LEEDpresentation-12011BB007 PKP
LEEDpresentation-12011BB007 PKP
Facility Managers
October 9th, 2008 8-10 AM
Presented By:
Kevin Sneed, LEED AP, AIA, IIDA
Partner, Director of Architecture; OTJ Architects
[email protected], 202.621.1369
Two recent studies (one by the New Buildings Institute, the other by CoStar) have
confirmed that:
LEED buildings are in demand, and the available supply is relatively low. Working to take
advantage of the LEED supply/demand gap makes solid business sense now, and their lower
operating costs will continue to make good business sense into the future.
• LEED building energy use is 25-30% lower, on average, than non-rated buildings
• LEED gold and platinum building energy use can be as high as 50% lower
Data taken from the national CoStar Realty Information Group study
Data taken from the national CoStar Realty Information Group study
In a joint study released this summer by Deloitte and
Charles Lockwood:
“By and large, our respondents’ green retrofits achieved many of the stated objectives. 93 % of our
respondents reported greater ability to attract talent, 81 % saw greater employee retention, 87 %
reported an improvement in workforce productivity, 75 % saw an improvement in employee health, and
73 % reported that they had achieved cost reductions as a result of implementing green measures…”
Data taken from a joint study by Deloitte and Charles Lockwood, released July 2008
LEED projects are becoming more common and
numerous across the US:
LEED projects are certified through several rating
systems, to four certification levels:
LEED CI
• 4 levels: certified, silver, gold, & platinum
• 6 prerequisites
• 57 total possible credits
• 21 credits, minimum, for certification
LEED CI: Prerequisites
The only caveat is that that individual may not be part of the design team working on the project
In essence, an effort to actively test all systems after they are installed to ensure that they are all
functioning according to the design intent
None of the HVAC&R systems in the project may use CFC based refrigerants
This should also be stipulated in the project drawings or proposal, as the MEP firm must evaluate the base building
components to ensure that they are not CFC based, as well as following this criteria in their own designs
A project MUST adhere to ALL of the prerequisites listed to obtain ANY LEED-CI certification rating
LEED CI: Prerequisites
MR PR1: Storage and Collection of Recyclables
Provide an easily accessible area that serves the entire building and is dedicated to the collection and
storage of non-hazardous materials for recycling, including (at a minimum) paper, corrugated cardboard,
glass, plastics and metals.
Buildings which are able to provide tenants with pictures, floorplans, and etc. information of building recycling
centers of a sufficient size to satisfy LEED requirements can include such an area as a marketing advantage when
attempting to attract LEED tenants
A project MUST adhere to ALL of the prerequisites listed to obtain ANY LEED-CI certification rating
LEED CI: Prerequisites
EQ PR2: Environmental Tobacco Smoke Control
This prerequisite is intended to limit tenant exposure to secondhand smoke, and has two options for
compliance for non-residential buildings:
Option 1:
Prohibit all smoking in the building, AND
Locate any exterior designated smoking areas at least 25 feet away from all building entrances, outdoor air
intakes, and operable windows
Option 2:
Prohibit all smoking in the building except in designated areas, AND
Locate any exterior designated smoking areas at least 25 feet away from all building entrances, outdoor air
intakes, and operable windows, AND
Locate designated smoking rooms to effectively contain, capture and remove ETS from the building.
A project MUST adhere to ALL of the prerequisites listed to obtain ANY LEED-CI certification rating
LEED CI: Sustainable Sites
Up to 3 points are possible in this category
All 3 points are automatically granted to a project which is located in a LEED building
Points may also be earned, piecemeal, by .5 – 1 point for each item (to a maximum of 3 points), for
each item that can be documented about the building:
•SS CRs 1.B&C: Stormwater Management (by rate & quantity, &/or treating the stormwater)
The stormwater rate and quantity must be reduced to, or beyond, that which was generated on site before anything
was built on the lot
The stormwater must be treated to remove 80% of TSS (total suspended solids) and 40% of the average TP (total
phosphorous)
LEED CI: Sustainable Sites, continued
•SS CRs 1.D&E: Heat Island Effect (on roof and/or non-roof surfaces)
1.1.D: On the roof: a building must have either a white/highly reflective surface (white pavers or a white
membrane, typically), OR a green roof on at least 50% of the roof area, OR a combination of the two
1.1.E: Off the roof: provide shade, and/or white/highly reflective surfaces, and/or open grid paving, for at least
30% of the site’s impervious surfaces (parking areas, walkways, fire lanes, etc.) OR place a minimum of 50% of
parking spaces underground OR use open-grid paving for 50% of the parking lot area
LEED CI: Sustainable Sites, continued
•SS CR 1.F: Light Pollution Reduction
Exterior/site lighting must not cross the site boundary, and light from site lighting fixtures must meet “full cutoff”
requirements so that light generated by those luminaires is restricted from reaching the night sky and causing light
pollution
•SS CRs 1.G&H: Water Efficient Irrigation (reducing potable water consumption)
Requires the use of high-efficiency irrigation technology, OR the use of captured rainwater for site irrigation, and
in doing so reduces the use of potable water for irrigation by 50%, or eliminates its use completely
This does not necessarily mean that a building or building site cannot have any landscaping. A building can use
xeriscaping instead of traditional landscaping, which involves the use of plants native to the area which will do
well without any irrigation. Use of these types of techniques, however, must be coupled with the knowledge that in
the event of a drought, the building landscaping will suffer just as much as native vegetation in any other non-
artificially-irrigated areas.
LEED CI: Sustainable Sites, continued
•SS CR 1.J: Water Use Reduction
A building must reduce its water use by 20%, and have an on-going plan to require future residents to comply with
this requirement as well
For base buildings, this will typically involve installing dual-flush units on all toilets, and aerators on faucets, and
may additionally involve installing waterless urinals and low-flow showerheads
LEED CI: Sustainable Sites, continued
•SS CR 1.K: On-Site Renewable Energy
A building must supply at least 5% of the building’s total energy use (expressed as a fraction of the annual energy
costs) from on-site renewable energy systems
LEED CI: Sustainable Sites, continued
•SS CR 2: Development Density and Community Connectivity
Aimed at channeling urban development to urban areas with existing infrastructure, this requires that projects be
located in areas with a minimum density of 60,000 sf/acre, and requires submission of a map that proves that the
building is within ½ mile of a residential zone with a minimum of 10 units per acre, and has pedestrian access to at
least 10 basic services(laundry, grocery, pharmacy, etc) within a half mile of the project site
DC Metro area buildings are typically able to meet these requirements easily, and often even qualify for exemplary
performance, granting them an extra Innovation credit—a major marketing advantage
This credit can easily be made a part of a LEED-friendly building’s marketing with research
LEED CI: Sustainable Sites, continued
•SS CR 3.1: Alternative Transportation: Public Transportation Access
Aimed at channeling urban development to urban areas with alternative transportation options (buses, subways, etc)
—by being within a ½ mile of a commuter rail station or ¼ mile of 2+ major bus lines
DC Metro area buildings are typically able to meet this requirement easily, and often even qualify for exemplary
performance, granting them an extra Innovation credit—a major marketing advantage
Many DC metro area buildings do not offer this as a building amenity, but could incorporate this relatively easy as
a LEED-friendly renovation, and use it as a marketing advantage
These credits can easily be made a part of a LEED-friendly building with only minor renovations & research
LEED CI: Sustainable Sites, continued
•SS CR 3.3: Alternative Transportation: Parking Availability
Case A: for projects occupying less than 75% of the gross building square footage
Parking spaces provided to the tenant shall not exceed the minimum number required by local zoning
regulations, AND Priority parking for car-pools or van-pools will be provided for 5% or more of the
tenant occupants
OR
No parking will be provided or subsidized for tenant occupants
Case A: for projects occupying less than 75% of the gross building square footage
Parking spaces provided to the tenant shall not exceed the minimum number required by local zoning
regulations, AND Priority parking for car-pools or van-pools will be provided for 5% or more of the
tenant occupants
OR
No new parking will be provided for rehabilitation projects, AND Priority parking for car-pools or van-
pools will be provided for 5% or more of the tenant occupants
This credit, under LEED-CI, only refers to those fixtures installed in the tenant space. However, a LEED-friendly building
should also provide retrofits to flushometers, faucets, showerheads, and urinals.
LEED CI: Energy & Atmosphere
•EA CRs 1.1 & 1.2: Optimize Energy Performance: Lighting Power and Lighting Controls
Intended to reduce lighting fixture energy use: CR 1.1 requires the reduction of lighting power density to 15%,
25%, or 35% below the ANSI/ASHRAE/IESNA 90.1-2004 standard; CR 1.2 requires the use of daylight
responsive controls in all regularly occupied spaces within 15 feet of windows, and under skylights
Building management can also decrease energy use from lighting by stocking and encouraging the use of T5, T5HO, and
CFL lamps, or even requiring the use of these lamps for 90% of tenant fixtures
LEED CI: Energy & Atmosphere, continued
•EA CR 1.3: Optimize Energy Performance: HVAC
Aimed at achieving increasing energy consumption by HVAC systems, this credit has 2 options for compliance:
• Demonstrate that the HVAC performance criteria for the tenant space is 15% below
ANSI/ASHRAE/IESNA 90.1-2004 (1 point)
OR
• Demonstrate that the HVAC performance criteria for the tenant space is 30% below
ANSI/ASHRAE/IESNA 90.1-2004 (2 points)
LEED CI: Energy & Atmosphere, continued
•EA CR 1.4: Optimize Energy Performance: Equipment & Appliances
Tenants can gain points by ensuring that most or all of their office equipment is Energy-Star Rated. This credit
does not include any HVAC or building envelope products, but does include computers, monitors, refrigerators,
freezers, copiers, fax machines, etc., etc. Some common equipment (microwaves, servers) has not yet been rated
by Energy Star, but in order to gain points in this category, tenants must have 70-90% Energy Star equipment (by
total non-HVAC equipment wattage on the project).
Building management can help support this effort by requiring, in the building rules and regulations, that all tenant
appliances be energy-star rated.
LEED CI: Energy & Atmosphere, continued
•EA CR 3: Energy Use: Measurement & Payment Accountability
The intent of this credit is to make tenants responsible for their own energy bills, therefore making them more
aware of their energy use, and more apt to take measures to reduce it. Compliance with this credit is broken into
two categories:
Case A: for projects occupying less than 75% of the gross building square footage
• Install sub-metering equipment for the tenant space, AND
• Negotiate a lease where energy costs are paid by the tenant, and are not included in the base rent.
Case A: for projects occupying more than 75% of the gross building square footage
• Install continuous metering equipment for a myriad of specific tenant energy-consuming equipment
(lighting systems and controls, boiler efficiencies, indoor water riser and outdoor irrigation, VFD
operation, etc), AND
• Develop a Measurement and Verification plan that incorporates the monitoring information from all
equipment required to be monitored, and is consistent with Option B, C, or D of the 2001 IPMVP
Protocol for measuring energy and water savings
Energy Use Measurement is a credit that it is especially important to keep in mind during lease negotiations
LEED CI: Materials & Resources
•MR CR 1.1: Tenant Space: Long-Term Commitment
This credit encourages conservation of natural resources by slowing the “churn” of tenant turnover, and rewards
tenants with a credit simply for committing to remain in their location, by the lease, for a minimum of 10 years.
•MR CRs 2.1 & 2.2 : Construction Waste Management: Divert From Landfill
Encouraging the diversion of recyclable components from the building construction waste stream, these credits
reward tenants and design teams who redirect 50% or 75% of construction waste from landfills.
Building management can increase the ability of design and construction teams to obtain this credit by ensuring
that there is adequate space for the placement of multiple dumpsters or other waste collection receptacles.
LEED CI: Materials & Resources
•MR CRs 3.1 & 3.2 : Resource Reuse
In order to reduce demand on virgin materials, and to reduce waste, these credits encourage design and construction
teams to use salvaged, refurbished, or reused materials for 5-10% of construction materials (excluding furniture).
Post consumer recycled content consists of materials that have already been made, and used by consumers, in one
form, and are now entering the recycling stream. Pre-consumer recycled content consists of scrap from the
manufacturing process—material that has not yet been used by consumers.
The possibilities for compliance with these credits depends heavily on base building system capabilities
LEED CI: Indoor Environmental Quality, continued
•EQ CRs 3.1 & 3.2: Construction IAQ Management
These credits aim to prevent indoor air quality problems after construction, by requiring:
3.1: Monitoring during construction (to ensure that the contractor is following SMACNA IAQ guidelines,
protecting on-site absorptive construction materials, using MERV-8 filters during construction, and replacing all of
those filters post construction and prior to tenant occupancy), AND/OR
3.2: Conducting a flush-out, or conducting indoor air quality testing, of the space after construction has concluded,
and prior to occupancy by the tenant.
•EQ CRs 4.1, 4.2, 4.3, 4.4, & 4.5: Low Emitting Materials
The intent of these credits is to reduce the irritating, odorous, and/or potentially harmful indoor air contaminants
exposure of both construction workers and tenants. These credits cover requirements for adhesives & sealants,
paints & coatings, carpet, composite wood & laminate adhesives, and systems furniture & seating.
Building management can help support this effort by requiring, in the building rules and regulations, that all tenant build
outs use low-voc paints, adhesives, and sealants.
LEED CI: Indoor Environmental Quality, continued
•EQ CR 5: Indoor Chemical & Pollutant Source Control
In an attempt to minimize exposure of tenants to potentially hazardous materials, this credit requires the use of
permanent entryway systems (grilles, grates, etc), at all high volume entryways; and where there are hazardous
gases or chemicals may be used, (including housekeeping, copy rooms, etc), provide deck to deck partitions and
particular exhaust systems; provide separately plumbed contaminant drains for hazardous liquid materials, and
provide regularly occupied areas of the tenant space with new air filtration media of MERV 13 or better.
Many credits (though not all) also offer extra exemplary performance credits under this category. Some which can
be targeted are:
Every project which can claim a LEED Accredited Professional among its members also receives one credit under
this category
LEED EB
• 4 levels: certified, silver, gold, & platinum
• 13 prerequisites
• 92 total possible credits
• 34 credits, minimum, for certification
• 3 month “performance period”
• 12 month occupancy minimum required
• 2 year old buildings (and older)
LEED EB: Prerequisites
A project MUST adhere to ALL of the prerequisites listed to obtain ANY
LEED-EB certification rating
SS PR1: Erosion & Sedimentation Control
SS PR2: Age of Building
WE PR1: Minimum Water Efficiency
WE PR2: Discharge Water Compliance
EA PR1: Existing Building Commissioning
EA PR2: Minimum Energy Performance
MR PR1: Source Reduction and Waste Management
MR PR2: Toxic Material Source Reduction
EQ PR1: Outside Air Introduction and Exhaust Systems
EQ PR2: Environmental Tobacco Smoke Control
EQ PR3: Asbestos Removal or Encapsulation
EQ PR4: Polychlorinated Biphenyl (PCB) Removal
LEED EB: Prerequisites
SS PR1: Erosion & Sedimentation Control
Develop & implement a site erosion and sedimentation plan, conforming to the EPA 832/R-92-005
(1992), or local standards and controls, preventing during construction the loss of soil to stormwater
runoff and wind erosion, preventing soil from entering streams or sewers, and preventing air pollution
from soil dust.
Reduce potable water use to a level equal to or below the water use baseline, provide at least one meter
for the overall building water use, and (it is encouraged, but not required) provide metering for cooling
towers and other process water uses.
A project MUST adhere to ALL of the prerequisites listed to obtain ANY LEED-EB certification rating
LEED EB: Prerequisites
EA PR1: Existing Building Commissioning
This prerequisite requires engaging an MEP firm to verify that building systems and assemblies are
performing efficiently, including developing a comprehensive building operation plan to meet the
requirements of current building usage, testing all systems against this operation plan, repairing or
upgrading systems as needed to meet these operational needs, and re-testing until compliance has been
achieved. A 1-5 year plan for achieving compliance may also be submitted, where all low & no-cost
measures are implemented in the first year, and continuous improvement will be made every year of the
submitted plan.
EA PR2: Minimum Energy Performance
Buildings pursuing LEED-EB certification must demonstrate that the building has achieved a minimum
rating of 60 under the EPA Energy Star rating system.
None of the HVAC&R systems in the building may use CFC based refrigerants, unless a third party
audit shows that system replacement or conversion is not economically feasible (if the simple payback
of the replacement of a chiller would not be achieved within 10 years).
A project MUST adhere to ALL of the prerequisites listed to obtain ANY LEED-EB certification rating
LEED EB: Prerequisites
MR PR1: Source Reduction and Waste Management
A project MUST adhere to ALL of the prerequisites listed to obtain ANY LEED-EB certification rating
LEED EB: Prerequisites
MR PR2: Toxic Material Source Reduction
This prerequisite requires that building management establish and maintain a program to reduce the
amount of mercury brought into the building in light bulbs. This program requires that mercury content
of all mercury-containing light bulbs must be maintained below 100 picograms per lumen hour, on a
weighted average.
A project MUST adhere to ALL of the prerequisites listed to obtain ANY LEED-EB certification rating
LEED EB: Prerequisites
EQ PR1: Outside Air Introduction and Exhaust Systems
Existing building outside air ventilation and distribution systems must supply the air at the ventilation
rate specified under ASHRAE 62.1-2004 under this prerequisite. If this is not feasible due to the
physical constraints of the existing system, that system must be modified to supply at least 10 CFM per
person. A program/plan to maintain these systems, and test all building exhaust to ensure compliance,
must be outlined and implemented.
A project MUST adhere to ALL of the prerequisites listed to obtain ANY LEED-EB certification rating
LEED EB: Prerequisites
EQ PR3: Asbestos Removal or Encapsulation
Under this prerequisite, buildings must have in place an asbestos management program (which shall
identify all applicable regulatory requirements), and have survey records which identify where asbestos
is located in the building and on the site.
Under this prerequisite, buildings must have in place an PCB management program (which shall
identify all applicable regulatory requirements), and have survey records which identify where PCB is
located in the building and on the site.
A project MUST adhere to ALL of the prerequisites listed to obtain ANY LEED-EB certification rating
LEED EB: Sustainable Sites
•SS CRs 1.1 & 1.2: Green Site and Building Exterior Management
To earn these credits, a building must have in place over the performance period a low-impact site and green
building exterior management plan that addresses:
(one point earned for every (4) items addressed)
• Maintenance Equipment • Fertilizer Use
• Plantings • Snow Removal
• Animal and Vegetation Pest Control • Cleaning of the Building Exterior
• Landscape Waste • Paints and Sealants used on the Building Exterior
• Irrigation Management • Other Maintenance of the Building Exterior
A narrative overview, and quarterly reports over the performance period, must be provided as part of the submittal
to USGBC LEED-Online.
LEED EB: Sustainable Sites, continued
•SS CR 2: High Development Density Building and Area
This credit relates to buildings which have a density of at least 60,000 sq. ft. of building floor space per acre, which
is also located within an area with the same density (generally met by two-story downtown developments).
These credits can easily be made a part of a LEED-friendly building with only minor renovations & research
LEED EB: Sustainable Sites, continued
•SS CRs 3.3 & 3.4: Alt. Transportation: Alternative Fuel Vehicles, Carpools, Telecommuting
When planting native vegetation, those which provide habitat or food for native species are preferred
LEED EB: Sustainable Sites, continued
•SS CR 6.1: Heat Island Reduction: Non-Roof
Provide (existing or within 5 years of landscape installation) shade, and/or white/highly reflective surfaces, and/or
open grid paving, for at least 30% of the site’s impervious surfaces (parking areas, walkways, fire lanes, etc.) OR
place a minimum of 50% of parking spaces underground OR use open-grid paving for 50% of the parking lot area
This does not necessarily mean that a building or building site cannot have any landscaping. A building can use
xeriscaping instead of traditional landscaping, which involves the use of plants native to the area which will do
well without any irrigation. Use of these types of techniques, however, must be coupled with the knowledge that in
the event of a drought, the building landscaping will suffer just as much as native vegetation in any other non-
artificially-irrigated areas.
•WE CRs 3.1 & 3.2: Water Use Reduction (reducing potable water consumption)
Reduce the use of potable water by 10-20% under baseline
This will typically involve installing dual-flush units on all toilets, and aerators on faucets, and may additionally
involve installing waterless urinals and low-flow showerheads
LEED EB: Energy & Atmosphere
•EA CR 1: Optimize Energy Performance
Demonstrate the EPA Energy Star energy performance rating that the building star has achieved.
This credit provides a potential for 1-10 points in the LEED-EB rating system (1 point for a 63 rating, 2 for 67, 3
for 71, 4 for 75, et cetera)
1 3% 15%
2 6% 30%
3 9% 45%
4 12% 60%
When purchasing hydropower certificates, it is important to purchase from low-impact hydropower installations
LEED EB: Energy & Atmosphere, continued
•EA CRs 3.1-3.3: Building Operation & Maintenance
In order to ensure that the building continues to deliver target performance over the long term, provide:
3.1: building operations and maintenance staff education program that provides each staff person working on the
building at least 24 hours of education per year (training must be of high quality and relevant to the building being
maintained);
3.2: a comprehensive Best Practices Equipment Preventative Maintenance Program that provides in-house or
contractual services to provide post-warranty maintenance;
3.3; a system for continuous tracking and optimization of systems that regular indoor comfort (temperature,
humidity, and CO2) in occupied spaces. The system must include:
• Adhesives and sealants with a VOC less than that described in SCAQMD rule #1168
• Paints and coatings with VOC emissions not exceeding the limits of Green Seal GS-11 requirements
• Carpet or carpet cushion that meets the requirements of the CRI Green Label Plus Carpet Testing Program
• Composite panels and agrifiber products that contain no added urea-formaldehyde resins
LEED EB: Materials & Resources, continued
•MR CRs 4.1 – 4.3: Sustainable Cleaning Products and Materials
Implement sustainable purchasing for cleaning products, disposable janitorial paper products, and trash bags. The
percentage of total sustainable cleaning product and material purchases determine the number of points earned, up to 3
points. One point will be awarded for each 30% of the total annual purchases of these products (on a cost basis) that meet
one of the following:
• Cleaning products that meet the Green Seal GS-37 standard, if applicable
• If GS-37 does not apply, use cleaning products that comply with the California Code of Regulations maximum
allowable VOC levels
• Disposable janitorial paper products and trash bags that meet the minimum requirements of the US EPA’s
Comprehensive Procurement Guidelines
•EQ CRs 7.1 & 7.2: Thermal Comfort: Compliance and Monitoring
Comply with ASHRAE Standard 55-2004, Thermal Comfort Conditions for Human Occupancy, and provide a permanent
monitoring system to ensure building performance to this standard.
LEED EB: Indoor Environmental Quality, continued
•EQ CRs 8.1 & 8.2: Daylight
Achieve a minimum daylight factor of 2% in space occupied for critical visual tasks (not including copy rooms, storage
areas, mechanical areas, laundry, and other low-occupancy support areas, and areas whose function would be impeded by
the introduction of daylight). Achieving this 2% daylight level in 50-75% of spaces will earn 1-2 points.
Many credits (though not all) also offer extra exemplary performance credits under this category. Some which can
be targeted are:
Every project which can claim a LEED Accredited Professional among its members also receives one credit under
this category
LEED CI: Gold: Union of Concerned Scientists
• Maximized the use of existing construction and furniture
• Building management was cooperative and supportive, adding bike racks, upgrading building core
with water-conserving measures, etc.
• Very high energy light fixtures with a very low overall wattage/SF consumption
• Many recycled and locally manufactured materials and resources
• Low VOC paints and adhesives throughout
• Greenguard certified furniture
• On time, within a (very restrictive) budget
Currently submitted to the USBGC LEED Online site with a LEED-CI Gold Rating (under review)
LEED NC: Gold: The American Legacy Foundation
• Heat island effect mitigation at the roof level, with a combination of highly reflective white roof
pavers and sections of green roof
• Water efficient landscaping
• Very high energy light fixtures with a very low overall wattage/SF consumption
• Many recycled and locally manufactured materials and resources
• Increased ventilation and outdoor air delivery monitoring
• Thermal comfort design and compliance monitoring
• Certified woods
• Diversion of construction wastes from landfills