Scribd
Upload
22 views18 pages

Plate 1 Lopez JJ Gonato DB

The document presents a series of STAAD verification problems related to structural analysis, comparing results from the book 'Theory of Structures' by Besavilla and 'Structural Analysis' by Aslam Kasimali. Most findings indicate minimal discrepancies, primarily due to rounding differences, while some problems show exact reactions but variations in shear and moment diagrams. Overall, the results from STAAD align closely with the book's answers, with a few exceptions noted for specific problems.

Uploaded by

Jechz Jacob Lopez
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
22 views18 pages

Plate 1 Lopez JJ Gonato DB

The document presents a series of STAAD verification problems related to structural analysis, comparing results from the book 'Theory of Structures' by Besavilla and 'Structural Analysis' by Aslam Kasimali. Most findings indicate minimal discrepancies, primarily due to rounding differences, while some problems show exact reactions but variations in shear and moment diagrams. Overall, the results from STAAD align closely with the book's answers, with a few exceptions noted for specific problems.

Uploaded by

Jechz Jacob Lopez
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd

College of Engineering Education

2nd Floor, B&E Building Matina


Campus, Davao City

NAMES: DARYLLE BRACE GONATO, JECHZ JACOB LOPEZ


SUBJECT/CODE: BCE1S/L (1520)
COURSE: BSCE MAJOR IN STRUCTURAL

STAAD VERIFICATION PROBLEMS

1. Problem 150 from Structural Analysis (Theory of Structures) by BESAVILLA

From book:

From STAAD:
Findings:
Minimal discrepancies can be seen. The answers in the book have been rounded up to
the tenth decimal place.

2. Problem 148 from Structural Analysis (Theory of Structures) by BESAVILLA

From book:
From STAAD:
Findings:
Minimal discrepancies can be seen. The answers in the book have been rounded up to
the tenth decimal place. Still, in context and in diagram, the answers are still the same.

3. Problem 310 from Structural Analysis (Theory of Structures) by BESAVILLA

From book:
From STAAD:
Findings:
Minimal discrepancies can be seen. The answers in the book have been rounded up to
the tenth decimal place. Still, in context and in diagram, the answers are still the same.

4. Problem 313 from Structural Analysis (Theory of Structures) by BESAVILLA


From book:
From STAAD:

Findings:
Minimal discrepancies can be seen.
5. Problem 185 from Structural Analysis (Theory of Structures) by BESAVILLA

From book:

From STAAD:
Findings:
Minimal discrepancies can be seen.

6. Problem found in STRUCTURAL


ANALYSIS 4TH EDITION BY ASLAM
KASIMALI (CHAPTER 13, 532)

From book:
From STAAD:

Findings:
Exact reactions, but different on shear and moment diagrams because the software
specified the bending moment direction.

7. Problem found in STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS 4TH EDITION BY ASLAM


KASIMALI (CHAPTER 12, PAGE 479)

From book:
From STAAD:
Findings:
Exact reactions and exact shear diagram but different in terms of moment, it might
because the problem just considered the left portion of the frame not the whole
structure.

8. Problem found in STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS 4TH EDITION BY ASLAM


KASIMALI (CHAPTER 5, PAGE 191)

From book:
From STAAD:

Findings:
Exact reactions and deflection curve.

9. Problem found in STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS 4TH EDITION BY ASLAM


KASIMALI (CHAPTER 3, PAGE 561)
From book:

From STAAD:
Findings:
Same reactions from the book and from the STAAD.

10. Problem found in STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS 4TH EDITION BY ASLAM


KASIMALI (CHAPTER 7, PAGE 332)

From book:
From STAAD:
Findings:
Manual Answer – 9.6 mm, STAAD – 9.222
Discrepancy occurred because there’s no exact material to use.

You might also like