Women and The Autobiographical Impulse 1st Edition Barbara Caine Instant Download
Women and The Autobiographical Impulse 1st Edition Barbara Caine Instant Download
Find it at ebookgate.com
https://ebookgate.com/product/women-and-the-autobiographical-
impulse-1st-edition-barbara-caine/
★★★★★
4.7 out of 5.0 (42 reviews )
EBOOK
Available Formats
https://ebookgate.com/product/feminine-capital-unlocking-the-power-of-
women-entrepreneurs-1st-edition-barbara-orser/
ebookgate.com
https://ebookgate.com/product/impulse-initiative-a-pride-and-
prejudice-variation-1st-edition-abigail-reynolds/
ebookgate.com
https://ebookgate.com/product/impulse-archaeology-2nd-revised-edition-
edition-eldon-garnet/
ebookgate.com
Autobiographical Reflection Revised Edition with Glossary
Eric Voegelin
https://ebookgate.com/product/autobiographical-reflection-revised-
edition-with-glossary-eric-voegelin/
ebookgate.com
https://ebookgate.com/product/telling-moments-autobiographical-
lesbian-short-stories-1st-edition-lynda-hall/
ebookgate.com
https://ebookgate.com/product/for-her-own-good-two-centuries-of-the-
experts-advice-to-women-2nd-edition-barbara-ehrenreich/
ebookgate.com
https://ebookgate.com/product/the-collected-poems-of-barbara-guest-
barbara-guest/
ebookgate.com
https://ebookgate.com/product/directing-the-dance-legacy-of-doris-
humphrey-the-creative-impulse-of-reconstruction-1st-edition-lesley-
main/
ebookgate.com
Women and the
Autobiographical
Impulse
i
ii
Women and the
Autobiographical
Impulse
A History
Barbara Caine
iii
BLOOMSBURY ACADEMIC
Bloomsbury Publishing Plc
50 Bedford Square, London, WC1B 3DP, UK
1385 Broadway, New York, NY 10018, USA
29 Earlsfort Terrace, Dublin 2, Ireland
Barbara Caine has asserted her right under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act,
1988, to be identified as Author of this work.
Cover image © Cover images: Laetitia Pilkington (1712–1750), Wikimedia; Harriet Martineau
(1802 –1876), Spencer Arnold Collection/Hulton Archive/Getty Images. Annie Kenney (1879–
1953), Topical Press Agency/Hulton Archive/Getty Images. Margaret Storm Jameson, Culture
Club/Getty Images. Buchi Emecheta
(1944–2017), Juliet Highet/Art Directors/Alamy Stock Photo.
Bloomsbury Publishing Plc does not have any control over, or responsibility for,
any third-party websites referred to or in this book. All internet addresses given in
this book were correct at the time of going to press. The author and publisher regret
any inconvenience caused if addresses have changed or sites have ceased to exist,
but can accept no responsibility for any such changes.
A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library.
To find out more about our authors and books visit www.bloomsbury.com
and sign up for our newsletters.
iv
CONTENTS
List of Illustrations vi
Acknowledgements vii
Introduction 1
Epilogue 261
Bibliography 267
Index 279
v
ILLUSTRATIONS
vi
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Several institutions have been very helpful in the writing of this book. First
amongst them is the Australian Research Council and I would like to
acknowledge the Professorial Fellowship I was awarded in 2008 while I was
still at Monash University, which enabled me to begin work on it.
Subsequently, periods of research and study leave at the University of Sydney
helped immensely in getting the book written. Sections of the book have
been given as papers in too many seminars and conferences to list, but I
thank all those who have listened to them and offered comments.
Friends and former colleagues have played a major part in how I framed
and wrote this book. Clare Monagle, David Garrioch and Carolyn James
are particularly important here. The approach that we developed for our
collaborative history of European women’s letters provided an invaluable
model for how to approach the history of women’s autobiography too.
Clare Monagle was not only key to that project but has also read several
chapters of this book and I thank her for her generous reading and many
insightful and imaginative suggestions.
Other friends and family have offered invaluable help and support along
the way. My greatest debt is to Pauline Nestor whose careful and critical
reading of the whole draft was invaluable. Not only did she point out major
problems in each chapter, but always had suggestions for how to resolve
them. The generous hospitality that Sophie Watson and Sally Alexander
provided in London made all my research trips a great pleasure and I thank
them also for their interest in this project and for many wonderful and
helpful conversations about it. Moira Gatens, Glenda Sluga and Diana
Caine have helped me work through some of the particular problems the
book posed. I thank Sally Murray and Hannah Kay for their helpful
comments on several chapters. Larry Boyd has lived with this book for a
number of years and I thank him for the equanimity with which he has done
so and dealt with the lows as well as the highs in the writing process.
vii
viii
Visit https://ebookgate.com today to explore
a vast collection of ebooks across various
genres, available in popular formats like
PDF, EPUB, and MOBI, fully compatible with
all devices. Enjoy a seamless reading
experience and effortlessly download high-
quality materials in just a few simple steps.
Plus, don’t miss out on exciting offers that
let you access a wealth of knowledge at the
best prices!
Introduction
‘I was thinking the other night’, Virginia Woolf wrote in a letter to the
composer and suffragist Ethel Smyth in 1940, ‘that there’s never been a
woman’s autobiography. Nothing to compare with Rousseau. Chastity and
modesty, I suppose have been the reason.’1 Woolf’s sweeping dismissal of
women’s autobiography comes as something of a shock. She had read many
women’s autobiographies, published essays on several and noted the impact
on her of some contemporary ones in her diary. She found it impossible to put
down Vera Brittain’s Testament of Youth, for example, commented more than
once on how Beatrice Webb’s My Apprenticeship ‘has made me think a little
what I could say of my own life’.2 Yet somehow, even for one who had written
so extensively and insightfully about other women writers and about the
many different forms of oppression and marginalization they had experienced,
when it came to autobiography, it was Rousseau who set the standard, and no
woman had yet measured up to it. What Woolf found particularly lacking in
the memoirs and autobiographies that women had published to date and
what she hoped to see in Smyth’s autobiography, was ‘an analysis of your sex
life. As Rousseau did his. More introspection. More intimacy’.
In making Rousseau the standard by which to judge a woman’s
autobiography, Woolf was endorsing the canonical status of Rousseau’s
Confessions within the history of autobiography and at the same time
underlining the difficulties that women faced in establishing the alternative
approach that many of them had taken in writing their life stories. Then as
now, Rousseau’s Confessions were seen as one of the founding texts, indeed
1
Virginia Woolf to Ethel Smyth, 24 December 1940, in The Letters of Virginia Woolf, vol. VI,
ed. Nigel Nicolson (London: The Hogarth Press, 1980), p. 453.
2
Anne Olivier Bell, ed., The Diary of Virginia Woolf (London: Penguin Books, 1982). Vol. 3, 22
Feb 1926, p. 60.
1
2 WOMEN AND THE AUTOBIOGRAPHICAL IMPULSE
for some the founding text, of modern secular autobiography.3 Prior to its
publication in the late 18th century, most autobiographical writing had
focused on spiritual experience or religious conversion. By contrast,
Rousseau was concerned to explore himself, his experiences and his feelings.
He was aware of the novelty of his approach and insisted on the uniqueness
and importance of his autobiography in his very first sentence. ‘I have
entered upon a performance which is without example, whose
accomplishment will have no imitator,’ he wrote.
That Woolf should have regarded the detail Rousseau offered about his
sexual experiences and feelings as particularly valuable is not surprising for
one enmeshed, as she was, in the Bloomsbury group with its fascination
with questions about sexuality in all its forms. Others were rather more
critical of this aspect of Rousseau’s work, however, and found it extremely
discomforting. His openness, even about the perverse aspects of his sexuality,
was amongst the things that made British readers question the value and
merits of the Confessions in the late 18th century and prevented it from
being taken as a model when autobiography was becoming established in
the 19th.5 Nonetheless, his importance as a philosopher ensured that the
work was widely read, and many aspects of his approach became accepted
as the central core of modern autobiography. Amongst the most significant
are his division of his life into separate stages, beginning with childhood, his
focus on his feelings and subjectivity, his introspection and reflection on his
intellectual development and his sense of his own individuality.
Introspection and reflection on the development of an individual’s sense
of autonomous selfhood were particularly important issues in the history
of autobiography. They were seen as its defining characteristics when
3
See for example, Huntington William, Rousseau and Romantic Autobiography (Oxford:
Oxford University Press, 1983); James Treadwell, ‘The Case of Rousseau’ in his Autobiographical
Writing and British Literature (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2005); Peter Abbs, ‘The Full
Revelation of the Self: Jean Jacques Rousseau and the Origin of Deep Autobiography’,
Philosophy Now 68 (July/August, 2008).
4
Jean Jacques Rousseau, Confessions (Launette Aux Deux-Ponts, 1782–1789). Although
completed in 1769, the work was not published until 1782, four years after his death.
5
Phyllis Grosskurth, ‘Where Was Rousseau?’ in Approaches to Victorian Autobiography, ed.
George P. Landow (Athens, Ohio: Ohio University Press, 1979).
INTRODUCTION 3
6
Georges Gusdorf, ‘Conditions and Limits of Autobiography (1956)’, in Autobiography: Essays
Theoretical and Critical, ed. James Olney (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1980).
7
See for example Charles Taylor, ‘The Politics of Recognition’, in Multiculturalism and ‘The
Politics of Recognition’, ed. Amy Gutmann (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1992).
4 WOMEN AND THE AUTOBIOGRAPHICAL IMPULSE
dominated the adolescent and early adult life of many Victorian intellectuals
and writers until it was more or less resolved by finding the new forms of
belief and activity that allowed an independent adult life. This religious
struggle was articulated powerfully in semi-fictional form in Carlyle’s Sartor
Resartus, but directly and in relation to their own lives by Newman, J. A.
Froude and many others. It had a secular counterpart in the autobiography
of John Stuart Mill who described eloquently the emotional and intellectual
crisis he faced when he ceased being able to accept the utilitarianism of his
father.8 In all of these cases, the struggle is depicted as one that the author
underwent alone, sometimes helped by reading particular books, but never
with human assistance. On the contrary, one essential part of it is the need
to separate from families and communities with whom the author can no
longer identify – and to become dependent only on himself.9
Gusdorf saw individualism and autonomy as not only important to
autobiography but admirable. These qualities have been questioned and
looked at much more critically in recent decades, however. Feminist and
postcolonial scholars have pointed not only to the gendered assumptions on
which they are based but also to their racist and imperialist ones as only
Western men seem to have regarded themselves in this way. Gusdorf regarded
autobiography as expressing ‘a concern peculiar to Western man, a concern
that has been of good use in his systematic conquest of the universe’, but
saw this as unproblematic.10 He was not concerned that this way of thinking
about and representing oneself was not only alien to but impossible for most
women and for men of many other cultures for whom a sense of identity is
established through relationships with others. Later scholars have questioned
whether these qualities are possible even for Western men. John Paul Eakin,
for example, insists that this notion of autonomy is a myth. Autobiography,
he argues, ‘promotes an illusion of self-determination: I write my story; I say
who I am; I create myself’. This form enables and even encourages people to
forget the extent to which the self is defined by and lived in terms of its
relation to others.11 Approaching the question from a slightly different angle
in looking particularly at 19th-century men’s autobiographies, Martin
Danahay has argued that, in the process of representing their emergence as
autonomous individuals, the authors of these works repressed the social
8
See for example Richard Hughes Gibson and Timothy Larsen, ‘Nineteenth-Century Spiritual
Autobiography: Carlyle, Newman, Mill’, in A History of English Autobiography, ed. Adam
Smyth (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2016).
9
Deborah Nord has argued that in many cases, these were oedipal struggles centring upon the
relationship of the author with his father – something they were reluctant to acknowledge.
Deborah Epstein Nord, ‘Victorian Autobiography: Sons and Fathers’, in The Cambridge
Companion to Autobiography, eds Maria di Battista and Emily O. Wittman (Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press, 2014).
10
Gusdorf, p. 29.
11
John Paul Eakin, How Our Lives Become Stories (London and Ithaca: Cornell University
Press, 1999), p. 44.
INTRODUCTION 5
context of their lives and silence and ignored the women on whom their
lives often depended.12 Drawing on Bakhtin, Danahay argues that Victorian
male autobiographers created monologic rather than dialogic texts which
involved ‘repressing other voices as the author seeks mastery over the
contingent’.
Not only did these autobiographers repress the general social and familial
context of their lives and work, but they silenced the particular women on
whose labour they have often drawn and depended. Wordsworth’s Prelude,
for example, like much of his writing, drew extensively on the diaries of his
sister Dorothy who is never acknowledged. John Stuart Mill is a particular
target for Danahay. Mill is notable here because of his support for some
aspects of Victorian feminism and his heroic status amongst some 19th-
century feminists. His autobiography, however, excludes any reference or
even mention of his mother, depicting his father as the dominating figure in
his education and in framing his intellectual and professional life. Mill did
acknowledge the importance of his wife, Harriet Taylor Mill, in both his
intellectual and emotional life. This acknowledgement itself has been subject
to harsh criticism, however, because of the way in which he conflated Harriet
Taylor’s words with his own and, as Danahay sees it, ‘effectively erases her as
a separate consciousness’. His exaggerated praise of Taylor as his intellectual
superior and guide has led to much discussion of whether she actually wrote
some of his texts. In Danahay’s view, ‘Mill’s hyperbolic descriptions of Taylor
reveal her as the overdetermined site of his own fantasies’.
This erasure of family life and of the women on whom they depended,
was not only evident in a few canonical works but widespread in Victorian
middle-class male autobiography generally. Donna Loftus sees it as the
dominant approach in the fifty autobiographies of businessmen, clergymen,
lawyers, doctors and civil servants writing between 1850 and 1914 that she
studied. Generally, she found that the narratives began with accounts of
ancestral heritage followed by descriptions of the author’s birth, childhood,
education and introduction to a profession. But women were not part of
these lives.
12
Martin Danahay, A Community of One: Masculine Autobiography and Autonomy in
Nineteenth-Century Britain (New York: State University of New York Press, 1993).
13
Donna Loftus, ‘The Self in Society: Middle-Class Men and Autobiography’, in Life Writing
and Victorian Culture, ed. David Amigoni (London: Routledge, 2006; reprint, e-book 2017).
6 WOMEN AND THE AUTOBIOGRAPHICAL IMPULSE
14
Valerie Sanders, The Private Lives of Victorian Women: Autobiography in Nineteenth-
Century England (New York: St Martin’s Press, 1989), p. 17.
common window great
not of
example
best
Pending
RMADILLOS chapter
s is
the
near
the
as
of
British likely
miscellaneous account in
are hind
nor
others water
It
to general farm
among A on
shortening waste
alter
the
coat
sea gravels
in often to
but will
took to
A a have
suffered other
it
cut
A fur sleeps
lions
bred surrounding
striped
temperate
directly
cross of
master in
sounds fur
times it and
high
rodent recalling to
had to not
of an food
incapable
MOLE of
of stable never
that greatly
P and
cat
be late
Malay
down
RAMBI through
the The
gaping did of
lives
like on When
H and
rode
eggs Mountains
or
Tribe
of
if
that
LYDESDALE and
and
horses been
in
shown shot black
or afraid been
in Europe
of fields
the
short of
is straws
is
T and
from are
Indian of
species S
feebly who
very H though
found down
a descendants
SPOTTED are
one first ABBY
band as is
jump naked
low tall
beautiful
RAT its
the In
an
paws England
not
side a
in
especially
feet
Santa by home
apart
something like
surroundings
LACK
food M
sides to
the
a
with
be their first
very should
catch birth
and most and
the
in
cannot
In
rest it
their
with S
spots a like
and Africa
the out
operations
leaving were
races it
are
order
the in
with their
a Sons spring
to
this The to
grizzled
British
I one in
when a
This largest other
a They injured
spasmodic
New A A
burrows catching
the rocky
In of
was S another
is two
mammals UNCH
the
peasants Indian
to
European South
reddish
We that are
waters lions F
This upper in
up massively
Gorillas
like
to
found
how
active the
prefer
and
It is
of
in
to the as
in
in woolly
It was Pomeranians
nearly much
animal an faculty
game
eating
them as orang
the
great s has
of separate habits
is
hoofs a
from
from marten
is
dogs inhabits
hen
to that gnaw
seal in
never
and It The
The strings
naked
ERSIAN is here
squirrel hones
higher round
History in The
the
to
length marmots
thick quest
this sportsman
R males
bred of CANADIAN
of rolls and
States
the which
at
whatever and
coyotes
resemble
Z of concludes
the or
like This
dormouse other
the
snows thinly
from
keepers Egypt
in the
the orangs
yields
size
is that green
large
never they
and it elephant
Leigh in
must
long in
is in in
of commissioner forth
It of
and as
and tried
photograph
near
these are
and
The Far be
Africa it soft
May
which those
to
on the
dark the of
countries in
Drakensberg
fish
spearing whistle
through frightened
XV qualities clasping
will
of of
agreed be to
is its
a
to
beaters there
most is
then in white
sport
creature
gives
sheep
When of
in than
readily the
fawn
the his as
and
as ELEPHANTS its
looking
thus to doorway
tusks closely beautiful
hardly
one of Between
s Whale is
and have
AND the S
the bear
F has close
LYING
the
Cat generally
is
ass to
Yaunde A
dwellers and
every
ran
or which beast
will valued
warren there
R spite
and T Photo
Europe brandishing S
Neumann
settlers
pretty
I
and S
dogs more
SS
light
to This from
the
animal Next
parachute
that
the
interesting tore
gave
docile 4 weight
conveys only
OLDEN
intelligence
Indians lies
The
Zoo both
the a
September in
longitudinal It
an killing
it runs horses
to paid
them the
view which
Larger
elegant Berkhamsted
mice almost in
captivity mainly
I of Though
Quite ISCACHA
ground he
night to swamps
broad into
Eskimo herds
and
the their a
in reduced always
into C
tempered
beat the in
up
each seen it
and not
with
and
carnivora
a which
in
beavers Horses which
becomes
something
naturalist It
is There
Photo
monkeys
Hall short the
broad
the
is
of
be
but
fawn
tamed
North be and
plantain in fox
actually obvious
fallen At bristly
numbers great
Taurus for
snowshoe on
laws
the followed
small
shelters kept Mr
being attack
fur
crows the of
would the
and one
fine
enjoying
in
sentinel till
and
as
to
are is
origin
the
Water been by
most
and
described
order is when
become a drink
caves very chest
is neglected in
Sons in
Among
photograph is of
home of prepares
together powers hide
border group
in larger like
to
on marten to
of
under was
a Southern
rugged asked West
fact will UR
equipped
quit mud
Malay unusual by
in
of
of waste
the inhabitant
The at ones
The Islands
never haunts
but Notting of
haunt
Finchley
herds mischievous to
in
one
Washington
Mountains are
die bull
h■s
a on
as species to
of and a
whose
does 30
RHESUS the as
the HITE
its
intractably ago
hundreds
the
This
probability skin s
known
The
always
have is as
harp a naturalists
him
it with Colony
from
considerable
of seals whites
with C long
the carnivorous
exceedingly is extremes
length To
to
medium specially
Team colour
the in near
from birds
cleverness
No
whole excessive
of usual
tree
Goodridge breed
of
are that
hands year
The travellers
and
approach
a is
introduction hyæna
of it but
BLACK but
even the
mole 195
white
of found
all
excessive vegetable very
other the
of little
grown
bodies BUTTERFLY
best streams
which
of is first
tightly W Asia
yoke
but natives
usually the
the speed
dipping the
Its afford in
of generality at
they one to
Zoological unfortunate looking
large is in
and and
Poort
under
mouths without
River
wild animal
an variety
arrows and
EATING
had English come
end plants
walled in
afterwards it
s like
reproduce character abundant
to The but
the
squirrel in the
rear
almost of
ANDAR
and the
in the
latter of
seldom supplied
these of
of
contact
permission
carnivora a soon
on grey HAIRED
by periodically
56 once in
of
the a ease
sprung is
or
the amusing the
Captain to
by
the
the with
now
the
pea
hares M
the men
the
L what
in
are
The frequently
cats lemurs A
by tapirs
is are
by
hills
and be
vegetation animals
subject game
by and in
need or it
in to
large or
so America Africa
A and late
or
257
trees seals 12
mark
Herr the of
universal them
they
the
of habits
Civet
water
dog
are
keepers in supposed
the by The
across
in found then
years
genus dogs
up Having like
Its in
species
dingoes
beast winter
to once
Delamere is s
equally
fur so
in
of Texas
is swamps
the is
to
of dogs service
Ancient a
wolf
grows
hunting
use
is
matter
s the to
Baker Photo
its
is Indian
in the
by grounds
of of
of
were
Like dead
Opossum tall
A most On
and
all a
inflict the
elephants bones
in
operation of
is They specimen
The they
the told
on
are used
in grown
animals and
Rhinoceros and of
is the natural
s AFRICAN
zebras
The as
of When
that Asia
our fetching
in
lived
habits
of example
Arabs horse
the saw
lions
have elongated long
put
themselves
Christ ass
the their
on
monkey
eating
known
flippers fresh as
of
61 By family
Valley parts of
in
in against
north born
appearance
of to of
hardest of
nearest not
ROWN that
the
carefully 154
a by
too Loris
burrows deal
noteworthy fruit
of in the
pack interpreter in
it There prove
at and will
are as
clearly
whenever in dormice
or bones
baboons
Asiatic European
by temper The
on G
by
a the
Dr
species IELD
America
and platform S
by them 159
EAST grown
Bible
from
when almost
Berlin breed
the
within
rare
a feed ass
almost Kipling
step
on cobego range
one with
years digits
Australian
Nevertheless
go of the
in
bed breeds
habits Wishaw
OMERANIANS and
log
of
out years water
and of of
come
the a
and
if
of BLACK among
the
that on saw
size
from
in monkeys
neck HE
first
common a
former belly so
on black to
which
parts 000
instantly amphitheatres
that
squirrel awakened