Topic 1
Accounting for
Leases
(MFRS 117)
Chapter Outline
Nature and classification of leases.
Accounting by lessee:
operating lease
finance lease
Accounting by lessor:
operating lease
direct financing lease
Sales and leaseback transactions.
Disclosure requirement.
Learning outcomes:
Define what is lease & differentiate
between operating & finance lease
Record the leases transactions in the
book of lessor and lessee
Define and record sales and leaseback
transantions
Definition of Lease
MFRS
MFRS 117
117 (Para
(Para 4):
4):
An
An agreement
agreement whereby
whereby the
the lessor
lessor conveys
conveys to
to
the
the lessee
lessee in
in return
return for
for aa payment
payment or
or series
series of
of
payments
payments the
the right
right to
to use
use an
an asset
asset for
for an
an
agreed
agreed period
period of
of time.
time.
Advantages of Lease
1) 100% financing at fixed rates without
requiring any down payment, lease
payments often remain fixed.
2) Protection against obsolescence reduce
risk of obsolescence.
3) Flexibility less restrictive provision than
other debt agreements.
4) Less costly financing.
5) Off-Balance-Sheet financing specifically
5
on operating lease.
Classification of Lease
Finance Lease
if it transfers
substantially all the risks
and rewards incidental to
ownership.
DMart
Operating
Lease
if it does not transfer
substantially all the risks
and rewards incidental to
ownership.
Classification of Lease
cont.
Rewards may be
represented by the
expectation of profitable
operation over the assets
economic life and of gain
from appreciation in value
or realization of a residual
value.
Risks include the
possibilities of losses from
idle capacity or
technological obsolescence
and of variations in return
due to changing economic
conditions
Ownership Transfer
Legal form:
- Title remains with the lessor for all
types of lease.
Accounting view:
Substance over form
A lease that transfers substantially all of
the benefits and risks incidental to the
ownership of property should be accounted
for as acquisition of an asset and the
incurrence of an obligation by the lessee.
practically how the asset treated/used
vs. legally who own the asset
Conclusion:
The ownership rights differs according to
type of the lease.
Classification of Lease:
Para 10 - depends on the substance of the
transaction rather than the form of the contract.
Ownership transfers at the end of the lease?
YES
Finance Lease
YES
Finance Lease
NO
Bargain Purchase Option?
NO
Lease term is for majority of economic life?75% or
more
YES
Finance Lease
NO
PV of MLP equals at least substantially all of FV of
the leased asset? 90% or more
NO
Leased asset(s) specialised?
NO
Operating Lease
YES
YES
Finance Lease
Finance Lease
Classification of Lease (Cont.):
Para 11: Indicators of situations which individually or
in combination could also lead to a lease being
classified as a finance lease are:
Cancellation losses borne by lessee?
YES
NO
Changes in FV of residual borne by lessee?
YES
NO
Bargain lease renewal option?
YES
NO
Operating Lease
10
Finance Lease
Terms
Lease Term
- Non-cancellable period for which lessee has contracted to lease.
- Commencement of lease term = when recognition takes place.
Inception date
- the earlier of the date of the lease agreement and the date of
commitment by the parties to the principle provision of the lease.
- Inception of the lease = when leases are classified.
Bargain purchase option (BPO)
- option to purchase the asset at a price lower than fair value at the date
of the option become exercisable.
11
Terms (cont)
Minimum Lease Payment (MLP)
Payments over the lease term that the lessee is or
can be required to make excluding contingent rent,
cost for services, and taxes, to be paid and
reimbursed to the lessor; together with
(+) Guaranteed residual value:
a) lessee: any amounts guaranteed by the
lessee or related party; or
b) lessor: any residual value guaranteed by
lessee or party related to lessee, or third party.
(+) BPO (bargain purchase option)
12
Terms (cont.)
Guaranteed Residual Value
-
13
Lessee: part of the RV guaranteed by the lessee or by a
party related to the lessee (being the max amounts payable
at the end of lease term)
Lessor: part of RV guaranteed by the lessee or by a third
party unrelated to the lessor who is capable to pay the
guaranteed amounts.
Initial direct cost
- incremental cost that are directly attributable to
negotiating and
arranging a lease, except for such costs incurred by
manufacturer or
dealer lessors.
- Example: legal fees, lease agreement commission etc.
Terms (cont.)
Gross Investment
a) the MLP receivable by the lessor under a finance lease, and
b) any unguaranteed residual value accruing to the lessor.
Net Investment
- the gross investment in the lease discounted at the interest rate
implicit in the lease.
14
Classification of Lease
cont.
Para 15A 18:
When a lease includes both land and buildings elements, an entity
assesses the classification of each element as a finance or an
operating lease separately in accordance with paragraphs 713.
Land
usually operating due to indefinite useful life.
if title passed finance lease.
MLP allocated in the proportion to the relative FV of both
elements.
if cannot reliably allocated: entire lease is considered finance lease,
unless it is clear that both are operating.
15
Classification
Classification of
of Lease
Lease
Illustration 1:
Pajakan Co. (Lessor) and Trojan Co. (Lessee)
entered into leasing agreement on 1 January 2012.
The term of lease is 15 years. The lease agreement
is non-cancellable and has minimum lease
payments with a present value of RM450,000. The
lease involves the use of machinery that has a 17
years estimated useful life and is valued at
RM460,000. The lease stated that Trojan has an
option to purchase the asset for RM20,000 at the
end of leased period.
16
Classification
Classification of
of Lease
Lease
Solution to illustration 1= Finance Lease
Criteria
17
Satisfied?
Y/N
Explanation
Transfer of
title
Not transferred.
BPO
BPO = RM20,000
Length of lease
term
useful life = 17 years;
Lease term = 15 years.
PV of MLP
FV = RM460,000;
PV of MLP = RM450,000.
Specialised
assets
Not specified.
Finance vs. operating lease
(Lessee)
Finance Lease
18
Operating Lease
Recognition of PPE and
liabilities on the book
Recognition of rental
expenses/revenue as
incurred/earned
PPE subject to impairment
and test
Not applicable
Lets take a look at
Operating Lease in
the book of Lessee
19
Operating Lease:
Accounting by Lessee
Para 33 34:
Lease payments should:
i. be recognised as an expense in the income statement
on a straight-line basis over the lease term.
ii. exclude costs for services such as insurance and
maintenance.
No records on the assets or liability related to the value of
the assets (off balance sheet).
20
Operating Lease:
Accounting by Lessee
Illustration 2:
Pajakan Company (lessor) leased an equipment costing
RM450,000 to Trojan Company. The economic useful life
of the asset is 20 years. The lease is classified as
operating lease with the lease term of 5 years starting
from 1/1/2011. Payments are made in advance as
follows:
1/1/11
RM18,000
1/1/12
RM16,000
1/1/13
RM14,000
1/1/14
RM12,000
1/1/15
RM10,000
Asset is used evenly throughout the lease term. The
21
accounting period of both parties ends on 31 December.
Operating Lease :
Accounting by Lessee
Solution to Illustration 2:
Total payment for the lease period:
= RM18,000 +RM16,000 + RM14,000 + RM12,000 + RM10,000
= RM70,000
Expenses recognized per year = RM70,000/5
= RM14,000
Journal entries?
22
BKAF3063 A132
Date
Particulars
Debit
1/1/11
Dr. Prepaid rent
Cr. Cash
Dr. Rent expense
Cr. Prepaid rent
18,000
Dr. Prepaid rent
Cr. Cash
Dr. Rent expense
Cr. Prepaid rent
16,000
Dr. Prepaid rent
Cr. Cash
Dr. Rent expense
Cr. Prepaid rent
14,000
Dr. Prepaid rent
Cr. Cash
Dr. Rent expense
Cr. Prepaid rent
12,000
Dr. Prepaid rent
Cr. Cash
Dr. Rent expense
Cr. Prepaid rent
10,000
31/12/11
1/1/12
31/12/12
1/1/13
31/12/13
1/1/14
31/12/14
1/1/15
31/12/15
23
Credit
18,000
14,000
14,000
16,000
14,000
14,000
14,000
14,000
14,000
12,000
14,000
14,000
10,000
14,000
14,000
Lets take a look at
Operating Lease
in the book of
Lessor
24
Operating Lease:
Accounting by Lessor
Para 49 55:
Present assets in the balance sheet
according to the nature of the assets.
Payments from lessee are recorded as Rent
Revenue on a straight-line basis over the lease
term.
Costs (e.g. depreciation) incurred in earning the
lease income are recognised as an expense.
Initial direct costs- shall be added to the
carrying amount of the leased asset and
recognised as an expense (depreciation expense)
25
over the lease term.
Operating
Operating Lease:
Lease:
Accounting
Accounting by
by Lessor
Lessor
Refer to Illustration 2:
Total payment received from lessee for the lease period:
= RM18,000 +RM16,000 + RM14,000 + RM12,000 + RM10,000
= RM70,000
Revenue recognized per year = RM70,000/5
= RM14,000
Depreciation expense recognized per year = RM450,000/20
= RM22,500
Journal entries?
26
Operating Lease :
Accounting by Lessor
Date
1/1/11
31/12/11
1/1/12
31/12/12
27
Particulars
Debit
Dr. Cash
Cr. Unearned rent revenue
Dr. Unearned rent revenue
Cr. Rent revenue
Dr. Depreciation expense
Cr. Accumulated depreciation
18,000
Dr. Cash
Cr. Unearned rent revenue
Dr. Unearned rent revenue
Cr. Rent revenue
Dr. Depreciation expense
Cr. Accumulated depreciation
16,000
Credit
18,000
14,000
14,000
22,500
22,500
16,000
14,000
14,000
22,500
22,500
Lets take a look at
Finance Lease in
the book of Lessee
28
BKAF3063 A132
Finance Lease :
Accounting by Lessee
Para 20 30:
Should be recognized as assets and liabilities (as if the
assets is being purchased) at amounts equal to the fair value of
leased asset OR if lower, at the PV of MLP [Para 20].
Cost of assets recorded in lessees book:
Fair value at inception date.
The lower of:
Reason: the leased
asset should not be
recorded for more than
its fair value.
29
OR
PV of MLP at inception date.
Finance
Finance Lease
Lease ::
Accounting
Accounting by
by Lessee
Lessee
The discount rate (to be used in calculating PV of MLP): implicit in the
lease.
IF impracticable to determine, use lessees incremental
borrowing rate.
MFRS 117 requires the lessee to record the obligation arising from
finance lease at then same amount as the leased asset ( para 22).
Journal entries :
Dr. Leased asset
Cr. Lease Liability
* The lower of fair value or PV of MLP
30
xxx *
xxx *
Finance
Finance Lease
Lease ::
Accounting
Accounting by
by Lessee
Lessee
Interest: MLP Lease Liabilities/FV of asset :
Lease payment should be apportioned between the
finance charge and the reduction of the outstanding
liability (principal amount).
Finance charge allocated to periods during the lease
term so as to produce a constant periodic rate of
interest on the remaining balance of the liability for
each period [ Para 27].
Contingent rents: charged as expense as incurred.
31
Finance
Finance Lease
Lease ::
Accounting
Accounting by
by Lessee
Lessee
Depreciation (Para 27):
Depreciation policy should be consistent with that for depreciable
assets which are owned by the lessee (in accordance with
MFRS116).
Use economic useful life, if the lease:
i. transferred rights at the end of lease term;
OR
ii. contains BPO.
Otherwise, use:
The lower of:
Lease term
OR
Economic useful life
32
Finance
Finance Lease
Lease ::
Accounting
Accounting by
by Lessee
Lessee
Illustration 3:
Assume that Pajakan Company (lessor) and Trojan Company
(lessee) sign a lease agreement dated 1 January 2012. The
terms are as follows:
Term of lease is 5 years, it is non-cancellable, requiring equal
rental payments of RM20,000 at the end of each year.
1. The FV = RM75,816 at the inception date, estimated useful
life of 5 years, and no residual value.
2. The lease contains no renewal options, and the equipment
reverts to Pajakan Co. at the termination of the lease.
3. Discount rate agreed by both parties is 10%.
33
4. Trojan Co. depreciates on a straight line basis, similar
equipment that it owns.
Finance
Finance Lease
Lease ::
Accounting
Accounting by
by Lessee
Lessee
Solution to Illustration 3:
Type of lease: Finance lease
MLP = 20,000 x 5 years = RM100,000
PV of MLP
= 20,000 x PVOA(5, 10%)
= 20,000 x 3.7908
= 75,816
FV = 75,816.
Journal entry on 1 Jan 2012
Dr. Leased asset
75,816
Cr. Lease Liability
75,816
(to recognise the asset leased and lease liability)
34
Finance
Finance Lease
Lease ::
Accounting
Accounting by
by Lessee
Lessee
Lease amortization schedule: Effective interest me
Date
Annual
lease
payment
(A)
Interest
(10%)
(B)
Principal
payment
(C)
1 Jan 12
75,816
31 Dec 12
20,000
7,582
12,418
63,398
31 Dec 13
20,000
6,340
13,660
49,738
31 Dec 14
20,000
4,974
15,026
34,712
31 Dec 15
20,000
3,471
16,529
18,183
31 Dec 16
20,000
1,818
18,182
(D) X 10%
35
Lease
liability
(D)
(A) - (B)
Preceeding
- (C)
Finance Lease :
Accounting by Lessee
Journal entries:
Date
Particulars
31/12/
12
Dr.
Lease liability
Interest expense
Cr. Cash
12,41
8
7,582
Depreciation expense
Cr. Accumulated
depreciation
15,16
3
Dr. Lease liability
Interest expense
Cr. Cash
13,66
0
6,340
Dr.
31/12/
13
Dr.
36
Debit
Depreciation expense
Cr. Accumulated
depreciation
15,16
3
Credit
20,00
0
15,16
3
20,00
0
15,16
Finance Lease :
Accounting by Lessee
Journal entries:
Date
Particulars
31/12/
14
Dr. Lease liability
Interest expense
Cr. Cash
Dr.
31/12/
15
37
Debit
15,02
6
4,974
Depreciation expense
Cr. Accumulated
depreciation
15,16
3
Dr. Lease liability
Interest expense
Cr. Cash
16,52
9
3,471
Dr.
Depreciation expense
Cr. Accumulated
15,16
3
Credit
20,00
0
15,16
3
20,00
0
Finance Lease :
Accounting by Lessee
Journal entries:
Date
Particulars
31/12/
16
Dr. Lease liability
Interest expense
Cr. Cash
Dr.
Depreciation expense
Cr. Accumulated
depreciation
Dr. Accumulated
depreciation
Cr. Leased assets
(to record the return of
the assets)
38
Debit
20,00
0
1,818
15,16
3
75,81
6
Credit
20,00
0
15,16
3
75,81
6
Lets take a look
at Finance
Lease in the
book of Lessor
39
Finance Lease :
Accounting by Lessor
Para 36 40:
The receivable to be presented in the
Balance Sheet/Statement of Fin. Position
at:
= an amount equal to the net
investment in the lease [Para 36], which
is defined in para 4 as the gross
investment in the lease less unearned
finance income
Initial direct costs included in the initial
measurement of finance lease receivable
40
Finance
Finance Lease
Lease ::
Accounting
Accounting by
by Lessor
Lessor
Refer to Illustration 3:
Gross investment = 20,000 x 5 years = RM100,000
Net investment = PV of gross investment
= 20,000 x PVOA(5, 10%)
= 20,000 x 3.7908
= 75,816
Unearned finance income = 100,000 75,816 = 24,184
Amortization schedule?
Journal entries?
41
Finance Lease :
Accounting by Lessor
Journal entries:
Date
Particulars
Debit
01/01/
05
Dr.
Lease receivable
Cr. Fixed assets
Unearned
interest revenue
100,00
0 75,816
24,184
31/12/
05
Dr.
20,000
Cash
Cr. Lease receivable
Dr. Unearned interest
revenue
Cr. Interest revenue
31/12/
06
42
Dr.
Cash
Cr. Lease receivable
Dr. Unearned interest
revenue
Credit
20,000
7,582
7,582
20,000
20,000
6,340
Bargain Purchase Option
MLP will be increased by the exercise price.
Useful life will be used as basis for depreciation charge.
Example:
On 1/1/2011, ABC Bhd entered into lease agreement with terms:
a) non-cancellable lease term of four years,
b) Lease rental of RM10,000 per year to be paid on 31 Dec,
commencing 31/12/2011.
c) ABC Bhd has an option to buy the equipment at the end of lease
term for RM1,000. On 1/1/2011, it was estimated that the fair value of
the equipment would be RM5,000 after 4 years usage.
The FV of the equipment on 1/1/2011 was RM42,000 and have
estimated useful life of 5 years. The implicit rate was 5%.
43
Bargain Purchase Option
Solution - Lesse:
MLP
= (10,000 x 4) + 1,000 = 41,000
PV of MLP
= (10,000 x PVAn=4,i=5%) + (1,000 x PV
= 36,282
1/1/11 : Dr. Leased Equipment
Cr. Lease Payable
36,282
36,282*
* The lower of FV or PV of MLP RM 42000 vs. RM 36282
Depreciation exp = 36,282 / 5 = RM7,256.40
31/12/14 - exercise of BPO:
Dr. Lease Payable
1,000
Cr. Cash
1,000
44
n=4,i=5%
Bargain Purchase Option
Solution - Lessor:
Gross Investment = (10,000 x 4) + 1,000 = 41,000
PV of MLP
= (10,000 x PV OAn=4,i=5%) + (1,000 x PV
= 36,282
1/1/11 : Dr. Leased Receivable
Cr. Equipment 36,282
Unearned interest revenue
41,000
4,718
31/12/14 - exercise of BPO:
Dr. Cash
1,000
Cr. Leased Receivable
45
1,000
n=4,i=5%
Guaranteed Residual Value
MLP will be increased by GRV
GRV will be deducted from the
depreciable amount of leased asset.
At the end of lease term,
the lease liability will have a balance
equal with GRV
If FV of leased asset < GRV , recognise
loss (lessee)
46
Guaranteed Residual Value
Example:
On 1/1/2011, ABC Bhd
agreement with terms:
entered
into
lease
a) non-cancellable lease term of four years,
b) Lease rental of RM10,000 per year to be paid on 31
Dec, commencing 31/12/2011.
c) ABC Bhd guaranteed to lessor that the leased asset
would have a residual value of RM5,000 at the
end of lease term.
The FV of the equipment on 1/1/2011 was RM42,000
and have estimated useful life of 5 years. The
implicit rate was 5%. The estimated residual
value at the end of lease term was RM7,000.
47
Guaranteed Residual Value
Solution Lessee:
MLP
= (10,000 x 4) + 5,000 = 45,000
PV of MLP = (10,000 x PV OAn=4,i=5%) + (5,000 x PV
n=4,i=5%)
= 39,572
1/1/11 : Dr. Leased Equipment
Cr. Lease Payable
39,572
39,572
Depreciation exp. = (39,572- 5,000) / 4 = RM8,643
48
31/12/14, if FV of leased asset is RM3,000:
Dr. Lease Payable
5,000
Accumulated depreciation
34,572
Cr. Leased Equipment
39,572
Dr. Loss on finance lease
2,000 (5K-3K)
Cr. Cash
2,000
Guaranteed Residual Value
Solution Lessor:
GI
= (10,000 x 4) + 7,000 = 47,000
PV of GI = (10,000 x PVOA n=4,i=5%) + (7,000 x PV
= 41,218
1/1/11 : Dr. Leased Receivable
Cr. Equipment
Unearned interest revenue
5,782
n=4,i=5%
47,000
41,218
31/12/14, if FV of leased asset is RM3,000:
Dr. Equipment
3,000
Cash
2,000
Loss on finance lease
2,000
Cr. Leased Receivable
7,000
49
Sales and Leaseback
Transaction
in which the owner of the asset
(seller, lessee) sells the asset to another and
simultaneously leases it back from the new
owner (lessor).
?
50
In the book of Buyer/lessor:
- Same as lessor as discuss before.
In the book of
seller/lessee:
-To recognize gain from
sales of asset:
immediate or defer.
Sales and Leaseback
Para 59: for Finance lease
Profit/Loss = Sales proceed
Carrying amount
Should not be recognized immediately,
instead, should be deferred and
amortized over the lease term.
51
Sales and Leaseback
Para 61: for Operating lease.
(a) If Selling price = FV
Profit = Sales proceed Carrying amou
Should be recognized immediately.
52
Sales and Leaseback
Para 61: for Operating lease
(b) If
Selling price
<
FV
LOSS = Sales proceed Carrying amo
Should be recognized immediately EXCEPT
THAT if the loss is compensated by future
lease payments at below market price, it
should be deferred and amortized.
53
Sales and Leaseback
Para 61: for Operating lease
Selling price
carrying amount)
(c) If
>
FV
(FV >
Profit = Sales proceed Carrying amo
Profit = Sales proceed
FV
deferred and
amortized.
54
Profit = FV - Carrying
amount
recognized immediately.
Sales and Leaseback
Illustration 5:
Chocolate Company sold an equipment to Chips
Company and lease back the asset. The carrying
amount (book value) of the asset is RM60,000.
The asset has a fair value of RM70,000.
How to recognize profit/loss if the selling price is:
1. RM70,000
2. RM55,000
3. RM50,000 (with lower future lease payment)
4. RM90,000
55
Sales and Leaseback
Solution to Illustration 5 (lessee):
1. SP = FV (SP > CA) =
Profit = 70,000 - 60,000 = 10,000
recognize immediately
2. SP < FV (SP < CA)
Loss = 55,000 60,000 = 5,000 loss
recognize immediately
3. SP < FV (SP < CA with lower lease payment)
Loss = 50,000 60,000 = 10,000 loss
56
defer & amortize
Sales and Leaseback
Solution to Illustration 5:
4. SP > FV =
Profit = 90,000 60,000 = 30,000
FV CA
= 70,000 60,000
= 10,000 recognize immediately
SP FV
= 90,000 70,000
= 20,000 defer & amortize
57
Disclosure
Requirements
For Lessee:
Para 31: Finance lease.
Para 35: Operating lease.
For Lessor:
Para 47: Finance lease.
Para 56: Operating lease.
58
End of Topic 1
(Part 1)
References:
MFRS 117 Lease
Ng Eng Juan 2012
Lazar & Huang 2012
Zaimah et al. 2009
59