Comparison and ContrastComparison and ContrastEnga.docx
- 1. Comparison and Contrast Comparison and Contrast Engages in two alternatives Make a decision by comparing alternatives in a series of relevant points and deciding the best advantage Basis for C & C Comparison – find and emphasize similarities Contrast – find and emphasize differences Either must have a basis for comparing or contrasting Something in common In Writing Subject - Important, two subjects, limit to relevant and pertinent points Purpose - Reason to reveal new or important elements, insights
- 2. Audience – Educate and enlighten Analogy Extended analogies used to clarify abstract or complex ideas Comparison and/or contrast between two subjects analyzed through exploring aspects of the subjects using complex analytical, critical thinking skills Visualize a new way of seeing the subjects Organizational Structure Must follow and maintain one of the two formats for a compare and contrast writing Essay still has an introduction, body paragraphs, and conclusion Subject by Subject (Block) Subject A (paragraph) Point 1 Point 2 Point 3 Point 4 Subject B (paragraph) Point 1 Point 2 Point 3
- 3. Point 4 Point by Point (Alternating) Point 1 Subject A & B (paragraph) Point 2 Subject A & B (paragraph) Point 3 Subject A & B (paragraph) Point 4 Subject A & B (paragraph) Block Format Introduction paragraph – both subjects Body paragraphs – one subject at a time Conclusion paragraph – both subjects Do NOT mixt subjects in any body paragraphs Alternating Format Introduction – both subjects Body – both subjects but only one point at a time
- 4. Conclusion – both subjects Body paragraphs focus on one point at a time Questions: Is your subject more alike or different? Why are you making this comparison and/or contrast? What do you want to explore and express about these subjects? What is the ethical dilemma? Is your writing clear and focused? Have you maintained the organizational format? Include: Only two units of c/c A committed specific thesis Analytical Critical Thinking One writing pattern, format Assignment Compare a set of two films from the three sets: Watch the films closely taking notes. Contemplate and analyze the films. What is the ethical question in the films? How does the decision of the characters affect society?
- 5. Use quotes from the films as evidence. Let’s discuss some images For Example: Life Choices Prisoner Homeless Freedoms Demonstrate Vote
- 6. Moral Decisions War Peace The Question? Remember Compare two films Have a specific thesis Use analytical Critical Thinking Stay in one writing pattern, format What is the ethical decision in the films? DJCAE 100 Compare and Contrast Essay 1. Write a 1000 word essay. 2. Submit a formal outline in the MLA format (from handout and/or book). 3. Final copy will also be submitted on Livetext. 4. Essay should include introduction with a thesis statement, title in italics of boths films and the directors.
- 7. 5. Body includes examples from each film with the ethical decision being made. 6. Include quotes from the films as evidence. 7. Conclusion includes all aspects and reflection with the ethical decisions. 8. Do not do any research. Ideas should come from you and the film. Think about it. 9. Only research is from the films. These are your primary sources. There must be quotes from the films. The films must be cited correctly using the MLA format as a Works Cited at the end of the paper. 10. No first person “I” point of view. 11. Mode is Compare & Contrast. Write about the similarities, differences, or both. Must follow block or alternating pattern format. 12. Topic is your choice of one set of thetwo films from the list of sets. Choose one of the groups of two films from the sets of two. 13. Compare and/or contrast the ethical decision of each character. What was the event that led the characters to their decision? What was the decision? How did each character reach his or her decision? How was the film effective in conveying this? DJCAE 100 Compare and Contrast Outline 1) Write a detailed comprehensive outline for your compare and contrast paper. 2) You can use the Inspiration app on the iPad and then print it out and hand in. 3) A hard copy will be handed-in in-class on the specified due date. 4) Follow the Outline Guide for specific number of sections. Main Idea: COMPARE & CONTRAST OF TWO FILMS I. Intro A. Attention getter
- 8. B. Title of both films and directors B. Thesis statement - ethical decisions of characters C. General introduction of paper ideas II. Similarity 1: A. First Film is - 1. Example 2. Quote from film (include in-text citation) 3. Explanation 4. Description details B. Second Film is - 1. Example 2. Quote from film (include in-text citation) 3. Explanation 4. Description details III. Difference 1: A. First Film is - 1. Example 2. Quote from film (include in-text citation) 3. Explanation 4. Description details B. Second Film is - 1. Example 2. Quote from film (include in-text citation) 3. Explanation 4. Description details IV. Similarity 2: A. First Film is - 1. Example 2. Quote from film (include in-text citation) 3. Explanation 4. Description details B. Second Film is - 1. Example 2. Quote from film (include in-text citation) 3. Explanation 4. Description detail
- 9. V. Difference 2: A. First Film is - 1. Example 2. Quote from film (include in-text citation) 3. Explanation 4. Description detail B. Second Film is - 1. Example 2. Quote from film (include in-text citation) 3. Explanation 4. Description detail VI. Conclusion A. Summary (2-3 sentences) B. Restate thesis statement C. Interest – tie-in to introduction D. Impact/effect of ethical decision E. Final thought - Reflection DJCE 100 - Film choices for Compare & Contrast Essay 1) Norma Rae (1979, 20th Century Fox) Martin Ritt Silkwood (1983, ABC Motion Pictures) Mike Nichols 2) Born on the Fourth of July (1989, Universal Pictures) Oliver Stone Scott Camil Will Not Die (2011, Substream Films) Georg Koszolinski 3) A Better Life (2011, Summit Entm.) Chris Weitz The Namesake (2006, Fox Searchlight) Mira Nair 4) The Hunger Games (2012, Lionsgate) Gary Ross Divergent (2014, Summit Entertainment) Neil Burger