Effective Lectures
• When lecturing can be an effective pedagogical tool and how to build it into
course design
• What cognitive principles should be considered (e.g., attention, cognitive load
theory) when creating PowerPoint slides
• Effective principles for utilizing PowerPoint slides
Lecture as a tool
The Lecture
• According to McKeachie, the
lecture is the oldest teaching
method and still the most
widely (badly?) used in
universities throughout the
world.

• Don’t believe it is the oldest?
The Lecture
• Effective lecturers combine the talents of the
scholar, writer, producer, comedian, entertainer and teacher to
promote student learning.
• If you are one dimensional so is your teaching when using the lecture.
• No, the lecture is not the most effective teaching method available
to teachers but when a curriculum is focused on covering the most
content in the shortest amount of time, the lecture tends to be the
pedagogy du jour. So, lets’ focus on it.
• For future reference, discussion methods are superior to lectures in:
•
•

student retention of information after the end of the course;
transfer of knowledge to new situations;
The Lecture
• Strengths of lecture according to Cashin:
• Some other advantages attributed to lectures are
perhaps more relevant to graduate
instruction, especially for majors. Lectures can show
how experts in a field think, how they approach
questions, and how they try to solve a problem. A
lecture can summarize scattered material, or describe
latest discoveries or issues.
The Lecture
• Limitations of lecture according to Cashin:
• However, lecturing also has some serious limitations
when it becomes the primary means of instruction. The
most serious is that lecturing is not suited for higher
levels of learning: comprehension, application,
analysis, synthesis, evaluation (Bloom et al., 1956),
and creativity (Anderson and Krathwohl, 2001).
• Perhaps equally limiting, in a traditional lecture, the
students are mostly passive. This results in learners’
attention waning quickly. If a lecture consists solely of
the teacher talking, lack of student feedback can be a
big problem.
Try those first 4 slides
again
The Lecture: the oldest and most used
teaching method
The Lecture: Most common but not most
effective Teaching method

Discussion

Lecture

Higher in
retention &
transfer
Lower in
retention &
transfer
The Lecture
• Strengths of lecture according to Cashin:
•
•
•
•
•

Lectures can show how experts in a field think,
How they approach questions
How they try to solve a problem
Summarize scattered material
Describe latest discoveries or issues
The Lecture
• Limitations of lecture according to Cashin:
• Not suited for higher levels of learning:
comprehension, application, analysis, synthesis, evalu
ation and creativity
• Passive student
• Waning attention
Think-Pair-Share

Compare & Contrast the two styles
How are most lectures Given
today?
What do student think of
this?
Things people would rather do than
encounter a PowerPoint
• Forego sex tonight

• Do their taxes
• Go to the dentist
• Work on Saturday
Things to Consider
Cognitive

Brain

Effective
Lecture Design

Presentation

Techniques
Cognitive Considerations
“Whatever you think about, that’s
what you remember. Memory is
the residue of thought.”
-Cognitive Psychologist Daniel
Willingham
Cognitive Considerations

Learning
Attention

Active
Processing

Cognitive
Load

Working
Memory
Sweller’s Cognitive Theory

Limited
space in
working
memory!
Sweller’s Cognitive Load
Theory
Type

Description

Extraneous

Cognitive processing that does
not serve the instructional goal;
caused by confusing
instructional design.

Intrinsic
(Sometime
called
Essential)

Cognitive processing required to
represent the essential material
in working memory; cause by the
complexity of material.

Germane
(Sometime
called
Essential
Generative)

Cognitive processing required for
deeper understanding; caused
by motivation of the learner.

Germane
Load

Intrinsic
Load

Extraneous
Load

Total Cognitive Load
Brain Considerations
Brain Likes Novelty
Are your
lectures
engaging or
sleep
inducing?
Brain Considerations
• Passive brains + Passive body

learning

• Brain Guru John Medina explains
Presentation
Considerations
Death by PowerPoint
• Dead Words on Screen
• Black and White
• Lots of text!

• Read most or all dead words to your
student
• Student 17-30 years old easily bored
and impatient
Lecture or Target Practice?

Learning
Conclusion
Problems with Lectures
• Why don’t students read the text?
• It will be “covered” in lecture

• Flawed Assumption: I have to “cover” the
material or students won’t know it.
Passive learning equals superficial
learning
• Active learning = lasting learning
Any Use for Lectures? Yes
• Mini/micro lectures – 10-15 min. long
• Clarification, examples
• Separate with engaged learning activities

• Brain Guru John Medina again
• Targeted lectures – not to “cover”
material
• Purpose: to expand, address
confusions, or illustrate applications
• Test comprehension and promote critical
thinking
• E.g. present case study, scenario, realistic simulation
Techniques to make
Lectures more engaging
Next Time
Friday January 17
“Core Services: Engaging Lecture”

FCTE Lecture/PowerPoint Presentation

  • 1.
    Effective Lectures • Whenlecturing can be an effective pedagogical tool and how to build it into course design • What cognitive principles should be considered (e.g., attention, cognitive load theory) when creating PowerPoint slides • Effective principles for utilizing PowerPoint slides
  • 2.
  • 3.
    The Lecture • Accordingto McKeachie, the lecture is the oldest teaching method and still the most widely (badly?) used in universities throughout the world. • Don’t believe it is the oldest?
  • 4.
    The Lecture • Effectivelecturers combine the talents of the scholar, writer, producer, comedian, entertainer and teacher to promote student learning. • If you are one dimensional so is your teaching when using the lecture. • No, the lecture is not the most effective teaching method available to teachers but when a curriculum is focused on covering the most content in the shortest amount of time, the lecture tends to be the pedagogy du jour. So, lets’ focus on it. • For future reference, discussion methods are superior to lectures in: • • student retention of information after the end of the course; transfer of knowledge to new situations;
  • 5.
    The Lecture • Strengthsof lecture according to Cashin: • Some other advantages attributed to lectures are perhaps more relevant to graduate instruction, especially for majors. Lectures can show how experts in a field think, how they approach questions, and how they try to solve a problem. A lecture can summarize scattered material, or describe latest discoveries or issues.
  • 6.
    The Lecture • Limitationsof lecture according to Cashin: • However, lecturing also has some serious limitations when it becomes the primary means of instruction. The most serious is that lecturing is not suited for higher levels of learning: comprehension, application, analysis, synthesis, evaluation (Bloom et al., 1956), and creativity (Anderson and Krathwohl, 2001). • Perhaps equally limiting, in a traditional lecture, the students are mostly passive. This results in learners’ attention waning quickly. If a lecture consists solely of the teacher talking, lack of student feedback can be a big problem.
  • 7.
    Try those first4 slides again
  • 8.
    The Lecture: theoldest and most used teaching method
  • 9.
    The Lecture: Mostcommon but not most effective Teaching method Discussion Lecture Higher in retention & transfer Lower in retention & transfer
  • 10.
    The Lecture • Strengthsof lecture according to Cashin: • • • • • Lectures can show how experts in a field think, How they approach questions How they try to solve a problem Summarize scattered material Describe latest discoveries or issues
  • 11.
    The Lecture • Limitationsof lecture according to Cashin: • Not suited for higher levels of learning: comprehension, application, analysis, synthesis, evalu ation and creativity • Passive student • Waning attention
  • 12.
  • 13.
    How are mostlectures Given today?
  • 14.
    What do studentthink of this?
  • 15.
    Things people wouldrather do than encounter a PowerPoint • Forego sex tonight • Do their taxes • Go to the dentist • Work on Saturday
  • 16.
  • 17.
  • 18.
    “Whatever you thinkabout, that’s what you remember. Memory is the residue of thought.” -Cognitive Psychologist Daniel Willingham
  • 19.
  • 20.
  • 21.
    Sweller’s Cognitive Load Theory Type Description Extraneous Cognitiveprocessing that does not serve the instructional goal; caused by confusing instructional design. Intrinsic (Sometime called Essential) Cognitive processing required to represent the essential material in working memory; cause by the complexity of material. Germane (Sometime called Essential Generative) Cognitive processing required for deeper understanding; caused by motivation of the learner. Germane Load Intrinsic Load Extraneous Load Total Cognitive Load
  • 22.
  • 23.
    Brain Likes Novelty Areyour lectures engaging or sleep inducing?
  • 24.
    Brain Considerations • Passivebrains + Passive body learning • Brain Guru John Medina explains
  • 25.
  • 26.
    Death by PowerPoint •Dead Words on Screen • Black and White • Lots of text! • Read most or all dead words to your student • Student 17-30 years old easily bored and impatient
  • 27.
    Lecture or TargetPractice? Learning
  • 28.
  • 29.
    Problems with Lectures •Why don’t students read the text? • It will be “covered” in lecture • Flawed Assumption: I have to “cover” the material or students won’t know it. Passive learning equals superficial learning • Active learning = lasting learning
  • 30.
    Any Use forLectures? Yes • Mini/micro lectures – 10-15 min. long • Clarification, examples • Separate with engaged learning activities • Brain Guru John Medina again
  • 31.
    • Targeted lectures– not to “cover” material • Purpose: to expand, address confusions, or illustrate applications • Test comprehension and promote critical thinking • E.g. present case study, scenario, realistic simulation
  • 32.
    Techniques to make Lecturesmore engaging Next Time Friday January 17 “Core Services: Engaging Lecture”

Editor's Notes

  • #3 By Howard Dickinshttp://www.flickr.com/photos/dorkomatic/5874024242/in/photolist-9X4UL3-8EmH4A-9X24un-9X4V9o-8ChUeR-85i4Ug-c6bmEy-85megQ-84Wmgs-cF79X1-eGrsYf-7QEABS-9pvoQJ-7QBgjk-89N3Zi-a7NKzn-8b4cZg-8416Nc-acquUy-acqv2Q-dJzboZ-8JA6QE-8nxbP8-8e9EpU-7QBgor-ajjHZf-8Pscxd-9X4VJQ-eq4ymJ-diRD56-gMyzxm-99zrEv-bDKJET-8JajbV-dumgJ6-e2qdsb-97Ee5j-aLaWv2-7LSbs5-8Vpg7v-duPqWG-eP2pe5-cJA8aj-bA5tUg-aUPX9v-bnaCkN-bnaCgo-8TQYST-8V3hwh-8nTJ81-7Gjw8E/
  • #4 McKeachie, W.J., and Svinicki, M. (2006). McKeachie’s teaching tips: Strategies, research, and theory for college and university teachers (12th ed.). Boston: Houghton Mifflin. This illustration from a fourteenth-century manuscript shows Henry of Germany delivering a lecture to university students in Bologna. 
Artist: Laurentius de Voltolina; Liber ethicorum des Henricus de Alemannia; Kupferstichkabinett SMPK, Berlin/Staatliche Museen 
PreussiischerKulturbesitz, Min. 1233
  • #7 Cashin, William. (2010). Effective Lecturing: Idea Paper #46. The Idea Center: Insight. Improvement. Impact.
  • #9 McKeachie, W.J., and Svinicki, M. (2006). McKeachie’s teaching tips: Strategies, research, and theory for college and university teachers (12th ed.). Boston: Houghton Mifflin. This illustration from a fourteenth-century manuscript shows Henry of Germany delivering a lecture to university students in Bologna. 
Artist: Laurentius de Voltolina; Liber ethicorum des Henricus de Alemannia; Kupferstichkabinett SMPK, Berlin/Staatliche Museen 
PreussiischerKulturbesitz, Min. 1233
  • #10 Effective lecturers combine the talents of the scholar, writer, producer, comedian, entertainer and teacher to promote student learning.If you are one dimensional so is your teaching when using the lecture.No, the lecture is not the most effective teaching method available to teachers but when a curriculum is focused on covering the most content in the shortest amount of time, the lecture tends to be the pedagogy du jour. So, lets’ focus on it.For future reference, discussion methods are superior to lectures in:student retention of information after the end of the course; transfer of knowledge to new situations;For future reference, discussion methods are superior to lectures in:student retention of information after the end of the course; transfer of knowledge to new situations;
  • #12 Cashin, William. (2010). Effective Lecturing: Idea Paper #46. The Idea Center: Insight. Improvement. Impact.
  • #14 Photo:AndriusPetruceniaTitle: A public lecture by AndriusKubilius, Prime Minister of Lithuania 2010Url: http://www.flickr.com/photos/andriux_uk_events/4729659879/
  • #15 http://sofushka.files.wordpress.com/2011/12/bsl.jpgUse laser pointer topointout students not paying attention
  • #16 Berk, R. A. ( 2012, April). Top 10 evidence-based, best practices for PowerPoint in the Classroom. Transformative Dialogues: Teaching & Learning Journal, 5 (3), 1-7.
  • #19 Source: Willingham. D. (2009) Why Don’t Students Like School…
  • #20 Clip art – Brain or thinkingAttentionCognitive loadWorking memory
  • #21 Working memory has limited space Consider what students are or should be thinking aboutDoes my lecture achieve my goal of what they should be thinking?Photo credit http://www.flickr.com/photos/60929693@N07/5801417258/Title: overflow
  • #22 Table 3.4. Three Kinds of Cognitive Load cognitive processing during learning that Mayer, Richard E. (2012-03-22). Multimedia Learning (Kindle Locations 1512-1514). Cambridge University Press. Kindle Edition. Extraneous Load: Mental work that irrelevant to learning goalWaste space Intrinsic Load: Element interactivity: several knowledge elements must be coordinated in working memory to accomplish as task. Can’t be alter by instructional designPrior knowledge or skills the students have (or don’t have – increases intrinsic cognitive load)Experts have automate skills – frees up intrinsic loadSimple tasks for experts are complicated tasks for novices that require multiple stepsGermane Load:Mental work imposed by instructional designUse diverse examples or methodsLead to better learning outcome
  • #25 Irony of lecture: lots of sitting
  • #27 Berk, R. A. ( 2012, April). Top 10 evidence-based, best practices for PowerPoint in the Classroom. Transformative Dialogues: Teaching & Learning Journal, 5 (3), 1-7.