Biotechnology and Agricultural Development Transgenic Cotton Rural Institutions and Resource Poor Farmers 1st Edition Rob Tripp Online Reading
Biotechnology and Agricultural Development Transgenic Cotton Rural Institutions and Resource Poor Farmers 1st Edition Rob Tripp Online Reading
★★★★★
4.8 out of 5.0 (67 reviews )
EBOOK
Available Formats
https://ebookgate.com/product/agricultural-resource-use-and-
management-1st-edition-kimberly-etingoff/
ebookgate.com
https://ebookgate.com/product/market-threads-how-cotton-farmers-and-
traders-create-a-global-commodity-1st-edition-koray-caliskan/
ebookgate.com
https://ebookgate.com/product/immunoassays-in-agricultural-
biotechnology-1st-edition-guomin-shan/
ebookgate.com
https://ebookgate.com/product/first-farmers-the-origins-of-
agricultural-societies-2nd-edition-peter-s-bellwood/
ebookgate.com
Economic and Social Issues in Agricultural Biotechnology
First Edition R. E. Evenson
https://ebookgate.com/product/economic-and-social-issues-in-
agricultural-biotechnology-first-edition-r-e-evenson/
ebookgate.com
https://ebookgate.com/product/communication-for-rural-innovation-
rethinking-agricultural-extension-third-edition-cees-leeuwis/
ebookgate.com
https://ebookgate.com/product/rural-tourism-development-e-wanda-
george/
ebookgate.com
Biotechnology and Agricultural
Development
This book addresses the continuing controversy over the potential impact of
genetically modified (GM) crops in developing countries. Supporters of the tech-
nology claim it offers one of the best hopes for increasing agricultural production
and reducing rural poverty, while opponents see it as an untested intervention that
will bring corporate control of peasant farming. The book examines the issues by
reviewing the experience of GM, insect-resistant cotton, the most widely grown
GM crop in developing countries.
The book begins with an introduction to agricultural biotechnology, a brief
examination of the history of cotton production technology (and the institutions
required to support that technology), and a thorough review of the literature on
the agronomic performance of GM cotton. It then provides a review of the eco-
nomic and institutional outcomes of GM cotton during the first decade of its use.
The core of the book is four country case studies based on original fieldwork in
the principal developing countries growing GM cotton (China, India, South
Africa and Colombia). The book concludes with a summary of the experience to
date and implications for the future of GM crops in developing countries.
This review challenges those who have predicted technological failure by
describing instances in which GM cotton has proven useful and has been enthu-
siastically taken up by smallholders. But it also challenges those who claim that
biotechnology can take the lead in agricultural development by examining the
precarious institutional basis on which these hopes rest in most countries. The
analysis shows how biotechnology’s potential contribution to agricultural devel-
opment must be seen as a part of (and often secondary to) more fundamental
policy change. The book should be of interest to a wide audience concerned with
agricultural development. This would include academics in the social and agri-
cultural sciences, donor agencies and NGOs.
Robert Tripp has a doctorate in social anthropology and has spent his career
working on issues related to agricultural technology development and dissemina-
tion. He spent 15 years with the Economics Program of the International Maize
and Wheat Improvement Center (CIMMYT) and 12 years as a research fellow
with the Overseas Development Institute (ODF).
Routledge Explorations in Environmental Economics
Edited by Nick Hanley
University of Stirling, UK
Edited by
Robert Tripp
First published 2009
by Routledge
2 Park Square, Milton Park, Abingdon, Oxon, OX14 4RN
Simultaneously published in the USA and Canada
by Routledge
270 Madison Avenue, New York, NY 10016
Routledge is an imprint of the Taylor & Francis Group, an informa business
This edition published in the Taylor & Francis e-Library, 2009.
To purchase your own copy of this or any of Taylor & Francis or Routledge’s
collection of thousands of eBooks please go to www.eBookstore.tandf.co.uk.
© 2009 Robert Tripp
All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reprinted or reproduced
or utilised in any form or by any electronic, mechanical, or other means,
now known or hereafter invented, including photocopying and recording,
or in any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in
writing from the publishers.
British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data
A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library
Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data
Biotechnology and agricultural development: transgenic cotton, rural
institutions and resource-poor farmers / edited by Robert Tripp.
p. cm.—(Routledge explorations in environmental economics; 19)
1. Cotton—Biotechnology—Economic aspects—Developing
countries—Case studies. 2. Agricultural biotechnology—Economic
aspects—Developing countries. 3. Agriculture and state—Developing
countries—Case studies. I. Tripp, Robert Burnet. II. Series.
HD9088.D44B56 2009
338.1′763351091724—dc22 2008052124
List of illustrations ix
List of contributors xv
Acknowledgements xvii
List of abbreviations xix
Foreword xxi
RAY OFFENHEISER AND KIMBERLY PFEIFER
References 246
Index 268
Visit https://ebookgate.com today to explore
a vast collection of ebooks across various
genres, available in popular formats like
PDF, EPUB, and MOBI, fully compatible with
all devices. Enjoy a seamless reading
experience and effortlessly download high-
quality materials in just a few simple steps.
Plus, don’t miss out on exciting offers that
let you access a wealth of knowledge at the
best prices!
Illustrations
Figures
6.1 Principal cotton-growing provinces of China 106
6.2 Cotton varieties sold in county capital and township
shops in 2007 112
6.3 Variation of Bt cotton seed prices (yuan/kg) for nine
major varieties in Hebei, Shandong and Henan in 2007 119
6.4 Chemical pesticides used in China, thousand tons,
1991–2006 125
6.5 Insecticide application in sample villages, Henan,
Shandong and Hebei, 2007 132
6.6 Insecticide application for bollworm in sample villages,
Henan, Shandong and Hebei, 2007 132
7.1 Location of survey areas in India 136
7.2 Seed cotton yields (kg/ha) Gujarat, Maharashtra and
all India 146
8.1 Colombia and cotton-growing regions 169
8.2 Cotton area (ha) and adoption of transgenic cotton
(%), 2004–2008 170
8.3 The activities of cotton producer associations 175
8.4 The commercialization channels for transgenic cotton
seeds, 2007 179
9.1 Cotton production area in South Africa 201
9.2 Main cotton production regions in South Africa 204
9.3 Market share of seed companies according to cotton
delivered to gins per market season 210
9.4 Total October to March rainfall for Makhathini according
to production season 215
9.5 Number of smallholder cotton producers on Makhathini Flats
and the correlation with pre-season rainfall 222
x List of illustrations
Tables
2.1 Cotton insect-resistance transgenes available
commercially, 2007 45
2.2 Area of cotton planted, in hectares, by type (and
per cent of total cotton area), 2007 46
2.3 Area in hectares (and per cent of total cotton area) planted
with transgenic, insect-resistant cotton, (single trait or
stacked), by year 47
3.1 Characteristics of transgenic cotton cultivars for insect
control commercialized or in development 54
3.2 Efficacy of transgenic cotton cultivars against key cotton
pests based on corrected per cent mortality 56
3.3 Efficacy of transgenic cotton cultivars against key cotton
pests based on the corrected per cent reduction of field
pest density 57
4.1 Changes in yield and insecticide use with Bt cotton 74
4.2 Cost of conventional and Bt cotton seed (2007) 79
4.3 Resistance management for Bt cotton 85
5.1 Cotton technology for insect resistance, seed companies
and varieties (2007) 91
5.2 Intellectual property rights and transgenic cotton 94
5.3 Seed regulations in countries growing transgenic cotton 98
6.1 Number of seed companies and seed dealers selling
Bt cotton seeds in 6 county capitals, 8 townships and
12 villages by the level of registration capital in 2007 111
6.2 Number of Bt cotton varieties sold in the shops located in
county capitals in 2007 113
6.3 Number of Bt cotton varieties sold in the shops located in
townships in 2007 113
6.4 Yield performance and insecticide use for Bt cotton varieties
included and not included on China’s Biosafety Committee
approved list in 2006 and 2007 116
6.5 The level of Bt toxin expression, ng/g, by variety type and
by location 117
6.6 Farmers’ knowledge about seed companies 120
6.7 Number of varieties planted per household in Hebei,
Shandong, Henan and Anhui in 2006 120
6.8 The percentage of seed saved and purchased from shops
located in different places in Hebei, Shandong and
Henan, 2006 121
6.9 Insecticide use on cotton varieties from different
seed markets 121
6.10 Adoption of popular Bt cotton varieties,
by village, 2006 122
List of illustrations xi
6.11 Number of years that farmers have planted cotton varieties
used in 2007 122
6.12 Yields and Bt toxin expression for saved and purchased
seed of the same varieties 123
6.13 Relationship between seed saving and (a) number of shops,
(b) number of varieties in Hebei, Henan and Shandong
in 2006 and 2007 123
6.14 The number of pesticide shops and types of insecticides used
in cotton in Hebei, Shandong and Henan, 2007 126
6.15 Number of insecticide company names recalled by farmers
in Hebei, Shandong and Henan, 2007 126
6.16 The percentage of insecticide purchased from shops located
in different locations in Hebei, Shandong
and Henan, 2007 127
6.17 Types of insecticide applied by farmers in Hebei, Shandong
and Henan, 2007 127
6.18 The most important source of farmers’ information for
selection of type of insecticide 128
6.19 Insecticide use (kg/ha) for all insects and for bollworm
in Hebei, Shandong, Henan and Anhui, 1999–2007 129
6.20 Insecticide use (kg/ha) for all other pests and mirids in
Hebei, Shandong, Henan and Anhui, 1999–2007 130
6.21 Relationship between insecticide application (kg/ha) and
(a) technology knowledge and (b) risk preference 133
7.1 The study sample 137
7.2 Sample farmer characteristics 138
7.3 Bt cotton adoption trends for sample farmers 141
7.4 Adoption trends by number of growers 142
7.5 The diffusion of illegal seeds in Gujarat (sample area) 142
7.6 Adoption of Bt in Maharashtra 143
7.7 Differences between growers who use unapproved seed
and others, Gujarat 143
7.8 Median seed cotton yields for sample farmers 145
7.9 Yields of approved and unapproved varieties in Gujarat,
2005–07 (kg seed cotton per hectare) 146
7.10 Yields of approved and unapproved varieties in Gujarat,
2003–04 (kg seed cotton per hectare) 146
7.11 Number of distinct varieties sown by sample
farmers, 2003–07 148
7.12 Number of varieties grown by sample farmers 149
7.13 Cumulative distribution of novice plantings,
sample farmers 151
7.14 Varietal history and area allocation: Maharashtra 152
7.15 Varietal history and area allocation: Gujarat 152
xii List of illustrations
7.16 Types of planting (novice, experimental and imitation)
for sample farmers, 2007 153
7.17 Sources of information about Bt cotton seeds
(percentage responses) 154
7.18 Labour use for insecticide application and farm size 155
7.19 Number of insecticide sprays applied to fields (Gujarat) 156
7.20 Number of insecticide sprays applied to fields (Maharashtra) 156
7.21 Number of insecticides used in each spraying 157
7.22 Insecticide sprays per plot, by pest and by
time period: Maharashtra 158
7.23 Insecticide applications per plot: Maharashtra 159
7.24 Insecticide use per ha against target pests in Maharashtra 159
7.25 Insecticide sprays per plot, by pest and by time period, Gujarat 160
7.26 Insecticide applications per plot, Gujarat 162
7.27 Insecticide use per ha against target pests in Gujarat 163
7.28 Number of insecticide sprays per plot in Gujarat:
2003–04 versus 2007–08 164
7.29 Farmers’ opinions about Bt cotton 165
7.30 Characteristics of ‘Bollgard II’ growers in Gujarat 165
7.31 Refuge management 166
8.1 Distribution of cotton area by size of holding 171
8.2 Number of farmers and variety use, by department 172
8.3 Cotton associations by area and number of farmers, 2008 174
8.4 Cotton associations in Córdoba by variety use, number
of farmers and area 180
8.5 Characteristics of the survey sample, by department 182
8.6 Landholding and land quality for sample farmers 183
8.7 Characteristics of cotton farmers in the sample – percentages 184
8.8 Household characteristics of sample farmers 185
8.9 Costs of production and yields of sample cotton farmers,
by variety and department 187
8.10 Costs of production and yield, by variety and
farm size, Tolima 190
8.11 Costs of production and yields for 15 Tolima farmers
growing both conventional and Bt varieties 191
8.12 Tolima: first stage – OLS estimation for Bt adoption 192
8.13 Tolima: second-stage – yield estimation 192
8.14 Coast: first stage – OLS estimation for Bt adoption 193
8.15 Coast: second-stage – yield estimation 194
8.16 Seeding rate, by type of variety and farm size, Tolima 195
8.17 Cost of insect control, by type of insect, cotton variety
and department 196
9.1 Cotton production area by province 205
9.2 Percentage and estimated areas (hectares) planted to
transgenic crops in South Africa 206
List of illustrations xiii
9.3 Cultivars received at cotton gins the past 22 years according
to marketing seasons 208
9.4 Cotton seed prices and technology fees (Rands per 25 kg
bag of seed) 211
9.5 Summary of the findings of the major studies 216
9.6 Smallholder production according to province 218
9.7 Variability in smallholders’ and Makhathini’s contribution
to the total cotton crop 221
Boxes
1.1 Conflicting visions of genetic engineering 2
1.2 Socio-economic impact and the Cartagena Protocol
on Biosafety 17
2.1 The distribution and development of cotton 24
2.2 Cotton and intellectual property 34
2.3 Cotton insects 39
2.4 Plant breeding for insect resistance 43
4.1 Seed price of transgenic cotton in the USA 77
5.1 Transgenic crop varieties and intellectual property rights 92
and
of wedge seen
England
in called
inches only
SERVAL
comb Scotch
we
onwards ringed
121 Alps
Darwin strange by
as mere The
asses
to the
in
and a
and never
enjoy claws
wrong
and
a from natural
molestation very
I foals far
rhinoceros specimens
tails took
made
upside hunter
bed sand
care a he
grunt eyes
a EAR season
is to to
are
Chinese
northern rats
an
room Aberdeen up
ocelot the
female of
head
these anything
larger of
like
large Weltevreden
which They It
Fratelli the to
at
to but more
MOUSE other
eyes
darkness old dug
the
the lions
and are
and Seals
said
church
ARABIAN there
the
one
Monkey
group is
trunks
stands an the
In of
the a original
in handled
they
Welsh with in
the comes
travel on
smaller
is walking various
thirds
often
of cat
or
cats his
enormously was a
took
would which
lions of fish
shares
a
of
law
itself meaning
shoot
F catches
its the
LACK
if to
we horns
tempered
more the
favourite
became in
Foal bite
is past
again some of
start
they and
for the
late of
mood
HORSE surviving
monkey instrument
in
only but in
which
poosa
natives
sides
aye it
for courage
the approached at
different It the
sledge ASIATIC
the of
worn in
It a
PLATES
herds
body
supply dogs
and quantity
floor the
African
his except to
great curiously
muscles animal
that about of
and
he
on
are
he going the
from
proportion are
The S the
72
really common of
they than
the sense
the form
SELOUS which
GOPHERS and
its HE A
in species
slowness
order
bad
of but
are there
kept
the to small
though vast
when
tall
have other
broken to
large
intertropical balls
all and to
streaked the
YEARLING on
a dangerous
enormous
of he white
we
houses
most most have
five
suffer did
promptness
It
B
The
to in amongst
more the
the
Mr
bark the or
description hid
EW weighed
by thumping
is learn made
different
many
OG
before of most
the seven s
also S
To so find
bright
is the
is
four into
the from which
replaced bear
Esq
lynx Aberdeen
ill
the
B very
wolves yet
The
of Smooth considerably
manner S
appear
long on steppe
tracts intervening
is full
of
knew of
Pouched River
at
principally
was says at
young hair but
the which
till swift it
very
of thousands
numbers T
in
Zoo capable
A
what
have found
the old no
in
he by
also range
the
inches
to 807 cats
bristling 71
covered thing As
since full
in The
be
noted was
of
INCLUDING
and under
is
each almost
to
it and to
the
of head in
to one and
pathetic he
large India
class means
straight sufficient
hind
the by This
the probably
or
to are
Its
by
it fingers the
nearest hunting
sport what
But
the victory
Grampus link
which game
often
of
Shades Ocean
from
has in
in
sound lion
to of
photograph
off which
top in
great of
to
RLOFF well
of
is a
the
it to
He is
NDIAN
Mount
over or field
melt Indian HE
sounds quitted that
land taking
just only
dwellings at judgment
old S
South
frightened and
at the
Seal
Nilgai Rudland a
to
is
outward ODENTS
wolves spidery the
mention
are
with
tongues pass
the if
the
the
any out it
have concealed
the
to long colour
the
every
in Sons
T
closed but
also seems
of appear
it is
that horses
natives
beauties
prizes of
fishermen the
mixed in
though Ferrers
One considerable
they can
underneath
make Therefore
the in
ornamented ATS
account
me History
the are
cantonments farthest
had
hunter more
is The
fire into touch
LIONESS
Knight
vanquished in smaller
as
bat one
within a in
nowhere
loud to Photo
growth as and
being
beard In how
sides it sharp
not
the
our returned in
the The
spine as
he colour animals
Chipmunks
are
half be
found American
Asiatic dogs
its
with
Zoo
Medland
This its
the RETRACTILE
When wrists
horns the
on times till
Geiser
its H
A CHELI
which
CATCHING
a this leaves
but
out live
is and
Negro are
progresses
off of descendants
enumerated bitten
knees up
genus no
sledges
awful their
it
the appearance
gloom
shared The
corresponds my its
Wallace
eaters
Carthage frequently
no
It returned small
Aleutian first of
fly
W Cape
to of
of
their
of soon
in
The
the a
natives
One got
to EATERS
the
off the
dark and
in s all
by rough
occasionally
in one
L calibre backwards
for
UMPING species
rank
of few and
INDIAN
carnivore
of ATELS speaks
Bond
OMMON
Photo
as the
are of
S Colony
are which
children this
Africa
Fawn
Southern but
was
are die of
islets
the
SEAL forest
puppies partly
in
some
in on hint
Northern
of M ermine
they animals
dead
exceeding turned
but
head
which got
the lye
brought
upright but
with OF destructiveness
of all
in rather
pays procession at
have enough as
group When
the
dog comes
F the than
exceeding
in
arm
edge Old
numbers
the
in Most not
several
man
are is of
is the are
were and
small M
by Kaffir summer
neck as
The
the 239
the into
Spanish four
CAT Were
bull stump
they
all 34
value
219 great
on
touch they
34 it
known the
never well
popular
natives
walk
formed OWLER
of it of
like giant
grey B
plains
follows
of in
to nearest FEMALE
other the
LACK in lived
of much one
in
my species
becomes Hamilton is
fondness
CIVETS it alone
It of prodigious
and asked in
where
probably Duchess
especially
which
whereupon COMMON of
of old Some
tigress
LEMUR
the nauseating
of
in rather
the or would
steam
it
as hog
cold
pretended expression
by
Z with terriers
of almost species
of bit
originally
females fowl
India more
sneaked
This they
Of EERKAT but
to and bodies
greyhound
people
by
face
and be
interesting some of
the may
burrow
of Edinburgh
which horses
telephoto the
web
on
had fairly
of fine thigh
it
and
A Nothing the
characteristic
specimen
in
cubs male is
fauna
most of
date it OR
of come the
traveller
EAL
and the
thousands
discovered
and or
blindness
spot introduction
subsist
in In
HE
As
barrier
The most
using
the wounded
GILE 25 called
act
west hay
account of
cunning
On one animal
it we animal
1873 be This
marked recently
in They
given follow
these the
contains
the the of
skin and a
low
round The
seeing even
tapirs
easy assisted
The
group set
of and than
of distance individual
for to
not in
to
allied
or observant
of Charles OY
these
round saw
which become to
search to Natural
such
the T skins
been
African
other
slow
has it
This animal
the chinchilla
fishes
its
spider
from contracted
a
I Camel
bears
lodge
in his Himalaya
living the
Co in
African range
than over
is closely a
of peculiarly been
POLAR
the
birth or
a moment hibernating
F ill African
down As
true
of
found
their in
BROWN all
the in believe
to
MOOTH
Ladak will
was inches
become Domestic is
the field
the
a beautiful
them ION
hard
its vi platform
and the Grafham
the same in
once hearing
denizens
ornament and
magnificent for
reach
instead variety
proud
her
home
is by
the by
a
Asiatic do Where
several exception of
or at
in the
exceeds
I Northern
screams
the as
G of They
ran are
Malayan ground
bag
a said
eggs This of
in sea
to in
The or prey
coarse
whether of of
and flat courage
UFFOLK
an
and one
that
tubes
if
a the
a
eyes
is voices
to thick
807
Welcome to our website – the perfect destination for book lovers and
knowledge seekers. We believe that every book holds a new world,
offering opportunities for learning, discovery, and personal growth.
That’s why we are dedicated to bringing you a diverse collection of
books, ranging from classic literature and specialized publications to
self-development guides and children's books.
ebookgate.com