Thenamaris Safety & Quality Insights
Thenamaris Safety & Quality Insights
SIRE 2.0 - A Message from the VLOC’s Under COOL RIDER Joins
Inspection Opening Thenamaris Safety The Spotlight After the Thenamaris LNG
Meeting Checklist & Quality Manager String of Losses Managed Fleet
WELCOME
Contents Welcome
By Captain Zacharias Vairamakis
PAGE PAGE PAGE
03 18 34
Welcome Observations from the Fleet, Safety Performance For decades the shipping industry has been working towards reducing the
including Repeated Observations Overview & Safety Scorecard
By Captain Zacharias Vairamakis
number of accidents and minimizing their impact. Initially, such efforts focused on
PAGE
improving the hardware through building better ships as per SOLAS requirements.
PAG E PAGE
04 21 34 Later, the focus shifted to implementing specific policies and procedures as per
Getting Along with Difficult People Undesired Events Safety Opportunities
By Athina Kapetanaki
PAGE the ISM code. Today, we are in the era of the human element and performance
PAGE
THENAMARIS CONBULK 36 influencing factors, with the human element being what makes humans behave
05 Observations from the Fleet, the way they do and the consequences resulting from this behavior, and
Spike in Container Losses Warrants PAG E including Repeated Observations
Further Investigation
26 PAGE
performance influencing factors being the factors that combine with basic human
PAGE Safety Scorecard
37 error tendencies to create error-likely situations. Statistics prove that safety in
06 PAG E Undesired Events the maritime industry has improved significantly over the years. However, that
SIRE 2.0 -
Inspection Opening Meeting Checklist 26 PAGE doesn’t mean that hardware is perfect, or that procedures and risk assessments
38
Observations from the Fleet, including
PAGE Repeated Observations on their own can ensure no accidents happen. It is important to combine hardware
10 PAG E
Best Practices/Safety-Energy Efficiency
Ideas and Experience Shared
with procedural and human elements to achieve a strong and sustainable safety
Industry Learning Material
27 PAGE
culture. Additionally, work to improve both hardware and procedures, as separate
Undesired Events
39 safety-related elements, must also continue.
PAGE
11 PAG E
28
Fleet Health & Safety
Thenamaris at Work
PAGE
Maritime organizations, including OCIMF, continue to raise the bar by implementing new requirements for the training of
VLOC’s Under the Spotlight
THENAMARIS
After String of Losses 40 shipboard and managing office personnel. There have been numerous instances where we at Thenamaris have initiated
safety improvements well before they were an industry obligation, and we continue to promptly respond to all emerging
Safety on Board
requirements. Whenever an undesired event occurs, we thoroughly investigate and analyze what happened to prevent
PAG E
46
PAG E reoccurrence. We believe there are lessons to be learned even from minor events. However, when an event results in
32
Safety Performance Overview
By Captain Georgios Deligiorgis Shell’s Maritime Partners
a tragic consequence, such as a fatality, in addition to investigating and analyzing what happened we must take a step
PAGE Overall Safety Performance in Safety Program back and carefully refocus our efforts. We must rigorously examine what should have been done differently, and come
16
of Thenamaris LNG Managed Fleet
up with new means of ensuring that safety is the highest priority.
47
PAG E
33
Safety Scorecard In addition to the standard Beacon features, this issue includes an article on ‘Getting Along with Difficult People’ by
COOL RIDER Joins the
PAGE
Athina Kapetanaki from the Marine Personnel team, as well as an industry alert about the ‘Spike in Container Losses’,
17
A Message from the Thenamaris LNG Thenamaris LNG Managed Fleet
Marine Superintendent LPG and the ‘SIRE 2.0 Inspection Opening Meeting Checklist’ as recently released by OCIMF. We have a safety message from
A Message from the Thenamaris By Captain Georgios Zoupas
the Thenamaris S&Q Manager Captain Panagiotis Kallinikos, as well as a message from the Thenamaris LNG Marine
Safety & Quality Manager
By Captain Panagiotis Kallinikos Superintendent LPG Captain Georgios Zoupas, and other industry learning material.
Safety-related articles and updates can also be found in the quarterly Thenamaris News.
Getting Along
with Difficult People
By Athina Kapetanaki
Most people have experienced a situation where they are trying to relate or reason with
a difficult person. A difficult person may lack empathy and concern towards others,
become easily upset and angry or have a sense of superiority and put others down. Trying
to reason and communicate with a difficult person may be frustrating and disappointing,
especially when he or she is a family member or colleague. However, relating with difficult
people may be unavoidable, either for personal or professional reasons.
HOW TO GET ALONG WITH A DIFFICULT to meet at a different time, take deep breaths and try to
PERSON stay calm during your interaction.
1. Practice active listening. Most people need to be 4. Be mindful of your non-verbal behavior. When we
understood and want to feel heard. Acknowledging disapprove of a behavior or feel frustrated with another
another person by engaging in active listening can help person we may display non-verbal cues that reveal our
facilitate dialogue and lead to a trust-based relationship. disapproval or frustration. Even smiling or nodding at
By focusing on what the other person is saying, instead an inappropriate time during a difficult conversation
may seem like you are mocking the other person, and
of what you want to reply, you may learn important
may be perceived as a sign of disrespect, which may
information that you were previously missing. It can
further fuel a heated discussion.
also help to consider what the person’s underlying need
might be. What does this person really want to achieve? 5. Behave how you would like to be treated. Reflect
I
try to avoid interactions with a difficult person as he or various factors, including past experiences, significant
she might increase your tension, leading to negative relationships with others, upbringing and personal n November 2020, the container ship One Apus lost The rise in container losses may be driven by a combination
consequences. If the difficult person approaches you at struggles. In many cases, you may have little information almost 2,000 containers in rough seas in the Pacific, of potential factors. Larger ships, more extreme weather
a time that is not suitable for you, explore with them the regarding such factors. The difficult individual’s behavior with hundreds more containers left damaged on board and a surge in freight rates and mis‑declared cargo weights
possibility of meeting at another time. If it is not possible and attitude may have nothing to do with you. the vessel. The incident was the worst since 4,293 containers could all be at play, but there are also growing questions for
were lost with the sinking of the container ship MOL Comfort how containers are secured on board ships. Of six cases of
in 2013. In January 2021, the Maersk Essen lost about 750 container losses in the North Pacific between November
boxes while sailing from China to Los Angeles. A month 2020 and March 2021 analyzed by AGCS (One Apus, Maersk
later, 260 containers fell off the Maersk Eindhoven when it Essen, Maersk Eindhoven, Ever Liberal, Tianping and MSC
lost power in heavy seas. Aries) there were a number of common factors.
The number of container losses is the worst in seven years. All container losses occurred in rough seas and when the
More than 3,000 containers were lost at sea last year, while vessels were on a westerly heading during the voyage from
more than 1,000 fell overboard during the first months of Asia to the US. The loss of containers could be the result
2021. This compares with an average of just 1,382 containers of a combination of various factors like synchronous
In summary, although getting along with difficult people is, lost each year from around 6,000 container vessels in and parametric rolling. But there may also be other
operation, according to a World Shipping Council2 report in issues at play, such as container stack collapse due to
by definition, not easy, learning how to do so may help you become more able November 2020. The accidents are disrupting supply chains mis‑declaration of cargo weights at a time when freight
for retailers and manufacturers ‑ from Amazon to Tesla. rates have been increasing.
to overcome challenging situations in general.
4 5
SIRE 2.0 - INSPECTION OPENING MEETING CHECKLIST
6 7
DETAINABLE DEFICIENCIES OVERVIEW
The Master should advise any additional PPE required by During inspection pre-work, the Inspector should
vessel procedures. The vessel should provide any such identify all potentially enclosed or hazardous spaces
additional PPE if inspector does not have it. Additional that may be entered during the inspection as stipulated
PPE requirements should be noted. in the CVIQ. These items should be noted prior to the
The Inspector should wear PPE appropriate for Opening Meeting.
the conditions encountered at all times during the 8. Defect List
inspection. (OCIMF recommends, as a minimum, a
safety helmet, fire retardant overalls or long-sleeved The Master should provide the Inspector with a list
clothing, safety shoes, gloves, hearing protection, eye of all open defects entered in the vessel’s defect
protection, and a personal gas monitor.) reporting system as required by core Question 2.4.1.
5. Order of Inspection All defects existing aboard the vessel at the time of the
The Inspector should: inspection, except sudden failures on the day of the
❚ Propose the order of inspection. inspection, should be included in this list.
❚ Identify the expected officers and ratings 9. Stop Work Authority (SWA)
relevant to the questions assigned to the The Inspector and Master should agree that both
CVIQ. vessel staff and the Inspector will have and respect
The Master should advise: SWA for inspection related activities.
❚ Any planned vessel operations that need to
10. Recording Negative Observations
be considered.
The Inspector should advise the Master that:
❚ Any anticipated need to pause the
❚ Any negative observations will be pointed
inspection.
out to the accompanying officer and
❚ The identity of the accompanying officer for recorded in the Inspection Editor at the
each area of the inspection.
time of finding.
❚ Any additional officers or crew that will
❚ Any corrective action taken to rectify a
be needed to support the accompanying
negative observation will be recorded as
officer.
an additional remark within the supporting
The order of the inspection and crew members to be
negative comment.
involved should be agreed to meet the needs of the
vessel and the inspector and noted. ❚ The addition or removal of negative
observations is tracked in the Inspection
6. Equipment to be Tested or Demonstrated
Editor. Errors will be corrected where
The Inspector should advise the Master of the items
warranted, but no negotiation will be
of equipment or machinery required to be tested or
undertaken.
demonstrated during the inspection. The Master
should advise of any port/terminal restrictions on 11. Planning the Closing Meeting
the required tests and arrange any necessary per- The Inspector should advise the Master that:
missions. The Inspector and Master should agree ❚ A wireless printer will be required to print
the vessel personnel designated to perform these the Observation Declaration prior to the
tests and demonstrations. During inspection pre- Closing Meeting.
work, the Inspector should identify those items of
❚ If no wireless printer is available the
equipment or machinery required to be tested or
content of the Observation Declaration will
demonstrated during the inspection as stipulated in
be dictated to the Master, and that screen
the CVIQ. These items should be noted prior to the
Opening Meeting. shots of the tablet are not permitted.
The Master should advise:
7. Permits Required for the Inspection
❚ If a wireless printer is available and has
The Inspector should advise the Master of all
potentially enclosed or hazardous spaces that may be been tested.
entered during the inspection. ❚ Who will be attending the Closing Meeting
on behalf of the vessel and vessel operator.
The Master should:
❚ Introduce the inspector to the sections of Use of the checklist
the SMS that identify enclosed or hazardous The opening meeting checklist is provided as an aid
spaces onboard and the required entry to assist both the Inspector and vessel staff to gain a
procedures for each. common understanding of the expectations for a SIRE
❚ Ensure that enclosed space entry permits 2.0 inspection opening [Link] Inspector is not
are prepared as required for the inspection required to use the checklist and, if they do, they are
in accordance with company procedures. not required to retain it for auditing purposes.
8 9
THENAMARIS AT WORK
10 11
Q2 2022 OVERVIEW
In Q2 2022 the managed tanker fleet achieved a poor safety performance with THREE (3)
reported injuries, one of them being fatal.
ONE (1) Environmental event was reported when the connection point between two fuel oil
transferring hoses failed, resulting in a small amount of oil being sprayed on the ship’s side.
Despite the fact that the hose was controlled by shore personnel, the crew is responsible
for ensuring that all equipment used is in good condition so as not to jeopardized the ship’s
safe operation.
14 15
A MESSAGE FROM THE THENAMARIS SAFETY & QUALITY MANAGER
16 17
OBSERVATIONS FROM THE FLEET, INCLUDING REPEATED OBSERVATIONS
Observations from the Fleet, As per the ‘cargo samples’ procedure, samples are to be disposed ashore in an
appropriate shore facility. If this is not feasible, then relevant samples are to be
emptied into the appropriate Residue/Slop/Waste Oil Tank and relevant bottles
cleaned and disposed of ashore as plastic garbage. Disposal policy for the cargo
Including Repeated Observations samples is 18 months after cargo has been fully discharged. If the dedicated
storage space is full, inform the Chief Officer and Chief Engineer and notify the
Operations and Safety & Quality departments for them to consider earlier disposal
of samples.
When an observation, even a minor one, is repeated within a specific time period it is an
early warning sign that it might result in an ACTUAL INCIDENT. 9.7 Specifications were Set the brake to the proper position having the indicator and the mark aligned.
available on the winch Verify the correct marking on the brake screw.
18 19
OVERALL SAFETY PERFORMANCE
Undesired Events
8.41 The vessel was discharging Ensure that during the entire cargo operation, manifold pressure gauges on both the
its cargo at the starboard side terminal and sea sides are uncovered, open and regularly checked. Manifold pressure
from the No.2 cargo manifold. gauges on the sea side must have a zero indication.
However, the pressure gauges of
the No.6 cargo manifold and slop
on the port side manifolds (sea
side) were in the shut position at We would have preferred to keep this section blank without any incidents
the time of the inspection. or accidents. This was unfortunately not the case, but remains a target we should
10.41 The gyro repeater located Check the gyro compass in the steering gear room prior to vessel’s arrival at port, or at
in the steering gear room least weekly. The repeater should display the correct reading in accordance with the gyro
all constantly work towards.
indicated a difference of 12 compass signal.
degrees from actual heading
Gyro repeaters are important for the safety of navigation in case of emergency.
as indicated by the navigational INCIDENTS Q2 2022
bridge gyro compass.
5.27 During lifeboat engine test it Ensure that the stopper is adjusted accordingly and confirm that when the control WHERE & WHEN WHAT WHY (ROOT CAUSE) PREVENTIVE ACTIONS
was noticed that the propeller lever is placed in neutral position, the shaft gear is disengaged and the propeller
was continuously turning. is stopped. The lever position should be tested to properly align with the propeller
Even with command in neutral movements in all positions (ahead-astern-neutral). SEAMERCURY The vessel heaved up its port ❚ Wrong positioning of the OS in ❚ A Safety Information Bulletin was
position, the shaft gear could anchor, but the anchor came up front of the warping drum instead disseminated to the managed
As per company’s procedures, lifeboat elements, such as the hull, superstructure, 9 Apr
not be disengaged. with its flukes facing downwards. A of in back of the warping drum. fleet.
hooks, fall preventer devices, water spray system, compressed air support system, messenger rope was used to turn He was holding the line sideways
steering, engine, stores and equipment, and seat safety belts, should be inspected in
the anchor flukes to the normal approximately 30cm close to
line with SOLAS. Inspections are performed by the Safety Officer (Chief Officer) with
upward position. The messenger the drum instead of more than 1
the assistance of the 2nd or 3rd Officer. The results of inspections are recorded in the
log book and the relevant inspections checklist. rope was laid on rounds on the meter facing the drum.
warping drum, and the OS in ❚ Mishandling of the messenger
8.46 The forecastle gas alarm, The fixed gas detection system should always be kept on during cargo operations. charge controlled it with both
forecastle air door open, P/R Place a warning sign next to the fixed gas detection system stating that it should not line; too much slack was given
hands. While the rope was under causing the strong snap of the
H2S pre-alarm, P/R H2S main be turned off without authorization from the Master.
alarm, located on the bridge
tension the OS gave it some slack. messenger line while the line was
and CCR, were found switched Due to strong tension, the slack under significant tension.
off. After it was pointed out by rope violently pulled away, causing
❚ Lack of experience; OS had little
the inspector the equipment a sudden and strong snap. The right
experience and was unfamiliar
was switched on and found to thumb of the OS hit the edge of the
with mooring operations.
be properly working. warping drum and was dislocated.
❚ Lack of supervision; operation
10.25 Gauge glass closing device of Ensure the engine room tank level gauge indication valves are properly closed when
gravity tank was not properly not used to take tank level measurements.
was carried out without
closed. supervision by a Deck Officer.
SEAEXPLORER During the connection of the cargo ❚ Wrong instinctive movement from ❚ A Safety Information Bulletin was
arm to manifold No.5, the cargo OS. disseminated to the managed
1 Jun arm operator on shore lost control fleet.
❚ Poor situational awareness and
and the loading arm dropped and insight.
hit the shore platform. An OS on
❚ Unnecessary presence near to
standby jumped over the manifold
the loading arms.
beam to avoid being hit by the
falling arm and landed on the main
deck behind the manifold’s drip
tray. The OS sustained a light injury
to his left knee.
20 21
OVERALL SAFETY PERFORMANCE
SEACROSS Two 2nd Officers were opening, ❚ Insufficient procedures related to ❚ The company’s SMS has been
emptying and removing the the condemnation and disposal enriched to include specific
6 Jun
CO2 cartridges from old and of fire extinguishers, especially guidelines for the condemnation
condemned foam fire extinguishers extinguishers under pressure. and disposal of fire extinguishers.
(non-permanently pressurized ❚ Failure to identify the hazards ❚ A Safety Information Bulletin was
type) to deliver ashore as garbage. associated with the development disseminated to the managed
One fire extinguisher could not be of pressure inside a condemned fleet.
opened with a spanner, so one of (out of use/decommissioned) ❚ All vessels have been informed
the 2nd Officers decided to empty fire extinguisher with signs of and instructed to carry out a very
it by activating it and releasing its corrosion, having been stored for thorough inspection of all fire
contents in the garbage room. As a long period of time in a relatively extinguishers.
soon as the trigger was pressed humid and exposed area, such as
and the CO2 was released, the fire ❚ A visual training material on the
the garbage room.
extinguisher violently exploded subject will be prepared by a
❚ Condemned (out of order/not to competent and qualified service
and hit the late 2nd Officer in
be operated) fire extinguishers provider.
the upper abdominal and chest
should not have been stored
area of his right side, causing ❚ A safety campaign focusing on the
under pressure and especially
heavy internal trauma. Crew and inspection of all fire extinguishers
in an area where exposure to
shore paramedics attempted has been launched.
the elements can accelerate
resuscitation and stabilization ❚ The company’s Garbage
corrosion of the metallic cell.
without avail and the 2nd Officer Management Plan has been
was declared dead. ❚ Lack of system in place to
enriched with guidelines for
specifically prevent crew
managing condemned (out of
members from attempting to
order/not to be operated) fire
discharge any equipment under
extinguishers, span gases and
pressure when it has been
aerosols tubes.
characterized as ‘out of order/not
to be operated.’ ❚ The job description on the
inspection of loose firefighting
❚ Failure of the service provider
equipment has been enriched.
to identify corrosion signs and
to condemn the subject fire ❚ A Non-Destructive Test (NDT)
extinguisher. on subject fire extinguisher
will be carried out by a certified
laboratory.
❚ The service provider that tested
the failed fire extinguisher in
February 2022 was placed on
hold.
❚ Develop a feedback form
regarding the condition of the
inspected fire extinguishers from
service providers.
ENVIRONMENTAL EVENTS
SEAEXPLORER While draining of the cargo arm to shore was ❚ Unsafe manner of working ❚ A Safety Information Bulletin
in progress, the hose connected to the shore and overconfidence from the was disseminated to the
1 Jun
cargo arm split resulting in a small amount terminal personnel as they managed fleet.
of oil being sprayed on the ship’s side as well failed to foresee the potential
as between the jetty and the ship’s side. hazard.
❚ Insufficient supervision of
the terminal personnel by
the crew in regards to the
equipment used during the
hazardous operation of cargo
arm draining.
22
OBSERVATIONS FROM THE FLEET, INCLUDING REPEATED OBSERVATIONS
0 2 0.90 PSC/ Material Safety Data Carry out onboard training and debriefing of all crew members regarding proper segregation
Vetting Sheet (MSDS) was and handling of chemicals on board and the requirement of MSDS for each chemical.
missing for chemical
PSC DETENTIONS UNLAWFUL ACTS products and/or not
available in English.
DEFICIENCIES
PSC Self-closing devices During the inspection the self-closing devices of the said doors were in good working
on fire doors were condition. The observation refers to small hooks that were fitted on the accommodation
1.03 0 1 held open to prevent self-closing doors to hold them open.
them closing.
As per company’s procedures, the accommodation fire doors are inspected on a biweekly
VETTING basis. The inspection includes verification that doors close properly, that self-closing
devices are operational, and that fire doors fitted with an automatic device are properly
OBSERVATIONS functioning.
To avoid re-occurrence:
9.00 ❚ All crew members should closely monitor the vessel and report any safety-related issue
they observe to the Chief Officer.
❚ All the fire doors on board should be checked to ensure that no such hooks are installed.
vations and consider these repeated observations as a The observations noted below have been identified dur- WHERE & WHEN WHAT WHY (ROOT CAUSE)
HIGH RISK even if they are not high risk in themselves. ing inspections (e.g., vetting, PSC, etc.) or from Port Cap-
tain attendances or vetting by Masters, and have been Bulk carrier The vessel’s ETO was occupied with replacing a broken lightbulb ❚ The ETO fell from the portable ladder and
selected based on their severity and repetitiveness. near the ECR entrance. As the bulb could not be reached from landed on the floor, with all of his weight
the floor, a portable aluminum ladder was needed. A Wiper was only on his left foot. This impact resulted
OUR GOAL IS TO: NOTE TO MASTERS: Have a meeting to discuss these 19 Jun assigned to assist the ETO with the job. Prior to commencing the in him suffering a calcaneus (heel bone)
observations and delegate responsibilities for preven- job, a visual inspection of the ladder took place. The Wiper held fracture.
❚ Avoid these observations happening again
tive tasks to ship Officers. Treat pending observations the ladder, and the ETO climbed on it to remove the light cover ❚ One of the legs of the portable ladder
❚ Identify the lesson to be learned from as outstanding items in TRITON. which he handed to the Wiper to place on the floor. While the ETO failed, bending unexpectedly. This led to
our past experience and share this with was removing the broken bulb, one leg of the ladder suddenly the ETO losing his balance and falling.
seafarers across the fleet bent, resulting in the ETO losing his balance and landing on the
floor with his left foot. Because the Wiper was holding the ladder,
it did not fall onto the ETO.
26 27
CARRIAGE OF SOLID BULK CARGOES - LIQUEFACTION AND DYNAMIC SEPARATION
28 29
A MESSAGE FROM THE THENAMARIS LNG MARINE SUPERINTENDENT LPG
Safety Scorecard commenced their writing. At the end of the test, the live positively!”
professor read the answers of all the students. I shared the above lesson with all of you, as thinking
Everyone without exception described the black about good things instead of the dark spots gives me
Q2 2022 strength to overcome the difficulties of work, as well
dot, trying to explain its position in the middle of
the page. After reading all of the answers, and once as the difficulties in my personal life. I hope it does the
INCIDENT TOTAL LTIF the students calmed down, the professor began to same for you.
RECORDABLE
CASES
11 0 0.41
PSC PSC UNLAWFUL ACTS the most beautiful moments that life gives you.
DEFICIENCIES DETENTIONS
0.33 0 0
32 33
SAFETY OPPORTUNITIES
During daily work, the grating located at Upon discovery the grating was The Chief Officer and 2nd Engineer
LNG FLEET the top of the stairs leading to the poop properly secured. discussed this subject during the pre-work
LNG VESSELS OPPORTUNITIES AVERAGE deck was found not secured with nuts Toolbox Talk the next morning, as well as in
that could cause slipping/tripping hazard. the next Safety Meeting.
5 183 12.20 Safety Opportunity #3: Failure of Fast Rescue Boat Throttle
While at anchor, the vessel was The Chief Engineer and 2nd The engine room team fabricated parts for
LPG FLEET conducting a Fast Rescue Boat (FRB) Engineer were notified. The 4th and a more robust and long-term solution. The
training and the three-monthly lifeboat 3rd Engineer made a repair to allow Senior Management Team of the vessel
LNG VESSELS OPPORTUNITIES AVERAGE
launching. During the training, the FRB the FRB to continue to function for suggested that this be communicated to
8 216 9.00
throttle lost connection, which resulted the remainder of the training and to the managed fleet, as several of the crew
in the throttle slipping back to the idle assist with the lifeboat launch. members know of similar problems having
ABA position. The 2nd Officer stopped the job occurred on other vessels. For the FRBs
and returned the FRB to the vessel for to run at a constant RPM as per design,
TOP
ABA FIVE ORIGINATORS OF SAFETY OPPORTUNITIES Q2 2022 repair. two persons are required in order to
SOAA
simultaneously control the FRB propulsion
SOAA 25 even though that is not the norm.
AB
34
Safety Opportunity #4: Oiler Slapped by Messenger Line
AB
CAP
During mooring, the Oiler was heaving The tug line was secured. All deck mooring team members were
CAP
SOB 34 up a messenger line from a tug line informed and briefed regarding this
on a winch. He stood 1.5 meter from occurrence, and all aft mooring station
SOB
SOA 43 the winch and was controlling the crew members were briefed to keep a
messenger line. The tug line got stuck proper distance from the winch and to
SOA 0 10 20 30 40 4550 on a storage drum of the tug, and the ensure the messenger line end remains in
0 10 20 30 40 50 messenger line was suddenly under front of them.
tension. The messenger line then
became twisted, and its end slapped the
Oiler’s left leg. The Oiler did not incur any
serious injury, and, as medical treatment
TOP FIVE ROOT CAUSE OF SAFETY OPPORTUNITIES Q2 2022 was not required, he continued his work.
It was the Oiler’s good body position and
distance from the drum that reduced the
Incorrect use of equipment or machinery 27
severity of this incident.
Incorrect
Defectiveuse of equipment or machinery 40
equipment, machinery or tools Safety Opportunity #5: No Emergency Means of Escape Arrangement Inside the Bow Thruster Room
Defective equipment, machinery or tools During a routine inspection, it was A safety harness was immediately Include the escape arrangement in the
Poor housekeeping/disorder 44 observed that there are no means of installed near the bottom part of the routine inspection checklist, and discuss
Poor housekeeping/disorder escape or rescue arrangements in bow thruster room. The harness this during the Safety Meeting.
Failure to warn or secure 48 place in case of an emergency when at was attached to one end of a rope,
the bottom of the bow thruster room. and the other end of the rope was
Failure to warn or secure
Failure to follow rules, regulations and procedures 64 secured to the entrance of the bow
thruster compartment.
Failure to follow rules, regulations and procedures 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
34 35
UNDESIRED EVENTS
3.75
INSPECTIONS COMPARISON
Ch.2 Cer fica on and Ch.3 Crew Ch.4 Naviga on and Ch.5 Safety Ch.6 Pollu on h.8 Cargo and Balla Ch.10 Engine and Ch.11 General
Ch.7 Mari me Securit General Informa on Null
Documenta on
Ch.2 Cer fica on and
Management
Ch.3 Crew
Communica ons
Ch.4 Naviga on and
Management
Ch.5 Safety
Preven on
Ch.6 Pollu on
Systems Ch.9 Mooring Steering
Ch.10 Engine and
Appearance and Cond.
Ch.11 General
COOL VOYAGER Blackout at anchorage. ❚ Defective ❚ Share report and findings with
h.8 Cargo and Balla
4
Documenta on Management Communica ons Management Preven on
Ch.7 Mari me Securit
Systems Ch.9 Mooring Steering Appearance and Cond.
General Informa on Null
5 Feb The vessel was at anchor in Rotterdam, when due to equipment, the managed fleet.
3
(Level 1) machinery or tools
3.75
4
prepare propulsions in standby mode and to be ready overspeed device according to
3.75
3
for departure. MGE No.1 was on load HV MSB BUS maker recommendation, and
at anchorage, when the duty engineer started MGE create relevant PMS work order.
Observatons Per Inspectons
32
2.38
1.63
2 moved to slow ahead.
2.38
1.38
1.38
2
Later on the same day, and while at anchorage, the
2.38
1.63
1
0.88
event which led to the blackout commenced. The HV
1.38
1.38
1.63
MSB BUS No.1 frequency triggered the low low-
1.38
1
1.38
0.88
0.67
0.44
0.22
0.22
1
0.88
0.17
0.17
0.38
0.38
0.67
0.13
0.170.13
0.13
0.13 0.00
+ USCG0.17 0.00
0.00
0.11 0.00
0.00
0.000.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.33
0.22
0.22
0
0.17
0.38
0.38
0.67
0.13
0.13
0.13
0.11
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
+ USCG 0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.33
0.22
0
0.17
PSC + USCG0.38
0.38
0.13
Attendance0.13
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
PSC + USCG
PSC + USCG
PSC + USCG
USCG
PSC + USCG
PSC + USCG
PSC + USCG
PSC + USCG
PSC + USCG
Attendance
Vetting
Attendance
Vetting
Attendance
Vetting
Vetting
Attendance
Vetting
Attendance
Vetting
Attendance
Attendance
PSC Vetting
Attendance
Vetting
Attendance
Vetting
Attendance
Vetting
Attendance
Vetting
0
PSC + USCG
PSC + USCG
PSC + USCG
PSC + USCG
PSC + USCG
PSC + USCG
PSC + USCG
PSC ++USCG
PSC + USCG
+ USCG
PSC + USCG
PSC + USCG
Attendance
Vetting
Attendance
Vetting
Attendance
Vetting
Attendance
Vetting
Attendance
Vetting
Attendance
Vetting
Attendance
Vetting
Attendance
Vetting
Attendance
Vetting
Attendance
Vetting
Attendance
PSCVetting
Attendance
Vetting
back up mode, and the emergency diesel generator
PSC + USCG
PSC + USCG
+ USCG
USCG
PSC + USCG
PSC + USCG
+ USCG
PSC + USCG
PSC + USCG
PSC + USCG
PSC + USCG
PSC + USCG
Attendance
Vetting
Attendance
Vetting
Attendance
Vetting
Attendance
Vetting
Attendance
Vetting
Attendance
Vetting
Attendance
Vetting
Attendance
Vetting
Attendance
Vetting
Attendance
Vetting
Attendance
Vetting
Attendance
Vetting
started automatically and connected to the emergency
PSC
PSC
PSC +
switchboard.
PSC
PSC
OBSERVATIONS
OBSERVATIONS
OBSERVATIONS
TOTAL OBSERVATIONS PER INSPECTIONS
TOTAL
TOTAL OBSERVATIONS
OBSERVATIONS PER 2022 PER INSPECTIONS
INSPECTIONS
12.25 2022
12.25
2022 COOL VOYAGER Failure of gas combustion unit (GCU) bearing and ❚ Defective ❚ Take vibration measurement with
12
12
12.25
4 Apr belts. equipment, Yellotec tester on a regular basis.
12 (Level 1) GCU fan No.2 belts and drive end bearings found machinery or tools ❚ Conduct thermographic check
10
10 broken, after dismantling of the bearing housing due to of belt-driven equipment after
damage of the fan shaft. maintenance.
10
8
8 REPEATED OBSERVATIONS FROM SIRE/ ❚ Ensure bearings are properly
greased and maintenance carried
6
USCG/PSC IN Q2 2022: out in line with manufacturer’s
8
6
There were no repeated observations from SIRE/PSC/ recommendations, including a
monthly performance test of the
4
4
6
3.17
3.17
USCG. GCU fans.
2
2.00 ❚ Issue defect report M176 ‘GCU fan
2
2.00
No.2 belts and drive end bearing
OBSERVATIONS THAT LED TO
0.33
4
3.17
0.33 broken’.
0
0 A endance
A endance
Ve ng
Ve ng
Vetting By Vessel
Vetting By Vessel
PSC+USCG
PSC+USCG MANAGEMENT SYSTEM CHANGES ❚ Check the temperature, noise,
2.00 and vibration of fan bearings after
2 IN Q2 2022: starting the GCU.
0.33
There were 3 SIRE observations that led to Management ❚ Issue a technical bulletin for the
0 proper installation and alignment
A endance Ve ng Vetting By Vessel PSC+USCG System changes. of belts.
SEASUCCESS Eye injury from broken quartz sleeve of UV ❚ Failure to follow ❚ Carry out training for Senior
18 May sterilizer. rules, regulations Officers regarding supervision
(Level 2) The ETO was given the job of rectifying the water leak and procedures and cross-checks before leak/
on the fresh water UV sterilizer. The job was part of ❚ Inadequate use of pressure tests.
the daily work plan and the Task Risk Assessment and protective PPE ❚ Carry out additional training
required Work Permit were in place. The ETO rectified for all crew regarding job
the leak and proceeded with recommissioning the UV procedures and leak/pressure
sterilizer. While switching the water on, the side quartz test procedures.
tube was blown out and shattered into pieces. Some ❚ Update the Risk Assessment,
of the shattered segments hit the ETO’s face and right since a full-face shield should
eye. First aid was administrated on board, and the ETO be used for leak/pressure tests.
was sent to shore for further treatment which included
eye surgery.
36 37
FLEET HEALTH & SAFETY
38 39
SAFETY ON BOARD
Safety on Board
Fleet Safety Man of the Month / Q2 2022
JUNE 2022
COOL VOYAGER - 4th Engineer Valic Mauro
4th Engineer Valic tends to encourage ratings to contribute and improve their behaviors to SEATEAM – AB Oliver Aguado
elevate the safety culture on board, and maintains good cooperation with the entire crew. He
is actively engaged in submitting high quality Safety Opportunities and encourages others AB Aguado was elected Safety Man of the Month for June. Oliver, who has served on board
to do so as well. He gives proactive advice during the debriefings of various drills, seeking different types of vessels in our company, always shares his knowledge and safety awareness
improvements. Moreover, he demonstrated proper operation of various safety systems and with the crew. After years of experience, he knows the meaning of ‘health and safety’ and is
devices, and properly uses PPE. well aware of safety procedures. He took part in safety activities on board, reported four Safety
Opportunities, and suggested the best practice for June; a hanger for the ammonia mask. He
applies Stop Work Authority with the crew, and is the one who does the safety stencils on the
deck. AB Oliver consistently helps to promote safety culture on board the vessel. Additionally,
he wrote the safety article for June about the ‘Importance of Recreational Activities Onboard’.
MAY 2022
COOL RUNNER – AB Eslao Aramis COOL RUNNER – Deck Cadet Matijevic Denis
AB Eslao was the most proactive person during the month of May. His performance was Deck Cadet Matijevic actively participated in trainings as the team leader. He reported four
excellent, he showed the crew a high level of responsibility, very good safety awareness Safety Opportunities and also wrote a safety article about ‘Intrinsically Safe and Explosion
and active participation in Safety Opportunity reporting. During May he reported ten Safety Proof Equipment on board.’
Opportunities. He has good knowledge and understanding of Take 5 for Safety and reported
two Stop Work Authorities; one for attempted lifting without gloves and one for a person
standing too near to lifting crane operations.
Congratulations to all, and keep up the good work and strong focus on safety!
40 41
SAFETY ON BOARD
COOL DISCOVERER
Despite following PER 05 - PPE All crew members will be frequently During April all areas were checked
Take 5 For Safety / Q2 2022 Matrix during working activities,
some crew members do not
reminded to strictly follow company
standards regarding dress and
for proper garbage bins, as well as
appropriate garbage segregation
always fulfill FIM requirements uniform, both when at sea and in port. instructions and color coding being
A) COOL DISCOVERER: B) While working at the paint store a crew member regarding foot protection outside All crew members should remind posted nearby the bins. All cabins
During unmooring operations, while heaving up wanted to lower a heavy bucket of paint from an upper of working hours. Occasionally, their colleagues of the proper foot were checked that relevant placards
mooring lines and storing them on a drum, a crew shelf. Initially he wanted to perform the operation when leaving their cabin for a wear. Relevant extract from FIM ‘Foot were displayed. The importance
member started to arrange the line. He took two quickly and easily, so he started climbing the shelves. snack or to visit the smoking Protection’ on p.68 will be temporarily of strict MARPOL and Garbage
steps back and away from the drum, still arranging But then he stopped, thought again and decided to room, crew members wear flip posted in the vicinity of smoking room Management Plan compliance, as
the line properly, but well clear from the winch. use a ladder to lower the paint from the shelf. flops. Upon observing a few and messrooms. well as related company policies, are
such cases, advice was given by brought to the attention of the crew on
superiors, as this is not a safe board as well as during familiarization
practice. of on signers. Misplaced garbage was
not reported during April.
42 43
SAFETY ON BOARD
WHAT IS THE WEAKEST AREA WHAT ACTIONS ARE WE GOING HAVE THE ACTIONS WE TOOK WHAT IS THE WEAKEST AREA WHAT ACTIONS ARE WE GOING HAVE THE ACTIONS WE TOOK
IN OUR PERFORMANCE THIS TO TAKE DURING THE NEXT MONTH LAST MONTH BEEN SUCCESSFUL (AND IN OUR PERFORMANCE THIS TO TAKE DURING THE NEXT MONTH LAST MONTH BEEN SUCCESSFUL (AND
MONTH? TO IMPROVE THIS AREA? WHY SO THAT OTHERS CAN LEARN MONTH? TO IMPROVE THIS AREA? WHY SO THAT OTHERS CAN LEARN
FROM IT)? FROM IT)?
COOL RUNNER Some of the reported Safety Effective supervision should be Crew conducted additional
Opportunities of this month were maintained on board to prevent familiarization.
During May the number of Safety 1) Each one of us must act responsibly As observed from the reported about lack of supervision from accidents or incidents. The person
Opportunities was very high, on board and understand that the Safety Opportunities trends for the person in charge. Lack of involved in a job should perform it as
however we noticed that there is vessel is like our second home, so May, we improved and achieved supervision has been identified discussed during the Toolbox Talk and
room for improvement and our we have to follow standards and this month’s goals. We noticed as a leading cause of injuries as per Task Risk Assessment.
weakest areas are: rules to keep it clean, tidy and safe. that each department had a clear at the workplace. Some people
By maintaining high housekeeping understanding and knowledge of tend to choose the quick and
1) Poor housekeeping; easy way and are complacent,
standards, we are eliminating potential the Garbage Management Plan and
Based on examples such as the safety hazards. waste segregation. Also, proactivity especially if they do the job very
garbage bin in the galley being of the crew members increased and often and forget or neglect the
Actions we planning to take are: consequences of not performing
overloaded, toasters found not performance was improved.
unplugged, poor housekeeping in ❚ Adequate leadership/supervision; the job safely.
the laundry area, loose items on each head of department shall
the floor, and unsecured items double-check his working area and
in the galley. We were able to crew before end of working day.
JUNE 2022
identify weak points and focus on ❚ Be prepared at all times for any
them the next month to improve weather and/or sea condition COOL RUNNER
our safety culture on board. changes. Ensure there are no loose
and unsecured items. After a discussion with the crew Encourage all crew members to share The best practice related to
2) The reported Near Miss ‘Oiler
❚ Follow the catering manual for public members it was decided that the their ideas and opinions. This way housekeeping significantly improved
Hit by Messenger Line’
spaces as well as the safety posters. weakest area is communication. intervention and soft skills should tidiness on board since last month.
❚ In case of a visitors and/or improve. The tips regarding the securing
contractors coming on board, ensure of items from the Health & Safety
that proper familiarization has been campaigns were also adopted. All the
given and monitor the execution of crew members were satisfied with the
relevant rules and standards. training, and the plan for upcoming
mooring operations was agreed with
all related personnel.
2) All of the deck mooring team was
informed and briefed accordingly.
SEAMAID
Mooring stations crew members were
briefed to keep proper distance from Based on Safety Opportunities To achieve a high safety performance ❚ Stores requisition was created.
winch and keep messenger line end in reported by the vessel in June, and a strong safety culture, compliance ❚ Close cooperation and
front of them. we believe that the wrong or with the company procedures is communication with superintendent.
Prior to the next mooring operation, incorrect use of PPE is our required. Thus, the PPE Matrix requires ❚ Advanced planning of consumption
the respective Task Risk Assessment weakest area. close monitoring and proactiveness, due to limited ROB.
will include the occurrence which must and ensuring the ship has adequate
be discussed with all crew involved in stock of PPE at all times is very
the mooring operation. important.
44 45
Shell’s Maritime Partners
in Safety Program - Thenamaris LNG
Another successful quarter was completed, with all crew members on board the
Thenamaris LNG managed vessels having reviewed the Shell safety material,
including presentations and videos, as well as having completed parts of the trainings
as per SQ53. Superintendents have resumed visits to the managed vessels where
possible given the COVID-19 restrictions, and were able to brief crews on board on
the Shell Maritime Partners in Safety Program.
46 47