Software Verification
PROGRAM NAME: SAP2000
REVISION NO.: 0
AS 3600-2009 Example 002
P-M INTERACTION CHECK FOR COMPRESSION-CONTROLLED RECTANGULAR COLUMN
EXAMPLE DESCRIPTION
The Demand/Capacity ratio for a given axial loading and moment is tested in this
example.
In this example, a reinforced concrete column is subjected to factored axial load
N = 1733 kN and moment My = 433 kN-m. This column is reinforced with five
25M bars. The design capacity ratio is checked by hand calculations and the
result is compared with computed results. The column is designed as a short,
non-sway member.
GEOMETRY, PROPERTIES AND LOADING
1733 kN
My= 433 kN-m
550mm
A A 60 mm 350mm
3m
Section A-A
Material Properties Section Properties Design Properties
Ec = 25x106 kN/m2 b = 350 m fcu = 30 MPa
= 0.2 d = 490 mm fy = 460 MPa
G = 10416666.7kN/m2
AS 3600-2009 Example 002 - 1
Software Verification
PROGRAM NAME: SAP2000
REVISION NO.: 0
TECHNICAL FEATURES TESTED
Tied reinforced concrete column design
RESULTS COMPARISON
Independent results are hand calculated and compared.
Percent
Output Parameter SAP2000 Independent Difference
Column Demand/Capacity Ratio 1.001 1.00 0.1%
COMPUTER FILE: AS 3600-2009 EX002
CONCLUSION
The computed results show an acceptable comparison with the independent
results.
AS 3600-2009 Example 002 - 2
Software Verification
PROGRAM NAME: SAP2000
REVISION NO.: 0
HAND CALCULATION
COLUMN STRENGTH UNDER COMPRESSION CONTROL
fcu = 30 MPa fy = 460 MPa
b = 350 mm d = 490 mm
1) Because e = 250 mm < (2/3)d = 327 mm, assume compression failure. This
assumption will be checked later. Calculate the distance to the neutral axis for a
balanced condition, cb:
Position of neutral axis at balance condition:
600 600
cb = dt = ( 490 ) = 277.4 mm
600 + f y 600 + 460
2) From the equation of equilibrium:
N = Cc + C s T
where
= Cc =
2 fc ab 0.85 30 =
350a 8925a
Cs = As ( f y 2 fc) = 2500 ( 460 0.85 30 ) = 1, 086, 250 N
Assume compression steel yields, (this assumption will be checked later).
T = As f = 2500 f s = 2500 f s ( f s < f y )
N1 =
8925a + 1.086, 250 2500 fs (Eqn. 1)
3) Taking moments about As:
1 a
=
N2 Cc d + C s ( d d )
e 2
The plastic centroid is at the center of the section and d = 215 mm
e =e + d =250 + 215 =465 mm
1 a
=N 8925a 490 + 1, 086, 250 ( 490 60 )
465 2
N = 9404.8a 9.597 a 2 + 1, 004, 489 (Eqn. 2)
AS 3600-2009 Example 002 - 3
Software Verification
PROGRAM NAME: SAP2000
REVISION NO.: 0
4) Assume c = 333.9 mm, which exceeds cb (296 mm).
= =
a 0.84 333.9 280.5 mm
Substitute in Eqn. 2:
N 2 = 8925 280.5 9.597 ( 280.5 ) + 1, 004, 489= 2,888, 240 N
2
5) Calculate fs from the strain diagram when c = 365 mm.
490 333.9
=fs = 600 280.5 MPa
333.9
s =t =fs Es = 0.0014
6) Substitute a = 280.5 mm and fs = 280.5 MPa in Eqn. 1 to calculate N1:
N1= 8925 ( 280.5 ) + 1, 086, 250 2500 ( 280.5 )= 2,887,373 N
which is very close to the calculated N2 of 2,888,240 (less than 1% difference)
250
= Ne
M = 2888 = 722 kN-m
1000
7) Check if compression steel yields. From strain diagram,
333.9 60
=s ( 0.003
= ) 0.0025=
> y 0.0023
333.9
Compression steel yields, as assumed.
8) Therefore, section capacity is
N = 2888 =
1733 kN
e 250
M = 2888 = 0.60 2888 = 433 kN-m
1000 1000
AS 3600-2009 Example 002 - 4