Corrosion Mechanism Amm Carbamate Urea Plant
Corrosion Mechanism Amm Carbamate Urea Plant
Alstom, Växjö
NTT Consultancy
Table of contents
- Introduction
- Stamicarbon CO2-stripping process
- Mechanism of carbamate corrosion
- Role of process parameters on corrosion
- Materials of construction in urea synthesis
- Morphology of corrosion phenomena in carbamate
solutions
NTT Consultancy
Functional block diagram of the Stamicarbon
CO2 - stripping urea process
NH3 CO2
Synthesis
Low-pressure
recirculation
Finishing
Urea
NTT Consultancy
Urea processes
NTT Consultancy
Stamicarbon CO2 – stripping urea process
l m
Cooling
water
g e
Steam
h
water
f
i
Con-
TCW TCW
c densate j
d
Steam
NH3
Condensate
CO2 k
Steam
b
Condensate
Urea melt to
a granulation
NTT Consultancy
Synthesis section of urea 2000 plusTM pool
reactor design
Carbamate recycle
LP absorber
HP
NH3 Pool reactor Scrubber
CO2
HP Stripper
NTT Consultancy
Chemical reactions in urea synthesis
NTT Consultancy
Corrosion mechanism
NH2COO- … NH4+
NTT Consultancy
Passivation
Passivation reaction:
2 Cr + 3 H2O → Cr2O3 + 6 H+ + 6 e–
NTT Consultancy
Active corrosion
NTT Consultancy
Voltomogram of 316L UG (X2CrNiMo18-14-3) in urea
synthesis solution
5.000
3.000
I /area (mA/cm 2)
<
1.000
-1.000
-3.000
NTT Consultancy
Active behaviour of stainless steel in
ammonium carbamate
log ic 1 2 3
a+c Ea E
C
1 = active region
log ic 2 = passive region
3 = transpassive region
a = anodic reaction
c = cathodic reaction
a + c = sum curve
C = 2NH4+ + 2e 2NH3 + H2
NTT Consultancy
Active/passive behaviour of stainless steel
in ammonium carbamate
log ia
Ep
Ea e
c k
a+c+k
c+k
k represents the reaction O2 + 2H2O + 4e 4OH-
a + c + k = sum curve
Two zero potentials:
Ea = metal in active state
log iC
Ep = metal in passive state
NTT Consultancy
Passive behaviour of stainless steel in
ammonium carbamate
log ia
Ep
a+c+k Ep e
k
c
c+k
NTT Consultancy
Relevant process parameters on corrosion
- Temperature
- Chloride contamination
- Sulphide contamination
NTT Consultancy
Relation between oxygen concentration in the
liquid phase of a urea synthesis solution and the
active (A) – passive (P) behaviour
Oxygen AISI 316 L X2CrNiMoN X2CrNiMoN2 X1CrNi26-1
concentration (UG) 25-22-2 9-6-2 (super
(duplex steel) ferritic
steel)
< 0.1 ppm A A A/P? A/P?
NTT Consultancy
Temperature and oxygen pressure level in the
synthesis section of urea CO2 stripping process
temperature oxygen
pressure
oxygen pressure
temperature
- Influence of microstructure
presence of precipitations is detrimental for corrosion
resistance; susceptible to intergranular corrosion
NTT Consultancy
Tests to determine susceptibility to intergranular
corrosion of stainless steels
NTT Consultancy
Materials of construction in urea synthesis
X2CrNiMoN22-5-3
X2CrNiMoN25-6-3 duplex stainl. steels
X2CrNiMoN29-6-2
-
NTT Consultancy
Material of construction selection criteria for liquid
concentrated carbamate (>10% wt)
Temperature [oxygen] in liquid phase Materials of construction
°C ppm (wt)
NTT Consultancy
Material of construction selection criteria for liquid
diluted carbamate (<10% wt)
210 °C
170 °C
X2CrNiMo17-13-2
O2 free environment
X2CrNiMoN22-5-3
150 °C X2CrNiMoN29-6-2
O2 > 1 ppm
X2CrNiMo18-14-3
X2CrNi19-11
(316LUG)
X2CrNiMo17-13-2
120 °C
Tn °C X2CrNi19-11
X2CrNiMo17-13-2
Safurex
10
1
0.0 0.1 0.5 1.0 10.0 100.0
0.1
0.01
P P M Ox ygen
NTT Consultancy
Global composition of urea synthesis
solution (USS)
Mole fraction:
water: 31 %
ammonia: 39 %
urea: 18 %
carbamate: 12 %
NTT Consultancy
Morphology of corrosion phenomena in carbamate
solutions
NTT Consultancy
HP Stripper
N14 N4
Gas outlet N13 N14
N4
see sheet 7
N4 N13
N1
USO inlet N7
N1 N7
Rupture disk
Steam inlet
N5 N11 10 weep holes
N5
dia. 6mm
equally divided
see sheet 8
Alternative B Alternative C
N4
N12
diameter
Vent N1
N6 Condensate N7
N6 outlet
N8
N8
Combinations of
see sheet 9
diameter
N15 the alternitives A
N9 up to C allowed as
CO2 inlet well. N9
N3
N3 Alternative D is
N13 only allowed if
N10 diameter is smaller
GUSO outlet N2 then approximately N2 N10
Alternative A 1000mm Alternative D
NTT Consultancy
Top chamber of stripper
Lining or overlay
welding N14
N13
Bufferlayer
Overlay welding
Gas outlet to
HDCC 800 dia 1000
N4
N1
Liquid inlet
Lining or overlay from reactor
welding
10
Overlay welding
R**
N7
**
R must be 0.25
x channel wall
thickness with a
Bufferlayer minimum of 30mm Only alternitive A is drawn. Alternitives B up to
D(see sheet 6) are applicable.
NTT Consultancy
Liquid divider of stripper with hold down plate and
holding down bolts
8.5mm
vent/drain hole **
dia 26 At least 3 lifting
–1.0
30
lugs per hold down
dia 12
2 +0.0
2 plate segment
10
* 2
PTFE rings
Hold down plate thickness 2.5mm
sealweld A A
* Weld a 15mm long piece of dia
4mm wire parallel to the gastube,
Reactor wall material to be used: BC.05 acc. to
specification A4-18005. Section A-A
** Number of holes about 1/3 of the
600
A A
PTFE bushing PTFE rings
2 thickness 2.5mm
Tube plate
NTT Consultancy
Liquid divider of stripper
dia 12 3 holes equally
seal weld seal weld spaced; dia … +0.05
dia. 36
1.6
ID. 20
dia. 28 *
OD. 25
10
15
25
dia 31
50
586
Seal weld
11°
3
ID. 24
OD. 28 *
1.6
1.6
45
22
10.5
3 holes
12
1.6
dia 33.4 +0.05 – 0.00
dia 37
N8
2d
200
d 8
To be supported Straight
length 1.5d
LP R.A source for level
HP 25 25 Dia 27 -0.0 +0.5
measurement
Hole for HLS
N9**
***
****
N15
Min.
CO2 from
compressor 150
N3
Leak detection hole: *
Cyl. volume
800 dia 1000 dia. 5mm … m3
28
N15
**** 28 * See instrument data sheet, loop number L-200.
** Nozzles N9 and N10 prependicularly above
Dia. 55 N13 each other. Dia N9 to be checked by contractor.
Dia. 55
same level N10** *** Must satisfy the design code and 2mm
N2 corrosion allowance.
as N9 **** N15 and N9 on same elevation and 180° in
Hole for level opposite orientation
Outlet transmitter
NTT Consultancy
Active corrosion in stripper tube due to flooding
NTT Consultancy
Active corrosion in stripper tube due to flooding
NTT Consultancy
Standard inspection program (HP equipment / Stainless
Eddy Current measurement Stripper tubes
Steels)
Steam
Corroded
area
2 - 3 meters
Baffle
Area with α
Fe2O3 scale build
up
X new tubes
%-age of tubes
51 months
average value
74 months on
stream
X
40
X
20
NTT Consultancy
Condensation corrosion in liner top stripper
NTT Consultancy
Condensation corrosion in strip overlay welding
NTT Consultancy
Strain induced intergranular cracking
NTT Consultancy
Microphoto of strain induced intergranular cracking
NTT Consultancy
Preferential locations of strain induced
intergranular cracking
Strip
Cracks Liner
Vessel wall
Liner
Cracks
Vessel wall
Vessel wall
NTT Consultancy
Stern face attack protruding tube ends
NTT Consultancy
Pitting and SCC in HP stripper gas tube
NTT Consultancy
Microphoto of pitting and stress corrosion
cracking
NTT Consultancy
Crevice corrosion of gas tubes due to fouling
NTT Consultancy
Fouling of gas tubes HP Stripper
NTT Consultancy
Oil fouling of HP Strippers
NTT Consultancy
Erosion corrosion in valve
NTT Consultancy
Embrittled titanium heat exchanger tube
due to titanium hydride formation
NTT Consultancy
Corrosion in piping
NTT Consultancy
Condensation corrosion at thermowell
NTT Consultancy
Case: Intergranular corrosion in weld-o-let in HP
line of Urea plant
NTT Consultancy
Weld-o-let failure in process line from reactor to
HP stripper
NTT Consultancy
Location of failure in weld-o-let of thermowell
Thermowell
Failed here
RTJ flange
1½”
8” NB E.S. MPE
SS 316 175 mm
NTT Consultancy
Weld-o-let connection to pipeline
NTT Consultancy
Corroded areas at HAZ’s of weld-o-let
1 ½” NB pipe
Failed here
Corroded areas
NTT Consultancy
Ruptured weld-o-let
NTT Consultancy
Ruptured weld-o-let
NTT Consultancy
Weld-o-let with corroded HAZ’s
NTT Consultancy
Weld-o-let with corroded HAZ’s
4 mm
NTT Consultancy
Intergranular corrosion in HAZ of weld-o-let
50 m
NTT Consultancy
Radiographic examination indicating corrosion in
HAZ’s of weld-o-let and connecting 11/2” pipeline
NTT Consultancy
Steam & Condensate System in Fertilizer Plant
Inert vent
steam
150 ºC high
PIC 4.5 bar pressure
high pressure steam condenser
film evaporator drum
condensate
drain
flash tank
PIC
9 bar
LIC LIC
HIC
vent CW
PIC N2 purge
steam saturator
21 bar LIC vent steam
condenser
25 bar steam LIC
steam condensate blow-down
tank
BL
tsp
hydrazine
NTT Consultancy
SCC in tubes of HP Carbamate Condenser
Tube
Connection weld
Overlay weld
C-steel
tube sheet corroded
area
NTT Consultancy
External SCC in AISI 316L urea grade HP
Carbamate Condenser tube
NTT Consultancy
External SCC in AISI 316L urea grade HP
Carbamate Condenser tube
180 m
NTT Consultancy
Urea Synthesis solution compared to sulphur
trioxide and sulphuric acid in aqueous solution
Carbonic acid
Carbamic acid
Sulphuric acid
NTT Consultancy
Corrosion mechanism
NTT Consultancy
Corrosion mechanism
Log i
O2 + 2H2O + 4e 4OH-
NTT Consultancy
Increase of stripper outlet temperature
NTT Consultancy
Material designation BC.01 (A4-18005)
For acceptable materials, see: MS.26
1. Weld metals
NTT Consultancy
Material designation BC.01 (continued)
2. Huey test
3. Selective attack.
The penetration of selective attack as determined by microscopic examination after
the Huey test shall not exceed
Note
Where material according to BC.01 is required, also material according to BC.05
may be allowed. Stamicarbon to be consulted.
NTT Consultancy
Material Specification MS.26 (A4-18005)
All wrought material shall have a fully austenitic structure (max. ferrite content 0.6 %)
after final heat treatment at the mill with the following composition (% wt):
The following standard materials are acceptable provided that their composition
corresponds with the above values.
NTT Consultancy
Material designation BC.05
For acceptable materials, see: MS.34
1. Weld metals
Weld metal for overlay and connection welds.
All deposited weld metal shall after final heat treatment, if any, have a fully austenitic
structure (max. ferrite content 0.6 %) with the following composition (% wt):
C max. 0.040, Cr min. 24.0, Ni min. 21.0, Mo 1.90‑2.70, Mn min. 3.00
2. Huey test
The materials shall be Huey‑tested in accordance with Stamicarbon specification 53961
and shall meet the following requirements:
The average value of the overall attack for 5 boiling periods of 48 hours each, shall not
exceed 0.16 gr/m2 hr (1 m/48 hr).
3. Selective attack
The penetration of selective attack as determined by microscopic examination after the
Huey test shall nowhere exceed 70 m, in any direction
Note: Solidification defects in overlay welds are acceptable up to a depth of 100 m.
NTT Consultancy
Material Specification MS.34
All wrought material shall have a fully austenitic structure (max. ferrite content 0.6 %)
after final heat treatment at the mill, with the following composition (% wt):
The following standard materials are acceptable provided that their composition
corresponds with the above values.
NTT Consultancy
Material designation BE.06
For acceptable materials, see: MS.50
1. Weld metals
The chemical composition of the deposited weld metal may differ from the base
material but shall be of a similar material type.
The ferrite content in the deposited weld metal and heat affected zone of the weld
shall be 30‑70 %.
2. Streicher test
The materials shall be Streicher‑tested in accordance with Stamicarbon specification
71112 and shall meet the following requirements:
The value of the overall attack shall not exceed 0.7 gr/m 2 hr. (4.3 m/48 hr)
3. Selective attack
The penetration of selective attack as determined by microscopic examination after
the Streicher test shall nowhere exceed 70 m, in any direction.
Notes:
1. Solidification defects in overlay welds are acceptable up to a depth of 100m.
2. Heat exchanger tubes shall be tested for homogeneity (ferrite‑austenite ratio) by
eddy‑current testing in accordance with Stamicarbon specification 71108.
NTT Consultancy
Material Specification MS.50
NTT Consultancy