Swept Versus FFT Versus Real Time Approach
Swept Versus FFT Versus Real Time Approach
E & T Team
September 2017
Operation principles of SPA architectures
Agenda Part I
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
2 Copyright© ANRITSU
Chasing dynamic and transient signals
Analysis of elusive signals?
Signal parameters
When did it occurs?
How long does it last?
Where did it occur?
What is the center frequeny?
What is the bandwidth?
What kind of modulation format?
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
3 Copyright© ANRITSU
Chasing dynamic and transient signals
Analysis of elusive signals?
Frequency Domain is best for identifying Time Domain is best for identifying when
what is happening in the spectrum something occurs
Static and / or dynamic behaviour At a specific time
Continuous, bursty Repetition rate
Modulated In a relative sense versus
other events
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
4 Copyright© ANRITSU
Probability of Intercept
What signal can I see?
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
6 Copyright© ANRITSU
Swept Spectrum Analyzer principle
Heterodyne Spectrum Analyzer
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
7 Copyright© ANRITSU
Swept Spectrum Analyzer principle
Superheterodyne Spectrum Analyzer
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
8 Copyright© ANRITSU
Swept Spectrum Analyzer principle
Basic operation of an analog Spectrum Analyzer - RBW influence
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
9 Copyright© ANRITSU
Swept Spectrum Analyzer principle
POI for Swept Spectrum Analysis
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
10 Copyright© ANRITSU
Swept Spectrum Analyzer principle
POI for Swept Spectrum Analysis
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
11 Copyright© ANRITSU
Swept Spectrum Analyzer principle
Catching up signals without gaps
[ window size + time record length − 1 − P]
LO is at a fixed frequency Tmin =
fs
Instantaneous Bandwidth (Analysis Window Size = FFT window length in #points
Bandwidth) allows capture and analysis of a Time Record Length = FFT bin size in #points
P = Overall FFT processing points
technically limited portion of the spectrum fs = sample rate
MS28xxA ↦ up to 1 GHz
MS2720T ↦ 15 MHz IQ Capture or 20 MHz
demodulation bandwidth
MS2710xA ↦ 20 MHz IQ data bock or 2,6
MHz streaming mode
Gap free capture for wide bandwidths
Best at measuring short duration signals
that are infrequent or occur periodically
MS2710xA has pre-trigger capability
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
12 Copyright© ANRITSU
Swept Spectrum Analyzer principle
Swept SPA Summary
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
13 Copyright© ANRITSU
FFT SPA principle
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
14 Copyright© ANRITSU
FFT Spectrum Analyzer principle
FFT Spectrum Analyzer - Analog frontend with digital IF and processing
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
15 Copyright© ANRITSU
FFT Spectrum Analyzer principle
FFT Spectrum Analyzer - Analog frontend with digital IF and processing
Digital decimating filters and resampling algorithms provide the solution to the limited
frequency resolution problem RBW = 𝛥f = fs/N
Digital decimating filters and resampling perform the operations necessary to allow
variable spans and resolution bandwidths
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
16 Copyright© ANRITSU
FFT Spectrum Analyzer principle
Basic FFT Relationships
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
17 Copyright© ANRITSU
FFT Based Spectrum Analysis
RBW of FFT based SPAs
RBW = 100 Hz
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
18 Copyright© ANRITSU
FFT Based Spectrum Analysis
Spectral Leakage & Windowing
Sampled Sampled
Time Record Time Record
Implied
Periodicity
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
19 Copyright© ANRITSU
FFT Spectrum Analyzer principle
Advantages of FFT spectrum analyzer technology
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
20 Copyright© ANRITSU
FFT Spectrum Analyzer principle
Disadvantages of FFT spectrum analyzer technology
Frequency limitations:
The main limit of the frequency and bandwidth of FFT spectrum analyzers is the analogue to
digital converter (ADC), that is used to convert the analogue signal into a digital format. While
technology is improving this component still places a major limitation on the upper frequency
limits or the bandwidth if a down-conversion stage is used. (There are forthcoming 12-bit
ADCs with 6.5 Gbps sampling rate. Looking at IF bandwidth in an instrument such as a VSA, 1
GHz is probably the best that can be done today, and 2 GHz in the next 18 months or so)
Cost:
The high level of performance required by the ADC means that this item is a very high cost
item. In addition to all the other processing and display circuitry required, this results in the
costs rising for these items.
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
21 Copyright© ANRITSU
FFT Based Spectrum Analysis
Difference between FFT SPA and FFT on an Oscilloscope
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
22 Copyright© ANRITSU
FFT Based Spectrum Analysis
Difference between FFT SPA and FFT on an Oscilloscope
[Link]
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
23 Copyright© ANRITSU
FFT Based Spectrum Analysis
Difference between FFT SPA and FFT on an Oscilloscope
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
24 Copyright© ANRITSU
FFT Based Spectrum Analysis
Performance differences between Signal Analyzer and Spectrum Analyzer mode
PD PRF
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
25 Copyright© ANRITSU
FFT Based Spectrum Analysis
Performance differences between Signal Analyzer and Spectrum Analyzer mode
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
26 Copyright© ANRITSU
FFT Based Spectrum Analysis
Overview Benchtop Product Portfolio
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
27 Copyright© ANRITSU
FFT Based Spectrum Analysis
Overview Product Portfolio
MS2830/40/50A
Full featured signal
analysis in the lab
up to 43 GHz (1 GHz)
Up to 300 GHz with
external mixers
MS2710xA MS2760A
Monitoring, Multilateration, mmWave spectrum analysis
MS2720T Demodulation 32, 44, 50, 70, 90, 110 GHz
Full featured spectrum Ext. SW Packages solutions for the lab, field or
analysis in the field Up to 6 GHz manufacturing line
Up to 43 GHz
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
29 Copyright© ANRITSU
Stepped FFT principle
Operation principle
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
30 Copyright© ANRITSU
MS2760A Spectrum Analyzer principle
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
31 Copyright© ANRITSU
MS2760A – NLTL based stepped FFT analyzer
NLTL sampler replacing mixer in a mm-wave spectrum analyzer
Sampler
FFT
VBW
DET
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
- 32 - Copyright© ANRITSU
MS2760A – NLTL based stepped FFT analyzer
MS2760A basic function principle
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
- 33 - Copyright© ANRITSU
MS2760A – NLTL based stepped FFT analyzer
Stepped FFT frequency representation
User Span
FFT
FFT FFT averaging 20 MHz Capture
for VBW Low Side sweep
FFT
Capture Time Take Min Hold Level of Display
both
20 MHz Capture
High Side sweep
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
- 34 - Copyright© ANRITSU
MS2760A – NLTL based stepped FFT analyzer
Stepped FFT frequency representation
To improve capturing transient events, user can select either automatic (min.),
or set minimum capture time for each 20 MHz wide capture
FFT For HIGH SIDE
and / or
FFT Max LOW SIDE
Value user stettable
FFT min. capture time
FFT
FFT
FFT
FFT
FFT
User stettable min. capture time
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
- 35 - Copyright© ANRITSU
MS2760A – NLTL based stepped FFT analyzer
High side / low side spur rejection
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
- 36 - Copyright© ANRITSU
MS2760A – NLTL based stepped FFT analyzer
Impact on frequency hopping signals
Every trace is a comparison of a HIGH SIDE and a LOW SIDE sample to remove unwanted
images and spurs
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
- 37 - Copyright© ANRITSU
MS2760A – NLTL based stepped FFT analyzer
Example of spectrogram operation
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
- 38 - Copyright© ANRITSU
MS2760A – NLTL based stepped FFT analyzer
Example of Zero SPAN operation
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
- 39 - Copyright© ANRITSU
Vector Signal Analyzer principle
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
40 Copyright© ANRITSU
VSA SPA principle
Basic architecture Vector Signal Analyzer (VSA)
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
41 Copyright© ANRITSU
VSA SPA principle
The digital side of a VSA
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
42 Copyright© ANRITSU
VSA SPA principle
VSA Summary
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
43 Copyright© ANRITSU
RTSA principle
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
44 Copyright© ANRITSU
RTSA SPA principle
Outcome and conclusion
RF tu
Trig
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
45 Copyright© ANRITSU
Real Time Spectrum Analysis
Catching up signals without gaps
CALC includes computation of an FFT or a power spectrum as well as averaging, display updates, and so on.
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
46 Copyright© ANRITSU
Real Time Spectrum Analysis
Catching up signals without gaps
Real-time operation:
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
47 Copyright© ANRITSU
Real Time Spectrum Analysis
Catching up signals without gaps
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
48 Copyright© ANRITSU
Real Time Spectrum Analysis
Catching up signals without gaps
Overlap processing provides significant benefits for signal analysis when processing is
faster than sampling by performing additional FFTs with partially-new time records as
samples come in.
Overlap processing provides significant benefits for signal analysis when processing is
faster than sampling by performing additional FFTs with
partially-new time records as samples come in.
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
49 Copyright© ANRITSU
Real Time Spectrum Analysis
Catching up signals without gaps
The diagram is showing a 50% overlap where each new FFT is performed on 50% new
samples and 50% from the most recent samples of the previously processed data.
With significant overlap it is possible to configure analysis so that all samples are
processed for some FFT result with no or minimal attenuation or de-emphasis due to
windowing.
Thus overlap is
improving (POI) and
accuracy.
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
50 Copyright© ANRITSU
Real Time Spectrum Analysis
RTSA simplified block diagram
FFT
Processor
Display Processor
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
51 Copyright© ANRITSU
Real Time Spectrum Analysis
RTSA Summary
A fixed LO w/ a given IF BW
Collects IQ data over an interval of time.
Data is corrected and FFT’d in parallel
Vector information is lost
Advanced displays for large mounts of
FFT’s
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
52 Copyright© ANRITSU
FFT Based Spectrum Analysis
Pros and Cons of Swept Spectrum Analyzer and FFT based Signal Analyzer
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
53 Copyright© ANRITSU
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
54 Copyright© ANRITSU
BackUp Slides
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
55 Copyright© ANRITSU
FFT SPA principle
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
56 Copyright© ANRITSU
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
57 Copyright© ANRITSU
FFT Spectrum Analyzer principle
Time & Frequency Domain Relationships
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
58 Copyright© ANRITSU
Non Linear Transmission Line (NLTL)
What is this?
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
59 Copyright© ANRITSU
NLTL Technology
Principle of Nonlinear Transmission-Line (NLTL)
Zl,
CD(U)
Under reverse bias, a diode behaves as Cl
Zl
a non-linear capacitance
1
fc
Strong input signals will generate harmonics and d cpw Zl Cl Cj
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
- 60 - Copyright© ANRITSU
NLTL Technology
Principle of Nonlinear Transmission-Line (NLTL)
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
- 61 - Copyright© ANRITSU
NLTL Technology
Principle of Nonlinear Transmission-Line (NLTL)
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
- 62 - Copyright© ANRITSU
NLTL Technology
Principle of Nonlinear Transmission-Line (NLTL)
At high negativ voltages, the capacitance of the diodes is small and the velocity is
fast. If the input voltage waveform has a negativ going function, the first part of the wave
propagate slower as the following parts.
So the fall time is becoming shorter and shorter as the wave propagates along the line.
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
- 63 - Copyright© ANRITSU
NLTL Technology
Principle Nonlinear Transmission-Line (NLTL) based Sub-Harmonic Sampler
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
- 64 - Copyright© ANRITSU
NLTL Technology
Principle Nonlinear Transmission-Line (NLTL) based Sub-Harmonic Sampler
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
- 65 - Copyright© ANRITSU
NLTL Technology
A success story of unique advantages
SPA Roadshow - Part IV - Swept versus FFT versus Real Time approach
- 66 - Copyright© ANRITSU