Chapter 4 Property Relations
Chapter 4 Property Relations
RELATION
- Philippine laws do not require the
agreement between the future spouses to
be registered in a government office to be
binding between the parties
- However, as a security for the properties
which may be affected by the agreement,
and in order to bind third parties,
Philippine law requires the recording of the
prenuptial agreement in the Local Civil
Registry where the marriage is celebrated,
AND at the Register of Deeds of the
province where the affected property is
- Prenuptial agreement must be writing, should be executed prior to the
located.
celebration of marriage and signed by the future spouses
- Any modification or amendment thereto may only be allowed before the
celebration of the marriage.
PROPERTY RELATIONS
- Used to distinguish a conjugal or community property from an exclusive
property. The property relationship between husband and wife shall be
governed in the following order:
1. By marriage settlements executed before the marriage
2. By provisions of law
3. By local custom
TYPES OF PROPERTY
RELATIONS
1. Absolute community of Property (ACP)
2. Conjugal partnership of gains (CPG)
3. Complete separation of property
4. Any other regime
In the event the couple had not adopted or agreed upon a system before
their marriage, the rule is
NOTE:
*Intangible properties including rights accruing before death, claims against insolvent
person, RA4917,
and receivable as proceeds from life insurance taken out by the decedent
**Refer to certain transfers made before death but will take effect upon death (transfer
mortis causa) as
well as revocable transfers.
***Always an exclusive deduction under CPG
Transfer for public use shall be classified as exclusive deductions unless expressly provided
otherwise.
Case A – Decedent is married; Family Home is conjugal Exclusive Conjugal Total
valued
at more than P10,000,000
Conjugal properties:
Real and personal properties P14,000,0
00
Family Home 30,000,00
0
Exclusive properties P6,000,000 _________
Gross Estate P6,000,000 P44,000,0 P50,000,0
00 00
Less: Ordinary Deductions:
Conjugal ordinary deductions (2,000,000 (2,000,00
) 0)
Exclusive ordinary deductions (1,000,000) _________ (1,000,00
0)
Net Estate before special deductions 5,000,000 42,000,00 47,000,00
0 0
Special deductions
Family Home (P30M/2); Maximum of P10M (10,000,0
00)
Standard deduction (5,000,00
0)
Case B – Decedent is married; Family Home is conjugal Exclusive Conjugal Total
valued
at below P10,000,000
Conjugal properties:
Real and personal properties P14,000,0
00
Family Home 9,000,000
Exclusive properties P6,000,000 _________
Gross Estate P6,000,000 P23,000,0 P29,000,0
00 00
Less: Ordinary Deductions:
Conjugal ordinary deductions (2,000,000 (2,000,00
) 0)
Exclusive ordinary deductions (1,000,000) _________ (1,000,00
0)
Net Estate before special deductions 5,000,000 21,000,00 26,000,00
0 0
Special deductions
Family Home (P9M/2); lower between 4.5M and max. P10M (4,500,00
0)
Standard deduction (5,000,00
0)
Net estate before share of the surviving spouse 16,500,00
Case C – Decedent is married; Family Home is exclusive Exclusive Conjugal Total
valued
at more than P10,000,000
Conjugal properties:
Real and personal properties P14,000,0
00
Family Home P30,000,000
Exclusive properties 6,000,000 _________
Gross Estate P36,000,000 P14,000,0 P50,000,0
00 00
Less: Ordinary Deductions:
Conjugal ordinary deductions (2,000,000 (2,000,00
) 0)
Exclusive ordinary deductions (1,000,000) _________ (1,000,00
0)
Net Estate before special deductions 35,000,000 12,000,00 47,000,00
0 0
Special deductions
Family Home (maximum of P10M) (10,000,0
00)
Standard deduction (5,000,00
0)
Net estate before share of the surviving spouse 32,000,00
COMPLETE SEPARATION OF PROPERTY
When a man and a woman who are capacitated to marry each other, live
exclusively with each other as husband and wife without the benefit of
marriage or under a void marriage, the following rules shall apply:
1. Only the property acquired by BOTH of them through their actual joint
contribution of money, property, or industry shall be owned in common in
proportion to their respective contributions. (if silent, assume equal
shares)
2. The share of any party who is married to another shall accrue to the
absolute or conjugal partnership, as the case may be, if existing under the
valid marriage.
Classify the following as exclusive or conjugal property under Absolute Community of Property (ACOP)
and Conjugal Partnership of Gains (CPC). Write "C" in the space provided if the property is classified
as common property and write "E" if the property is classified as exclusive.
ITEM PROPERTY ACP CPG
1 Properties owned by the spouses before the marriage C E
2 Rental income on a property acquired before marriage. C C
3 Property acquired during marriage C C
4 Income on property described in #3 C C
5 Property acquired by gift before marriage C E
6 Income on property described in #5 C C
7 Property inherited during marriage E E
8 Income on property described in #7 E C
9 Property acquired during marriage from common fund C C
10 Income on property described in #9 C C
11 Car purchased during marriage using funds derived from practice of C C
profession
12 Property owned before marriage for personal and exclusive use of the E E
decedent.
13 Jewelry items during marriage for personal and exclusive use by the C E
decedent
Illustration 1
A non-resident alien, married, died on September 25, 2022. He left the following:
• Conjugal properties, Philippines P 5,000,000
• Exclusive properties, Philippines 2,000,000
• Conjugal properties, USA 10,000,000
• Exclusive properties, USA 5,000,000
The following deductions were claimed:
• Actual funeral expenses P1,250,000
• Judicial expenses 800,000
• Claims against the estate 1,725,000
• Transfer for public use 200,000
• Medical expenses 875,000
Included in the Philippines gross estate (conjugal) were the following:
• Domestic shares P 500,000
• Share in a partnership 1,000,000
• Other tangible personal properties 3,500,000
The Philippine exclusive properties were all tangible personal properties. These included a car, which was
inherited 3 1/2 years before the present decedent's death, and had a fair market value of P500,000.
**** Since the properties were already classified as exclusive and common,
it should be assumed that the exclusive properties were already inclusive of
transfer for public use
ILLUSTRATION 3
JL Cruz died intestate on September 30, 2021. He was survived by his wife and his two children. He left the
following properties:
• Land (1 ,000 sq. m.) inherited from his father 15 months before JL's death. Fair market value per tax
declaration at the time of JL's death, P20,000,000; Zonal value at the time of JL's death, P30,000 per sq.
m.
• House and lot (Family Home) acquired during the marriage, FMV, P50,000,000
• Other tangible personal properties (mode of acquisition unknown), FMV, P22,000,000;
The estate of the decedent’s father paid the estate tax on the land at the fair value of P25,000,000. During
the marriage, JL mortgaged the inherited land for P7,000,000 for the benefit of the family. He paid
P3,500,000 before he died.
Exclusive Conjugal Total
Land P30,000,000
House and Lot (Family Home) P50,000,000
Other tangible personal properties 22,000,000
Claims against insolvent persons 500,000 P102,500,000
Ordinary deductions:
Other claims against conjugal properties (5,000,000)
Claims against insolvent persons (500,000)
Unpaid mortgage** (3,500,000)
VANISHING DEDUCTION* (18,243,902) (13,560,976)
Net exclusive/conjugal P11,756,098 P63,500,000 P75,256,098
Special deductions:
Standard deduction (5,000,000)
Family Home (10,000,000)
Medical expenses –
Share of the surviving spouse ½ of 63.5M (31,750,000)
TAXABLE ESTATE P28,506,098
Estate Tax Due (P28,506,098 x 6%) P1,710,366
** P7,000,000 – 3,500,000 = P3,500,000
Value to take/Initial Basis*** ***The value to take shall be lower amount between the
P25,000,000 valuation at the time of death and the valuation upon inheritance
2nd Deduction: (25,000/102,500 )x 9,000,000 (P30M vs P25M). Likewise, the amount paid on the mortgage
(2,195,122) Final Basis should not be considered in computing the vanishing deduction
because the amount pertains to a mortgage entered into by
P22,804,878
Pedro during his lifetime. To be considered in computing the VD,
x VD rate
the mortgage should have been assumed on the property at the
80%
ILLUSTRATION 4
A resident alien. Single died intestate on October 10, 2022. the following data were provided to you:
House and lot. USA (family home)
P20,000,000
Investment in stock, Philippines 8,000,000
Investment in stock. USA
10,000,000
Investment in bonds, USA (85% of the business of the USA Corp. is in the Philippines)
7,000,000
Cash in bank. Philippines
3,000,000
Cash on hand. Philippines
500,000
Accounts receivable from a debtor who resides in USA (fully uncollectible)
2,000,000
Vehicles In the Philippines
8,000,000
Actual funeral expenses 1,500,000
Judicial expenses
3,000,000
Unpaid Philippine income tax for income in 2021 1,200,000
Loss on December 31, 2021 due to theft 800,000
Devise to Quezon City for children's playground 700,000
Medical expenses
5,000,000
House and lot, USA * P20,000,000
Investment in stock, Philippines 8,000,000
Investment in stock, USA 10,000,000
Investment in bonds, USA 7,000,000
Cash in bank, Philippines 3,000,000
Cash on hand, Philippines 500,000
Claim against insolvent person (fully uncollectible) 2,000,000
Car, Philippines 8,000,000
Devise to Quezon City for children’s playground** 700,000
Total Gross Estate P59,200,000
Ordinary Deductions:
Funeral expenses -
Judicial expenses -
Unpaid Philippine income tax for income in 2021 1,200,000
Loss on December 31, 2021 due to theft 800,000
Devise to Quezon City for children’s playground 700,000
Claim against insolvent person (fully uncollectible) *** 2,000,000 (4,700,000)
Special Deductions:
Standard deduction (5,000,000)
Medical expenses –
Net Taxable Estate P49,500,000
Estate Tax Due (P49,500,000 x 6%) P2,970,000
NOTE :
#1: The statement is applicable to CPG
#4: Under CPG, property brought into marriage is classified as exclusive property
#5: Shall be ½ of the net conjugal property
#6: The properties described in the problem shall be classified as exclusive properties.
#7: If the problem is silent or unless the type of property relationship is specifically
provided in the problem, the term “community” property is generally used in case of
Absolute Community Property regime. Thus, the statement in #7 is correct. On the other
hand, unless provided otherwise, the term “conjugal” property is generally used in case of
Conjugal Partnership of Gains regime.
(No. 23)
Conjugal properties 20,000,000
Conjugal Deductions**:
Funeral and judicial expenses (no longer allowed) -
Casualty losses (3,500,000)
Unpaid taxes (2,000,000)
Claim against the estate (4,500,000)
Net Conjugal properties before special deductions 10,000,000
Divide 2
Share of the Surviving Spouse 5,000,000
(No. 24)
Real property, Philippines 7,000,000
Real property, USA 5,000,000
Claim against insolvent persons 50,000
Claim against insolvent persons (50,000)
Unpaid taxes (50,000)
Balance 11,950,000
Standard Deductions (5,000,000)
Family Home (P1,500,000/2) (750,000)
Share of the surviving spouse (P11,950,000/2) (5,975,000)
Net Taxable Estate 225,000
25 Exclusive Common Total
Conjugal real properties 7,000,000
Conjugal family home 5,000,000
Paraphernal properties
(excluded; exclusive of the surviving spouse)
Exclusive properties 2,500,000 0
Total 2,500,000 12,000,000 14,500,000
Ordinary Deductions:
Unpaid taxes
Casualty losses (from excl.property) (100,000)
Other losses (P1M x 75%) (750,000) (850,000) (850,000)
Net Estate before Special Deductions 2,400,000 11,250,000 13,650,000
Special Deductions:
Standard Deductions (5,000,000)
Medical expenses -
Family Home (5,000,000/2) (2,500,000)
Share of the surviving spouse (P11,250,000/2) (5,625,000)
Net Taxable Estate 525,000
(No. 26 and 27) ABSOLUTE COMMUNITY OF PROPERTY
Exclusive Common
Properties-Land 24,000,000
Other personal property owned before marriage 16,000,000
Other personal property acquired during marriage 5,000,000
Gross Estate 24,000,000 21,000,000
Vanishing deduction (11,200,000)
Claim against the estate (2,000,000)
Losses (1,000,000)
Net conjugal before special deductions 18,000,000
Share of surviving spouse (P1,800,000/2) 9,000,000
(No. 28) CONJUGAL PARTNERSHIP OF GAINS
Exclusive Common Total
Properties-Land 24,000,000
Other personal property owned before marriage 16,000,000
Other personal property acquired during marriage**** 5,000,000
Gross Estate 40,000,000 5,000,000
45,000,000
Ordinary Deductions
Claim against the estate (2,000,000)
Losses (1,000,000)
Vanishing Deductions***** (11,200,000) 0
Net Estate Before Special Deductions 28,800,000 2,000,000
Share of the surviving spouse (P2,000,000/2)
(1,000,000)
****If silent or unless the problem clearly illustrate that it is exclusive, assume the property
is a common property.