Elucidating the Effect of Estragole: Unlocking the Fine Line between Dose, Risk and Efficiency - A Scientific Narrative Review
Elucidating the Effect of Estragole: Unlocking the Fine Line between Dose, Risk and Efficiency - A Scientific Narrative Review
Abstract:
Background:
Estragole is a constituent of herbs such as tarragon, basil, and fennel. It is known for its anti-inflammatory and
antimicrobial activity. There is evidence of its carcinogenic potential in animal models. Estragole carcinogenicity may be
linked to its metabolic conversion, forming 1′-sulfoxy metabolites. These metabolites can form covalent DNA adducts,
inducing hepatic tumors at high-dose repeated exposure in rodents.
Aim:
This narrative review aimed to evaluate the carcinogenic potential of estragole by systematically analysing published
animal trials and assessing the neoplastic changes.
Results:
The included animal trials investigated estragoles effect on mice and rats at various doses. Estragole was shown to have
high carcinogenic potential at high doses. With an increase in estragole dosage, there was an increase in hepatic tumors in
both mice and rats.
Conclusion:
In rat and mice animal models, high dosage of estragole induces tumor formation. The risk of estragole for humans is
presently not determined, as it is consumed at low ppm levels. Estragole is a potential carcinogenic agent. Further metabolic,
and human related studies are needed to determine carcinogenic risk of estragole to human.
How to Cite: Priyanka; Lubna Fathima; Muthulakshmi S.; Dinesh Dhamodhar; Sindhu R; Prabu D.; Rajmohan M. (2025)
Elucidating the Effect of Estragole: Unlocking the Fine Line between Dose, Risk and Efficiency - A Scientific Narrative Review.
International Journal of Innovative Science and Research Technology, 10(11),
474-481 https://doi.org/10.38124/ijisrt/25nov222
III. RESULTS
Figure 1 shows PRISMA flowchart resulted in 45 articles, of which 9 were full-text articles having accessibility and were
eligible for review. Ultimately, 4 articles were chosen for inclusion in this systematic review.
Table 1 shows the Characteristics of the studies included in the systematic review with Author name, samples recruited, sample
characteristics, duration of the study and sample allocation.
Table 2 Characteristic of the Primary Outcome and Results of Studies Included in the Current Study
S.no Author Year Effect Measure Result
Name
1. Drinkwater, 1976 The number of mice with a Fourteen of the mice under the lower doses of estragole had
N. R. et single hepatocellular cancer. single hepatocellular carcinoma, three had multiple hepatocellular
al.22 Mice having numerous carcinomas, three had lung adenomas, and three had malignantly
hepatocellular carcinomas amphora. Seven mice in the higher dose estragole group had a
were counted. How many single hepatocellular carcinoma, five had multiple hepatocellular
mice had lung adenomas? carcinomas, zero had lung adenomas, and zero had malignant
Mice having malignant lymphoma.
lymphoma in number.
2. Wiseman, 1988 Susceptibility to Hepatoma By 14 months, male C3H/HeJ mice who received cumulative
R.W. et Induction in Relation to dosages of roughly 1.5 μmol/g body weight of 1'-hydroxy
al.23 Mouse Strain, Sex, and Age estragole during the first 21 days after birth had five to ten times
of Treatment more hepatomas than male CS7BL/6J mice that received the
same treatment. This approach, which delivered the carcinogen
only before weaning, made female mice of both strains extremely
resistant to hepatoma induction. When the hepatoma responses of
male B6C3F mice treated with 1'-hydroxyestragole at 1 or 12
days of age were compared, it was shown that the 12-day-old
animals were two to three times more susceptible. Only 73 and
43% of the mice treated with 1'-hydroxyestragole at 1 and 12
days of age, respectively, survived to weaning due to acute
toxicity at the 0.15 μmol/g body weight dose.
3. Bristol 2011 Complete histopathologic In rats, both sexes' livers and male rats' kidneys showed
DW. et al.12 analyses, clinical chemistry, noticeable damage. The 300 and 600 mg/kg groups had the most
and hematology. lesions. Two male rats given 600 mg/kg developed numerous
All groups had their target liver cholangiocarcinomas, while a third had a hepatocellul
tissues analyzed. A no-effect aradenoma. Every male with 600 mg/kg had cholangiofibrosis.
level of examination was Hepatocellular hypertrophy was present in all males given 75
performed on nontarget mg/kg or more and all females given 150 mg/kg or more, and the
tissues. The kidney, liver, severity increased with increasing dose. In mice, all male dosage
lung, mesenteric lymph groups had higher absolute liver weights. The 75 and 150 mg/kg
node, nose, pituitary gland, groups showed a significant increase. Additionally, 300 mg/kg
salivary gland, glandular females had a considerably higher absolute liver weight. In those
stomach, and testis were the receiving 75 mg/kg or more, relative liver weights increased
target tissues in rats, while considerably. Hepatocellular hypertrophy and hepatocellular
the kidney, liver, mandibular degeneration were markedly elevated in 75 mg/kg females, 300
and mesenteric lymph nodes, and 600 mg/kg males, and 150 and 300 mg/kg females. Males at
nose, spleen, forestomach, 300 and 600 mg/kg and females at 75, 150, 300, and 600 mg/kg
and glandular stomach were had significantly higher levels of oval cell hyperplasia in their
the target tissues in mice. livers.
4. Suzuki,Y.et 2012 Liver weights, body weights, Two out of ten, five out of ten, and five out of six female mice in
al.24 alterations in the liver's the 75, 150, and 250 mg/kg bw groups, respectively, showed very
histology, Comparing the minor hepatocellular hypertrophy. After 13 weeks of ES
expression of mRNA in the treatment, the amounts of ES-DNA adducts, ES-3′-8-dG, 3′-N2-
livers of men and women dG, and 3′-N6-dA, in liver DNA were assessed using the LC–
ES-DNA adduct MS/MS method. While no ES-DNA adducts were found in the
concentrations in the livers controls, the DNA adducts were found in the livers treated with
of mice, In vivo tests for ES. With the exception of the females in the 250 mg/kg bw
mutations, MN test in bone group, ES-specific DNA adduct production from ES-treated mice
marrow from mice. increased in a linear dose-dependent manner.
Table 2 Shows the intervention used in the study included with the outcome.
Wisem
an,
R.W. et
al.
Bristol
DW. et
al.
Suzuki,
Y. et
al.
Risk of Bias Definitely low risk of bias Probably low risk of Probably high risk of Definitely high risk of
bias bias bias
Colour
Table 3 shows the Risk of bias in all the included studies based on the Office of Health Assessment and Translation (OHAT)
Assessment tool.
was shown that the 12-day-old animals were two to three the level consumed is small at low ppm levels typically
times more susceptible. estimated to be 0.01–0.07 mg/kg/day. Further metabolic, and
human related studies are needed to determine carcinogenic
In a study by Bristol DW. et al.,12 Rats and male mice risk of estragole to humans.
given 300 or 600 mg/kg, and female mice given 75 mg/kg or
more, showed a substantial drop in mean body weight. For REFERENCES
both male and female rats given Estragole, the liver, glandular
stomach, nose, kidney, and salivary gland were the main [1]. Bray F, Laversanne M, Sung H, Ferlay J, Siegel RL,
target organs. Male rats' bone marrow, pituitary gland, testes, Soerjomataram I, Jemal A. Global cancer statistics
and epididymides all showed signs of estragole-related 2022: GLOBOCAN estimates of incidence and
toxicity. The target organs of estragole poisoning in mice mortality worldwide for 36 cancers in 185 countries.
were found to be the stomach for females and the liver and CA: a cancer journal for clinicians. 2024
nose for both males and females. Estragole therapy was May;74(3):229-63.
linked to both neoplastic and nonneoplastic liver lesions in [2]. Dixon K, Kopras E. Genetic alterations and DNA
rats. One male rat had a hepatocellular adenoma, while two repair in human carcinogenesis. InSeminars in cancer
male rats given 600 mg/kg had numerous biology 2004 Dec 1 (Vol. 14, No. 6, pp. 441-448).
cholangiocarcinomas. Rats and mice also have a markedly Academic Press.
higher incidence of hepatocellular neoplasms of the liver. [3]. Kobets T, Smith BP, Williams GM. Food-borne
chemical carcinogens and the evidence for human
In a study done by Suzuki, Y. et al.,24 The mice were cancer risk. Foods. 2022 Sep 13;11(18):2828.
administered ES(Estragole) in corn oil by gavage five days a [4]. Abbott PJ. Carcinogenic chemicals in food: evaluating
week for 13 weeks commencing at six weeks of age, at the health risk. Food and chemical toxicology. 1992
dosages of 37.5, 75, 150, or 300 mg/10 mL/kg body weight Apr 1;30(4):327-32.
(bw) (250 mg/10 mL/kg bw beginning in week two for the [5]. Koshy A. Evolving global etiology of hepatocellular
females). Only maize oil was given to vehicle control animals carcinoma (HCC): insights and trends for 2024.
(0 mg/10 mL/kg bw). Each mouse was killed twenty-four Journal of Clinical and Experimental Hepatology.
hours after the last treatment. At doses higher than 75 mg/kg 2025 Jan 1;15(1):102406.
bw in males and 250 mg/kg bw in females, there was a [6]. Kew M. C. (2014). Hepatocellular carcinoma:
substantial increase in both absolute and relative liver epidemiology and risk factors. Journal of
weights. Compared to male mice, female mice exhibited hepatocellular carcinoma, 1, 115–125.
higher amounts of DNA adducts and MFs of the gpt gene due https://doi.org/10.2147/JHC.S44381
to their higher Sult1a1 expression level. Thus, it is proposed [7]. Acharya SK. Epidemiology of hepatocellular
that the carcinogenic mechanism of ES is connected to the carcinoma in India. Journal of clinical and
genotoxic mechanism. Its genotoxicity is probably caused by experimental hepatology. 2014 Aug 1;4:S27-33.
SULT-mediated metabolites that produce ES-specific DNA [8]. Singh SP, Madke T, Chand P. Global epidemiology of
adducts. hepatocellular carcinoma. Journal of Clinical and
Experimental Hepatology. 2025 Mar 1;15(2):102446.
When combined, Estragole's genotoxic and [9]. Tu J, Wang B, Wang X, Huo K, Hu W, Zhang R, Li J,
carcinogenic potential in rodents is well established; Zhu S, Liang Q, Han S. Current status and new
however, because of the significantly lower levels of dietary directions for hepatocellular carcinoma diagnosis.
exposure and interspecies variations in Estragole metabolism, Liver Research. 2024 Dec 1;8(4):218-36.
its applicability to human health is still limited. Rather than [10]. Brown JS, Amend SR, Austin RH, Gatenby RA,
being a direct-acting genotoxic process at human exposure Hammarlund EU, Pienta KJ. Updating the definition
levels, the evidence suggests that estragole-induced of cancer. Molecular Cancer Research. 2023 Nov
hepatocarcinogenesis is primarily a threshold-dependent, 1;21(11):1142-7.
metabolism-mediated event. As a result, the risk to humans [11]. Júnior EB, de Oliveira Formiga R, de Lima Serafim
under typical dietary conditions seems insignificant, even CA, Araruna ME, de Souza Pessoa ML, Vasconcelos
though high-dose experimental data calls for caution in food RC, de Carvalho TG, de Jesus TG, Araújo AA, de
safety assessments. To improve quantitative risk assessment Araujo Junior RF, Vieira GC. Estragole prevents
models for estragole exposure, future research on human- gastric ulcers via cytoprotective, antioxidant and
specific metabolic pathways, dose-response relationships, immunoregulatory mechanisms in animal models.
and DNA repair dynamics will be crucial. Biomedicine & Pharmacotherapy. 2020 Oct
1;130:110578.
V. CONCLUSION [12]. Bristol DW. NTP 3-month toxicity studies of estragole
(CAS No. 140-67-0) administered by gavage to
This narrative review shows estragole as a potential F344/N rats and B6C3F1 mice. Toxicity report series.
carcinogenic agent. It is seen in mice and rats, that high doses 2011 Jan 1(82):1-11.
of estragole induces tumor formation, especially in the liver. [13]. Nasaba EM, Athari SM, Motlagh B, Athari SS. Effects
Estragole occurs naturally and is used in food additives. The of oral administration of Ocimum basilicum on goblet
risk of estragole for humans is presently not determined, as cell hyperplasia and upstream cytokine gene