SUSPICIOUS ACTIVITY REPORTS

AND THE SURVEILLANCE STATE:

The Suppression of Dissent and the
Criminalization of Arabs and Muslims in Illinois
MAY 2022

A REPORT BY THE ARAB AMERICAN ACTION NETWORK AND THE POLICING IN

CHICAGO RESEARCH GROUP AT THE UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS CHICAGO
i
ii
 Par
tner
sands
uppor
ter
soft
hecampai
gn:

Youni sAl jazarah Mijent e

Ana k baya nChi cag o Na tiona lBor i
cuaHuma nRi ght sNe twork
Ar abRe sour cea ndOr ganizingCe nter Na tiona lKor eanAme r icanS er vi
c e
As i
a nAme rica
nsAdv ancingJus tice|Chi c
ago &Educ ati
onCons or tium
As sata’sDa ughters Na tiona lLa wy ersGui ld
Ra hef Awa dall
ah Nic oleNg uy e n
BlackL ivesMa t
ter -Chic a
g o Or ga ni
z edCommuni ti
e sAg ainstDe port
ati
ons
Br i
ght onPa rkNe ighbor hoodCounc il Pales ti
neL eg al
Tom Ca l
laha n PAS O/ We stS ubur ba nAc t
ionPr oject
Ca mpa ignt oTAKEON HATE Li
s aMa riePi ck e
ns
BillCha mbe r
s Cor inaP edr aza-Palomi nos
Chi cag oAl li
anceAg a i
nstRa ci
s tand Col l
inP oi rot
Politi
c alRe pr es
sion Pue bloS inF ronte ras/F ami l
iaL atinaUnida
Chi cag oT eachersUni on Pue rtoRi c anCul tur al Ce nter
Chi cag oT or t
ureJ usticeCe nte r Raz iRa shid
Coa liti
onof Afri
ca n,Ar a
b ,As i
an,Eur opean, Ras me aDe f
e nseCommi ttee
andL atinoI mmi gr antsofI l
li
noi s Dic kRe i
ll
y( Re s
tI nP owe r)&Chr i
sGe ovani
s
Coa liti
ont oPr ote ctP eopl e’
sRi ght
s Re si
g nBr anni ganCoa l
ition
Commi t
te etoS topF BIRe pre ssion Re si
s tRe ima gi
neRe bui l
d( R3)Coa l
iti
on
Counc i
lonAme rica n-I
slami cRe l
a t
ions-
Chicago RuddRe sour ces
De sisRi singUpa ndMov ing Na se rRus tom
Mi cha elDe utsc
ha ndP eople’sL awOf f
ice Re be cca&Ha i
tha mS a l
awde h
J
a net&J imF enne rty Sarah- J
i (Lov e&S t
r ug glePhot os)
FirstDe fens eLeg alAi d School ofUni tya ndL ibe rati
on
Fre edom Roa dSoc i
a l
istOr g
a nizati
on RupaS ha h
Na ye fGhus ein NinaS homa n-Da jani
GoodKi dsMa dCi ty De bbi eS out hor n,Ma ryZe rk el,and
Ha naCe nte r Ame ricanF riendsS erv iceCommi tt
ee
Lam Ng uye nHo, Ha nanEr ik
a tVa nDr i
l,
Wa ll
yHi l
ke, Sout hsideT og e t
he rOr ganizingf orP ower
Ni ckBe de nk,andBe y
ondL ega lAid Sout hsider sOr ganiz edf orUni t
ya ndL i
berat
ion
I
lli
noi sCoa l
iti
onf orI mmi granta ndRe fugeeRights Sout hwe s
t Yout hCol l
a bor at
ive
Mwa faqJ ba ra StopL APDS pyi
ngCoa li
tion
VivianKha laf Ma ns ourT a dros( Re s tInP owe r)
Be rjKha l
e elandAl wa nPr inting Ayoub( Res tInP owe r)&Gha daT al
hami
J
e remyL ahoud Uni tedAf ric anOr ga nization
Ga ur angL i
ma chia U.S .PalestinianCommuni tyNe twor k
Luc yPa rsonsL abs
Ma ma sAc tivati
ngMov eme ntsf or
Abol itiona ndS olida ri
ty

i
ii
iv
v v
vi
1
2
3
Progr am parti
cipant sreported av ari
etyofencount ers,in- I
talsopublishedAAAN’ sfir
st(andst
il
lonly)book,T
owar ds
cludingr aci
alpr ofi
li
ngandhar as smentdur i
ngt raf
fi
cs tops, theSun,⁴writt
enandedi tedbyOdeh,whi chdescr
ibes(in
thet argeti
ngoff amily-owneds toresandot hers mallbus i
- ArabicandEngl i
sh)thefoundingofbotht heAWC andi ts
nes ses,and U. S.ci t
izenship delay scaus ed byt hecov ert groundbr
eaking oralhi
story wri
ti
ng pr
oject,and i
ncludes
Cont roll
ed Appl i
cation Rev iew and Res oluti
on Program. powerfuls
tori
eswr i
tt
enbyov eradozenleadingmember sof
Undert heauspicesoft hisprogr am,U. S.Citi
z enshi
pandI m- thebody.
mi grati
onServ i
ces( USCI S)gav et heFBIdi r
ectpowert oin
terveneanddel ayt hepr ocessingofi mmi grants’cit
izenship YOPandAWC
andv i
saapplications. l
eader spr octored
Youthwerealsomov edbyt hecaseoftheMidwest23,anin-
thecommuni t
y
vest
igati
onthatt ar
geted communitymemberswhom YOP surveyviagr ass-
member sknewper sonall
y— incl
udingAAANleaders— with rootscirculati
on
FBIraidsoftheirhomesands ubpoenastoafederalgr
and andonl i
ne,col -
j
ury.
³Thes e conversat
ionsprompted AAAN youthtotake l
ectingover450
act
ion;theseedsofCERPwer eplanted.
compl et
edques-
Thef i
rstst
epwast hedevelopmentofacommuni tysurvey
, ti
onnaires.The
producedbyYOP l eadersandAAAN or gani
zi
ngs taf
f,and result
sreveal eda
basedont heworkofoursis
terorganiz
ati
on,DesisRisi
ngUp communi tyrav-
andMov i
ng(DRUM)ofQueens ,NewYor k.Thesurveyasked agedbyr acial
respondentsawider angeofques t
ionsabouttheirexperi
-
enceswi t
hlocal
,st
ate,andfederall
aw enfor
cement.
profi
li
ng.

Atthi
spoint ,YOPmember sr eachedoutt ot
heAWC,another
AAAN init
iativet
hatfocusesonor ganizi
ngtrai
ni
ng,pol
it
ical Oneoutofevery10respondent
shadsomelevelofin-
educati
on,ands oci
al,per
s onal,andleaders
hipdevel
opment t
eract
ionwit
htheFBI
,andoneoutof12hadaninterac-
foras i
gni
ficantbaseofArabi mmi grantandref
ugeewomen t
ionwithsomeonewhot heybel
i
evedwasaninf
ormant.
i
nChi cagoland.
Theeff
ectsoft hi
shyper -
sur
veil
lancewer ealsomade
Co-foundedint hemi d-2000sbyf or
merAAAN cl
earbytherespondents.Oneoutoff i
ver eport
edbei ng
Associat
eDi r
ect orRasmeaOdehandani ni
ti
al afr
aidt
ospeakf reel
ybecauseoft hepr esenceofi nf
or-
baseofadozenorsoAr abwomen,t heAWC

S
NOI
mantsinthecommuni t
y,⁵whil
et hesamenumberr e-

LLI
l
eadsAAAN’ si mmi gr
antr ight
sorganizingand port
edthattheywer elessli
kel
yt ogeti nvolvedint he

NI
now has over700 member sfr
om count r
ies

MSI
communityortoparti
ci
pateinpolit
icalevents,ral
l
ies,or

ONOFARABSANDMUSLI
across the Arab wor l
d,i ncl
udi
ng Pal esti
ne, prot
est
sasar esult.
Syri
a,Jordan,Iraq,Yemen,Egypt ,Algeri
a,Mo-
rocco,andothers. Thesur
veyresultsandanalysi
smadei tcl
earthatAr
abs
andMusl imsinChicagolandwerebeing
tar
get edbyfederal
,stat
e,andlocall
aw

ZATI
enforcement,andthatthetar
geti
ngwas

NALI
havingadet r
imentaleff
ectonour

MI
SSENTANDTHECRI
communi ti
es.

Int hesummerof2013,YOPandAWC t ook

directactioninresponsetothefindings,and

ONOFDI
fort hefi
rstti
mei nnearl
ytwodecades,Ar ab
yout hledapr ot
estintheheartofdownt own

ATE:THESUPPRESSI
Chi cago.Ther all
yandmar chofhundr eds,
from Feder alPl
az atotheU. S.Immi gration
and Cust oms Enforcement( I
CE)bui l
ding,
calledforanendt ofeder
allaw enforcement
LLANCEST

attacksonourcommuni t
ies.
CI
SUSPI VI
OUSACTI TYREPORTSANDTHESURVEI

4
5
Angela Davis, Frank Chapman, and Rasmea Odeh

¹¹ See article on Why Countering extremism is bad by the Brennan Center for Justice:
www.brennancenter.org/our-work/research-reports/why-countering-violent-extremism-programs-are-bad-policy
¹² See DHS Grants Opportunity: www.grants.gov/web/grants/view-opportunity.html?oppId=285773
¹³ See article on Chicago Arab and Black youth campaign against racial profiling by Bill Chambers, issued on August 20, 2016:
www.chicagomonitor.com/2016/08/chicago-arab-and-black-youth-campaign-against-racial-profiling-by-the-fbi/

6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
 Arab American Action Network

Policing in Chicago Research Group

www.aaan.org