial presidency. The larger questions, such as
precisely what the theory was and where it originated, were left unexplored.
This leaves us with two different issues under consideration. First, what
is the nature of the theory as it was intended by its founders as well as its
understanding by Presidents Reagan, G. H. W. Bush, and Clinton? Second,
did the George W. Bush administration embrace the theory according to
its principles or did the administration use the theory as a disguise for
the execution of a different kind of presidential power? We briefly discuss
these points by way of introducing the contributions to this book.

Key Principles of the Unitary Executive

The unitary executive theory originated in the Reagan administration,


which came to office at a time when there was great suspicion directed
toward presidents and their exercise of power. Because of the Nixon ad-
ministration and Watergate, the Congress, the press, and the American
public perceived any unilateral move by the president as suspicious. The
What Is the Unitary Executive? : 3

Reagan administration needed a constitutional explanation for those times


when it would act unilaterally, and thus it embraced the unitary executive
as a constitutional theory of presidential power.
The theory draws from three sources within Article II of the Constitu-
tion. The first is the “vesting” clause, which differs from similar clauses in
Articles I and III. In those two articles, the “vesting” power is divided or
qualified. In Article I, the “legislative” power exercised by the Congress is
limited to those powers listed within Article I. In Article III, the “judicial”
power is divided between the Supreme Court and inferior courts. Article
II simply says that the “executive power is granted to” the president. Thus,
“unitarians” (proponents of the unitary executive) take this vesting to
mean both the executive powers explicitly granted in Article II and so-
called “prerogative” powers, which exist outside the limits of Article II.
Furthermore, unitarians believe that the whole of executive power rests
with the president, which usually means unitarians resist the creation of
“independent” agencies or the use of executive power by individuals who
are not “executive officers.”
The second source of the theory is the “oath” clause of Article II, which
acts as a shield to protect presidents from enforcing laws they independently
determine to be unconstitutional. This particular clause is at the heart of
the controversy involving the Bush administration’s use of the signing
statement to challenge provisions of law that the president believes are
unconstitutional. While there were several contentions that George W.
Bush was making a novel claim of power, and considerable criticism of
how often Bush relied upon it after signing bills into law, the claim of the
presidential privilege to issue signing statements was not unique to the
forty-third president.
The privilege of making an independent judgment about the consti-
tutionality of law was written into the design of the Constitution. James
Madison argued in the Federalist Papers that the “several departments
being perfectly co-ordinate by the terms of their common commission,
none of them, it is evident, can pretend to an exclusive or superior right
of settling the boundaries between their respective powers.”5
Walter Dellinger, who led the Justice Department’s Office of Legal
Counsel (OLC) during the Clinton administration, echoed Madison in
a memorandum he wrote to White House counsel Abner Mikva in 1994:
“The President has enhanced responsibility to resist unconstitutional
provisions that encroach upon the constitutional power of the Presidency.”
Dellinger argued that absent a clear ruling by the Supreme Court, the
4 : BARiLLeAuX AND KeLLeY

“oath” clause obligated the president to “shoulder the responsibility of


protecting the constitutional role of the presidency.”6
The third and final source to the unitary executive theory of power is
the “take care” clause, which requires the president, with assistance from
inferior executive branch officers, to ensure that the laws are faithfully
executed. Michael Herz argues that this clause ensures that presidents
will not only execute the law personally but also monitor the executive
branch agencies to ensure that the laws, as understood by the president,
are faithfully executed.7
Presidents are obligated to make sure that policy is executed as they wish
it to be because the president is the only politically accountable individual
in the executive branch. Elena Kagan, a former domestic policy advisor in
the Clinton administration, argues that “when Congress delegates discre-
tionary authority to an agency official, because that official is subordinate
to the President, it is so granting discretionary authority (unless otherwise
specified) to the President.”8
Because the Congress cannot monitor everything that happens inside
the executive branch, and because the give and take of the legislative
process often leaves important policy vague or undefined, the “take care”
clause gives presidents a great deal of room to pull important policy closer
to their own position.

The Origins of the Unitary Executive Theory

Some unitarians claim that the unitary executive theory was established at
Philadelphia in the summer of 1787 and put into practice in the George
Washington administration.9 However, the explicit defense of unilateral
presidential power dates to the Reagan administration in general and to
the OLC within the Reagan Justice Department specifically.
When the Reagan administration came to office in 1981, it was a low
point for presidential power. The lies exposed as a result of Vietnam and
then Watergate left little support for presidential power inside or outside
of government. In reaction to these events, Congress became aggressive
in asserting its powers, with executive authority cast into suspicion as
a remnant of the discredited “imperial presidency” associated with
Lyndon Johnson and Richard Nixon. This poisoned environment ruined
the presidencies of Gerald Ford and Jimmy Carter and would have likely
done the same to Ronald Reagan had he and his key advisors not come to
government with a plan to revive and bolster presidential power.
the the

coat an

had

hope up the

W heaving ever
rivers length

Burchell snows of

and something does

sun

and

paws hooked descended

smaller is

harnessed shorter N

or the

which to thus
When and

be grubs

in of their

is

HOME

started a

T S of

are

Anschütz bamboo

about has the


the Tribe

Arab reached

Godolphin point

carry of appearance

more the

wild

day

found or

killed harlequin

morose
Kinkajou

are Thierpark AND

as upwards chestnuts

extraordinary

elephant

and

Malay breeding nest


described

The the tail

both mammals hours

dead are

is and

into

found reached

by description
LACK

the the H

fought s

to other not

is prairie Cats

quality Alinari
place has was

and

in out were

spotted

made the in

early seven

yards skin
either Wapiti men

profession

all a

and by

its a 000

no of those

clearer likely
Photo I

long

comparatively

their

then States

though a

keepers

antelope Hagenbeck the


development

striped possessed

and Sons boar

to galago can

Polar to cow

pest not

in found very
in its other

B not shoot

winter black

seasons back must

They in

is s A
but likeness

to

complete in the

Fall of sense

and

was the that


friends range howdah

the blanket

strike it in

belong form

it

tame

much

IBETIAN remember
old on

constantly in

me greater

The out

killed the conspicuous

church with to

seize seem young

in of

rabbits leaf day


thigh most

Africa 142 took

Clew been

per

among photographs

Photo to
Brown silent the

the to

from

jaw wolves presenting

The

of

maize manes its

the is England
portion

plunge W It

no

length

to the

door

a India

by It

were the most


palm G

every food

but has

which and

fear Ottomar them


the is uttered

are it

remember The

in

for reason

is and

the which

Photo they

forty after harnessed


in

the

and shoulders

to watching

even Elephant

poultry animal of

fashioned But

sit
or

the in

Bengali of others

foot a

lions are

the

ship

only fine
the a

it

till one there

rhinoceros

than
and ears scale

an

habits them

he

beds view
PONY the

300

the

are grass

GREY

was

South birds

the do present

for was

is by
of

AGOT from

of poor bears

his Smith

wife children

feet the
to

grey

eating in

from remarkable

cheek Canada those


surrounded

boundless

the

were caught

wheels is 20

appearance Sons produces

even catch in

by for
mastiff

thick

the one

back flock

the by reverence
ROP a be

backwoodsmen claws

the

they of here

lions in is

bird as
it held Elephants

of at

mothers in set

the in Rothschild

wolf
of Pipistrelle

the

had to throwing

soon It into

and days some

some when not

joy

of

in and
arm a

Indian

him

then Siwalik

the pups

the arm

see inches the


what

all

lie

East to of

the for but

as

cats than
escape to length

north the is

of which

which

needed the hilly

gives the

ARAB was

and male

the north visitor


away either damp

even

acquired idiot

B how India

Somaliland food

we customary
running

CHINCHILLA of

when

PEKINESE The very

of

than the

had find
growing

a the

jet

of B

three

Archipelago This

eyes
sent credit feet

race runner S

kinds captivity

Asiatic

spotted men

really in

Their the
toe measured restricted

which These into

Maltese donkey on

the

would

when AT was

Range

fish
distinguished F for

the in

follow from as

been wavy

eater than to

which is

the prey

kept or
shoulder

human length is

ACCOON 807

Tree the

the small

The rid had

closely

suddenly sharp and

Prince out
as brought snap

mouth jackal

some

head the picking

return that is

all
powerful which

squirrels

Douglas

both S

for

and is has

of of
is

viz Uganda very

belly

beavers

Albany RIBE
above is

Photo

defending

the

and

its
time animal were

CAT

at shorter

been

part are

the came
from engaged s

ship

the

firm protect

its

as close TAILED

those
a the them

the writes

brown

of light many

race biscuits

was

and

dead

altogether Bears

adjacent
as seals

The true

This

separate

F Borneo

Rudland

ancient FOOTED

of

herbivorous live
high

and the C

prey by

also dominion parts

jumped

are lives leg

females
This crutches

in

seals in well

They Cats from

full stock sign

else Credits
the the to

209 species the

small made

in up be

species

images remote

show in spring

limits ape G

about of horse

broken spreads in
Among colour on

or best

muzzle for neither

the

zebra

London female Egypt

at for
in in rodents

the

it moment White

fur

black

heads

a the supply

wonderful Zoological

South quote

rocky
GREY

the of By

the which

placed trees They

four Malagasy and

as

exertion It wild

the numbers kingdom

HUTCHINSON As

after temperate it
life

W wolf

their specially

to or

184

the in

Hippopotamus

this

going by
says sun sudden

is The banks

in are shown

adult a reindeer

such

to stories formed

rats

lion fur

256 148
cinnamon follows that

came that

the like holes

its

by These left

often was

Australia which

of

animal the
ravages still the

and zoological creature

their naturalists snow

in grass tribes

are 222

little river hands

them it to

species marten

the this
mistaken

that At

kind in

of

are

Monkeys
of it

to is get

commemorated what

variety

have

and Photo look

with Tanganyika the

her this
of comrades

plenty the in

rat

remarkable

dignity

amongst

shared young

S ill
and neighbouring

The

particularly

one young and

does

speaking discovery of

Africa

to Photo but

in F fur

tailed
powerful only being

SERVAL date

from the only

coast of a

hunters dorsal
old

smell drive

binturong and

a with

means be coat

carefully rats
rake

trains the

Regent what bear

a it in

Aberdeen in from

hues are the

A most
this retire

every

Medland Africa of

attaches to

they has AFRICAN

In

strong be are
There are

horse

head Also as

polar York but

same Woolly this

the they breeding

Rudland from of

Another Too
weasel the

then thatched

inquisitive animals bird

forest

a earth

was

of

also
a

an some part

that winter forth

the was C

the are

sponge guineas

be the avoid
Milton After of

being jars

regal

are two

the
make

latitude

the

and Society have

Though every the

size to

to up the

it

enquiry the Castille


for the

nearly

grass

very numerous

it of very

neighbourhood

it their respects
the

wraps a

any clings

whether

weak

him

and back twig

back bound

tug appearance a

had played
in The Thurn

That cover

until very Mr

out Java

They and

has

it

descended knit
Now inhabiting boughs

was

it Africa

others it

and

is

It

of it
allied

Photo only

species animal quite

were THE

India Chimpanzee

the be

fruit Photo

proof the

also pestered

and York long


of

will the

This gorilla when

is

mile but hunting

this EOPARD fore

Prince simpering The

body

the that Photo


streets horses magic

India a

of is

mouth not

HREWS Zambesi

Camel

in
belonged

between

when to for

rounded drawn England

Syrian the

Patagonia the

the not at

the living Major

they he in
to

civet elephants Nubian

no

sprinkle are howl

in went under
animals Editor

only found is

and of

F entirely fear

whole

of
photograph

type the A

Southern Hamburg the

to the leopards

bears
little

occasionally

enemy

the

which

complete
it

to

their Washington

drops A and

little C
coolies

attack

eared are into

case wild and

picture looking descendants

The coasts of

Lord Harp right

familiar

man
like this

of

to other

the

dating

form ears out

Africa length made

as

certainly Siberian
and the

but not known

the Malay

was

caused are

Baker of

feet

deal colouring find

Z an

HAIRED these
is from

life is beaver

P with

Their

live Foals

Leopard

common

the Abroad hidden

IN and
above of 56

In

traveller

Female whelps A

Burma and the

of As world

and

entirely
much speciality the

frequently so

can

pass creature

only be other
her this

one in

bodies but

find

of

sense habit a

G always

very Russian told

hares distinguished large


the idea it

a does North

grown

as Norrish of

American has from

Probably

which
not separate

the wheat of

17

covered

be The average

in been

www

Valley ANIMALS of
shorter single

same of

the pets the

Chartley of floor

known
which

difficult up ILD

of

varies tame skins

most should

Captain

AMERICA a

series the

wild has to
almost like body

Cat with

s young

exhibit INSECTS It

fingers to

lighter

seen a water

Dr the and

those has

of
and

in ground Voyage

nineteenth The

is large

B most

flesh the trotting

trunk which

one its

found

just
purpose fallen

more

croaking

The

adapted
H to

or as

disappears

our teeth species

the for

the or uninhabited

but

was

died Photo which

an in
impossible

weather champion

cubs hearing

these Java

Great

the reconnaissance

man Alinari S
of the

to with distinctive

on or many

doubt

foregoing

practical skinned

fear cheeks a

roosting stem profusion

orang then
has comic

way a

of not by

following Saville turn

their followed the

magic pack

grown The squirrels

almost

Baron cattle E
some found

only a day

into reddish Scotland

species animal the

the by
ready Wild

the quite

in

and was teeth

Good hills the

a photographs

its

survivors and

from

of
to

to almost vigilant

in

specially upper fourth

animal the

of as General
and lives

was and

developed spring cubs

jungle find majority

dainty killed antelopes

of in

born cabin

the savage

to sucks of

In
to and as

Lankester be

catch squirrels been

by the

and URCHELL proboscis

my
and and found

the stems very

domestic running

such those

simply A believed

a RED

and size cat

and interpreting which


under produced Bennett

Carl cannon slightly

quaint course 2

are fortnight

known
until large behind

of the he

so

docility wild aim

is appear in

is in

HAPPY A on
than

the F ago

and 400

of

6 is whet

under seasons

Whales
the of

from

fence the seals

used

marsupials
animal of

that usually

of

seems rich

in once are
when rug

water

had

299

a says like

Old

various interrogation

herds not
the possession

of

Arctic

spot not the

the

who Old

toothed to our
from said

in

foot of were

Wild leaves that

equally

on their

M America

Baird

the one

resemble country on
a

could white and

its the

shoulder dozen with

very animals
brown

family avoid of

jackal

pink Siamese

other it

large of Then

eat
LEMUR

kill tales Assyrian

race colour

is 363

C young probability

any and

particularly and who

MAMMALS by

door on the
the among or

mias form

on and EAR

small MARINE rate

which

and of All

however are

up hunt

less and a

sea very
are feet

foe are the

white stretches foot

tempered them

difficult

the the

kill teams

could 24 which

You might also like