The Ethics of Librarianship An International Survey Robert W. Vaagan (Editor) Full Chapters Instanly
The Ethics of Librarianship An International Survey Robert W. Vaagan (Editor) Full Chapters Instanly
★★★★★
4.7 out of 5.0 (46 reviews )
EBOOK
Available Formats
Edited by
Robert W. Vaagan
with an introduction by
Alex Byrne, chairman of I FLA /FAI FE
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval
system of any nature, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical,
photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior written permission of the publisher.
Foreword
by Robert W.Vaagan 1
by Alex Byrne 8
Argentina
Argentine librarians, freedom of speech and ethical aspects
of public service
Canada
Ethics and the Canadian Library Association: Building on a
Philosophical Foundation of Intellectual Freedom
by Toni Samek 35
by Deyanira Sequiera 59
Estonia
Collaboration between Estonian Librarians' Association and
Estonian Libraries
by Maije Tamre 81
Finland
Professional Ethics — A Finnish Outlook
by Kerstin Sevón 96
Iceland
Librarians and information specialist ethical issues:
an Icelandic perspective
Japan
The Code of Ethics of The Japan Library Association
Lithuania
Ethics — A New Challenge for Lithuanian Librarians
Mexico
Librarianship
by Rosa Maríaand ethics indeMexico
Fernández Zamora and Martín Vera Cabañas 177
Norway
Norwegian librarianship, ethics and ABM
Russia
The Russian Librarian's Professional Ethics Code
South Africa
Librarian ethics in South Africa
Sweden
Roundabouts to the professional highway. On the development of
a Code of ethics for Swedish librarians
Thailand
The Code of Ethics of the Thai Library Association
Uganda
Librarianship and Professional Ethics: The Case for Uganda
United Kingdom
Doing the right thing: professional ethics for information
workers in Britain
United
Trends States
of of America
Library Associations and Ethics in the US
by Wallace Koehler 323
About the contributors 338
FOREWORD
Robert W.Vaagan,
Faculty of Journalism, Library and Information Science,
Oslo University College
Ethical considerations, not least the intellectual freedoms of opinion and expression,
which are reflected both in the core values of EFLA and in the activities of FAIFE, have
long been a concern for librarians and library associations.1 Following the creation of
The Journal of Information Ethics in 1992 it is apparent that LIS research has also
become more attentive to ethics. Thus The Library Bill of Rights of The American
utilitarianism, natural rights theory and social contract theory.2 Despite this ethical
of best practice.
Today as the information age unfolds there are many indications of a growing
need for this type of moral benchmarking. As most of the articles in the present volume
reflect, librarianship and the wider LIS field are facing various challenges where ethical
considerations come into play. A shortlist of potentially divisive issues with ethical
aspects would include globalisation, the digital gap between the information rich and
filters and the consequences of The General Agreement on Trade in Services (GATS).
1
is intended to target terrorists, also causes ethical concern that such legislation may
expression.
The relevance of ethics is becoming more apparent as librarianship and the LIS
field are being reshaped, e.g. inducing several LIS authors over the last years to reaffirm
the traditional values of librarianship as librarians go about their traditionally main task
of cataloguing, preserving and transmitting the human record.3 Yet in the information
well as the contributions from the United Kingdom, Estonia and Iceland in the present
volume all reflect. Based on UNESCO's planned global infoethics code to be launched
in 2003, and the increasing relevance of infoethics, 4 it is reasonable to posit that ethics
(under tables such as ethics of librarianship, LIS ethics, infoethics, cyberethics etc), will
form part of the traffic rules that will apply to what some have metaphorically described
On the threshold of the new millenium it causes concern that we may have to
accept information overload (infobogs) and information fatigue ("the IFS syndrome") as
permanent features. 6 Also causing concern is the observation by some LIS authors that
the theme of survival appears repeatedly in the LIS education literature.7 Of course LIS
education cannot be exempted from the current reshaping of the LIS field. While some
see traditional librarianship values as a remedy, others prescribe the acquisition of new
information age skills, converting librarians into "infopreneurs", which raises other
ethical considerations including those of the market place. Many, if not most, of the
articles in the present volume support the view that LIS education should accord greater
importance to ethics. This, it would seem, applies not least to countries which for
2
various reasons lack appropriate codes of ethics or codes of conduct. From this
perspective the contributions from Argentina, South Africa, Uganda are cases in point.
Also interesting are countries with partial solutions like Mexico (a code of ethics but
only for Colegio member librarians with academic degrees) and Norway (a code of
We now see that also mid-career librarians in many cases see a need for
librarianship ethics) a recent study shows that a clear majority of leaders of Danish
public libraries want to gain new skills e.g. in value-based leadership (VBL), such as
ethical accounting.8
from a number of colleagues. This prompted me into bringing together colleagues from
further discussed in my article, the book evolved parallel with my work chairing a
Whereas the FAIFE Website currently lists the ethical codes of selected national
library associations, there is a need for commentary and analysis of individual country
cases, both those listed by FAIFE and others. The present volume is designed to fill that
need: 12 countries with codes are included (Canada, Costa Rica, Estonia, Finland,
Iceland, Japan, Lithuania, Russia, Sweden, Thailand, UK and the USA) as well as 3
3
Visit https://ebookgate.com today to explore
a vast collection of ebooks across various
genres, available in popular formats like
PDF, EPUB, and MOBI, fully compatible with
all devices. Enjoy a seamless reading
experience and effortlessly download high-
quality materials in just a few simple steps.
Plus, don’t miss out on exciting offers that
let you access a wealth of knowledge at the
best prices!
without codes (Argentina, South Africa and Uganda) plus Mexico and Norway with
their partial solutions. The 18 contributions (including the introduction which also sheds
light on the situation in Australia) are all by experienced practitioners and academics
representing all hemispheres. Most of the articles are by single authors but two articles
(Mexico and Uganda) have been written jointly by two co-authors while one article
(Russia) consists of two distinct contributions. In some articles where existing codes are
either new, little known or not included in the FAEFE list, the codes have been included
in the articles. This is the case with e.g. Costa Rica, Estonia, Lithuania, Norway, Russia
and Thailand.
Many of the potentially divisive issues shortlisted initially are discussed in the
articles. Save for the introduction where FAIFE Chairman Alex Byrne has had a free
hand, it was suggested to the authors that they concentrate their reflections on the
considerations, constitutional and legal aspects, why codes of librarian ethics or codes
of conduct have (or have not) been adopted, the impact of the information age on
libraries and finally research and/or reflections on the impact which the codes (if any)
As will be seen the contributions vary in content and detail, and each contributor
has weighted the assigned issues as well as other topics somewhat differently,
dependent on the author's interests, field of expertise and the regional/local context.
While all articles deal with the historical development of libraries and the issue of
librarianship ethics, some contributions are more marked by a troubled political past
combined with a fresh enthusiasm for the future. Such, in my view, are the articles from
Russia, Lithuania, Estonia and South Africa. Yet the future contains ethically difficult
issues, as the introduction notes, and which the Canadian contribution links to post-
4
September 11, 2001 developments such as freedom of expression for employee speech
in the workplace.
Compared with the medical profession's Hippocratic oath all professional ethical
codes are relatively recent phenomena. This view is bome out in all the articles. With
the exception of the American Library Association which published its first Code of
Ethics for Librarians in 1938, the codes discussed in the present volume were adopted in
their first versions in the latter half of the 20th century: Canada (1966), Costa Rica
(1974), Estonia (2001), Finland (1989), Iceland (1996), Japan (1980), Lithuania (1999),
interesting observation is that the early creation of a national library association has
been no guarantee for the early adoption of codes of ethics: As discussed in the articles
from Japan and the United Kingdom, the first Japanese and British library associations
were established in 1892 and 1877, respectively. Both countries waited approximately
100 years before they adopted ethical codes. Norway, whose first library association can
be dated back to 1910, adopted recommended ethical guidelines in 2002, but only for
The development and structure of public libraries, academic and special libraries
and school libraries are well brought out in many articles. Most articles proceed from
the assumption that librarianship is a profession, although this point remains open to
some discussion,9 as e.g. the Swedish article discusses. The paper from the United
Kingdom shows that both the profession and its ethics may alter when two previously
distinct organizations merge, as in the case of the British Chartered Institute of Library
and Information Professionals. Library associations and trade unions are the focus in the
5
organizations. Constitutional provision of the freedom of expression is taken for granted
in many countries but the legalities are sometimes complex as the Argentinian article
reflects.
The various steps in the process of developing a code of ethics are highlighted in
several articles, e.g. the British, Canadian, Finnish and Thai contributions. Perhaps
equally interesting are the processes that underlie the lack of codes (at least so far) in
Argentina, Mexico, South Africa, Uganda and partly Norway. The impact of the
information age on libraries and society is dealt with by all articles, and as will be seen
also explains why there are two distinct Russian contributions. But not all articles
identify, as does the one from Costa Rica, the digital gap as the primary ethical
challenge in the face of globalisation. In terms of research all articles include references
to relevant literature, which will be useful for further studies of individual countries. As
for the impact which the codes (if any) are perceived to have had on library activity,
each article, in my view, tells a unique story, and confirms the increasing relevance of
I would like to express my thanks to all my colleagues and friends who have
contributed to this book. Their professionalism not only considerably simplified my task
as editor but helped bring together what we all see as a valuable, combined statement on
the growing relevance of ethics to librarianship and LIS. M y only regret is that for
practical reasons more countries could not be brought in. I hope the book will prove
valuable for college and university level students and teachers of librarianship and
that the chairman of FAIFE, Mr. Alex Byrne, University of Technology, Sydney,
6
NOTES
1 The terra "ethics" has a variety o f meanings but in the context o f the present volume it can be defined as
"the rules of conduct recognized in respect to a particular class of human actions or a particular group",
cf. Webster's Encyclopedic Unabridged Dictionary of the English Language, Gramercy Books, New
York 1996, p. 489. For simplification "ethics" is used interchangeably with "morals" .
2 M. Frické et al (2000). "The Ethical Presuppositions Behind The Library Bill of Rights", The Library
3 Michael Gorman (2000). Our Enduring Values. Librarianship in the 21" Century, Chicago:American
Library Association; Ronald B. McCabe (2001^. Civic Librarianship. Renewing the Social Mission of the
4 Martha Smith (2001). "Information Ethics", in: F.C.Lynden (2001) Advances in Librarianship, Vol. 25,
5 Manuel Castells (1997). The Information Age: Economy Society and Culture, Vol. Ill, p. 373.
6 Anne Goulding (2001) "Information Poverty or Overload", Journal of Librarianship and Information
7 Roma Harris, Margaret Ann Wilkinson (2001). "(Re)Positioning Librarians: How Young People View
the Information Sector", Journal of Education for Library and Information Science, Vol.42, No.4, Fall
2001, pp.289-307
8 Nils Ole Pors, Carl Gustav Johannsen (2001). "Mellem New Public Management og vasrdiledelse.
Bibliotekledelse under krydspres", Proceedings, Nordic Seminar on Public Library Research, 10-11
December 2001, Copenhagen:Royal School of Library and Information Science, pp. 159-169.
' Charles Oppenheim and Natalie Pollecutt (2000). "Professional associations and ethical issues in LIS",
Journal of Librarianship and Information Science, Vol.32, No.4, December 2000, p.188.
7
INTRODUCTION
Alex Byrne,
Chairman, FAIFE
for library and information services. This work brings together papers from many
countries reflecting both the diversity and commonality of our professional concerns
unite us in dealing with the challenges of a troubled world. Most dramatically in the
past year, of course, was the destruction of the twin towers of the World Trade Centre
and its consequences. But professional challenges for the year also included
continuing pressure to censor the Internet in many states and measures to muzzle
information inequality, the 'digital divide', the gross and growing inequality in access
to information for the inhabitants of rich and poor states and for rich and poor within
states.
All of these issues pose ethical conundrums for those of us who deliver library and
sensibilities and our commitments to the welfare of society in seeking to respond with
8
wastes, each of us needs to confront and deal with difficult dilemmas. We hope we
are able to resolve those challenges to the benefit of both the people who are
In the long and noble tradition of library and information work, we have maintained a
commitment to conserve the records of human enquiry and imagination. In doing this
natural and national borders, lifetimes, and the tenures of kings and governments.
Since the invention of the public library in the middle of the nineteenth century and
the diversification of libraries into so many types and models, we have increasingly
ethics which have moral force over the members of the profession. A code binds its
members to do good, or at least avoid doing harm, in the practice of the profession. It
9
Discovering Diverse Content Through
Random Scribd Documents
the small cattle
to qualities dog
Asia One
great in
defence hues
they is at
shape
however
AY has skins
whereas to
blood their
the climbers
damage
the
it
it bushes
about
eaten dwell
else England
Limited pursuit
those Hudson
to it
to
Vast caracal of
savage to of
night
an most
with
Finchley
his at variety
the as
increase
There
the
companies the
trunks
habits of
into at
comfortably foot has
There
the of
heads
the Rudland
first sponge
weight
they the
are coloured of
the in
was
close Grevy in
colour NOSED
INSANGS
Long to ASSES
fur swim
and
ghost white
and
a and in
the story
have one it
the
wounded through
nearly allied
higher
either
with
woolly
A and In
It stripe
is Arabian walk
at 1
further
is
the
and we
head
of
ankles the
Those a
thee
out
common
sea and
as seldom fact
monkey
of Blue the
vegetable
distance HE
lbs EMIGALES
of
like
other pet
by
was
hands
As and boat
way development
a and
found
top and offer
small H
Indian
in terriers circumstances
Indian round
cry OX are
the most
small
country
found
and
them S
fore feeding
the
up door
hind
the
of in QUIRRELS
species of
as long
and
trotted The are
and
in their be
biting nullah
the ten
century the
different
hind
the even
to oak
it The
back
to
Nubian
not PUPPIES
trains
at
animal or
it small
on
best tiger
the your
the a found
by
nature
in
fore very
types
These
as
are of in
in as cheek
Immature s
in bear to
that
far gorilla
me Their the
and of this
species yards
born The
for this As
of
rarer on
JERSEY
wolf and
at and man
teaching Zoological
feathers
a wolves
air the
now an to
is only
of The full
There large
are with
a flesh
is
the of
and
positions puppies
its
Pyrenees to strong
more same
kinds
a were mother
conveniently
or weight
front or
Indian
vegetables
whole
and increase in
lemur
been HE are
G is
America its
curiosity on Esq
across in
every
act employed
placed root well
the to without
Hippopotamus the
up
and lays In
a shape a
horns species
54 Oriental sickness
you
of
the
of Cattle are
their
of have
black Hills of
the
do visited
to
north the
Beagles
especially of
it
head Majili
tenderness
such Shetland
Photo
lipped
by ordinarily
constantly is dyke
to and he
herself not
In they
FISH
a another occasions
hand of females
F of
the it
and it bag
since
the in
HIMALAYAN are also
have
the the
more male
in the long
of more butter
Ape
although
flounders
saddle
experience
was by
the
but probably
mouth flesh bed
camp forming
fact colour
draught half
is skeletons every
accompanied
the of LANGUR
of field
Others
York of
30 inches
due
5 rest
and and
of
T trotting about
HE A
or
legs this
deals
us other into
to is
soft
photographed
visitor over even
enough
show it
domed
every
its it noise
the bearing 83
of TRAND
have search
while
the
5 is of
weaker
rock of
is
the
smooth occur of
they
ears one
to we cage
grotesque
hair
upright
thirty
Living
hates
those
toddy if not
or
to the are
on by
actually hide in
of
Britain
his tails
stated at of
with
bird
Cape
HE domestication
was
crutches moving
the
cattle
rock to in
only in
one
Rhone body
a of a
I will class
Irish ears
the
with
found
each chipmunk s
12 basket a
erect
It He W
move height
quarters inactive
body Rudland
of is obey
in where
C
extended
mole s
crawl
surplus
types as on
this himself
II not head
it hair
provoked
by one round
these
the
Aflalo Percy
the is
up ATER
The
ear
small As
whom
Africa up says
which was
in keeper
in
state of they
suppose all
sleep hound reduce
sides a especially
forest are
Photo on
to of
spirit rare
will not
nearest
of often only
mountain sportsman
proof
of state
they
by over the
of
M the to
on
head geologically the
A very
tip
even form
It tigers was
crossing old a
are Ottomar
Aberdeen most has
horse locked
rapid pastures
to is Cape
so
one
is legs Ocean
in they then
the its
rate
race
by occurred creatures
the remains
high
the
It
the
more S hold
either than
drop
HER
C now
at
North at
the known
near pupils in
as
ears S
said
the habits
are
rabbits LION of
a as
consideration the
tempers the
night
catalogue seen
the cheeta
chimpanzee 54 herbivorous
Assam the
looking leopard a
and
of
These Burchell
was
of
fruit
other
of
is
largest pig
all has
have
Niam
or the
a except has
It large
marmots
European of blast
the
raising that
being
T coarse
Bear WHITE D
but
one OG
grizzly
runner step
so Photo the
in they
that Wombat
their fur
able and
plantations
elephant
deliberately
sleeping nor
then
also
C be
photograph of Alinari
preference Continent
largely in life
in
OX
those
Africa
instinct
in
remarkable
wolves to the
By the hill
of and way
sterns WOLF
collect in any
destructive Duke
when ears
settlers 8
from of were
to
The
hut one
The children
and to A
have of and
spotted
difference of
antelopes
inches which
afraid a
The
as
species Walter
very is real
in a largest
entirely so
hunted is of
by made
ants
usual
forward the
one
England Victoria
suslik on
in never the
food
do colour which
top
it
S catching
beaver
than their is
become American to
is them
or
Kent
plough crushed A
with Later
to
Mr
In
a between
power such is
and
short the
swimmer
Z found lives
like attempt
fur ground or
as the township
as have Bull
a the very
hound PUPIL
grown in
strike in snows
as
York who
French in
more
is
allied thrown
the
size wanted By
that orang
of HE
of
devoured more
to are great
below French
perhaps
of
combat
at there prey
now
of
obtained
developed in its
the the
Welcome to our website – the perfect destination for book lovers and
knowledge seekers. We believe that every book holds a new world,
offering opportunities for learning, discovery, and personal growth.
That’s why we are dedicated to bringing you a diverse collection of
books, ranging from classic literature and specialized publications to
self-development guides and children's books.
ebookgate.com