NETWORKING WITH
FARMERS &
FARMERGROUPS

         R P Singh
Associate Director Extension
  Directorate of Extension
         Education
a few questions
             How will we feed the world?
How will we manage the commons?
How will we allocate the world’s biomass to meet
our food, feed, fuel, and fiber needs?
How do we keep market forces from
squeezing out small producers?
How do we make public food service
a driver of sustainability and health?
Where do individuals go for
help in solving problems?
                                                Non-electronic
     Non-electronic
      documents                         Intranet documents Contacts in
                                                              other offices


                        Firm boundary
Internet
                                                                       Internal
                                                                      electronic
                                                                      networks

 External
electronic
                                                                   Co-located
networks
              Other                                                colleagues
             contacts
Knowledge networking
through communities of
practice        Connecting people
                         so that they
                     collaborate, share
                     ideas, and create
                         knowledge
What are communities of
practice?
• Groups of people who come
  together to share and to learn from
  one another face-to-face and/or
  virtually.
• They are held together by a
  common interest in a body of
  knowledge and are driven by a
  desire and need to share problems,
  experiences, insights, templates,
  tools, and best practices.
Communities are the grease in the
KM wheel


                KM
 Embedding                  Creating
 knowledge                 knowledge
                       C

Disseminating              Organizing
  knowledge                knowledge
Two extreme communities
of practice
   Face-to-face




                  Virtual
Encourage an open
innovation attitude
   Closed attitude             Open attitude
                           Not all the smart people
                           work for us. We need to
  The smart people in
                           work with smart people
  our field work for us.
                            inside and outside the
                                   company.

 If you create the most     If you make the best
  and the best ideas in      use of internal and
  the industry, you will     external ideas, you
           win.                    will win.


                                Chesborough 2003
Agricultural
Innovation Value
Chain    AAFC                        IC                          CFIA


Idea                  Innovation             Commercialized               Adopted


         scientists                company                     farmers

                                                          producers                 HC

       municipalities                consumers                retailers


                  Consumption                    Market                   Food
Waste
                                                                          product

            EC                            HC                   CFIA
Group Dialogue
• Dialogue is NOT:
  • Discussion, deliberation,
    negotiation
  • Committee, team, task or
    working group
  • Majority wins, minority
    dominance, groupthink
• Dialogue IS:
  • Free-flowing exchange of ideas
    among equals
                         ( Sunstein, 2006)
  • All ideas are solicited and are
    considered
Network
Relationships
                   Governments

    Businesses                   People


                   Department

   Practitioners                  Educators

Agreements,
                     NGOs
Outputs,
Inputs
Network
Structure
Types of Informal
Agreements
• Group: few participants; elicit
 knowledge; unstructured;
 aggregating knowledge (CFIA
 Modeling Framework Group)

• Communities: many participants;
 share knowledge; self-directed;
 common interest (departmental IM
 community)

• Networks: massive participants;
 peer production; emergent
 processes; common ownership
Is there a place for family farms?
Family Farming

• Versus agro-industrial
  farming
• Family has control over
  resources
• Family takes decisions in
  relation to the
  management of the farm
Networking with farmers & farmergroups
The contribution of agriculture to livelihoods is
evident from the fact that 70 percent of the world’s
poor people, including the poorest of the poor, and 75
percent of the world’s malnourished live in rural
areas, where most of them are involved in agriculture.
So what’s wrong?



      •Food crisis
      •Environmental crisis
      •Climate crisis
      •Financial crisis

      All of them are interlinked…
CRISIS


•Ecological: deforestation, genetic resources disappear,
toxic wastes, climate change,Hunger and Poverty:
    • Food Production: 175 % increase between 1975 and 2005
    16 % more food per person
    • 15 % world population undernourished
Financial crisis interlinked


    Solution for one; more problems for others?
Technology and science


•Green revolution did NOT improve access to food for
poor people; wonder seeds are not pro-poor, don’t
take into account the complexity of farming systems
•India: poorest 30 % of population (285 million!) no
increase in food and nutrient intake during the last 25
years
•Environmental problems: erosion, soil intoxification,
increase in pests and diseases…
Can family farming feed the world?

•‘You don’t have another choice than promote small-scale
agriculture. Those small farmers don’t have another option, there
are no jobs in industry or services for them. In the short term you
can only strive for more means for small farmers, if not, you will
create a massive emigraton from rural areas.‘

• ‘There’s more, small-scale agriculture has 3 big advantages.
Firstly there’s more respect for the environment, just because
there’s no money for pesticides and chemical fertilizers. That
kind of agriculture is more in harmony with the environment and
the climate.
•Secondly, it is a labour-intensive production, creating a lot of
jobs.
•And thirdly, it can be a very productive agriculture, on the
condition that those farmers have access to the know-how that is
needed.
Definition of a Group

A collection of
individuals, the
members accept a
common task,
become
interdependent in
their performance,
and interact with
one another to
promote its
Various Types of Groups



Formal groups        Informal Groups        Small groups
                                            Large groups
                                            Primary groups
  Command            Friendship
                                            Secondary groups
   groups              groups
                                            Coalitions
  Task groups        Interest groups
                                            Membership groups
                                            Reference groups
Stages of Group
Development
Challeng
 es
• Legislative
• Policy
• Regulatory
• Financial
• Infrastructure
• Human
  resources
• Cultural
  factors
                   (Neish, 2007)
• Intellectual
  Property
Road to
•
     Success
    Support from
    senior
    management
•   Clear
    understandable
    statement of what
    you want to do and
    why
•   Good working
    relationships with
    corporate and
    legal enablers
•   Willingness to
    compromise on         (Neish, 2007)
    issues that are not
    mission critical
•   Perseverance and
Capturin
g Value
Bring it inside the organization




  Stabilize it; make it work
Conclusi
      ons
• Social networks have both promise
  and peril
• Consider both strengths and
  weaknesses
• Analyze both opportunities and
  threats


• Is it a tool in search of a problem,
  or does it solve a recognized
  problem?
• What will it do (or do better) that
Thanks for your attention…


                      Can I shed
                      more light on
                      the subject?

More Related Content

PPT
Discovering The Value Of Social Networks and Communities of Practice
PPT
Communities Of Practice Teigland
PDF
Basic networkconceptsnewfoundland
PDF
Community Organisers - Civil Society Innovation Network 23 Jan 2012
PDF
LLC Webinar Series: Are you a Network Weaver?
PDF
Communities of practice
PPTX
Se hub pres v2
PDF
Communities of Practice Intro
Discovering The Value Of Social Networks and Communities of Practice
Communities Of Practice Teigland
Basic networkconceptsnewfoundland
Community Organisers - Civil Society Innovation Network 23 Jan 2012
LLC Webinar Series: Are you a Network Weaver?
Communities of practice
Se hub pres v2
Communities of Practice Intro

What's hot (20)

PPTX
Iabc world conference keynote
PPT
Introduction and benefits of Communities of Practice
PDF
Community Development
PPTX
The 5 Must-Avoid Collaboration Mistakes
PDF
eLeadership model
PPTX
Strategic Communities of Practice
DOC
Defining Communities of Practice
PDF
Collaborative behaviours
PPT
Dialogue and Deliberation for civic engagement in chicago
PPT
Communities of practice presentation
PPTX
Crimmins networking webinar slides 3 13-12
PDF
Seduction Of The Swarm: Understanding patterns of online participation
PPT
Community of Practice & Civic Infrastructure
PPTX
Beyond functional silos with communities of practice
PPT
Social Media in Government
KEY
(160) Presentation On Efficiency ( Glasgow, November 2010)
PDF
Community Planning: Principles, Methods and Strategies
PDF
Social media! are you ready?
PDF
Intentions, Processes and Frameworks for Change
PDF
Brief History of IxDA
Iabc world conference keynote
Introduction and benefits of Communities of Practice
Community Development
The 5 Must-Avoid Collaboration Mistakes
eLeadership model
Strategic Communities of Practice
Defining Communities of Practice
Collaborative behaviours
Dialogue and Deliberation for civic engagement in chicago
Communities of practice presentation
Crimmins networking webinar slides 3 13-12
Seduction Of The Swarm: Understanding patterns of online participation
Community of Practice & Civic Infrastructure
Beyond functional silos with communities of practice
Social Media in Government
(160) Presentation On Efficiency ( Glasgow, November 2010)
Community Planning: Principles, Methods and Strategies
Social media! are you ready?
Intentions, Processes and Frameworks for Change
Brief History of IxDA
Ad

Viewers also liked (6)

PPT
10 tips for effective e mail
PPSX
How to-write-and-deliver-a-succesful-speech
PPT
You want to deliver an effective speech?
PPTX
Lecture 8 giving speech.
PPTX
Writing a speech
10 tips for effective e mail
How to-write-and-deliver-a-succesful-speech
You want to deliver an effective speech?
Lecture 8 giving speech.
Writing a speech
Ad

Similar to Networking with farmers & farmergroups (20)

PDF
Izmir2010 anttila
PDF
What are Communities of Practice?
PDF
Knowledge Across Borders
PDF
Knowledge Based Norway-10-6-10-mg russell
PPTX
Knowledge and communication in the Livestock and Fish Research Program: The f...
PPTX
Social Media
PDF
America21 - Portland Urban Innovation Roundtable
PDF
Portland Urban Innovation Roundtable - Strategic Assembly Plan - June 2012
PDF
Challenge future
PPTX
Energizing the Rural Policy Voice: Building Collaborative Capacity for Policy...
PPTX
10 17-11 katherine-fulton_nw_presentation
PPTX
Building Collaborative Capacity for Policy Change
PPTX
The Rainforest
PPT
Social Networking in Government
PDF
Copenh thomas andersson_dec18final
PPTX
10 17-11 networks 101 geo conference
PPTX
Communities of practice
PPTX
M&E tools for NGO capacity building, by CHF International
PPTX
Communities of Practice
Izmir2010 anttila
What are Communities of Practice?
Knowledge Across Borders
Knowledge Based Norway-10-6-10-mg russell
Knowledge and communication in the Livestock and Fish Research Program: The f...
Social Media
America21 - Portland Urban Innovation Roundtable
Portland Urban Innovation Roundtable - Strategic Assembly Plan - June 2012
Challenge future
Energizing the Rural Policy Voice: Building Collaborative Capacity for Policy...
10 17-11 katherine-fulton_nw_presentation
Building Collaborative Capacity for Policy Change
The Rainforest
Social Networking in Government
Copenh thomas andersson_dec18final
10 17-11 networks 101 geo conference
Communities of practice
M&E tools for NGO capacity building, by CHF International
Communities of Practice

More from G B Pant University of Agriculture & Technology, Pantnagar, (U S Nagar), Uttarakhand, India (20)

DOCX

Recently uploaded (20)

PDF
The Relationship between Leadership Behaviourand Firm Performance in the Read...
PPTX
Accounting Management SystemBatch-4.pptx
PPTX
OS ALL UNITS MATxtdtc5ctc5cycgctERIAL.pptx
PPTX
Capital Investment in IS Infrastracture and Innovation (SDG9)
PDF
audit case scenario .pdf by icai ca inter
PDF
The Impact of Policy Changes on Legal Communication Strategies (www.kiu.ac.ug)
PDF
Nante Industrial Plug Socket Connector Sustainability Insights
PDF
El futuro empresarial 2024 una vista gen
DOCX
Handbook of entrepreneurship- Chapter 10 - Feasibility analysis by Subin K Mohan
PPTX
Warehouse. B pptx
PDF
The Evolution of Legal Communication through History (www.kiu.ac.ug)
PDF
109422672-Doc-8973-05-Security-Manual-Seventh-Edition.pdf
PPTX
IndustrialAIGuerillaInnovatorsARCPodcastEp3.pptx
PPTX
TS - CIM-as of august 2023 .pptx
PDF
Management Theories and Digitalization at Emirates Airline
PDF
the role of manager in strategic alliances
PPTX
UNIT 3 INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS [Autosaved].pptx
PPTX
organizational behavior notes prepared by sonam lama sawan lama
PDF
COVID-19 Primer for business case prep.pdf
PDF
The Accidental Empire. How Google’s Founders Stumbled Into History
The Relationship between Leadership Behaviourand Firm Performance in the Read...
Accounting Management SystemBatch-4.pptx
OS ALL UNITS MATxtdtc5ctc5cycgctERIAL.pptx
Capital Investment in IS Infrastracture and Innovation (SDG9)
audit case scenario .pdf by icai ca inter
The Impact of Policy Changes on Legal Communication Strategies (www.kiu.ac.ug)
Nante Industrial Plug Socket Connector Sustainability Insights
El futuro empresarial 2024 una vista gen
Handbook of entrepreneurship- Chapter 10 - Feasibility analysis by Subin K Mohan
Warehouse. B pptx
The Evolution of Legal Communication through History (www.kiu.ac.ug)
109422672-Doc-8973-05-Security-Manual-Seventh-Edition.pdf
IndustrialAIGuerillaInnovatorsARCPodcastEp3.pptx
TS - CIM-as of august 2023 .pptx
Management Theories and Digitalization at Emirates Airline
the role of manager in strategic alliances
UNIT 3 INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS [Autosaved].pptx
organizational behavior notes prepared by sonam lama sawan lama
COVID-19 Primer for business case prep.pdf
The Accidental Empire. How Google’s Founders Stumbled Into History

Networking with farmers & farmergroups

  • 1. NETWORKING WITH FARMERS & FARMERGROUPS R P Singh Associate Director Extension Directorate of Extension Education
  • 2. a few questions How will we feed the world?
  • 3. How will we manage the commons?
  • 4. How will we allocate the world’s biomass to meet our food, feed, fuel, and fiber needs?
  • 5. How do we keep market forces from squeezing out small producers?
  • 6. How do we make public food service a driver of sustainability and health?
  • 7. Where do individuals go for help in solving problems? Non-electronic Non-electronic documents Intranet documents Contacts in other offices Firm boundary Internet Internal electronic networks External electronic Co-located networks Other colleagues contacts
  • 8. Knowledge networking through communities of practice Connecting people so that they collaborate, share ideas, and create knowledge
  • 9. What are communities of practice? • Groups of people who come together to share and to learn from one another face-to-face and/or virtually. • They are held together by a common interest in a body of knowledge and are driven by a desire and need to share problems, experiences, insights, templates, tools, and best practices.
  • 10. Communities are the grease in the KM wheel KM Embedding Creating knowledge knowledge C Disseminating Organizing knowledge knowledge
  • 11. Two extreme communities of practice Face-to-face Virtual
  • 12. Encourage an open innovation attitude Closed attitude Open attitude Not all the smart people work for us. We need to The smart people in work with smart people our field work for us. inside and outside the company. If you create the most If you make the best and the best ideas in use of internal and the industry, you will external ideas, you win. will win. Chesborough 2003
  • 13. Agricultural Innovation Value Chain AAFC IC CFIA Idea Innovation Commercialized Adopted scientists company farmers producers HC municipalities consumers retailers Consumption Market Food Waste product EC HC CFIA
  • 14. Group Dialogue • Dialogue is NOT: • Discussion, deliberation, negotiation • Committee, team, task or working group • Majority wins, minority dominance, groupthink • Dialogue IS: • Free-flowing exchange of ideas among equals ( Sunstein, 2006) • All ideas are solicited and are considered
  • 15. Network Relationships Governments Businesses People Department Practitioners Educators Agreements, NGOs Outputs, Inputs
  • 17. Types of Informal Agreements • Group: few participants; elicit knowledge; unstructured; aggregating knowledge (CFIA Modeling Framework Group) • Communities: many participants; share knowledge; self-directed; common interest (departmental IM community) • Networks: massive participants; peer production; emergent processes; common ownership
  • 18. Is there a place for family farms?
  • 19. Family Farming • Versus agro-industrial farming • Family has control over resources • Family takes decisions in relation to the management of the farm
  • 21. The contribution of agriculture to livelihoods is evident from the fact that 70 percent of the world’s poor people, including the poorest of the poor, and 75 percent of the world’s malnourished live in rural areas, where most of them are involved in agriculture.
  • 22. So what’s wrong? •Food crisis •Environmental crisis •Climate crisis •Financial crisis All of them are interlinked…
  • 23. CRISIS •Ecological: deforestation, genetic resources disappear, toxic wastes, climate change,Hunger and Poverty: • Food Production: 175 % increase between 1975 and 2005 16 % more food per person • 15 % world population undernourished Financial crisis interlinked Solution for one; more problems for others?
  • 24. Technology and science •Green revolution did NOT improve access to food for poor people; wonder seeds are not pro-poor, don’t take into account the complexity of farming systems •India: poorest 30 % of population (285 million!) no increase in food and nutrient intake during the last 25 years •Environmental problems: erosion, soil intoxification, increase in pests and diseases…
  • 25. Can family farming feed the world? •‘You don’t have another choice than promote small-scale agriculture. Those small farmers don’t have another option, there are no jobs in industry or services for them. In the short term you can only strive for more means for small farmers, if not, you will create a massive emigraton from rural areas.‘ • ‘There’s more, small-scale agriculture has 3 big advantages. Firstly there’s more respect for the environment, just because there’s no money for pesticides and chemical fertilizers. That kind of agriculture is more in harmony with the environment and the climate. •Secondly, it is a labour-intensive production, creating a lot of jobs. •And thirdly, it can be a very productive agriculture, on the condition that those farmers have access to the know-how that is needed.
  • 26. Definition of a Group A collection of individuals, the members accept a common task, become interdependent in their performance, and interact with one another to promote its
  • 27. Various Types of Groups Formal groups Informal Groups  Small groups  Large groups  Primary groups  Command  Friendship  Secondary groups groups groups  Coalitions  Task groups  Interest groups  Membership groups  Reference groups
  • 29. Challeng es • Legislative • Policy • Regulatory • Financial • Infrastructure • Human resources • Cultural factors (Neish, 2007) • Intellectual Property
  • 30. Road to • Success Support from senior management • Clear understandable statement of what you want to do and why • Good working relationships with corporate and legal enablers • Willingness to compromise on (Neish, 2007) issues that are not mission critical • Perseverance and
  • 31. Capturin g Value Bring it inside the organization Stabilize it; make it work
  • 32. Conclusi ons • Social networks have both promise and peril • Consider both strengths and weaknesses • Analyze both opportunities and threats • Is it a tool in search of a problem, or does it solve a recognized problem? • What will it do (or do better) that
  • 33. Thanks for your attention… Can I shed more light on the subject?

Editor's Notes

  • #8: My research at three different companies, Cap Gemini, Icon Medialab, and Ericsson. What do you think used most?
  • #9: See that increasingly through informal networks that info is found and work gets done. Considerable research done on communities of practice, networks of practice. Temporary structures – cps Why do you think this way? Easier than following the traditional chains, don’t know the person, prestige, speak same language, identify with individual, trust. Result is that informal structure better at promoting flexibility, innovation, efficiency Yet unfortunately, mgt in many orgs do not pay attention or provide these networks with resources. Often know little about our own networks outside the closest 5-6 people. And in fact we often treat as invisible enemy, can’t see it, can’t manage it, and one that keeps decisions from being made and work from getting done. But today hope to deepen your understanding of these networks. Company’s intelligence is in its social systems, not in its computer systems – this is data. Tools for developing mutual knowledge
  • #10: Communities of Practice: Boundary spanning A channel for knowledge to flow Means to strengthen the social fabric The locus of knowledge creation and use Solve the problem of getting knowledge to those who need it. COPs, more than any other organization, develop strong feelings of social capital Communication and Ke exchange a regular part of COPs Development of special codes and routines (overlapping knowledge) Training new members - mix of experts/novices New ideas easily flow War stories and gossip critical for exchanging knowledge
  • #11: End this session with our definition of KM
  • #13: Alliances - In addition, they found that successful collaboration between university and industry was often the result of emergent personal relationships. Kreiner & Schulz RD - 40% of potential solutions and opportunities derived from personal external contacts powell et al - interorganizational networks in biotech industry provide knowledge critical to innovation mgt unaware of what going on - 10 vs 57 ongoing efforts at partnering in multinational telecom company.
  • #15: It is important to understand that social networking groups are different from traditional groups found in government departments. Describe what they are not. Describe what they are.
  • #16: This chart places a department in the context of various types external organizations that it might interact with. Discuss the six types of organizations. Note that governments refer to other departments or governments. Interactions with the parent government is through the departmental mandate and budget. Each of these is situated in a different region of the service delivery spectrum, meaning that each type of interaction will be different. Note that these organizations interact with each other as well as a department. The arrows represent two-way agreements between our department and other organizations, the flow of outputs (services) from us to external organizations, and the flow of inputs (services) from external organizations to us. This is a simplified view.
  • #17: A network really looks something like this, with every department connected to every other department. Each connection in a network is called a “node.” Reflect, for a moment on everything that each of the simple connecting lines represents: agreements, content, services, and delivery strategy.
  • #18: Informal agreements can be grouped into three categories. Groups consist of 5-10 people; any larger and synergy is lost in the logistics of participation. Eliciting knowledge means finding out what people might know but haven’t or can’t express. Unstructured means going wherever the dialogue leads and taking whatever time is needed to understand things. Aggregating means considering everything that is known by all members of the groupThe best answers will probably be found in the outliers, not in what everyone already knows. Communities comprise 20-30 people with a common interest; an adequate sample but allows personal trust. More about finding existing expertise and experience; avoiding duplication, reinvention. Self-directed means that the community itself sets the rules of participation, not the organization. Passive mechanisms are needed to “harvest” community outputs to benefit an organization Networks normally comprise more than 100 people; most problems can be solved with enough “eyeballs.” Peer production means that all participants and all knowledge are equal. Emergent processes (complexity theory) means that with enough “agents” outcomes emerge that could not have been predicted.
  • #30: There are a number of challenges to implementing social networks in government departments. A department’s legal mandate may not be suited to SN The policy framework may not permit SN Regulatory activities may be incompatible with SN Financing external activities may be problematic for SN The departmental infrastructure may not support SN HR capacity may be inadequate to implement SN Creating a sharing culture remains a key barrier to SN Protecting departmental IP may be difficult with SN
  • #31: Fortunately, there is a path that leads to social networking success. Describe the five steps.
  • #32: The key question is: if a department participates in a social network, how does it “capture value” from commonly held external intellectual property? The answer, in a few words, is to bring it inside the organization. The common property has to be stabilized. A report, policy, or regulation cannot change once it is formalized. Internal value has to be added by ensuring that it works. For example, in policy, all stakeholder concerns must be addressed; in business, an innovation must be producible and marketable. A key implication is that a department must retain enough internal core capacity to be able to add value to commonly-held IP.
  • #33: In summary, there are a few important things to consider about social networking. Describe the three analyses Describe the two questions
  • #34: I’ll conclude with a few words from THE management guru of the 20 th century. Meanwhile, I’ll be happy to answer any questions that you might have.