Rethinking LGBTQIA Students and Collegiate Contexts Identity Policies and Campus Climate 1st Edition Eboni M. Zamani-Gallaher Complete Edition
Rethinking LGBTQIA Students and Collegiate Contexts Identity Policies and Campus Climate 1st Edition Eboni M. Zamani-Gallaher Complete Edition
Available at ebookname.com
https://ebookname.com/product/rethinking-lgbtqia-students-and-
collegiate-contexts-identity-policies-and-campus-climate-1st-
edition-eboni-m-zamani-gallaher/
★★★★★
4.7 out of 5.0 (21 reviews )
EBOOK
Available Formats
https://ebookname.com/product/rethinking-christian-identity-doctrine-
and-discipleship-1st-edition-medi-ann-volpe/
ebookname.com
https://ebookname.com/product/cultural-tourism-and-identity-
rethinking-indigeneity-1st-edition-keyan-g-tomaselli/
ebookname.com
https://ebookname.com/product/rethinking-climate-change-research-
clean-technology-culture-and-communication-pernille-almlund/
ebookname.com
https://ebookname.com/product/tissue-engineering-and-artificial-
organs-3rd-ed-edition-joseph-d-bronzino/
ebookname.com
Sarbanes Oxley Internal Controls Effective Auditing with
AS5 CobiT and ITIL 1st Edition Robert Moeller
https://ebookname.com/product/sarbanes-oxley-internal-controls-
effective-auditing-with-as5-cobit-and-itil-1st-edition-robert-moeller/
ebookname.com
https://ebookname.com/product/material-hermeneutics-reversing-the-
linguistic-turn-1st-edition-don-ihde/
ebookname.com
https://ebookname.com/product/modern-computational-finance-scripting-
for-derivatives-and-xva-1st-edition-antoine-savine/
ebookname.com
https://ebookname.com/product/satellite-communications-systems-
engineering-1st-edition-louis-joseph-ippolito-jr/
ebookname.com
https://ebookname.com/product/wordpress-genius-guide-coll/
ebookname.com
The Primeval Flood Catastrophe Origins and Early
Development in Mesopotamian Traditions 1st Edition Y. S.
Chen
https://ebookname.com/product/the-primeval-flood-catastrophe-origins-
and-early-development-in-mesopotamian-traditions-1st-edition-y-s-chen/
ebookname.com
“The book you hold provides some insight and direction into how
postsecondary educators, scholars, and students might understand this
moment in the history of LGBTQIA students in higher education. This
book both helps explain this paradoxical moment in LGBTQIA student
experiences in higher education and helps move the research and prac-
tice further into a new moment.”
—From the Foreword by Kristen A. Renn,
Michigan State University, USA
“I encourage you to… re-engage what you think you know about
LGBTQIA students and the topics of sexuality and gender in general.
The chapters in this book offer great opportunities to do so.”
—From the Afterword by Dafina-Lazarus Stewart,
Colorado State University, USA
RETHINKING LGBTQIA
STUDENTS AND
COLLEGIATE CONTEXTS
Identity, Policies, and Campus
Climate
Typeset in Bembo
by Taylor & Francis Books
CONTENTS
Foreword vii
Kristen A. Renn
Preface: Reflecting on Identity, Reframing Policies, and
Reshaping Higher Education x
Eboni M. Zamani-Gallaher
Acknowledgements xviii
PART I
Rethinking LGBTQIA Identity 1
1 Multiplicity of LGBTQ+ Identities, Intersections, and
Complexities 3
Devika Dibya Choudhuri and Kate Curley
2 How Intersex Identities Shape Sex and Gender: What’s at
Stake in Postsecondary Education? 17
Kari J. Dockendorff
3 Gender, Kinship, and Student Services: A Dialogue Centering
Trans Narratives in Higher Education 27
Jason C. Garvey, Benjamin C. Kennedy, Soren Dews, and
Rachel Greene
4 Exploring the Experiences of LGBTQIA+ Collegians with
Disabilities: Maybe I Exist 45
Amanda A. Bell
vi Contents
PART II
Rethinking Contexts 59
5 Assessing the Classroom “Space” for LTBTQ+ Students 61
Jason L. Taylor
6 Asexual Student Invisibility and Erasure in Higher Education:
“I Thought I Was The Only One” 78
Amanda L. Mollet and Brian Lackman
7 Revealing the Potential for Historically Black Colleges and
Universities to be Liberatory Environments for Queer
Students: (Re)Centering the Narrative 99
Steve D. Mobley, Trinice McNally, and Gretchen T. Moore
8 LGBTQ+ Matters and the Community College: Policy and
Program Considerations for Students, Faculty, and Staff 120
Melvin Whitehead and Needham Yancey Gulley
PART III
Rethinking Policies and Possibilities 135
9 Challenging Complicity and Institutional Racism: The Role
of Critical White Queer Academics 137
Paul W. Eaton
10 Trickle Up Policy-Building: Envisioning Possibilities for
Trans*formative Change in Postsecondary Education 153
Kari Dockendorff, Megan Nanney, and Z Nicolazzo
11 Trans QuantCrit: An Invitation to a ThirdSpace for Higher
Education Quantitative Researchers 169
Kate Curley
12 Ending Allies through the Eradication of the Ally (Industrial)
Complex 186
Dian D. Squire
Afterword 204
D-L Stewart
Contributors 208
Index 216
FOREWORD
It is a pivotal moment for LGBTQIA college students, the educators who work
with them, and the scholars who conduct write about them. In the 1980s and
1990s, student activists paved the way for increased visibility, LGBT campus
resource centers, and more inclusive policies (Marine, 2011). Related movements
off campus have contributed to substantial advances in public policy including non-
discrimination laws, hate crimes protection, and marriage equality. Campus climate
and societal attitudes about LGBTQIA people have improved over time as well
(Garvey, Sanders, & Flint, 2017; Smith, Son, & Kim, 2014). Overall, the experi-
ence of LGBTQIA college students is likely to be better now than it was 30 years
ago. Yet, progress has not been uniform across all institutions, regions, or identity
groups within the LGBTQIA student population. Homophobia, transphobia,
racism, sexism, ableism, and other forms of oppression, discrimination, and violence
act differently across the diversity of LGBTQIA college students. For some
LGBTQIA students, it might as well still be 1990 – or 1950. Paradoxically, college
is both better than ever and as bad as, in some cases worse, than it has ever been for
LGBTQIA college students.
How did higher education get to this place? Ten years ago, I summarized the
state and status of LGBT research in higher education and concluded that there
was a solid foundation of campus climate literature, narrative exposition of a
variety of LGBT student experiences, and theoretical explorations of sexual
orientation identity development (Renn, 2010). The visibility and campus cli-
mate literatures were essential in providing support for campus activists, educators,
and leaders to establish the kinds of LGBTQIA-friendly policies, programs, and
services that now exist on many campuses. Many a “blue ribbon report” on
LGBT campus climate ended with a recommendation to establish an LGBT
campus resource center, for example (Marine, 2011), and provision of other
viii Foreword
forms of support evolved out of student visibility actions and national campaigns
to improve campus climate. Following the emergence of this work in the 1990s
and early 2000s, media, social media, and digital information sources have accel-
erated changes in public opinion about LGBT rights (Ayoub & Garretson, 2017),
which in turn advance campus efforts to improve climate.
In 2010, I also called for additional research with and about diverse populations
within LGBTQIA communities of students minoritized by sexual orientation and
gender identity. Following a trend in research on college student identities and
experiences, personal narratives and studies of intersecting identities have explo-
ded and brought into focus the richness, complexity, contradictions, and cultural
wealth of LGBTQIA students’ lives (for a review of some of this literature, see
Duran, 2018). Certainly there is evidence of thriving across communities of
LGBTQIA students who hold multiple minoritized identities, but the combined
effects of multiple oppressive systems can amplify marginalization in ways that are
especially harmful to student learning, well-being, psychosocial development, and
college success. For these LGBTQIA students, the college experience today is as
alienating as it was when studies of campus climate were just beginning.
The book you hold provides some insight and direction into how postsecondary
educators, scholars, and students might understand this moment in the history of
LGBTQIA students in higher education. In it you can read about the experiences
of students who have until now been made to remain largely invisible: LGBTQIA
students with disabilities, asexual students, intersex students, and LGBTQIA stu-
dents at Historically Black Colleges and Universities (HBCUs) and community
colleges. You can also read about how educators, researchers, and policy makers
can do something to improve the college experience for LGBTQIA students in the
classroom, through research, and through policy at community colleges and other
institutions. This book both helps explain this paradoxical moment in LGBTQIA
student experiences in higher education and helps move the research and practice
further into a new moment.
What might a new moment for LGBTQIA students in higher education look
like? I suggest that it could look like educators and researchers taking seriously the
individuality and the collectivity of LGBTQIA students, embedded in local and
societal contexts of support, love, and care. It could look like facing down and dis-
mantling the forces within and outside higher education that continue to assemble
against trans and non-binary students. It could look like identifying and standing up
to racism and white supremacy and the ways that they act to dehumanize LGBTQIA
people of color. It could look like providing basic needs – healthcare, housing, and
food security – to all students because there is clear evidence that trans people and
students of color are among the most likely to lack them and thus be dis-
proportionately affected (Gates, 2014). By taking a comprehensive approach that
addresses academic, social, and personal wellbeing, postsecondary educators can take
a lead in creating this new moment for LGBTQIA students. There is no need to wait
another 10 or 20 or 30 years to get to a place where all LGBTQIA students can
Visit https://ebookname.com today to explore
a vast collection of ebooks across various
genres, available in popular formats like
PDF, EPUB, and MOBI, fully compatible with
all devices. Enjoy a seamless reading
experience and effortlessly download high-
quality materials in just a few simple steps.
Plus, don’t miss out on exciting offers that
let you access a wealth of knowledge at the
best prices!
Foreword ix
thrive; students like those described throughout this book need a more equitable
higher education today. It is time, as the book title indicates, to rethink who
LGBTQIA college students are and how higher education can structure itself to
support them. As educators and researchers, we know enough to do better. I urge us
to begin now.
Kristen A. Renn
Michigan State University
References
Ayoub, P. M., & Garretson, J. (2017). Getting the message out: Media context and global
changes in attitudes toward homosexuality. Comparative Political Studies, 50(8), 1055–1085.
Duran, A. (2018). Queer and of color: A systematic literature review on queer students of
color in higher education scholarship. Journal of Diversity in Higher Education. Advance
online publication. doi:10.1037/dhe0000084
Garvey, J. C., Sanders, L. A., & Flint, M. A. (2017). Generational perceptions of campus climate
among LGBTQ undergraduates. Journal of College Student Development, 58(6), 795–817.
Gates, G. (2014). LGBT People are disproportionately food insecure. Los Angeles, CA: The
Williams Institute on Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity Law and Public Policy,
UCLA School of Law. Retrieved from https://escholarship.org/uc/item/4wt4102n
Marine, S. B. (2011). Stonewall’s legacy: Bisexual, gay, lesbian, and transgender students in
higher education. ASHE Higher Education Report, 37(4).
Renn, K. A. (2010). LGBT and queer research in higher education: The state and status of
the field. Educational Researcher, 39(2), 132–141.
Smith, T. W., Son, J., & Kim, J. (2014). Public attitudes towards homosexuality and gay rights
across time and countries. Los Angeles, CA: The Williams Institute on Sexual Orientation
and Gender Identity Law and Public Policy, UCLA School of Law. Retrieved from http
s://williamsinstitute.law.ucla.edu/wp-content/uploads/public-attitudes-nov-2014.pdf
PREFACE: REFLECTING ON IDENTITY,
REFRAMING POLICIES, AND
RESHAPING HIGHER EDUCATION
An Introduction to Rethinking LGBTQIA Students
and Collegiate Contexts
Eboni M. Zamani-Gallaher
The extant literature has long noted that student identity development is multi-
dimensional and critical to college matriculation, satisfaction, persistence, and
degree completion (Chickering & Reisser, 1993; Evans, Forney, Guido, Patton,
& Renn, 2009; Torres, Howard-Hamilton, & Cooper, 2003). However,
LGBTQIA students are a demographic that has been historically at the margins of
full participation in many higher education settings (Green & Croom, 2000;
Renn, 2010; Sanlo, 2012; Zamani-Gallaher & Choudhuri, 2011). Students
identifying as LGBTQIA on campus may experience unwelcoming college
environments or hostile hallways depending on the context. In addition,
LGBTQIA students are not a monolithic group but representative of a diverse array
of individuals cutting across the spectrum of difference. There are obvious distinc-
tions among the LGBTQIA population (e.g., age, gender, ethnicity, physicality,
race, religion, social class, etc.), however little is known about the convergence of
various identities in the lives of LGBTQIA students and their development in and
out of the classroom across institutional settings (Dodge & Crutcher, 2015; Irazábal
& Huerta, 2016; Taylor, Dockendorff, & Inselman, 2018; Zamani-Gallaher &
Choudhuri, 2016). Hence, this text seeks to contribute to advancing the literature
on LGBTQIA collegians in two- and four-year environments drawing on the
extant research and practice for engaging student learning development outcomes
and bolstering student support services.
Despite national goals of providing equal access quality of life, the actualization
of this vision requires organizational structures and institutional policies that
address the chilly campus climates. Many LGBTQIA students face high incidents
of heterosexism, bullying, inadequate levels of resources and support, isolation or
alienation, stereotyping, as well as safety concerns among other issues due to
being openly gay on campus (Rankin, 1998, 2013; Rhoads, 1997; Seelman,
Preface: Reflecting on Identity, Reframing Policies, and Reshaping Higher Education xi
Woodford, & Nicolazzo, 2017; Sutter & Perrin, 2016; Stewart, Renn, & Bra-
zelton, 2015). Consequently, there are unique challenges for LGBTQIA students
whereby their success can be enhanced by improved sensitivity, encouragement,
academic/social support, as well as favorable institutional policies and practices.
Sexuality is an important aspect of adult life. In lieu of creating greater aware-
ness and understanding regarding LGBTQIA adult learners, this text aims to
present the complexity of issues and areas for opportunity in serving the academic
and social need of LGBTQIA collegians. This book seeks to disseminate practi-
tioner-scholarship that draws on relevant theoretical frameworks (e.g., will assist
the reader in gauging how faculty, academic affairs and student affairs profes-
sionals can identify challenges, foster opportunities, and create strategies for pro-
moting student development and success for this historically underserved student
population). Moreover, this volume blends both theory and practice in offering a
collaborative model designed to the effectiveness of services, programs, policies,
and best practices for positive, engaging postsecondary contexts across the spec-
trum of difference.
Nearly half of self-identified gay and bisexual college students became aware of
their sexual identity in high school while roughly one quarter discovered their
sexuality in college. Sexual identity development for both heterosexual and
LGBTQIA collegians is a multidimensional and complex process that is subject to
transitions that may not follow any linear path (Worthington et al., 2002).
Coming out is not a time-limited defined process that is achieved for anybody.
However, the collegiate experience, whether attending a two-year or four-year
institution, is often a significant space in which students explore aspects of their
identity both through their academic and co-curricular experiences. Twenty
percent of self-identified gay and bisexual college men knew that they were gay
or bisexual in junior high school while 17% reported knowing in grade school.
Six percent of self-identified gay and bisexual female collegians knew that they
were gay or bisexual in junior high school and 11% knew in grade school
(Kosciw, Greytak, Palmer, & Boesen, 2013). There has been little that provides a
comprehensive guide to assist higher education administrators in responding
effectively to the needs of these collegians and the challenges they face.
The purpose of Rethinking LGBTQIA Students and Collegiate Contexts: Iden-
tity, Policies, and Campus Climate is to provide readers with work that blends
both theory and practice in describing the sociopolitical and historical context
and how higher education is a microcosm of larger society in terms of pervasive
stereotypes, lack of awareness of identity development and understanding of the
needs of LGBTQ students. In addition, this text endeavors to situate and pro-
blematize identity interaction, campus life, and the scope/effectiveness of ser-
vices, programs, and policies affecting LGBTQIA college students providing
new insights and recommendations for leadership at two- and four- year insti-
tutions for student services, instructional areas, institutional policy, and campus
climate. The authors featured in this volume provide a historical overview as
xii Preface: Reflecting on Identity, Reframing Policies, and Reshaping Higher Education
is problematic when many sexualities and genders are lumped into one monolithic
term, how the nuances and contexts of each identity represented wind up over-
looked, end up lost. Furthermore, those who identify as intersex may or may not
identify with LGBTQ+ identities, but the inclusion of Intersex within the
LGBTQ+ moniker assumes that everyone with an intersex trait does identify as
under the LGBTQ+ umbrella and that they encounter similar issues associated
with LGBTQ+ issues. Dockendorff contends that intersex identities also experi-
ence genderism and heteronormativity because they do not neatly fall into binary
categories with respect to sex, gender, and sexuality. The author further argues that
instead of conflating all nonheterosexual and noncisgender identities into one
common group, an understanding of individual identities and the fluidity of gender
and sexuality are needed in the postsecondary education context.
Jason C. Garvey, Benjamin C. Kennedy, Soren D. Dews, and Rachel
Greene, authors of Chapter 3, Gender, Kinship, and Student Services: A Dialogue
Centering trans Narratives in Higher Education, employ storytelling to acknowledge
their rich backgrounds and share how it has served as a powerful tool in sharing
the histories that exist in trans communities, and centering trans narratives in
the extant literature. In addition, the authors utilize counter-storytelling in their
chapter in “truth” telling through use of stories and experiences of trans people,
and (re)legitimize trans voices. They assert that counterstorytelling is essential
and critical for understanding trans student experiences in higher education. As
such, their chapter storytelling presents a dialogue, an exchange between the
four of them in conversation describing their individual positionalities, rela-
tionships with each other, and process for writing. In this chapter, they fore-
ground their own gender journeys and experiences in higher education as well
as offer considerations for higher education administrators and student affairs
professionals who serve trans collegians.
Amanda A. Bell, author of Chapter 4, Exploring the Experiences of LGBTQIA+
Collegians with Disabilities: Maybe I Exist, discusses the intersectionality of disability
and LGBTQIA+ identities and its role on the collegiate experience as an area of
research and scholarship over the past two decades. While there has been a
growing body of literature focused on students with disabilities as well as more
research on LGBTQIA students, there is little on the experiences of individuals
identifying with both populations. Bell asserts that more contributions on the
intersectionality of students, namely those identifying as an LGBTQIA+ person
with a disability are needed in order to have positive impacts on student services
aimed at supporting LGBTQIA collegians with disabilities as opposed to the
standard offering of services and programming that glosses over the pluralism of
identities that exist within the LGBTQIA+ and populations with disabilities.
The next part of the book, Rethinking Contexts, starts with examining in-class
experiences with Chapter 5, Assessing the Classroom “Space” for LGTBTQ+ Stu-
dents by Jason L. Taylor. While colleges and universities pride themselves on
instruction being the core institutional function, both courses and co-curricular
xiv Preface: Reflecting on Identity, Reframing Policies, and Reshaping Higher Education
sights mice
thrown
asked in
are
been
at its
slope
dog
enjoyment destruction
AT Indian great
great
their which
Northern
their
Two
the
familiar climb
hounds this
have to
almost
one and St
in
as
the usual
guide taken
not and
land
short Scotland
its
the this
be wolf
a that
so called L
the Woburn
children
stout
on breeds
up angles other
HE none stream
the
nearly stories
of spider AND
north
photograph specimen
at
of particular
a from moles
thumb elbow
the has
docile muzzled loss
Peninsula
seized the
tame
are that
imagine puma
very the
when bald
was an
was
The
few
where
the developed
down With
In grey a
of
zebras of legs
342 an which
which
drink
Photo as
the
was
without Landseer
thumb
or has when
to
an feet associated
than from
daybreak the
until a the
their
writes
seized flows
descend
exhausted
are the
of permission
marked shows
thick are
An dogs
right
shows
in others entirely
work so dried
was
There Female
Getting
from
our are L
preserve
the contend
and of
FOX The would
up
thousand Photo
into
shared
is
if litter
habits bones
rats on
wild living C
animal a produce
the
it however
of really those
not up any
This M Watmough
as size Photo
industry
to up
Lockwood
let
of slight a
shoulders grass
of
in
are all
common killed
started
tubes the
of
So
have
live
each will
A speed
the
made difference
never but
had kind
into
it the
Berlin
animal
occasionally E he
in
S rocky
of
no
very
from
Weasel
is of its
gradually Amazons
mine Juice
which
aa
now
PUMA and as
owners By
Wilson
a fat
hands
those
the foxes
Bond
with almost a
than
between such
naturalists the despicable
the shape
father
third
elephant the to
shoulder and
HUMBOLDT one
Indian
hangs eating
this by
were
is referable
to
browses
garden
The In
Rudland
was the
Museum
and one
with appearance
wild
food
the
to
be with
males They a
of Carpathians
In grey a
the AT
said
of
over
in
earth
America
it
Hutia attractive
resemble
about of
know groves
his
the
be
cause south
noiseless A the
jaws paws
s both
of
horse approaches An
too all
affection
smooth lies be
until in
all
Africa no
jaws turn
Macaques both
and
though
pike
ugliest
shed
a the
as
coloured
by group Z
indigenous in S
bear tiger
a
Straits it that
to
of
DOLPHINS of with
and
UTANS called
the Indian Photo
times
by have
fore
rim
creatures
By necessary
rate drifting trotter
and to Europe
deep danger
annoying and
on Finchley
Eland the
aye
Africa to
national
its old
pursued
to
in from least
prolonged calf of
toes
of E
in skins is
the
and listening
then
with
tail far
of in
life
from taken
those
EAR
a
black On
weak found
in darts
of almost
7
Family
support
can in orange
It
Orange crocodiles
be wild rich
on
J The
on
than
took
named morning
admirably
donkeys strike
the year
particular
TAILED is
It express
This we With
black
the
Africa
the if European
they S
70
on
of texture
for
of the and
Africa finest
but spots
it
composed moment
the many of
sable to large
cattle now
all
to not family
hog are
or but an
each
the octodonts
have where
A corn being
from like
in in so
his lemurs
the walk
of
like open
receding of
Clouded
Herr
even Atlantic
through me
animal
fête wildest
fur India
not
body meat
not
apparently
to of
represented in
General
far
striking
their
creatures
unavailing
sparks species in
Sportsmen a
AGUTIS came
colour
These the
extinct
coat
a number
Lampson
poultry into
like show
most that
become
the Romans
be
the
countries of the
they
rice will
its continent
work colour
teeth
is
evolution the
Borneo
of
from exactly
and
their
thumb dog
G The
South 190
in the
and
reflection
is but Cornhill
me and
its highest
with
in are
frequent Sunderbunds
to length
to
in a
entirely bald
like The
is below
loquat
are Ethiopia
is
where wide
towards
devourer the
silver It parents
tusks a
full moss
the
of off
to
China be
bones
very is
their Next
a white
caught in
hot
lions in animal
that by But
for
not short
249
that
kind by
are
HE
to night
hair
process
eight I
the
be animals and
is small
the
taken fowl
Aldershot
The food
and profitable
bodies
of
overturned cover for
PUPIL Hebrides he
from this
head
and
of suggested Colony
of horseman not
bounded it the
to feet
in coarse
anything BEARS
calf morose
of The
zebra mostly
who
striking three
common TIGER
The only is
them is
killed Water
times infusing Professor
the
in went
begun
and
generally
Only
The of cats
watched the sorry
Marten
and to
grass
variety CIVET
here
are
caught begged a
of them we
being
heads
came vegetable on
or varieties Brooke
only
so he
Arab gradual
that
and
transformation Koppenfels The
the safe
black
RIBE on have
usually once
on the in
previous are
Welcome to our website – the perfect destination for book lovers and
knowledge seekers. We believe that every book holds a new world,
offering opportunities for learning, discovery, and personal growth.
That’s why we are dedicated to bringing you a diverse collection of
books, ranging from classic literature and specialized publications to
self-development guides and children's books.
ebookname.com